Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Comparision Between EUDL & Moving Load

    Uploaded by

    Sanjoy Sanyal
    17 views2 pages
    The document compares minimum loads, maximum moments, maximum loads, and minimum moments at the bottom of piles under equivalent uniform distributed loads (EUDL) and moving loads conditions. It provides these values at various nodes along the pile for both load cases. It concludes that EUDL generally provides more critical values and should be used for pile design.

    Original Description:

    bridge

    Copyright

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    The document compares minimum loads, maximum moments, maximum loads, and minimum moments at the bottom of piles under equivalent uniform distributed loads (EUDL) and moving loads conditions. It provides these values at various nodes along the pile for both load cases. It concludes that EUDL generally provides more critical values and should be used for pile design.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    17 views2 pages

    Comparision Between EUDL & Moving Load

    Uploaded by

    Sanjoy Sanyal
    The document compares minimum loads, maximum moments, maximum loads, and minimum moments at the bottom of piles under equivalent uniform distributed loads (EUDL) and moving loads conditions. It provides these values at various nodes along the pile for both load cases. It concludes that EUDL generally provides more critical values and should be used for pile design.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 2

    6.9.

    Comparision between EUDL & Moving Loads


    Comparision of Min.Loads and Max. Moments at Pile bottom between EUDL & Moving loads
    min Load
    max.moments
    min Load
    Node
    EUDL
    moving
    EUDL
    moving
    Node
    EUDL
    moving
    5000
    -16.693
    -22.901
    47.733
    35.565
    5002
    2.601
    -12.663
    5001
    -24.801
    -37.992
    35.53
    38.507
    5004
    2.679
    -14.537
    5003
    -27.995
    -29.181
    46.916
    39.098
    5006
    2.444
    -14.371
    5005
    -31.068
    -35.171
    60.343
    47.248
    5008
    2.219
    -23.575
    5007
    -93.175
    -75.363
    90.56
    77.953
    5009
    -16.939
    -28.242

    max.moments
    EUDL
    moving
    64.986
    44.306
    50.711
    30.805
    38.471
    30.894
    38.829
    44.168
    66.265
    55.603

    5010
    5011
    5013
    5016
    5018
    5019
    5021

    -17.771
    -13.032
    -14.542
    -19.715
    -23.022
    -40.718
    -50.577

    -34.148
    -19.497
    -13.804
    -23.669
    -18.521
    -34.347
    -46.449

    61.943
    57.366
    49.428
    50.009
    61.884
    72.792
    79.806

    50.581
    47.959
    34.58
    33.445
    54.965
    72.615
    85.898

    5012
    5014
    5015
    5017
    5020
    5022
    5023

    -56.19
    -48.825
    -34.423
    -25.452
    -17.182
    -15.5
    -22.589

    -44.876
    -43.092
    -30.085
    -20.765
    -24.466
    -17.133
    -40.132

    75.971
    70.077
    63.191
    53.232
    49.559
    59.378
    63.706

    87.516
    68.474
    51.837
    31.863
    42.422
    55.314
    70.746

    5024
    5026
    5028
    5030
    5032
    5034

    -20.844
    4.845
    4.64
    4.89
    4.991
    -16.357

    -61.938
    -31.31
    -16.303
    -23.61
    -32.606
    -42.825

    53.396
    32.105
    29.113
    38.039
    40.734
    45.779

    51.989
    31.138
    26.735
    35.521
    35.21
    48.325

    5025
    5027
    5029
    5031
    5033
    5035

    -98.035
    -53.539
    -45.159
    -36.039
    -27.11
    -25.757

    -48.393
    -21.271
    -18.455
    -16.367
    -17.644
    -4.865

    73.946
    54.513
    44.11
    36.704
    29.885
    33.545

    66.63
    39.832
    27.862
    43.663
    46.981
    36.304

    Comparision of Max.Loads and Min. Moments at Pile bottom between EUDL & Moving loads
    Max. Load
    Min Moment
    Max. Load
    Node
    EUDL
    Moving
    EUDL
    Moving
    Node
    EUDL
    Moving
    5000 654.331 406.437
    3.742
    0.011
    5002 291.057 190.028
    5001 793.487 486.177
    0.526
    0.001
    5004 321.473 188.812
    5003 781.163 448.309
    3.764
    0.006
    5006 296.986 171.884
    5005 692.794 429.763
    3.648
    0
    5008 243.754 165.317
    5007 760.737
    598.5
    3.156
    0.01
    5009 231.792
    199.83

    Min Moment
    EUDL
    Moving
    3.589
    0.01
    3.614
    0.008
    1.917
    0.01
    0.891
    0.012
    3.175
    0.009

    5010
    5011
    5013
    5016
    5018
    5019
    5021

    230.725
    313.344
    446.666
    583.424
    449.279
    354.679
    294.509

    191.925
    196.49
    287.317
    352.74
    289.111
    248.086
    275.03

    13.311
    10.866
    3.033
    4.486
    12.92
    14.885
    5.072

    0.002
    0.012
    0.015
    0.007
    0.006
    0.051
    0.012

    5012
    5014
    5015
    5017
    5020
    5022
    5023

    275.233
    352.167
    442.885
    553.277
    391.48
    295.868
    246.857

    229.575
    233.872
    297.455
    364.917
    273.39
    206.618
    226.612

    1.997
    12.102
    17.335
    6.622
    3.697
    13.809
    16.574

    0.014
    0.001
    0.005
    0.03
    0.001
    0.002
    0.011

    5024
    5026
    5028
    5030
    5032
    5034

    304.823
    382.775
    475.596
    518.602
    457.823
    363.889

    264.437
    270.076
    270.114
    355.984
    396.849
    479.596

    2.308
    2.5
    1.858
    3.302
    4.419
    1.687

    0.006
    0.004
    0.011
    0.009
    0.001
    0.003

    5025
    5027
    5029
    5031
    5033
    5035

    462.624
    475.996
    539.929
    553.234
    463.37
    334.589

    346.988
    285.871
    265.623
    294.606
    248.814
    208.017

    1.378
    4.563
    3.192
    3.35
    3.598
    2.648

    0.001
    0.001
    0.007
    0.001
    0.018
    0.029

    1) For EUDL - Single span load, 2 span load, 3 span load, all 4 span load, top half loaded & bottom half loaded conditions are considered
    and the critical value obtained at pile bottom are tabulated
    2) For Moving loads- single track, 2 track, 3 track and all 4 track loaded conditions are considered and the critical values at pile bottom
    are tabulated.
    Conclusion:
    Almost at all location, EUDL gives critical values and hence the same is considered for Pile design.

    You might also like