COMPARATIVE

ANLYSIS
S.NO CATEGORIES
1 CASE STUDY CONTEXT
2 WHY THIS CASE STUDY
JAYAPRAKASH NARAYAN INTERPRETATION
CENTER AT LUKNOW
THIS CASE STUDY IS INFLUNECD BY THE
INDIAN CONTEXT . IN WHICH THE INDIAN
STYLE AND INDIAN DESING IS KEPT INTO
THE CONSIDERATION.
THIS PROJECT IS DESIGNED IN NEW
CONCEPTS WITH OLD TECHNOLOGIES
WHICH MAKE THIS BUILDING LOOK MORE
STERDY .AND GIVES LOTS OF
INFORMATION.
MAPUNGUBWE INTERPRETATION CENTER
THIS CASE STUDY IS MORE OF AN NEWLY
BUILD STYLE OF ARCHITECTURE IN WHICH
NEW TECNIQES AND LOCAL MATERIALS ARE
TOOK INTO CONDIDERATION.
THIS CASE GIVE HE IDEA OF USING THE
LOCAL CLIMATE AND LOCAL MATERIALS IN
BEST WAY AND THE CASE STUDY IS IN THE
INTERNATIONAL CONTEXT.WHICH STILL
SDOPTS THE LOCAL AND PAST TECNOLOGIES.

3 RELATED YES, THIS CASE STUDY IS MORE OF AN
RELATED TO THE STUDIES OF
INTERPREATATION CENTRE
4 LOCATION  VIPIN KHAND, GOMTI NAGAR, LUCKNOW,
UTTAR PRADESH
5 CLIMATE ENHANCE THE LOCAL CLIMATE OF THE LUCKNOW
DEPENDS ON THE DESIGNING STRETEGY.
THAT IS HUMID SUB TROPICAL CLIMATE.
6 ACCESSIBILITY THROUGH THE CITY AND THE MAIN ROAD
OF THE CENTRAL CITY.
7 APPROCH TO THE SITE BY THE MEANS OF THE LOCAL
TRANSPORT FACILITIES OVER THERE IN
LUCKNOW.
8 SURROUNDING AS THIS SITE IS AT THE CENTRE PART OF THIS SITE IS LOCATED IN THE REMOTE ARE
THE CITY IT HAS A MEMORIAL PARK
BESIDE, RIVER GOMUDI,CO OPREATIVE
OFFICE.AND SOME INSTITUTIONS.
9 ARCHITECT APPROCH TO VOLUMINOUS APPORCH TO THE DESING
DESING MAKES THE LOOK OF BUILDING VERY
MUCH ATTRACTIVE.
10 CONCEPT VOLUMINOUS ARCHITECTURE AND THE
INTERLOCKING OF THE SOLIDS AND VOIDS. THE LOCAL COMMUNITIES AND
11 CIRCULATION VERY MUCH COMFORT WITH THE USERS
AS THE ZONES PROVIDE THE EASY
MOVEMENT FOR THE PEOPLE TO WALK
THROUHT IT.
THOUGHT ITS NOT A HERITAGE
INTERPREATTION CENTRE. BUT STILL THIS
HEKPS TO ANLYSE THE WAY OF DESIGN
CONSIDERARTION.
MUSINA, SOUTH AFRICA
THE CLIMATE CONSIDERATION IS VERY SEVER
AS THE SOUTH AFRICA IS HITTING THE VERY
PEAK CLIMATE AS SUMMER.
THE ACCESSIBLITY WAS THE MAIN CALLENGE
TO THE ARCHITCTS TO DESIGN THE
PROJECT.AS THERE IS NO PROPER ROADS OR
THE ACCSSE TO REACH THE SITE BUT AFTER
THE CONSTRUCTION THE SITE HAS GOT
MORE REACHBLE MEANS.
AS THE PLACE ITSLEF IS THE REMOTE AREA
THE ACCESS TO THE SITE IS QUITE RISKY
WITHOUT THE HELP OF FORECT AND THE
AUTORITOES PRESENT OVER THERE.
THE SUROUDING IS ALL OCCUPIED BY THE
NATURAL LANDCASE NO BUILDING NO
HUMAN PRESENCE OVER THERE
THE APPROCH OF THE ARCHITECT IS VERY
MUCH REALIABLE THERE IS VERY MUCH
SIMLICITY IN THE DESIGNING BY USING THE
LOCAL MATERIALS
THE COCEPT IS MORE RELATED TO ENHANCE
TEMPREATURE.
MUCH RELATED WITH THE INTERNATIONAL
STYLE OF CIRCULATION AND USEAGE . NO
MUCH OF THE CONFUSIONS ARE DONE BUT
THE CIRCULAR FORMS MAKES QUITE
CONFUSIONS AT THE SOME POINT OF THE
CIRCULATIONS.

12 ZONING ACCORDING DONE WITH THE INDIAN
USERS AND BEHEVIOUR OF THE TOURIST
COIMG TO VISIT. THE ZONING MAKES THE
WAY EASIER FOR THE PER TO WALK
THROUOUT THE SITE.
13 LAND USE LOOKING AT THE LAND USE THERE ARE
MANY CONSIDERATION TOOK INTO THE
DESIGN THAT ARE PARKING, PEDESTRIAN,
SERVICE, ENTRIES AND EXITS.
MAKES THE WAY ESIER TFOR THE VISITORS
TO TAKE THE TOUR AROUND THE BUILDING.
NOT MUCH IN CONSIDERATION THE LAND
USE PATERN IS NOT THAT HIGHLIGHTED IN
THE DESING AS THEY AS DIVIDED INTO VERY
LESS EXPREENCE OF THE SPACE.

14 CONSTRUCTION NEW TECHNIQES AND FORMS MATRIALS VERY MUCH TRICKY CONTRUCTION IS USED
ARE USED FOR THR CONSTRUCTION. IN THE DESIGN AS THE ARCHITECT
CONSIDERD THE LOCAL CLIMATE AND
MATERIAL IN HIS CONSIDERATIONS. WHICH
HAS COME UP WITH VERY BEST RESULS.
S.NO CATEGORIES JAYAPRAKASH NARAYAN INTERPRETATION MAPUNGBWE INTERPRETATION CENTER
CENTER AT LUKNOW

15 MATERIALS NEW MATRIALS ARE APPILED TO THE
CONSTRUCTION AS THE PLANNING AND
MATERIALS GOES HAND IN HAND AND
MAKES LOOK BUILDING SOLID
VOLUMINOUS CONSTRUCTION.
VERY MUCH TECHNICALLY THE MATERIALS
ARE USED FOR THE BUILDING. THE SAND
STONE EHICH IS LOCALLY FPUND THERE IS
USED FOR THE CONSTRUCTION.

16 DESINGING STRATERGY FREE DESIGNING WITH SOLIDS AND VOIDS COMPLICATED DESIGN AND TRIES TO BRING
AND THE INTERLOCKING OF THE OF THE THE LIVELYNESS IN THE BUILDING OF THE
SOLIDS INTERPREATATION CENTRE.

17 SPACE USE ZONED THE SPACE AND USED IT WITH PROPER ZONING IS DONE WITH THE USAGE
PROPER CONSIDERATIONS. OF THE SPACE CONSIDERING THE TOURIST
FOLLOW AND EXISITING SITE.

18 LANDSCAPE WELCOMING LANDSCAPE IS GIVEN WHICH NO MANMADE LANDSCAPE ONLY THE

GOES WITH THE BUILDING . THE NATURAL LANDSCAPE PRESENT OVER THERE.
GREENERY IS TOOK INTO THE
CONSIDERATION WHILE DESIGNING

19 SERVICE CORE ALL SERVICES ARE PROVIDED WITH DIFFICULTIES IN FINDING THE SAPCE TO
PROPER MAINTANCE AND COME UP WITH THE PROPER SERVICE AREA.
CONSIDERATIONS.
20 USEAGE EXPERIENCE ACCORDING TO THE PEOPLE REVIEW THE AS THERE IS NO MUCH REVIEWS ON THIS
BUILDING WORKS OUT VERY SMOOTHLY BUT THE SOME VISITORS CONSIDERS THIS AS
WITH ALL CONSIDERATION. THE NEW STYLE OF EXPRENCING THE SPACE
WITH SUCH KIND OF NATURAL
GEOGRPHYCALLY TOPOGRAPHY AND
NATURAL LANDSCAPE.

21 DESING CONSIDERATIONS LOCATION AS THE THE BUILDING STANDS ACCORDING WITH THE LOCAL CLIMATE AND
ON THE HOT LOCATION AND GETS THE MATRIALS WITH THE NATURAL TOPOGRAPHY
RIVER VIEW WHICH ALSO MAKES THE OF THE SITE.
STRONG POINT TO CONDIDER.

22 OPEN SPACE INFLUNECE THE LANDSCAPE MAKES THE WELCOMING THE SITE ITSELF LOCATED IN THE REMOTE
MODE OF THE SPACE TO THE BUILDING . AREA AND THE PLACE WITH ALL OPEN
SPACE ARROUND THE SITE.
23 FAÇADE SOLID LOOK IS GIVEN TO THE FACAD THE FULIDITY IS FPUND AROUND THE
WHICH MAKES BUILDING LOOKS LIKE BUILDING WHICH IS MADE BY THE VAULTS
SOLID ROCK. FORMED BY THE LOCAL LAND SCAPE FOUND
OVER THERE.

24 BUILDING FORM SOLID AND VOIDS INTERLOCKING SYSTEM
IS MORE OF IN THIS CONDIDERATIONS.
25 VISITORS REVIEW VERY GOOD PLACE TO VISIT NICE GOING .
THE LOOK AND THE SMOOTH RUNWAYS
AND PATHWAYS MAKES USERS EASY
CIRCULAR PLANNING WITH ALL OVER
VAULTING SYSTEM MAKES BUILDING LOOKS
VERY MUCH FLUID IN NATURE.
BREATHTAKING NATURE! VERY FRIENDLY
STAFF. THE SELFCATERING
ACCOMMODATION WAS MORE THAN WE
EXPECTED! HIGHLY RECOMMENDABLE!

26 FACILITIES ALL OF THE FACILITIES ARE PROVIDED IN LESS FACILITIES WITH HIGH NATURAL SENCE
EVERY CONSIDERED WAY WHICH MAKES OF EXPRENCE IS GIVEN WITH THE FACILITIES.
USER FRIENDLY WITH THE SITE.

27 AMENITIES NOT MORE AMENITIES ARE PROVIDED NO ANY OF THEM ARE IN THE
BUT CONSIDERED ARE TOOK INTO THE CONSIDERATION BUT CAFES AND THE
SITE. RESTOS ARE TOOK INTO THE
CONSIDERATION.

28 SOURCE OF STUDY OFFICAL PAGE , PEOPLES REVIEW AND THE THE OFFICIAL PAGE OF THE CENTRE AND THE
GOOGLE SITES. WIKIPEDIA AND THE RESERCH BASED ON
THEM .
S.NO CATEGORIES JAYAPRAKASH NARAYAN MAPUNGBWE INTERPRETATION
INTERPRETATION CENTER AT CENTER
LUKNOW
29 ADD UP TO THE ANLYSIS OF MY OWN AND THE NO ADD UPS ARE REQUIRED AS
STUDIES PART OF THE SYIDIES I ARCHITECT HAS MADE MORE
CONSIDERED TO DO. POTENTIAL THE AREA WITH SUCH
KIND OF PROJECTS.
30 THEROTICAL SUCH OF THEROTICAL PRACTICALY DONE THINGS ARE
KNOWLEDGE IS TAKEN OUT TOOK IN THE DESIGN WITH
FROM THE CASE STUDY MATERIALS AND THE
TECHNOLOGY.
31 CONCLUSION IT WAS GOOD KNOWLEDGE VERY MUCH HELPFUL STUDY EVER
SHARING STUDIES WHICH THIS MAKES THE WIDE RANGE OF
HELPED WITH STUDY OF THE UNDERSTANDING THE
SPACE AND THE USEAGES. THE INTERPREATATION CENTRE IN THE
DESIGNING PERSPECTIVE TO DIFFERENT WAY.
SHOW THE MANS PAST IS DONE
WITH ALL CONSIDERATIONS.
S.N CATEGORIES JAYAPRAKASH MAPUNGBWE
NARAYAN INTERPREATATION
INTERPRETATION CENTRE
CENTER
LOCATION YES NO NONE YES NO NONE
1 Do site slection is considered in
design methodology ?
2 Does site surrounding has any
consideration with design ?
3 Therotically helpfull
4 Practically helpfull
5 Do building has any special
design stretergy ?
6 Adjoining roads and buildings
7 Access to the site
8 Visibility splays
9 Landscape
The site:
10 Boundary treatment and the
relationship of
the development with
its boundaries and
existing buildings
11 Car parking
12 The relationship
between buildings and spaces ar
ound them.
13 Accessibility of the site
14 The impact of
the layout on energy
consumption and comfort.
15 Crime prevention measures
Buildings
16 The height, width, length and
orientation of buildings and
their relationship to the
local context and the human
scale.

17 Entrances and facades

18 The appearance of the buildings.
19 Their distribution across the site.
20 Their relationship to uses
surrounding the site.