The cost of carry model determines futures prices in such a way that no arbitrage opportunities arise. The price of the contract defined under this model is: F = S + C Futures price = Spot price + Carry costs Pricing of Futures
If an investor wants to acquire shares in a particular
company, he can acquire this shares today itself at the current price or he can take a long position in futures. In either case, he will be having the asset. No doubt, the market determined cost of acquiring the asset in either of these strategies must be equal. So, there is some relationship between the current price of the asset and cost of holding it in future and futures price today. Pricing of futures The relationship between the current spot price and the futures price is known as spot-futures parity or cost of carry relationship. The expected dividend (income) the asset gives during the futures period can also be accommodated in the analysis. The price of futures contract depends on the following: 1) The price of the underlying asset in the cash market 2) The rate of return expected from investment in the asset 3) Risk free rate of interest Pricing of futures Suppose, in cash market, the underlying asset is selling at Rs.100. The expected return from the asset is 3% per quarter. The risk-free rate of borrowing or lending is 8% per annum or 2% per quarter. The futures contract period is also for 3 months. What should be the price of futures? Now Futures price = Spot price + Carry costs F = S + S(r-y) Where, S = current spot price of the asset F = futures price r = % financing cost per futures period y = percentage yield on investment per futures period Pricing of futures Suppose, the investor borrows funds to purchase one unit of asset “x” resulting in no initial cash outlay for his strategy. At the end of three months period, Rs.3 will be received from holding the asset “x” and would be required to pay interest (financing cost) of Rs.2. In the example given above, F = 100 + 100(0.02 - 0.03) = Rs.99 So, the futures price should be Rs.99. This is called the theoretical price of the futures. Pricing of futures What happens if the futures price is Rs.92 or Rs.107? The position can be explained as follows:
In case, the futures contract is available at Rs.92 (less than the
theoretical price of Rs.99), the investor should buy one future contract for Rs.92 and should sell one unit of asset “x” for Rs.100 and invest the money @ 8% per annum for 3 months. After 3 months, he will receive the proceeds of Rs.102 (Rs.100 +Rs.2). he will spend Rs.92 to purchase an asset (out of futures contract) Besides, he will not receive the yield of Rs.3 from the Asset. So his cost is Rs.95 (92 + 3). His gain would be Rs.7 (102-95). Pricing of futures Similarly, if the futures contract price is Rs.107, He should sell futures contract at Rs.107 and should borrow Rs.100 now to buy one unit of asset x in the spot market. After 3 months, proceeds would be Rs.110 (107+3) and payment would be Rs.102 (100+2). He would be able to make a profit of Rs.8. So, if the futures prices other than the theoretical price Rs.99, it could give rise to arbitrage opportunities. in case of price of Rs.92 or Rs.107, investors can look for riskless arbitrage profit of Rs.7 or Rs.8. The demand and supply forces would react to this arbitrage opportunity and the futures price would settle around the equilibrium level of Rs.99 Pricing of futures The procedure for pricing futures can be standardised in 3 different situations as follows: When the asset provides no income F = S x ert
When the asset provides known dividend (i.e. Dividend in Rs.)
F = (S x ert) – (I x ert)
When the asset provides a known dividend yield (i.e. Dividend in terms of %) F = S x e(r-q)t Pricing of futures Where, F = Futures Price S = Spot Price of the underlying asset e = 2.7183 r = Rate of interest on borrowing or lending t = Time or duration of futures contract I = Expected Dividend q = Dividend yield. Cash and Carry Arbitrage Cash-and-carry-arbitrage is a market neutral strategy combining the purchase of a long position in an asset such as a stock or commodity, and the sale (short) of a position in a futures contract on that same underlying asset. It seeks to exploit pricing inefficiencies for the asset in the cash (or spot) market and futures markets, in order to make riskless profits. The futures contract must be theoretically expensive relative to the underlying asset or the arbitrage will not be profitable. Cash and carry Arbitrage strategy is implemented when futures is Over Priced. Cash and Carry Arbitrage (Cont.) Following are the steps in Cash and Carry Arbitrage: Step 1: Borrow amount equal to Spot price of an asset at risk-free rate. Step 2: Purchase the asset in the spot market at the current spot price Step 3: Sell the futures based in the asset. Step 4: On maturity of the contract, deliver the share at futures price Step 5: Repay the loan with interest. Reverse Cash and Carry Arbitrage Reverse cash-and-carry arbitrage is a market neutral strategy combining a short position in an asset and a long futures position in that same asset. Its goal is to exploit pricing inefficiencies between that asset's cash, or spot, price and the corresponding future's price to generate riskless profits. Reverse Cash and carry Arbitrage strategy is implemented when futures are Under Priced. Reverse Cash and Carry Arbitrage (Cont.) Following are the steps in Reverse Cash and Carry Arbitrage: Step 1: Borrow share of the company under Stock Lending and Borrowing Scheme. Step 2: Sell the borrowed share at the current spot price in the stock market. Step 3: Lend money realized for the stock market at a risk free rate of interest. Step 4: Buy Futures contract on the share of the company. Step 5: On maturity recover the loan with interest. Step 6: Purchase the share on maturity of futures contract and return the share to the broker.