June 02, 2007 Saturday Jamadi-ul-Awwal 16, 1428

Open season on minorities

By Irfan Husain

By Irfan Husain

LOVE for one’s country comes in different Although Islam directs its followers
forms. At one extreme is the American patriot to protect non-Muslims, the fact is
who pronounced: “My country, right or wrong!” that in Pakistan, these injunctions are
At the other is the saying: “Patriotism is the last largely ignored by the clergy and their
refuge of the scoundrel.” fanatical followers. The state looks the
other way when minorities are
persecuted because they are seen as
I personally tend towards the latter view. When
those ruling the country say or do something I powerless.
disagree with, I do not feel I am being
unpatriotic by pointing it out. Indeed, I agree completely with the sentiment
expressed in this wise observation: “A patriot is somebody who will defend the state
against the government of the day.”

There are times — all too rare, alas! — when I am proud to be a Pakistani. Far more
frequently, the antics of our rulers and our public figures are a source of shame. But
while the impact of most official decisions and actions is fleeting, the ongoing
disgrace of our nation’s treatment of its minorities is a permanent blot on our
collective reputation and conscience. While I understand why our religious extremists
behave the way they do, the failure of civil society to force a change in laws and
attitudes is far more deplorable.

What re-ignited my sense of outrage was the recent visit by a European Union joint
commission to Islamabad where they were, in effect, told by the Pakistani team that
all was well with our minorities. Those representing us must be totally shameless, for
they said without an iota of remorse that our blasphemy laws had been around for a
100 years. This is rubbish, as they were inflicted on us by Ziaul Haq just over 20
years ago.

Our team went on to ask the EU not to pressurise the Pakistan government to repeal
this infamous piece of legislation as this might make the public think we were being
pushed into changing the law under western prodding. Considering that the
government often does the right thing only under foreign pressure, there is every
reason for the EU to continue pushing.

For those who think I am over-stating my case, here are some random examples of
the excesses inflicted on our non-Muslim and Ahmadi citizens over the last year.
These are mostly drawn from the 14th issue of a newsletter called Pakistan Concern
that focused on our minorities.

On April 1, the police in Toba Tek Singh arrested Salamat Masih and 11-year old
Daniel Masih, while warrants under the blasphemy laws were issued for the arrest of
three other members of the Christian family. The charge? That they forcibly removed
the ‘Islamic sticker’ from the pocket of Faisal Gulzar, a Muslim boy, and trampled on
it. A mob later attacked the Christian colony where Ratan, a disabled boy, was badly
injured. But according to Father Bonnie Mendes, the whole incident started with a
fight among the boys in which their parents got involved.

On March 23, Amanat Masih, a 50-year old Christian from Sheikhupura, was tortured
by a mob for allegedly burning some pages from the Holy Quran. He was later
arrested by the police under the blasphemy laws, and remains in jail. His wife,
Zohera Bibi, had saved Rs 50,000 for their daughter’s wedding. This sum was looted
by the mob.

On April 8, Shaheen Masih, a 12-year old Christian girl was kidnapped by four
Muslim men and gang-raped over two days after which she was finally rescued by
the police. But although she was medically examined, the police refused to give the
report to her parents. The four men were arrested and a case was registered against
them, but they were later released. One of them was reported as saying to the
others: “Don’t hesitate to rape a Christian girl. Even if she dies, no one will get us.
Her poor parents cannot pursue us.”

In Charsadda, a small town in the NWFP with an old, established Christian

community, letters have recently been slipped under the doors of Christian homes,
warning the inhabitants to convert to Islam or face death. So clearly, the
Talibanisation of the Frontier does not countenance any non-Muslims in the areas it
seeks to control.

Ahmadis, too, bear the brunt of Pakistan’s rising tide of Islamic extremism.
According to the latest Ahmadiya community report, 79 Ahmadis have been killed
between 1984 and 2005 simply for their belief. The report goes on to say: “Religious
extremists remained free to congregate in numbers in Rabwah and indulge in
abusive rhetoric, but Ahmadis were not allowed to hold a single open-air community
event in their own town.”

According to the Pakistan Hindu Council, Hindus in Sindh are insecure because of the
rising number of kidnappings and murders. An estimated 1.5 million Hindus live in
Pakistan, and according to Nisar Khuhro of the Pakistan People’s Party, more and
more of them are being kidnapped for ransom. On March 2, the BBC reported the
disappearance of Garish Kumar from Umerkot. His dismembered body was found
near a madressah, and the police suspected an extreme Islamic group of the crime.
His father, a local trader, says nobody in authority is interested in taking up the case
because the victim was a Hindu.
According to the Minority Rights Group’s annual report, Pakistan has risen by eight
places to occupy eighth position on the MRG’s ranking of countries where minorities
are at risk. In fact, this view is widely reflected in the international media where the
plight of Pakistan’s hapless minorities gets hugely adverse coverage. But apart from
stout denial, this government has done little to confront the issue, and give our
minorities a sense of security.

All these random incidents I have cited here have been reported in the media, and to
the police. The fact that little or no action has been taken is a reflection of the
apathy in our society towards our minorities. And clearly, it is further proof that
Musharraf’s boast about his agenda of ‘enlightened moderation’ is just hot air. Only
when a particularly gruesome story hits the foreign media is there any pretence of
official action. But as soon as the furore has died down, it is open season on non-
Muslims again.

Although Islam directs its followers to protect non-Muslims, the fact is that in
Pakistan, these injunctions are largely ignored by the clergy and their fanatical
followers. The state looks the other way when minorities are persecuted because
they are seen as powerless. Until those at the top show a sense of outrage, non-
Muslims will continue to be treated as second-class citizens.

© The DAWN Group of Newspapers, 2007

Source : www.dawn.com/weekly/mazdak/mazdak.htm