You are on page 1of 145




 :
     

!  2007
*() )( ' &
( +
) (1* ( (&. (!  2 (

(:45
)(  2005 >= =< ; : -.8  5. .6 .3 4 ! .-./ ?1300 5.
.
 <  C  <
8:MN - K =- ; ( 4 IH  F- C   D =C

 0  C )=- .  ( .


-.N 5. TN . .> 5. ./H  .P- -.O

3     U: -.M8 V/  (.) .C
.Y I.C . X8
.W .
 ..C  (  ..  ..  0 ..M :..! 5..M  Z..  ..  M..O 
)  .. ..O . 8
 4M  !8- (.) .C3 .U F:.  . )
N .8 _ .^ . (.U
 ]U .  ..
. `8
)( C
PH V/  (  5? .a
. 
 . N (.! . .! H
 
   -
 b 5 -8- ! H  
   5 8  .  :.c 
 . = . .
 ( )(  =C !:.  I.C .  .  b.a . 
 . (WGEA) ..
 ( a Uf (C3  0 2007 2005
-N  - 
:    (  6 .$ .! " 8  . 
 . :.! .
 a 
0 (C3
)!( 
]
a = K 5 3 
  : (NK8  ZO8
   (   !-8- (
8 !
i  :f  5 4M 0
P _
= UP < ON 
   ( 0   (   _ 
 kN    (.
$ )( - F:    4M 5
  
8 I4
]  -4 0 )( : -O / F-C
4W   N
8
) 5   / F-C . .!  N .  :. ) .-.
F: o:  5 .C   .  -.

.8 
. . 8  .  .
.
N 5CM -8!<
$)!< 0
5. -.8-
4.W   N .Cp
.PH
.)H  . 58:.  ) (.-. F:. ) 0 .;
.
 =0 ( -

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

-N  
  : 6 7!     _ 5 F- ]. .$8
=         5 - 
  )( UP  0 2007 2005
)  (8 K   ?6
PH -:
UN 
  N !N
=        -C : 
 " !  
  0
  5 ! H  
   : ? _ 
   .
 ]WN 5 -=
.  . F:.!  .H o:.  k.M? 5. ( . F:..OM . .
 5 -8  _ -P      
     6 0

!8 7
() )(* 9:
' & (  +

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

< !451
..cp .. 8 F:.. ].. 
4..W  .. . ! H  .. 
 .. .. (.. (..) b c..  ..
 f 
   (       o: 
  ` 
 cM 
   6  58:- =N ) (.
_ . -.i .cf F:.-.) .!< <.
54N F: ;!
  0
  - F: ! - N(  5 ! N 
  :    4

4W =6 
8-   58:  )( - F: :  uf
 / -C
D8. o.8 ) .
  / -C)

8 
4 -C   8
 8 -C / 8  b8 )  4
-C   /   -C  ) /

o8 8 8 -C  /  b


  D  / -C6 8 8    4M 5

  . .8 -.C .c) /  . .$
-C  4 /   -
c  I4 5
]  -40

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

 (:(! .
.>2

(=
?>
1 @A -

45 -

9
-

i -(   (.

10

 _ 8  (.

12


   (.

13

M  4 . -C

13

> 2C D) >E :


 0 6

15

 -  U   (     
C3

15

 - !-8- 
 C3  (

20

 - 
> x _ 8  (  cM 

28

> 2 :  F E () G(21  


 0 6

31

Uf H -8-MN :  ( - 


> f.

32

-!N0 F
-

Uf ?  <!) : )  o.N F .N 4M!-.8-

32

>H 
C3 0
-

....Uf ? ? :.... ...P  ....a  ....8 


0 ....

33

...Uf 
 ... -...8-MN : ... T
 : ...-... 
...

34

  I uMc  a =  .yM

> 2 : HF 


 6

49

O  :
  N  (.

50

  > k . M

57

H  
.
Uf a

67

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

H .P-

78

> 5  F : .

86

H (a
>.

93

 > 5 8
M .

101

  .

108

   z .

118

k)-N  (   U M  O {UP 

125

 I. : 1 G *() )( ' & (  0 +

130

 I.: 2 G'>1 
 (K .6

134

 I. A (: : 3 G )N= DN  N


N 6N

137

  DC   .


 I. : 4 G >1
 )= : 6  A0

145

 I.Q : 5 G.

151

 I. : 6 G<( ( '2 E .

153

 I.Q : 7 G (.S2 .

155

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

?>
1 @A
-8  ( M    ] -( ;
 C  C - c 5. .cf
M  N  3 4  =-_ y  M ) H  - N .M8 .U .Ci .
N OM U  _ ?  H U    F -.N . .U-.O .`8

c  O 0 8 _ 8  ( ( M   )
 )=- p8  :
=
H .
)=-  (.
 W   ( M  N . 3 W

.zN .)  f.a <;. . 
.a
..N (. .C} 8 ) . .

 ? . :  ..

 U  U   z   =N !( )=   cN6-   / f ( .


) Z8
N 54 8 ( 1992 ( )   ( (  : (N
 )  5 3 4  ] 5 M O   8
 b  8
M ;<   3
.P
 W (   kN:  W8  5 /H ;<  0
= b.a - .4M 8
.WN   . 
. 8 .` ]. .  T.  .! " 5.4 8 ( .
 
  pN  )( _ 8.  k.8
> 5. ( .
 . . .! H .4M
 MN ! H  
   P x8cN 
   
  (  (.
 -
! H  
   C  < 
 180 M   <;  / P 
 ( .-.
 .  247  .U  ./ P . .  -.8-6.P o. 
.c ._ 1993 5.
0 2003

WN  cN  (  -8-!N D P 
 M  ( -:

zN > : 5 Cf .bc
/H  ) P- z  ( (.
6z  .
3
 ^
 
/:z.3

z  (P _ 
M.
x 5 `N!-8-
PH :  4  
U    )
MO CN 
MO(
=
/  0

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

-N UWH 8
W  IC
-=) ) (C3 .  ( . . ) <.=N .; . .) (.
cH W ) =8 " 2005 W 
W  K -8-$  . Z3 .4 .U I.H
- ; ( 4 <- I  F- C  H =  < 0 " C $ -N
p8  bcN> 5 ]  5 TN
`M   6z   
3   c /H
=N  <; 4M F: UWH .! " 54 8 o:  . 
 . .=N -. .) (.C3
 . .
H 04M
 >
-8-  8 M  (  5 F:!-8- 54 )  W  > ?  M k 
  M > 54 8 cM   .4 .  .P ( . >! .. . ) .U
 ? .. 5..4 8 :-f.. _-.. k3M .. ../H 
! ..UN.. _-.. k3 ..N ..  ..
 cM  H _ 8 /H  5=
54 8 cM  /H    .H  .
)  >-M k F  (   > <8 k 8-8-W )!  oH 0  ( .
a ]  0   ( ) P  
   ( 5.4 8 .48 ?
. -.M
  ! " C  
   
P  a 5. )
 .O.  5.-. 5.8 I.C .
 5 -8- f )  k8 :
 U )    ? : /H ;<  (.
!-8- )    ? -=) :  > 5 
( .
     ) 4M ? : . cN - .   . > . . =N 
^K.
( (.
 G1 4= V? TK  D :
 F- C

  5    (.
Z=?N
 W 5 >   ( 
 I .
Z/- 
(C3: 54 8 pN 8 ! H  
  
 )  4M :N

  ! 0

..  .. _  . ! " ..  <..N .. !N- ..C  .. 
 .. ..N Z..
..P ..a

 (   5 `N
 5H   0
68> 2C <8 :
a  Z8   (  U 
  5 -c  W I
 
   (  <N Z F:
 0
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

68> 2 <8 : 6 F


)` >
P =8 -  . 
 ..  ( .Z./
Uf H  H ( -: a c  !c/
.......Uf H -.......8-MN : ..............  (.......- ( ....... ....... !-.......8- (.......
8 ! 0
Uf ?  :    F:! 4M!-8- -8-MN
>H   0 Uf ? ? : P  a  8 
. Uf 
 :  () b T
 : - 
   . yM
P (.)  .Oc?  -. : y.
.  . 
.W 5.  .a 
 .cf  ..
 ( .. :..cN <..N .. ) ..  ].. ..) ..cf ..M  0 < .. -..
..  ..4 ..C
a  : N 8
 O 
8
  5  M  cN -  8
W   C 
.T =` 8 . !?M  M8  _ .
!;N 
 F:. .! .  5. .! H  . 
 .  5.4 8 . p.8 .) .C3

   8 M 4M  ( .
.OM  .? .
.P  5. . 
 .. 
 ]. Vc.ON :( .  .4.$ . .

  b 
4( :
)(http:/ www.environmental-auditing.org/intosai/ wgea.nsf/viewAuditsissues1

10

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 45
>= . cN ..  Z.8
N <.8 ( ...  ( .. . _ ..  3 .F
 5 58 3 4  ] 5 M .O . H .a  .8
M
Y 5. . <;..
 3
Y 5 o    ( 4N ! : .:. 5 .`8. .P.H
)  5H N ;<  0 !Cc

8  (   6   -8 < a > C -8  uf8 _i .
8 P-N -8 36i )  bc F !  a 0
-..M8 )=-.. .. -..  ( ..
.) .C
Y . X8 ( .Ci .C8 )=-.
.... -.... ) ( .... ...._H  5.... ..../
M ....  ....N  ....3 4  ( ....=-F:....

 G 1
458 
XC -! Z/ 15589
=  F. Z.../ 784=
(...) b...a ...M
6 1500  : 88

 Cf
$  =8
U
^pN )  .4 <;..


XC ( = SEZ

    (U_ 0 N_ 8-MN -  .cM

-... <...N Z. ./ 388 - -...  ...

 ... ...  ( ... ... ...8 ... I...U

  ........ ......../H  
........a

 ...   I...C ... ...8  4...C ...8

 UP60

!6 0 IM8 -8  ]. .)


.W .M

[
- cP   z )( 25.

 <  ;<   8  ( 0

....CP <....N - ?5.... % 90 5....


....

) 2004 .... .... ) ....  ....  ]....


  
 ..  ..  .. ..) ..
..8)k..

  z )( 29
P 0
....CP ) ..../ ....UY  .... z )=` ..  .. .  z  u .. ..F

...`H  ...
... ...  ...  ( ...F

  z (  2000. 52005 .

 ..a  ..M   
 ..  ..  ....

-._ ) 3. 7 )-.  8.

) ....UP (.... 0 2007 2005 .... ....

......CN _ ......C (...... _......(

 5.... -....8- . ..! H .... -....N .... 


 ....


  0

 ...!c ( ... 5...4 8 ... ...8 -...MN ...? 8

..... 350 -  .....)  .....C < .....

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

11


 _ MUO IC 
 =0 8-

8....UN <N-.... F:....i ....$  F- ....C

; !
....=) <.... -.... 8 ....
 Y  $ } M  M 0

! H  
   
  ( .
k=MN:N
-f...! ?= Z...
...  ...W 5 >...  ( 
 I  0
Z../-.. 
(..C3:.. 5..4 8 pN..8 . .! H 
 ...) ...  ... ... _ ...!N 4
:N
   0 !N
 ... _  - ...CN ... . .! H  ...
   <N .N Z
.P .a
F:...
 ...  ... 5 ...`N ...
... 5...
H   .

K 4
 6 6
=
! -i -( H  _ 8 : U C f  5=
 58
W)  1972 .
)  <!4  ]   < 
H    W=` 8 ) 
Np <H -M  0  .Ci
 - :  8 ` 
Np Uf ( 54 8 :f8 -.N Z.
.W  . :.o.

8UN <N b  cN  -  8 M O= 8 ` T 8 !`    ( 0
 .. cN   ..H .. .. cN..  ( .. ..N .. ..OOP ..cM  ....
 ( -f  -C   ( <N 
! )  .  .) 1992 .H  .8-.8

-
Np: <a>
 cN.  . ( . :. . .;8 .  .M  .
 -C 0)  <N 2002
UP
N ]a   "-   ( "2010
Ui -N   (  C  <   C ( i >( M  0 2010
_-.. 
../
F:..! ..C3 .. cN (.. ..8  .. (..  ..) ( .. .. 
.. U= (..C3
 O 8  {Uf  0

12

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 .. .. cN  ..  ..


..P -..M 8 ..` T ..N.. F  ..? ( ..H (.a
> .. ..N
/H  !-  Oc?  5 y F: oN ZO8  cN    = ! 0
= - <=N kU;  "<= 2005  ) c

  1

 5 6)  Ci ; ( : =<.

(S.:
-

=N <`8-8-
8       $ MN 5

 -8 ....O .... < ....k....8


U
 !6 M  .2050

    . _ 5 <;. . . 0 ( .

5. %29 ../H  ..8


M

  -< ?
.P 1300 5.
.  95 5. .) .:.

H  -.5. .H b.`cf

=

..8:..  {..`..  .. -..f 
..C3

! _ 5 %100 (/H

 ]C  H .!N (. <;. 0. ./N -.

C= 6^ / N*NC '& N:

: =

8 
UP     W.

/ a ( 
-

 <a -:. =


8:.MN <. ./ )  .W  .C

-....=) <....N _.... 5.... %50


H (a
> .  . b.

) IC8 ! i   Z3  -8" U

   .1900

-... ...)
^p...8  <;...4 ...
)...N ... I...

-....=) <...N _....( 5.... % 35

_ . H =  5. -.8 <. y.M . 5.4

...$H ...... :... 3

4N F:H  5 C
).N V/:.z

1985  ....4N ....  . ..

  F ...
...W M ...O  ... U  ...  4...C

 
..  5.. ..C ..Cf
......C ...... %38 ......C

  .c4N  ?  58-8
.   <;. .C =-. 5.

 <.

 N M   .   ..N (.

5... % 20
-...N <...N ...W

 IH  M V / Cc )M( ^?  -f


  
) -.N

 !-..=N .. ..C} ..U -..N ) ].. .. ..M

 %20 C
P .

 < 0 ) ] )  -3( ! 5. ..-

)

4 <N - I  !6 /H (.) . .U

 ].. -..N  <;.. .... k3 .. ..


 ..
 .. -..   ..c" .. ..) ..! k..  ]..

5.. -..8  ..8MN <..NH..a


   .) / M?5.^6
 1950 :.. ..?..) ..
..
)
..  ..3 :.. .. 5..C P

- )(  
0 2000

1700 1850 ..VU.. ]..

 -.. b..a ..4M 8


..WN   .. 
..T

H  .........M <;.........

   ` 8  0 ( . H 


.C3

 0

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

13

 !-fCN .4M <.8


.) !.a5.Oc

 .2
-

H ?  0

-..N 5.. % 20 -10 5.. ..


H (a ) .

( !(c
 6
- N .M  .H  . .U .M8 .
.W  5. .U -.P . : .? .
 .  ..3 :..z 0 .. -.O ..U 
..c  ..O 8 ..8 _
..N.. 5.. ( ..
 MO ] 0 OMN     Ci 5 -8- ]C 5. . H <;. .5 .`N .
8:YH 8
M M 6 M  <Mc  IWf   - 0 3 5 `N;< 
 : N 8

)NH0 8
=N!  0
ZcfN^  c   `c.
 cM  
 . !OP -8-N
 M) 4  5 uf 8 c .
IOfN / M 
`f . U

W:.
_ F _
 
/:z. 3
 M) 4)      M]  U.
_ 8W>  5 8
M  ICH.
=
   3.
k=MN-    5 uf
^K     )
U .

)N_   .
_ -8 < I8
 b 
W ;<     <- M . .  ? . bM.a
   z  . .-. .M :. .=N  . . z ) . _ .   F . 5 .`8. ( .
=
;<  _ y =`  _ -. ./H 5.4 8 .)
^p.8; .  .  .CC:z.3
K ! 0
14

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

-_ - <=N;  "- c -P 5 24 ;  Va=



.8 -. .! 15
)( _  -N :
)N 5 `8  F
W M O  -8 O 8
M-  H 5
=  
_  8- =-   V$
N  P ^ <;N UPH  U  I.Of
- ;<   )  M) 4) 0
 5.. -..8- <;..
..8  .. ! ..U .. ..  ]..  <..8 U 5.. .. 36 .  .. _..
 O 0 8 )
8-.=N <.N 1997 . .= . .O 8
.W  -.f ; .  16 5. . 54
8
N  
0 8 (48 F: -f 54 8 4N  ;  Z 4 MC8_0 !6
_ ?8-!
4  U _ F
W  5 54 cM ! xcfN
aH 
<N ;<   4W)`    ? ) < H P ]=N  U  CN 
<N y_ 2004 cM    z  3  b
^KN  oN 5 b N!   V O
 
   _ C   ? )
! 8MN 6P 5 CC
N 4$  { 
Y -

N  H (a
>  =` F: 8 M ICN U O
a ) 8
N  
0 2005   8 8 > W
 
 : 6
  b ! H  
  ) ]  M  <   -. 5 =8 5. 180 . 
 .<;.
   ( -
 247   U  1993  5 .2003 
 D N;<
  { C  F   z       8
M
Y  5 F:  .a
54 8 
   ( 0  .) . M .Oc? 5. . .  V.aN y.
 
   ( 0
 . <  :
F: i $ ! " 8  
  <C=N O) 3 -=8 0  OcH 5 cP
 ( / P cO -c8=
-  .a  .C -.8 
. Z.8 .  0 ( . .
ZO8  
C3
  UN  ( !-.8- 
. .C3  ( .0 ! .

P I ZO8  _ 8  (  54 8 Z= ! 0


ZO8 Oc?  !  P < ON 
   0
Uf H   ) Ma:  - C Oc
 -8-MN  5a 8   (
 
 C  ) !< 0
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

15


P 5 `8  Oc?  y _    ! b ! H  
  ) ]. . .M  0 < .<.C=8
 F
...W ... ...C K...W  ...a ...  ( ...H? ...$
...
N ... ! ... . .! H  ...

 0M8 .  .cP . <.C . K.W . H =` . . cN6 Z./ - . .T

   M - ! -N <8 _    _ 5  <.

16

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

> 2C D) >E :


 
_ 8 8 _ N U   (    ; 5 
{ =8 .
 ..   .. ..48 ..$  . ..
^K..N ..  5.. 5..4 8 .. ..)
^p. 8; ..  .. ..N
 ( .4
  S 
  6  ' (  Q:
..CN
.8 )=-.. .  ( .._ -..  . 
..H ..C3 -.8- 5..4 8
3 ..Cf ) :
pN ) ! .8 .U  .=
. .H .=N. ) . u3 .Of^ ". . "  .W
    . .N  5. ]3 .$ . _ .  5.4 8 . p.8 
.zN . 
. ) .  .=8
> .<;.
.

8  ( -= a   5 -8- V6 54 8
U c/ -8- 0
>2 e

WN cO ^  
4   x M )( DNA -MN  cO
-8
c 
) 4  0
8  <M  =  "
! ;
 ^ .N
8
 cO ^   cM      3H ] 
z 0
   ) )=-   ( 54 8 p8  =
. .H . . ? . <.8{.=) .
 5.. 5..H  5.. <Y
 .. .. 0 .. Z..f Z../ 120000 5.. ! <.. ..cM  o..N ....H
 =
 .a  .cM  ..H 5.4 8 -.8 8 .= . i -. c
.H ]. ) .   .
H .
' ( a 458 
 *
:
 cf -  4C -.N   ].
.8 . = ..H ?
." .a

..
  ?  x!c 4N =8
)H 
UP" a  IC cf -  cf _ 0 ! N
)  b- y^
8  M 5. c/ 6500M .   -.! .
= . F   I.C .
   ?8-M -=) -     IC   5_6c -. 5.
z./ ./ M -. .
N
5
z/ M  5 -_-    3 0 M ) W 54 8 48  .
.$  I.
 5H:z0 (3

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

17

 C :
H  3    8:z  0
^ 4 o.  .) ! N <8 .3 4  .M-._ -.
 _ 75 1  5H ) .0 < .
.8  . _. . 100 .   .b.


Y)   M8 ! -8- (NK8 :8- I 0 cON
 <a: 1 G(( f  C
((<

 C ( 8

 8
4

4000

 3 4 _ F-f

80000

M

1320000

 8
Uc

72000

 N

270000

6(K

1746000

' ( a 5  C : <Y =


? =
./ 8- .> .  (.
U..WH 8
..W ..
..i :..   -.. -..  ..M    .. -.. x.. b..a=
8-.. :..
 -  8 Za 1000 -  0 U
N UWH-. . 8
.W .C . 50
.P
  5 
_- =
) N X8H 
 : cP / 8-  65 :  0
F:.. 5 ..`N U..WH -..O
3 ..
-..N ..> 5 ..U  ..  ..
..?8=
..
  .. 
.. _ 5..4 8  y..
.. ) ..
-..N ..> 5 .. I..C
..  <..;  ..C3 =
..
H 0
H  8
z 54 8 P-
^KN
^pN 
-  M  N  U ICN=

)
^pN;    0 5.4 8 .MN  .4
N I..H ) .; .  .O .
 H   0 /H ? ) H -.!N 8
z 5. %80 ./H  !-. ).=U .
) )  )
0 =8

18

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

  <=8  .MN -.  .cM  . .U  .  . _ .U.H  !-. . 3 
.W8
 H  !- -  CH  !- ) =  3
M  W  ) V`8 2006 4W< 2
0?
 160000 5  5M  N 
!.-8-
 <a :2G (:5(. .17 4 >. )    S (4 ' 5 2006
Q
<
:
) jQc(*()(

 C (8X
) 4 (

 C (4

 C (4

)  4 (

) 
( Q

>!5

58 808

5624

10

? 8-

5416

1093

20

U

9934

1206

12

 _Z

8240

341


 3

5918

1811

31

H

29300

1173

1190200

2101

0.18

587! " a.


!E m

287655


1

8390


N C  8 !-  5H 
8-? C  cN  I.C .  5. -.8  .
! ?
 5  
PH )( ] 54 8 4N  C  =c 8 8  !- ?
.  cN
Z..ON ..= .. 3
.. M ..H  

> ..f  ..aH?
..=6 ..a
N
..    ....^6^ ..
c..ON )!-..-..! ..
_ ..=8
U F
= .. F
..=6 ..a
 " ..N .. ..) 8..C
M  N 
 8 C -(  586-. . <.`N  5. 5.86.  .N
M .
  )!(
N  5M  M .N  .-.  5. F
.  .  =.W
! 5 .`N:.z . H   =. .Wf .WPH !-. 8H. .8 <.8 .8 -.
 x M  N -  
) F  _ F: .

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

19

  I
PH ? )=-  > ) 5 F: CN -  3 4 p.N  .=
.
H.
(^-:D

W8 > 5  4 _ F 3 4 48  > IC_ 5 . ZO .a  .: F . F .
 .M
:3 <a(^ DC=
D !+ Q<j

) ? N  F_ : VU 5 %1H  ) !? N <8: 


<  (.
 -:NNo. ..  58 ..N ..  ..> 5H . a -..O I..C_ 58 ..N ..   .. ) .. .. ? ..
x ZO8 _? 3 W_ 5   ) C!  Y
P   !cO8!  W(.
(^ DC= -: D(p 1
[ -:
)  _ C
8-=N <N 2000  z  3.866.1 .4._ - ^ y. . F
.4H.a
 Y !%95 >  Y %5   .-=8 ! ZO 5 `N (   (   .
  z  U( N H)  U OM )  ] 5 ( _ C;< 0
:q:a.
UzN 5. %40 3 WM .H ) . b. <.N
.a M . .! -.8- .W8 o.

) 
48  W  ) 
48  ) D 
$ )  ) C )
0 =8
.2:
Z8
N <8
MO   48 )! 
f
 5 . .)
.U ? . 
M.O

4 ) )
=8
M/  ) ! (-
N  5 c  -8-W  > . ). .
 5 M H  !4 8  MN
M -8-W
 c  !46.P 5. Z4   .
>.
(
^ I:S5
  > k= U ?
 >
 5.F

20

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 - 8  5  > k= :U oN I  > k= ) U _ - N oN = I.U .W
 - N  . z   .   . .! . P -. N  k> .=._ .U 
.4N x. . ).
 {M )?   (D  > k= . .) .U . -. ) I.H . cN  5. .
  -  cN  W=0
^ D( T ? :
 5 `N      ) 
M  : !H H (a
> _ UzN
VU 5 {=) % 1H 0 <Y  <CN o  -8-W MN -. .  5.
..H 0. Y
.W8
W 
= .  5.  F . .: -. 8  . .   F .. .:   .  .C :.z
  0
(^ D: !.
 M  UM    5 VU 5 % 70 UzN
.4 H 0 .a) x. . .H5

 7000 !=  8 <Y {  =! _
 4000 0
] {N
N M )   F  !` ( M6P 5 x  H
^KN - 0
 M  () N
M ? ) !   VUH I.O8 H= . ) .  I.C F . D .W.
 ON  k?

 100 5 ( 
z/ C  5 <M  0  > 5 .8
M_ .C
 5 5  > kH?
.  .) . < . _ .C 5 .`N . . ) .a ? . 6. 
 ( .
  > k  W>   > k  _c UM 0
- 8?
6 5 1  
$ 5>  M  C  <.
' ( ra  ( e: 6
) ]  M  < ]UCNM  N (  MN !4 8 U.WH 8
.W .M .MN
H N (. .=
. 5.4 
.z ) .-f. H
-.N I.CN (.a 5>. .Uk.P

; ) ^ NHp8  - F  cf . ) .. M .  .N .:.  ^.
:  C8 D .  `8 . .3 . 6./  .    .p.N .  . .P .
.P

Gs:+
;    ; 5  5 6  
 U6 c    5. .N M .
) o:
W!<  (8; (  !c 5 ?
5  $ > 5 {C 5 `8;
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

21

  > 5 3 4 !N6 cN


Y  5  5 `N:z   U  - F _ !N
 cf
-N; (  
^KN
  ( : - .  .=8
> .)
^p.8 F<;.
 .   = F-  - N ; ( .      cM  .; . (.
   ? _
8 =-    Y ) (C3 8 )! p8 ) C3 .W .>5
-8-  ]U k8
> 5 $H kP
0
' (  [ 8 t:o-:+
)=-   ( 54 8 ()
^p8 Z3; .  6 . (.; .  (.?.a

.
 -O = 8  6?
ca - N  F -8 Ci   5  M8
a0 8
 `N -  3 4 48 
^KN o:  Z3; ( )   ? : cf  3: )
 8  -M  .cN -.  .z  k> . .) .
N . . M ..=8 -. -.Mk3
 8 -  3:  M ) o  F (  5H.
H  C 5  
N P- ()
^pN;<  ..48 o. k.8
> 5. . Y
  ) Cc  H _ / >  H 5 U   . U]  5.
.8  o!.C

^KN -8-MN< .( i


_  N -=- -8 
> f
 UN P H M M  P- - ]
8 o  :
 C  () -8-W- 
W UWH
z .
8 
_   _ C  cN  W H .P-
   4!4 
 Q: 6

 cN  ( -8-!N C P  C3  (:

zN >: 5-=c  .3
 Y) 8
Y P  (.
6z  .
3
  8  ) >
c
/:z.3

zN  _ 
M.
-...8-!N -... N
...P 5 ...`N ... 4  ... I ...  . .
M...O=
.../
   
z
W )! F:!-8-  ! - ) !OfN <N < . 4
NUWH
 8
W IC
-.=) .) C3 .  . . .3 N 5>.:. .!) I.CN
.`M .

22

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

6z 
3  =
 xH =N  oN <;  _ 4M U.WH:.4 ]U.CN
! H  
  IN  ) 
 H 04M
4  :4 G 4!4 
 Q:  6& :*:
4!41 
 6
)=-  > 5 3


u:

&C: Sa C!a


 )
z-f 8MNH IC

 cf ) N ]8_ <..

* .

^ ".

*.
`M
*
^  N)
W   z(.
*  ) 8-N !H  IM. 5. F .
!H.
* 
-N  IC
M=

) 
Y IMC8 oW -/ (
M
 8
Y P
) Y  (

 W 
Y) P(/

) b..W  -..


.. 5.. (. a6.......P U..WH )
.......   ).......C
(8
W

6z 
3
) / P
)i ) -/
H(

-8-!N=
 5. ./
 cU!.5

*>  I... -...8_ ...O  ... 


... -.......N ...  -8 .......O .......
 8C -.

PH

* -C
Y ;< .
* 
W
Y ) ]U $H-./
H 
(-O

....  ....8  ....) ....>


c
O  5 uf  . O

* ^ ......
...... : )F ......


/:z3

 3 4  .3
* 8  .) .>
c
./
 :8:z
...  I... MU ...N ?...c
p...N  ... c... H5...C
  "
Y
 5 3 4  ) N= .


zN  _ 
M
..zN ) ... N .. 
..W..  ...M *N ..)
.zN ].8..H _<..

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

23

>
!6

 4C bN -

!
...... ......8 )......WcN ......
 U
H.
* ....6 x....N5.... ....C3
 I..W
 I..C .. ..cN
 _
  .C . F
.VUC

N
W
Y F "

....N x.... ....) F....H .... H -8-!N V ....O?


 5H .
 O.8

   4N

3  -^ ^ :() ?  C4

^ .... .... M ....C4

*>6 
a

 3 4   .-^ .

* N
 F-M

 H 
.8

^ .... .... M ....C4


  ( <N

>6..  ..3 4   ..-^ ..


) ... ... ...) ... ? ...
 . ... ^ ]..... ..........H
.(/H
    3

  ...
....U 8
....W  ....   ....3 x -8-!N  4H.

N(   (.


MO

....)i ) ....  .... .... ....$ .... cf =-  . <..

_H
zN  .


  /

 .

! .. -f..CN ..  ..  ..> ..)=  5 ) M   ;) M


 - .x8N V

-f.....  -.....C  .....


  .

458 (^ D  *:


 =8
UH?
)   cM    (  ] ) ? N -    C> .5 >=
- .) )=-.  .> .? N 5! -.8-
5. % 85 .C .C3.  .3 4  :. ) .= . 3

M  MN6 -  cM   U   .U

24

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 


!;N-  -.! N )
`MH  ].U k.8
> 5. .$H . H (
8.U  . . z
]    CN <! T )=-  .> .5  <;. . .8
M  <.N _ .C) .C
zN .

zN IC ) .-f. 
-.N .> ) 5
8.U _ .C  . -./ .H .

_H    58- 


NM  N  .(3
 
WN 3 y_ 5 ) <C=N > .  .W >
.  U.W
.P  _ .C (8
.W

 5 > 5  ]U
z/ (a .   N 5 3  IOH    . .cM
 - 
)  5 3 4  a  H 
N = -  !3 M ! . 5 =N `8
 3 4  = )  >0 5
;<  )   F 54 8  i   4W
zN IC
-N-C  f <.; IC
P   F 
O  MO= ;<  () <4M  `c.
6>6   _  
 )  o a ;
 F N -3 C  ( ) .= . U
 O 8  {Uf ) (3 i Oc? 0y
 : !m E
 - W H  8
z  ? )  N M 3 _
z/ 
.W <N ).
 P  ]8  ) ) ! U .a ) . -.O= (
.a M -. 6.P 5. -.O U.W
 ] bC) 8
WH  a 8
z  <N - P -  !
?4  Hc -.3 . !-.=N . .
 _  5
P x ICN -H :() P-

W
H  N M /H )
! 0

zN > 5 `
Y 5>  8  M " 0 /H
N - > C M  -
 5H /H <!> MN N :Y. !3
 -. T.
.f .H 
.N .P-
3 .Cf I.  ..^
..  ( .p.8 -. ..
=
H  0 M
. 3  5 `N .MN  .cM  ..H < . . 100  5..H  .P-Purple loose .8
z
strife .. ..
z  ..  ..W ..a ..  8  >
..C
..`PH ..Y ..$ 3 ..
 o ...W  ..  4 ..
.N ..H  > ..C   .. 
.c :.. ) .=
.. ] ..C

W! bH  ) P-=
_ 5 % 40M .  .) I.C
. o. 0

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

25


3 Cf 8C  !) bCN
WM  ) P- 8  -M   4 -M 
.
 )
=8 ! - 
-N 8  100  
0 (48
  H?
W $   3 4 4N 6P 5  ?=  5 TN 5cC:. .=8
 3000 8 5 8
=NM  N 0 V
8
M -.8-!  .? {Uf; . .
M..

..4 ) ..-..  ..8  -..M k..8
> 5.. .48
H6!..  k..
..N ..
:z 
5
?4 C3 H 0
6>6   _  
 )  o a ;
H  ) P- Oc? 0 y
&
 ( :  S
] N-N -8  4  < : / ?
. . 5. )
. _  . . _  .-.8 :.z
 4 } 0 $ I H= OM 8-  . -. . Y .c?4 . 4 !8-.N <.N .U
  
   ] 6z   
3  U
N  z -O x. P-. C3-.
 54 ) IC8 - o=
 ?
< <80 - M  !N
 
5. <Y  K. 
.N .8
M -.O H 
. 4. 5.
.?4 5N .C_ ./ P

=c !< 548 < p  4C   
.) C3-.  .  -8 .O .H .  <.; )
  -O C    4N  5 
).N .U " .Y <.8 .) !6z. . 6.H
 -../ <..8 -. .H 
..4 -..  <..8 T8=` .  ....H
z./H -.. x..) 0 ..8-
 .  .? ) -O
c  . -.O ( ." -.8-!N .? N  0 .8
M 5 .`N!-.8- 
.W
Y 4$    ) -O ? o$- 5c  Z_6C .( 
N ) 3
 ) ai  ) o 6z    
z  ]U=N ) U $H  -O  
z
!  > k ]UC8 ( -OI ) a  -8- !N ( 0
6>6   _  
 )  o a ;.
.> 5  F . .: . .
  z )  Oc? . y
  ! (>^ 8
 X[?: :

^pN ^ .  M./ ..  .3 4  . .
.$  4.W ? .  Dc.N -. 
.Y 4.W
 N -
$ ^  ) .
N ]   F N ! -
=CN  Y  5. -.O (./H
!
N-M 
z)  ^  ) 0  C  -  3 4
$ 
^pN  :z.
 - H ? 
 5  b8
4 cCc  5 -8 N  i  ) .) P-; . .
 U ICN 8  ) >
c
/ 0 8:z
26

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 


)i ) 
/  
^p8 8:z 
/:z <; 3 .!c3 4.W
  kUH  H ) 0 !8MN  MN   8.C  5. .
.  .? 5.a
 IW 0-8-! a

N -
..? 8
8) ) 5..$ 4 c.. H 5.. 5..C I..C .. ..N  ..c?4 ( ..>
c ..N 
../
:z 3   -8-!N   F .: ; <. ..`cf8 y._ .8
M  .= 5. ? 5.
. .3 4
 -  3 M 0 -!8  ) : 48  5
8) 4 
CN  ) ( {c  F .
H  M./
UP 4W.H
-.8.  I.) 0 ( . ! o.N .!-.8- 6.P 5.
 - .
6>6   _  
 )  o a ;
 .> 5 .8
M  .) ..Oc
? 0 y
[1(
 ' c . :
MN ]
^ 4NM  N   ) !N  > kH? ]. . KN
.  .
^K.N (.!)
K )
zN  0

.._ . H -..  ]..cN
N  5.. .. 000 :..
..P b. .. 10 -..
..8
=N V..a
=< 
] )  ( 2007 O   5 4M 
z   : (NK8
bcN  _
 VUH  =- 74 0  -  8 =
 0 a
 b C  cN 
M _ .

zN  x N Z?4N f.
cN C  F )
M <  =-
 17 6P =
.58
W
!
-
zN     
^KN  ( _p8 y  =
.H

-N > 0 5 x =NH   > k?
 ] ! cN  M8 y_  36 -8-
54 
P 0  N
^-N -
 5. T..8 -._ .. 
.M ..cN )..C .  .M :.. -..!8 -.  .> 5 !-.. ..$H
 3  IW
 .H (.a
> . 0 _ .C
.!;N 3-.  . - . .?8-M
  ]`N 8N
.zN  . . p.8  .-.  ./H ]8
.C  .
.zNF .N

.8 ..N  ..UM  8..C PH .. 
..M ..  ..
^p. N ..
 ..UM
_H 
U 8
M < -8-MN <8 )  0
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

27

 * m(a)  :
8
P -8-!N - 8    ( ) ? 8 
z
W H  5M  N.

8-ON <8 !<  F-  :
 x N M
8-ON <8 -f!  H
YH 0 U
 N _
P
8-ON <8 ] N  H ! ) ? :H.( -

8-ON <8 H
N  3 4   ) _ 8
M! .

8-ON <8U M    ) c ?  z ( 0
oN
8-ON
8H x )  
Y M  x.
8-.ON.H o.N . Y -.
-=8! cWN
H =N  . . ) MO ? . x. -.=8  . 
. 5.4 8 b.N
f
-f ) M/ 5CMN Ci ( 48  3 0  
Y
) c?
 5- 54 8 pN N H  <  O 0 ]  ) o x
8-ONH
-!8 - = 0 !3
6 F:=`  b. 5. -.8--. . cN . .) . ( .CN 1975 . cN . -.) .
  N M 
8 
 
Uf a ! oN 0
 5 -8  _ F:  cN 6>6   _  
 ) . o. .a ;
.
H  
)
Uf a Oc? 0 y
 <
  :
=- )(   4  N } C =  cO ^ . 5.  . 0
.P 8-.N
 cO ^ 
)N  - C8 -?
 5:z N  H -8-.  0  4.C  ]. .N  o. F:.
-8-
N  4  C ?
 5 !  ^    M./   M .Ci ) ?:.
_  C .U (  .
> .f :.? ) .. 0 ( ( . ./ P .3 4   .-^ ..
O kUN) )   U(  
^pN -  (  k8
> 5) -) ]. (k..H
/H  C cf  )  M ^  ) 0 ?  b cO ^  .-
 <!..?N
..) 5.. k....H o..N ]U..CN . /H..H  c..O ^ ..  ..-.. D) ..
  ] H /H   `=N - ^ 0 U

28

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

& j) . (: :



..)i ) (.. .. p..8 -.. (..$ -..N .. ; .. 
 V..ON .._ ..H  _ ..

U..`N _ ..   F .. F .. o:.. ..UH  b..)


(..
-.. I..C .. 
..`f ..c) 0
..

MO 8
)i ) 

^p8    `8 . U
       .) -8-.$
.zN .
 . .) ]. ) .U :. .
 C  $    > k!  W  > > 5  ?   z H (a
> 0
) x c- ICN -    z ;< 
)( cN C   F:. p.8 -. 
.N .<
6H   VUC: 4W V/  C3  4C  5M F:;
]UCN pN
  ()
MO
P0
H
= -..  .. ..
N ..) ]8
..CM ..  ..N  ..3
3 ..CP ..?
.. ) ..; ..  ..0_ ..C
)   =)-  -P 5 oN 
NM  N  ]UCN 3 4N  ? . . <f.a 5.4 8
-CcN > 5 H  UM 54 8 () ICN  4=
H  .cU  .= .U

- 8
  .
 .2 a .2 :

W8
MO -N H )   > k ) .  .) .W .c   k> . .W>.
 IC ?
zN   UWH 8
W >=   cN <H -M  M) 4_.
M.O
 3600 4 5 % 70H (a ) )  ]. ) < . .  M.O -8-.$  .c ( -.
- ba
N -= 0 b !. U.WH .) 8
.W6.P 5.
M.O  . . z
.)i ) . .

M 
 / P  M  IWf ]8
C_

>H 
M/ W08
 
X5 :
=
../  ..6z.. 
..z ..  .. - ..  ....a ..
8-.. -..8-
  0   C    " .8 - .C  5. . ^
8-.=N <.N . . 75000 5. .
 
(48  150000  
/
= ) 8 (48  z.CN . 
) . Y . 
).
= 4C 8- 5/H ;  5  M
z   40 8
4c
  IH?
/
= -  ) ? 8/    ^ N ]8 -3 0 =.W
)  W     C ) 8 -3  ^ ]UCN ]WN cM -f  -C 
 ( 0_  4.$ 58.4N <.N < .  5. -.M .-f.
.Y .  uP
. ^.) .
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

29

  IU- -= 0 =


_  {.a=
./  .; k.8
> 5. .  . .P> .
   cN  (  5 `8;  ` _.O M./  
) .=. .8-
  IO  5 0 8
 
) =  ? N 8-  
 5-      H  ._ .M < .
 - 8  
8-=N oN  = -8 
)
N  !)   )=H {. o.-. 8 58:. ! .
) _ <!N    ? N  O `8    5
?4) 0 ?8-M  .  .M . -f.C
] ? -     -   N 5 <N 
) = 0 .8- o.N ]U.CN 
).
!i  4W
)    -C <; )    H  Dc ) ]=N M  > k .YH
  5  N ^ )  < -= 0-f ` o.N   . . .=8
U ( .
  8-C 0 5C
6>6  
  _  _ :  a ]   ^ )(  Oc? 0 y
   yS  !(. >. ) 
  6
? N UWH 8
W H 

3 Cf C3  ( .) o:. 0 _ . .) 5. 48 4.W
>
=8    8
W   _ IN y 4M 
=) 0 !) 8  -f  C
  ) ] Uf <!) : 2   .4M
.>H  .a   . ./ .) 22 .Oc?(  .
;<  UW Ci ? 
`M
f     . . .8 _ . - .CN .
!N ( 0
 >
-.8-  .8 M.  ( ._-. F:.
.U  .W  .? . M k> .-.Mk3
    M ) - F:
)N - M  =8
U  > k H K  M  3 4 ; !
 0  C8 ;) M   o P ] "  cM   <;. .  .> 5 .U  .W
_  3 4 =   M )   > k U 0 "<!  3
>
8 M  ^ =8  ( ) ? N-f >
=8 .P .;) M  -. . _ .) ].
N  4)
 ;) M P ] .
N .P ;) M   ]. " (. .4 . .;) M .
 ( P >!< -_ ? " U k3M M  MH  = ! -Mk3
 N    cM   oN
)N -=) 0
. i .a -.a=
. . 0  .
 TM  N ) 48  U  M  3 M .  . -.N <.  . .M ) .! ; .
 0 U

30

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

>
..=8
..P  ..cM  ....H 
c ..8 ..  

..Uf ..a (.." (..) !..a k> ..
 "P C   >48 k )! 
 o.N .  . ..H 0 o.N
.N= . K. .Y P .C
 .. !-.. F .. N >..C -..8-!N .. ..CP  >! o..N ..?0 .. -..8-MN I..8 k> ..
_ 5 !8 UWH ?  
z
M k3    -O ! _
 a0
z
    ;) MH I.8
N . . .> 5 . CM -.8
c    .
.N -. .
_0  M k>  :
I8 fN 
 ]  W H  P-6P 5 8
z  N 0 8  I8- 

> <=N  <!. I.8 .


 .`8  . .!" <.!N  . z  -8 .O   .
  I.8 0 . :..PKN .4M ) .. . ..  -. ( . ..fN 
. .
^p..N-f..
H (a ?   0 U
-fCN  .4M  Z.f  . C  <-. .
.  .8 M o.N <.H . . cN
 -  i  ]8
W 
 T    N <.8! 4.W .? .) 6.OcN
.5.Oc
?  ? . y
 >
=8
.P  .8 M.  ( .  .) .? N . .;) M .8  . . =` 8 .
  ( ; 
8?= Z <  _ -
W >=   cN6 - 0

8 yM 
   ) _ 8.  ( .  . _ .8  .  
) .  . <.!c
 (   !-8-  N ! 0 <=N ]a  ( )  cO ^ H
 <;..
..8 ( ..-..M 
..N I..) ..C3)
 5.. -..8  ..  ..W  I.. 4)=-.. ../
 / M  )
zH   !-
.Y !-.  5. . .cM  ..  0 ( .
_   > 5 ;<  !-8- N I8! ) - H 
  6 (C3   
_ !
?N _i  ) T3  -8-0 -z
- < uf8 5
i  54 8 :fN - >=  ! ;
 H   . cN.
 (.
 <a5 G
^ SK :QE
 :
-1) >  (4 Q  ) 5CMN :-f H (a   F .  .  .8:z  45. .8
   
NM  N  . 3
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

31

zSA1 -2(
I^N .8 _ : N S  k> . . .z  ( . -.=N . -.P   .; .
 0-f H (a <N  .` !_6.O= _ 5. .! . . .) ].  . .
N
M  N  0 3
-3'&7 NN (4 NNQ : 5.. -..M6!.. 
..c  .. U ..WPH :..z ../ P..M .. 5..
=  U . ]    z
-4'& [7 *N( : ! :N  Z. .   . -./ .H  .>
c
-. ..) ].
 > k  M  8
M -/ ZH  3 4  
.
Uf a
8 _ :c  Gs -5_ oN;<   .
).N . . 
.=c  .C Z4 .
]
zN  / ]
)N -P = ; (.

32

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

> 2 F
 E () G(21  
 6

z  5:  Oc $ ! H  
  .
.  -. 5= .  .P < .ON
  
   ( ( ! " 8-MN ? N  
  . . . ? 5.
.
.U .
Z..ON ..U ) 5.. c..O ^ .. ....H  .. <;.. (..!-..8- ) ..CP 5..  5>....
  . (
.`M  .  .4M ) 5.
Np. - . .-.M k3  . . =N .
.^H
(( 4 -8-MN   M) -./  
N 8
:  Oc F- C  ]a ! H  
  
 .) 5_ . . 4  .!3 5 .`8H].
UP  H   <N M  <!c/?
) 6OcN- < :6
*Uf < -8-MN :1  ( - !-8-  N !0
*Uf < :2    o 4M!-8-
>H  0
*Uf < :3 P  a 
 0 !8
*Uf <: 4 fN 
_ >

 :- 
 N . uMc
o..N..Uf .._
=
..N )= {.. !8-..N 5..4 8) Z.. k.._ .. ! .. ..

  54 8-f oNUf  -8-MH-  U  
 .
c. .8 ( .
 8> UP ]a    H 
> f   C :cN  H 
  .5. <Y
.
oNUf UP > ) ]  .6 - N .-0 .! .P .Uf H5.4 8 .
 !  -  
 H ) P  6 a 
 ) 
P .a 5.4 8

] 
   Oc? OM y    _  a 0
 MN ! H  
   .`8cN . ./ P .  :.c  . 
 .. .? ( .
]   
 
 ]UCN    (  8 .` .
 .  .
.
 ) ai  = U 
 H   x8cN! 0  
 H.OM  . .
.._ ) ..a x8..cN! .. .. 
 ..H
 .. .. ]..
 ..  ..  ..  ....
5 WEGA=-  N ) 
  . ] .`8  k.M. . 3 = 1<.  .  .

    ! " C  
 .

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

33

 ` 8  ( = F- b.  .! !) I.O8? 5.


. .! H 5. . 
 .

P  . 8 .` <.!)  !N- C  x. V.a= . ..OM  . . ) .a ].

     yM   =-  N ) 
  ) uPH  (2007 H 
.4
 H W _ -f
P0
 <a: 6 GSE V && ' E = 
( u 
 
SA C 4!4.1 :
 4 6 ( ^A 41 6 T
)=-  > 5 3

I H   


N I

 8
Y P


MO

 / 8  >
c

  4 


zN  _ 
M

=
/ 

6z 
3  U
SA  : F & *  f  <. 4!4 ^C (

D



 ...........4M >...........

 W  > M k

 .....;) M  .....4M

t
]N  cN 
]8
WN 5

 ) M 8-(
]a .UP :.cN_ .
"  

Uf a

4M


 ....5.... uf....
H P-

!......4_
......Y F . ....
 Cp  - .MN

-f.. {..UfN ]..a


H

 ...... 
......W

  ]a

 ]aT
-f........................ H
 O 8M)

 OOf  M

]WN W U

   -

 
^" <=N(
8 N MH

8UN< 

34

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

SA  : FF =) (  C!



(N>   (

 > M k

   z

 

Uf a

 F N -3 C  ( ) =  U

 P

  ^

 O 8 {Uf(3 i

> 5  F :


zN
^KN     

H (a
>


MO   

 > 5 8
M
SA    : ^! 5(    u
1
i   - ; 

 C   M kC=-.

    cN = 5  C

 yM  


k N  C

< 

= D8H  3

- =N6 
8  .

SA C 4!4.1 .


 4 6  4!4  1 6 :

C8  OcH 5   cP  ( ZO8       _.


 <  x!-8-     .   . {N
.N .  ._ -.8
) . 8 .` . _I.C
- _
?N : )
_ -8   ( . 5
.>
8.UN . 
 .M  8 .` ..
 .. I..8 ( .. .! H  .. 
 ..   ..) Z.. <!..!-..8- 
.. ..C3..
 ( .

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

35

~Q   :Q: (  84


 I8
 5 () (8  :P :
)S5 Sa C' 2!  N) 4N( 1 N(N  . . :N ? . .
=8  O   -8 O   z   ) c -/  /  fa

8 cM  ]  3 4  5 3 .H 
.a
. I.8) .M8 4.W .!N
  4N; (
)i ) 0 )    5.4 8 -.O .48 -.
-. 6 . .
 (.
^  &Qc C (s
 > A  8 +4   : ?
.N .-._ .
 -;<   8
M F    kN : 
8  <! cN ;<  I.W

 H (a
> $H  3 
N?
$ W MN   Y
 0  8 M ;  4W8 
z/ - 54 8 a F  08
(Q(    4514E 
Ns 4 N+ N N' N2  N5 N2 N:
   ? 
NH (a
> $H  3   5 8 M `c
^  = V C 84 .  : ? .
.N . .
.H > .
UP
&~  : Q:  4!4  f  Q:( )
1
   =   5
N H  !-8- )  ! (  =   . ? o.N .<.N (.
) !c/  f  !-8- 
) C3 OcH 0  I8
] )!< !-.8-
  ..  .. ) ..- .. 
> ..f o..N!-..8-  Z..N -.. (....U  ..O 
..P
     0
   D !  
 H =8 =< !-8- 
C3  0 4M-8-M
!-8-  ]UC8 M! . 
 .H .  5. y.M .P! .  .4M-.!8 .
!
 .. ..
..$i  ....  ..) ( ..- .. ..O -.. N
..P   .. 5 ..`N
   ;  4_
z -    D M  4M = 5 6i 0

36

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

-8-!N -8-MN -   ( I8 :8



 5 . )
.$ 
.Y ]. -.)]
 
..$ ? .. .. 4..C 3 ..O_i  ..O 8    ..  .. C ?= ) ..  ..8-
    4
zN ICN )   ( 0
)  x .M .8  )
-.  .4M -.8-! <.36 <.=N N . ..  0 ( .
  .M8 - o: 
.  . .W  ; .  .4_
.z   . ; .
  5 <=N   b o =N - ! H  
   WC 5 !N- C  58  
 ]UCN  <!c4N <8 ! H  
  <8-.=N .W  0 .4M ].=. . Y <!K.) o.
- > C 
8
=N  - <=N < 4M!-8- 
8 !   (  I.o

P MN ! H  
   )!< .H o.N!-.8- ) -. ].  0 ( 4 <.

z ) -f H (a 
.`M   .   .? 5.
. .
.PH ]U.CN
) ].. ^ .. !-..8-  ..) !..W  <..N .. .  ..f  !-..8- 
5.. ..C3 ..OcH 0
 ) ai - I8 o cY      O ? 8 _ C  -8 )   > kP C
..  ..) ( .. o..N ..c) 0 < ..  k> ..N P ..C .. ..4M -..MN 5..CMN ..W
 O - 
  4N   0 U  _ C .48 . .M  ! {Uf ! .
^   ]U=N ? cf $   z /H    . .M . <8-.=N.H
 P- = u  F -N    .F
 _ ) a
^KN  _ C  ( 54 8.OM ! cN& " 5. .

  " 6 I4  ( 
f {3] (2003 UNEP ) _ C
www.unep.org/PDF/Tourism-and-biodiversity.pdf

SA  G8 :  F  8 f1 T*1 <. 4!4 ^C  Q:(


 :
IN 4M
UP ) _ 8  ( ) ! H  
   =N  
 . . .
)!< =8  
   4M!: )   
)!< !  
    
C3 
) - !-8-  o  )  48   M )!<  =N   Z.cf 4M o.N ].!-.8-
)   
 T       C  ( -fC 5  C  ! ! F:  _:

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

37

]UCN ! H  
   .H= x8.cN .? .8-
 . 
> .f   .
 .
- H   P C  a 
 -8-MN0 !N 8
&~  : Q:  >1 f1 T*1 <. 4!4
 : )  : N >
 8 M  cM    ( )(  OcH
]U..CN ..4M ..fN
.. ) ..8 _ F ..N (.. ..   ..  ..cM !.=8 <..!) ..  ..W
_-   k3  M
P  ;8   -/M -/ H 6z  . .U
)    ? :  z ( 
   -f H (a!: <!4 8-f     cf

i 8 N oN :cN


i 0 5 `N  C    . cN - . =. 5 
. T
<  (8 ) H Z/?
  C  $ 3 CH?

 C  $ 05
>1  4  :
 .. ? 5..
..=` 8 .. ..
^p..N ..4K I.. 
. W 6..  I..UN ..!) .. .. 5..
 4M > - ]N <N -  cN  ^ 3  . . 5. . .4M > .cM .
  
. = 0 . ]U.CN .! H  . 
 . I.N
 .) .C3  .o.N :.cN .c
  cN ) :N
   4M o => !N  cN 0
 5 -8  _   cN   - - ] -/i       

   "  '>1  +4 " )  ( 2001 ]  (:
www.environmentalauditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewContainerpub/eng01pustudyauditerenvaccord.pdf/$file/eng01pustudyauditn
terenvaccord.pdf

 I8
  )
 5  b- -. . b. . cN   . .UN
 . 5. ( .
!  5 C 6 - F:  cN ?
 54!-  5:  ) ? 8 yM <!c/]
M8 o   kM<  cN   3   2 <  F C  i= .
) (8  cN  - 
C3 
^pN  (
N C  cN H 3<
H?
 :;_6   =M u3 Of
oN x C3  cN : )  Oc? .y
-  cN  .

38


N  N f  H  .

 cN - )   N M 


8 
(CITES)
Uf a

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

.... cN ....cM  ........H  !


....  5....M .... 
 ....CN) ....8 ....`8.... cN
().(CMS

. cNH  .-" .. (.a


> ../ P .. 5>....
N )  ..CN .. cN ..C
" (a
>( 0

 cN
  (WHC).   cN- 
  ?= 
 I   5.5cC  cN <H -M  M) 4(UNCCD).
MO  cN>   <H -M 
zN 5  (UNFCCC).  cN <H -M   5  M(UNCLOS).-

 cN  8 M )(IPPC

 cN MO MO (SPS) N !a1 -..


)..8 : :  ..4M  U..   ]U..CN .. ..-f..! ) .. !..
 W UWH 0 5 `N UC =   8
W )

 
.4( .V3
 O V8
uP= 5 
cH
 !8- 4M ) . 8-  C .cf
) 5  = 5> 4N  :c  U  cN -  . . ? . 
. .
 I8  cN
] 8  <N ^   ]8
WN ]a  . :.cN .M)x. .
 M 5CN-  :c  5 . cN  .?
.  5.4 8 . .8 ]8
.WN_ . .?) -.
_ - ( 8  5  cN .
) _ .
.P .4N =. 5> . cN  .UN

.Y . - .-.!N   .6 > .C.
_ . > . <..8-f.  U..C =  .M .. . ..Wi ]. _-. .8 _ ..  k3..H
 5 -M 
 H 0P-
  5
?4 C ! H  
 
8   5>) .   . I.U (. (.
   :c 
  0
NN&Q NN ]U..CN : u ..4M ..  Y ../ ..`8 > 5.. ....  . ( .... N
  C  -.8-MN F .N . 5.4 .4N . . 
.Y .4N -.=) .   .  . C .8
  ..
..Y) x.. .. ..M <-..N 5..4 8  .. C  k..8
> 5..
.. (:..cN {..UP) ..

  ) ( ) T ? . .4N -.   . .4_ . .W  5. .C-.M k3  . 5. .
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

39

 W oN-M k3 . _ ..  T .


 . -. :.c 0 ! ./ I.U8 :.c
. V .T
N)
 = 8- ) f$ !
F-.  U. . I.8 .4M D8 .= ].a  .
!N   :cN
! 0
ba 4M b
 `8 5 yM T  ( .4N   Y 
. T y.M.UN
 F:.

  -  0
 NN2! NNc-f..CN :8  ..4M  V..=
..  <-..`
.. I3..  ..-f ..N
 -fK
P  5  C .)  x M
8 -f oNH  5.H .$ (.
)  ]8
W ( (.
G51 er <8: 6+-f. <.=N
^K. u.Mc (ETAS) (.
.W 
. T  . C
` ]a
^K ]   ) 6 .$.  (.) (( . .  . ].a. ]8
.W <.=N

^K( 
UP {UfN F  () a 
3 Cf
.4  5.4 8  (. !_6./(.
 !) IC8 - Ci  .  ) Wc oN
3 Cf ]a
-.  ! Zcf  36
  
  T 
W p8 -  ) C ( -N ) M/ Ci Z .4N .O 8:.
) ..  x.. ..4M .. u..N:.. = ..  !N 8
..WN (..) .. <.. x..
8
..P . .. 5..
  C.
NNa  : NN)S
..W  ..U (.. .. cN  ..4_ 5.. ; ..  ..Cp  -..!N V
..
8  
Y k=M 
W - =N ]8
WN  x 4M  ;  cM  Of .
 6 ]W H (a
).N  / f" . .8 M (.a  k> . .U . CM
6P 5   cN 0U
&~ D :6Q: G^C  Q:(
   GG1+Q
 I8
] -8-MN
>H 
C3  54 8 4N F:
>H -. 5.4 8
..48 ! ..  ..   ..  . ..
c I..8 .. -..M8 
]..  ..W  ..U
^K..N
..> ..
...C3  ..WN -..
..>H   ..i ! ..  .. ..4M ..C ) (>..-..c (
=
( i  ) M 8-( . cN 
   4M>
    8  ( 5.
 .. .. ..
..N U..C ..) ..4M -..8- .. 5.. ..C .. C  .
.. ..C3
 C >  $ =  .cM  ..  . ( . F:. .a 5. .C U.C k.UN
= 5   5!   /  / f .C x. 5. .`8 .? U.WH-.  
8 .
 .. -..8-MN .. C  ..-../ 
.. uP6 <.._ 5.. -..M ..
N . ^ .. <..N ..
40

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

) !c8
ON 4N  C 5 `8   - (   M kUN
z  -!
= 5 
P
a. 8
)  x- . MN ! . > / .-c . .C) . x.x8.cN 5.4 8
.P
 8..C  ..C i ..8 ..H o.. N ..4M >) ..-c (.. ..M ) 8-..(  U..
 cf: ZfN< pC -W <!N  )  ? N  4M >
8UNY /
  xcP 8C  4M   oN :c  C =N  .4M > 5.C . 8
.W
 V3> -f.CN  8.C  .M ? .H 
. uP b.C F:. . ^ -.
!:  I8
 5  !c8 =` 8 6N  UC C  5 8 4M! ..
- 54 8 8! :  C .
! ..
..Y ..? ..4M! ...  ..- ..Cp  ..  ..  ! ...
   M!
Y 4M U H !     -  ! . pN.8
)  x- )   5 !< {CN o:`  - 
C3: pN 8   H -.=)
  <; b- 
 DK ]    -  4$ H  .8 M
.W  .
=) 8- ()K ufN0
 ) ai < O    x IN -=) 5
W 4M "
.W  "z.W.P
  . <!N
i 
W  4M   WN 
.U -.NN ].8 .
!4  .
( 54 8 48 !  
^KN  . ( .:.  I.Y
8 -.
. ) -.8-MN .! .

W i a f -  )
^pN  .
SA : FF E =) (  ! :

]..  ..a -..8-M -..C 
 .. ..4 6..P 5.. _.. .. F:....
 >
-8- ) >   a -8-MN 
  =    ( F ! H 54 8

  .. .. ..fN ! -..8- .. ..  .. ..) ( .. ? .. ..H  (..P- ..fN
   a . .) 5 5> )
^p8 F ? . .H  .) .P- .> 5 . (.8
M
.H
!   -8-MN
N  . yMM8  Oc?    y ) OcN
8   WN

 4
>H   H=   a 5 ( yM 
   M :

i N>   (.
  > k )  M-M k3  M   M  U =z(0
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

41

H  
0
Uf a
H .P-

> 5  F : .

H (a
> 0
 > 5 8
M .
  ^ )  (0
   z0
 F N -3 C  ( ) =  U  O 8 {Uf 03

zN
^KN     (.

MO  (.
! 8
_   
 H .P .a 
 . ].aH .8  5 .`N .
.  ..H
 :
&~ : Q: ) ( ) ^A +& 4A C  
..M8 ! .. <..=N -.. .. 
 ..H!-..8- 
 .. ..UN  ( .. ..
.. ..MN
 -8-M
> f
i ?
  36) -3 I8 :.PK8
.) ]. . F  .
^K..c
  5 4   ]  O  <=N -!-8-    I8
U8 
]
K..W ..  ..c 5.. uf..
..aH ! ..)
..CN .. F ..N ..C4..MN  ]) .. .. o..
`
:  54 8   C
> f ) IC8  uf ..Of ) .ai  . .I.8 o.
:..PK8
..) ].. ..-.. F  F..`
..  5..
..8 ..H ..8   .. 5.. -..M!-..8-

Uf  - 8  F
  <!N .4_ <.=N .! 5.
.P I.> <!.4 8  - .C 5.

f ) :    .
H
) _  ;<  -M I8 F -8 
 !-8-      c.C -.N
 > 5
^KN `
     M 5 -cCN ]C -f    ? -.

=8 !
 . 
 H  . .  .8 M .4M .$H . .=U
.N .!H 3 .W
   z ) !H $H( pN  .8 _ .) ..W> 0 .CN -.a;
. H  . -8 .O
   C>     54 8 _ C =8 !
  
 H  - <=N- 4M
$H  5KN ) 3-  .-8 O

42

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

  x C ! H  


  C
8 
O)   5 6  4M  ) ai  
 x    8
WN I   !OOfN 54 8 N -M.F
&~ : Q: !( f*  )C >! y SQ7
 -8-MN -
>H   I8 -M8 !  
 H / OP ]`f8 <!8
  .
_ )  4N -=) 4M    . {.=) . .C ) (>.-.c ( (. i
 ) M 8-( ! 54 8    
 H
>H    5= U  f )? .= .U
 f 
W 
8-N - !
.Y (.4M 5. <!8. N <.8 58:. .   .
 
- 5 <Y `P  x
>H 
   
Y 5 <Y / OP  x I.8 5.6

8 
]  5  - :  8  54 8 4M <;N . .
^p.N!< 6.P 5.
  I  C  .
) _ -. . .`P
.>H   .H?
^K.N
.  .OP ! . .=N . 
) . 
 .H
 
 ) uf8:  a.
&~ : Q: (=  ( 
 ) .. = .. H I..8
..=8 
.. ].. ..  ..  ..O  
8 ..  ..<..N ..
  !   
 :
  b 4M  cN  =    
  b 4M= 5.V3
   b `8 4M   C 
 (=N 68 N 4M 5 ) a! - ) . . ? .  5.-.O . (  .
 MN H((    !N =    cN -   / f  
&~ : Q: !(< D 4.1 (  8 87 E? (*
 I8!  <=N  
 H 8 
8UN )  cH : -fCN.4M
) _ 8  cM    (  :PK8 -
] )  H  :
 .. ..  .. 
..8
=N -f..C
 ../ P .. 5-f..C .. .. )5.. H ? ..

 (.
 ( H  a  C   ( i C UWH4M
  
^K ]    5
  p   
  )


() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

43


 <N   a  5
   O^= !:  a  8 M_ C}  H

=8 - ! -  
 H o  
8-. D . 
 . .= .` . .) ( .
F:
_ 0 _  5
P  I.U8 -! . . 
 .H .Cc  .a 5.  . k.N
 ( 
 -    
8  (  ` Cc  ) !) C3 ? -
 W8! a  
 H  Cc 
^KN 5  .  .. 
 .  .) ( . .

zN  .
) >   :   F
8U b 
 >  -  -8-M C 
 H.8
-8-!N   ( 
 T ]   4M F:!-8-  5 M./  M.O5. H
 a   5O ))(  4W6.P (7 <. F:.  <.N . .P  .a . -.8-MN T
.
 .4
<  :7 G 
  : s 4 ..Q
]=N- {za bMN C 5 3   cM    ( )! -  5 ! -:
8  4.C 
.=c6z. - . ) (. .8   .  . .$H .N   F .6z.
.Y
  
W   U  - N ;< .
:..! . -.. - :..cN ..) ../ ..C-. ..M ..  ..cH  . 2015 ..= .. -.. D..

   ! 8-
8U C>     (     4M--.8-MN .) C
H- 
:c C3-   )  W8 . cH>  
 6_-:
<!cN (1-   ) 0c
-8-MN (2- 
 (C3  ( ) k=MN-   )( 0c
-8-MN (3 $H ( -!N   ( )? 0(
MO
-..8-MN (4 ...H 
-...8-! ..C3 ) ? ...6z.. ... 
3 ...  ..Wf
M k...3]...U
$H - 0( uP
N
<!cN (5
 T( =N  4M( H  <!N 
64W  C30
-8-MN (6
>H 
C3   <!4 8 58: - C )(  
 T.4M
 -.. ..) :..PH ..   ..   _
.. .. 
..  .. ..$H (..! -..8- .. V..

44

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 ( ) (c = _ C ]U=N .CN . Y  _ .C F


.4 I.6 ].=-.  <8-.= . 4
WPH   O   -   IWf   O b.8 .f 58-.!:. )=. <!K.

! .
  
  $H  H-  -:
! k^N    ]   4M  ].U .WPH
.Y=  . .cM  . k> .
  M  .  ].U .$H !.   ) c.W .U (.) .C  . z 6.
 4 IW.o
) uMH   - ( <NOM !  5  
WPH  UN0
= 5 (O Cc _ . .CY.H  -._ . M^!< !.  .=8i .4M ].U=N
WPH
Y= (  _  > kH (a  z.
  C ( i-( <

 
W )(     :


Y ) 
W WPH H  
0
Uf a

_
k3  z.
? - )  N  z.

a -8-MN - 

i H?

 54 8 c  5- )(   {UfN
.
SA   :A1  c ^ (  :4 (  *1.1
  F:! C.Uf
.PH .M8 
.  .= . 
 T!.  . .P -. 
 .
   Cc 0
&~  : 6Q: C4 (
& *' '& >Q  ( ( 
)  . x 8  .Cc  .4 .H=  0 y.M . 4.W .8 ! .) 8 <.:.  .
Va8 ]UC8 Z
 a ] N  - T 0
K ( NN 
-f..  : NNs ..=N 
 ..  ..= 5..4 8 ..8- u..Mc8
..
-f H   ) 
W ) 
 T
N    (  cM .
 <8 c H 
. . T.  4.W ( .  _6.O .=> <. .ci
 V3
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

45

 <N O ]a 8 N ) 


 T 8 M

 <8  c H
   :  <8      c H
 - - N .) .`8N 3 . C .
.H o:..N .  -.3=. .8
8-
 ( ] 
3 Cf
8 !
' NN 'NN>1 NN5  DNN&Q 5..4 8 :
 ..  V..aN  .... N ( ..)k..
  
N  
 T=  4M 5  V3   cN -  b.  .-.
 ] ! .
 cN   4M )=   cN6 = 5   C 
 T )  . x. .8
 Cc :
 - N  cN   MN  ( P-M -  C   k> . . M

W
 ]N- = -   cN  _- !N  cN -  <N] !
  b 4M= 5 :c V3  !N-   !N M
 - 8 6P )  5  C >   ( = 5 -
 :cN <8= 5 V3 K  <36
 - 8 6P  5  C >   cN -   ! b-
 54 8 : &Q 4N 
 . . C 
. T . ./ f 
 ( . 0 .  .
 VN  F  C  / f  ( 8 Ma   5 `N -: 8  yM
 <N    C  4M
 ba   4M 8 M / P .cM  .O . .  ( . .
 N  C ] !-8- H?

V..aN <..N .. -..8-MN :..cN .. C   ..W .. ..  ..) ( ..=.. 5
H = 
PH ?  {Uf  
 
- C  8 M -M  54 8 fN  8 M;  :
 ]=8-M 
z)  C
   
z  =
_  N  C > k=MN)`  T3

46

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 C 
 54 8 : u:   <=N 
   (  
. T.4M
-8-! / f   ( ` .  cM   .> 5 ; .  I.Y
N -. . .! H
 
  ) <=N
/?6 = 8- c4   c O 8
 T IY
N.) `8
<=N   -8-M -fC    T3 F:! / f  0
   b!     -8-M T3  
!
  
$p
8U b = F:! D8 T3 
 b N!  !

 54 8     = -fC H

   k=MN 
 T  ( -)!  T3 )-!C

 . . -. k.=MN . C 


.H T-.)!  .!3  . 5.4 8 Z.
 !!

(Q 
IQ 45
; :   a   ( ?
  WN 5. -8-! .
 4M >
 .
.P .) .! H  5.4 8 . 
 . <.=N -. :.
.!;8 .
} - !    ?  C =-  )  F .N <!N .C
. T
H   ) ai  oN kCN H 0
-...8-MN <...8 ...  ...C  ...C ! ...  ...a ...Of ) ? ......
i (
 <N ]a 
a <; 8 
 - !     8
W )  :c< <!N C
 _ O   - I8 ) 4
 > ! ;< i - ! ) 5 -8 8  P
 HN. ( 6N ( : N -.  . ..4M
.  y.M 
 .; ..  5.4 8 .
^p..N
 .)
$  4W .8 _ .c. ( .)  5. -.8--. -.8-MN <.8 F:. 4.W .C
  <N  8 )0
_  a  Cc6 :
 -  4M    ) P      W (58 UNH.8
 ) ! H   (
  ;< ) 
 a _    (

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

47

 cMN= 4M   -   / P  (  P ]   yM


 N <8    <; 5
 > -
 
O  !  >6     UWK / f

  G   :48  F 
 .8 _ T .> . - .` .  < . {N
. . 5.4 8
 c   
 5  )  F:
 T:. 5.4 8  .WN .! H . 
 .
 5 5
P a  Cc   :
 uOfN 4M   . )
.W .?= ) .  ]. .) .
_ ) 5. .].a
O   {Uf :c =< (   C
 ]WN 4M= 5 U  f  8 M  
  b 4M    ( )   !N 
 =N  = 4M  !3    ==M
)4 51!  (7 *( 54 8 : 4N  U - = -O
8  H 
.
   ? I.UN  5. -.8- . cN - . -.=N  .4M >
.8
=N . ! .
<H -M ! -
PH ) ? !   ) .ai  ( M . ! .  ; .
P- - I UN - !
8
=N  8
.W-. . 
.8
=N -.N -. 
 .  .f
!<  8 0
 I8  =8
U 4N      - =
8  C )  !a VM.O :. ].  W8  .   .MN .H -. = . .W
8  T3 . 5.4 8 KN -. .! H
 
   k UN 5 F:=
8 H ]  
8 = -  V3 54 8 0  36 :PKN
! H  
  )  :
 -N Z!  =N !3  5
8
 <8)    - >  = - =
8

 @A () u(  :
 4..W u..f8 8 <..
..U -..8- 
..  ..4  ..a -.._N <!..4 8 .._ 5 ..
 (  . .  T
 0 . 
 ..  .UzN -. ( .?.a 5.
. ). 3  .
  a 54 8-f ?

 T! 5  a 4 
 -M   ( 0 
? ..  
 ..  ..M8 .. 
.. ..48 ?
.. ..U -..8-MN -.. .. 
 0 .. ../ P

48

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 


 5-     C 
   ( )!<   M P  .U 
k.=M .  .
!   0
 .. .. ? ..
.. ! ..
 .. 
 ..H  T ..
 .. ..4M:.. ..=8  :..c .. cN-..
 () <4M  / f   F?= 
 I   5 5cC .  Uz.
5.a .
 5  ( :H  P-  > 5 8
M  
)
k8
 <=N
 T
  -8-M :
<8 H   = => T 
 OOf   >( )i   ;  ( 0
 UP b   F .?= . (.
.!N! .
.MN .C  . cN- D8 .= ) .H
 .( T3
=N ! =  D8 =) ! 
 T3H  . (T3
k=M8
  T T3  )= D8H  .(T3
-..N! .. 5.. ..C

..8
=N T . .. H .. cN ....U .. ">
..  ..
 W )
)N -a 8 MH  P- = 
M ) - =N T3  
8  = U
  cN = 5   C ( 0
-fCN !    )( =N
8  ) ! 
 5CM- =N. ( T3  
8

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

49

< )= : 8 G 
  6 
 u( 

 u(  )
=) 
 

K (

'  '>1

:

5  D&Q

&Q

 9!5C 
u:

(
(Q

.C  (


IQ

(

45

(N>   
  k> .... ).... M-....M k3 k> ....
 ( M  M U(
H  

Uf a
H P-
> 5  F : 
H (a
>
 > 5 8
M  O
  ^
   z
 F ....N.... -3 ....C ....) ( ....
=  U  O 8  {Uf(3 i

zN
^KN     


MO   

50

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

  G 

)4 51!

u:

> 2 : HF  


 6
!- 
5 C3:  Oc  U ! H  
      5 
 ..
 ( )( ]  M  <  WN . .?H  5.-.  .U  T3 .
 . ./
  54:o
<C=8 Oc 
W  C a UzN   ( 
C3 <N
) :2 Oc


N>   ( .

  > k )  M    > k  M  M U( .

 
.
Uf a

 . P

> 5  F : .

H (a
> .

 > 5 8
M .

  ^ .

   z .

 F N -3 C  ( )( =  U  O 8 {Uf. (3 i


   T!   W8 <C 
 :  W8

 cP .



8  -O   cN -  8
W   C 
. T

 a  - CN - yM    M


 -8-MN ) 5-   .
 . .a
 Cc .

 _   5 ! H  
  .
 
5 <Y    " (a 5
MO  " "
zN
^KN   ..
 "   < <8 ! ) : =
- IC
8 _ N   M .  36
  ] <N -   
   6.P 5.  .  5..  <.N ( .  .(.
! H  
  !  yM  
  ]     
 .. .
4$   bMN 
  )(  <  -:

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

51

www.enviromental-auditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewAuditsIssue1.
_?  <N 54-f  _   ] 5 M  < ]  -=) o  _  )={  x  >.k
  kM<    3  <`8 3 
   (  : )( F:  ) ai( <  x
<8
F  F-8 - 54
] -c   
 )  . =C
2  :&  *1^
 
 : 6
>E :

8.   f.a .   .` ( . Z.f8 .C_i 
^K 5. .
.PH . o:.
 I8 4M  =C -MN    c:  a.

 5 -8- ! H  
  
 -=N _ ) <!N 4 ]a
N> -._   {UP
  -8  =    >=   cN6
C3  / f  (  cN  (
]
. 4M
 ! (  :

8  <; NKN
  5   O ! ) . . cN.   . .4
oN    8
W   C )    cN  ( .
NNN>1
NNN  :6NNN ... ... cN ... .../ P ... ...=N ...!    ... -... ]...a

N   ( > {UP  >=   .  cN
)  1992=   ] - ) 8 
   W W - .  .  .^ . 
Np.
  H _ y  ]      5 cf?
 180 5 .. .W  b. N -. . cN.
 ( KN 5 -)
  " U "  =  .
 cN  ( (  cN  <!N I.   . .  b. .`8H(.) .
   cM  !H -f  -C   .
<  : 9 G >1
  !& .( (CBD ) 6
1!  . 19928 5 : V
1! !Q 29 :. 1993
 C8
)4 ^C (a W 190 :( 2007
8 8 )) : .
^C (: (a http//www.biodiv.org/world/parties.asp :
 V<   http//www/biodiv.org/default.shtml:

52

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

C4 mC :

 cM    ( .

-f  -C  4   ( .

<C=N 8 5 N-f  8-f


PH   ^   =8
U
 C. 8

(=) Q> &7 5 :


>=   cN  ( -!N  4M   cM  -f  -C   ( <!)
 U  ]a
N >    {UP  ( ) (NBSAP! ]  {.Uf>.
/ P N .  . )  . 
. (T ].`N .8 ) M.a;
. . (6:. .
 ..P 4..W   .. U= ..C  .. z   .. -8 ..O .. U 3 ..= .. {..Uf
...
5 `N 
PH   I:8   cN

48  !8-=-  :c ) 4


N>    {UP  ( .

4!4.1  4 !    (  MN (  8 M-f  -C ) ;


.
 . (7

 W   M  cM    (   ]WN I  _  C F:  ) k> .;
.
 . (8

 _ . 
.  <;. . -. . ].WN .H  !-.   .  ]. 4.C
 )5M;
 . ( 8

_
.. _ ..8 ..cM  ..( NN  -f..6 NN!45  -..C .. P-..N ].. ( ..
 4  - 5/H    ) M;
 . (8

] P 
  H  .8
z-.!N -. .  <;. .  .> 5 . ).;
.
 . ( 8

 ( ^A   5 3 4  M  -^ ) ;


 . ( 8

]..WN(NNa   NN <..=N -.. ../ P


^K.. 
..W  ..   ..-..!N .. ..
 ( ) ;
 . (14

t5F1 IW .8 . 5. (.  ..  ( . . M8 _ (..) ; .
.
.(13

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

53

)4  5!  5c   } c8 K-)!  =    ( ) ;


 . (26


)8 4kM : o. u  4  cN  (  :  .
-=N     .-.  . <.   :.c .  . cN6 .=> <!N . . :. b.  -.

=8  <8-= 1991 25 4  


/ ) (48  V
W 8 N  -   54 8
=N ! H  
  
  c c F:H .
) ... ... 2002
...
Np.... ...f 
>K... ... cN....  ...UP ( ...
....N
) k...=M " (http//www.biodiv.org/sp/default.shtml ...cf ) ... -...  u=...  ...M...
 (   .C    . .M.M >.  . 2010 .C   5. Z.cf
.=c .)i
 M VU  4H" -!N>
 k=M  cN-  C  2010  ( .
 WN Uf
i 4 N- C3
Y 18 ].WN (.!) -.
.>H  .

 ..  .. <! .. ../ P
.. <!N N>.. ..  ( .. {..UP . <! .. -..
Np..
..

..>H  ..W > .. 


.. <..= . .. H =-..  k..=MN . M -!..C ) .... ( ..
_. (http//www.biodiv.org/decisions/default.aspx?m=cop-07&id=7767) 2010
54 8 4N F:
YH H- -O  
 C 
8 . 5
  !a  :&Q 5. . :-.  .  u.Of ]8
.WN ].a .Uz  .$ .I.
  H  ]8
W c  Uz8 -  M 5 -8- _  5 . I
P b  5 -8-
-..  ]..a
.. N > .... ..  {..UP  ..U   ..c ( .. >= .. cN ....
 ( .

 - N - : u  kN  T   ./ P   b. 8
.WN 5.C .4M  ].o.
I..8 y..M8
..  5. 
..-..!N T  ..8 _ (.. ..U ..> 5 I..8 .. ..?M8 5..

N > {UP    ( ) (NBSAPS  .U >= . cN ..
 ( o: -C -=N $  8 M  ( .
^C (
  :
5 <Y  5 -8-i   C <!8-  . k.N ( .
)  C ]a
N> 4N   Y i ac _- _- ;  x. .-.  !8-.
.. I.4 .48 .. . Y  .  .. 5.. <!.4 .. . cN..  ( .
..NF:..
 = IN 4 -OM > 8    .

54

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

=) 
 54 8 : H. .  5 .?M8   .a   T!. -.8-MN -. .
 . .f
!< .   b: 4M

 ]a
N>   / P  (  U >=   cN  ( .

 ]a
N >    {UP  ( ) (NBSAP  U >=. cN .
  ( .

 :c
N  (  ! / f {UP H .

 :c   cN  ( 6P 5  8


W .

=  T3 ! )  _ 8  ( .

 ]a 8  k=M- 2010   cN => a  ( .

 6i  8 _ ) !-=N 5  (   cN  ( .

- 
 Z=? T   5  _ 8  ( .

& ( c  :


) 6^ 8  _  
 :c kN  >=   cN  ( :
* : 4 7Q! )C >1
  6(  +
)   2006  I4
 > 
 -6C8  !  => 4M
  cN   )(CBD

4 )( (  :
) uM kUN c 4M>    cN => !N  ( .

S
 UW    ]  UW  !N :cN  cN  ( ) . -6C8
( !
*  cN  ( .
*  ]8
W-6C8   C  )    ( .

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

55

(sc7
]N  cN  (  -M
^KN   8 z ]8
W-C8   C   =.

   ( .

< <8 {UP ]a> 8 M  $


   ( .

  b
 4M - 5
z/ MH  M kN  ( -C8 (.c8  o
  U  cN  ( .

< 548 Ma _ :cN C  MN 4   cN  ( .

:cN  cN  ( W 3. <;


Y

* 4
 8  )C 2 ?>
1 : >1! 
 6
)   2004 ! - )  
 H 
  
 "
O :cN  cN 8   " .

4 )( (  :
) u..M -.. :..  ..z k..) ..4M  .. cN . => ..!N.. -..C  k..8 .. ) ( ..
!N 8
WN
i N>.

S :
* )

 2001
8 8 5 :( . 20038
* <N P  
W_-  5]  8C  cf=  :
 /=
;<  . (3)8  UW yM- H . (4) 4W   / f ! i   C  . (7)M _ 8 P ]). (2( !
*  cN 8 
  ( .
* = 5 8
W > .

56

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

(sc7

- 8 c)   V3  MN  ( )   .

 yM ( ! .  .= U (._ .8-f.  -.C . -.M ( . I.C


O )(  . 8

    _ 5- ) U MN ( . y8-MN

<  54N -  ) ; N    (  ^-M<


 54N 5 - 4W
  .
< x :cN <8 !  =   8 M P ] 68-N IC  V3O )(  . 8

<N W  5. -8- .c f ) .  . .P D.KN  k> . . M  4.W ..8 M
H .Natura 2000 U
* 8  )C
! Q : u 
  6 (
^ I(. (.
)  . 2006  I.4
]. . 

. (OAG) .8 
U.WH .
   k8 ) 4M - . cN .=> ..   . I.4 u.M) .

]  
-. K.C 8 .8 c  .  = . . -  ..
 T  - UN

> f 8 c
i  . 3

4 )( ( 
) uM! (   ! b!  VC
   ( - )  -CBD (7   >k
 )  M. (8

S :
* )

 1997 5 :( . 2006
* ! D P  VC
 .  : .  .   .:.z
 -8 O 4 CW  _ C <  yM 
.  U

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

57

* 
 5 . .C8 5.C3 ) . .; ].a . . -.8- 
) . . - .

O
.) .C3
.i N
k.U .8 . cN. -.i T .
 : ( .

f {3
  C -   ) ai   4 
  VC T
 >(.
* -M k3>  cM   > k 
 U  M . U
( !:
*  cN    N . 78
*  V3. uOf
*
i N>  cM  -f  -C   .
*  $  5-  . 4M
* ..=N .. 

8 
 .. k..N ..8  ( .. .. i  -..C ../N  ..WN ..

  .
(sc7:

  C >( !



  T;<  () Za M (.8 .  {.Uf  . .
? !  yM - 
8-=N -8-MN <8 < c4  4W  -  . VC

_.. 5.. % 30  k> .. -..! .. M b ..`N.. ..!N>..O 5 .. .. . ? ..
 bUH-M k>  8 M 8  
- 5 <Y
8-=N y8-MN  c4 = ! .

< -8-MN <8- ; i  -8-:  - 8 


)  5. . .  -. 4WI.O
<=N N  {Uf> 
  T
 .

<N = ZW ` Z   )   ]/=


.   {.Uf .C= .
 T .
. .
I4 -
] >  
 T8  M(  {Uf ) -    .

 I4 T
]  . 
-. .8 -. ! .  .8MN . ._ U  .-. (.

( _ .

58

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

(
^ I(: (.
: >E

N  > k .? . M-.M k3> . . M  .U . .c   ! .-.=c 
.C
;    5 3 4  _ UzN VU 5 %12
4 H. a
_ Z8
N IC MN      M  ) U   > k  M :
"  _ C  5H /  8 M OOP 
4
M cM    (   U
?= )  _ O <86P 5 !N  3=   3  c
PH " .
  WN  > k oN  M   )={  H )!  -8 5. -8-. -.MN . k> .
 )  M UM  8 M   . 8
M UUf <C=8  M H .a .8
M k> . (.
 WN  3;  F:  > k  M  
 .=U -8-.$ .8 M ]. N .8   .=U  .> M.
F:..  ..=U
  ..8-8-..$ ..8 M ].. N .. ..;M ..=U P-.. )!].. N 5>.. .. MN ..
  48 -   .=U  . 5. -.8--f. -!.CN  .   .=U
5. .8
!-8- 
N ! !  .  M

N  > k .cM .C  .8 z . !  M  . .    . .U?= ). MN .!) .
 > 5 U M  NM ) - CN cM  =
   > k   P5.4 8
-f   > k -i  M   > k
c8   
c -f H (.a!  .6= .W-.N
.P k.P Z3 .. . .M 
 .. Z.=?N .. .Of  . M  .. 5
) . ..
 . _ C .) o:. . ; <.-.  !8-.; .U .   k> . . M .a . 
.
.! " 3 $  .
  . . 5. <Y
. .8 )-. .  _ .C  k> . .O
.8 . M

$p -     _   KW .C  .8 M = F:.! .-  k> .-. .!N
- =8
U .
 W <;N-M k3   <8_  z8 -8-!N 
 6.C F:.  .  .WN
F:!-8-  >C  8
WM   
M k3
W 
O  MO  U

U  P-  V CN   =U -O -/ H  ) . .M 
.8 ]. .WP .
 ]U $H  58-  = 5 I z 
.
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

59

54 8?   5 -8   5  > k U )  M 5


8
=N UNEP  >k
  M    ;
 $  =` 8 
C3 )   ] 
4((
quin.unep.wcme.org/resources/publications/pa.biodiv/

( !
>1
 : 6
 W   > k  M cM ! -f  -C 
W _i 
< )
H (a   P M
M !   )  ) (8 / f "  cM .P  5. " ].. cN
  ) ]  <CO 
4 :
N>    - 36 Mc./ -3 .Oc
.( 24 kM
 -.. -..  ..
..>H  ..W
8..UN ..cM  ..; ..  k> .. .. M> ....

O
i C3 kUN ) <!N  cN  ( .
>1
  ( 2010
 
4 C !(c !S1 :
  
Gs +(^ D XC *(  .
C4
*  %10 8 _ 1-1 5 H < H     ) 4W.
* 8 _ 2-1  > k H   C  / f  (.

>1   ( :
!  . cN
.    . -.8-MN ._ .8
.    .?= ) .. .  k.8
> 5. .U<3
 ] =    KN. !8 _ -
>1 E :
]  <CH a
> )  Oc?  y: ZO8  cN C .

60

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 <a : (10) G >1   ( (.  !& .


1!  1972
 ) 16 : V
1! !Q 17:1975
 C8
)4 ^C (a
>183 : ) ) 23
( 2006
^C (: (a http//whc.unesco.org/en/statesparties/ :
( V'<   http:// whc.unesco.org :
C4 mC :

)  ; b <H -M <  ?= ) )  (4C8  M  1972( -.8-MN.8 M
- k>    3    / f bCKN -  cN
    -  -.
).N.8 M

   ?= ) . U
=)  Q> &7 :
b=cN- `H  -.8-MN V.$
N ]. .P  ! .>  .- . . 3  .) .

   =N -   5- `H 
.UN !)  ] V$ ) . 5. ./ c.c
_ 8-=N 8 M UP .  ;) M
 5 ] `8 =N - .`H  .8 M= <.    . ].
.    .  . ) .=.<3
]WN F:-  =N <8-=N
8. ! _ 5 8
  !a  :&Q :
   WN 8
W _
UC  4  ? UWH -.O -./ o .C ].U .$H )(.
-M k3  54 8 ]8
 .8 8
.WN _ .4 >.Of .   k> . . M
  )  UP  M =U 4 -O
N .
8   -
x V CN- = U  f    > k / P  M   !   _ ) .F:.
 ... I...8 .. M= ...U  ...f ... 8  x..  ...U ]U...C8
... ...`8 x...
 Cc  yM ! F:  U .
V CN x ) 4M  > k
f   M  -C   ? ..M -f.  k> .
 )  M yM    <;N <8 F: UWH 54 8 4N -O 

8 . 5

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

61

: u
=N  x 4M -  5 8
W  W 
 -8-M   T
   > k . M 5.4 8 .8
 5 -8-
 T P  > k  M N : 5

-8-N_  > 5. /H

 cM  H  
.
> f  a

ZcfN^
H . P-

 kP   K -


{  5  > k .  M

 <.=N 
-.=8 T .  . .^i  . .  .Wc:. -. - .C8 )-.8-MN .

z i 8`
8=8  :i   5
4 W 
Uf .

^C (
 :
  Z4N <8i         U   > k  M]
 !) o  -M _   :! KWN 
z .

8 4C /H  4C W8 58: 
PH  =  _   > k  M< >

 4 8 5 5  :cN 5 <!UW= ) 8- F:  >. k


 >

P ) .   k> . . M .= .U  .f .) ./ P  .O .8-
   48 ._ k> . .) M.O !8-. _ . .P  k> . . M) x. . .M .
_- )! 
f  . ) . -. ].N  k> . . M .  . 5. -.x8.  .O

3 Cf _ .   b
=)  : H.
*  =N  W 4M k>   4$
N  M _ H  cf  ;H
*  {UfN Z Wi 4M  >-8-  M k
*    b- <= 4M CN   > k 8 M  MH  

Uf a- .
_  
 5 F:  > 8 M kH  )-!C
*  ]`N   4M K 5. -.  4.W  .> .  k> . . MN . M.
 ( O ) 

62

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

*  :cN k>    uf8 ) !N   4M  M


*  pN  UW/ 4M (  8
  8 M
*  =N      4M- {Uf 8   > k  M
* 
)N 4M  M6  cM  _ 8  > k  M
* 
. i  . !N:.fN  .4M ! . U.WH . 
.z6z. . 
3 .
 U P  > k  )  M
* ...=N ...  <...= ...4M ...P U...WH   k> ... ... M ...)
^p...N -... ... ...M 
...8
  
* -.._ ..  .. ...4M ... .. 6  ...$) ..i (Z ..4   k> ... .. M...
bOOP F:  O    <N Z F: 
& ( c  :
 M H   - _  
  kN   > k .  M
* 4  )C 
[ :K >   <a(
^ I((.

..  I..4
 >.. 
 ..z  ..  .. .... 2004 "
 4W k>   / f  M) 
> .f <.= " .!N-f.

Y -C   6M a H   )   > k .  M
_ P  > k  M) x. . .M -._ . )! .
f.  . ) . -. ].N
  > k  M   5 - x8  O
3 Cf _ .   b
4 (  :

- yM _ 8  ) U  > k O  M   .

- yM <;N  > k O  M   .


S :

 <C   > k   M  . U

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

63


W C P   > k .  M

 x! . O

( ! :

    > k  M.(1994) / f

    > k    > k  M. / f

(sc7:

:cN <N ) 8-N UW  > k -8   M! =    > k  M. / f

 <N  5 -8- 
4C  _ C  )   > k .   M_-. .) 6.P.
..O I..C .. ) .. k..C-.. ..
..^" <..=N .. 5.. (..  ....U
 ;
PH . O

 <..=N <..8 <.. 


 .... - ( ....O ..z .. ; ].. .. ..  x.. ..W
  .. ) .. ..; ..   k> .. ..? ..z  .. M)= .. -..  (..   ..  ..  ..
 
PH 6 -  ! T
    . 8
W

- 8 c
i  <N fN _  -O
3-f   C . U

-  8 c <C zWN   > k :c  M  .O N )  .H .<.8 <. .


 uOfN UWH :c  i .

-.. N -..8   k> .. .. M M..H  ..!c-..  ..ON 


 .. ..f
 O (
8  ] ($ N .

 X :
  : U

 W  -      =    (   > k  M 5CMN


 -. 8

fN UP _?? -i   > k 5c    M p 5 -   6.

8 (  UWH
8 M 8 U  .

64

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

) u..M
.. uP !..W .. 6z.. H  ..4! ..  
..W  ..) .. k> ..

 . M
<=N=
8-   
^K Oc  fN

a -a 8! .

* : D2  )C   D D


e((.  S

...  I...4
 >...  ... 5...O  ...
 2004  ...)u...M
 .. M ..U> ....W8 ..  T .. M..U 
..8>..
  IN y_ TW 8 C  M  U -3 ) _ 8.
 ( ;< ) . 5O
_ P  > k  M) x. . .M -._ . )! .
f.  . ) . -. ].N
  > k  M   5 - x8  O
3 Cf _ .   b
4 (  :
 M <!c c4 `)H   M . U

S :

i  8 M 4M.

i W 4M   z .

^ 5 5  M . U

( !:

= 5.V3

 
8 .


8
P )(   ?  Uf C f
$ ) 8 M ( 2005-2001 (.

f
.

(sc7:

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

65

  M  U(  x T3 .-. . (.  ? . >= b. .4M  .M

=.. 5.. V3 .. ..? ..O.. ..8 _ V3 .. Y ..W8 ..  T -..  .. M
 ) UW8   T <- o   M . U
Y <N 5 6  5 5 M P  < <8 fN
)    !  o5. -.

.6
  ] F:=`  =C
 X:

5CMN
     =U
8  =U    > k
 M  8 . U


..  5.. -..8 ..MH   ! . Y .. ..H  f ..O .. )  .. -..C .. N ..
 .

* 4
<  )C : <  8 +(
 ^


....  I....4
].... .... -....4  ....
 2004  ....  ....
  ..  ..8-4 .. 4 ..!N ..) ..  .. > ....8
  .. 4 .. ..4N  ..4 ../H  .. .. ( ..
 ..4 :H ..N ; ..  <.. .. I..4 u..M) -..
].. ..
-..4  .. ..c  
 .. .._ ..  .. 4 ..-..
..8
=N 5..
_ ^  
W > .
_ P  > k  M) x. . .M -._ . )! .
f.  . ) . -. ].N
  > k  M   5 - x8  O
3 Cf _ .   b
4 (  :
 -8-MN :<N -

- 
8
=N  5  4 .


  . .M  5. . 4 -. . . .=` 8 .
. .8 .  <.N -..N
 T3  k=M <N-f  cM  6/   4 <N-f  ) =^ <-  .

i  UW ._i  8 .` b.C4 -. -.8-


.8 <.N  .=> .!N . =.
  4W <N-f!  cM  _   4 ( < ^= )  .

66

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 


S:
 UW
 MH i  UW -8-
<  
W ^6  5 C  .8-4
  .
( !:
$   i   4   5CM !N  4 )   > .
(sc7:

 UW  
  ./ f . -.8- 8 .` b.> P <
.
.8 x.  .WN=` 8 .
 =    ( Z3;   `. {z

 ^
z )  UzN =` 8
c -/ ? 
 M 
8 .W 
.W
) > 5 ]   CM {UfN c F:=` . 8

< <8-f  UW


 _i 
< -  .ON (. .!
^K.N .O <-. o.<.!c
 8 `= W  4 .

=
8 =  _ 5 -  - b  C
C
Y 54 .

.. N ..  .. >..OM .. 


.. ..
 T..^ .. ! 5.. .. _ .. ..=8
U ..
I> fN-)!   4 .


8UN <Ni $  5CM
8 UW
 .

 X :

 . 
8.UN . .-. = . 5..
8_.   . >-f.  . = . i ..$8
 =8
U?

 8  5 `N ? 5.
. T3 .  .   .?  ..8
 !i
>H
PH .

-f  {Uf } ^-M -   6 ?


z )  UW -8-
< .


8UN T  
 _i : k8
> 5 o
; kUN -   i $  UWH ! / f
 _i .

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

67

-8-MN)
  4<  ]  UW
 _i . - =NOf 8 
8
i  <N fN  5CM
 _i .* (*  )C! &8 :(
 ^
 8& 8
  I4
 >(  ! ) 8  :.c 2005  .
  >   M )C U .
_ P  > k  M) x. . .M -._ . )! .
f.  . ) . -. ].N
  > k  M   5 - x8  O
3 Cf _ .   b
4 (  :
=N<:

-.. .. :..cN   .. > .. .. M  )..C ..U   ...8 _ ..M ..!N
  > .

  <N -  UW 8 M )   >  4W O Z ) .

    cN  -  8


W > .

 O 8 c )  H   8 M =c ) U  > .


S :

 5 UWH 2003(  . 2004

  > .

  M  )C U .

( ! :

= 5. V3

  cN -  )  _ 8  > .

(sc7:

68

   
 OOf _   b  5 =- .

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 - -M  5  5c 
f .

- 8 c MH UWH   :cN <N .

 X :

 uOfNH 
/   >
8UN
.W  . -. ! ..
< -/  5 !8 N  MN H( .

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

69

 C ( = SE :
>E
N -....H  
..)
> ..f  ..a .. ..   ]..  o.. ..M  < .. .. . 
8-..=N
Ci -   - =
H 6P =
. = . .8 .  .a 
. Z. .8  5. -.
   - N X8
4 H. a
-=N  .  .) 8.C .M 
.8   .  . -.  5. .
.c  .WN
  5 586 .N  . M .  o.$ .C 6z.  x.. M .  .N

- ]cN  ? F:  x. I. . .
.PH -.=c  5>. 5. (./H 5.4

=N  xH  ) M=


.
. N ..4_ 5.. -..8- -. 
8..UN .... {.UP :..cN <.. ..H  
..UP" ..a
!-..8-  ..! _ (.. ..U..48 -.. -.. F:..-.. c..ON  ..8 M ..cf o:.. ..! ..V../
 ?
.^ .  . .! H  . 
 . ].`P -.:.
a 
 H  

> f  a
 a 
 
c >   o  cN   : .  k.N 1975 
3 . ) ..H
 
.
> f  a
 5 -8  ) :  a ] ) O=
H  " <C 5  . . ( .
    
" C3 ) o OcH .
 ! ( 
>1
 : 6
  >
.  5.
.>H   . . . cN.  ( .6./ _ . . ;H.
 -
C8    H  

> .f  .a .! _ . .U
.>" 5.4 8  .
k=MN
8UN k8
> 5 o {UP :cN 
N ) ai  8
8UN 8-N 8
W /
4_H ; 
PH  8 MH  

> f  a  ) . ]  kM   8 -< . ( 4
>1
  2010 64 
 6Q: 6
4  () ! 1 :  F>. ) 
1  C
C4 :
* 1-2  cM  -N xcP  N H  5    cO f .
* Z 5CMN 2-2H  

> f  a VO8 5 -8H !- 54

  8 M H  . !` Z 5CM8

70

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

ra >1  * 4 8 C ( = ( D ^A


1 .  ! :
.. .. cN 5.. .. ..4M ` .. -.. -..8-!N .. - ..) ..M ..  ..N 
..8
=   - M  - .  V/ . . _ I.W Z.  . 5. -.8-.H  .  
.a
 ?
> f
 c]  <N _ o
H 
   M( KW  cN  . -.) .
H  
)
> f  a C )    W - KW <.;N . ) . .M 
.!8 M .8
-..8- .!c b..  . ..C..! I..UN <..;N .. ) ..M ..  ..N 
N ..8 . ..!H .
N -M 
z)  bz/ -  cN - ) H  

.
> .f  a :.  .
-.. .. .. MN .. cN .. - ..) ....H  
-..-
> ..f  ..a  ..= -..cf ?
..
0005 30  5M )? ..H  .M
.) . .! .OM .   (Z> . .N )?.
WH   -  (cc M  8
 : oN
8 <  cN  _ 5 -H  =N  cN

Uf !8 M=
.
 <a : 11G >1 * 4 8 C ( = ( !& .( -^A
1!    3 : V . 1973
1! !Q . 1975 8 1 :
)4 ^C (a ) ) :.169 ( 2006
 C8
^C (: (ahttp//www.cites.org/eng/disc/parties. :
( V'<  http//www/cites.org/ : 6

C4 mC :
a - -8-!N - )  M  N 

=6 8 .
=)  : H.

O=N  cN - ) H  

 .
> .f  a . . - .) ..H
 

> f  a Z8
N <8 -   I x. ]. ) !K  cN ?. =-. .( .
  Z  !) :PpN  5  5 

> f  a <8 ! 
-M - .
 - 
  ) H  Dc =8
U  !
UCN N
P 6.P 5  .

  c-M  P-
PH .
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

71

!(c >1 C (  D.  ! :

N F:
N  cN   cN  `8    b 1979-!N ( _ 8H  !

8
 8
M-  8
 {P >. ! N 5
 N
>H  W )(  / 8 _
)N   cN  ;< H  !
.  

> .f  .a

 cN   -
>H H -M
. .M N . . .8 _ U.W  I.F:.
 <..N . cN
. 
.W .. .. cN  ..8 M . .M -..) .U  ..8
M . =cZ_6..C

8 8
M z )H  )
-8  5U Uz8 . H 5.
. F:..8 _ . cN
U  3 !

)H8 5  235 -8U.
= - =
H  -  N 4M ]  
C3 / P-f
.Y -.C
  )=- > 5 ] UWH` ? 8 -O
Y=  ) M 
. 8
 <a : 12G >1 ( !& .
1!  . 19798 23 : V
1! !Q . 1983
 ) 1 :
)4 ^C (a . 101 ( 2007
8 8 ) ) :
^C (: (a :
http//www.cms int/eng/about/partlsthtm.
( V'<  http//www/cms.int/ : 6

C4 mC:
  >
8  :

]  ] 5 -MH  !
.

 5 -M M `
 .> 5 ]. .P . .8
Y .P U.WH;
.
.PH
 N - !
-N ] PH  !
.

P- )  cN  .Of =.C . !


. -.M   .  5..H .
! U 5 `8>
k8
8
W ]`fN k>  !N >
5
P
>H .

=)  : H.

 ?
 100 5  5H  !
 
a  )
> f  5 1 kM. cN


>H ! D8
4N  5  :

72

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 cM  _ > 5  ?_ -  8-. o  - .6i . .!-.8- =
.
]  /  
^K.   U.W" .C  k.3.N . ]. N!
.(  -MH ! . ! x8
 ].. x..cP
U..C  .. ..
..N .. ..H 
> ..f  5.. .. M.- )
> f  !a
N

].. N .. cN ..cM  ....H  !


.. ]....H   ..  kM  . (1) <..  5.. ..

YH   5CMN6C = . .H  -. . .M -f. =-.  5. .


  W;

Y . 8

  !a  :&Q:



N= 5  cN -   C
a-=) ]  8 H = -. b.P .4M ).
- -8- 8
WN -M  8 MH  

> .f  .a .  5 .`N . F:.=. . 5 -.8-M
.H  

> ..f  ..a i .UUP ..!N ..! _ (.. 5.. .. M .. _ ..4 ) .. 8
..W ..

PH < 54N 8
WN -M .Of .H  
. I.8 o:.
> .f  .a
. 5
 5 yM  C  =  8 MH  

$  =8
U
> f  a
$ 
Y .
)   k8 ) H  
.48 -.
> f  a  . 8
.WN .-.M V3   (.cN F .
_ IC  cN-  ) H  
.
> f  a
: u
 -M ]8
WN  8 MH  

> f  a <;N )! ) 5  M 

 -M T ) :  a .
x - N
 T
N  - CN ] 6M a H  

> .f  a ! -.8-K. ) -.
{UP _ H xcP I8  !-.8-  p8 . .= -. .H  -. . .M ) .
.8
  - . 8U
=N -  4M
 :c `8 i T P H  
5 -8-! a M ( >!
/H:  Y

a OM   )  5  ) .
 <-. .8 .!N(.
_ !  U a 
.
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

73

^C (
 :
  48 i   8! -3 ) _ 8H  

> f  a! -8-)(.
 x-
.PH I.N
.P ? .  -8 .O .H   . .C3 b.
- _- >
  cN-  ) H  
5. )
> .f  .a . M .4N i
   c  c4-M    z 
W ) . o
4N o:    /H  - NM 
8  M  N>
.  .) .
  fN =
) H  k8  

> .f  .a I.8 .  ]. (.  ..) ./ P
   cM P  >" 5  
.
> f  a
=)  : H.
   b4M :
*  -8-MH  
()
> f  a-
*  !N 8
WN :c  !N =  H  

> f  a
* 
 N H  

> f  a
*  M 
Y=  M 
8 M  N
*  kU  cN - ?   cN-  ) H  
.
> f  a
*
 ]`N T _ > 5  "  
-M   {UP ]
> f  a ]a
 :c
*  8 _ k>  -8-MH  

> f  aH  !

* 
 .. -..O
..z= ( ..:.. 5..4 8 ..)
^p..8..H  

> ..f  ..a ..H
 !

& ( c  :
kN   M?6      cN-  ) .H  

> .f  .a .
) H {UP :cN _ H  
.
> f  a
*  8  )C
 * 8  .  !  4!4.1& 42 G( V.  .

74

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 !  )  
 H   .
 2003 -. .  . . H .
 ..) ..- ..=  .. _ .. .. ..;) M   !..`8cN_ ..= .. ..N )..
M 
8   <  -M  -O< ] M .M

4 (  :

<=N    cN  M 
.8

MN=
 -.O u.O_ V. .!   <.8 _ .cM u.OM .  .M-f.
 M 
PH .


S :
UWH(  H    2002 .2003
( !:

- > .

= 5.V3

(sc7:

-.. 5..48 <. .. H  .8 M ..Cp .. ..  .. . .. ..;) M KN -..-f..
 -C M 
. 8

:6
< <8  =  4  M 
8    ( ? )
  5..- ..   .. !..a
c8 ..= ..
-f..   .. - .. 3 ..O_i  -.. i 6z   . U
-   M( <=N
^K 6z ( uP
N M 
.8 <N U
f x8cN   5M 
5. 8 . M  .  .U^.)
.N ;  : 8 M ] 8=  .
-... ... i ...UP ...H = 6z...6 ... 5 ...`N
...  ...8 M 
)...  ... ... -... N (... ...   5...4 8 y...M ...-f...! ...K 
..." T
-f  -C" .

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

75

 X :

-  V 6z. -.8- x8.cN .H _-.MN . . H  . .


. 5. M.a
6P  cO V3-M -C pN --f  = " =   - M .

 .. ]..a; ..? ..8 M .. 36


.... M .. 
6.. -..N ..? ..8 ) ..<..^
..H
> !> ) !6. (/H

]a .  k.UN  ]. .M . ; .    .H . 8  .M  ; .


i 4M  M 
8 > 5 ] /H  f     U M 
.8

 ) $  .

KN -
$i  
 UWH - 
 :cN 3 O_i .

-  <3."  .  

> .f  .a!-.8-  .) - .C . ].a -..V3
 cM   > 5" /H     = .  3

* !'  )C ( 4. <!C


  !(c C ( = ( ^A zSE:c
 I4 :c
]    8  -M D. P 2005-2002 . 5. . .48
H
  ... 
 ...8 M k...N ......H  
.
> ...f  ...a ...  b...OM) -...

 
 T_ -f     W ci .

) 5 5^ uf 8 F:


 :
-&  *1. ( ^! C( u  S) c &>. .X  .

4 (  :
<=N D.H 
.= . 
.C3 = cM.C  . . )
8-.=N -
. i  <.N . fN .
 cM   cMC Z -8-MN-H -8-MN Z 4 8
 _ O _i.

76

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

1 NN Nm - NN NN+(NN&C NN. ! NNNNC (NNcK NN22A NN C ) NNNN C
C! 25 < .1 D  6 G54 5 @2A1C .
4 (  :
<=N = c  OOf   i _ . .H . .-P .H  .M 
]. .8
..! N i ..Of  ..8  .. _ .. ..H  ..
 ..)
^p..N ..u..Of ..!N
H F N _ H .

S 
) 4( 
) 4(

  -c   !8-      I H  


.
> f  a

MH  
Y-c .

( ! 
) 4 ( 
) 4 (

= 5 V3-c.


   -c .


f .

(sc7 
) 4 ( 
) 4 (

bN  -c ) ;<  M = 5 V3-c   :c H  


a
 .
> f

   Of c )   x


. T

 )=  VaN x :cN c


. T

-&  *1. ( ^! C( u  S) c &>. .X  .
 X :

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

77

]..a :..cN
..
.. {
.. =..  ..?M N H  T3 ....M  .. <..=N..8
 Uf _  cM
M/   - -MN <=N - P f .8  / f
  
  8U-"  H.
1  m -  +(&C . ! C (cK 22A  C ) N C C!N
25 < .1 D  6 G54 5 @2A1C .
 X :
= <..-..  ..  b....H H ..8=..O ..=N..H ..i _ ..!36.. F:..
    " ` -f  H  M 
8    _ i _i -f.
. ?H
* 4
 8  )C
'  ^
 ( j' >14  * 8 C ( = (^A

 )
z-. . 
 .  .
 1999  k.UN .  .
>   I  cN-  ) H  
.
> f  a
4 ( 
k-...N U...W . .! H i ...8 ...8-  ... ; ...
...PH ) ? ...Cp ... ... H
 Cp
Y (4M -!N  8 MM _ / P   _ .  6./ -.

 b8     . 2002

S :
..CN^  .. !  ..WN ..  ..c ..8
U> ..  ..c ..8
U-M ..8I..N 4
 .

( ! :

78

  cN-  ) H  


.
> f  a
     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

= 5 V3> .

(sc7 :

< -ON   = :c V3 _ 8M  . 1997:. .c8  .   I.


  cN-  ) H  
.
> f  a

-/   M8
ON 488 1998)  ZOH 
 1999 M . 
.8
  I  cN-  ) H  

> .f  a -.)` b.-./ -. M8
.ON
 M -/ <N  5
 C < 5 54 8^ -O .

-/ 
>H 6.P 58
U F:.
.c   I. U.C . .!M 8 .= . 
.U-
-  5  cN-  ) H  
.ON -
> f  a
. V8000_ 10 .
5. . .  6

<N V8
ON 309 ! 8-/ )  ZOH  548 < ! ; 1999 
 -8-MN MC  kUN 5 -  cN-  ) H  
.
> f  a

 IN 4 b M  _ 62 . <.N


. ! .4_H .  . cN- . . ).
H  
_360ufN ! 12)
> f  a _ 6 ? N(.

- 6 N   M .cH6.M  ].M .  .C !.$ . 3 V.aN


 KW M/M < 548 )
U uM Uz8M .

< -=N  =



8C "      cN6-  ) .H  

> .f  .a
 5 :cN c  - !N   I  cN-  ) H  
.
> f  a

er1(  (
<() 8 Q (   :

bM/ M36 .= 8:c _ .8M .  . . 1997 8 .c  . 2002pN .-.
_ 4   cN-  ) H  

> f  a -= CN <;N - ).
 M  -    I  cN-  ) H  
.
> f  a

>= b _  6i 6    V3   5   . cN- . . )(.
H  
.
> f  a

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

79

b/N -P   c 8


U-M -=  cN 8 ) M .

86P 5 F:-N <N  cN c I8 .  .c_ .4  . cN- . . ).
H  
.
> f  a

)
/N 
  5 1999-  - c
U  .N   . 6.M
 )  NM . cH

 ..=N <8-..=N <..8 <..6..P


8 )
.. 
 ..  5.. M..W    .._ 5 ..`N .. .. ! ..WN
  cN-  ) M  

> f  a( - .


-/  O V8
. .8
U M . 
.O .8  .ON 5. =.C V8. cN
- .. .. ) ....H  
)
> ..f  ..a <..N .. ..O)i !
 (..) ..  .. .. (1999
-8-MN 6  8 _ 5 -M .  .C   I. . cN- . .
  MC
) H  
H
> f  a F: O  V8 5 `N  b H "  4 .

80

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 C E4
>E

NH  8
z  P--=c C3  ._ ( .  < . -. b.P 8.C

) cN 6./  _ .C .  5. -.8.H  .8
z .P--.8-!N 4.WN . 
.8
;  

M .
<; ONH  8
z P- >! -8- 6P 5 ] N>6  .  .O 5.
 5cC]  ) o )`6 
N_H 
.N 3_-.  .O ! ." .  .8
z .P-
!  ;    5  O.

 4WH  8
z  )
ON IUN    4W P-  8C  - b.a
-8- ;   ] 
  4W-f <=N _  p
> f  z  Z 4  .O8
 4] F:-N  ;H
^KNH  .8
z
.  .P- .) .!P  . _ 5. -.8  .
   ] 5 !P- .8 54 8 48 ! F:H  z 8
^KN P- 
$   c4 O
  
 ) ! H  
  .
 - V/:  a 
 5 -8   5 F:=` ]   a     OcH :
=
H .
 ^ M .

z )  Z3.
H  8
z. P-
 ! ( 
>1
 
  >
 5
>H    . ]. . cN .P 
 .  .O .H .8
z
 P- -!N ; !  > 5 ] H /H
>H  C 5 `8K-
 5 UWH )(  .U !N 8
.WN 
!
.a I.CN  .  .) .
.P) ]..
< kM   8 3< . (4

>1
  20104  D
 
4  :6 G 4!41  C [! E4
C4
* C 1-6 "  8
z P-  H bMN 4

* 2-6 {UP ]a" 8  8
z  H -!N  ;H > 5 ]
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     
H .

81

 - ]`N 4M 
N )   xcf W
^KNH  8
z .P-  8-.M
N (.. .. .. 8-..MN .. 
..c :.. ) .. ..M I..8 ..4N 
..c  -..
.. " ^= ..  ..
i $ ]  " 8 W ^ ZcfN H  8
z-.!N .  <;. .  .> 5 .H )  .
 cN  (  x ( 2002    .UN - .4M .$ M.a 5. .
H-  54 8 ! 5CN .! H  .  .) . 
 . 
 .
.  . N 5 .! .

 6   = U
   
   c 

PH .
' >14   2 & j  51 8 D>Q.


Np: =
) ) - 2004
8  cN- 
    .O 
 I..
!=N ) 5cC M  ] ^ 
-.  -._ . M^! k.8
> 5. - .  -. -.8
M .P .
P  ] D) N M 
8 . .U .N  .
.Y . cN 8 .c  ].  ) o.-. .!3
-f..CN  .. -.. i  ..3 4  ..P- .. 5.. ..N  ..O 
 I.. 5..4 8 ..-f..
Uf i $ 8 -O   .
 <a :13 G' >14  )  2 ( !& .
1!  
) 13 : V2004
8
1! !Q - ! 8
 <8 < :
)4 ^C (a ) ) :6 ( 2006 DUCY
< (  http/www.imo.org:
) ;
(   <^ 8
M   O ( 
  T   i   O htt /glaball sat

C4 mC:
] =N 8MN 5 3 ! -M .3 4  .8
M` .  .3 4 

 k.8
> 5. .`8.

 I  ufN  5 5cC  O .
=)  H.
I.UN .. cN ..=N  ].i .UP :..c 5c..C  ..  ..O 
 I. .. I..8F:..
 5cC    MN  O =N 
i   / f  O >=   . 5

82

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

' >14  !(.


1
<N
  cN-  8 M N )  . . ; k.8
> 5. 1951 .8:YH  . .
! <H -M  :P   !=N
MN ] -.   ]. .P  .W  . .N ].
 ...N ...fN
...   ... 36 ... <...N -...
... ... cN ) ...fC  ...- ( ) ... ... 1997
)(https//www.ippc.int/ipp/cn/defaultjsp
  !a 5  D&Q
   x b-  ]a>   ]8
W  $=(  -( ; .  <. .P
H  .P- o:. .!N
U.C ! . 5 .`N -. F:. 8
.W  . U  5. .cfU.WH
)   ? :   8:YH=   O ( .
 
 5 =8  ;_6: (N
 5
N   C ( 54 8-f! 
UC  H  8
z. P-
I> f8 ]8
WNi P   -
Y  " - . P-
  cN  5 <N ;   i .Uf  :.fN . x.cP .) - .CN .8
 5i P
Y  " - . P-
: u
 -..8 -..
.. 
..H .. k..N T -.. ..) ..P-  5..i ..  .. ..=N ..
.  5. .C=` 8 .
.
8.U . ].  T .P .H  .8
z i .!N
U.C .
H  8
z P- 4N -  - bP6  . c

 :cN <8  3  N T6 M = .- ]. .8 .W ." -. 


.z  . .P--.

=N F:
  T
> f 5 -M TH  P- <86P 5 ! P ` ]3 .8 .
   / f  O  I3 =M OfW
3 U . 5cC
 b  - 4M 
. k.U .?M T  .8
8UN ! .? . F:. .W -.MN -. F:.
.T

U 
C3( P-. V CN .H  . . .P- ? . ) .  .U -._ ( .

 54 8 
U i H . P-
^C (
 :

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

83

 ) .ai ..
..>H   ..) 58i ..  5.. ..C .. 5..4 8 (-8 ..O
..$
  8:YH=
_  ..W>  .  . ) . .H .8
z
H P- >
=8 P F:H  5 ZfN P-
PH o:
>H   ! F:=`.
=)  :H.
 =N -: NK8  4M
:cN 8
W   C  =  H . P-

-8-MNH  P-
) C3- .

<8-=N    _ C / f H - P-


PH .
fN UP )
8 N 
> f xcf  36 a H  P-. 8
z

MH      .

W?= ) 8   = . C
Y UWK
:cN 
  -M
M D8 = ]a MO` ! .
<=N

Y UWH
W 
WNH . P-

 cN -M ] -   .
:..cN
..  5.. -..M..H  ..8
z6..P 5.. ..P-   .. 
 .. ....3 4
  6P 5  >.5

 :cN T i ) W4 F:H 
 .) .P-_! .H . ].a
. 5. -.M
 W .

.. 
 ..
U..C ..4M  ....H  ..P- ..8
z..a .. ..8 z ]..C
   48 -  5
  4M   _ {=) -  U _ .U .? UW" -   . . z
. 5MW
& ( c  -:
) (8 =N 5  H  P-] )
H .
*  )C<
4 : C  8 E4
4
) .. .. .. 2004  I..4
].. .. -..4 
 .. .. ..8-4 -8 ..O
 .UM  3 .=-.4 ..  . -..8-M o.  b. ..4M-c-.. .

84

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

  :.c <36 M  b  I.   .!N . cN-. . ( .

i N 8-4  ( ) uf8H . P-

4 (  :
.. -..8-MN  b.. ..4M-c -.. .. 4..W  <..36 4..W b ....H ]..N :.. ..P-  cN  / f  ( .?-.8-MN
.  :. Y .O!
.} .3 N. .8-4
 ( .
  ) k=M  b   !8- 8-4   3 -: (8  )
  ! MN  H  4WN! -8-H
.
  
U 
C3  5  M . !6P 5 ON
  5:  :f
  ! ? F:
> f
C3 - )  F:
i.
  5.. k..=M ..c  ..4M-c.." ..  ..P- ..
.. ..ON ..  ..O

   " b. . -8 .O .UM  . b.O_ -. ".8-4  .
 H .MN !  . ! .6P-.  .  b. . 3 .= .5 .`N .8-4
 8
WN   36

 =U  W< )   F. 8-4

S :

  . 8-4


  -8 O UM . 8-4
  3= . 8-4
 cN  ( .

i N 8-4  ( .

( ! :

(sc7:

 x8ci  W8 `8c  8


W =  H . P-
 cN  ( .

i N 8-4  ( .

 
5 <Y   4M :PKN < !) 8-4 ) _ F: , 4W.
.W -
 5 )=   cN6
i 8  N - H  ) P-- 
C )  . -8
 - 8 )-
N "O  " <! -_H D H UCK  4 5. - .fN
:..
.. i  ..  -..8-MN <..8 <.. ..C H ..a   ]..i -c..
 . OOf
< <=N 4M-c   -8-MH  ]a! -8-< -8-M <=N
U 5.4 8 .
! F:H 6 !6P 5 ON ! < - <=N ]UCN U ) :cN  . !N
 X :
 + +<
: !4
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

85

. 36 . .  UP ]a;


 <. . -. = . . ) .  
8
. i .
-a b NH . P-
  !-  =  i -c   )  !i . Uf  / f
 +& :
5<
: !4
 W   
    / f  O ] _
C_   8  -M .

i  :c 8
W  =C
O / f  F O .
 +( 4!2(S. <
: !4

8..UN :..cN
.. i  -..8-M <..=N
> ..f
H .. ..UN  ..3 ..P--..8-MN
H 8 H-  F:! / f .
> f
  )  F:
i - 
8
=N 
 .
* <((  )C( 4. !(c:((< ( 4.  D 8 
1
) .. .. .. 2003  I..4
 .. ..4   >.. -..M :..c

  -3 ci  5 8 W H . P-
4 (  :
) uM 3  5  8:YHW 
c8  MN

> .f 5 8
.
)  .

S :

> f
C3 !) ICN
)  N .
6 i )   ] H .
  i  5 ZW4
H H !<  5 W .
( ! :

(sc7:

 ]8
W= .
 U ;      .
! N  MN H( . EC/29/2000
  cN-  8 M N  O   ;" 5 8:YH    "<  -M" .

K :
  bi - ) (C3_
< - - ) ] 
H ) .
  M  5 -8
  
> f
C3 . T3
- 6!   3  K 5 -  . !Wc

86

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

! I8
  C =-   `
6P 8 H = .
 X :


  
> f
C3 . T3
 ] kC  O;
. I H
K 5 -    . 5Wc
 C =-   6 .

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

87

^ D( T ?  :


: ) >E
  WN> 5  F  ) 
M !H 
-   F  F .) . ] . F .
 !4 . -. N !.C  
.`c .a  =.C ....!) ( X.  .O :.z . P-.
 ) .
.( .) ./ P  k> .
-.  .c8   .
).N F:. <;. . . . U
 6/    -8-  _ C  (3_ 
 I
/ ) .ai  8:z.
! >M 5  N .
;   f   : : =8   Y Ci O F
z 
  5?
;<
  !- .< F:!-8-  :

z .
)=- -N  >. 5

O .(MO
6z  .
3
 .
 W H  8
z. P-
4 5 %41 8  < ) 8 !H  5  N`: {z
N ?
5 %20 5
 10000  ) 8 o  F  )  < 
=6 !- 
)
Uf a= =
. 8
 ]OU  O  ]8
C 8   4.C .8MN .; .  F .  . .: .8
)=-   (  C C
Y . .  .  ._ -.8 . .;) M  .  5.4 8 .
)
  ( )   F- P =N
> f N . 5. -.8-.H _ ].`N  .-.3 c
 -f  . !-=N
 _   -8 
8.U M ; .  F .  .- . =  .P I.U
.C  F .  -.8
  .
V/
z  > 5 C
zN k)-N  ) F .-.C P .   5. (F .?
.!-.8-
 )    5C f
PH ;  . .f    F .  . I. . .   ) . F ..
 k8
> 5    O  U  M ) F
O( 
 I. (IOf
)( ] ?
 =N ! 
   
 N   F  .
 ! (  :
'>1 4 -. N  : N . cN  .8 M .OOf .  F .  .  . -. 5.
.
  cN  i !H  / f 
M  ! 
  
;N F:  cN -O
 
8
 .
]  .) o . cN.  .8 M ].
 -.N ( .  F .  . -.
Np. ].a
.>H  .

  P T    (   F-. P
>1
  2010 64 
 . 6
4NN  yNNN>E (5) GNN[NNp  4NN58 DNNN) NN* NNN (NNN^ NN[1 : D&7[ NNN C
41 '& 4A m(4 Q (. T
4 >) 4  y>E 1-5 QA  4 8(^ D.  S
88

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

  !a 5  D&Q :


8   Y P ]8
WN -   F  5 `N  3 F: 8
W   C
$  
] =` 8 / f    F 5 `N -
.$ .`8 F .  ./ P
.W _ .8  F .).
 IC?
-.  ) 5-f.C  . )  .O .M
.P( -f.CN . . Y  .4M
 F  ]   4 UH    _ _ 8  .F =
.$ 
.WN  - 5 .
  ( )   ?  ]8
W:  {M8   U 3 
!4  5 N . (-C

 54 8  uM) 5 P ]8
WN   5 8 _ .8.H . .  ? .
 .. ! .. 
  ..
 ..H  .. -8 ..O- ..) ..P  ]8
..W ..f   ..48 -.. -8 ..O -..O ..
  .
8
  UN   C   F    / f C >
=) 5 `N .8 M / P.H . Y
 48 - "  I 5 "=c ])-8  oN  C .
: u
_ y   .) o$ . 8
.WN   . ].8 -.=) F .   ./ P
. . 
.. T
   F  x F:
4N - T !   6  ( .
^C (
 :
IN   .  .U  8 .! .  . -.3 ) F .   u.f8 .  .o:.
i  5 C -8 O  8! . 54 8 48 !  . ! H  
  () :PH
 i  -f.CN (.  .  o.N .? .3    . . ) .ai  . U.
 4M  M( =N  :c  C    a C > ! ? -M  .3
 UC  48 - 3 ! Pa   `8 .
 . !p: H.
 =N -: NK8  4M
!N 8
WN :cN  !N =    F  .  T  ( )    F_ !H   {.UP= . U 
.UN  a .
]a;     F    M cM ! . N <;N   5 F=  U  . cf 
     . F F  8
cN <;N
O . MO ]  W H . 8
z ]WN-f   4  `cf Z 4  T 
4 i    . F _ <8-=N)  cM  -f  -C   (   F-. P
$i   -8 O- P  ;) M  . <!) 5CMN  (   F- P!-8-  ;  / f  .() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

89

  :cN -_   $ <=N 


^KN 5 . 
   (   F- P 5C8 -=
^=     
  ) 
 .=` 8 ..   ./ f
.P : F .! H
 
  
W <N )  2004 5 `N _ 
 .  . .U. ,( .
!H 
M    . F
 -  5 =
. <.`NH (.a
> . .:.  .  
. .=8 . . Y 5

   c _ 8 M <!N 4H (a
> )=   cN C 
N <N - : a Oc
.
& ( c  :
{N
N(   M  5 _ !H  -8 O  F. :
* (*  )C!  s 4!4*1 u  : fa ( ) s8. C
)   2004 ! . !  . 
 .H .8
 o.W .

  T_ ; . .!H :. -!.  . ; .  F .  . .
 k8
> 5 N_ H 5 U . UM: 
 T . . .
 ..  5..- .. ..
 T ..- ..cM ..  .. ..U ..H5
 U!  / f 8. oW

4 (  :
K IN 5 -    -   (  <; -8- !H .

S :
 . ! 
8-N   5    . =(    . ] 
 <; -8-N T !H bMN 8    .( ! :
= 5    kN - .  8 _ 5  > k.U 
-N 5_   . N   ; T 
 / f -8-N !H .   C - .  cN C )
$ 
Y =8
U( .(sc7:
 -. .!c .) .8 c  . K k.8 . ) . i 
  <.=N <.) .. ].a- -N 8 )
 D P - ! =N 54 8 8  =
) 
 . T
;< H   b)
/ - T 
 OOf 6/ 
M " P -.8-  F .-f6 

90

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

< -fCN   _i ( !  !-f^ fN k3 =


 4W  .  :..cN <.. U..W
..  ..U   5..  ..C
..   -..-.. ..c 4..W 
N:.. D48-f " ?H.
 X -:
 I8 8 )  
 
) . .! . .a  . 
.W 
 T . -.! .

W .
* Q   )C  :(Q  8 4!2 
) ... ... ... 2005  I...4
]... ... ...C 
 :...c  ...H
  .O-. -.8-M 4 .C ; ..  U.W -.O .Y > . .. C
  zW
^KN<  -  -8 O.

4 (  -:
 -8-MN  <C -8 O ] i  M 
8-M k3= ) 8- (DWNP  .() .4
 i zW _ 8  O: (8  -8-MN k8
> 5 4 C
 : = o 8 <C>   K  C- . Ma
<     {.UP ].a b. .8> .8 . H -f. 
. N  -8 .O
)
 8 M V3-f  -C   .
<
^KN -O c   f H .
    :cN <N -  c
. N
 : = - <C)    8 M N  3 -8-MN <N ) (.   .  .
)  )
(SADC) =8 
N  ) -8 O.(15 14 5N

 - 8  )  36 ] .

S :
)

   5 2001  . 2004  <C -8 O ] i  M 
8-M k3= ). (DWNP i M( .M/ _ _ $ ) - C  {WN UW . -8 O( ! :
  _ 8 H  1975C  V3 . -8 O  {Uf
i N <C= / f . -8 O  .M 
.8-.M k3= (DWNP) . i M( . (DAHP) M/

N      )  )
(SADC) =8 f   . -8 O(sc7:
< ]`8: = <C>    <8-=  C  ! `
 O 8. 4 C   V/ _ 8 H  y_ =   1975  . ]. . u8_ .? -.O  f . 4 C
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

91

-.. ..   .. )-..  ..   .. -.. 5.. ..H ) (-..O! -.. ..U  -..O=-..
) Uf  M (C -.8-  ) .  .) .C  .= -.O  <.4 -.O ( . i.
! F:. UWH
 a - N{     8 M H  .>.=8 . 5  <.C . -8 .O  .M 
.8
-M k3= <  O 58   <!WN I H-   . -.O F:.
  !O=8-   ! c8 O .
 cf =-   ) : = y_ <C 6 C 5 %70 :! 5 = <!.O=8 <.C-.I8
    -O
 (  
5 <Y   - <! -8- <  <!Cc. N
= ..
8 8..C-..O8 .. = ..   ..6 ..! <..C !:..N <.. ..

.. ..8 _ T ..H
]WN-f  -C    b==_ - T3
 .

 X :
<C  I8  -8 O  M 
8-M k3> =8  -: 8
 ;
)   _ 8 H .  ..4  .... 5..CM T   .. ) .. .. ? .. : ..8  (u..Mc ..OM ..U ..  5 =C -O <;N! 5CMN
 T  .
K ..MN 5.. -..  ..  .f  ../ f ..H -../ = ..
8 =V..  
..C o:.. ..:f =
>6 c    . =-

MH 
^K.N -8-M I .-. -. -.O -f. o.$ . .) .z ? . :-.O 6C  fc(
^KN  
)!  ) C -.  -O -. -.O ) .
  ) Uf  _  - C .o C F:  )( 8C <=N  M.
]a
.8 M  .$ N .> . 5 {.UP <.`N . ; )  . ]. .H  ^. H .
K 5 -   c4 b N - uMc )  K = != U 5 - _ 8 H . K 5 -6 =p 5c  <CH 5  !<  . ! 5c4 K 5 - =N
8  <.C -8 .O .f   .M 
.8-.M k3> <.`N . . :.= 8 _ ) <C H  > 5K 5. -.6. 
 . -f.  I.W  -.C  .
. 4 C

92

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

C= 6^ :
: >E
H (..a
> .. _ ..C .. ..48 )! .. .. ..  .. (.. H ..
U..C ..  ..M
 NM 
! UN: -M8 48 - C   =
 5  VU.C D6H
 UzN <8 -H    F`
N . MH (a
>  5_ -  ;H <-  H M .
H _ y! 4 5 UzN 5 %64.I

NH (a
> >-8-$ 5 H .H . ?
.  5.M .  .N I.N .
 ) V$
N
)N  F . .;) M
./:z .3
 I.-._ ].a .W> Z.cfN
_-   `c
.NH (.a
> 5. .?
. . ;H . .) . < . 5. .f <.  .
  oN ? N )
)( H.
..= -.. 8 H (..a
> .. .. ..! ..;) M  ../ ..!c3 5.. ... _ .. ..f8 b..
H (a
> !-   8- 
.O  M.O6.O H (.a. -f.  ).C
?   U 
 .
)( ]
NH (a
>  5  a    =N ! H  
  
! .
 ! (  :
>1Q = 6^ :
.. cNH (..a
> ..  .. ....  ..C  ../ P>..> 5  .. ) .. cN ..C
" a
>( ( < "  cN a
>    cN_- ( -=N _ -.M 8  5>.
> ] )
<; o N . -8- .a> . 153 b.  -. . ] . . . cN .C -.8-MN <.N
]  C ) ]  C - _  1630  <( .
p..N -..   .. )= F:..! .. .. cN
.. .. ../ P T   .. ..4N -.. -..O H-..


8  . V. N F:. . cN- .> .  . " . > . . -.  . .;) M
-f.. " ..?H ..a
> ..:... ..  -..= .. 
 ..H (..a
>-..8 .. .. Y ..

   cN C .
4N -  cN  ( -O  
8- 
 .) V.`8 .  .f   k> .
  I8 .  M- DKN  ;) M  > k !)   MH (a
>.
 <a (1~ 14 GQ = ^ :  !& .( 8
1!  
) 2 : V. 1971
8
1! !Q 21 :. 1975
 C8
)4 ^C (a 21 ) :. 153 : 2006
 C8
^C (: (a :
http//www. Ramsar. org/key. Cp.e.htm
( V'<   http/www. Ramsar.org/ :

mC C4 :

i >  -   ;) MH (a


>  .
=)  Q> &7:
<`N  cN     ! b=cN
>H   :
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

93

.1( V(4 ) : (:5


 H  U uOfN > _-  <.` H . 3  .H (.a
> .
H  - )  3 C(  .!8 _ ].W o . 5.4-f.   .?H I.8 . . <.8
..P  ..UH 
> .. .. .. ! .. .. ..M  ..N <....M  <..  F .. ..
 ..3  b..N -..
..>H  ..W  ..  5....UP ..$ ..? -..8-M 8 F:.. ) ]..;
..
  
 / f C  < . (4
  2006
 ) 5 V/  5 ] 1630]  C  -M " .a
>.
 ( O8  145.6 4 ) ]  M  <.
 bN -!c  cN ] 
H  Z8 (a
>  : (N
" ! _ ...C ..  =..C 
... H (..a ..!fN ... .. F ... > ..
o
6
=8
U  /  3  p  b   ^ F  =)-  :    M
  M _ C  WN  5  F(  -8  =! ]  -   xcf ".
6.  . .) o. H (.a
> . . 3  .)  .W .C "  c.a 5 .`N -. .!H  k> .
 _ ..C  " .. P (..a
> .. .   F .. ..8
M..48 ..  =! ..? 6 5..
.. ..  -.. -..
 ."xcf
  I D P  N <N  cN   " a
> :
) !.H (a
>  _ C  WN
M ` MW>  8
fO


M 
( .
 j2 C )  WN - > k -  =C( .
. )H (a
> 

M  UN( .

! )H (a
> ]   5 !H -(.

^4  I E ) =C H (a ^ (.
'& 4A : FC
.2
)= F:..! .. .. I..8 .. ) .. cN
..>H  ..W ..) :..PKN ..  .. ..;) MH(..a

> -.. ..-f.. {..Uf H (..a> <!.. I..8 o:.. .. .." ]..WN 5..4-f.. ..?H
" a
> ) 6<" ). 5 1-3( cN
 -
Np -
>H  W Uf i $ 5 8" k=MN c-f ".?H:. <.N -.
F
CcN -f  "-f6  -C" ).;
  C  < .( 7
'^ c  4!: j
.3
b=cN
>H  W   W _ > > ) H (a
> _  " C (a.
  3  ! WN C   ]WN- yM C  I8i
$i .
.4  4 :
b=cN
>H  .W  . .W >
.
.P  .W  . k.UN .c F:../ P . cN
H (a
>  
-M ;<   F .
.W .H 
.W ); .
.  .C
 < . (13

C  
Np
>H  W 
Cc VaNH]    H ..a
UP $- C  8 ) :cN , F:Uf i $
W <N - 8 )  C . .C );
.
  C Mc/< . (16

94

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

)4  5! b  :
>H  W  6i  5=-  : ) k.UN . F:.  . )= .
 .. cN6 ..=N <8-..=N k..8
> 5.. o..
8>
Np..  ..
..>H  ..W 6..^ .. .. -..
bM/ F:=
8>  56C   .
  !a 5) 4&Q :
48  - - P ]8
WN  H (a
>   <!8-
?4 8
.W  . MN . .M 
.8
 > 5 ! / f UzN <8   YH (a
> bMN:   5 ]8
W:.   . .
M8  O W / P  > 8 M OOf k M 
. 8
  ] N F: 8
W ? UWH -O
-./ o .C U.WH
.PH p.N -. .
F: >  CN   Y . 5 F:  > k   M>U 5  8
M H (a
>  -
 .U .C ./ P.U  !
.  -.8-MN <.N <.^ 5. 5. -.8-H (.a
> .  k> . ..
U ). (IBA
 b  - 5 -8--  . .;) M  .  ]aH (.a
> . .I. U 5. I.U .
.  cN
: u
..=N -.. i .. 
..
8..U ..  :..c ../ P T  ..8 M_ .. ..a 6z..
 -C " (a
> x. .) . ._H .4N 
." .OOf
.Y T (.a
> .5.4
 U !8- ] ?  cM   >. 5
^C (
 :
4N   Y   8!  x. ) C-. .4N -.  .  .U
 ..U-..M k3   .. .. 5.. <Y
....4N -.. o..  ..
..P ..8 _ 5.. ..C
H (..a
> .. ..
]..  V..a8 ..i  ..C ..  b. .. -..M
. Ma
)(  x _H 4N  x. .Cp  ; .  .? .4_
.z-.O -.(  < . .M

8 _ U   -O   U  / f  M 
.8>5. .C .
_ 8H (a
>  .N - 5. .i .  ]. F:. ; . :. . )  5. . !<.

 F: ; ) 
_ H  5
  ` <!cH (a
> ) - .
=)  :H.
 N   cN  4M C
   b -8-M 4M  5H (a
> 
$ ! kUN  cN C
 - - 8  4M
N >     C>  8 MH (a
>
 - - 8  4M        P H (a
>  !8 _ I8
 bai {UP 4M _ < H (a
>  !=UN <N
  < -   ;) MH (a
> H ) 8-
..=N ..  ..= ..4M UN ..) .. .. ..;) MH (..a
> .. -f..CN ..  ..4M

$p
 =N - 4M =N 
 ! 8-=
8 )  8( ^< ])
N    cN C

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

95

& ( c  :


   M   _ 5 
  UN
N   cN C.
C    <  D
( Q(* IS1 : >1Q ) . &4 . 18
)  b  2003   4M 5
  C 8 I4
.
-  
 :.c
.  .H  -f. =.C . -.8 M .

M - ) . cN .=> .N .C . ].=N
.M -._ .
 C 
. -.8
) ] .> . <.i 5.?
.  ].
.3 =.
 U )  : ?  5 - N  4 _ 8]. .U
  .  i
4 (  :

 8 c)    8-  
 T
i  !UUfN <N:cN .  5 ZW4  -f  / f  O }< . 
_ ! F:  . <=N  5-. 5
S :

c  M
  1979 5 . 2003  =8-M> - .  4M  M
W -_H )  
M / f - ). N UWH :c   5   -c   z    . F   5  5 C 
)  =8-M> .( ! :
'NN>1 4 : NN  .. M ..=U)= 6 .. ..  .. cN  ../ f - .. .. 5.. ..
- 5  <! 5 . cN .C " (.a
> .
Np..  ( . .! N  .MN
H(  8 MU  >. 5
= 5=
> .
(sc7:

<N)    - >=   cN C    ;) M> 5  . F


 N   5 ;  5 4 4M 
 . C
 5CMN   O F 
 5KN> 5  M F M  .- 4W N
6z 
M  I 4 k=M O - 8^ .
.  . . .U .W ].
= kP - IO .N ./H
.
.M  ) .ai .
.O  5. . .
 -O -/ H ._ C
 b`cf  f = I 5 IO
M )  
.

 X :

96

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 )  MN - 5  N . - .-.fN . .O )` . V .O


  . =U
-8-MN k^N  > - k -8-MN  > k  8 M    > kH (.a
.;M8 .
)! . -O
 C  <!c )
8U  W. <i
 -/ ) k-U  ) 3  > k
  M C .
IN-f 
M
YH  O.8

* Q!Q  )C IS1 : >1Q . GK  . 9  Q


) .. .. .. 2004 ! ..
..C8C .. 
 ..H k..UN u..Mc
  >= ! F: )  cN <i
M {M . D C
4 (  :
) uM =U   cN  / f C " a
> .  -8-MN   _ b  M  ) U< 
M  ] ($ N D C  . cN( ^A + Q:  G1 : 
 I5.
 cf CP H . -f
Y -C   . N ;  .
S :
< ) 
C8 )
M   (D C-M  5   6^) C _ ( .  5 kC UC -c  UC .  i  5 kCi -c .( ! :
 cN C " a
> . =  
C8C = 5 8
W  8 ). (< H(sc7:
    8M T-  8
C8C  cN C )  5 . ! / f
- :cN 8
W )   ] ) : 8_- ! b   5
?4 O:
-   8  ] )  > k :c (M 8
W . -   8  ]  :.c  .U  = .6  . 
.WN -. . . .  M > .
 I8 8 -=N >.OM I.  .
.$i  .U  . M:. <.  )- .
 / )  5 6 Cp  i-c .
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

97

  W kC  / P P  -c !  5 Cp .  i


 X :
]a
N> " a
> . 8
8UN ON ] -   ) C  ( .
_ <a -M   C -N (C I8  M .U
8UN kC P   F- )  8
C8C C   :c.( cN  ]WN   M 6P 5 U 8 (   .   ! 5 -M - :cN )
PK.  cN ]WN ]   > k   =  -  Wi  cN   M > 
.-.M )(._  N -_-  .

98

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

(^ D !. :


D) >E(= :
UzN UM VU 5 %70H 4N   8
M.?)  k>  5 _ C
 k> .. . $  
..z .. 3 I..W
 .. ..W 
..M I.. MU  ..  ..UM
 _c   M  =(   - CN  ../ 5.
.?4  .M T.N . .M y.^ .8
M
 CH  5CH -=N -O ^ 
 5 5N ! 5 ZUN
z   . P

^KN UWH <;  8
W  8
M ! C=N 54 8 _ C D P   :
  3 4. IOf
 -8 O .8

zN      .

z )   > k. U
Y H . P-
=-N -  5
?4  > k .8
M _ .C . -.M:. . I.O8= ) .ai  ..
 ..cf  . f  (..) o ..C < .. 
..N ( ..  -../ k> .. ..H 
..Uf ..cP  .. . `8
6z  . 
3
.P ? . .$  
.z  I.W
 ..H 6z.6 ].`fN .
(
N  IW
 -  IC
- UWH 8
W
_ 
M .
6z 
3 < <;. -.8-!N .6.P .8
M  . 5.C f  . -.=) .a-.O
   )
P?  N  =8
5 <Y    -/
.
.`8:. `{z.
   ( 
M  )
UP 4W ?
 5 <  5 xcf8 _ N o C C  .
cf ;N 
O  MO
-O  =   <M  8
M -=) _ C  .cf

O  ) MO.C_  4.W6.P
. ?.= .^6  ) .ai  .a . o. V./. M
:z 3 5 TN   5 c?4H !  ) _ 8  > k 8
M
.CN
8  b.8.N 8 c
)  M  5 H !  ) N  F.
M
OM    5=` !  H . ./ f  5. .P- . . .8
M;
..H
 ) P-: . Oc
..=N .. . 3 .! H 
 .. 
 .. ..N ..  ..> 5 ..  ..8
M  ].. .! H .. 
 ..

PH  <=N -    cN -  =   


M  ) ai .
.N o  -8 .O
`  =N ! H  
  
! .

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

99

 ! ( :
>1 GC( 4. ra   . )(UNCLOS
<N   . cN <.H -.M K.W  .  .M ) 1982 .) (UNCLOS ].`N F:. .; . cN
 (  M  UM <;N    -f  UM.
' >14 (
V  
 D) u1(MARPOL) D>Q

N  cN-  ]   5 TN 5cC(   cN- 
C3 / f  M
 5) 5cC  IC  zW  - (- 
z
 b F: k.8
> 5  cN  T.<.N 5N-.
  ! )( 1973 19786.P 5 !?8-MN <N 68-. 5.4 8 ..OM  . . ) .a
 5  cN-  ]   5 TN  5cC ] 
4(  ;  - (IMO) 8
M
http://www.imo.org.conventions/contents.asp?doc id=&topic id=258
 - ba
>H  W )  cN  ( 
  P T  5..  ( .
.M
- C  (_ C -  _ <! 8 8
M .
  !a  :&Q:
<4MN UM 8
WN  -./ k> .  / P V3 .H  5M.W  k> . .8
M . M
 - ba 5
?4-   
N -M F N UM.

 54 8  5-f k>   ]8
WN P 8
M  .U  U.C > .= -.   .M .
 = -O   .
8
 -:fN  x- = D8 8
WN /  5  :(N
 Z -O
3 / P:
U <8 . /
]    -O
-.
!   
Y -O= (
Y ;<.
: u
54 8 ]8
. . 
. 8
.W  k.N T  . C  5. .. M8 -. .8
M
` !< 
$   ( 6? )  
: (8  <!N T
   /  > k 8
M _ C . M

W  5 -M  
- )( .-O
]WN-f  -C    M 8
M._ C
]
^KN ZcfN  /H   P- > 5.8
M
^C (
 :
.. I..8
..  5 ..  :..PH 
.._ U..W ..C_   I..  -8 ..O  ..UM.
 ) ai  o  bM 
 . I.8 
.  5 .W  .  -8 .O ./
- - 5MW 8
.
=)  :H.
 51 :61' <.
!  :cN =   UM.
 W  k>    4 8
M   -fC _ C 
N  .
5CMN  I ;) M-f  -C   (   F   C-.
100

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

N <;N   F <  5=  U  .cf


8 c <;N 
O .(MO
 W  /  M  8
M _ C( <8. c !N
<=N cON -/ UW H
Y= .
] xcP^ 6z6 C  ]WN k8
> 5-f I .H .c -.C .
 .3
 ]a 
   ] 
U  WN 5M.W .  . .3 .Y
.CN -. (.
H 8
z

= 54 8 
  -./  
 .  .  .
 8 .` .  . 
.P : F . .! H
 
   W )( 2004(   WN _  
    / f .8
M
& ( c  :
N -   _ 86/ _  M :cN
i N>  UM.
* 68  )C  !(c :7X  .C  .&C.
)(  . .)
Y b.  2003 (.) . M

 (ACU) . k.UN .

  T=(  8 M 6/ 
MH 
MH :. -.N
.C  ^ . )! -.. . ; .  . (. . ! .. -. b.
..
_ .4
 .. .. .. cN  5. ..-f.. _ ..8 ..  ..
 !..C U..W ..8 M6../i -..( ; ..  .. ..f 
..MH

MH.

4 ( :
- MN   c  uOfN  36 -  :c  >= 
  T>( 8 M
 6/i 
MH 
MH.

S
)

  2001 5 .2002
  4M UC kUN ()  i
  T>(  8 M 6./ 
.MH

MH.
( !
8 _  cN
MH  5.
..UP ..
..i6../i N 
..M..H _ ) ..8 z ..! b-../ -.. ..8   ..
   MN 
(
N
 (.
  cN -. .  ( ._ .8 .N M . 
.8_ .8-f.  
 .

 3-M 
M -.

u:

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

101

 kUN ()
PK= 5 { UN ;<     4 5 -M  4
) (..  ..=U ._ ..C I..CN -.. (..) o.. ..  ..  ?.. ..Y

..Y )58
?..C  ..
.I H
< -fCN    ) K- 
  T <N- !N c.
uOfN <N    
. . b.C .8 _ T  .8
.O8 <. 5. !.`8c
 I
 T> .
 X
8-N=K 5
 8 N
  T>(  () Oc -  .
 DKN 8 `= P 
^p )( 
.MH 
.M.H =.  5. k.C
 UW UC  8:c
8 .M
* 68  )C
4 ?>
1 :& S.(  *1:
)(   2005  I.4
]. . ) (OAG-.4 
 :.c  .
 5  c   -8 .O .UM  . k.U .8-4  .UM :.
-/  .1996 I4 uM) -
]  )( -  :(8
* i )
8..UN (.. :..cN
.. N> ..UM  .. {..UP
 UM   > k  M.8
M
*
i (   ! b 4M  -8 O .UM F .N .8-4
  .8
M

4 ( 
-!N 
   -8-MN  b  -8 O UM :(N  b  - 8-4
)  !N C .O ! . (.) .  .UM  . ?. ( . "
. N
 UM".
)    > -  =   UM.
:c -  / i  8- -8 O   3 UM     = .

 b  -  - =N 5
8  T3 UW  UM.

S
)

  2004
  5 .2005 8
Uf ( :fN -/ :    UM )(  .2005 8 _ 1996
 -8 O UM .8-4
( !
   UM  .1996

N UM .8-4

N   -C.
  cN -  UM.
/N  -.  3
=N
8H.
(sc7
102

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 


 - ^ (   5 T8 <  UM )`  UM  .
:cN=  
N UM < 5 54N 8 .4M
- !  5i {UP ]a  UM  H  =  H i 
8U -.C
  O  UM   / f  M   (-fC 5 UM.
-=N k=MN  () {C W  > 8
M  M k:   .=
.P
.8_ -.3 .
8 M  H > 5 8
M  (.
< -=8 
       5H ( C  ! M8 i >= = .
< ZNi    ) !N-
8
=N   _ 5 UM.

 X
I8
  .c .  .UP .UM   .  ].i  .W . I.8
i  N
8UN !CN {UP :cN .
!  5Uf i $ 8 {Uf zWi    4  WN  > k  M.8
M
{UfN  i _ 5 54 N)    H-.
]a >i 3 ! z/ :cN    C  5 UW  UM.
 <8-=N ) 54 8 !  5H     
  -8-M C
) uf8 UW  UM.
5CMN 3 ON   IW   WN  _ 5 8 UM.

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

103

( *

D) >E(=

WN=
8- 5 %40 O   (  - 8  .   .   .:.
.8
-f  c   (    8C )  (..H  <;.
.$ (. .  k.C
 -C.
_ 4 ( 
 : ) -8- D  -_6c  
 = .3 .OPi !5.
 8- N M ]WN C 
Y )! ( 5CMN :.z .  (.) ..
.W

PH _ b^-  4  ^ ?8-M )( -  


zN 4$  M.
 I..C-f..  ..  Z..?4 .. ..  (..) ( ..  .. .. 4  I..U ..$

P I8    5
?4=` ` 8 -  W .
^KN  4   
 ( 
 b.C)-. . _ .:. . . I.8 k.UN .4M -.  ]. .  (3 .=` 8 .
 =    .
 W8 H  (   5 cf = D8  C
. i  .=N (.
> .f-. (.
!) ICN  4    MO 5. .8
.W .$H !  . ].a
.  .^ .3
)! )   .3 4   .-^) <.;N 5.4 8 ._ . -.3 . 4  . .=N .
> .fI.8
P F:
i  3    b  4  ) -. !8

P I    C    OM   Cc 8 -3   5 c   
 . 5 `8 o/     I  = .   . 4 I.  ]. . 36(.) :.PH
  =M  o / f  = x .- 
8 ]8
WN !8- I/   
-  5
N  W   / f )( -.3 c x. o. N .  .-.
.PH . .M
. ).
 Cf   -8 )(  ( )(  ./ M
a      () -8-
 ( =N ! ! H  
   ].o.
)= - bM/ .  ].a . .  5.
.?4 .! H  I.C . 
 . . _ (.) <!.4:.
  .  Of .a ;M8 - =
./  _ .C  .
. ) (.
.C  .
- (  <CN  ( 
.
2. )   = D) 8? (= s QC   68> 2C:
 .
=
H.
  4  .
=
/  .

104

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 ! ( 
>1
 (CBA) 6

.$ .  .WN  ].W . ..;) M.  (. .W   .. .Cc 8 -.3 5.. .
-f     WN
$ `8  4  / P  );
.. 16 15 8 1
kM   19< 6. .(4  . o. ].a .W ) (. . cN.  . (CBD) ( . 2010
- P    (   .
) 20104 
  68 6 >1
 :6
4 V*a1 : 3( ) s8.
 *
.6
4 >) : 1-3 6  ./ M  (. .$. .$H  .! <.N (. .H  .M

8H = 
PH ( b N ! ;) M 
) H . .M
)= . <.N (._ .c
! .
4 : 9>. ) 
 ' ()- 6 ( *( 685F C (..
4
4 >) 8 _ : 1 9 6 
)  4   =.8-
4NN >)..=_ ..8 _ : 2 9 6NN    .. H .. <!)
.. F ..N ..M ..4   ..
= 8- () <!=_  WN W )( c.-3
4NN : 10 r 6NN8 4NNNN2. )) NN2c NN NNNNQ!  DNN> 4NN:
( DNN) NN&4A NN (NN
*
.
C4
4 >)N : 1 10 6) M k /     ]. . cN.  ( ..O

.o: UN
4NN >) : 2 10 6NNc -..3 5.. ..-f..  .. -f..
..P  .. ..
   =8
U  ] - ( -=N oN  ( ]. (.$ N . cN.  ( ..O
 = . o:

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

105

1  
1 6

..
Np..:.. = ..N-
..>H  .W ) (.. .. cN..  ( .. .. 4N .. cN ..

N "  N  ( )( 8
 ) 2000
8 8 29 -4 .: 
N . .cN
(    <4M8
M -  3 4   -^ .
 <a : 15 G1 :  !& .( 
1
1!  2000 !
! 29 :V
1! !Q2003 ( & 11 :
)4 ^C ( a 137 (2007 !
! 68) :
^C (: (a :
http://www.biodiv.org/world/parties.asp
 V'  :
http://www.biodiv.org/biosafety/default.aspx
C4 mC:
K 5 -  3 4   -^ -( . M8 .48  !8-.^ .  .; . .C4  .;) M
-f  -C   (   MO <!= <8 - 8
W !< -f!< . =8
U
=)  Q> &7:
KN-O -  3 4   -^  5)  -C 6  ]   .5MW
I..86..  ..4M
.. i -..8-MN <..8
> ..f   .. <..=N
> ..f`{..
  .=C
> f
- ( C - 53 ^ .
> f  <=N :cN 5 C
 - N 5 ) a  4  )( 5H (  . . 2003 .O 5.
  N
4......... ......... 8 ......... cN.........  ( .........
 T ......... <.........H -.........M (UNEP) .........
http://www.biodiv.org/doc/press/pressltits/bs/cpbs_unep_cbd_enpdf
  !a  :&Q:
 WN 6C    5. . . = D8 . . C
. i = 5. .
> .f
(  ICN -  4  )( _-^!   M.O .8
.W x. .c  b.  -.-. (.
  / !8-  - N  fa  4   P ( ]8
WN;< =<  .
> .f ].o.
  b?
 5-   C -N .V3
 5H !    M ]a
^ 6 ! .)  .3 4 .   .-^5.4 8 (.4 .
) <;N -3  4  xcP
> f
. ! UN
) = -- ( ]  N 3 4   -^   O -
8UN <8 < -.
 ; !8- D ( 
8U 5KN W      C 8   5-f   .
:u

106

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 


 54 8  5 5 yM
N>   4  ) ai  . .N 5.4 8 o. -.

.. 5.. T .. 4  .._ ..8 ..  ..K..W uPH .. ^ ..  ..8U ..3 4 .. H
  -^  ;< .
48 -  4M
. `8 5. T= .  . 4 .N   .  .  (.c 5. (.

8UN  4 .
^C (
:
)(  x-48 -  .   . 4 .  .  .. . M8 .`8 . 
y.M .
> =N - )( .yM
 P-N - ? oN  6  8:z  . -8 .O.W  f .
 -  .
 ..N
N (..) P-..8 -..  ..W ) (.. ..  ..8  ..>
..
..P ? ..   ..  ..M
H 
W  / f!
Y 4M Cp  yM (.
 . !p: H.
 N 
 4MN  N
 o N 4M
 4 N 
 =N  ]8
.WN ]a 4M  .
.P K 5. -._
.  .cM  .  ./ 
).
= 8- !N =UN
.=N .. ..4M ..   5.. .. ; .. - ..cM ..  .. .. .. ..
o:
/ <8 Z   
 =N    
  4M
Y UWH=  ( KW <N 
 3 4   -^
& ( c 
N - 5 
 5  )
   _  8   .N
* 68  )C! 5c : (< ><! 8 
*  (:.
) .. (.. .. 4M b..  2006
 ..

 :..c ..8  .. =<..


a i -c =M   4 8
4c
) ]WN   (
 .M

4 ( :
<=NH ( !-fCNi -c  x.cf .
.Y . (.) 
.W M .
 N 
8  
_- -.
K 8 _ 5 -_
_=   4. 8
4c
<=N i 
) ]W   (  .M

S:
   ?
M  . 58
 ! -
 (8   -.
 >
W-c.
( !:
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

107

 V3>.
 cN  (.
(sc7:

-  !N )
.  4.W -. () .-.M ) (. .U  k)-.N . .c .
.
-.. ..8 c
.. 5M..$ 58 .fN6..  M..W .. H..MN -.. (..  .... ..P
) / P D) f 8H   )(  WM.((Wf

N=
/ 
  ()  8 - <
Y -8-MN <8   ! .
- :cN=   ;< /  .  . 5M.W -.  -. K.W-f.! "
.Y
 .8

 X :
 ) F .   (!:
N6!CN -8
$i    ?
M   - 6  .4 
-.N 5. .
 - ..! .C
..W_ <..`N -.. (.. 
.." .C .. 
..N -.. (.. 
..W ..
?
M  . =8
U -
> f
 ) F .   (! Da ( D) +Q
  S(  . !:
-N I8  5c 5M$ 5 5C` () ]3 U 
i  5MW  C .
 (  4! + 6( ( *4:
    UM () cN U _   <N y
8-ON
  .N_ ../ P
)(  =U H.
  ^a>4:

.. -.. ..  ..; ]..a  .. (..   ..  5.._-.. !N .. -f..C8 ; ..  M..

<3 
<3
PH  ) ai -N I8   () 5 
 8.
 :+
 W  -    5     ( !KW yM   <8   .=W
)

   /  
(    8 N 54 8 _ 5MW . C  .
)( :   4N (4 ?
) .
  +    <
:
 >6    M 
W 4W  -  D 
( ! .
* 68  )C
:4>. )  *
 
 68 1
:4
) .. (.. .. 2004  I..4
 I..
].. .. ) (..!
 -..  ..
   ) (.6.  -. . 
 . . . .;) M .
  N UW VC (   ( .  (.(.) o.
..a   ..  ! -..=..M (.. .. .. I..4..  (>..
  N: <N W ]  F <8-=N <=N cM k.^N .N .
  .N . ! -. (. .C  5.= . !.  . .;) M
108

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 N    (  ( .P   ]. ..C .`8


 5=  P 
MK (MO 5 -  .  .C  -.O
 ^  ) N ( 5  P
H ) .

4 ( :
 ) <=N c ! 8 c  I4>(     .) N  .N .C:. <.=N 5 .`8
:(NH
 UW yM( 5 KWN W ]8  - P P  .
!..  : ..cM ..  .. .. ^ ..  ../ M  ..H  ..C? .. 50 5..
..
H !8 fN?
  25 5 k^N  <8 (4
! -f! .!C
: ! )( 
M (MO cN  .  ^ .  .W 
.WM ) . -.8-
 4C  cU 
^  .N
!... ...N  ^ ... i ...P ...N N... ]...8  ...  y...M ...N k...^N
...W
  .

S:
)

   5  _ 1997 .2003
=` 8 =   I4>(     .N
( !
= -i 8 V3 8
W 
  UN !.-

f.
 V3 ;  
 N c M ) M3
 !.(-
(sc7:
_= k I4>(     -=N N kUN () Za ) W  ]   5 ^ 
 
Y  cM    5 ^   C.8
Uc
 :! ) ai <=8 <  I4>(     :(N  N
  cM    ^ )(  .N W
OM      5 C 5) 58= U  f(.
 ..;_6=.. .. V3
..M ..N  (M..O  .. T.. ..
..O
..Y ! .. 5.. ..
 ^ .
-f.. 6!..CN _.. = ..  .. ..   .. 
..z   ..^ ..
..
P 
M (MO W    8  .
 U     8  ^  () cM o=(  .
 8(< j^
( 6 *
 
:1
) k I4>(      N:(N

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

109

Z?4N!  W . ]. N  ^ . ) (.  k> . .! (. .? .8 ./ M
H  > H 
8  O= ./ M   .8 .M.  ./ M .O8
 
.
Uf a
].  ..    5.. .. ..C 58!..  ^ .. )
..$ ) ..ai  (../ P..cN ..
!< 
. C3
-/     8  ^  - 4  k=M ! )(  o=(  .

110

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 [:
D) >E(=:

N -  z  5 <; (YH (.a-.=N  . z  .M   .-.  .W>.cf 5
 N M  3 4  =- <`N  z;   5H )(  <.
-=8   ( )(     z
 5` ]3 -f -  5   Wf
YWf

zN Zcf  )(  Dc
).N b. . z . 
.   .  5. 5.86 ]. (.)
.W .M
 <  ) ai !  O 8   ^= ) )( _  5
?4   H  .M

8   ( _  -=c  IC (.) 


.C .
.C4N-.N ..  . z.
>= .. ;  ..:..z   ..  <.." .. -..M .. :.. -..=N 1990 ) ../ ..Cf ..M 8..C
9.4 4 5 ! ;   z  (.) U  k> .. .3H F:.H . -.  .WN  .
   z4N -=)  Cf  ==M?
 14 5 4 ?
)( .C

8 W 
W   ICH?
 )( xcP  z !N ( : W8
8MN  z  .

(  .$ 
3
i
Y -C   z.
  ]U=  
Y WPH.
P H  8
z.P-
 ) M
U  
!4
8U  ] 
((.
 58-6z .{c
_
k3  z .


zN  .
 . .$H _ . .H 5 .U ]. . z (.U  4.W - . -. .
. .8
 ..Cf ) k> .  (.. .. z . H (..a  .. .. z ?  ..8  .. 5..
..?4 ....
 ( ..  .. ) (.. .. z  ..U .. _ ..
N .. .!.. ) (.. ..cM  k> .. .. .. z
  5-!   H.(a
 - U
  z  )( 
 " !  
   ;< -  F N ]8
WN !8-  z.
 ! ( :
>1
 :6
<!N  cN  (    (   z 
$  <N -
6P 5  cN 
 T
    <.N -
. . F . 5. 2002
Np. =
.>" -.  .W ) (.   . .C  .W8

    T
.  5.H-.
.YH U.WH-.!N (.  . .cM  .. ( .
  z -f  -C  !N 4 ]8  8   5     z.
48 
 6^ 5 T  :
/
   8 c   ? xcP!-8- 6P 5    . z   .
UH  W  >. M k
  Cp    O cM  V CN 8  -f  -C   (   z.
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

111

=< 
.
  !a  :&Q:

N 8
W  V3  / f   z  -O -.  
8 .
 . ]U.C8

 ;
 I H( 8 N ! <8 8
W   C    _  .  . z  ./ f.
)-  WN  3 F:  C  -f6  -C  .  . z  = . . (.c) . ( .
 5
?4- bM/   -C   z   N
.W  . z  .Of -.8
N (.
!N  ]N P .
:u
o N  3 4M 
 ]  N T   z48 - 6? ) .  
-M T  5:(NH
6z  -C   .Wf
    > k( -8
N <N .
 W . M k>   /
] ZcfNP H .P-
_ 8H  
 ()
> f  a> 5  z.
   KW    z _
! .
^C (
 :
 ..  o.. N ..-..  .. z  ..  ].. ..  ..U  .. z.
 ) ai 
WC8 - o
 ;   z
$   I $H .OM  .
 5= U  O . -N   = 8-( -fCN .  . z   !.W 5. .`8
.>H
`  H  cM  > 5  z.
 . !pH.
 o N  z   4M  8 `= <!N  (  !=UN <8
 - C8
  T>(   z  8 _  4M  (
 :cN 4M!  =    z

N I 4M  
z=  = ]U $H
 =N 4M!-8- ( N    (   z
  MN
CN -CN 4M  (   z
 ]WN 4M-f  -C   (   z
 ]WN 4M   -C   z
 <=N 4M  (   z 5 -8 N 
)  Z3; (
 =N  K 4M =< 


112

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

& ( c 


kN-    () 5 M
    z.
* 68  )C  : [:
)(  )
Y b  2004 ()  M
 
 H  -f
- .. = .. z ..-  I..N 4 = > ..  ..! .. ..!N.. i
  -8-M  b  z  <N - !N ._
 (.) / P . . z
K ( .
4 ( :
4!4.1:61C
;< i ( -=N $ -f6 (     z )( ;   8 )
Y
 (

^K  i -8 $H 
4 <=N^
.  o

S:

  z )(
 .
-f    - i   z.
 ]8
..W
.. T ..4M .. i.. ../ f  .. z .. V3^ k3 ..i ..8
..PH
 =  UWH W )(   z.
( !:
    z )(
 .
  H )(
 .
 
  8 M.
(sc7:

- 8 c   Y  8 MN  
.
-=c8; ! 4  (CpZ.
- a  C M/ H (a F N / f    z  ! 8_ . !8
-    >  -f   z  UW  z.
-    36 )

  -f6 C  f     z.
- 
CN>(     z  8C : . (.)  8  . z 
.a
= .

 X :
; kUN i  $   z )   8 8 M $H 
4(.
]  5 IWf   k8
> 5 =U-8
8-N .4M
uOfN  (  5- i   z.
8MN
    Ci  4   z    )( -   O P .

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

113

* 68  )C! && :[


)(  . 4M b.  2004
 (.) .

 :.c .8  .
=<   - )(    z.
4 ( :
-..8-MN ..W 
..C3 ../N ]..a  5..CM -.. 36_-.. )- .._-.. ..8 M
  - )(  =U=  -M i   z )(  =U H = .
( ^A +H. 5

-N 3 N >.5
   8M  " -8 (a 
.

S:
  b
 =<  UW   () !N Cp   > k . M . .P <.i=( .
)( H.
( !:
  C> .
= 5>  =    > k . M

f.

8 ( -8-MN <N  5   -f  
.8
(sc7:
 ].. 8 <.. ..W _-.. _ ..  ..8  .. .. z   (..) . <..i= (..) ( .. ..H 
_-..  ]..WN <..-f..  -..C  ..  ..U ..P_-.. U..WH -..C ) (.. k> ..
 .UM
 X :
 (MMA) +
-._ .UP ].a _ .8>  .WN . .. .$}. 8  -._ . 4  .8 M-..MN (.
H-  {UfH 8
YH = D8H.
 * 9 (  4! + 6(   S( *4 )(IBAMA

 DKN " M =  :(N


 ] T3  _ N MH ( () b N_-  <; 4W 8 M^ k (.
] {UP ]a      z M   F
   _ P_- .8 M
    +! )
  6[ IQ
1C   
( (4 Q(:
]a
N ]   UP ! -
. (8 .  .U -. ].WNU.WH
 -C )(   > k -_  UM   M  () 54 F:_-   ` !Cc UWH:N
 N
)N- I8-.  -. ) (.  .  -.C    . ) (.  k> . .UM
 _-  a  C   M :N
 i  -C   z.
114

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 ]a
= ]U
M  ;<.
  cM  
 )    .
  OM  -C   .U
-8-MN P )!
    -C (
8UN <N  
 I T 
  ..8
_ 54 N   )( oN 5 < H W 
) oN
. T

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

115

I841
  . 6)S5 ' 2! zSE
(
:>A
54 8-=) 5 -M   (  
  H 

z C3 ].W o.
.>H
  )( =  U  O 8
-_i C3 5 xcfN
^K   C  (]WN .

..>H 
..C3_ -..W 58-..8p -..) .. 5 !.. ?
.. F:..! ..=` . 8 ..!:.. (NK.. (..
i  .. C  -..8  .. ) ..ai`
..
..z 8 (..) - ..C (.. T..  .. ..
 ( )(  Zf=  U  O.8
 T   ( )( =  U  O 8
.? .C3:.z   . .
  U 58-   O  8  / P <_ <!C8  U (.) -f.C F:.= . U )(.
-..N .. 6..P 5.. ( ..
..zN  .. :.. V../ I..C:..! (.  H -.. ..U ..4) .
 ..O 
^K..N .. ..  ....  ) ..ai  .( .. .. .._6 o.. .. ../^= 5.. ....
 (  5. -M
.=c 5.4 8 . -.=) Z.`8 .  ( .-.M -.P ; . 5. (.
-   )( 5 -8- ) cH
i ( 54 8 .   ]8
.C 
.C :cN .O 8-.M
 5 54 8
=c  
`N  (  () H - =.
O
 ;
 F: 6  
 I8 4 W   (  -   ]a {UP
T
   -C   W  .
 5 -8  KW F:=` ;
 CH   )(  OcH:
6z   
3 . U
   M:z. (3
  4 .
>
  
NM  .3
=
/ .
 ! ( :
  !a  :N&Q 5. D. :  ]. -.8
. -.M ]8
.WN !:.  .a
] :. <.`8 5. -.8-
.>H   x. o. N . 
) ..-. -.M ]8
.WN <;.8
^K.
(    U -M )   ? :  U 6z 
( : 54 8 -O -8
 
8
 .   C ( ]WN  V) 4N
=c  C  54 8 8 4N
-..O 5.. -..8  .
8 .. 
..P  ..  5.. 8
..W 
^K..  ../ f (..= ..

i . N .c! (.) .  .  .cf;


..Uf  5. 2 <.   .
 4M
>H   )(  Oc? (.
54 8 4N 
N   . -.C =- .U-. .8 .!i  T-.N Z..4M
  / P  ( )(  !UW.4M
 5. -8  . ) (. F:.=` .;
. .`8H 
 .  .   ./ f  .:.
   -C : ! H  
    H  .   ./ f -.C : .
.
 f  ! H  
  );
 kM< 1 f =  3^ k3 .O .  .  5.

 (.
:u

116

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

54 8 -N 
 T  =  U 5.4 8
.WC8
.  <.!3658:.
 8 ] ! -M 8i 
 T
.C3 I.8 (.:.P ) (. . )
 . Tk.N (.
 -f    U   O 8     ?) M  U-   F
=( ! 
$ 
^KN  (.
^C (
 :

>H    ZfN  oN 5
W )(   a
PH  IC
 (..) ]..= .. U  ..O 8 5..4 8 (.. . ! {..WN- ) ..ai  ... ..i  ..
..
..  5..4 8 .  5 :..P  ..  ..
..c8 ..  ..U .. U ..O
   O 8W  f    M H   W  {UfN M6z
H (a  N -  () _ C = U  .f 5.4 8 Z.cf8
^K.(.C
UWH O 8 
8= U  f >
) . C3
: H.  !p
 <N
. . =N
.^H
.W  (. 
.4 o.N <.`N .= .  . .
 (
 {UfN :cN <N6z H (a     (
   <`N  ) =  U  cf   ( 6P 5 <=N
iN

T-..N .. ..4M..  ( ..  ..  {..UP (..) ..= .. U 5.. .. {..UP
= .. U 
.. T .. C ) (..  .. ? .. ..  ..O {..UfN 6z.. H(.a
  U  UW
P ()
^pN  ( 
$
$ 
Y
& ( c :
kN-   -. kUN c4  -. 
-.N x8. (. .> 5.
^K.N 
.8
  M 
.8
* 4
  )C 4 IS1 :  ! y.6+
)(   4M b  2006
-.! . 
-. k.UN . x8.
(.
5..4 8 I..CN
..W ? .. ..W 
..U  ..W (..)  ../ ..=U
.(..
-..N-..
..8  x8.. 5.. x8.. ..=8
> (.. -.. (..
 I
^KN xcP F:H  5
W  .

4 ( :
! <=N  UC !-  cM    > k-! U
8UN {Uf -C.

S:
  {Uf ( 4  U   M =     : N
  I=   -  x8(.
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

117

  ON 
>H 
W   a.
 -8-MN pC ) ! .
  UC  M>
= U  f ( ICN - (.
( !:
 ]8
WH( : $  > 5U.
 ]8
W ( H f  8 M U {UfN >.5
  4M
8
 ! 8- / f    C    
.
(sc7:
!
 -  M 8 _   8 c U .=U
_-     5 .N 54
)(  5 -8- M <8   x8( `
.
 X:
 I8
 =8
> 5CMN :cN)     cM    > k.U
 I8
)N  -. . I8=. 5   . 
8 . 
). ./ P
 58: :cN <! I< )? :  5 54M .(5M
* !'  )C ( 4.  :<!C ! !(c. !
)(  I4 :c 2005
]    8  -M 
 .
 
8 :
^K   M 
8 C  <; 4M 
_ 8 M 
8    <!N = -  <.;N .
   
8  8 M .M 
. .8  I.4
]. . =<.
= 5 V3   ! .
4 ( :
<=N- 
f 6!CN
^KN 5 . 
.8  . .M 
(.) .8 .8  -.M
H  xcf 4 IN: .
^K
 C   6!CN <;N () 4M >  
8.
 C    8 _ () 4M M 
.8

S :
= 5 V3 4M-c  =   >
8U
8 _ 8 M 
.8
( !:
= 5  V3 
f.
(sc7:

118

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

^
.. >  ..
..8  .. ..M 
k> .. x.. (..) ..8- ... -.. I..C .. 
) ....) ?4
  4C" /H   -8-M /  _
^K.
 >
8UN <;N <N
8   8C  M-c  8 ._ y ;<
.
 -
8U:fN  -)
Y D ) ;  b U   M _ (4Z.fN (.

^K C  <!8    4 M 


.8
 ; x
 M 
<N 8=` ! 6!CN  5 >  
8  I. 5. . M=.5
-c H ( <N fN )( F:  M.
- fN
 -=`  H 
z I. 5.  M= . -.c(5. <Y
 .
 ..4M-c -.. ..-../  .. . $  - ..C  ..  -..8-MN .. ..H 5  ..
6!C >  
8.

 X:
I8 -=N   -f  4 C .M 
. .8  .   .8  .M K.W  .
:(8

^K  U  M
8   M 
8  U / f
8.

a     )
 () <!N- C fN =
 K / f6!CN 5 >  
8.

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

119

 I. 1 G *() )(    +C XA   :


] ^ k3 = !:  a )
  ] :(NH
http://www.environmental-auditing.org

 ( *() )(    +A (=) (:


 -  5 -8-       
  )( 
c  . N <N a.  ].
! H  
  = <8-.  . .?M  . . ]. N <.N -. F:.H  (.) .?M . .

C W )(   .
F:= -=N  3  a H  5  .
' ( . ) () )(*( a   + 
1  )  ! 25 D :(2007 ! 29

 =` 8    /. i

 =` 8  .M
 a  5 Y
 .
 T ! H  
   
 .
' (NN   NN() NN)(*( NN NN NN+  <NN&-NN'NN.1 & 27 DNN) 6NN NN1 NN
:(2005 (8

   (.


zN  .
8
^KN 
 .

   : !  8-M.
' (  & () )(*( V   +! ! ) ! 30 D :(2004  ! 2

    (.
 
    
W  .=C

  
 ; .

   : !  8-M -8- .
 T!  =  
 HH     / f -C.
' (  () )(*( DF   +& 
4 )  ! 24 D :(2003  ! 27

  
 ; .
   -C : ! H  
 .
` 8  F  C ! H  
 

 M   cf.
4& K (*() )(   :+

 8 ...` ... 
...P : F ... . .! H  ...z  (2004) ... 
 ...  ...8...C
c
 H
.
120

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 


   ( : $ " !  
  ) z  (2007 .8
 ...  5... . .! H  ...M N :... 
 ... ? 5... ... ... 
 ...
...W )(2007
  .8

 .. ..
 ..;  ..z  (2004) .. ..8 i ..C
c  .... H

.
UN N 
  ) z  (2007 .8
i $  :c / f 
 ;  UWH ( ) z  (2001  8C
c
   H
.
 54 8 Z N ! H 
 . . 
 .  . . cN - . .z  (1998) .
 8 C
c   H
.
  ... -...C : . .! H  ...z  (2004) ... 
 ...  ...8 ...C
c ...
 H
.
   M 5   z  (1998) U  8 C
c  . H
=      5   -C : 
 " !  
  ) z  (2007 .8

   cN -  ) z  (2001  8 .

  cf ) z  (2004  8 C
c  H
.

)(   ' & ( :+ 5


 Of  
  5 ! H  
  )
 ]     

 ) )(  <C 
 ..C . . :. < . _ I.C=` 8 . .- (.
 5 -8-  a )
)={   z>.
  u 4!( 6   () )(*( +  :+
-..= <..N -N-..  ..8  ..! " 5..  ..W   .. 
 ..  .. ].. .. N
 < ON <N-  (OOf U-  5 I8  N <N N !T
..=8  .. ..W
8 .. . -.. D..48_ .. .. i 5 ..`N-.. < ..ON
   -  5 -8  .Oc  N  -C  ON Mrs.Else Karin
) I3  Kristensen (else-karin.kristenesen@idi.no
8-    N )
 -
.T8
2A SE ( (*() )(    +   & 7 2007.-2005

W 1H 
   )
" !  
 .
2 8 N    5 ! H  
  -N ]N  <!8  I
 .
3 8 -  
    
W   =  I 5 ! H  
 .
4 8  ON  5
     UW  .
5 8  
     5   ! -
PH.
6   4OM  P 8 N (
     UWH  .
2004 - 2002
b `N UWH( :cN <N 
8UN - I8
)N
  / P  .
 
    ] =C ! H  
   =   . . ) . (.= .  .
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

121

  .. -..C ..N   ..  ].. . ! H  .. 


 ..
..PH -.. H ..?M

   oN 5  a ?     F  cf.
2001 - 1999
<N
.a "  F .
.  ".: H . (.) . 1995
.:.  .a )(.
p
N      - 
.c 5. . <.  .a 
.UP (.) .C3 .K-.
   5 <  
8 C =` 8 (
  !U -N -M b `N -
UWH
PH f
8UN   cN -  8 N ]8  .
1998 1996
  =`-M 5 5N : .
 . 
 .  . cN6 =.C -.
 .. .. M ..  ...U ..  ..
N ..`8 .. . <.. ..N
..CN (..Cp
  
f  Cp 5 

8UN Uf i $ 8
.U  I .
.
 . <N - P )  F
 (: H a )(  M
 . . . U.WH=`.
( ]   
N- )( ] 
_  .

122

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 I. 2 G'>1 
 (K : 6
) x.  .. 3  (..8 .. .. cN  = .. ..  <..} ..=> ( ..
z) .(..F:..
  cN !
$  /
$ 
Y  8 M  ( 54 8 .  -  ./ f
! F:  cN  6P 5 4W 
M .yM
GK*[68


5!8

&

 

&>f

'>1 
 (K 6
 cN cM   M 
8 > 5 UH )
Np
. (Bern

KW Z   (.
.. cN ..  ..8 M-f..  -..C !
..-.. ).. cN
_
! 8-  
) <  `8.( )/  cN
- 
N  5 MN H(.
.Natura 2000
bN  MN H( 8 M ]8
WN > 5.H :-.
i ..$  ..> .. 48 5 -..i ..$ ..U ..W I.. U8
  4....$ Natura2000  ....CN ]........U  5....
....>H
 ..W ..8 M ../ P k> .. D..KN..U ../ P k> ..
. 8 M
  cN cM =8
)i     .U
.. .. cN  ..W   ..  :..c ..(   .. ..
..Y
=  M 
8 M  -. (CITES + CBD) .N

$ {  )
. =8

N..  ..f    k> .. .. MM .. 
..8 ..M

$ =U () N )
. =8
  - -8HH -KW =8
)H U  .3
..8 _ .. cN
8..UN .. ..8
M
..$ <..i _ ..C
)
. =8

M -8 O  ;  cN )4. 8


8 _  ; DKN  cN 
W H.
8 _  cN
MH  5.
8 _  cN )(   =U .oc
  cN cM  i   
M
_H- TP.
>   8 _  cN 
M 8
M  4 . Caspian
 cN    -C M !
.Mekong
8 _  cN   U  . <. .UM  oc.

N 
. ! UN
>    cN cM     8
M () M (  .M
  ) oc(Galapagos  cN

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

123

!< &6S
*


<!6

124

 cN cM ASEAN   U  .U


 cN cM   ) U  .oc
8 _  cN   =U .oc
.. cN ..cM  .. ).. ..H  !
..  {..
..Y
 {M .(4c
  cNi  i  cM   ;H   z U

8UN   z.
.. cN ..  ..8 M  .. -..C  .. ..8
M_ ..C
 M  W
$  ) oc.(Antigua  cN
 cN6z  cM     8
M  .oc

N..  ..cM  ..   k> .. ..8
M _ ..C .. M
  =U
$  .oc
.. cN ..cM  ....  ( .._ ..8  k> ..
(..) . 8

48. (U
8 _  cN  8
M  > k _ C
$  .oc
8 _  cN U cM   M 
() 8 ZO.(
z
5   cN 8 M 548
H cM   Z_6C .3
 -  H(.

N   k  O 5 TN  UWH  .f
   cN 8 M 1983
8UN  <i 8
M 4.(8

N..  k> ..   k.. .. M ..M 
..8 ..f  .. cN
_ 8  N  <i 8
M 4.(8
....8 _ .... cN .... N .... ....=U  ....8
M ....4) (8.... cN
(Cartagena

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

NN  NNC NN DNN ?NN>


( 6NN NN
 NN ) NN= DNN NN A NN(: - 3 GNN INN.
:
 . k8
> 5  F:( cp  kM  :  )( -   
 IY< 8-=N <N
-.( .) . - y. ? .Oc )( :   M ]  .  
  ! H<    N
. ! Of 
 o _   b
 )  {  ] ai  ( 
.N .  .8  .z  {.=)
)N 
 o 
4_; 
{ 6 

. 
 . .! H 5. . ! 4 (
4
  ] P z
PH 

.
c
VcON  
  ! H  5 :c    
   ( $
?  3   OM
:
(       
 4 ]
http://www.environmental-auditing.org

6 '< V( 1

  (D!)


 

4

:6 
 XA* ^
 1& K
http://www.environmentalauditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewContainer2/ca
eng04ar_ft_cesdch1agreements.pdf/$file/caeng0
4ar_ft_cesdch1agreements.pdf
http://www.environmentalauditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewContainer2/ca
eng05ar_ft_cesdch3biodiversity.pdf/$file/caeng0
5ar_ft_cesdch3biodiversity.pdf
http://www.rikisendurskodun.is/index.php?modu
le=news&action=show&news_id=34&highlight
=biological&language=en
http://www.riksrevisjonen.no/NR/rdonlyres/FFB
B1A9B-6063-42E8-95745BE9755123E4/0/Eng_Doc_3_12_2005_2006.p
df

http://www.environmentalauditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewContainer2/ca
eng05ar_ft_cesdch2eco%20integrity.pdf/$file/ca
eng05ar_ft_cesdch2eco%20integrity.pdf

..... .....- ..... cN


CESD-1 Oc

2004

... ...8-4 N
...i
...   ...  ( 
...
CESD -3Oc

2005

-( .... .... .... cN





2005

4
Q!

........] ........ 
I........4
....! ..../ f ....==M
..... 
V.....C  U.....C
 ( ....... .......
. M  k>  

... 8 ... cN k..UN
.(   5

-2005
2006

u!


2003

4


.... Y ....) ....> ....=8-M


-) !

k3-...M ...) ... ... 4
-2 .....Oc -.....4 .....>
CESD
== 
 _ MN

125

(.( I^
(
2004
Q(

2005

2004

D2

      :  


 - +() )( ' & ( 

.5> 5 M
....  ....  ...

..YH ..OOf  ..-


 8 M
...... M  k> ......  4......$
. !N) 
. > 4W
.> k3-M c
. U k3-M c
!N:.....fN( .....
..... i
. .cM > k3-M
.._ -..C  -f..
.U 
..4 ...- ... 
.> k3-M

2001 NNNNN!(
fa 
2004

[


2006
2000
2002
2005

4

4

4

4


2005

8&

SA = (  C
http://www.environmentalauditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewContainer2/ca
eng01ar_sm_legacy.pdf/$file/caeng01ar_sm_
legacy.pdf

http://eurosai.nik.gov.pl/en/site/px_Animal_Prot
ection_Poland.pdf

http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d0323.pdf

http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d02581.pdf

http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d03803.pdf

: .......^ 
....... = .......8 _
(....) -....C { ....UfN
...._ (.... ;
....M
<...C= .D... b ...
...!
_ ....C .... D ....f
(.......)
> .......f  .......a

...M (... ;
...M
...Oc D... b ...
...!
CESD -1
..H ..OOf .. 
8
 M 5
 M 8 _

2001

2003



1999

4


8 M / f V3 kUN
..P .. ] .. ..M
. M=

...Uf ...a
  ...H
.. 
y..M N
..
......U  ...... H ......8>
Z_6C  cM T 

......=U ......) 8
M......O
Mojave
....a
  ....H T ....

.c  _ .
Uf
.  .  uOfN
.UWH :cN -KN
.
> ..f  ..a
  ..H
..8
 ..M ..H ..
._   . )` -fCN
-.. ..W
.. ..fN

2002

4


 
  " ! $  :  
  -      


2002 NNNNNNNNN!'
4. (

2002 NNNNNNNNN!'
4. (
2003 NNNNNNNNN!'
4. (

126

http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d0493.pdf

http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d05211.pdf

.... _ .... 5....4< 3....=


-.8-M () .a $ -
.
M 5> 
.
....Uf ....a
  ....H
5..... -.....8  ..... _ .....
i ..... 5..... ..... 
.... 
8....U ....-c
. W
.
> ..f  ..a
  ..H
..M ..H .. .
N
 H  8

...........8H ...........H
.. .. M ..!4 ..O=
.8 =< =
N

2004 NNNNNNNNN!'
4. (

2005 NNNNNNNNN!'
4. (

E4  C
http://www.environmentalauditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewContainer2/ca
eng02ar_ft_c4species.pdf/$file/caeng02ar_ft_c4s
pecies.pdf

4.....Oc .....P- .....H


CESD

2002

http://www.nao.org.uk/publications/nao_reports/
02-03/02031186.pdf
http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d031.pdf

) 5 8 
8 _


. .
N ...P- .../H
.U
. . V.a
. W   ) i

.; ! .P- H

......Y ......! ......8


8-.M k8 ) -c
. W 

.......8 ........P- .......H

..a k..C ..


.....W" ..... c} .....
.P-
-.......= ........P- .......H
]....  ....UN
 8-....M
F ..  ..P- ..H ..P
F ...
... -...M  ...8
.5cC 5 N   O

2003 NNNNNNNNNN<((
4. (
2002 NNNNNNNNN!'
4. (

http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d031089r.pdf

http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d05185.pdf

http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d051026t.pdf

2003 NNNNNNNNN!'
4. (
2005 NNNNNNNNN!'
4. (
2005 NNNNNNNNN!'
4. (

  ? T( D^


http://eurosai.nik.gov.pl/en/site/px_Thaya_biodiv .=  T
.
i
_A.pdf
...... ......U ......8 M

...! ..._ ...) ( ...


Thaya
http://www.nku.cz/publications/en/thaya_river_b =.....C  ..... 
..... 
asin_2005.pdf
........=  ........!  :........c
............
 ............W  

127

2005

Q(


2004 NNNNNNNNNNNNNQ(

NN!(
fa 

      :  


 - +() )( ' & ( 


..! .._ (..)
.. i
Thaya
(..) -..O  ../ .. 

CN
http://www.environmentalCESD - H ..........Oc
auditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewContainer2/ca k..8
> 5.. :
.. ..8 _
eng01ar_sm_legacy.pdf/$file/caeng01ar_sm_
5.... -....C < ....ON
legacy.pdf
..._ ... ;
...M
:6 <..C .D.. b ..
..!
. -8 O 
http://www.nku.cz/scripts/detail.asp?id=868

 ......W 
...... i

.....! ....._ .....) .....


....- 5.... ....  Thaya
.... ....-=  ....H
. f 5
......-=  ......  3 ......
http://www.nku.cz/scripts/detail.asp?id=869
! H _ ;< T 

http://eurosai.nik.gov.pl/en/site/px_Danube_river  ...... ......f
......8
=
_Romania.pdf
.O .  
4M
....  ..../ f .... cN

....! -....C  -f....


( )/  cN )-

2005

 Q1

2001

2004 NNNNN!(
fa 

2004 NNNNN!(
fa 
2002
 

^ 6=C
http://www.environmental...) ...C ... cN k...UN 2002
Q(

auditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewContainer2/ate
C 
ng03ar_sm_ramsar.pdf/$file/ateng03ar_sm_rams
ar.pdf
http://eurosai.nik.gov.pl/en/site/px_Neusiedl_Au ...) ...U ...8 _ ... 
2003 NNNNNNNNNNNNNQ(

stria_Hungary.pdf

.......................M <.......................
*(
Neusiedl/Ferto
http://www.environmental...- ... cN  ...
1999
4

auditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewContainer2/nl
>
( aH KW
eng99ar_sm_wetlands.pdf/$file/nleng99ar_sm_w
etlands.pdf
http://www.sfao.admin.ch/pdf/ZF_e_Ramsar.pdf ......  :......c u......M)
2004
Q!&
K.......W .......C ....... cN
>
( aH
! . D^(
http://www.environmental--... ...UM  -8 ...O 
2005
4

auditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewContainer2/ca .....UM  N


.....
eng05ar_ft_cesdch1fish.pdf/$file/caeng05ar_ft_
CESD 1Oc --
cesdch1fish.pdf
http://www.environmental(...)  ...C ... ...^
2000
4

auditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewContainer2/ca ..... ..... U8


 .....
eng00ar_ft_salmon.pdf/$file/caeng00ar_ft_salmo  ........C 6........
n.pdf
OAG
 .........C8 ..........8

30 Oc
 
  " ! $  :  
  -      


128

http://www.environmental.auditing.org/intosai/w - -..4 ..UM  -8 ..O 


gea.nsp/view.container2/caeng04arft.cesd.ch5fis 5>..   ..C 6..
heries/pdf/$file/caengo4arft.cesdch5fisheries,pdf. ...N  ...M ...
N
D ......f ......Oc.......3 
CESD
http://www.environmental
z Scheldt  k N
auditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewContainer2/nl
eng00ar_sm_deepwestscheldt.pdf/$file/nleng00a
r_sm_deepwestscheldt.pdf
......O_ -f...... ...... 

.)   3  
... 
8 ...O ...=U 
8 MN
http://www.environmental...... -f...... ...... 

auditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewContainer2/uk ...........OOf  ........... 


eng03ar_sm_azovblacksea.pdf/$file/ukeng03ar_s ._ 8 M - T 


......M
.....M .....
m_azovblacksea.pdf
2002-2001 6P H

2004

1999

4


..8 M ..4M
.. i
( 
http://www.oag....4M( ....) 8.... .... 
bvg.gc.ca/domino/reports.nsf/html/c006ce.html/$ ..........N )
..........-c
file/c006ce.pdf
N
.. .. 6..C
Oc    4
CESD - 6
http://www.oag.. ..c ..8-4 .. 
bvg.gc.ca/domino/reports.nsf/html/20040304ce.h ......N < ......;N :......z
tml/$file/20040304ce.pdf
4 ......Oc -......8- ......C
OAG 
(>..... I.....4  ..... 

. N   
http://www.oag.govt.nz/2002/biosecurity/
: ..... z ..... 
...........8 M >
...........f

> .....f / . ... 


.. ..  6.C
. _
http://www.oag.govt.nz/2006/maf/
: ..... z ..... 
...........8 M >
...........f
8 M 6  

.......N (....... .......8


M
. >

f 

2005

!

2000

2004

-2002
2003
2002

4

4
!

2006

4
!

2002 NNNNNNNNNNNNN&
/NN!.1'
!
2003

 

e( 

 [
http://www.rekenkamer.nl/cgibin/as.cgi/0282000/c/start/file=/9282400/module
sf/g02lrziy

129

   z
$
.-

2000

4


      :  


 - +() )( ' & ( 


 2004  ... ...c ...
 
 .. z ) ..=U (.. 5^ ..
K

' T*1
 4:Q  6+ E)S5 ' 2!  zSA
(

^K..N 2004  .. ..- ..
!

-N  z.

^K..N 2003
...U ... 8
..C
!
.
- kUN 2006  x8(.

4
http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d05906.pdf
'!NNNNNNNNN ... > 2005
...8 :...
^K...
 ....M 
....8 ....C
( 4.
  N 5= 4M_ .8
 M 
.8

130

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

 I. : 4 G >1
 )= :(CBD) 6  A
) x. (.8 . !  . cN ..  ( . <.N (. .$i  (.) <!.^=. .
54 8OM   u  cN  4  ( )( 
{ 
4( :(NH
http://www.biodiv.org/doc/legal/cbd-un-en.pdf

(  :1 GC4
-..!N F:.. .. cN I..8 ) .. {..H-..  ..O 
( ..! ..UN .. ..;) M.. ( ..
-f  -C  N 4 W    C  8 8   5. c.  5. . .
5 `N/    <36  = .   . 4 I.    ]. . (.) :.PH . .
=M  F:     4  8  .I
(  : 3 G(4
].. N-.. ..?  ..=> <..H -..M  .. = .. -..( kM ..  ..C ) (..6z..  .N ..
 ! C  ` C - ICN UWH( .U () P-N !./ OP  !
-.N (.) .
 -
PH   > k P _-  UC=` 3>.
(  : 8 G>. E(V
 
>H  W () 
 54  b  4W   I =N  :(N
)(  W ;   > k  M   > k( MN  . .fN =-.M D8 .  .cM  ..
 (.
)( UP ]a $ - 8  P  W   > k  M   > k( .MN
 fN = -M D8  cM    (.
)( <;N      cM   . ( . .P  k> . . M
P ! ] () :PH a  cM !< -f  -C !<.
)( 8 _ ]WN;<   > 5 U cM  ..    .  (.) .M k> .
 U .UM
)( ]WN     C -C )(   > k    > k
 ].  M . .8
 F:! 8 M  >.k
)( 6/  ;<   - ]WN .H  
-.8-! .a.48 5. o.
6P ]a :cN {Uf 
N i 8
PH.
)(  ..W  ..cM  .. <..; 3 .. 
 ..
> ..f
-f..  ..UN >6..
 3 4  M  - 5 N  ( (  M8 48 !  (
^KN
^p. D
  ;) M-f  -C   ( ] :PH () `8  M/ 
> f
Ci.
)( ] P 
 =`  .H  .8
z-.!N (.  <;. . .> 5.H
. /H
)( 
)... (...C
...W  5... k...) ...U-f...  ... M ... ...;) M...
 ( -f  -C  .N 4
)( ..`f  !8
..W (>._
..  ..cM  .. 
) .. ..4   .. ../ f
    H  M `  I H M = 8-   
.cM  .UN  ..
 ( -f  -C  ) ai   k.8
> 5. <!N =UN 8 N
.
.$ M./
oN 
)  4   ]WN W   .C  8 .8 5. .-f. o.N
 
)  4   .

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

131

)(
..a ]..a  .. ..;) M ]8
..W/ ..O ;  ..
..PH  ..8 M..H
 3 4  !-.
)(  -.8-MN -^ (.C4
. .  ..  .  .=> ( .  <.;N I.8 7 <.   .
 =  )  5.UWH
)(  )(
)N <- (  <-  
PH cM P ]  : ) (.
.=c .
c
) 5(  )(  :  () / P F6-  .
(  : 12 G H. 4!j

>H  W () F:P _ -  / f   =  :(N
)( ].a_
. .c <.. T (. (.c-.. .  . I8  -..8-M .cM  .-f..
 -C   (   N 4 .=N 
).:.! <-.  <.-.]. (.$ 8 .  I8
 U -  .
)( 5CMN ]WN yM: () <!C8 cM  .-f.  -.C . (.) ./ P ( .
-   >= =

Np
>H  W ] () :PH  ./ ! ..
c
_ i $  (  (c.( 4
)(  O   < 20 18 16(  uN
8U )( -f =-  (
) (. .M . 
.> ]..a ( . .U  .cM  ..-f.  -.C  . ..
 (.
(  : 13 G    G) 6 
 =N
>H  W  :(NK8
)( cMN ]WN    ;) M  ( . = D8 . .cM .U  .o:.
 W 6P 5  36i 5 `N F:  a )( 
 T
 <.
)(   ].  36 =8
U-.  ; . - .
.PH )
8.UN (.
. T  .(.
 ] () :PH  8 M-f  -C   (.
(  G51 : 14 G er y>E er  <Q
  >
 5
>H  W   54 o)( _-  N  4=   (:
)( P
i    ( <=N
^K( 
W  =
_ (  5  M 48 

^KN   C4  ( ] 


 IN xcP F:
^K   54 o.  .C
  W   )( ? F:
i.
)( P 
N 6 ` 
  I ! F:
 T  C  5. (. . M
48 !  (C4
^KN  (.
)( ]WN D 
.f .UPi .N   .  .W ) . (. .=> U.WH
 U  _6O
   <! / f(  5  M  (C4
Y 4W
^pN  (
-..
..PH   ..P k> ..  ..OP  ]..WN k..8
> 5.. (>..
..N ? ..3.. i
 -
>H _48 C . 36 o
)( )-._ . _ (.
.a
.UP .U (.) P-.8 <.  _6.O 
 . . (.) ( .
  k> .. U.. b..MN .. ..8
..P
..P I..86..i ).. -..  ..?  .. M:..

Uf `
o:- )( fN
 ] ? xcP: 
Uf `
.

132

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

)(
8UN
N =    U UW" 3 -._H .4N -. (.  (.> I.C

..Y o..
..a ..? N -.. (.
..UP.. <..  ( .. ]..WN .. -..(  <-..!..
>  54> {UP ]a 
W  5-    4 O  .cf
)( ..=8 
Np..
..>H  ..W  .. ..  5.. F:..cN <..N .. .. ..` u..Mc - ..C
_6/i -(   5 `N _i  -8- 5 x8
aH C  ( .
 ? 48 :  K$ . {=) (P
(  :15 GX  ( *

-1 .=M  ..C-.. 8  . .. ..U -..8-MN U.../  . .. ..
4M a P > !N 8
WN> .
(C8 -2  5
>H  W 8
 !C./  . . -f.6 .
   C U
>H  W
PH - )
 N ] - F: cN
.

YH -3 F: <N  cN-    


> U  5
>H  W <NF
.
)( F: .
-4 N 16 19 )={  <.N-.<  U.>
.  .W  (. (.  F:.! K.W
   k8
> 5
>H O_ 58:     )= ! F:.  cN
I8 -5 <8/   54 o)=  )=    O ]`f8 F: .
-6/      ]`fN)= 
>" =C  W  = .?  - F:. . 
=8
> -8-MN <N
P  oN U
>H .
C8 -7 >
 5
>H  W 
8U :cN MH     -    
 = - U.
.>H  .W
.PH  ]. .W  . 4 . 5.4 o. o.
.>H
 W .
:..f8 -8
..> ..  5..
..>H  ..W
.. 8
..WN ..8   ..  ].. k..cN ..
 16 5N - 19`
6P 5     O ! 6.P 5.  .,20 5N
-! 21  W   =8
U  C T3  8 yM
8Uc -3   5.-f.
 .. -f..
..PH  ..  ].. ..
..>H  ..W -..=8 58:.. ? ..F:..
  ? . F: C  
W>   )=    .

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

133

(  :16 GX   <


 5
-1 >
 5
>H  W -8   WN  4  4  . ./
 .. .. 4=! 5.. ..
..>H  ..W 5..
..8
../!  k..=M ..-.. F:..
 I..8 .. cN ..8  ..`f ..4_H F:.. ..  V.. /
..CN../  ..=..

..>" .. 4  ..W
..PH  = ..cM  ..  ..-f..  -..C ..
 ( -f     IC8  4W
a
UP  .
-2 /  =   4 W  ) 
=c - (1) = C   I.8 /V. 8

C8)= 
W     36 (
$  WN  8 5. .! kc `cN5 .
)=       => a < 20 21 . 5.4 . _ (.) . o. . 4

 a f 
P _=   4 8
4c
PH I8 .? <8:. ./ =.
 ($ 8 4W8) ] k 8 M=M  c   4 8
4c4 kUN F:
.=c )= .
] 
=c 5 4 3 : 58 .F
:f8 -3 >
 5
>H  W
8
WN 8  -.! . 36 . N-.8

>H  W / P-   ( -=N   kM ->6    4
= .. .. 4 5.. -c..CN (.. F:.. ..  .. o..  .. ..cN  .. 5 ..`8o..
  4(
 8 M ] N 
P _=   4 8
4c
PH )( _  `

6..P 5. k..UN_ ..4  .. 21 20 5N>= ..= .. -..(  ].. (..$ 8 ...5 4 5N
..=c
 : N  .F
:f8 -4 >
 5
>H  W
8
WN 8   -.!  36 !.CN
P = U  f  
8U=   4 W ! ) (.
.=c V .O .  (1) <.
5.. ..! ..  ..4M= ..U  ..f  -..   ..) ..:.. K..W  ..
..> ..
   ( ! `N
=c .  3 2 1
N -5
>H  W (

=N 
P _=.   .4 .8
4c
.PH (.
 :cN 
^pN - F: ()  cN: KW >=  8
W > =  -.( K -.
F:=M <-N-)! 
C3 N ! .
( : 19 G  68 <
  1! V!
:..f8 -1
..> ..  5..
..>H   -..
.. 8
..WN ..8  k..=M .. 36 ..
 ..W  ..) .. c..M U..W  .. 4  .. 5.. ..
..>H  ..W ../ P
-   ( -=N    ! F:M _? 48 
>" 8-  W .
:f8 -2 >
 5
>H  W ]
i   
. T8 5.CMN .8./
 ..  D.. .. ..C 5.. 8
..>H  ..W (..) ../ P-..  ../ .. T3 ..
  )]    5  4  =   3    = 5. .- F:.
.>H
 W  
$ <8 cN !   4W .

N -3
>H  W   M
 ]aN -M8
. i <8-.=N 5 .`8 MM.O
    cN   )(  =  5  ] -f. -. (._ 53 .
  5 TN  4  ( 48 - ! 8 _  (C4
^KN  (
-f  -C .
=8 -4  >
 5
>H  W 
$  =8
U  (.> uf.$  .
.3 4  ( U bMN  .W ! (.) .
.=c ) <8-.= .  (3  .  _5. .
134

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

-f
 6C  ! 
U  W  -.  ]. . F:. .3 4 o:.
  _  5.
^K. (.C4 .3 4 5.4  -.M 
.?N (. . 
.U  .W
: =-  F: 3 4.
(  :26 G 5!
-=8  >
 5.
.>H  .W 
.) . -.M8 .cf 
Np.
.>H .=N -5.
8

.. i  <..N (.. fN :..c .._ ..4 F:.. .. cN-.. ) ! k..=MN (..) ..H-.. 
F:..! ..C3
   cN -=N  .
Np

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

135

Q -5 G I.(
(1992) (    cN
<  :2007 
  zN : 2007 IPCC 
  zN  _4M 5  
] =< 

8
=( )( H      C .   C( a uf 
.Mc/ 18 
  zN  _4M 5   5 O
(http://www.biodiv.org)

(http://www.ipcc.ch/SPM2feb07.pdf )

.(2003)  
] 
 VC  T3  :(2004)       

(http://www.environmentalauditing.org/intosai/wgea.nsf/viewContainerPub/fourth_survey_environmental_auditing.pdf/$file/fourth_
survey_environmental_auditing.pdf),

5U$ C?
8 U :
W 6 ;<  : (2005) c" (=< ; N
(http://www.maweb.org/documents/document.356.aspx.pdf) .Mc/ 137  / 
-! ZKN -(   :
W 6 ;<  : (2005) c" (=< ; N
.Mc/ 86  /  5U$    
(http://www.maweb.org/documents/document.354.aspx.pdf )

ZKN - F  ( 
> aH :
W 6 ;<  : (2005) c" (=< ; N
.Mc/ 68  /  5U$      -!
(http://www.maweb.org/documents/document.358.aspx.pdf )

 -! ZKN -
MO :
W 6 ;<  : (2005) c" (=< ; N
(http://www.maweb.org/documents/document.355.aspx.pdf ).Mc/ 26  /  5U$   
aH H -  :
W 6 ;<  : (2005) c" (=< ; N

C_ -$ ZKN -     N aH T3  :  M N
.Mc/ 917  /  5U$
8  U  c 4
(http://www.maweb.org/en/Condition.aspx )

H^
KN ZcfN P  ] 8 $  : (2002) (    cN  
. H 5>    ;< -!N ( 8
z
(http://www.biodiv.org/programmes/cross-cutting/alien/decision-v8.shtml?dec=VI/23&menu=crosscutting&filter=alien ),

81 8
 (   ;
^     ( :(2006) (    cN  
(http://www.biodiv.org/gbo2/default.shtml). Mc/ 7 +
:    6C (2003)  -M < H T 
    ( cN  
. Mc/ 20   6C 4N N 
-=
(http://www.biodiv.org/doc/press/presskits/bs/cpbs-unep-cbd-en.pdf

. Mc/ 416 (   ;
^ ?    ( : (2002)  -M < H T 

(http://www.unep.org/Geo/geo3/ )

.    _ C {UP ]a : (  _  C : (2003)  -M < H T 



(http://www.unep.org/pdf/Tourism-and-biodiversity.pdf )

 $    ( ;


M  k>  
8
=N : (2004)  -M < H T 

(http://quin..unep-wcmc.org/resoources/publications/pa-biodiv/). C3
 8 `=
100 2006         $ ;
: (2006)  -M < H T 

(http://www.unep.org/geo/yearbook/yb2006/). Mc/

 
  " ! $  :  
  -      


136

:(2006) 8
 M 5   !
H  cM  cN  -M < H T 

68   . 8
 M
  zN ^
KN : 
  zN  !
H
(http://www.cms.int/publications/pdf/CMS_CimateChange.pdf). Mc/
H IC (   -=) ]  $ : (2000)(IUCN) (   8 M MN
(http://www.iucn.org/themes/ssc/publications/policy/invasivesEng.htm). 8
z P-

137

      :  


 - +() )( ' & ( 

 I. : 6 G<( ( '2 E


 cN  (.
CBD
CITES  cN - )(   N M 
8 
.
Uf a
 cN cM  H  !
 5M  N 
.8
CMS

 .
EA
  4(.
EI
<=N
^K(.
EIA
.4_
Y   ; ENGO
 I4
]   8  -M.
GAO
6!CN    .
GEF
3 )  -;
`8 3 _ .(-
GMO
  >U k ! .
IBA
IBAMA ! -
 (8   U - 
.8
  cN- .
IEA
INTOSAI ;  - " !  
 .
 MN -(  cM   U    C8) U `8 MN  cM -((.
IUCN
3 _ . -
LMO
 a   . yM
LOE
- .  cH
MDG
.
ME
<=N; ( ".c
MA
 
.8
MMA
NBSAP
.. N ..  ..UP>.. .. ..O) ( .. ! (..) .. .. cN..
 ((.
;  .4_
Y
NGO
! . 
 H
SAI
    .
SEAM
UNCCD  cN <H -M  M) 4.
MO
 ; UNESCO <H -M 
  ?= ).
 cN
  (.
WHC

     WGEA  .


WSSD=        -C.

138

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

139

Q : 7 I. (.S2
4 ( :
 . -.M  -..!N . 
 . . .. F/  .C :.  .. I.
 ..5 ..`N -.

  T3  - 8
 <8=NH.
S ( :
 > _-  a 
.
 ! ( :
( 
$p (  <=N 54 8 !=8
> 5  a.

 : 6
  5 )   3 4  :M
8 8
M 3  ;H 
 ( . -.N
! .. :.. 5 ..`8.. D..c ..P..  5....H  ..cf .. ;H ..  ..W8:..

Z8 N M Ci  3 4  M =-  .! / f . ;H.
( . !U=N

5 
 
EQ :6
(.. ..H 5H .. ..z H .. ../OP  ..  !-.. ..H  >..CN (.. ..

> f( )=- >!  k  T8
. F
<
:  68 .:G
(  3 4  () M<    N  3 4  =-_  =U < -M.
  '  :
) 8 `=  k8  .fN  .ON (.  6.CN (. . U.WH .4M)=.= .5
 
8 .. .. C  .. .. 58..C ..M-..( )_..48 y..  ( ..  o..;
.. ..`8

 ; .
>1
 :6
!N <N^   H  1992 <N 188 . 5. .! k8-O .-.  . 5. 2006
N F:  cN-  8 M  . .M 6.P 5.  .W  . M >
.
.P<.8 .
8 _ `8H  
CITES

Uf a(  cN - ) (..H  
.a

Uf(   b .1973
(  ( a :
( 5 4$ 4$   5.
 .
.W 
 .   . 5.4 8 .4N F:.

 ..
 .. 
..W .. = .. ..Oc
8 
  ..

..8
= ..  .. (.._-..
 = ) ai.Oc M
8
(  ( 
:

140

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

( 
 8 ^ ?
 5 ! H  
   )(  b_ -k8
) k8
> 5 54

   5 =C !  
  = U.C F
8
=N - 8
.W  .4M .!8 (.
 !   W8=

8 ;_6 /  T3 = -.
 :.2

N . 
 I.C . (.) .  k> .= _ .  ) . .$ ) . .$
> .(.
 !) bCN ? 
z   P UWH.8
W
( C:
=
Np - <H -M  5   ) .) (UNCED.8
 .  . .1992 . :.
 -_  ? 
Np (.) (C3! -. (  . :.   ]. . .W  .   :.-.
-/ - 105   "." 8

s :6+
 
) I  5 M  N  3 4  .M .=- ]. .!N6 cN
.Y ..M
_-  .
 < :6+
 - ; (    O M/
. )
).N (.  .  -.f .U
 cM    ( .

 (:D^ Q
  _- N  cON -M =U () {=) -.
(  :+

 (..  ..! .. ..a  .. 


 ..H  .. .. (.. ? ..  .. C 
.. T..
 I   C _ .4
.P  .  .  
i . k.  .
 5.4 8 .
 <`N )  
 ? :
   
  = U
 H.
 :j2A
 8 ) ai  F   8:z : ;<  8
M( pN   8 ) .  (. .  .

zN Y

Y )! 4.$ (.) . .c; .  .(.  I.Of . . . M .
 8:z .
>. E (^: D
 cM   4   .P ( . >! . . (.U ) (. .-._ .? 5 k3.M
  _ Z-M k3 N_H  3 4  O  8
M  .
' 5:
 cP    5  3 4  5 M  )(    >.k
' F :
 _  -   )(  -   =U =O.

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

141

(  ( :

 V CN  = <3  


] -. K.W .8  .  b. F:.=. <.N -. <3-. 5.
] _( H   >} => -C  -M -i =
8  .;
: `8
.
; .
c   C !=:
( M 
8U H ( <N U/   U 
.a 8
>2 :e

4 ..  ..  x.. M.. ) (..8-..MN ..  ..
..) .. ..
-fCN $} `8  -       cO  ^.
(^:D
  ( !) 8M  (
N   )(  <   z M  N.U
>. E(^: D
  cM  ; (  > 5 U_  .H  K .=  .M . .P
 !UM (U) . _ ..H  > .  b.MN (. (.) .8 . .UN y._ .UM
!O3 OP  .
 C :E4
(  3 4  M (.) P-.N (.; . N 5.48 <. y._ (. -. > .) .6.P 5. o.
 > W -.  8
.W -. 
.Y --.8-!N 4.WN o:. . ". ./H
.N .H
 P-H  `8  8
z   .
'.1 4>. 6 )   S( :IOCN  S
;
) MN  cM   <(.
(  ( a:
( 

 k8
) k8
> 5 :cN  4 
 5  ! 5 5 58 
  ?
_y
=8 -

8
=N  _ - ] () F
W o- 
W.
 C= 6^ C( 4:
 >
 5
>H )(  cN C   P ] _  -H H >i . .! P
)( = -8-MN
8   =>  3H (a
> H  -  -M   I. cN

: : 4  c
( 3 _ 5 cN o N ^ -f  o   4  .?8-M
4 : (
 >C
)(  
2000
191 6  c <H -M :  - .  cH

142

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

- cH -M  5. . 5. -.M


.=c-.  M.O <. .C  5. . H
 /  W    M  .2015
! (>^ 68([?! :
NKN 8  8:.z ?
 . . 
.  5c.Cc   F . 5. .  .  .M .cf
 . ..MN (..  .. ..
f )`6.. M .. . -....P o..N 8:..z 
..M
!H   54 8 8
M () ICN.IOf
  C:
( 
 )  c  O -fCN   ! ! . 5. !8-. . . 
 a f
)( . !C :cN
 (:Q:
  3 
WH (a
> H  -.
(  
: s
( K 5 - C  !  KC  a f u.M) 5 .`8 o <.=N6.C  .
- 
_ = <3  K 5 - C  }  4M
 .4  .. ;H
  .. 6 ..  -.. <..=N  ..` ..  .  = . 5.. V3 ..C
 8  ..
 ..
- P
 !c3      36=
i 8( !N:.fN! .
 .a f .
- 5
8
=N  a  / 5. .N =
  .  .
.8 (. ! . . 
 .H

a O)i ! .
(  :
( - ; (  
_ - /H 8-N
Ua.

1  C :
..
8. U..H (3 .. i -..8-  .. b.. ) ..O_-.. ^ <..=
..Y 5. cf 5..Oc b ..C
  5N!.5
 C :
(    5 3 4 ! =-  ! 4W 5 (P 5 D 54`  5
P.

( (4 Q:
(   ( N_   M 6Pi =-  H =  KW N_ . !N
'& 4A (4 Q:
 -f. 
./  . .=8
U .cfp.N  .C  . -. -. -. .
 ( -  ) M8 o: !N   4_  H 
a M  .=C
C= 6^:
() )( ' & (   - + 
  :     

143

(  _ C 4N   !) F(   
(C3  () <4M _ F M -. NF:.
H48 y_ (a C  . /-. 
= .  VU. 5.H _.4N y. H  .Uz
  .Ma F
]  ;_6)  cN C( " (.a
> .;:.
. ) . cN .C( (.) 3-3 -. b.MNF:.
 .
.1 >. )  :G
-8 MN  cM   < ] .cM 4.$  . <.`8 y._ < . .MN  82 . . 111
 _ 4?
 4_
Y  ; 800 5 _( < . 10.000 181 5.
.P(.) .

$      . . ! uf.N .MN ) (.


^K. ].WN <-.N   . ) (. . .M
 <   4N 8 MN K U 5 - -f.  . 4. .U  . -.C
 5 _ 
W8 o: MN ) 
_  3( "  !-  =
 C  < .
 (:   (:6
(     3]  f 
 5 
  ( _- )
;  <H -.M 
 ..
?= ) ) (4C .? N F:.= . . 3  5.
. ?= () . (.U
N (. . .
.
  (        .

144

     
 
 -     : $ " !  
 

() )( ' & (   - + 


  :     

145

You might also like