groups. People and change Every change has an impact on people associated with it. Effective and efficient management of change depends on people who are actually involved in implementation of change. Organizations are made up of people and if people within the organization do not change the organizations can not change. People and change It is very important for every manager to understand the human response to change. There are three distinct ways by which people are affected by change. First is operational, which refers to alterations in behaviors. This demands changes from the routine ways of doing work Demands people to learn new method or new sequence of doing a work People and change Second is psychological, which relates to what an employee feels about what he or she doing. Some fear like whether one will be able to master new skills, or whether he will be compensated fairly for new responsibility etc The third is social, which relates to alterations in established relationships among the individuals. Changes in formal or informal relationships People and change Thus people resist change and effective change management calls for Understanding the human response to change Overcoming individual and group resistance to change Tuning the organizational change. Human response to change Individuals both fear and seek change. Hence both change as well as stagnation are resisted. Continuity without change leads to stagnation and hence it results boredom and frustration. Change without continuity leads to ambiguity, conflict and stress. Thus change can be an opportunity or a threat. Human response to change Change to many individuals may be learning new skills, acquiring new relationships, by abandoning earlier habit patterns. Individuals may not resist change. But what they resist is imposition of change. So when change is felt by an individual (internal) it is easy to change than being imposed by others (external). Human response to change Change is always threat when done to people, but an opportunity when done by people. Change is intensely personal Change give rise to emotions which could be positive or negative. The best strategy for managing change is to make people choose change. Change and employee attitude Attitude continuum
Aggressive Passive Passive Active
Neutral Resistance Resistance Acceptance Involvement Change and employee attitude Individuals may develop different types of attitudes towards change. Pareto principle holds good for attitude to change also-80% of resistance to change in organizations may come form 20% of people. Majority of the people belong to neutral category. Change and employee attitude Aggressive resistance-Complaining, criticism, non cooperation, Withdrawal, Counter control activities, sabotage. Passive resistance- fake sympathy, spreading of rumors, reluctance to cooperate, delaying change implementation. Neutral- Cats on the wall, May tilt to either side depending on what is advantageous to them. Change and employee attitude Passive acceptance- Accept the need for change but may not fully accept the way it is implemented, or work behind the scene and support change, Watch/wait before expressing full support, may not support directly due to peer group pressure. Active involvement- highly positive about intended change, try to convince others for change, wants to learn new skills, try out new things, innovators. Why individuals resist change? Personal Loss Job security-workforce reduction, elimination of jobs. Salary and income-reduction in salary, pay benefits, and overtime allowances. Pride and satisfaction-current skills may become obsolete, or of less importance. Job nature-job may become either simple or more complex, necessitates new procedures and methods, need for new skills, increased work load. Why individuals resist change? Personal Loss Friendship and associations-Need to move to another location, working with new people, separation from close associates. Freedom to do the job the way one has been doing- Increase in supervision, increased responsibilities. Negative attitudes-Towards organization or superiors, lack of trust, earlier bitter experiences. Why individuals resist change? Lack of involvement- No participation in decisions related to change, Lack of first hand information about the change, Opinions are not sought. Personal criticism-Questioning of one’s capability, performance, challenge to authority. Loss of status and authority-Relegation of job to lower level in the hierarchy, loss of power. Why individuals resist change? Inappropriate timing-People are loaded with work. Cognitive rigidity-Belief that old practices that are evolved over time still the best. Challenging authority-want to challenge boss as one do not like him Discomfort with uncertainty-people are not aware of significant details of new state and it leads to ambiguity or uncertainty and they are not comfortable at this state of mind. Why individuals resist change? Attachment to established culture-People may feel threat to established beliefs, values, and artifacts. Perceived breach of psychological contract- Employees form belief as to the nature of reciprocal relationship between them and their employer and it is called psychological contract. People may feel that there may be breach or violation of this contract due to changes that may be brought in. Why individuals resist change? Lack of conviction that the change is needed- Good track record of success, lack of visible crisis, feel that no need of any change at all. Lack of clarity to what is expected Belief that proposed change is inappropriate Excessive change-Several change initiatives at once results in initiative fatigue, burnout etc. Cumulative effect of other changes in one’s own life-changes not related to employment Why individuals resist change? Perceived clash with ethics Reaction to the experience of previous changes Disagreement with the way change is being made Selective perception Fear of unknown Resentment towards the initiators Why people accept change Change results in benefits in terms what an individual values Increased job security-Both job and occupant become more important Increased monetary and other benefits- Increased salary, perks, better working conditions, opportunities for more personal contacts. Personal satisfaction-more interesting job, more challenging, easier job with better performance Opportunity to contribute more Assessing employee attitude to change Helps to determine employees readiness to change Helps to classify individuals on the basis of attitudinal continuum. Quantitative methods-Survey research methods using questionnaires, interviews, and observation methods. Qualitative methods- Analysis of rumors, opinion polls from leaders.