Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1-1+2 Costs Analysis Lecture Notes
1-1+2 Costs Analysis Lecture Notes
Get familiar with the main tools to calculate and analyze costs in order to :
• Identify cost objects and choose the right method according to the question raised
• Calculate and analyze the economical impact of a managerial decision
• Measure the products’ or customers’ or activities’ profitability
2
Agenda of the intensive session
3
3
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
References
Course book reference: Drury C. (2019), Management Accounting for business,
Cengage Learning, Edition 10th
Charles T. Horngren, George Foster, Srikant M. Datar, May 2020) Cost Accounting: A
managerial emphasis; Pearson / Prentice Hall International Edition-16th
Cavélius et al. (avril 2019): Comptabilité de gestion : le pilotage des coûts, Éditions
Pearson, 2ème édition
4
Introduction
Cost Accounting: a tool for Management Control
-00/00/2014
TITRE DE LA PRÉSENTATION -
Management control: a definition which evolved
A constantly changing definition:
• Taylor: (1902): management process: monitoring activity, improving
productivity
6
Function and activity: Everyone is involved in management control eve... with
help from the management controller
7
Various actors in the company and their management tools
Choose a
strategy, guide Record events, report, in
particular to third parties
the work
Central
of operational Decision-makers Management Accountants
staff, decide, Controllers
8
From financial accounting to management
accounting
-00/00/2014
TITRE DE LA PRÉSENTATION -
A small group work
-10
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
10
Management accounting: a specific information system that measures economic
facts according to each firm’s business model
•Monitoring
•Support decision making and implementation (price setting, outsourcing decision, cost
reduction, diagnosis for other strategies,…)
•Induce alignment in managers towards organizational goals
11
Management accounting…cont.
Information on business results, costs, resources, margins,…
12
The various roles of management accounting
13
13
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Structural differences between management accounting and financial accounting
(1/2)
A « custom-made » system
• According to the specific needs of the economic sector, particularly strategic ones
• According to available information systems, management culture and historical context
Priorities, common values,
employee awareness, etc.
14
Structural differences between management accounting and financial accounting
(2/2)
15
Links between financial accounting and management control accounting
Financial accounting informs on:
• Company’s worth and financial position: Balance Sheet
• Global performance: Profit & Loss Statements
But Financial accounting does not inform on:
• The reasons for performance (why we earned or lost money)
• If a particular activity in the company is profitable or not
• How to choose between different options
• How to simulate results according to some assumptions
16
Who are the users?
Financial accounting
• Inside the firm: accountants record
transactions while managers take
financing decisions on the short and long-
run
• Outside the firm: shareholders, auditors,
financial analysts, potential investors,
banks, suppliers and customers (in order
to assess the durability of commercial
relationships). Consequently, this
information needs to be audited
(approved)
Management accounting
• Only for internal use: management
accountants, financial accountants, cost
controllers, marketing department,
production department, every
responsibility center in its own perimeter,
and of course the general management of 17
Synthesis: Management accounting and Financial accounting
Is organization-specific, with some legal restrictions, Is guided by prescribed accounting principles and is
but no regulation. Specific-purpose compulsory for all organizations.
Is not compulsory, not present in most small
companies General-purpose
Not audited Audited
Reports historical and current information and Provides information for the past period.
provides information on expected future performance Aggregate, GAAP (IFRS/SFAS)
and activities.
Very detailed, No GAAP
Variable reporting interval: monthly, weekly, hourly, Annual reporting (semi-annual and quarterly reports also
ad-hoc analysis… exist in some companies)
18
18
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Costs terms and purpose
-00/00/2014
TITRE DE LA PRÉSENTATION -
Definitions
The amount of economic resources acquired
A Cost is a resource forgone to achieve a specific objective.
• It is usually measured as the monetary amount that must be paid to acquire goods and
service.
A cost object is anything for which a separate measurement of costs is desired.
• It can be a brand (Taillefine), a product line (Taillefine natural yogurt), a reference
(Taillefine natural yogurt x4); a client; a project; an activity; in hospitals: Diagnosis
Related Groups, …
Costs don’t necessarily result in expenses, all expenses are not costs…
• Acquisitions and investments: neither expenses nor costs, but decrease in cash and increase
in assets
• Depreciation allowances: don’t result in cash-out but constitute a cost and an expense
Assets Expenses
Unexpired cost Expired cost
Direct materials Inventory
Direct labor (MFG costs, Product costs)
Manufacturing overhead WIP Inventory
FG Inventory Cost of Goods Sold
Sold 20
20
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Variable – Fixed costs
Variable costs change in total in proportion to changes in the related level of total activity or
volume.
Fixed costs do not change in total for a given time period despite wide changes in the related level
of total activity or volume.
(fc)
(VC) (v) (FC)
21
21
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Direct vs indirect costs
Direct costs of a cost object are those that are related to a given cost object (product,
department, etc.) and that can be traced to it in an economically feasible way without
any ambiguity
Indirect costs are related to the particular cost object but cannot be traced to it in an
economically feasible way
22
22
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Variable vs Fixed costs + Direct vs indirect costs
Does a cost
change in
proportion
to the level
of activity?
23
23
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Total Costs and Unit Costs
A unit cost (also called an average cost) is computed by dividing some amount of cost total by some
number of units.
The ‘units’ may be expressed in various ways:
– Hours worked
– Packages delivered
– Bicycles assembled
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
24
Conclusion on this first part: costs diversity and diversity of decisions…
Do or outsource?
Give up an activity?
25
Full costing
-00/00/2014
TITRE DE LA PRÉSENTATION -
Rationale for full costing / total costing
A full cost takes into account the whole set of costs inherent to a product
• Variable and fixed costs, direct and indirect costs
• Costs of supply, manufacturing, commercialization, overhead, administration,
…
Managers frequently ask for the cost of products / services
• Pricing policy, business portfolio strategy,
• Cost cutting
• Caution: full costing should NOT be used for decision making on ending
products, outsourcing, … => relevant / differential cost – revenue analysis
• The structure of cost is an important element of competitivity for firms and
should be included in follow-up and reportings.
• Cost of good sold needed for financial accounting reporting
27
27
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
The problem of indirect costs: how to
allocate them to cost objects?
Cost Assignment
Direct Cost
Costs Tracing
Cost
Indirect Cost Object
Costs Allocation
?
Causal relation, Benefits received, Reasonableness
28
28
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Methods to allocate indirect costs
Constraints
-29
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
29
Coefficient method
Total costs
Coefficient
30
Example: Biscuit Factory
Indirect costs allocation
Indirects costs are imputed to the products, in proportion to the direct costs.
Coefficient calculation: 147 000/ 300 000 = 0,49
Coûts indirects
imputés (Indirect cost 147 000 34 300 98 000 14 700
allocated)
31
Example: Biscuit Factory
Full costs and results
32
Job-Costing and Process-Costing Systems
There are two basic systems used to assign costs to products or services:
• Job costing
• Process costing
In a job-costing system, the cost object is an individual unit, batch, or lot of a distinct product or
service called a job (specific to the customer’s need)
In process costing, the cost object is masses of identical or similar units of a product or service.
33
33
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Implementing job order costing
34
34
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Process-costing
In a process-costing system, the unit cost of a product or service is obtained by
assigning total costs to many identical or similar units.
In a manufacturing setting, each unit is assumed to receive the same amount of direct
material costs, direct manufacturing labour costs, and indirect manufacturing costs
35
35
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
To conclude on this second part
Need to assess the part of conventions attached to full costs, depending on:
• The method
• The indirect/direct costs relationship
36
36
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
« The cost of a product is a construct »
It is necessary to specify:
• The goal of cost calculation
• The characteristics of the context
• The validity conditions of the calculation (clarification of definitions and hypotheses)
37
37
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Partial Costs analysis and decisions
-00/00/2014
TITRE DE LA PRÉSENTATION -
Examples of decisions where cost issues are important
39
39
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
A first modelization of cost behavior: the Cost – Volume - Profit model
and breakeven analysis
Cost-volume-profit (CVP) analysis examines the behaviour of total revenues, total costs,
and operating profit as changes occur in the output level, selling price, variable costs per
unit, or fixed costs.
40
40
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Example of CVP analysis
The shop Dresses by Mary can purchase dresses for £32 from a local factory; other variable costs amount
to £10 per dress. The local factory allows Mary to return all unsold dresses and receive a full £32 refund
per dress within one year=> no stock
the average selling price per dress (p) is £70 ☞ variable cost per unit (v) = £42/unit
Total fixed costs (FC) amount to £84,000.
How much revenue will she receive if she sells 2,500 dresses? Would she show an operating profit or
an operating loss?
Revenue: £70 × 2,500 = £175,000, Variable costs: £42 × 2,500 = £105,000
Operating P&L: Revenue (p×Q) – Variable costs (v×Q) – Fixed costs (FC)
= £175,000 – 105,000 – 84,000 = (£14,000)
41
41
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Example of CVP analysis
42
42
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Example of CVP analysis
43
43
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Breakeven point
Using the equation approach, compute the breakeven for Dresses by Mary.
• p×Q – v×Q – FC = 0
• £70Q – £42Q – £84,000 = 0
• £28Q = £84,000
• Q = £84,000 ÷ £28
• Q = 3,000 units
44
44
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Breakeven point representation
Sales p×Q
Value
Volume (Q)
0
BE Q* = FC (pv)
p×Q – (FC + v×Q) =0
45
45
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
The use of breakeven analysis
Breakeven
0 Volume (Q)
BE Q* Actual Q
= FC (pv)
Fixed costs
(FC)
Safety margin
Actual Q – BE Q*
46
46
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Limitations of the model: Implicit assumptions
Value
Product cost for economists
Volume (Q)
0
Relevance interval
Let’s practise with Montvert!
47
47
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Relevant costs and revenues
48
48
Example: Noel
49
49
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Example: Noel
50
50
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Pitfalls to avoid
General assumptions:
Do not assume that all variable costs are relevant.
Do not assume that all fixed costs are irrelevant.
51
51
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Opportunity costs
Opportunity cost is the contribution to profit that is foregone (rejected) by not using a limited
resource in its next-best alternative use.
Opportunity costs are not recorded in formal accounting records since they do not generate
cash outlays.
These costs also are not ordinarily incorporated into formal reports.
52
52
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Costs and pricing policy
Infinite number of ways depending on the economic sector, the past of the firm,…
The cost is only one of the elements to take into account when making a decision
• Competition
• Customers capacity
• Value attached to the offer
Cost + Margin
-Differentiate « special sales » from the usual price tag
-Consider mid-term impact, synergies in the product portfolio (loss leader)
53
53
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Course conclusion
-00/00/2014
TITRE DE LA PRÉSENTATION -
What we have covered in this one-day course on Costs Analysis:
55
55
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-
Key takeaways
56
56
-
TITRE
DE LA
PRÉS
ENTA
TION
-