Case Study


 
!"
#$&% '( )*#'+ #

+ ),)' &

-+./)01  2 / +./ 2




(Case Study) 
 !"#$%&'( )*&+,-./,)01,$%&'(2

)0!3),//(4 (5/678)*3,& 06)+ 2
3(9:(;,!*8.$%&'( $5/2
<#8)*
=+ "5/!*8.4> *)
.48)*> .*/(7"!"#2:
>64,
4 3:0<";"+,8)*$#;66"2


.*/,&+,- 8)*> *6(=+ "5/>2: ?7*<,././$#6; ?7*6/,./,
<@AB /(" B2
8)*> *.*/(7"
&./, <@AB /(" B &(6(<', ././><
<@AB /(" B 2
> *6(+((5/>&/6:9(&+,,C
4 ?7*<2: ,/+,',+ <#(
#D=B&+/'==
$67!"#?7*2
3><<# $#<#8)*2
 ./,
 !"#3(9!* 8)*/+,97&*/,!"#&,<;) 5/&*/,:8>=*!2,><)
2:
&+/8

,3/'E' <2
?7*<)2:



 





 
- 
!"#
- $ %& % !"#
% '(!"#)*+*!"#
- % '(
- 

 % )*-$!#-(
$ !
'(

*
- +/

- $ "#
-   
-
*($ %& 
1%%22/*
2/*$ &%%22/*%$
(
'3 4
'('2+*
- 
6)&
 )*6
%273%*
- )



1
1
1
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
4

6
6
6


+%
- '
 8$ 1
- '
 8$ 2
- '
 8$ 3
- 2#9
 8$ 1
- 2#9
 8$ 2
- 2#9
 8$ 3
- ):2
- 
22('(

7  <@AB 2* /(" B

7 *3 '
(% $ 16  &;"6( .! 2533
 18 < =* D/
/37 8 (. 5/4 > $$#'26(
 $$#  %  & 63160
1. 
 
<@AB /(" B )02
(
 2,)*$%&'(!3),// 5/,<. #2
3/$+
<@AB /(" B (<#8(+6+/&4,><
 =/=$5/6;,64, 3(E'34 =/6$5/2

#&'8(+6+/)
,64,08)* - 8(+6+/(D,
 )* &;
4<,3><2
<#$5/=+!*8. 
2,)*$%&'(
2. 
!"#
2.1 $5/3 &;./, 
2.2 $5/!2,!*8.
2.3 $5/!*8. !"#2:=+ "5/)02
2:$5/> *(
$%&'(2
)
.4+)'(
3. $ %& % !"#
3.1 % '(3%' %)*

 %
7  <@AB 2* /(" B 7 *3 ' 787'( 82 
7'( 82 ! $;2E
(% $ 16  &;"6( .! 2533  18 <
/37 8 (. 5/4 > $$#'26(    %  '  &#9 63160
$ /3  *".2
 455 '* / )% $$#  / ' $$#  %  &  &#9 63160
>$! $(2:) 087-3071180 >$! $ () 055-569054
(7  <" 2* /(" B 787'( 82 
7'( 82 ! $;2E
27  ,"))"B 2* /(" B 787'( 82 
7'( 82 ! $;2E
+/
7  ,"))"B 2* /(" B 787'( 82 
7'( 82 ! $;2E
 47 < 7 6*. &'3 10,000 $ ?7*6/,
.*/,
 !(+ *".2
 455
'* / )% $$#  / ' $$#  %  &  &#9 63160 >$! $ 055-569054

:( C 2
( ) ') T ()/7+)*
( ) ') - ()!/7+
( ) ') T () +*,
( ) ')9,!+(
( ) ()9,!+(
(U ) ') T ()9,!+(
( ) /5 - (D)#;).....................................................

(
$
*/,+(') T ())
 2 6 ((24,&
)*)

$ 1 ! 7  24 7 &237

$ 2 ! 7  18 7   > %($
2
3.2 % '(!"#)*+*
<@AB /(" B '(.*
=4(E(V2
 1- (E(V2
 3 <D,
$$#
'26( &. $$# /. $$# <. & <<;
/7+=4(EV2
 5/4 D,
$$#'26( &. $$#
/. $$# <. &
3.3 % '(
<@AB /(" B /; 18 V 62
(
3;.W$8(+6+/!.0,!,3(7 B 7+,?/( ?'.
 "5/, 37, 4:  52 'D"( 3+37, 168 1&'(&
3.4 

 %)*-$!#-(
<@AB /(" B /7+>/;#"
4,)7./,,"))"B /(" B 1, !(+ (
X#
", /7+$
=/
1 6 $,")<2 
3.5 $ !
'(

*$ 2'3 +/

<@AB /(" B )02
6+/.*,<#(
3(E'34 , (+/"/,64, 8(+=//+ ,35/ !&+
62
=/"+
Y /( B+',!<+(>3 =+,*2;/+,
$ "#
<@AB /(" B 8(+3><
,'= 8(+"*!3),// =/6;
 4
<@AB /(" B 62
+', &" =/6; !&+,0,
 8(+6;>6

3.6 
*($ %& 

* #9$3 : <@AB (
7+,?/( ?'. "5/, 37,
* #9$29 : <@AB 6+', &" =/6;
* #9$'(

 : <@AB (
?"3(%2E'Z2,
/7+> [B2
$/>=*
* #9$ 
2: <@AB 3(9&.*$5/=8)*)
+$5/ ',
3.7 G'(2$
% )& (* 2&)
1.  5/,$%&'((D,
 8(+6+/(

2.  5/ ,$%&'(>. #2

 8(+&4,><
,64, 8(+3><3+,, !"#&')&(,
4. %%22/*&%%22/*%(H'3&8
U  '
U  2
U  2#9
U  '7%% '(
U 67):2
U $ 
22('(
U 2
U %(H 4 ()......................
2/*$ &%%22/*%$
(
'34 2$ 8'
%222/*& 8
(1)  ')* $" '
<3,&$+ <@AB 8(+6+/3><
>,64, 1,3 &;> *8(+2:, !"#3+,,8(+2
(2)  2#9
<3(W B2:> *2" #'3 6(6')
$5/ !"#6/6+ <@AB 
)0(
 8(+6+/3><
 8(+6+/(D,
 $+/!(+!2, "V!"* $+/08/7+!(+> (+ 64,<#(
"7 <<;
4//7+!(+ !"#$
.
(3)  2
<
(* " #**7=4)
 ***../, !"#.\&
] <@AB
(
*/,./,&/,/7+ */,3;)2*>*
(4)  ''7%% '(

</&&=
#&'./,<@AB <#62
 +,!(+( 2:2;/+,$5/!(+ (5/(
 0<#6;!(+
9,!(*+!(*!(+<#);)++/0&(
(5) ):2
<3/9($+ <@AB (
 )*$%&'(!3),//65/.62
<#&(
$5/!6+";+()
 !(*+<#68(+6+/)
2+8 +0&(!(*,<#/( B)
6;3; !&+,08(+3><>6"
(6) $2 <2#
3#3(2:> *2.*/(7"
 <@AB /(" B ),
4
6.1 % '(

 %
<@AB /(" B /; 18 V ;&62
 2 ')()!2,2-3 V2
?+( <<;
<@AB //7+!(+ !"#$
= 8)*,'D)#( )5/"# 700 2 5/3) B"# 150 2
6.2 % '(
<@AB /(" B 62
(
3;.W$8(+6+/!.0,!,3(7 B)
$#?+?+&)83*&',(5/V2

!"* !"#(5/&*V0979=)<02
. 2;
4,(
 "0)(/7+>. <,58(+6+/8)* 3 &; ,2
8(+(
.*!9&/=*!"#8(+6+/(D,

6.3 % '(!"#
<@AB /(" B '(.*
=4(E(V2
 1- (E(V2
 3 <D,
$$#
'26( &. $$# /. $$# <. & <<;
/7+=4(E(V2
 5/4 D,
$$#'26( &. $
$# /. $$# <. &
5.22'(-

",<
)*'E
&+,- !"*8)*.*/(7" 2
+3>< ),
4
1.  )*$%&'( <@AB 65/"2
/7+2
*<#6
*/ =+ "5/,2
*2;/+,
!&+. #2
/7+D,
<# 8(+&4,><

2.  )*
 5/,<. #2
673/ <@AB 8(+3>< !"#8(+&4,><
>, 2:> *
. #2
2:'<(>=4
<,') 65/ &/6:9(678(+8)* 67&*/,3
"/E'> (+!"#8(+3><&')&(,
8(+3+,,&,&(: )"2
3,

6. )%$)&

#;'E
!*8.  5/> *6(=+ "5/>##34!"### 24,>3+2
2:!"*"#2:&+/8
<2
2 ./, <@AB /(" B 8)*,!?>=+ "5/!"#2:=+ "5/),
4
1. $(> *6(=+ "5/ D).*8$7)6;> *6: 32<@AB +/-> *.')
6(8*,><!"#3(9$7)6;8)*2;5/,
2. > *6(3><!"#/><>3+ 2:> *.7*3+,(
62
&*/,. !"#.*><./7+*,
3. $(> */<B2
> *6(3><D):5/,./,<@AB 8"+> */<B2
3/6
/5 - ^, $5/2
<#8)*=+>)*
 !"#&&5/9,!3),$%&'(2
8(+)

4. )*
 $(#&;*> *<@AB (
6(?')=/ !"#_'&'&> *)
3; 6> *6(
=+ "5/ !"#> *6:;66"
7. '('2+*
#;'E
!"#=+,">&')?"$5/#('#3'2E'W$./,C$#2
2:+(

>)>=*8)*?"!"#/#82
>=*!"*8(+')?"<&')&(?">=+, 2 )5/&+/( ",<2: $+8)*?")
.4
*,$/3(6"+65/ <@AB 3><
(.4+)'(  08)*<3+,, &/6:9(
8. 
6)&
)*6
%273%*2  8
1. $(> *6(=+ "5/D).*8$7)6; 32 $5/3*,6(6;*6 > *.')6(8*><2
<#
$7)6;
2. > *6(3>< 2:> *.7*+,(
62
 +,./7+
9. )
<<@AB /(" B $+8)*.*/(7"
<@AB "#/
)$/3(6<
3(97*3W$ 8)*+ <2
$+/!"#!(+!2, 2:> *<@AB )02
(
 

/( B !"#(
$%&'(2
+ +,65/ . #2
/7+D,
 =/!";+(<#&(!&+";+()'( 3 6!2+4 !"#2

3:6. #2

08(+&4,>< 8(+&')&(, 8(+#&5/5/* !"#. #2
/7+2
*0<#2:&!&&+,2
D,
65/
!(+2:, 
*/&*

  8+/6"6
3))%$66
%273%*1$ $!"# 8

1. ) +/

?7*6/,6> *6(3><!+<@AB D))7!"/+,>"*=') =+ $(2:> *.7*3+9,8(+
(
$+/ 2
. !&+.0(
!(+2
6/> *6()7!"/><>3+6$(3/)3+/,)7!"$%&'(!3),//24,2
/7+2

* !"#2
D,
D).*8$7)6;/<B#<:#=42
2

2. ) $ "#
/<B2
6> *)7!"/><>3+ !"#6+/&&5/(5/<@AB 2:?')D)/ &;?"3(/+
$%&'(!4(8(+)
&+/&/,!"#6/.*, 6+/> *6:!#: /, (5/<@AB (
 
80=+3+,3'( 33;/()0 $(3+,3'( 5/> *2:'<($5/")6(6
) 6)7!"5/,

2:, $*/(24,/E'9, &;?" !"#/><>3+$'
3. ) +/$ !"#'3&
?7*2
3><<#&+/8 6> *6(/, /(!"#.*><>&./,?7*(- &"/)<> *
6( 6(3>< 6( +,> <#2:> *.7*3//;+ 2E!"#"*2
<#6(7*32
!2*<',//( 1,2:
> *')6(.*><!"#<#8)*=+ "5/8)*97&*/,&, 2
#3/7+
10. $!"#9
 88 2>7'3%(77
/ !"#

1. 2:> *7*<
2
&/,3/(',.4
2. 2:> *.*><$%&'(./,)0(',.4
3. `a+,!?,/+,#!"#7*<!* 
4. 3(9:
8>=*>!*  

3/>=4

5. 8)*6(7*3(9:8>=*>=
'&#<:8)*
6. 8)*
7*$%&'(./,)0 8)*7*<3,&
!"#0(.*/(7"&+,

4 5

) '
 8$ 1

% $ 10  @6( .!. 2551
:$  ' > */,
6/($'&/B %*$  ' 08.40 T 10.20 .
+/:/ ' <@AB /(" B 7 8 ( . 5/4
+/ ' ,3/'E' <2/,3"'
/'2#2B
:9$  ' . #2

'=6/($'&/B , 40203
2326 '
1. $5/&*/,2" #$%&'(!3),//. #2


2. $5/ 3 &;./,8(+&4,><

G'(2$ )
>. #2

'=6/($'&/B <@AB /(" B 8(+&4,><
 =$5/6; . #2
3//7+0
(<#=/(/,//8/ */, ,64,0 )'8)'(*, !"#"679(>54/  5/3,,> *2: 0(<#8(+2:
!"#&/6:9(8(+8)*" $5/-0 #

%2
(1
<$%&'(!3),//./,<@AB /(" B !3),+ 63(E'34 8(+3>< !"#&4,><


)+/ '673%*)&G'(2
<$%&'(2
<@AB !3),//(. #2
:",3/ .8(+&4,><!"#8(+3><
4$#
+"2
.8(+.*>< .8(+"*9(67 5/,</$5/

",=5/..........................................................?7*3,&
(,3/'E' <2 )
67<*,

) '
 8$ 2

% $ 11  @6( .!. 2551
:$  ' > */,
6/($'&/B %*$  ' 13.10 T14.50 .
+/:/ ' <@AB /(" B 7 8 ( . 5/4
+/ ' ,3/'E' <2/,3"'
/'2#2B
:9$  ' . #2

'=6/($'&/B , 40203
2326 '
$5/2$%&'(!3),//+(
"
!",8 5/8(+
G'(2$ )
>. #2

'=6/($'&/B <@AB ,6,8(+&4,><
 =/=$5/6; / "> */,
,)'8)'( !/.*/'&/B0& !"#"679(!"#> *//( * */,0(<#8(+"* 8(+=///( *
*/,!"#8(+=/2:'<(

%2
(1
<$%&'(!3),//./, <@AB >
40,6, (5/3,&>!65/ 6
3(E'34 =/6;. #2

 8(+3>< !"#&4,><

)+/ '673%*)&G'(2
<$%&'(2
 <@AB !3),//(. #2
:",3/ 4 $(> *)0(,&,.*, *
!"#6/19(+/ -

",=5/..........................................................?7*3,&
(,3/'E' <2 )
67<*,

) '
 8$ 3

% $ 17  @6( .!. 2551
:$  ' > */,
6/($'&/B %*$  ' 08.40 T 10.20 .
+/:/ ' <@AB /(" B 7 8 ( . 5/4
+/ ' ,3/'E' <2/,3"'
/'2#2B
:9$  ' . #2

'=6/($'&/B , 40203
2326 '
3,&&6("
!",./,$%&'(!3),//. #2


G'(2$ )
>. #2

'=6/($'&/B <@AB / " ,64,/'=/5.4(2: "2
8(+.*><0<#
9(.*><,+ 62

7*8)*0 !&+..
4
<!"#8(+3><2
<#
7*

%2
(1
<$%&'(!3),//./,<@AB !3),+ 69*&4,><2:!"*0<#3(92:8)*)
+
$5/>";+(
)+/ '673%*)&G'(2
<$%&'(2
<@AB !3),//(2:> *2+.(
3(E'34 1,6(7*8)*>##34

",=5/..........................................................?7*3,&
(,3/'E' <2 )
67<*,

) '
 8$ 4

% $ 18  @6( .!. 2551
:$  ' > */,
6/($'&/B %*$  ' 13.10 T14.50 .
+/:/ ' <@AB /(" B 7 8 ( . 5/4
+/ ' ,3/'E' <2/,3"'
/'2#2B
:9$  ' . #2

'=6/($'&/B , 40203
2326 '
3,&&6("
!",./,$%&'(!3),//. #2


G'(2$ )
>. #2

'=6/($'&/B <@AB ^,$", !/.*/'&/B0& ,64,/'=/5.4(2:
"2
8(+.*><0<#9( .*><,+ 62

7*8)*0 !&+..
4
<!"#8(+3><2
<#
7*

%2
(1
<$%&'(!3),//./,<@AB !3),+ 69*&4,><2:!"*0<#3(92:8)*)
+
$5/>";+(
)+/ '673%*)&G'(2
<$%&'(2
<@AB !3),//(2:> *2+.(
3(E'34 1,6(7*8)*>##346> *
(,&,!9 * $5/<#8)*.*><(.4 !"#(
3(E'>
(.4

",=5/..........................................................?7*3,&
(,3/'E' <2 )
67<*,

) 2#9
 8$ 1

% $ 14  @6( .!. 2551
:$  2#9 X$#.*,D,
 %*$  ' 12.30 .
+/:/ ' <@AB /(" B 7 8 ( . 5/4
+/ ' ,3/'E' <2/,3"'
/'2#2B
2326 2#9
$5/3(W B6(/7+ !"#" #6/6
2/*$ & 2#9
2:> *2+ <@AB "762
 2 $+/!(+!2, <<;//7+ !(+ !"#$
=(&"/)
<@AB <#3'2!(+(+$+/ !"#(+$
 <@AB 8(+6+/=/!(+>5/,2
!(+=/); )+

%2
(1)*)
<@AB 62
<#$(& !"#(
(;3($EB2
)
&+/;66">6/6
 2#9
<@AB 8(+6+/&/6:9(/<$#,8(+(
6(7*36;*6!"#8*,><672+8 +

",=5/..........................................................?7*3,&
(,3/'E' <2 )
67<*,

) 2#9
 8$ 2

% $ 16  @6( .!. 2551
:$  2#9 .*, */,'= %*$  ' 11.35 .
+/:/ ' <@AB /(" B 7 8 ( . 5/4
+/ ' ,3/'E' <2/,3"'
/'2#2B
2326 2#9
$5/3(W B6(3($EB$5/+( */,
2/*$ & 2#9
2:> *2+ <@AB 3'2C$#$5/?7*=(+$5/?7* ',D)C$#DE' <#3'2
(2
3;) 8(+=/2:,+($5/?7* ',6(6') 0!"#.*/3/!#<@AB 62
<#$(&
!"#(
(;3($EB2
)
&+/$5/8(++= 5/ ',
 2#9
<@AB> *6(+((5/(.4 &/6:9(!22;.*/

",=5/..........................................................?7*3,&
(,3/'E' <2 )
67<*,

) 2#9
 8$ 3

% $ 18  @6( .!. 2551
:$  2#9 X$#.*,D,
 %*$  ' 14.10 .
+/:/ ' <@AB /(" B 7 8 ( . 5/4
+/ ' ,3/'E' <2/,3"'
/'2#2B
2326 2#9
$5/3(W B.*/20<<',


2/*$ & 2#9
2:> *2+ <@AB =/
'= !#! 8(+=/
'= 6 '&3&B 6(6') 0!"#
.*/3/!# <@AB 62
<#&4,><
"2
673/ !"#(5/8(+.*><06(5/9(/<B
 2#9
<@AB > *6(+((5/(.4 &/6:9(2;.*/ (
6(7*3+6;*667(.4"*2
9(
D&*&/

",=5/..........................................................?7*3,&
(,3/'E' <2 )
67<*,

 !"#19

9$ "#)*+/%>%($
2 (9)*%1
%
 !"#9 K 8L3%" MN9%(77
/ 8'12/

9$ "#
...............................................................
( %*(  2 )
+/73%+/%MO(%(7

...............................................................
( 3 +(%9)
+/%>%($
2

...................................................................
( 2! (P *(! ' H)
+/%>%($
2

')+**$ 
22('(

+/*
DE'
<@AB
=(
E$"
W2W B
X'&'AB
="'&
='2B
[
(
""B
(
1
6(9

2
+*%2
%2:
6(9
 x 1

<@
DE' AB
2
1
2

=
(

+/:/*
W2
E$" W B X'&'AB
1
2
2

="'&

='2B

[
( ""B

1
2
2

1
1
2
1
2

1
2

1
1
2
2

1
1
2
2

0
0
0
0

1
3
4
2

2
1
1
2
2

%2
)

6#!2

: )> *

1
2
1
3
4

1
1
2
2

1
1
2
2

1
1
2
2

1
0
1
2

: )> * /) 1 67 2 6#!

/) 2 67 1 6#!
P25
P50
P75

25
x 10 = 3
100
50 x 10 = 5
100
75 x 10 = 8
100

%$ 1
) > 8

%$ 2
) 5 - 8
%$ 3
) 3 - 4 , %$ 4
) <

$)++  
22('(

=(

3
=#'2B

""B

<@AB

2
X'&'&B

DE'

1
E$"
[
(

="'&

W2W B

6

   1
   2

)*
%22)++  
22('(
1. ";+(+/(
24, () ";+(65/
";+(+/2
 1 #/)* E$" ,DE' , <@AB
";+(+/2
 2 #/)* [
( , =#'2B , ="'&
2. 22./,3(='
1. Star
65/ 2. Rejectee
65/ =(
3. Neelectee 65/ ""B
4. Isolator
65/ 5. Mutual choice
/))

/) 1 65/ X'&'&B ,W=W B
/) 2 65/ &+,/)
8)*!+ =#'2B-="'& , [
(- ="'& , =#'2B-[
( , <@AB- E$" ,
<@AB- DE' , DE' - E$"

! $$ 67
1. Star

65/ ?7*2
/7+,>3;)8)*"5/<$5/(2
3;)

2. Rejectee

65/ ?7*2
/7+,/3;)!"#8(+(
$5/"5/

3. Neelectee

65/ ?7*2
/7+,/3;)!"#(
$5/"5/

4. Isolator

65/ ?7*2
8(+(
>6"5/!"#8(+"5/>6

5. Mutual choice

65/ "5/1,!"#

"5//))

65/ /) 1

"5//))

65/ /) 2

6
"5/&+,/)