Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CLUB
Dr Vaishali Mathapati
!st year MD Clinical Naturopathy
29/06/2020
DETERMINATION OF EFFICACY OF
REFLEXOLOGY IN MANAGING PATIENTS WITH
DIABETIC NEUROPATHY: A RANDOMIZED
CONTROLLED CLINICAL TRIAL
Author: Krishna Dalal, V. Bharathi Maran, Ravindra M. Pandey, and Manjari
Tripathi
Journal: Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine
Published on 9 January 2014
Impact factor 2.629
ABSTRACT
◦ BACKGROUND
◦ METHOD
◦ RESULT
◦ CONCLUSION
INTRODUCTION
◦ Diabetes can affect nearly every organ system in the body
◦ Prevalence: Worldwide 2000 2.8%
2030 4.4%
India 2006 40.9 million
2025 69.9 million
◦ Risk: 25 Blindness
17 Kidney disease
30-40 Amputation
2-4 MI
2 Stroke
◦ Most common complication: Diabetic Neuropathy
◦ Most common type: Distal Symmetric Polyneuropathy
◦ Type of Neuropathy α duration of Diabetes and Glycaemic control
◦ Patient presentation:
•Distal sensory loss
•Loss of ankle reflex
•Abnormal position sense
•Hyperesthesia
•Paraesthesia
•Related pain
CONVENTIONAL MANAGEMENT
◦ PRIMARY: Glycaemic Control
◦ SECONDARY: Neuropathy pain – Analgesics
Aldoze reductase inhibitors
GABA pentin
Over the time:
Progressive neuropathy
Sensory defect
TITLE AUTHOR CONCLUSION REFERENC
E NO.
Fine Touch and Slow Meissners Corpuscles 0.7 mm below the skin surface [50
Vibration (RA) Hz]
Stronger pressure Pacinian Corpuscles 2mm below the skin surface in dermis
and Fast Vibrations and subcutaneous layers, periosteum
and some viscera. [200-300 Hz]
Autonomic-somatic Integration Theory Nerve Conduction
Sensory nerve to brain for interpretation Hoffmann Reflex: measures the rate of change and the amplitude of
muscular excitability in direct response to a neural stimulus, can show
Efferent signals to site of action
how intense the stimulus is by measuring the changes in the amplitude of
muscle involved.
9. STUDY DESIGN FOR REFLEXOLOGY GROUP: RAs: energy balance, lymphatic system, solar
plexus, adrenal glands, spine, urinary system, digestive system, brain, other endocrine glands, sciatic
nerve, knee and hip.
Difference in neuropathic pain reduction in reflexology group with respect to control group was 52.4%
with a p-Value ˂ 0.001
Secondary Outcome Measures
◦ Positive response in each category of the parameters with statistical significance (p
˂ 0.05) among reflexology group.
◦ 100% response in improving cold sensitivity among reflexology group.
◦ Postprandial blood glucose frequency (p ˂ 0.082)
◦ 21.3% more improvement in reflexology group than control group with p value =
0.001 and 95% confidence interval with respect to QOL
Reflexology Areas
◦ Abnormal characteristics:
• Tenderness
• Hyperpigmentation
• Convexity
• Concavity
• Change in skin colour
• Felling of presence of granules
a b c
d e
(d) reddish brown and concave solar plexus RAs; (e) dark brown and concave solar plexus
RAs (e1) and dark brown pituitary gland RAs (e2);
f
(f) 58M: reddish brown pancreas
(f1)
RA (f1) and reddish brown
(f2) lumbar vertebrae RA (f2);
g1 g2 (g1)-(g2)
30F: concave
and brown
sciatic nerve
RAs.
a b Observations on pancreas
(63M) and adrenal gland
(58M) reflexology areas at
the pre- and post-
reflexology therapy
sessions.
(a) pretherapy session:
reddish brown skin colour
of pancreas RA; (b)
posttherapy session:
pancreas RA with normal
skin colour; (c) pretherapy
c d session: reddish brown
Figure 3 adrenal gland RA and (d)
posttherapy session:
adrenal gland RA with
normal skin colour.
b
Figure 4
a
c d
the subcutaneous features (up to 1.75 mm) of urinary bladder reflexology areas. (a) A normal structure (without the
presence of any abnormal skin characteristics); (b) the onset of an abnormal condition (tender RA); (c) an abnormal
condition (tender and swollen RA); (d) an advanced stage of abnormality (tender, swollen and hard
Table 1. Comparison of Pre and Posttherapy glycosylated hemoglobin and blood glucose in between
groups
Variables Groups Frequency of symptoms Pre and Post Therapy data comparison (mean ± SD)
present in samples*
Pretherapy Posttherapy n Pre Post Improveme p Value
n (n%) (n%) therapy (n = therapy (n = nt (%) 2
29) 29)
HbA1c Reflexology 29 (100%) 10 (34.4%) 9.7 ± 2.5 6.4 ± 1.0 34.0 0.001
Control 29 (100%) 19 (65.5%) 9.4 ± 1.7 8.6 ± 2.1 8.5 0.001
p Value 1.00 0.018 0.5541 0.001
FBS Reflexology 29 (100%) 9 (31.0%) 160.2 ± 46.7 109.6 ± 24.0 31.6 0.001
(mg/dL)
Control 19 (100%) 18 (62.1%) 153.4 ± 32.6 130.7 ± 29.5 14.8 0.001
p Value 1.00 0.018 0.525 0.012
PPBS Reflexology 29 (100%) 17 (58.6%) 230.0 ± 53.4 141.0 ± 15,8 38.7 0.001
(mg/dL)
Control 29 (100%) 24 (82.8%) 220.8 ± 41.9 178.7 ± 40.0 19.1 0.007
p Value 1.00 0.082 0.201 0.002
*The frequency percentage was used to determine the frequency of the trial population presented with a particular physiological
parameter
Table 2: Comparison of different parameters between groups.
Lumbar Vertebrae
(concavity, tenderness, change in skin colour)
Low Back Pain Abnormality
(present) 21 (72.41) 6 (20.69) 0.001
(not present 8 (27.59) 23 (79.39)
Abnormal nocturia, micturition, Urinary Bladder
syncope while coughing, (concavity, tenderness, change in skin colour)
coughing, sneezing, burning Abnormality
sensation during urination)
(present) 24 (82.76) 7 (24.14) 0.001
(not present 5 (17.24) 22 (75.86)
Nausea and vomiting, dyspepsia, Stomach
constipation, lack of appetite, (tenderness, felling of presence of tiny granules)
sour belching, indigestion. Abnormality
(present) 20 (68.96) 7 (24.14) 0.001
(not present 9 (31.03) 22 (75.86)
Sleep disturbance: monophasic Brain
Biphasic (tenderness, feeling of the presence of tiny
polyphasic granules, change in skin colour)
Abnormality
(present) 17 (58.62) 9 (31.03)
0.001
(not present) 12 (41.38) 20 (68.96)
Pancreas
Poor glycemic control, abnormal (tenderness, feeling of the presence of tiny
blood glucose (fasting and granules, change in skin colour)
postprandial) Abnormality
(present) 27 (93.10) 6 (20.69)
0.001
(not present) 2 (6.90) 23 (79.39)