Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bio Ethics Summer Lessons Fro Students
Bio Ethics Summer Lessons Fro Students
BIOETHICS
Definition of Terms
What is Ethics?
Its primary and major predicaments are those concerning life, health
and death that have resulted from modern biological technology,
particularly the way they have affected human values.
EVOLUTION PHASES OF BIOETHICAL
STUDIES
A. Medical Ethics
Oldest Phase
A formulation of ethical norms for the conduct of health care
professionals in the treatment of patients.
Code of Ethics were written by and for physician as early as the 3rd
century BC.
HIPPOCRATIC OATH
Oldest known formulation of medical ethics.
Named after Hippocrates
He set the stepping stones for the foundations of
medicine, developing medical terms and definitions,
protocols and guidelines for the classification of diseases.
To be kept from harm and injustice (physicians should
not prescribe fatal drugs nor should suggest fatal drugs
to be taken. Father of modern medicine
Conscience
the moral faculty of a man which tell him subjectively what is good
and evil.
Sensitivity with regards to choosing our actions.
The last arbiter of one’s moral decision.
THE SCHOOL OF THOUGHT
A. ETHICAL RELATIVISM
Moral Relativism
Claims that there are no universal or absolute moral
principles.
Standards of right and wrong are always relative to a
particular culture or society.
THE SCHOOL OF THOUGHT
B. RELATIVISM
The most widely held moral view in our culture.
Holds the societies and/or individuals decide what is right
and wrong.
There are no objective moral truths, just behaviors created
by peolple., and they are subject to change.
THE SCHOOL OF THOUGHT
B. SITUATION ETHICS
Consist of 3 approaches to Morality
Proposed by Joseph Fletcher who is an American Protestant
Medical Doctor.
1. Legalistic/Normative
Prescribes certain general moral prescriptions , laws, norms
by which to judge, determine and settle the rightness and
wrongness of human judgement or decision.
Fletcher finds this too restrictive.
2. Antinomian
Frees the Christian from the obligations of the moral law.
There are no absolute precepts or moral principles by which to be
guided in making decision.
Fletcher finds it too liberal and unconventional which may lead to
anarchy and chaos.
3. Situation
Refers to human condition or any state of moral affairs and issues
that demand a moral judgement or action.
The moral norm depend upon a given situation.
Whatever the situation may be, one must always act in the name
of Christian love.
3. Situation Ethics
Fletcher preferred approach.
Situationism is a theory that changed in human behaviour
are factors of the situation rather than the traits a person
possesses.
Behavior is believed to be influences by external, situational
factors rather than internal traits or motivations.
This means external factors play more important role to
determine individual differences.
TAKE NOTE IN MEDICAL CONTEXT
COMBINE LOVE AND JUSTICE IN TREATING ILL PATIENTS.
Argument…..
Materialistic- it claim that the truth is cast value of an idea.
True and valid form of knowledge
according to Pierce
1. Practical- one that we can practice and produces
practical results.
2. Workable- one that we can put to work, it can be
worked out and it works.
3. Beneficial- it benefits people . Useful one that can be
used to attain good results.
THE SCHOOL OF THOUGHT
E.UTILITARIAN
JEREMY BENTHAM and JOHN STUART MILL
English Philosophers
It claims that there is one and only moral principles- the
principle of utility.
States that the rightness or wrongness of actions is
determined by the goodness and badness of their
consequences.
The utility of an action is determined by the extent to which
it promotes happiness rather consequences.
THE SCHOOL OF THOUGHT
E.UTILITARIAN
Promote the Principle of Greatest Happines.
Believes that the purpose of morality is to make life better
by increasing the number of good things. Such, pleasure and
happiness and decreasing number of bad things such pain
and unhappiness.
They reject moral codes or system that consist command or
taboos .
The Principle of Greatest Happiness
AN ACTIONIS GOOD (RIGHT) IN SO FAR AS IT PRODUCES HAPPINESS
FOR THE GREATEST NUMBER OF PEOPLE.
GOOD MOTIVES
• moral goodness belongs to motives
• ACT
• that which is don
ACTION
• the doing of an act; the carrying out or the execution
• The doing of a right act can be the result of a morally bad motive or
the doing of a wrong act can originate from a good motive.
• In considering the rightness of an act as well as the goodness of a
motive, we have to determine the non-moral properties or
circumstances surrounding the act (the what, why, and why it is being
done).
ACTUAL DUTY AND PRIMA FACIE DUTY
• To resolve the question which one should apply when moral rules
come in conflict in particular situations
ACTUAL DUTY
• one’s real duty in a given situation; the action
• one ought to choose from among many other actions
PRIMA FACIE DUTY
• (Latin: “at first view” or so far as it appears); one that directs or
commands what one ought to perform when other relevant factors
are not taken into account.
2 PRINCIPLES TO RESOLVE CASES OF CONFLICTING DUTIES
1. Act in accordance with the stronger, more stringent or more severe
prima facie duty.
2. Act in accordance with the prima facie duty which has a greater
balance of rightness or wrongness compared to other prima facie duties.
ARGUMENT
● Persons differ in their moral perceptions so that Ross’s “more
stringent duty principle”varies from one individual to another.
RAWLS’S ETHICS
• John Rawls's concept of social morality on the ultimate dignity of
human beings.
• He talks about what he calls “the original position” in trying to explain
his concept of justice and further introduces the concept of social
justice wherein we must recognize our duties to ourselves and to
others.
• A noted Harvard philosopher has attempted a brilliant synthesis of
the strengths of utilitarianism and of the deontological views of Kant
and Ross.
RAWLS’S ETHICS
• had built on both Kant’s and Ross’s fundamental notion of the
ultimate dignity of human beings in his concept of social morality
which serves as the basis of social justice.
• He also perceives the need to rank our duties to prioritize them
according to higher and lower categories in order to resolve any
possible conflict.
• He introduced the concept of an order of priority with regard to
equal access to health care (equal opportunity and equal distribution
of socio-medical resources)
RAWLS’S ETHICS
• Rawls’s talks of a hypothetical situation which he calls “the original
position” in trying to elucidate his concept of justice.
● individuals under the veil of ignorance
● self-interested and rational
● choices and decisions are fair
● Justice is fairness
THEORY OF JUSTICE INCLUDES:
1. Every individual is inviolable
• Not even the general welfare of the society can override or supersede it
• The greater good to be shared by all members should not be used to justify the loss of
freedom of others.
• Answer:
ACT DONE IN ACCORD WITH DUTY
VS ACT
DONE FROM A SENSE OF DUTY
• Acting in accord with duty
Person performs his/her function merely out of the desire to do so or
out of fear of being accused of negligence, such action is non-moral;
has no moral significance
• Act done from a sense of duty
A person recognizes the presence of special obligation which is brought
about by the existence of a relationship
TYPES OF DUTY
Perfect
● one which must always be observed irrespective of time, place and
circumstances
Imperfect
● one which must be observed only on some occasions
CATEGORICAL IMPERATIVE
VS
HYPOTHETICAL IMPERATIVE
• Categorical Imperative
• mandates an action without any condition whatsoever and without
regard to the consequences that such an action may yield
• Hypothetical Imperative
• a command with a corresponding condition or limitation
NATURAL LAW ETHICS (OTHER NAMES)
THOMISTIC ETHICS
• after St. Thomas Aquinas, a profound Italian
• philosopher and theologian who gave this doctrine its most influential
formulation and articulation in the 13th century.
• certain moral principles are objective and can be found in the nature
of things through reason and reflection
• believes that the moral law is the dictate of the voice of reason which
is expressed in the moral principle, “The good must be done and evil
avoided”.
• view the voice of reason as the voice of conscience, refers to the
immediate judgment of practical reason applying the general principle
of morality.
• the natural moral law is founded in human nature
(that is man’s being rational and free) which is
regarded as unchangeable ,hence, natural law itself is
unchangeable.
• The natural moral law is universal, seen as the same
for all people at all times and in all places in so far as
every individual is endowed with reason and freedom.
• The ultimate source is divine wisdom and God’s
eternal law. So, natural law is the divine law expressed
in human nature.
3 Determinants of Moral Action
1. The Object
➔ that which the will intends directly and primarily. It may be either a
thing or an
• action.
e.g. The nurse injecting a drug into an ailing patient.
Object – injecting a drug
2. The Circumstances
➔ conditions which when superadded to the nature of the moral act
will affect its morality; will either mitigate or aggravate the goodness or
badness of a particular act
7 Circumstances:
1. Who – has something to do with the special quality, prestige, rank or
excellence of the person involved in the moral act
2. What – refers to the quantity or quality of the moral object
3. Where – denotes the place where the act occurs
4. By what means – refers to the means used in carrying out the act
5. Why – the end or purpose of the action
6. How – indicates the manner in which the action is done
- complete willingness, prerequisite of imputability
7. When – refers to the time element involved in the performance of an
action
3. The End of the Agent
➔ the end or purpose of the doer or agent
• For a given act to be truly morally good, it must be good in all is three
elements.
Key Points in the Medical Context
● Natural law ethical principle
• it is morally wrong to allow babies suffering from serious birth deformities to die;
• hasten the death of a person as direct and primary
• intention and to perform acts that terminate the lives of the incurable either by taking
steps to bring about their death or by failing to take steps to prolong their lives through
ordinary treatment.
• The principle of procreation considers abortion and the use of positive methods of
contraception to be morally wrong.
• From the moment of conception, the conceptus is considered to be a person with all
the rights of a person, hence, abortion at any stage of pregnancy is morally wrong.
Argument
• Everything has a goal or purpose. Nature does nothing in vain.
Bacteria or germs have their reason for being. Once this is rejected,
the natural law theory collapses.
• Concept of conscience – by product of one’s upbringing and
development, so, it differs from one person to another.
SCHOLASTIC ETHICS
• after the brilliant moral teachings of a group of scholars known as
Scholastics or Schoolmen headed by St. Thomas Aquinas in the
University of Paris during the middle ages
GEDER EXPRESSION
Gender expression is what’s visible about your gender to other people.
Gender expression refers to the ways that people present their gender
identity to the world. This may be through clothing, haircuts,
behaviors, and other choices.
SEX ASSIGNED AT BIRTH
The sex (male, female, intersex) assigned to a child at birth, most often
based on the child's external anatomy. Also referred to as birth sex,
natal sex, biological sex, or sex.
SEXUAL ETHICS
• ethics concerned with issues from all aspects of human sexuality
including human sexual behavior
SEXUAL CONSERVATISM
• group of beliefs that emphasize the acceptance and/or affirmation of
social and normative conventions regarding sexuality, respect to
traditions, and the maintenance of society.
• Sex is permissible between a legally married man and woman.
• Sexual behavior must have a morally significant goal, such as
procreation
SEXUAL LIBERISM
• Group of beliefs that emphasize the acceptance and/or affirmation of
individual sexual freedom and respect for one’s sexual autonomy. Any
sexual activity between consenting adults is morally fine.
SEXUALITY: MORAL THEORIES
NATURAL LAW
• moral actions follow the natural course of human nature
• procreation is natural and other acts considered non-procreational are immoral
supports the conventional view
KANTIAN ETHICS
• the basis of his general conception of morality is that actions are wrong when
we treat people disrespectfully as mere objects or instruments. It is traditional
and conservative.
UTILITARIANISM
• any sexual act is moral based on the overall good it creates for everyone.
MORAL ISSUES ON SEXUALITY
HOMOSEXUALITY
• sexual interest in and attraction to members of one's own sex
• some hold the view that homosexuality is related to a mental
disorder
• most religions discourage homosexual activities
• homosexuality in the Philippines is increasingly being tolerated
• 49% view homosexual relations between consenting adults as morally
wrong or unacceptable
PRE-MARITAL SEX
• sexual relations between two people prior to marriage
• sex before marriage is a sin against the body
EXTRAMARITAL SEX
• consensual sexual intercourse by a married person with someone other
than their lawful spouse
CONTRACEPTION
• deliberate use of artificial methods or other techniques to prevent
pregnancy as a consequence of sexual intercourse
• opposes the traditional view of sex as a means of procreation
• sterilization violates the principle of totality and its integrity
ARTIFICIAL REPRODUCTION
• creation of new life by other than the natural means available to an
organism.
1) Artificial Insemination
• assisted method of reproduction in which the sperm is provided
typically by means of masturbation and is injected into the woman’s
reproductive tract through a catheter.
• excludes the marital act from procreation.
• distorts the meaning and purpose of procreation.
ARTIFICIAL REPRODUCTION
2) In-Vitro Fertilization
• a medical procedure whereby an egg fertilized by sperm in a test tube
or elsewhere outside the body
• ethical issues: disposal of spare embryos, and use of embryonic tissue
in medical research
3) Surrogacy
• an arrangement, often supported by a legal agreement, whereby a
woman (the surrogate mother) agrees to bear a child for another
person or persons, who will become the child's parent(s) after birth
ARTIFICIAL REPRODUCTION
4) Abortion
• ending of a pregnancy by removal or expulsion of an embryo or fetus
Types of abortion:
Spontaneous abortion
induced abortion
• motivation
personal
societal
maternal and fetal health
• ethical issues
sanctity of life
autonomy (Independence)
pro-life vs pro-choice
DIGNITY IN DEATH AND DYING
• Dying with Dignity- movement that promotes the ability to meet
death on your own terms.
Types:
1. By Reason of the manner of attaining death
• Active or Direct Euthanasia- the active taking of steps by the physician
or the caregiver to end the life of the patient.
• Passive or Indirect Euthanasia- the intentional omission or non-
administration of medical treatment to cause or hasten the death of the
patient.
2. By reason of patient’s consent
• Voluntary Euthanasia- the patient consciously and directly requests
the health care provider to take the steps to put an end to the patient’s
life.
• Involuntary Euthanasia- the act of seeking the
death of the patient is without the patient’s
consent or knowledge.
➢ Argument favoring Euthanasia:
• compassion for the patient and shortening the period
• of suffering of the patient
➢ Argument disapproving Euthanasia:
• it is intrinsically wrong since it rejects life.
• ORTHOTHANASIA
• A normal or natural manner of death and dying. Sometimes used to
denote the deliberate stopping artificial or heroic means of
maintaining life Passive euthanasia, see there.
ADMINISTRATION OF DRUGS TO THE
DYING
In Medicine, specifically in end-of-life care, palliative sedation (calm) is
the practice of relieving distress in a terminally ill person in the last
hours or days of a dying patient's life.
Palliative sedation is an option of last resort for patients whose
symptoms cannot be controlled by any other means. It's not a form of
euthanasia, as the goal of palliative sedation is to control symptoms,
rather than to shorten the patient's life.