Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword
Like this
4Activity
P. 1
Heidegger, Derrida, and the Aporia of Death

Heidegger, Derrida, and the Aporia of Death

Ratings: (0)|Views: 227 |Likes:
Published by Rafael Pangilinan

More info:

Categories:Types, Research
Published by: Rafael Pangilinan on Nov 15, 2010
Copyright:Traditional Copyright: All rights reserved

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

11/18/2012

pdf

 
NWJDBL. _kn" 0<. Bk"0. Kcxk`gp 09<9. DSSB 0948*<<66 FKNT BLJG WBD_GPSDXT
 
< ko 04
FGDHGMMGP. HGPPDHL. LBH XFG LYKPDL KO HGLXF
Plolgn H" Ylbmdndblb. J"L"Wbdvgpsdxt ko Slbxk XkjlsGsylül Sx". Jlbdnl
DBXPKHWCXDKB
Alc|wgs Hgppdhl ds bk} mgbgplnnt lmpggh‘`t `kxf hgvkxggs lbh cpdxdcs lndeg‘xk `g kbgko xfg jksx dbonwgbxdln yfdnkskyfgps ko xfg nlxg x}gbxdgxf cgbxwpt" Xk ywx dx sdjynt. Alc|wgsHgppdhl `gcljg bkx awsx kbg ko xfg `gsx*ebk}b bljgs db ckbxgjykplpt yfdnkskyft db xfg <4=9slbh <469s. `wx skjgxfdbm ko l jghdl yfgbkjgbkb }fksg oljg sxpgxcfgh olp `gtkbh xfg }lnns ko xfg wbdvgpsdxt" Fds jkhg ko yfdnkskyft‘}fdcf |wdcent lc|wdpgh xfg oljkws kp bkxkpdkws `plbhbljg ko ‖hgckbsxpwcxdkb—‘fls dbonwgbcgh lnjksx gvgpt lclhgjdc hdscdyndbg opkj lpx fdsxkpt xkscdgbcgs" Okp Hgppdhl. fds glpnt gynkplxdkbs ko xfg ypk`ngj ko }pdxdbm db }gsxgpb xfkwmfx kbntpgypgsgbxgh xfg `gmdbbdbm ko l jwcf }dhgp gb|wdpt lbh fds jlbt sw`sg|wgbx xgxs hgvgnky xfdsxfgjg db bg}. sdbmwnlp lbh swpypdsdbm hdpgcxdkbs" Loxgp xfg <4?9s. fg }gbx kb xk gynkpg swcfhdvgpsg lpgls. xfgjgs lbh hdscdyndbgs ls lpx lbh lpcfdxgcxwpg. ndxgplxwpg. ndbmwdsxdcs. ykndxdcs lbhdbxgpblxdkbln pgnlxdkbs. ystcfklblntsds. pgndmdkws sxwhdgs lbh xfgknkmt. xgcfbknkmt lbh xfg jghdl.lbh }dxbgssdbm lbh xgsxdjkbt" Opkj xfg <469s kb}lphs. dx lnsk `gckjgs ykssd`ng xk hgxgcx lbdbcpglsdbmnt jlpegh ‖gxfdcln— kp ‖ykndxdcln— xwpb db Hgppdhl—s }kpe lbh xfkwmfx" Xfg yfdnkskyfgplx nglsx lyyglps xk jkvg l}lt opkj xfg sggjdbmnt l`sxplcx yfdnkskyfdcln |wgsxdkbs ko xfg glpndgp}kpe lbh xk mplvdxlxg xk}lphs ckbcpgxg ykndxdcln ypk`ngjs swcf ls lylpxfgdh. xfg olnn ko ckjjwbdsj lbh xfg owxwpg ko Gwpkyg" Xfds djypgssdkb ds ckbodpjgh `t xfg lyyglplbcg ko lbdbcpglsdbmnt gxfdcln‘gvgb xfgknkmdcln‘vkcl`wnlpt db xfg nlxgp }kpe }fdcf hpl}s kb swcfxfgjgs ls xfg mdox. slcpdodcg. xfg djykssd`ng. lbh ygpflys jksx dbxpdmwdbmnt. xfg jgssdlbdc"Xfds ylygp }dnn bkx ckjypgfgbsdvgnt xfpgsf kwx xfg gbxdpg hgckbsxpwcxdvg ypkagcx ko Hgppdhl
vdl
bgmkxdlxdbm fds jkpg xflb ?9 `kkes xplbsnlxgh dbxk Gbmndsf. ls }gnn ls fds bwjgpkwsgsslts lbh jlbwscpdyxs db Opgbcf xflx lpg sxdnn wblvldnl`ng okp Gbmndsf pglhgpsfdy" Dbsxglh. dx }dnnckbcgbxplxg kb xfg gylxdlxdkb ko Hgppdhl—s hgckbsxpwcxdkb ko Jlpxdb Fgdhgmmgp—s gdsxgbxdlnlblntsds ko Hlsgdb—s hglxf db
 @gdbm lbh Xdjg
.
<
}fdcf Hgppdhl xfgkpdqgh ls lykpgxdc. xfpkwmflnnwsdkbs xk fds
 Lykpdls
lbh kxfgp pgnlxgh }pdxdbms"Db
 Lykpdls
. Hgppdhl lses1 Clb }g `g „cgpxldb‚ ko hglxf; Bkx ko }flx jdmfx flyygb loxgphglxf.
0
`wx ko xfg „`pwxg‚ olcx xflx glcf ko ws }dnn jggx }dxf fds kp fgp k}b hglxf; Okp SdmjwbhOpgwh. }fk fls ggpxgh l ckbsdhgpl`ng dbonwgbcg kb Hgppdhl. dx ds djykssd`ng xk djlmdbg kwp k}bhglxf. ngx lnkbg `g cgpxldb l`kwx dx. `gclwsg }fgbgvgp }g lxxgjyx xk hk sk }g clb ygpcgdvg xflx}g lpg db olcx sxdnn ypgsgbx ls sygcxlxkps" Db olcx. }g ckwnh slt xflx }g lssdsx lx kwp k}b hglxf. lsdo xfg kbg }fk hdgs db kwp djlmdblxdkb }gpg l hdoogpgbx ygpskb" ]g clbbkx djlmdbg fk} }g}kwnh `g ndeg hglh. }dxfkwx `gdbm l`ng xk xfdbe kp sgg. okp gljyng" ]g clbbkx lccgyx kwp k}bhglxf5 lx `kxxkj bk kbg `gndgvgs db fds k}b hglxf" Ls Opgwh cnldjs. db xfg wbckbscdkws gvgpt kbgko ws ds ckbvdbcgh ko fds k}b djjkpxlndxt" Xfgpg ds bk sgbsg ko xfg ylsslmg ko xdjg5 xdjg hkgsbkx }kpe cfpkbknkmdclnnt db kwp wbckbscdkws" Xfds wbckbscdkws `gndgo xflx bkxfdbm clb flyygb xk
 
NWJDBL. _kn" 0<. Bk"0. Kcxk`gp 09<9. DSSB 0948*<<66 FKNT BLJG WBD_GPSDXT
 
0 ko 04
ws jlt `g sggb ls xfg sgcpgx ko fgpkdsj" Sdbcg }g flvg bkx mkbg xfpkwmf xfg gygpdgbcg ko hglxf&ls }g flvg bgvgp hdgh `gokpg$ lbh sdbcg hglxf hkgs bkx gdsx db kwp wbckbscdkws. }g clbbkxlcxwlnnt oglp hglxf dxsgno" ]fgb }g slt }g lpg lopldh ko hglxf. lcckphdbm xk Opgwh. }g jlt oglpskjgxfdbm gnsg‘swcf ls l`lbhkbjgbx. clsxplxdkb. vlpdkws wbpgsknvgh ckbondcxs. kp kxfgp}dsg oglpko hglxf jlt `g xfg kwxckjg ko l sgbsg ko mwdnx" Tgx Opgwh lnsk sygcdodgs xflx oglp ko hglxfhkjdblxgs ws koxgbgp xflb }g ebk}" Dx ds bkx ljdss xk bkxg xflx fg yksdxs xfg gdsxgbcg ko hglxfhpdvg. l hgsxpwcxdvg hpdvg. }fdcf fls lb ldj xk nglh }flx ds ndvdbm dbxk lb dbkpmlbdc sxlxg" „Xfgldj ko lnn ndog ds hglxf.‚
3
fg sldh" Xfds nglhs Opgwh xk xfg ylplhkdcln ckbcnwsdkb xflx ndog ds lhgxkwp kb xfg }lt xk hglxf. `lsgh kb „xfg hpdvg xk pgxwpb xk xfg dblbdjlxg sxlxg"‚
8
 Sggb db xfds ndmfx. xfg xfgkpgxdcln djykpxlbcg ko xfg hpdvgs ko sgno ypgsgpvlxdkb. ko sgno lssgpxdkb lbh ko jlsxgpt mpglxnt hdjdbdsfgs U Z ]g flvg bk nkbmgp xk pgcekb}dxf xfg kpmlbdsj—s ywqqndbm hgxgpjdblxdkb xk jldbxldb dxs k}b gdsxgbcg db xfgolcg ko gvgpt k`sxlcng" ]flx }g lpg ngox }dxf ds xfg olcx xflx xfg kpmlbdsj }dsfgsxk hdg kbnt db dxs k}b olsfdkb"‚
7
Sgno*ypgsgpvlxdvg hpdvgs lpg ckbsgpvlxdvg hpdvgs.`gclwsg xfgt gbswpg xflx xfg kpmlbdsj }dnn hdg „kbnt db dxs k}b olsfdkb"
?
 Xfds jlegs ndog cdpcwdxkws ylxfs xk hglxf. oldxfownnt egyx `t xfg ckbsgpvlxdvg hpdvgs lbhynlcgs xfg sxpwmmng okp ndog. lbh sk lnsk xfg Gpkxdc hpdvgs db xfg sgpvdcg ko xfg hglxf hpdvg"
=
Xfgpgygxdxdkb ckjywnsdkb xfgpgokpg kvgppdhgs xfg ynglswpg ypdbcdyng. pgynlcdbm xfg sxpdvdbm okpynglswpg }dxf l sxpdvdbm okp hglxf"Gvgb xfkwmf Opgwh lhjdxs xflx hglxf ds skjgxfdbm blxwpln. }g hk xpt xk hgln }dxf dx dbvlpdkws }lts. lbh }g pglcx xk dx hdoogpgbxnt" Kwp hdoogpgbx lxxdxwhgs xk}lphs hglxf jlt lcckwbxokp xfg gdsxgbcg ko vlpdkws `gflvdkps. okp xfg cpglxdkb ko `gndgos swcf ls xfksg db ndog loxgp hglxf"Ko ckwpsg. dx ds kwp wbckbscdkws xflx ds xfg clwsg ko jksx ko kwp `gndgos lbh `gflvdkps. kp gvgboggndbms db pgnlxdkb xk hglxf"Lmldb okp Opgwh. bkbg ko ws fls „cgpxldbxt‚ }dxf pgmlph xk hglxf" ]g lnn slt „D ebk} D ljmkdbm xk hdg.‚ `wx hggy hk}b. `gfdbh xfg kbg*}lt jdppkp ko xfg wbckbscdkws. xfg lpcfdvlnpgyksdxkpt ko xfg pgypgssgh. bkbg ko ws `gndgvgs dx" Okp Fgdhgmmgp. kb xfg kxfgp flbh. hglxf dsjkpg cgpxldb‘kp `gxxgp. ds cgpxldb db l jkpg „ypdjkphdln‚ &
wpsypþbmsndcfg
$ }lt‘xflb gydsxgjdccgpxldbxt kp gvgb ckmbdxdvg cgpxldbxt" Fgdhgmmgp ds bk segyxdc5 okp fdj. „fknhdbm xk xfg xpwxf ko hglxf‘}fdcf ls }g }dnn sgg jglbs jldbxldbdbm kwpsgnvgs db xfg wbckbcglnghbgss ko xfgyfgbkjgbkb ko kwp k}b hglxf‘pgvglns l cgpxldbxt }fdcf ds l`sknwxgnt `lsdc xk xfg xkxlndxt ko ndvgh ckbxgxs ckbsxdxwxdbm }kpnh dbxgnndmd`dndxt" Ls `gdbm*db*xfg*}kpnh &
 Db*hgp*}gnx*Sgdb
$. Hlsgdbhdgs5 xfgpg ds bkxfdbm jkpg cgpxldb1 „Jkpg kpdmdbln xflb jlb ds xfg odbdxwhg ko xfg Hlsgdb }dxfdbfdj"‚
6
 Do. lcckphdbmnt. Fgdhgmmgp lbh Opgwh lpg xlegb ls x}k gxpgjg cflplcxgpdqlxdkbs ko xfgckmbdxdvg pgnlxdkb kbg sxlbhs db pgnlxdkb xk kbg—s k}b hglxf. xfgb dx `gckjgs glsdgp xk djlmdbg}ft Hgppdhl jdmfx lse swcf l sxplbmg. ygpflys dbcpghd`ng. |wgsxdkb5 okp xfds sggjs xk `g lbdppgckbcdnl`ng kyyksdxdkb. lb gdxfgp+kp ko xfg xtyg bkxkpdkwsnt jksx vwnbgpl`ng xk Hgppdhl—shgckbsxpwcxdkbs" Xfws. }fgb Hgppdhl lses. „Ds jt hglxf ykssd`ng;‚ fg ds bkx sdjynt sygcwnlxdbmls xk }fgxfgp kbg clb `g cgpxldb ko hglxf—s k`xldbdbm5 fds ds l jkpg plhdcln |wgsxdkbdbm1 Clb D
 
NWJDBL. _kn" 0<. Bk"0. Kcxk`gp 09<9. DSSB 0948*<<66 FKNT BLJG WBD_GPSDXT
 
3 ko 04
hdg; Ds dx gvgb ykssd`ng okp jg xk hdg; Clb D jggx }dxf hglxf; Db }flx sgbsg clb hglxf flyygb xkjg‘clb „dx‚ flyygb xk „jg‚ lx lnn;
HGCKBSXPWCXDKB1 XTDBM XFG EBKX XDMFXGP
4
 
Hgckbsxpwcxdkb ds lb lyypklcf. dbxpkhwcgh `t Opgbcf yfdnkskyfgp Alc|wgs Hgppdhl. }fdcfpdmkpkwsnt ywpswgs xfg jglbdbm ko l xgx xk xfg ykdbx ko wbhkdbm xfg kyyksdxdkbs kb }fdcf dx dslyylpgbxnt okwbhgh. lbh xk xfg ykdbx ko sfk}dbm xflx xfksg okwbhlxdkbs lpg dppghwcd`nt ckjyng.wbsxl`ng kp djykssd`ng" Dx mgbgplnnt xpdgs xk hgjkbsxplxg xflx lbt xgx fls jkpg xflb kbgdbxgpypgxlxdkb5 xflx xfg xgx dxsgno ndbes xfgsg dbxgpypgxlxdkbs dbgxpdcl`nt5 xflx xfg dbckjylxd`dndxtko xfgsg dbxgpypgxlxdkbs ds dppghwcd`ng5 lbh xfws xflx lb dbxgpypgxlxdvg pglhdbm clbbkx mk `gtkbh lcgpxldb ykdbx" Hgppdhl pgogps xk xfds ykdbx ls lb lykpdl db xfg xgx. lbh xgpjs hgckbsxpwcxdvgpglhdbm „lykpgxdc‚" @t hgjkbsxplxdbm xfg lykpdls lbh gnndysgs ko xfkwmfx. Hgppdhl fkygh xk sfk}xfg dbodbdxgnt sw`xng }lts xflx xfds kpdmdblpt ckjyngdxt. }fdcf `t hgodbdxdkb clbbkx gvgp `gckjyngxgnt ebk}b. }kpes dxs sxpwcxwpdbm lbh hgsxpwcxwpdbm googcxs" Lb lykpgxdc pglhdbm clb. dblhhdxdkb. sfk} xfg oldnwpg ko glpndgp yfdnkskyfdcln stsxgjs &ndeg xflx ko Fgdhgmmgp$ lbh xfgbgcgssdxt ko ckbxdbwdbm xk yfdnkskyfdqg xfpkwmf xfgj }dxf hgckbsxpwcxdkb"Xfg `kke 
 Lykpdls
. l pgnlxdvgnt pgcgbx lhhdxdkb db l nkbm ndbg ko Hgppdhl—s dbxgpypgxlxdkb ko Fgdhgmmgp—s xfdbedbm. ds swpgnt `gsx fglph ls sygledbm kwx ko xfg pdcf fgpdxlmg ko xflx ndbglmg"
<9
 Xfg xgpj „lykpdl‚ ndxgplnnt jglbs „bkbylsslmg‚ kp „}dxfkwx ylsslmg‚ lbh dbvknvgs lb gygpdgbcgko bkx ebk}dbm }flx ylxf xk oknnk} kp ckjdbm xk xfg ykdbx }fgpg bk ylxf clb `g okwbh"— LsHgppdhl ykdbxs kwx. xfg gygpdgbcg ko xfg lykpdl ds bkx lx lnn okpgdmb xk xfg yfdnkskyfdclnxplhdxdkb"
<<
Db olcx. oknnk}dbm Fgdhgmmgp. Hgppdhl bkxgs fk}. gsygcdlnnt db Elbx lbh Fgmgn. xfggygpdgbcg ko xfg lykpdl ds pgbhgpgh hdlngcxdclnnt kp hdlngcxdcdqgh"
<0
Fk}gvgp. Hgppdhl cfkksgsxfg xgpj lykpdl dbsxglh ko „lbxdbkjt‚ &}fdcf Elbx. ko ckwpsg. wsgs$ sdbcg lb lbxdbkjt dbvknvgs„ckbxplhdcxdkbs kp lbxlmkbdsjs ljkbm g|wlnnt djygplxdvg nl}s‚ xflx clb `g sknvgh kp kvgpckjg.}fgpgls lb lykpdl dbvknvgs lb dppghwcd`ng lbh ckbsxdxwxdvg gygpdgbcg ko djykssd`dndxt kpbkbylsslmg"
<3
Xfg ckbxplhdcxdkb ko g|wlnnt vlndh lbh bgcgsslpt ypkyksdxdkbs okwbh db lblbxdbkjt ds sknvgh `t sfk}dbm fk} dx ds „lyylpgbx kp dnnwskpt.‚ `t hdlngcxdcdqdbm xfgckbxplhdcxdkb db l Fgmgndlb kp Jlpdsx jlbbgp. kp `t pgbhgpdbm dx ls l „xplbscgbhgbxln dnnwsdkb dbl hdlngcxdc ko xfg Elbxdlb xtyg"‚
<8
 Db ckbxplsx xk xfgsg gygpdgbcgs ko xfg lykpdl. xfg hgckbsxpwcxdvg lpxdcwnlxdkb ko xfg lykpdlsfk}s dx xk `g dppghwcd`ng lbh ckbsxdxwxdvg xk xfg hgmpgg xflx dx clbbkx `g kvgpckjg" ]fdng lFgmgndlb kp Jlpdsx xfkwmfx. okp gljyng. }kwnh gynkdx xfg ckbsxdxwxdvg lbh bgcgsslpt blxwpg ko xfg lykpdl db kphgp xk gbmgbhgp l hdlngcxdcln ypkmpgssdkb. okp Hgppdhl xfg dppghwcd`ng lbhdbxgpjdbl`ng blxwpg ko xfg lykpdl }dnn ln}lts hdspwyx xfds ypkmpgss `t sfk}dbm fk} xfkwmfx lbhlcxdkb pgjldb clwmfx db xfg jkvgjgbx ko xfg „hkw`ng `dbh"‚
<7
Dbsxglh ko `gdbm sw`nlxgh kpkvgpckjg. xfg lykpdl okp hgckbsxpwcxdkb `gckjgs xfg vgpt kphgln ko lnn gygpdgbcg" Xfg lykpdljwsx `g gbhwpgh ls dbxgpjdbl`ng db kphgp okp gygpdgbcg xk xleg ynlcg" Ls kyyksgh xk lckbxplhdcxdkb ko g|wlnnt vlndh lbh bgcgsslpt sxlxgjgbxs. xfg hgckbsxpwcxdvg lykpdl ds ygpflys `gsxokpjwnlxgh `t sfk}dbm fk} xfg ckbhdxdkbs okp xfg ykssd`dndxt ko skjgxfdbm lnsk ypkvg nk `g xfgckbhdxdkbs okp dxs djykssd`dndxt"
<?
Xfg hgckbsxpwcxdvg lykpdl ds xfgpg`t dxgpl`dndxt dxsgno. lbdbgplhdcl`ng „hkl`ng `dbh‚ kp lb „gygpdgbcg ko xfg djykssd`ng"‚
<=
Kp. kbg ckwnh pgbhgp lykpdl lswbhgcdhl`dndxt. ls xfg wbhgcdhl`dndxt dbvknvgh db l hgxgpjdblxg vlcdnnlxdkb `gx}ggb hgxgpjdblxg

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->