You are on page 1of 61

Introduction to Auditing

(chap 1)
• Definitions and concepts: • External Auditor is an outside firm/auditor
Auditing is an independent examination of financial who does an independent examination of
statements to express an opinion on whether they give a the financial statements in order to express
true and fair view of the state of affairs at a particular an opinion on whether the books give a true
date and comply with IFRS,ISAs and applicable laws at a and fair view of the state of affairs and
time.
comply with applicable laws and IFRS as at
Auditing 11 (P:17) focuses on the practical part of an that date. This may not look at all areas the
audit and to pass this paper the student must know how internal auditor looks at.
to apply the knowledge acquired in Audit 1(P:12)
-Audit is divided into two ie Internal and external audits. • Financial statements include; SOCI, SOFP,
-Internal gives an assurance on the internal control
SOE,CFs, Notes and appendices.
systems eg payment vouchers, Risk management, HR • In doing the audit work, one is guided by the
issues, asset management and governance issues to
achieve company objectives and the auditor is stationed
IFRS and ISAs and for one to be an auditor,
at the entity’s premises but not part of management. you must be better than Accountant ie know
all the applicable standards.

1
Other Assurance services:
• This is an independent opinion where a • Financial Auditing:
professional Accountant evaluates the
responsibility of another and gives an opinion -This is an independent, objective evaluation of
or reasonable assurance to the user. the company’s financial reports and financial
reporting process to give stake holders reasonable
assurance on the accuracy and completeness to
• Areas an auditor can give an assurance enable them make informed decisions.
service include; -It may be conducted to check on disclosures,
compliance, taxation, legal and other purposes.
-Business performance management.
-Forensic audit .Compliance Auditing:
This is a comprehensive review of organization’s
-Value for money adherence to regulatory guidelines. E.g. security
-Risk management process. policies, user access controls and risk management
procedures ie compliance to agreements by governing
-Internal audit body-ICPAU Vs. Firm.
-Social and environmental audit
-Internal control systems.
2
Concepts cont’d Discussion questions

• Operational Auditing: 1.Distinguish between operational


This is the systematic review of effectiveness, efficiency and
audit and Financial Audits.
economy of operation.
2.Explain the advantages and
-It is a future – oriented, systematic and independent
evaluation of organizational activities to identify likely risks, disadvantages of operational
and senior management position to avert them.
audits.
Governance Auditing: 3.Discuss the principles of good
Corporate governance involves a set of relationships that
exist between the B.o.D, management and other stake corporate governance.
holders
-This involves investigating the internal audit’s role in
improving organizational governance and assessing the
principles of good governance e.g openness and
transparency.

3
Need for financial Audits
by external auditors: Code of conduct of
professional Accountants
-The rules of professional conduct apply to accountancy
1. The objectives of management may be students, graduates and members of the profession and
different from those of share holders hence their objective is to ensure that proper standards of the
need to get an independent assurance. profession are observed and thus give fundamental
principles and specific guidance statements.
2.Comply with statutory requirements- Fundamental principles are:
registered, listed -a must. 1.Integrity-honest, fair dealing and straight forward.
2.Objectivity- mind free from bias-Independence from
3.Tax assessments are better done with audited external influence.
financial statements. 3.Professional competence and due care-KES- Don’t
accept work you are not competent- due care- don’t due
4.Help capital mobilization-Listed companies. work for sake of finishing-due diligence.
5.Corporate governance gesture-transparency 4.Confidentiality-Don’t disclose clients information
and accountability. unless otherwise or use it to your advantage.
5.Professional behavior- don’t do things that will
6.Assurance on investment and divestment- discredit the profession, your firm and your sel
f.

right amount charged.


7.Detection of errors and fraud.
8.Increase reliability of F/S to decision makers
e.g banks.
4
Threats to compliance with
fundamental principles:

1.Self review threat-when auditor has to review • Safe guards to threats:


work done by him. -self review- Chinese walls on audit team-
2.Self interest- when a friend or close family has segregation of duties.
a financial or other interest in the client being -Self interest- Disclose and rotate auditors.
audited- employment, loans etc.
-Advocacy- Insist on professional behavior, turn
3.Advocacy threat- auditor is representing/ down the offer.
bargaining for a client eg in courts of law.
-Familiarity- Rotate staff, firm rotation after 3
4.Familiarity threat- overstaying for more than
years.
3-5 years.
-Intimidation- maintain professionalism.
5.Intimidation threat- to give un qualified
opinion ”will expose you” -Un necessary hospitality- Decline or disclose
the gifts
6.Un necessary hospitality- special privilege eg
discounts, free goods/services. -other service- Rotate staff, segregation of
duties.
7.Provision of other assurance services-
taxation HR, etc. 5
Concept of independence THE LEGAL & REGULATORY OF
in relation to audits: FRAME WORK OF AUDITING IN UGANDA

(chap 2)
• This is about objectivity, skepticism and Auditors in Uganda are regulated by the Accountants act
integrity of external auditors in carrying out and no person shall practice accountancy unless he/she
possesses a practicing certificate or license issued under
their audit work. this act and no member shall accept to be appointed as
• Objectivity- mind free from bias Auditors unless they have this certificate issued by ICPAU.
• Eligibility Criteria: To be eligible for registration, one shall:
• Integrity- honest, fair dealing.
1.Be enrolled and registered as a member of ICPAU.
• Skepticism- be negative and doubt when 2.Possess 3 years of relevant and sufficient experience.
approaching audit. 3.Have paid all subscribed fees.

• Independence- includes being free from 4.Have obtained professional indemnity insurance.

external influence ie an auditor must be and 5.Foreign nationals must possess valid work permit.

be seen to be independent in professional 6.In case of partnership-valid partnership deed.


judgment. 7.Have obtained 40 CPD hours in a year prior to application.
8. Have proper registered business practice.
• Threats to auditor independence refer to
9.Free from any significant disciplinary action
above threats to fundamental principles.

6
Major categories of membership (sec 5 of the act)

1. Full membership: One must have • Roles & Responsibilities of ICPAU


passed all the ICPAU papers and or a
member of accountancy body 1.Organise,set and mark exams.
recognized by Council. 2.Establish guideline principles to
2. Associate Membership: For persons its members.
in audit practice on 7th Aug,1992
when the accountants act came into 3.Desciplinary action to its
force but were not qualified as members-questionable behaviors.
professional accountants at that time.
4.Arrange for CPDs for its members
3. Honorary membership: To any body
the council considers deserving. 5.Registration-mbrs,Firms
4. ACCA Members. Law and taxation.

7
Rules governing registered and practicing
auditors( effective mar,2013)

-Firms/auditors are required to comply with • Reasons for regulating auditors:


audit Regulations and guidance.
-The institute has rules and regulations on how
these firms must be run.
1.To ensure registered auditors maintain
high standards of audit work.
Examples are;
- A member must have appropriate qualification, 2.To maintain the reputation of registered
pay membership, attend CPD s, Not advertise, auditors with the public.
Not discredit others, not to engage in illegal 3.To ensure the application of the
activities etc. regulation is fair but firm.
- The regulations must be read in conjunction
with institute’s code of ethics. 4.To ensure regulations apply to all sizes
of firm.
-Examples; Integrity, Objectivity-Independence,
competence& due care, confidentiality, 5.To comply with International standards
Professional behavior. on Audit.(ISAs).
8
Qualification for appointment
as co auditors

-The appointment of an auditor will be done by the • Duties of an auditor(external):


BoD prior to the first annual general meeting of the
co and will hold office until the end of the first 1.To express an independent opinion
annual meeting -cos act sec 159(5). on the truth and fairness of F/S.
-Directors of the co can also fill the position on
casual basis. 2.Duty of due care to 3rd party who rely
- At each annual general meeting, members will on his opinion.
decide who the next auditor should be and 3.Confidentiality-Not disclose-unless
directors will approve the terms of the contract
for first auditor and subsequently, it will be the otherwise.
members to approve. 4.To deposit a statement of
- Registrar may also appoint where the above fail to circumstances up on resignation.
appoint one at an AGM.
- Auditors may be removed from office any time by 5. Not his duty to detect fraud or
members of the the co. during his term in office. control it.
9
Rights of Auditors: Regulations governing the rights
and duties of auditors

1.Access any records of the co –minutes, ISA 250 deals with the auditor’s responsibility to consider
laws and regulations in an audit of financial statements.
files. -It is the responsibility of management, with the
2.Right to attend AGM. oversight of those charged with governance to ensure
the entity’s operations are conducted in accordance with
3.Right to speak in an AGM. provisions of laws and regulations.
-The auditor is not responsible for preventing non-
4.Right to examine books of accounts. compliance and can not be expected to detect non
compliance with the laws and regulations but rather
5.Right to be paid his fees. responsible for giving reasonable assurance that fin.
Statements are free from material misstatements.
6.Right to resign.
7.Right to exercise a lien-if not paid can • Rotation of auditors
confiscate a report.
Sec 139(2) of cos act ,2013,require auditors to be rotated
8.Right to get a copy of any written resolution after a 2 5year term in office and 3 years for cos existing
proposed. before commencement of this act.

10
Resignation & Dismissal
• Resignation of auditors ( procedure)
1.Must deposit a written notice together with
• Reasons auditors may resign
statement of circumstances to members. 1.Disagreement due to change of terms
2.Notice of resignation is sent to regulators by the co. of engagement.
3.The auditor may require directors to call extra-
ordinary meeting to discuss reasons for resignation. 2.Threat to independence that became
known after commencement.
Removal of Auditors: 3.Un able to obtain sufficient evidence on
1.Notice to be given to the auditor.
material misstatement.
2.Resolution from AGM. 4.Not taking corrective actions on
3.Representation by auditor why he must stay in office. recommendation by auditors.
4.Resolution to be deposited to registrar of companies. 5.Illegal activities-money laundering.
6.Failure to pay audit fees by the client.

11
Rights & Duties of Directors: Auditors
Liability:
1.Directors have a duty of running the company
through staff. 1. Negligence; If he fails to design procedures
2.Reporting and accountability to the chair man BoD. that will detect and discover errors and fraud.
3.Ensure appropriate staff to implement day today - Damages- his duty is to ensure that f/s give a
true and fair view position of the state of affairs
work. and if he fails to detect that, he is liable.
4.Decision making and together with NEDS.they
- Losses on contractual breach; If he fails to
formulate the strategy to achieve goals. examine books of accounts and detect
5.Implement policies laid down by NEDS. fraudulent entries e.g in the case of city fire
6.Monitor performance in operations. insurance co.(1924), the directors made frauds
on items of balance sheet for 3 years and
7.Build and maintain effective management team. auditors failed to detect them and were sued.
8.Represent the company to major suppliers, - They were held liable for negligence because
customers and professionals. the auditor relied on certificates and never
examined the books-KES

12
2. Criminal liability: 3.Liability to 3rd party( Tort):

• Its an offence to accept an appointment when


not capable. • 3rd party may sue the auditor for
• Criminal liability can a rise under the following; damages but plaintiff must prove;
• Accepting an appointment when ineligible e.g 1) The defendant (auditor) owed a
continuing in office after becoming ineligible.
• Instances of fraud e.g misappropriation of
duty of care.
assets, falsifying records etc. 2) The defendant breached the
• Insider dealing ie misuse of un published appropriate standard of care.
information e.g pending change in price of
shares. 3) The plaintiff suffered a loss as a
Penalty- Warning, fines, reprimand, direct result of relying on it.
imprisonment or expulsion depending.

13
4.Liability under private & 5. Liability under public interest
statutory audits:

• Auditor has a duty to report to members/ • A member of the public can sue the auditor in
appointing authority on whether; public interest.
• F/S are free from material misstatements. • Auditors are obliged to act in public interests
and should consider whether to report in the
• Prepared in accordance to IFRS and interest of the public or not.
applicable laws. • Failure to do that may result in legal suit.
• Directors report is consistent with F/S.
In case things go wrong, auditor will be
liable either under negligence or tortious
liability.

14
Safeguards to reduce liability

• Proper client screening- understanding-KYC.


• Compulsory insurance for directors and staff
(professional indemnity).
• Financial cap on liability.
• Maintain independency-skepticism.
• Document your work properly.
• Deal with clients with no integrity issues-
fraud, illegal activities.
• Modification of the joint and several liability
principle.

15
AUDIT PLANNING (ISA 300)
(chap 3)
Questions
• Assignment: • It is the formulation of a strategy that is used
• Read about the following: to collect audit evidence on which the
opinion is based.
• Corporate governance
• The auditor should plan and perform the
• Audit committee, its objectives and role.
audit with an attitude of professional
• Role of Board, NEDS,CEO, Board skepticism recognizing that circumstances
may exist which cause f/s to be material
misstated.
• Types of audit plans:
1. Flexible- for each audit irrespective of past
audit
2. Standard plans-prepared once and is used for
all audits.

16
Rationale for Audit planning: Planning
Activities:
1.To maximize the efficiency(resources) and 1.Establish an overall audit strategy-scope,
effectiveness(objectives) of audit. applicable laws & IFRS, and timing-when is the
2.To identify risky and problematic areas. report needed.
2.Develop detailed audit plan-
3.It is the requirement of the standard (ISA
300). 3.Continous update of above 1 &2 -new things
4.To establish a strategy/direction-when, where, come up.
what, how and why. 4.Directing and supervision audit team and
5.To determine the appropriate fees-time, reviewing work.
scope, Risk, skills & seniority. 5.Documenting all above-minutes.
6.To minimize client disruption- auditors are 6.Communication-with management and those
visitors. charged with governance.
7.Time saving.

17
Details on planning activities: Source of information on
client
(Understanding
business)
1. Overall audit strategy: • From the client-meeting.
This includes the scope of the audit, • Review of the previous f/s-SOCI,SOFP,CFs etc.
characteristics of engagement in relation to • Website-company profile, products,
applicable laws and GAAPS, ascertaining the management caliber.
date, direction and resources needed to
complete the audit. • Trade press.
2.Developing a detailed Audit Plan: • Previous auditors- management integrity,
strategy.
This include the following:
• Board minutes- authorization , Resolutions.
-Understanding the business-what client does,
customers, directors. • Internal audit reports.
-Understanding accounting and internal control • Policies and procedure manuals
systems. • Industry survey and experts
-Risk identification and assessment. • Suppliers and customers.
-Setting materiality levels.
-Design the audit methodology and time table.
18
Uses of information:
1)Staffing and expert team: • Qualitative must be disclosed however
• How many staff. small it is otherwise even if it is one shs, its
• Skills and experience.
material.
• Ethical issues- independency. • Fraud and errors.
• Firm with –KES. • Related party transactions.
11) Determination of the nature, purpose and scope- • Directors emoluments.
how long.
111) Materiality levels-(if it exceeds below, then its
material) 1v) Risk assessment- directly related to fees
-Quantitative- General errors-> 10% charge
-Turn over >0.5 – 1% AR= CR*IR*DR
- Net assets > 1%- 2%
- Net profit >5%-10%

19
Risk Identification & assessment (ISA 315)

• This is done to determine whether • Audit Risk Modal


the risk is high, moderate or low.
AR=CR*IR*DR
• Risk is related to fees ie the higher
the risk, the higher the fees. Where;
• It also has implication on scope, AR= Audit Risk
staffing, materiality levels, strategy CR= Control Risk
to use and acceptance or rejection.
IR = Inherent Risk
DR = Detection Risk

20
Materiality Levels (ISA 320)
Refers to the significance of an item to the f/s and • Discussion questions:
differs from business to business- use judgment. 1) Discuss reasons for the need to have an
-The higher the Risk, the lower the materiality levels. independent examination of books of accounts.
- Materiality levels-(if it exceeds below, then its 2) ISA 300, gives guidelines on things an auditor must
material) perform at preliminary Review. Explain them.
-Quantitative- General errors-> 10% 3) What are the matters one should consider and
procedures to be done before accepting an
-Turn over >0.5 – 1% appointment of an audit assignment? Give reasons
- Net assets > 1%- 2% not to commence an audit before the above
- Net profit >5%-10% procedures are done.
• Qualitative: must be disclosed however small it is 4) Discuss the key stages in an audit (Audit process).
otherwise even if it is one shs, its material.e.g. 5) What is an engagement letter? What is its purpose
• Fraud and errors. and state its contents.
• Related party transactions. 6) With examples, explain the 3 categories of business
• Directors emoluments. Risks.

21
Materiality cont’d
7) Discuss indicators of going concern
problems.
8) Distinguish between ‘’opinion shopping’’
and ‘’low balling’’ and how can you deal
with opinion shopping?.
9) Discuss the preliminary activities you
would consider important for an audit
exercise.
10) What conditions and events may
indicate Risks of material misstatements.

22
INTERNAL CONTROL SYSTEMS:
( chap 4)
3)Corrective controls: These aim at restoring the
Internal control systems refer to policies and system or process back to the state prior to harmful
procedures in place to ensure the company’s event e.g. after evidence was discovered that there
objectives are achieved.-aim at minimizing risks that was fraud.
may stop achieving co objectives. 4) Administrative controls: These are laws,
regulations, policies, practices and guidelines that
govern the overall requirements and controls for an
Types of Controls: information security e.g. data security
1) Detective controls: These monitor activity to
5) Physical controls: These prevent access office or
identify instances where practices or procedures storage room e.g. video surveillance systems, gates
were not followed e.g. bank reconciliation to and barricades, remote backup facilities and guards.
detect fraudulent payments. 6) Logical controls: These are vital application and
2) Preventive controls: These aim at preventing the technical controls (systems and software) e.g.
loss or harm from occurring e.g. segregation of firewalls, anti virus software.
duties to minimize fraud.

23
Principal control objectives: Pros and cons of
Internal control systems
• Protect against financial loss. Pros:
• Prevent fraudulent acts by employees. • Limit access to un authorized personnel.
• Inventory control. • Optimal control.
• Product quality • Easy monitoring

• Safe guard company assets. • Inventory control.


• Product quality
• Comply with laws.
• Safe guard company assets.
• Public trust-secure finance.

Cons:
.Costs- Installation
.Passcodes, pins, password-threat.

24
Role of control systems in Discussion questions
detecting errors and fraud

• Error: Refers to un intentional misapplication of


accounting policies, oversights or interpretations of
• Distinguish between fraud and
fact and clerical mistakes. error as used in Audit of
• Fraud: Refers to acts which may involve falsification financial statements.
of documents and records, misappropriation of
assets or misapplication of accounting policies to • State the factors and conditions
ones advantage.
that promote fraud in
• Strong internal controls are expected to result in
less fraud. organizations.
• Internal controls do not guarantee elimination of
the risk of errors and fraud.
• The main goal of internal control systems is to
reduce the risk to an acceptable levels ie
reasonable assurance

25
Understanding the accounting and internal
control systems: ( chap 5)
• Internal control systems refer to policies and 2. Entity’s Risk assessment: How management
procedures in place to ensure the company’s identifies business risk, risk register and know
objectives are achieved.-aim at minimizing which controls to avert them.
risks that may stop achieving co objectives. -Risks can arise or change due to the following;
• Components of good internal 1) Changes in operating environment-
regulations.
control systems. 2) New personnel- new ideas.
1.Control environment: This includes 3) New or revamped information systems.
communication and enforcement of 4) Rapid growth – breakdown
integrity and ethical values,
5) New technology
participation by those charged with
governance, organization structure, HR 6) New products
policies and practices. 7) Expanded foreign operations.

26
Components cont’d
3. Control activities: This includes
performance reviews- actual vs budgets,
physical controls-security, access etc.

4. Monitoring controls: This includes


establishing whether staff are following.

5. Information systems: This includes


recording information from the start to
the end eg receivables, payables etc.

27
Features of good internal controls
• O- Organization plan/ chart • S-Segregation of duties
• R- Recording and record keeping • O-Organizational chart
• D- Division or segregation of duties.
• A- Authorization
• A- Authorization and approval
• P-Physical controls
• S- Supervision
• S- Safeguarding assets
• S-Supervision
• I- Internal audit • P-Personnel
• C- Competence of staff • A-Arithmetic procedures
• A- Arithmetic and accounting controls • M-Management

28
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER
TRANSACTION CYCLES AND AUDIT
PROCEDURES
• Transactions • For each of the above, look at;
• The auditor needs to know the following
accounting information; 1) Transaction.
1) Sales and accounts receivable. 2) Control objective
2) Purchases and accounts payable. 3) Control procedure in place
3) Salaries and wages system-payroll.
4) Audit procedure.
4) Cash and bank system-reconciliation.
5) Inventory management system- IAS 2
6) Revenue and capital expenditure.
7) Tangible assets.
8) Non current liabilities

29
Details
1. Sales and Accounts Receivables • Objectives:
1. That all sales are correctly recorded –Amt,
• The system assumes sales are made on credit with accuracy, occurrence etc.
the following steps;
1. Get an order from the customer.
2. That all payments received if not, there is
accounts receivable in place.
2. Check availability of the goods in stock and credit
limit. 3. To ensure procedure to collect receivables
are in place to avoid bad debts- time.
3. Approval of the sales order.
4. Dispatch of goods- customer must acknowledge 4. To know at what point is revenue
Dispatch Note. recognized.- comply with IFRS, IAS 18.
5. Invoice the customer- Revenue recogn-P &L 5. How to account /make a provision.
Receivable in Bal. sheet 6. Sales are made to valid customers.
6. Payment by the customer.

30
Details cont’d
• Control procedures over sales and • Audit procedures on Receivables:
Receivables: 1. Tests of control: Check authorization for
1. Orders: Be checked vs customers accounts, acceptance of orders, dispatch, serial
credit limit given, pre-number sales, numbers, accuracy, etc.
authorization and use of dispatch Note. 2. Substantive procedures: Check records
2. Dispatch: Dispatch Note to be pre- additions, postings, sales day book, invoice
numbered, authorization of dispatch and and credit notes, inventory records
acknowledgment by buyer.
3. Circularization- to third parties to confirm
3. Invoicing & credit Notes: Be authorized by existence and valuation.
responsible person, entered in sales book,
4. Analytical procedures: cut offs, disclosures,
serial numbered and cancelled retained.
fluctuations in sales
4. Returns:Be checked and credit Note issued.
5. Bad debts: Be authority to write off

31
Details cont’d
2. Purchases & payable system • Purchase/ procurement procedures & their
(procurement): controls ( Test controls)
1. Requisition from the user department
Objectives:
2. Sourcing or call for quotations- competitive
1. To ensure purchases are made when there is bidding of atleast 3 suppliers.
need.
3. Evaluation of quotations to get best
2. Ensure VFM in procurement.
4. Issue of LPO or purchase invoice –Numbering
3. Goods/services delivered are what was
ordered. 5. Receipt of goods- GRN
4. Ensure quality of goods/services. 6. Returns out- ensure acknowledgment
5. To ensure all liabilities are recorded correctly. 7. Recognition of liability in ledgers- payable
6. That liabilities are paid in time to avoid risks. 8. Payment- ensure approval and obtain receipt

32
Details cont’d
3. Inventory Management (IAS 2) • Control procedures over inventory
- Receipt of goods into the store is the starting point.
- For consultancy firm, don’t waste time because
these are done after understanding the business. 1. Approval & control of documents eg
issues.
Objectives 2. Ensure there is a bin card and stock card
1. To ensure accompany has adequate levels 3. Arithmetic accuracy eg value of WIP
2. To ensure what you received is what you ordered 4. Comparison of assets and records- auditor
for. must attend the exercise.
3. To ensure quality not dead stock receipts.
5. Access to assets and records be restricted
4. To ensure both receipts and returns are approved. to avoid theft and damage.
5. To ensure safety & proper valuation

33
Details cont’d
4. Salaries &wages system (payroll) • Control procedures on payroll:
Objectives: 1. Authorization and control of documents eg
over time.
5. To ensure right people are paid-not ghosts.
2. Time sheets
6. Ensure employees are paid at the correct
rate. 3. Segregation of duties preparation,
authorization and approval
7. To ensure employees are paid for work
done. 4. Ensure correct rates and benefits are
captured.
8. To ensure statutory deductions are made
and remitted. 5. Keep personal records- placement,
promotions etc
9. To ensure deductions are correct.
6. Cheque signatories checked.

34
Details cont’d
• Tests of control on payroll: • Substantive procedures
1. Sample time sheets, clock cards 1. Select sample of time records eg
2. Observe wage distribution calculations
3. Test authority for payment of casual workers 2. Test rates of pay
4. Test control over payroll amendments 3. Details of leavers and joiners
5. Examine evidence of checking payroll 4. Test postings of payroll to generate ledger
calculations. accounts.
6. Inspect payroll reconciliations
7. Examine explanations for payroll deductions.
8. Test controls over un claimed wages.

35
Details cont’d
5. Cash and Bank system:
This includes cash at hand and cash at bank and
the auditor should ensure what is in the cash b) Controls over banking:
book tally with what is cash at bank.
- Receipts should be banked intact daily
It includes the following controls;
- Each day’s receipt be recorded promptly in
a) Controls over cash: Cash book.
- Recorded when a sale has taken place. - Sales ledger personnel should have no access
- Pre-number sales invoice & maintain a register to the cash or preparation of pay in slips
- Cash received should be reconciled daily with - Approval of withdrawals
invoice totals by independent person.
- Daily banking and reconciliation

36
Details con’t
c) Bank Reconciliation: d) Controls over petty cash:
- The level and location of cash floats be laid
down formally.
- Bank Reconciliations should be prepared at
least monthly. - Restricted access to the floats.

- Person responsible for preparation should be - Cash should be kept in a safe.


independent of receipts and payments. - Ensure approval of expenditures.
- Statements should be obtained directly from - Budget to be followed.
the bank and held until reconciliation is
- Receipts for each payment to be made.
complete.
- Vouchers to be produced before cheque is
signed for reimbursement.
- Abrupt/surprise cash checks and counts.

37
Details cont’d
6: Revenue & Expenditure system 7: Tangible Assets (NCA)
- Ensure there is capital expenditure budgets-
refer to procurement process.
The audit of tangible assets should check;
- Ensure expenditure is on company’s
a) Existence- select a sample from asset
expenses.
register and physically inspect.
- Ensure expenses are recorded at correct
b) Completeness- check from books to ensure
amount each is included.
Key controls are: c) Valuation- correct amount- depreciation
- Requisition -Pre-number
d) Rights and obligation- ownership-title
- Approval - Cancel payments- PAID e) Disclosure- Face and notes
- Receipt

38
Details cont’d
8. Non current Liabilities: 9. Audit of payables and Accruals:
- Loans payable- Agree loan balance to the loan 1. -Obtain a list of individual balances from
statement. the payables ledgers, check the cost and
- Agree interest payments to the loan agreements.
agree totals to trade payables figures in
the draft financial statements.
- Recalculate interest accruals for accuracy.
2. Ensure the balances have been correctly
- Analyze relevant disclosures of interest rates,
amounts due etc.
extracted from the payables’ ledger.
- Provisions and contingencies- Discuss the matter 3. Obtain a list of debt balances in the
giving rise to a provision with the client to payables ledger and obtain explanations
establish whether the obligation exist. from management.
- Obtain confirmation from client’s lawyers- 4. Agree brought forward figures from the
probability of making payment. last year’s audit file.

39
Details cont’d
• Note the following on payables • Cont’d
1. Presentations & disclosures: - Review after date invoices and payments
and ensure they have been provided for at
Check that the figures disclosed in the F/S the year end as appropriate.
agree to the audited figures.
- Analytical review
2. Existence - Calculate the trade payables payment
Circularize a sample of trade payables to period and compare to the last year’s to
confirm the balance at the end of the year. assess reasonableness.
3. Completeness. 4. Cut offs:
- Investigate any supplier names that were - Select as ample of GRN’s immediately prior
shown on last year’s payables listing but do to the year end and included in the year end
not have a balance showing in present year’s payables and ensure that the goods are
list balances. included in the year end inventories.

40
Details cont’d
• Accruals • Questions
- Review relevant invoices when received a) Identify the audit procedures on
after the balance sheet date – if non are Accounts payables, Accruals and
received compere with the previous
period. other provisions.
- Obtain a list of accruals from the client, b) Give reasons why audit of trade
cast it to confirm arithmetic accuracy. payables, accruals and provisions
- Agree the figures per schedule to the is more demanding than audit of
general ledger and Financial statements. trade receivables, prepayments
- Agree the calculation of accrual by and other receivables
reference to the supporting documents Ref bk
e.g previous period invoice.

41
AUDIT PROCEDURES(AUDIT RESPONSE TO RISKS)- ISA
330:
(EXECUTION) –chap 8
• This involves the audit strategy or • Tests of control include the following;
approaches/responses in response to assessed Risk
in execution of the audit assignment. 1) Sequence test checks: This involves checking invoice,
credit Notes and orders to ensure that all items are
• There are basically 2 types of audit procedures ie included and no duplications.
-Tests of controls. 2) Checks on authorization for; acceptance of the orders,
dispatch ,pricing and discounts, write off bad debts and
-Substantive tests. signatures.
3) Arithmetic accuracy: invoices, credit Notes and sales
1. Tests of control: tax.

-These are procedures performed to get evidence as to 4) Checks on dispatch Notes and goods returned note,
credit note.
whether internal controls is working or performing as
expected i.e. is it followed. . Analytical procedures:
-It is the requirement of the standard that even if the These are a must perform even if internal controls are good
controls are good-do test of control + analytical and they include trend and Ratio analysis- used for
procedures e.g. bank reconciliation. comparisons.

42
Procedures cont’d: Substantive procedures to
get
evidence include:
2. Substantive Tests: • A- Analytical procedure-trend, Ratio
-These are procedures you perform to detect a • E – Enquiry from management- meeting.
misstatement in the f/s e.g. controls are weak and
you do such tests to check on accuracy. • I - Inspection- documents and tangible assets
-There are 2 types of substantive tests ie • O- Observation- e.g. stock.
-Analytical procedures. • U- RecompUte e.g. bank reconciliation, addns
- Tests of detail.
Analytical procedures:
- Include trend and Ratio Analysis
Tests of detail/ Detail testing:
Involves getting a sample, check on every supporting
documents from start to the end.

43
Presentation of Financial Statements in view of IFRS:
(chap 9)

• Definitions: Components of Full set of F/S:


• General purpose F/S: These are F/S intended to meet • SOCI-( Income statement)
the needs of users who are not in a position to require
an entity to prepare reports tailored to their particular • SOFP-(Balance sheet)
information needs. • CFs –(IAS 7)
• IFRS: These are standards and interpretations adopted • SOE
by the IASB and they comprise of-IFRs,
IAS,IFRIC( International International Reporting • Notes and Appendices to F/S.
Interpretations Committee
• Objective of IAS 1: To prescribe the basis for
presentation of general purpose F/S to ensure
comparability of the entity with other entities and Scope of IAS 1:
entity's current and previous years. • It applies to general purpose F/S based on IFRS.
• IAS 1 sets guidelines for the structure and minimum
requirements for the contents of F/S.

44
Fair presentation and Assumptions in presentation
compliance with IFRS: of F/S:
• The F/S must ‘’present fairly’’ the financial position, • Going concern: An entity preparing IFRS F/S is
financial performance and cash flows of an entity. presumed to be a going concern about the entity’s
ability to continue as a going concern, the un
• Fair presentation requires the faithful
certainties must be disclosed and if so, F/S must be
representation of the effects of transactions, either
prepared on a breakup.
events and conditions in accordance with the
definitions and recognition criteria of assets, • Accrual basis: IAS 1 requires that an entity
liabilities, income and expenses with those setout prepares its F/S except for cash flow information,
in the frame work. using accrual basis of accounting.
• The application of IFRS with additional disclosures • Here, transactions and events are simply
when necessary, is presumed to result in F/S that recognized at the point when they occur and
achieve a fair presentation. matched to the period in the F/S to which they
relate.
• Offsetting: Assets and liabilities, and incomes and
expenses may not be offset unless required or
permitted by a standard or interpretation.

45
Assumptions cont’d: Structure of F/S in general

• The following must clearly be shown;


• Consistency of presentation: The presentation and
classification of items in the F/S shall be retained • Name of the entity.
from one period to the next unless changes/ a • The Financial statements
change is justified either by a change in
circumstances or a requirement of a new IFRS. • The date or period covered
• Materiality and aggregation: Each material class of • The presentation currency
items must be presented separately in the F/S and • The level of precision e.g thousands, millions.
dissimilar items may be aggregated only if they are
individually immaterial.
• Comparative information: IAS 1 requires that • Reporting period: There is a presumption that F/S
comparative information shall be disclosed in will be prepared at least annually, if there a change
respect of the previous period for all amounts and F/S are prepared for a different period, it must
reported in the F/S and Notes unless another be disclosed.
standard requires otherwise -for comparison.

46
SOFP(Balance sheet): Minimum items on face of
SOFP
• An entity must normally present a classified • PPE(IAS 16).
balance sheet, separating NCA and current assets • Investment property(IAS 40)
and liabilities i.e. Financial position.
• Biological assets(IAS 41)
• IAS 1 does not prescribe the format of the
• Intangible assets
statement of Financial position to be used but a
net asset presentation is allowed i.e. Assets- • Financial assets
Liabilities. • Inventories(IAS 2)
• Trade & other Receivables
• Cash and cash equivalents
• Trade and other payables
• Provisions
• Capital and reserves
• Liabilities
• Drawings

47
SOCI (Income statement): Discussion
questions
• All items of income and expense recognized in a period 1) What steps would you follow to carry out
must be included in the profit or loss unless a standard analytical procedures?
or an interpretation requires otherwise. 2) Evaluate the factors and procedures to be
Minimum items on the face include; performed in deciding the extent of reliance on
the work of an internal auditor.
• Revenue
• C.O.S 3) What factors may signal to you that an
organization could be having high level of
• Finance costs inherent Risk.
• Share of profits/loss of associates/joint venture 4) Distinguish fraud from error. List the indicators
• Tax expense of fraud in an organization?
• Administrative expense 5) ISA 570 requires an auditor to consider going
• Interest expense concern of an entity. Discuss the financial and
• Profit or loss Formats for F/S – non financial indicators of going concern
problems.
Refer to your Financial Accounting Notes-formats

48
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
ASSERTIONS:
• Definition. These are management’s 1) Completeness: Here, auditors ascertains
explanation(claims) about the recognition, whether all Revenues, expenses, assets and
measurement, presentation and disclosure of liabilities have been captured. These affects
information in the F/S. the SOCI and SOFP.
• Accountants evaluate records based on 2) Occurrence: Did all transactions in respect
assertions imbedded in the in the F/S. of Revenue and Expenses take place and for
• Example in preparation of F/S management the entity. This affects the SOCI.
makes claims on buildings appearing in the
balance sheet valued at 100m. The auditor shall 3) Valuation: Have all the assets and liabilities
assume that the building exists, is owned and been captured at the correct value e.g there
controlled by the company, accurately valued could be a risk that trade receivables are not
etc. properly valued. This applies to SOFP.
• The auditor comes in to verify and see which 4) Existence: Are all items in the balance sheet
assertions and what F/S does it affect. These there ie assets, liabilities, equity.
assertions include - COVERMPC.

49
Discuss the audit work/ tests you would
perform on accounts Receivable

5) Rights and obligations: Do assets and


liabilities in the balance sheet belong to
the entity.
6) Measurement: Revenue and expenditure
or transactions have been captured at the
right amount. They apply to income
statement.
7) Presentation and disclosure: Each has
been categorized appropriately ie
NCA,NCL CA, CL, Revenue and expenses.
8) Cut off: That transactions and events have
been recorded in the correct accounting
period ie accruals and prepayments.

50
AUDIT SAMPLING:
• Audit sampling means the • Sampling Methods:
application of audit procedures to 1) Random sampling-where each item in the
less than 100% of the items within population has an equal chance of being
selected.
an account balance or less
2) Systematic/ interval sampling –start with
transactions in order to assist in random, then select nth item there after.
forming a conclusion concerning 3) Stratified sampling –divide population into
the account balance or class of subpopulations then samples selected
transactions. from them.
• Population- Is a set of data from 4) Monetary unit- every shilling has an equal
chance.
which the auditor wishes to sample
in order to reach a conclusion. 5) Attribute sampling- According to
characteristics e,g. sex, age.

51
Sampling cont’d
• Where sampling is not • Factors that influence size of the sample:
advisable: • Auditor’s intended reliance on systems of
controls.
1) Where population is too small.
• Expected error- deviation is high, large
2) Transactions are small in number. sample.
3) Material fraud indication. • Confidence level required by the auditor-
4) Director’s salary and taxation. high, large sample.
5) Where population has not been • Number of sampling units in the
maintained In a manner suitable for population.
audit sampling. E.g where sales are • Nature of risk- Higher risk, large sample.
maintained per customer and not • Population size- large the population, the
numerically. larger the sample size.

52
AUDIT EVIDENCE (ISA 500):
• Audit evidence refers to all information • Factors that determine the reliability of
used by the auditor in arriving at the evidence.(DOIID)
conclusions on which the audit opinion 1. Documentation: Documented evidence is
is based. more reliable than verbal.
2. Original documentation: Original documents
• ISA 500 requires that auditors should more reliable than photocopies –never audit on
obtain sufficient and appropriate audit photocopies.
evidence to be able to draw reasonable 3. Independent source: More reliable if obtained
conclusions on which to base the audit independently eg bank statement obtained from
opinion. the bank.
• Sufficient- looks at quantity/volume 4. Internal control systems: More reliable where
internal controls are effective e.g segregation of
• Appropriate- Quality of audit evidence duties.
ie reliability and relevancy. 5. Direct source: More reliable e.g observation.

53
Evidence cont’d
• Concept of Relevancy • Assertions on PPE F/S
Audit evidence should be relevant procedure
to the applicable assertions e.g
having a car log book does not
confirm its existence.
- Have procedures on valuation,
existence, completeness e.g PTO

54
Evidence cont’d
• Procedures/Techniques to • NOTE
gather Evidence • Evidence is used to support the
A- Analytical procedures- trends, Ratio opinion
for comparison
E- Enquiry- from mgmt. and staff
I- Inspection- of records/documents
O- Observation
U- RecompUtation
C - Circularization- 3rd party

55
AUDIT DOCUMENTATION( ISA 230)
• The principle in audit evidence is that it must • WORKING PAPERS
be documented ie anything you do during the • These are documents which record all audit evidence
audit must be documented as per ISA 230 in obtained during financial statements auditing, internal
audit working papers. management, systems auditing and investigations.
• Contents of working papers/Attributes
• Importance of documentation
1. Name of the client you are auditing.
1. It Is a proof that you performed your work- 2. Period covered by the audit.
ref.
3. Subject matter eg PPE, Receivables
2. It can save you in case they take you to court. 4. Person who prepared/reviewed them.
3. It increases audit efficiency and effectiveness. 5. Objective to be achieved.
4. It is the requirement of the standard 6. Procedures that were performed.
5. It helps in reviews- peer, cold and hot 7. Results/findings, conclusion.
reviews 8. Headed paper, evidence, tests and sample size used.

56
Documentation cont’d
• Specimen of working paper • AUDIT FILE
Client …. Prepared by…. Date..
Year end: …. File is where audit working papers
Subject: PPE Reviewed by… are filed. They are of 2 types i.e
Date…..
Objective: To determine whether PPE exist.
-Permanent and
-Current files
Work done: Audit procedures performed-
sampling

Results/ Findings- some assets missing

Conclusion- PPE not properly recorded……

57
Documentation cont’d
• PERMANENT FILE • CURRENT FILE
• These keep evidence that is of permanent • These keep evidence that keeps changing every
nature about the client e.g. understanding year and include the following;
business of your client, you come a cross the 1. Schedules of Revenues
following that have to be filed;
2. Fixed asset register
1. Memorandum and articles of association
3. Debtors aging schedule
2. Procedure manuals
4. Current year’s financial statements
3. Strategic plans.
5. Current year’s staffing strategies
4. Accounting policies and systems
6. Current year’s board work plans
5. Funding and loan agreements.
7. New signed procurement deals
6. Titles of ownership 8. Financial reporting time table.
7. Previous year’s audit reports 9. Others – ref Revenues, expenses, bal sheet
8. Previous year’s financial statements. heads

58
COMPLETION AND REVIEW
• Audit reviews
• This is the overall stage at which the final 3. Have the necessary completion procedures
decisions are taken. The auditor should ask been carried out ie
him/herself the following questions;
- Subsequent events review- ISA 560/ IAS 10
1. Do the F/S comply with the relevant Reporting
frame work ie Laws and other regulations, - Going concern review- ISA 570/ IAS 1
GAAPS,IFRS. - Management representation obtained ISA
2. Does the audit evidence gathered in the course 580
of audit support the audit opinion ie
- Final analytical review – ISA 520
- Was the plan followed
- Second partner review/ opinion
- Sufficient and appropriate audit evidence
- Draft report(mgt letter & report)- ISA 700
- What issues arose
- Has the file been adequately reviewed by - Contingencies
senior - Opening balances

59
1. Subsequent events review (ISA 560)
• The auditor should study the effect of events • Non adjusting events
after reporting date(ISA 560) on the F/S and • For example Stock destroyed by fire after
auditor’s report. balance sheet date.
• IAS 10, deals with the treatment of F/S events
both favorable and un favorable that occur
between the date of F/S ie bal. sheet date and Audit procedures on subsequent
when statements are authorized for issue. events:
• Events can either be adjusting or non adjusting 1. Be sensitive to dates of occurrence.
ie
2. Confirm the event is directly or indirectly
related to F/S information.
• Adjusting events include- law suite where the
3. Review Board minutes.
lawyer has assured you the client will win the
case, bad debts written off and debtor 4. Always assess materiality of the event.
reappears and pays. 5. Review management F/S (Accounts).

60
2. Going concern Review (ISA 570 /IAS 1):

61

You might also like