Case 3:12-cv-01749-CCC Document 51

Filed 10/16/12 Page 1 of 2

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF PUERTO RICO

MINUTES OF PROCEEDINGS: BEFORE HONORABLE CARMEN C. CEREZO COURTROOM DEPUTY: Gretchen S. Rodriguez COURT REPORTER: Zulma Ruiz INTERPRETERS: Carlos Lao DATE: October 16, 2012 CASE NO. CV. 12-1749 (CCC)

Attorneys Myrna Colon-Marrero, et al. Carlos Del Valle Cruz Carlos M. Hernandez Lopez Juan Saavedra

v. Hector Conty Perez Edwin Mundo Rios (NPP) Jose L. Nieto Mingo Ramon Walker Merino Claudio Aliff Ortiz David Indiano Vicic Seth Erbe Jorge Martinez Luciano Emil Rodriguez Escudero

Eder E. Ortiz Ortiz (PDP) Roberto I. Aponte Berrios (PIP) Julio Fontanet Maldonado (MUS) Adrian Diaz Diaz (PPR) Carlos Quiros Mendez (PPT) v. Norman Parkhurst (intervenor defendant)

Marcos Valls Nelson N. Cordova Morales Manuel Rodriguez Banchs

John Mudd

Second Day of Evidentiary Hearing held. Counsel informed that Attorney Rafael Garcia-Rodon was sick and unable to attend to todays hearing. Further testimony of Edwin Mundo is heard on his behalf as electoral commissioner of the New Progressive Party (NPP) heard. Testimony of Guillermo Cordero (direct and cross), Luz Delia Vazquez-Resto (direct, cross, re direct), qualified as an expert in the field of added by hand voters, Jose Antonio Gonzalez-Diaz

Case 3:12-cv-01749-CCC Document 51

Filed 10/16/12 Page 2 of 2

2 (direct and cross), Julio Bonet-Diaz (direct and cross), Marcos V. Vargas-Carrillo (direct, cross, re direct), Jose A. Torres (direct and cross), and Maria Dolores Santiago-Rodriguez (direct), on behalf of the Electoral Commission. Testimony of witnesses were limited due to time constraints. Matter is taken under advisement.

s/ Gretchen S. Rodriguez Gretchen S. Rodriguez Courtroom Deputy