Professional Documents
Culture Documents
False, according to Admission of Advocates Act a person must be over 21 years old to become
an advocate
True or False:
• Roman Law was codified for the first time in the Law of the Twelve
Tables.
True, the first codification of Roman Law was found in the Twelve Tables
Identify and explain Justinian’s
codification of law. (10 Marks)
• Justinian’s codification codified Roman law, as this was know as, the
Corpus Iuris Civilis, which was made up of the following:
• Institutiones – Textbooks provided to law students to simplify the law;
• Digesta – The codification of writings and opinions of jurists who wrote
on Roman Law;
• Codex – The collection of imperial legislation; and
• Novellae – New Legislation passed by Justinian.
Explain the difference between
substantive and procedural law (8):
Substantive Law: Procedural Law:
• Substantive law is the written and • Procedural law, which is sometimes also referred
to as adjectival law, deals broadly with the rules
unwritten law of a country that defines according to which a court hears legal proceedings
the legal relationships between people, and what happens in these proceedings.
as well as between people and the state. • Sub-categories of procedural law: The law of
• Substantive law in turn can be divided evidence
into two main branches which is public • The law of criminal procedure; the law of civil
procedure; and the law of interpretation of
law and private law. statutes.
Explain what is meant by Mediation: (5)
• Mediation is a consensus-based approach where the parties to a
dispute involve a neutral or acceptable third party, the mediator, to
assist them in resolving the dispute.
• In doing so, the parties hope to arrive at a mutually acceptable and
binding solution. Mediation is also sometimes referred to as
conciliation.
• The mediator should be an independent, mutually accepted third party
who will listen to both sides of the case and then make proposals or
recommendations on how the dispute could be resolved.
List the requirements to become an Advocate in South
Africa with reference to relevant authority (6):
• A key feature of the Constitution is that it seeks to transform South Africa from its deeply
divided, unequal past into a society founded on equality, dignity, and freedom. In this sense
the Constitution, unlike many other constitutions, does not seek to maintain a status quo.
The Constitution is an ambitious legal document that aims to change the material
conditions of South African society.
• The Constitution, given its transformative nature, emphatically demands attention to history
and the existing socio-economic context when interpreting and applying its rules.
• Transformative constitutionalism demands that lawyers are aware of how the law does and
can play a role in affecting power relations, access to resources, and human dignity.
• It also demands that lawyers understand that legal reasoning is heavily influenced by a
lawyer’s political and moral convictions, especially when the law is ambiguous or vague.
Distinguish between law and morality (6):
Law: Morality:
• Law is a body/system of rules that • Morality is a natural feeling that
regulates conduct and behaviour of assists a person to distinguish
people with in a country. between right and wrong.
• Law can be found in legislation, • Morality is often determined by
Constitution, common law, case law, ect.
personal character such as religion,
• If the law is breached people are culture and up bringing.
punished according the law.
• Morality is not punishable by law.
Discuss how Hugo De Groot influenced
modern South African Law (10):
• He made many important intellectual contributions to legal scholarship, political and theological
philosophy, and even wrote poetry.
• He started his studies at the age of 12 at the University of Leiden and was awarded his first
doctorate in law at age 15.
• The Dutch authorities did not approve of De Groot's theological writings and De Groot was
imprisoned.
• While in prison, De Groot wrote a foundational text of Roman-Dutch jurisprudence: Inleidinge tot
de Hollandsche Regsgeleerdbeid.
• The Inleidinge is considered to be the first authoritative, work on Roman-Dutch law.
• The work was enormously influential on the scholarship of other important Roman-Dutch
scholars including Simon van Leeuwen and Simon van Groenewegen van der Made.
Discuss the concept of a social contract
(10):
• Thomas Hobbes and John Locke first actually formulated it as a formal theory by which people are said to
have abandoned the ‘state of nature’ to form a more organised and just society.
• They assumed that people at first lived in a state where there was no organisation or government.
• The social contract is the hypothesis that human beings, as they came together to live in communities and
society… must reach a common agreement regarding the relationships and responsibilities and rights of
that society’s members.
• It represents an implied contract, agreement or covenant by which individuals are said to have abandoned
their ‘natural state’ and its freedoms to form the more organised society in which they now live.
• The contract should provide room for diverse positions in society; it emerges from a joint decision of rational
individuals.
• The emergence of a social contract amongst individuals who widely differ from one another in terms of
background, religion, culture, customs and habits leads to a well-ordered society, to the well-being of all the
contracting parties and to social justice for all concerned.
Distinguish between ratio decideni and
obiter dicta (8):
Ratio decideni: Obiter dicta:
• This is a Latin terms that means the • This is a Latin term that means ‘which
reason for the decision. is said in the passing’.
• This is the key factual point or • This is a legal opinion provided by a
reasoning used to come to a judge which is put into a written
conclusion in a final judgement. judgement.
• This is often used as a precedent for • This is usually provided by minority
other cases and is legal binding. of the judges and is not legal binding.
Discuss Roman-Dutch Law in the Cape of
Good Hope (5):
• In 1652, the VOC sent Jan van Riebeeck to the Cape to establish a
Dutch settlement.
• Van Riebeeck planted a vegetable garden to serve as a refreshment
station for Dutch ships sailing between Holland and the East. More
Dutch settlers followed.
• The VOC was registered in Holland and it favoured the use of Roman-
Dutch law to administer the territories that they controlled.
• As a result, Roman-Dutch law was adopted at the Cape of Good Hope.
With reference to relevant authority, explain
the interpretation of law in South Africa (8):
• Section 39(1) of the Constitution is the interpretation clause which provides:
• When interpreting and developing common law and customary law in South
Africa the courts, tribunal or forum must:
• (a) must promote the values that underlie an open and democratic society
based on human dignity, equality and freedom;
• (b) must consider international law; and
• (c) may consider foreign law.
Identify and discuss the elements of a
crime (10):
• unlawful voluntary conduct, which is conduct that lies within a person's control
and which the law regards as being unlawful in nature
• causation, which refers to the fact that the accused's conduct caused the unlawful
consequence, or made it happen
• criminal capacity, which is the accused's ability to understand the difference
between right and wrong and his commission of the act with full knowledge of this
difference
• fault, which refers to the fact that the accused must either have intended the
wrongful conduct, or must negligently have allowed the consequence to occur.
Provide and discuss the ways in which
ownership may be acquired in South Africa (4):
• original acquisition, which means that you own your property legally,
even if your predecessor did not legally own the property or agree to
transfer the property, and
• derivative acquisition, which means that you may only own your
property legally if your predecessor owned the property legally.
Identify and Discuss the types of Democracy
recognised by the Constitution (9):
• Representative democracy: Citizens vote for individuals or political
parties to speak and act for them in government decisions.
• Participatory democracy: Citizens help government to make decisions,
not only by voting for their representatives, but also in other ways such as
participation in the legislative process.
• Direct democracy: Citizens take part directly in making public decisions
without elected or appointed officials acting as their representatives.
With reference to Authority, provide the categories
of legal practitioners in South Africa (6):
• The Legal Practice Act 28 of 2014 will retain has retained this
distinction.
• Section 34 of the Act refers to three categories of practitioners:
• attorneys
• advocates, who may only act upon receipt of a brief from an attorney
• advocates, who may accept briefs directly from a member of the public
provided that he or she is in possession of a Fidelity Fund certificate and has
notified the Legal Practice Council thereof.
Discuss the concept of Rule of Law in
terms of the Constitution (5):
• The Constitution has much in common with the rule of law doctrine.
• The values found in section 1 of the Constitution, as well as the various human
rights included in the Bill of Rights (such as the right to equality and human dignity,
as well as access to the courts and a fair trial), all form part of the rule of law
doctrine.
• Also, the Constitution emphasises the importance of the judiciary (the courts) and
its independence from other organs of government, which is fundamental to the
rule of law.
• We can now see that the Constitution gives form to the rule of law doctrine in
several ways.
Explain what is meant by ethical and
professional conduct (6):
• A practitioner's conduct must, at all times, be ethical and professional.
• As such, legal practitioners are required to maintain the highest standard
of honesty and integrity at all times.
• Legal practitioners are bound to comply with a strict code of ethics.
• If a practitioner does not follow these rules, he may be suspended or
struck of the roll.
Discuss what happens when a case is
appealed (8):
• When a litigant is unsuccessful in a matter (loses the case) and feels
dissatisfied with the outcome or feels that the court has erred in its decision or
judgment, the litigant might decide to lodge an appeal against that decision.
• This applies to both civil and criminal matters.
• In the court of appeal, the dissatisfied litigant who lodges the appeal is called
the appellant.
• The party in whose favour the decision in the court a quo (from where') went,
and who is therefore the person against whom the appeal is made, is called
the respondent.
Thank you so much!!!