Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Meaning, Nature Value
Meaning, Nature Value
in the eye of
justice
NATURE & VALUE
• Investigation into the abstract, general and theoretical nature of law. Some points under
investigation include:
Pros and cons of codification,
Methods of judicial reasoning,
Value of a strict system of judicial precedent, etc.
• Deals with why the questions, rather than what the questions are.
• Distinguishes law from morality, etiquette and other related phenomena.
• Attempts to look at the actual working of an authority within a particular system.
• Abstract study of the concepts of ‘right’, ‘duty’, ‘intention’, ‘negligence’, ‘ownership’,
‘possession’, etc. against the background of ordinary language to understand the relation
between law and legal usage.
• The jurist assumes the role of a logician by elucidating legal notions, removing confusion
and constructing a synthesis of legal concepts.
NATURE & VALUE
• Undertakes the task of linking law with other disciplines to locate law within a wider
social context and the changing economic and political attitudes.
• Helps in formulation of general principles from individual cases. Eg.: the English Law
relating to Negligence.
• Has an educational value. Provides a logical analysis of legal concepts which sharpens
the lawyer’s technique and broadens his understanding.
• Helps in checking the vices of legal formalism by accommodating present social needs
rather than the distilled wisdom of the past.
• Not concerned with derivation and application of rules, rather reflects on the nature
of rules, on the underlying meanings of the concept and on the essential features of
legal systems.
• Is not derived from authority.
NATURE & VALUE
• Harold Laski calls Jurisprudence the “eye of law”.
• Provides logical training to the lawyer by training the critical faculties to detect fallacies and
use accurate legal terminology and expression.
• It is the grammar of law:
Helps legislators acquaint with precise and unambiguous terminology.
Helps judges in ascertaining true meanings of the laws passed by the legislatures by
providing the rules of interpretation.
• J.G. Phillimore, “Such is the exalted science of jurisprudence, the knowledge of which sends
the students into civil life, full of luminous precepts and notions, applicable to every
exigency of human affairs.”
• Helps in improvement of law in the context of prevailing socio-economic and political
philosophies.
• Prof. R.W.M. Dias, “…Teachers of law hope to encourage their pupils to learn how to think
rather than what to know and jurisprudence is peculiarly suited to this end.”
JURISPRUDENCE AND OTHER SOCIAL SCIENCES