Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chopra Scm5 Ch13
Chopra Scm5 Ch13
Determining the
Optimal Level of
Product Availability
13-1
1-1
Learning Objectives
1. Identify the factors affecting the optimal level
of product availability and evaluate the optimal
cycle service level
2. Use managerial levers that improve supply
chain profitability through optimal service
levels
3. Understand conditions under which
postponement is valuable in a supply chain
4. Allocate limited supply capacity among
multiple products to maximize expected profits
• Cost of overstocking, C o
• Cost of understocking, C u
• Possible scenarios
– Seasonal items with a single order in a season
– One-time orders in the presence of quantity
discounts
– Continuously stocked items
– Demand during stockout is backlogged
– Demand during stockout is lost
Copyright ©2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall. 13-4
L.L. Bean Example
Table 13-1
Expected profit
from extra 100 parkas = 5,500 x Prob(demand ≥ 1,100) –
500
x Prob(demand < 1,100)
= $5,500 x 0.49 – $500 x 0.51 =
Expected profit from
$2,440
ordering 1,300 parkas = $49,900 + $2,440 + $1,240 +
$580
= $54,160
Copyright ©2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall. 13-6
L.L. Bean Example
Table 13-2
Expected marginal
contribution of raising = (1 – CSL*)(p – c) – CSL*(c – s)
order size
Copyright ©2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall. 13-9
Optimal Cycle Service Level for Seasonal
Items – Single Order
p–c Cu 1
CSL* =Prob(Demand £O*) = = =
p – s Cu + Co 1+ Co / Cu ( )
O* =F –1(CSL*, m ,s ) =NORMINV (CSL*, m,s )
æO – m ö æO – m ö
Expected profit =( p – s)m Fs ç ÷– ( p – s)s f s ç ÷
è s ø è s ø
–O(c – s)F(O, m ,s ) + O( p – c) éë1– F(O, m,s )ùû
Cu 150
CSL* =Prob(Demand £O*) = = =0.88
Cu + Co 150 + 20
Expected é æO – m öù æO – m ö
=(m – O) ê1– FS ç ÷ú+ s f S ç ÷
understock ë è s øû è s ø
Expected =(m – O) é1– NORMDIST é(O – m) / s ,0,1,1ùù
understock ë ë ûû
+s NORMDIST éë(O – m ) / s ,0,1,0ù
û
Copyright ©2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall. 13-14
Evaluating Expected Overstock
and Understock
μ = 350, σ = 100, O = 450
Expected =(O – m)NORMDIST é(O – m) / s ,0,1,1ù
overstock ë û
+s NORMDIST é ë(O – m ) / s ,0,1,0ù
û
=(450 – 350)NORMDIST é ù
ë(450 – 350) / 100,0,1,1û
+100NORMDIST é ù
ë(450 – 350) / 100,0,1,0û=108
Expected =(m – O) é1– NORMDIST é(O – m) / s ,0,1,1ùù
understock ë ë ûû
+s NORMDIST é ë(O – m) / s ,0,1,0û
ù
=(350 – 450) é
ë1– NORMDIST é(450 – 350) / 100,0,1,1ùù
ë ûû
+100NORMDIST é ë(450 – 350) / 100,0,1,0ù=8
û
Copyright ©2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall. 13-15
One-Time Orders in the Presence
of Quantity Discounts
1. Using Co = c – s and Cu = p – c, evaluate the optimal
cycle service level CSL* and order size O* without a
discount
• Evaluate the expected profit from ordering O*
2. Using Co = cd – s and Cu = p – cd, evaluate the optimal
cycle service level CSL*d and order size O*d with a
discount
• If O*d ≥ K, evaluate the expected profit from ordering O*d
• If O*d < K, evaluate the expected profit from ordering K units
3. Order O* units if the profit in step 1 is higher
• If the profit in step 2 is higher, order O*d units if O*d ≥ K or K
units if O*d < K
Copyright ©2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall. 13-16
Evaluating Service Level with Quantity
Discounts
• Step 1, c = $50
Cost of understocking = Cu = p – c = $200 – $50 = $150
Cost of overstocking = Co = c – s = $50 – $0 = $50
Cu 150
CSL* =Prob(Demand £ O*) = = =0.75
Cu + Co 150 + 50
Cu 150
CSL* =Prob(Demand £ O*) = = =0.775
Cu + Co 150 + 45
é HQ ù
CSL* =1– ê ú
ëDCu û
=20 2 =28.3
HQ 0.6 ´ 400
Cu = = =$230.8 per gallon
(1– CSL)D 0.0002 ´ 5,200
HQ
CSL* =1–
HQ + DCu
0.6 ´ 400
=1– =0.98
0.6 ´ 400 + 2 ´ 5,200
• “Obvious” actions
1. Increase salvage value of each unit
2. Decrease the margin lost from a stockout
• Improved forecasting
• Quick response
• Postponement
• Tailored sourcing
Figure 13-2
150
CSL* =Prob(Demand £ O*) ³ =0.88
150 + 20
Standard
Deviation of Optimal
Forecast Order Expected Expected Expected
Error σ Size O* Overstock Understock Profit
150 526 186.7 8.6 $47,469
120 491 149.3 6.9 $48,476
90 456 112.0 5.2 $49,482
60 420 74.7 3.5 $50,488
30 385 37.3 1.7 $51,494
0 350 0 0 $52,500
Table 13-3
Figure 13-3
p – c 150 – 40
CSL* = = =0.92
p – s 150 – 30
Figure 13-4
Figure 13-5
• Option 2
m A =3,100 + 3 ´ 300 =4,000
s A = 8002 + 3 ´ 2002 =872
Manufacturing Policy
Average Average Average
Q1 Q2 Profit Overstock Understock
0 4,524 $97,847 510 210
1,337 0 $94,377 1,369 282
700 1,850 $102,730 308 168
800 1,550 $104,603 427 170
900 950 $101,326 607 266
900 1,050 $101,647 664 230
1,000 850 $100,312 815 195
1,000 950 $100,951 803 149
1,100 550 $99,180 1,026 211
1,100 650 $100,510 1,008 185
Table 13-5
Copyright ©2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall. 13-55
Setting Optimal Levels of
Product Availability in Practice
1. Beware of preset levels of availability
2. Use approximate costs because profit-
maximizing solutions are quite robust
3. Estimate a range for the cost of
stocking out
4. Tailor your response to uncertainty