Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Katharina von Bora, Luther's wife, by Lucas Lutherhaus, Luther's residence in Wittenberg
Cranach the Elder, 1528
Luther and Zwingli
• H. Another unfortunate situation was that Luther did
not agree with Zwingli on some points. Even though they
agreed with each other on many points, they disagreed on
how Christ was present in the elements of Communion.
Luther believed there is a real physical presence of Christ
in the Communion, though the substance of the bread
and wine did not change (consubstantiation), while
Zwingli considered Communion as a memorial of
Christ’s death. The problem was that while Zwingli was
willing to fellowship with the Lutherans, Luther was not
willing to fellowship with the followers of Zwingli.
Marburg Castle
Disagreement at Marburg Colloquy
• There was a disagreement between Luther and Zwingli in
Lord Supper. The meeting was held in October 1529. That
was the only point that they disagreed of 15 concepts.
• Sometime the confrontation was uneasy. Citing Jesus’
words “The flesh profiteth nothing” (John 6.63), Zwingli
said, “This passage breaks your neck.” “Don’t be too
proud,” Luther retorted, “German necks don’t break that
easily. This is Hesse, not Switzerland.” On his table Luther
wrote the words “Hoc est corpus meum” (“This is my
body”) in chalk, to continually indicate his firm stance.
Two Diets at Speier
• I. At the second Diet at Speier in 1529, the
decision of the previous Diet in 1526 was
cancelled (that the ruler should choose the
religion of his state), and declared that the
Roman Catholic was the only true and legal faith.
Six princes, who followed Luther, representing
fourteen free cities, presented a Protestation.
From then on, the followers of Luther have been
called “Protestants” by their opponents.
Diet of Augsburg
• J. At the Diet of Augsburg in 1530,
Melanchthon (with Luther’s approval)
presented the Augsburg Confession, which
later became the official creed of the Lutheran
church. There were 28 articles but the last
seven were showing how the Protestants
differed with Catholic.
Reading of the Augsburg Confession by
Emperor Charles V at the Diet of Augsburg,
1530
Schmalkaldic League
• A. In 1531, the Protestant princes decided to
organize the Schmalkaldic League (the Protestant
League) in order to defend their faith by force of
arms if necessary.
• B. Through Luther’s order of ordination in 1535,
the Lutherans broke the ecclesiastical relationship
with the Roman Catholic.
John Frederick I
of Saxony by
Portrait of Philip I, Lucas Cranach
Landgrave of Hesse the Younger.
Peace of Augsburg
• C. The war between Emperor Charles V and the
German princes (between 1546 and 1552) was
finally ended by the Peace of Augsburg (now
Bavaria, Germany0 in September 25, 1555. There
was some agreement between Roman Catholics
and the German Protestants:
(1) Lutheranism gained legal equality with Roman
Catholic in Germany; (2) Each prince can determine
the religion in his territory; (3) dissenters should be
allowed to emigrate; and (4) if a Catholic leader
becomes Protestant, he must give up his position.
Peace of Augsburg
• D. The national Lutheran churches of
Germany and the Scandinavian countries (as
the territorial churches) were a result of the
processes described above.
Luther on his deathbed by The house where Luther's tombstone in the Castle Church
Lucas Cranach the Elder Luther died in Wittenberg (Beneath the pulpit
The other side of Luther: Bigamy of Philip I
of Hesse
• Like other noblemen, usually marriage happened
because of the political reason. To strengthen his
position he was married by the daughter of
Saxony ruler, Christina. Yet, he fell in love with
Margaret van der Saal. Christina agreed with this
decision but the problem was as a protestant it is
not allowed by the Scripture. Interestingly enough
Luther, Melanchton and Bucer agreed even the
last two theologians were as the witnesses of this
marriage.
The Other Side of Luther: Anti-Judaism
• In 1523 Luther attempted to convert the Jew
by writing his That Jesus Christ was Born a
Jew however this effort was having no
success. As the result he wrote On the Jews
and Their Lies in 1543 because they crucified
and rejected Jesus as Messiah as well as lied
about his resurrection.
• As the result, Hitler utilized his writings to
assault huge number of Jews in WWII.
Luther’s system of beliefs—Sola Fide
• He made strenuous efforts to find a gracious God,
doing penance according to the dictates of scholastic
theology. Ultimately he became frustrated to the
point of despair. Through his understanding of
Rome 1:17, he realized that only faith and not works
that human being would be saved by the merit of
Jesus Christ. Luther considered justification by faith
“the summary of all Christian doctrine” and “the
article by which the church stands or falls.” In the
Smalkald Articles of 1537 he wrote: “Nothing in
this article can be given up or compromised, even if
heaven and earth and things temporal should be
Luther’s system of beliefs—Sola Scriptura
• At the Diet of Worms in 1521, Martin Luther
declared his conscience captive to the Word of God.
For Luther, the church does not take priority over
the Bible; instead, the church is the creation of the
Bible. It is born in the womb of Scripture. Luther
held a high view of the inspiration of the Bible, but
what truly distinguished his exegesis was his ability
to make the text come alive. For him, Bible stories
were not distant historical acts but living current
events. Thus, for Luther, the Bible is no mere
depository of doctrine. In it, a living God confronts
Luther’s system of beliefs—Sola Gratia
• For Luther, salvation was anchored in the eternal mysterious
purpose of God. Luther anticipated the human-centeredness
of later Protestant piety and guarded against it by insisting
that God’s grace comes from outside us. Faith is not a
human possibility, nor a dimension of the religious
personality; it is a radical and free gift of God. Luther saw
the human will enslaved by sin and Satan. We think we are
free, he contended, but we only reinforce our bondage by
indulging in sin. Grace releases us from this enslaving
illusion and leads us into “the glorious liberty of the
children of God.” God wants us to love him freely. But that
is only possible when we have been freed from captivity to
Luther’s system of beliefs—Sola Sacerdos
• Luther believed that every Christian is a priest
and eligible to come to the Lord directly
without any help of human being because
Jesus Christ is our high priest and becomes our
intercessor before the Father.
Luther and his Soul Sleep
• Luther believed the immortality of the soul.
However, he believed a soul sleep which means
that the dead person knows nothing or he does not
aware of anything happens in this earth. The
argument that he suggested is that the Bible says
death as sleep. The one who sleep is not dead, he is
sleeping and not aware of anything but the person
is not dead. Thus, for Luther even though he
believed the soul sleep concept but it means that
the soul is still awake while the person in condition
of death.
Conclusion
• Luther was a brilliant and brave man.
Nevertheless, the tension in political and
theological manner sometimes confused him. In
the case of Philip of Hesse, he attempted to keep
in balance between politic and the truth. The
same thing happened in the understanding of the
state of the dead, while he believed dualistic
concept, and he found that it contradicts with the
biblical view of soul, he preferred to philosophy
to answer this confusion.