LECTURE 11: WHERE A DEFENDANT BLAMES ANOTHER PARTY FOR
HIS WOES
THIRD PARTY NOTICE
THIRD PARTY NOTICE O.1 R.15 Where the defendant claims against another party not already a party to the suit – (a) that he is entitled to contribution or indemnity from him (b) that he is entitled to a relief or remedy relating to or connected to the original suit and therefore the same as some of the relief or remedy claimed by the plaintiff (c) that the question or issue relating to or connected to the subject matter of the suit is essentially the same question or issue arising between the plaintiff and the defendant and should properly be determined as between plaintiff , defendant and third party, or any or either of them Procedure He shall apply to the court, by way of an ex parte chamber summons application supported by an affidavit, within 14 days after the close of pleadings for leave of the court to issue a third party notice A copy of the notice shall be filed and served upon the third party having regard to the rules of service of summons The notice shall be in the form of Form No. 1 Appendix A and shall state the nature and grounds of the claim and shall be filed within 14 days of service This third party can seek the courts leave to issue a third party notice to any other third party that he may deem to be responsible for the initial suit and the same rules shall apply The court shall not grant leave to issue a third party notice against the government unless the court is satisfied that the government has all the information sufficient in the circumstances of the alleged liability which has arisen against it (r.16) A third party who intends to dispute a plaintiff’s claim as against the defendant or his own liability to the defendant will need to enter an appearance in the suit on or before the day specified on the notice (r.17) Non-Appearance by Third Party In default of entering appearance in time he shall be deemed to admit the validity of the decree obtained against the defendant, whether or not by consent, and his own liability to contribute or indemnify to the extent claimed in the third party notice (r.17) The third party who is in default of entering appearance within the period fixed will however have a chance to apply to the court showing good cause and the court may grant leave giving such terms as the court shall think fit (r.17) In the case of third party proceedings against the government, the government shall not be considered to be in default, and there will not be any admittance of validity of decree obtained against the defendant or its liability to contribute or indemnify the defendant to the extent claimed in the third party notice An application by chamber sermons served not less than 7 days before the return day may be made to court seeking an order to declare the government to be in default for not entering appearance Judgment upon default If the third party makes default in entering appearance or delivering any pleadings and the defendant giving notice suffers judgment by default , the defendant shall, after satisfaction of the decree against himself (to be entered on record) be entitled to judgment against the third party to the extent claimed in the third party notice (r.19) The court may upon application by defendant pass such judgment against third party before the defendant has satisfied the decree passed against him (r.19) A defendant shall not be entitled to enter such judgment against the government without the leave of the court (r.20(1)) The leave of the court may be sought by a chamber summons application to be served not less than 7 days before the return day (r20(2)). Where the plaintiff has won the case due to the third party’s default of entering appearance, the court may either at or after trial enter judgment for the defendant giving notice as against a third party (r.21(1)) However execution of such judgment can only be after satisfaction of the decree against him, unless leave of the court is sought (r.21(1). Where the suit is decided in favor of the plaintiff otherwise than through trial, the court may by an ex parte chamber summons application supported by an affidavit order judgment for defendant who has given notice against a third party at any time after satisfaction of the decree obtained against him by the plaintiff (r.21(2)). Appearance of third party r.22 If the third party enters appearance pursuant to the third party notice: (i) The defendant may apply through chamber summons to the court to give directions (ii) The court hearing such application may – (a) if satisfied there is a question as to the liability of the third party to the defendant order question of liability to be tried at or after the trial of the main suit (b) if not satisfied may order judgment to be entered for the defendant giving notice against third party
Melissa Jennings, and Debbie Keller v. University of North Carolina, at Chapel Hill Anson Dorrance, Individually and as Women's Soccer Coach at Unc William Palladino, Individually and as Assistant Women's Soccer Coach at Unc Chris Ducar, Individually and as Assistant Women's Soccer Coach at Unc Bill Prentice, Individually and as Athletic Trainer at Unc Michael K. Hooker, Individually and as Chancellor at Unc Susan Ehringhaus, Individually and as Assistant to the Chancellor at Unc Richard A. Baddour, Individually and as Director of Athletics for Unc Beth Miller, Individually and as Senior Associate Director of Athletics at Unc John Swofford, Individually and as Former Director of Athletics for Unc All, 482 F.3d 686, 4th Cir. (2007)