123

&
&

&

AM: 1109002

MAX WEBER

:
1. , ( )
2. ,
3. ,

2012


.
.
. .

.
1. 4
2. Max Weber..7
3. .37
4. ...58
5. 65

1. .

Max
Weber.


.
Max Weber


. -

. -
.
, ,
. .
Max Weber


.
Max Weber .


. ,

 , ,
.
20
.
.
.

.
.

.
Weber .
, .
. sine ira
et studio . Weber
.

. ,
Weber .


. Weber
Reich
. Weber
.

 .
Reich

. .
Weber :
, , ,
. Weber W.
Mommsen, D. Beetham A. Giddens,
,
.


.

2. Max Weber.

e Weber
[Entzauberung der Welt] .
Wissenschaft als Beruf 1917

.1

.
.

.
Weber
.2

Weber

.3
.

Weber .4
,
.
.

Max Weber, , . , , 1933, .

67.
2
Catherine Colliot Thelene, Max Weber , . . , ,
2005, . 103.
3
Andreas Calyvas, The Politics of the Extraordinary, Cambridge University Press, 2009, . 66.
4
Max Weber, , .., . 78-79.


.
.
[Intellektualisierung]
[Rationalisierung]

.5 ,
, , , ,

. O Weber
. ,

-
.

.
Weber
.

. H Weber ,
, -

Steven Seidman, Modernity, Meaning and Cultural Pessimism in Max Weber, State University of
New York, Sociological Analysis, Oxford University Press, 44, 1983, . 274.

 -.6 Weber

. , Weber,
.7

.
, Weber ,
.8

.

9 Weber ,
. Weber


.10
Weber
.11
.
. Weber
,

., . 276.
Max Weber, , .., . 72.
8
Catherine Colliot Thelene, Max Weber , .., 138.
9
., .139.
10
A. Calyvas, The Politics of the Extraordinary,, .., . 70.
11
Max Weber, , 1, , - , 2005, . 56.
7

 .12 Weber
.


.13 . Weber
.
,
.
,
.14

, Weber
.15 ,
,

,

.16 Weber

.

.

12

Max Weber, , - . , ,
1985. . 96.
13
A. Calyvas, The Politics of the Extraordinary, , .., . 41.
14
Max Weber, , , .., . 96.
15
A. Calyvas, The Politics of the Extraordinary, , .., . 30.
16
. . 31-32.

10



.17 Weber
.

.18

. :

, .19
Weber
.

.20


.21

[Legalitt]. , Weber,

.22
. minimum
17

. , Max Weber, , 2001,

. 89.
18
., . 103.
19
. . 101.
20
. . 35.
21
., . 107.
22
Max Weber, , 1, .., . 242.

11

 ,
, .23
, Weber,
.
,

.
.24
Weber

.
,
; Weber ,
- .
.


.25

[Legitimitt] ,

.
.
,

Weber, : )

, ) , )
23

., . 241.
., . 242.
25
. , , .., . 96.
24

12

.26
, o Weber,
,
.

.27 ,
, ,
,
(
).28
Weber , -
.

. Weber ,
.
.
,
.


.29 , Weber,
: : )
26

Max Weber, , 1, .., . 243.

.
28
., . 38.
29
Max Weber, , 5, , ,
2009, 23.
27

13


, )
, )
.30

. : ) ,

, ) ,
)
,
.31



. Weber
.
.

.
Weber ,
,
.
.32

, Weber,

30

.
Max Weber, , 1, .., . 244.
32
., . 304.
31

14

 .33
.
[Jede Herrschaft uert sich und funktioniert als
Verwaltung].34
, ,

.
, ,
.

,
.
.
Weber
.

.

Weber .

. O Weber
.35
Weber , ,
. ,
33

., . 305.
. , , .., . 91.
35
D. Beetham, Max Weber and the Theory of Modern Politics, .., . 20.
34

15


.36 Weber
.
.37
.
, , Weber
. Weber
. :
, .38 Weber
.

:
,


.39
Weber
,
-,
,
, -
.40 Weber
.
36

Max Weber, , .., . 110.

Max Weber, , 5, .., . 403.
38
., . 14.
39
Max Weber, , 5, , .., . 24.
40
., . 26 . 58.
37

16

.

.41
, Weber,
,
.42
.
.
, .
.

.43
.
,
,
,
,
,
,
,

41

., .27.
., . 57.
43
Max Weber, , .., . 110.
42

17


.44
Weber
, .45

, .46
Weber

.
.
- .

.47
, Weber,


.48
,

,
.

44

Max Weber, , 5, , .., . 88.

D. Beetham : Max Weber and the Theory of Modern Politics, 1991, . 67
Max Weber, ,
- .
46
Max Weber, , 5, .., . 57.
47
Max Weber, , 1, , .., . 256.
48
Max Weber, , 5, , .., . 62.
45

18

 Weber
.49
Weber

[Regelhaftigkeit] .50


.
.
,
, .51

Weber .52

.


,
. Weber,


: .53

49

.
..
51
., . 50.
52
., . 68.
53
Max Weber, , .., . 100.
50

19


.
.

,
.



.
, Weber,
,
.
.

.54

.55
,
.56

,
54

Max Weber, , 5, , .., . 65.

Max Weber, , 1, , .., . 308.
56
.
55

20

 ,

.57

, ,
.58 Weber,
,
.

.59 ,
19 ,
.
,
,
.60
O Weber Verein fur Sozialpolitik
Gustav Schmoller.61

Schmoller
,

.

57

., . 311.
Max Weber, , 5, , .., . 72.
59
, , , 1989, . 40
.
60
.
61
W. Mommsen, The Political and Social Theory of Max Weber, .., . 173-175.
58

21

 Hegel.62 Weber

.63

.
,
.
.64

Weber

.65 ,
Weber,
. Weber
,

.66
.
:
62

D. Beetham, Max Weber and the Theory of Modern Politics, .., . 19. Hegel
' ,
, , . Hegel
, , "
" ( 28/10/1816).
Hegel
-
. http://www.politikokafeneio.com/leksiko/l36.htm
63
D. Beetham, Max Weber and the Theory of Modern Politics, .., . 67
64
Max Weber, , 1, .., 255.
65
., . 71.
66
.

22

 .67 Weber
,
.68

.

,
1789. Weber
, ,
16 .69
, Weber, .70
, Weber,
.

: ) 1570-715 .. ,
284-305 ..
13 .71
.
.
.
, , ,
,
.
67

.
Max Weber, , 5, , .., . 72.
69
Max Weber, , .., . 111.
70
.
71
., . 35.
68

23


.
, Weber
, .

. , ,

.



.72

. ,
Weber,
.73

.74 20
.
.75
. , Weber,

72

Max Weber, , 5, .., . 89.

Max Weber, Parliament and Government in Germany, .., . 179.
74
., . 178.
75
Max Weber, , .., . 147.
73

24

sine ira et studio .76 ,

, .
Weber
,
.77

.

Weber

.
.
,
.

.



.
Weber

76

., . 120
., . 145. Weber : ,
,
,
, ,
.
77

25

. .78
.79


.80
Weber
[Legalitt] [Legitimitt]
.
.


.

.
. O Weber
J. Locke J. J.
Rousseau - .81
.

. Weber
.82 , Weber, .83

78

Max Weber, , 5, , .., . 20.

Max Weber, Parliament and Government in Germany, .., . 230.
80
.
81
Max Weber, , 1, .., . 466.
82
Max Weber, , .., . 71.
83
.
79

26

 , Weber

, .84

Weber:

:
85.

.

. Weber
.

. .86 O Weber
:


: ,
. Weber

. , Weber,
. Weber
.
.
.
84

., . 72.
., .150.
86
., . 148-150.
85

27


.
. Weber
.87
.
. .
Weber .

88

, Weber, ,
,
.89

. Weber :
: , .
, ,
.90
Weber
.
,
.
. ,
Weber, ,
.91 ,
.
87

., .150-155.
., . 166.
89
.
90
., .121.
91
., . 150.
88

28


, ,

Weber,

.
.
, .92
[Beruf] Weber
.93 Weber

.

- -
[Erwerbsprinzip]
. .
Weber
( )

homo economicus.
, .
-




.
92
93

., . 168.
Max Weber, , , 41.

29

.
.94 .
Weber

.95
,
.96 minimum


.97 , [Beruf]
- .

. analogia entis analogia fidei.
-
.
.

[certitudo salutatis].

.

.

94

Max Weber, , 5,, .., . 381.

Lutz Kaelber, Max Webers Protest antic Ethic in the 21st Century, International Journal of
Politics, Culture and Society, 2002, . 136.
96
Ian Craib, , . , ,
1998, 434, 435.
97
Max Weber, , 5, , .., . 325.
95

30

 ,
.


.
Weber
. Weber
,
.98 Weber
.
.99 T

.
.100 Weber
.
,
. , Weber,
.
.101
.
.102

98

Max Weber, , .., . 105.

Max Weber, Parliament and Government in Germany, Political Writings, Cambridge
University Press, 1994, . 162.
100
., . 160.
101
., . 178.
102
., . 147.
99

31

 Weber
,
.103

.
20 , pouvoir neutre,

. Weber

.104
.
Weber
fair play
.
pro et contra .
O Weber
.
19

.
, ,
,
, literati

103
104

., . 166.
., . 131.

32

Weber.105
20

.
Weber
,
. 20
Junkers
. Weber
.

.106 Junkers .
Weber
.
.107
- . Weber

.
,
, ,
.
. ,

105

Max Weber, Parliament and Government, .., . 173.

Max Weber, The Nation State and Economic Policy, Political Writings, Cambridge
University Press, 1994, 16.
107
Max Weber, Parliament and Government, .., . 178.
106

33


. Weber
[Versterreicherung].
Weber
- .

. O Weber
.
.
, Weber,
.

.
,
.
.108
Weber :

.109

. Weber
.
, Weber, .

108

Max Weber, The Nation State and Economic Policy, Max Weber Political Writings, .
19.
109
Max Weber, Parliament and Government in Germany, Max Weber Political Writings, .
167.

34

O Weber
. ,
,
. Weber
, ,
.

110

- .
.


.

.111



.112
Weber

( ) .

.113 Weber ,
20

110

., . 173.
Max Weber, Parliament and Government, .., . 204.
112
.
113
., . 75.
111

35

. , , .

.114
Weber
.
Weber
.
.

114

Max Weber, , .., . 144.

36

3. .
Weber
.

.
. Max Weber
.

.
Max Weber.
Weber

. Weber Rudolph Sohm,

[Kirchenrecht,
1892] . Weber


.115
.116

.117
.
Weber
,
115

Max Weber, , 1 , .., 275.

., . 276.
117
.
116

37

 .

, .

. , Weber,

.

118

. ,
, . Weber
.

.
.

- , -

.119
, Weber,
.120

.
.
.
118

Max Weber, , .., 120. Weber :

.
.
119
A. Calyvas, The Politics of the Extraordinary, , .., . 65.
120
Max Weber, , 1 , . 465.

38

. Weber

.121 , Weber :

.122


, ,

, ,

, , ,
,
.
.

.123

.124
,
;

121

Max Weber, , 5, , . 259.

., . 254.
123
., . 249.
124
D. Beetham, Max Weber and the Legitimacy of the Modern State, Analyse and Kritik, 1991, .
36.
122

39

 Max Weber
,125
.126

Max Weber

,
.127 Max Weber
.128 ,
,
.
, ,
. D. Beetham
[Legitimittsglaube]
Max Weber .129

.
,

,

.130
O Andreas Calyvas Max Weber

125

Max Weber, , .., . 121 & 149-150.

Andreas Calyvas, The Politics of the Extraordinary, Cambridge University Press, 2009, .34.
127
Max Weber, , 1, , .., . 32-34.
128
Max Weber, , 1, , .., . 276, 279-280.
129
D. Beetham, Max Weber and the Legitimacy of the Modern State, .., . 42.
130
., . 44.
126

40

 .131 Weber
.
.
.
A. Calyvas .
Max Weber
.
.
.
.
,

. 132


.133 Max Weber ,
,

.134

.
. . O

131

Andreas Calyvas, The Politics of the Extraordinary, , .., . 62.

A. Calyvas, The Politics of the Extraordinary,, .., . 54.
133
Max Weber, , 1, , .., 277 Max Weber
, 5, , .., . 267.
134
Max Weber, , -: ,
, , 2005, . 53-60.
132

41


. extra ecclesiam salus non est
.


, .135

.136 Weber,

.137
.

.138 )
)

.139

Weber

.140

.

135

Max Weber, , 1, , .., . 281.

., . 285.
137
Max Weber, , 5, , .., 267.
138
., . 269.
139
., . 413
140
., . 288.
136

42

 Weber

.

.
, ,

.
Weber
) , )
) )
, ) )
.141
Weber
.
, ,
,
, .
, .

, .
, Weber,
.142

141
142

Weber, , 5, , .., . 414-415.

., . 303.

43

 Weber
.
Weber
.
.143
.
.


.

.144
. ,
-
.

,
: ,
() .


-
, ,
,
-
143
144

. , , , 2007, . 105.
Max Weber, , 5, , .., . 269.

44


.145
Max Weber,

.146 Weber

, .

, .147

. .
,
. ,
, ,
. ,
.
,
.
.
-.

, -
.

.
145

., . 379.
A. Calyvas, The Politics of the Extraordinary, , .., . 61.
147
Max Weber, , , 2005, . 166.
146

45

 ,
Weber, .148

, .149

( )
, Weber,
.150 ,

Weber,

.
, .

.
Weber .
. .

.

;
, .
.
Weber
.
,151 .

148

Max Weber, , 5, , .., . 253.

., . 257.
150
., . 252.
151
Max Weber, , , .., . 164.
149

46

 . To
,

1930 ,

Weber

. Weber .
Weber
.
Junkers
.152 Weber

Reich

.153
.
,
, ,
.
,
.154
Weber

.
Weber .

152

. , , .., . 145.
Max Weber, Parliament and Government, .., . 152.
154
., . 222.
153

47

 .155
Reich
. Weber


.
.
, Weber,

.
Weber , ,
.
Weber
20 . Weber

, .156
Weber
.157 Weber


.158
Weber

155

., . 230.
A. Calyvas, The Politics of the Extraordinary, , .., . 69.
157
.
158
., . 70.
156

48

 .
, .159


, .160 ,
.
.
Weber
.

.

.
Weber

.161 Weber
o-
.
Hegel
159

. , , , .., . 143.
., . 146.
161
W. Mommsen, The Political and Social Theory of Max Weber, , .., . 4.
160

49


.162
,
Weber, - .
o Weber
.

. Weber
.
, Weber, ,
(
),
, , .163

Weber

.
. Weber
[Sachlichkeit].

, .
Weber .164 O Weber
. O Weber

162

A. Calyvas, Democracy and Politics of the extraordinary, .., . 38.

Max Weber, , 1, , .., . 335.
164
Stefan Breuer Robert Maier The illusion of Politics: Politics and Rationalization in Max Weber
and Georg Luacs, New German Critique, 26, 1982, . 62.
163

50

 .

.165
Weber


.166

Weber

. , Weber,
.167
Weber
.
, .

.
.
Weber:

.168
.

165

W. Mommsen, The political and Social Theory of Max Weber, Polity Press, . 29.
T Maley, Democracy and the Political in Max Webers thought, University of Toronto Press, 2011,
. 3-4.
167
., .. 37.
168
Max Weber, The President of the Reich, .., . 305.
166

51

 .
,
.169



.
Weber

.170

.171 Weber:
,
: .172 O Weber

.173

. Weber


. Weber
.174

169

Max Weber, , 5, , .., . 270-271.

T. Maley, Democracy and the Political in Max Webers thought, .., . 47.
171
., . 48.
172
Max Weber, Parliament and Government in Germany, .., . 156.
173
. , Weber Marx , , . 97.
174
Max Weber, Parliament and Government in Germany, .., . 216.
170

52

 Weber .
.

.
Weber

.175
Weber .176

-
-
[der bureaukratischen rationalen Wissenherrschaft].177
.
Weber; Weber
,

, .
,
, .
.
;
Weber

175

T. Maley, Democracy and the Political in Max Webers thought, .., . 48.
W. Mommsen, The Political and Social Theory of Max Weber, University of California Press, .
184.
177
T. Maley, Democracy and the Political in Max Webers thought, .., . 48.
176

53

 .178 Weber
,
.
Weber.179

, Weber,

180
, .181


. .182
[Parliamentarisierung]

11
1919.183 .
. Weber
.

.
- .

,
.184

178

Max Weber, , 5, , . 265, 395, 389-390.

Max Weber, , .., . 147.
180
Max Weber.
181
.
182
Max Weber, Parliament and Government, .., . 251 266.
183
. , , .., . 144.
184
. Calyvas, The Politics of the Extraordinary, , .., . 73.
179

54

 Weber, ,
,

.185

.

.


.186

:
[Fuhrerdiktatur];187
Weber
1933 Adolf Hitler
. Weber


.

. H ,
, , ,

185

.
. , , .., . 151.
187
., . 160.
186

55

,
.188
Weber :


.

,
.189
Weber
,
.
.
.

.


. Weber
.
.190 Weber

.

188

Max Weber, , 1, , .., . 309.

., . 155.
190
Max Weber, Parliament and Government .., . 178-179.
189

56

57

4. .
O Max Weber 20

-
.
Weber
.
, ,
, ,
,

Max Weber, ,
.

.
, Weber,

.
Weber .
,
,
.191

191

A. Giddens, Max Weber, .., . 80.

58

 Marx Nietzsche
.192
Weber
,
Weber . Max Weber
.
.
. Max Weber
.
Weber
.


.193

, Weber
.194

.
Weber
, .

. Weber

192

.
Bryan S. Turner, Max Weber, From History to Modernity, Routledge, 1992, . 194.
194
., . 203.
193

59

 :
, ;


.
. Weber
.
,



.
.


.195
Weber
( ) (
). Weber

.196 Weber

195

. , , , . 8-9.
Hans Blokland, Modernization and its Political Consequences, Weber, Mannheim, and Schumpeter,
Yale University, 2006, . 23.

196

60


.197
Weber
.

-
Weber.198 Weber ,


.
.
.199
Weber
.200

Weber

- .

. Weber

- -
.

197

. , ,

5, . 138.
198
. , , .., . 59.
199
., . 71-75.
200
Ian Craib, , . , , 1998, .
71.

61


Weber
.201 -
.
,
.202
Weber

.
.
.
Weber
-

, .

.
character indelebilis -
.
Weber
.
-
Weber - .

201

A. Giddens, Max Weber, , 1993, .

79.
202
. , Max Weber , 1, , 1999, .
70.

62

 . Weber

.203

Weber

.
.

.
.
.
:
;
. ,

.

.

,
.

.
. .

.

203

C. Turner, Modernity and Politics in the Work of Max Weber, Taylor & Francis, 1992, . 107.

63

 .
.

.

.
.
Weber
, . .
,
.
,
.
,
.
. ,
, ,
,
. , , :
, .204

204

Max Weber, , .., . 168.

64

7. .
7.1. .
Max Weber, The Nation State and Economic Policy, Political Writings,
Cambridge University Press, 1994,
Max Weber, Parliament and Government in Germany, Political Writings,
Cambridge University Press, 1994
Max Weber, The President of the Reich, Political Writings, Cambridge
University Press, 1994
Max Weber, , / .
1985
Max Weber, ,

Max Weber, , / , 1932
Max Weber, , 1, ,
- , 2005
Max Weber, , 5, ,
, , 2009
Max Weber, , :
, , 2005
Max Weber, ,
2002

65

7.2. .
Catherine Colliot Thelene, Max Weber ,
, , 2005
Giddens A. Max Weber,
2005.
, Max
Weber, ,
. , , ,
2002
. , , , 2007
J Sabine
. , Weber Marx, ,
1999
. , Max Weber,
, 2001
, , ,
1989
D. Beetham, Max Weber and the Legitimacy of the Modern State, Analyse
& Kritik (13), 1991
D. Beetham, Max Weber and the Theory of Modern Politics, 1991
Hans Bruun, Science Values and Politics in Max Webers Methodology,
Ashgate 1972
Stefan Breuer Robert Maier The illusion of Politics: Politics and
Rationalization in Max Weber and Georg Luacs, New German Critique, 26,
1982

66

A. Calyvas, Democracy and the Politics of Extraordinary, Cambridge

University Press, 2009
T Maley, Democracy and the Political in Max Webers thought, University of
Toronto Press, 2011
J. P. Mayer, Max Weber and German Politics, London 1943
W. Mommsen, Max Weber and German Politics 1890 1920, 1990
W. Mommsen, The Political and Social Theory of Max Weber, Polity Press,
1989
W. Mommsen, The Political and Social Theory of Max Weber, University of
Chicago Press, 1989
Steven Pfuff, Nationalism, Charisma and Plebiscitary Leadership: The
problem of Democratization in Max Webers Political Sociology, Volume: 72,
Issue: 1
Steven Seidman, Modernity, Meaning and Cultural Pessimism in Max Weber,
State University of New York, Sociological Analysis, Oxford University
Press, Vol. 44, No. 4 (Winter, 1983),
Bryan S. Turner, Max Weber, From History to Modernity, Taylor &
Francis2007
Sam Whimster, Wolfgang Mommsen: A British Appreciation, Max Weber
Studies, 5.1 (2005),

67

68