Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SPIROKOSTOF
BOOKREVIEWPRESENTATION REVIEWEDBYMADHUMALUKANI(SA1103)
KOSTOFSAPPROACH
Kostofemphasizesonthestudyofarchitectureasawholeandsaid,"Allbuildingsofthepast,regardlessofsizeorstatus orconsequence,shouldideallybedeemedworthyofstudy."Hisapproachtoarchitecturalhistorystressesonurbanism alongwitharchitecturalworksandshowshowbuildingsareembeddedintheirphysicalandsocialcontexts.Kostofs bookAHistoryofArchitecture:Settingsandritualsembodiestheseideasandillustrateshisnewperspectivestowards architecturalstudy. Kostofsharesfourpointswhichhehasfollowedinhisstudy. farchitecture whereinheregards g structureandaestheticsasinseparable; p Theonenessof Thesettingofarchitecture buildingscannotbestudiedinisolationfromimmediatecontext; Thecommunityofarchitectureculturalvaluesofthesocietywhichpreventarchitecturefrombeingmerelyabuildform; Themeaningofarchitecture whereinhediscussesthereason,timeandpurposebehindthebuildingbeingwhatitis.
ABOUTTHEBOOK
Thebookisdividedintothreesegments:Thefirstrevealstheoriginanddevelopmentofearlycitieswithreferenceto Mesopotamia,Egypt,Greece,Romeandotherrelevantcivilizations. Thesecondpartdiscussesthemedievalperiod,studyingtheurbanizationofEuropeancountriesuntilthe18th century andthethirdpartdiscussestheinfluencesofmodernism. Kostofhasnotfollowedastrictchronologicalpatterninhisdepiction.Thesequenceismerelyonthedegreeof evolution,yet,attimes,hehaslaidparallelstocomparethetimeframe.Forinstancehehaslinkedtheemergenceof g oftheStonehenge. g Thisgives g thereadertheclearideaoftimeframeofvarious Sumerwiththethirdrearrangement events andtherebycomparisonsbetweenvariouscivilizationscanbeestablished. Whileexplainingtheculturalandreligiousaspectsinrelationtothecity,Kostofhasnotneglectedotherdetailssuchas constructiontechniquesandmaterialsandtheiravailability,hencegivingacompleteoverviewofthecivilization. IhavefocusedmystudyonthefirstfewchapterswhichdiscusstheNeolithiceraandtheearlysettlementswhichset thefoundationsofurbanrevolutionandthecitiesofMesopotamiaandEgypt.
THERISEOFTHECITY:ARCHITECTUREINWESTERNASIA
THEURBANREVOLUTION BEFORETHECITIES NEOLITHICSETTLEMENTS
JERICHO, KHIROKITIAAND CATALHOYUK
CITIESOFMESOPOTAMIA
URBANREVOLUTION
NearEast TheCradleOfCivilization ThisdatesbacktothesecondmillenniumB.C.,thetimeofthethirdrearrangementoftheStonehenge. WhileNeolithic Europecarriedonastoneusingpeasanteconomy,intwospotsofneareast,MesopotamiaandEgypt,therewere contemporaryliterateculturesthatknewhowtoworkmetal,ororganizefoodproduction,andkeepwrittenrecordsoftheir transactionsandbeliefs. BeingCivilized ,whichmeanscity. y Thisgives g ustheotheraccepted p characterof ThewordcivilizationderivesfromtheLatinwordcivitas, civilizedhumanity thatithasforitstheatreofactivitiesanintricateartifact,thecity.ButKostofquestionsthefactthat civilizedlifecannotexistoutsideofcities andsays,incorrelatingurbanismandcivilizedhistory,wehaveimbuedthecity withpositivequalitiestheabsenceofwhichhastendedtodowngradeothersocialorganisms.Hevalidatesthiswith illustrationsofthreesettlementswhichqualifyasatown:Jericho,KhirokitiaandCatalhoyuk.
BEFORETHECITIES:NEOLITHICSETTLEMENTS
JERICHO,(ISRAEL),7500B.C.
Theearliestsurvivingtown. Thestorybeginswiththelifegivingsourceoffreshwater(nowcalledElishasfountain)wherehunterssettledfor agriculture. Theearliesthousesdatingbackto7500B.C.haddomedhousesofmudbrickwithanentranceporchandcurvedwalls, probablyan imitationofroundtentsofthenomadichunters. Thelaterhouses(6500B.C.)wererectangularwithroundedcorners,arrangedaroundcourtyardswhichwereusedfor cooking.Severalpublicbuildingssetasidewithforworshipwere interwoven withthehouses. Theclusterpatternwasdominantandhencethestreetsweremissing. missing Themostimportantfeatureofthissettlementwasfortification.
JERICHO,TOWERBUILTAGAINSTSIDEOFSETTLEMENTWALL(FORTIFICATION),7500B.C.
KHIROKITIA,(CYPRUS),5500B.C.
Thissettlementshowsthepresenceoffirsttruestreet. Thestreetrunningfromtheriverbank,uphill,formsthe mainspine. UnlikeJerichowhichwasaclosedtown,Khirokita hadan opencompositionwithhousesoneithersideofthestreet. Hencegrowth wasnotrestricted. Thestreetalsoshowedapresenceofhaltingplaceinthe formofawidenedplatformwhichcanbeconsideredan antecedenttoacitysquare.
KHIROKITIA, NEOLITHIC SETTLEMENT, ca. 5500 B.C., PLAN SHOWING STREET SPINE AND HOUSES
CATALHOYUK,(TURKEY),7000B.C.
Besideshuntingandagriculture,thisNeolithicsettlement restsonanewrationaletrade. Obsidian(blackvolcanic glass)wasthemainarticlefortrade.Obsidiantoolswere probablytradedforseashellsandflintfromSyria. Anotherimportantskilltheypossessedwasworkingwith metal. Thiswastooearlyforsuchtechnicalknowledge,as metallurgywasnotfullypracticeduntiltheculturesof MesopotamiaandEgypt. Thesettlementisbelievedtobeenrichedwithshopsof merchantsofleatherandfur,smithsmakingornamentsand publicmarketsinthemidstofurbanfabric. toolsandp
Thesettlementwasneitheropennorclosed.Thebuildings weregroupedintotightquartersandwhichopenedupan occasionalcourtyard.Acontinuousblankwallfacedthe y countryside. Streetswereabsent.Entryofthehouseswasthrougha holeintheflatroofreachedbyawoodenladder.Italso actedasasmokestack. Theshrineswerelaidonthesameschemeashouses. Plasterreliefsofmothergoddessresemblingtoimagery ofoldstoneage formedthesurfacedecor. decor
7000
B.C.,
THECITIESOFMESOPOTAMIA
LAYOUTOFCITIES TEMPLESANDZIGGURATS PALACES
THECITIESOFMESOPOTAMIA
MAP: MESOPOTAMIA
Mesopotamia(fromthefourthmillenniumB.C.)wasthefirstsettlementqualifiedasacity andthefirsttoexhibitthe writingtradition. Itshistoryisdividedintofourbroadsegmentsofchronology. Protoliterate Period(3500 3000B.C.) Battlementsofringwalls Templeandzigguratbegantogainarchitecturaldefinition Firstwrittendocument yDynastic y Period(3000 ( 2350B.C.) ) Early Kingshipandestablishmentofhereditarykingship Monumentalpalaceasanadministrativecentre Raisingthedefensivesystemofthecity LaterSumerianPeriod(upto 1600B.C.) Riseofempire,collectiveruleofcitystates Highpointofbuildingtypeofziggurat(zigguratofUr Nammu) TheAssyrianPeriod(1350 612B.C.) ThenorthernregionflourishedattheexpenseoflowerMesopotamia imposingstatereliefsandpalacesaccompaniedbydeclineinpositionofziggurat
LAYOUTOFCITIES
HistorybeforetheEarlyDynasticperiodisstillblurred. Howeverby b then h about b ad dozencitiesh had dfl flourished h din SumerandtowardsnorthinBabylon. Thecitieswereenclosedbyawallandsurroundedby suburbanvillagesandhamlets. Thetwomonumentalcenterswerethezigguratcomplex overseenbythepalace.Theurbanfabricwasapromiscuous blendofresidentialandcommercialbuildings.AtUr,an exampleofabazaar wasfound:aconcentrationoflittle boothsalonganarrowpassagewithdoorsateitherends. Amplesquaresandpublicgardenswererare.
Streetwidthforprinciplethoroughfareswasnotmorethan3 meters.Theseledtopublicbuildingsandwereborderedwith thehousesoftherich.Trafficwasmostlypedestrian,however servicecartsandchariotshavealsobeenexcavated. Housesweregroupedintocongestedblockssharingparty walls,againsttheorthogonalneatdesignofarchitects.Even whilereplacement,theplanoftheolderhousehadadirect bearingastheruinswereusedasfoundation. Thearchitecturalmetabolismconstantlytransformedthe makeupofthecityscapewhichwasheldtogetherbystiffer fstreets. skeletonof Thelevelofthestreetsroseduetothedumpingofrefuse leadingtosinkingfloorlevels.Whenthegroundlevelgot buriedconsiderably,thehousewasraisedtotheceilingusing thegroundasservicevault. Therewerenowindowstowardstheoutsideandeverything openedintothecourtyard.
LEFT: UR, RESIDENTIAL QUARTER BETWEEN THE ZIGGURAT PRECINCT AND THE WEST HARBOR, PLAN ABOVE: UR, UR COURTYARD OF RESIDENTIAL QUARTER, RECONSTRUCTION DRAWING
TEMPLESANDZIGGURATS
Smallshrineswerescatteredthrough g outthefabric.They y hadtwostandardfeatures:anicheofepiphanymarked bythestatueofdeityoranalter,andatableforofferings. By3500B.C.,theevolvedintomonumentaltemples. Thetemplecomplexwasthehubofaneconomicsystem thathasbeendescribedastheocraticsocialism. Itwassurroundedbyitsownprotectivewall,formingthe lastbulwarkagainstattack. attack Thetemplestoodona tremendousplatformcalledthezigguratandwasfreeof thepressuresofdensityinitsampleprecinct.
Theexperience Th i of fziggurat i ttemple t l rested t don reverential ti lclimbing. li bi However H unlike lik the th earlier li temples, t l placed l din i open landscapeatthehighestofthecity,theurbantemple exhibitedadifferentapproach.Dedicatedtolesserdeities,itwasbuilt closertothelivingspaceofthecityandwassurroundedbycommonstructures. SintempleIIatKhafaje f illustratestheresultof fthiscondition.Thetemplebecametheinnermostof faseriesof fenclosedspaces withasingleentranceinoneofitslongsides. ThisisincompletecontrasttowhitetempleatWarka, whichwasanopenloftedundisturbedstructure.
LEFT:KHAFAJE,OVALTEMPLE,ca.26502350B.C.;RIGHT:WARKA,WHITETEMPLE,35003000B.C.
PALACES
Theziggurat gg intimelostsomephysical p y prominence p tootherfocalp pointsofthe urbanfabric,theprincipalonebeingthepalaceoftheking.
A
DuringtheAssyrianperiod,thezigguratbecameamereadjuncttothekings palace,whichthencompletelydominatedthecityscape.
SKETCH PLANS SHOWING RELATIONSHIP OF ZIGGURAT (RED) AND ROYAL PALACE (GREEN) : A. AT UR, ca. 2000 B.C. SSU , ca ca. 1800 800 B.C. C B. AT ASSUR, C. AT ASSUR, ca. 1200 B.C. D. AT KHORSABAD, ca. 700 B.C.
Thefinal Th fi ldebasement d b of fthe h ziggurat i occurred datKhorsabad. Kh b d Thepalacehere,ratherthanbeingsurroundedbythefabricof thecity,showeditsbacktothecitywalls.Thepalacewhichhad startedoutasanaccessorytotheziggurat,nowgrewatthe expenseofit,intoatheatreofabsolutepowerandintimidation.
LEFT: KHORSABAD, THE POSITION OF ZIGGURAT IN THE PALACE COMPLEX. ABOVE: KHORSABAD, THE PALACE IN RELATION TO THE CITY
THEARCHITECTUREOFANCIENTEGYPT
THELANDOFEGYPT THEBURIALOFKINGS THETIMEOFTHEGODS ENDURANCEOFTHECULT
ARCHITECTUREOFANCIENTEGYPT
Thissophisticatedcultureofriversettlementsisattributedwithconservatism,orratherthebalanceitsustainsbetween innovationandtradition. NeolithicvillagelifealongNiledevelopedintotwoindependentpolities:LowerEgypt,whichincludedtheDeltaregion untilMemphisandUpperEgypt,southwardsuntilAswan. LaterKingMenesofUpperEgyptinvadedthenorthandunifiedthecountryandestablisheditscapitalatMemphis.This coincideswiththeProtoliterate PeriodinMesopotamia,about3000B.C. ARCHAICPERIOD,3000 2665B.C.:Architectureshowedgreatadvancesduringthisperiod;beginningwithbricktombs andpalacesitevolvedtostonemonumentslikethoseatSaqqara. Thiscoincideswiththeearlydynasticperiodin Mesopotamia. OLDKINGDOM,until2150B.C.:MarkedbytheemergenceofabsoluteKingship,theruleofPharaoh.Thearchitectural sequelwasfollowedbytruepyramidsasthoseatGiza. MIDDLEKINGDOM KINGDOM,2250 1570B B.C. C :Th Theperiod i dof fsocial i land dpolitical liti lchaos, h t towards d th theend dof fthi third dmillennium, ill i came toanendandthecapitalwasestablishedatThebes.Dominanceofreligionoverfuneraryarchitectureandpriesthood overkingship wasobserved. NEWDINGDOM,16001300B.C.:Monumental ltemple l architecture h flourished fl h dasdistinct d from f the h royal lburials. b l This h era alsowitnessedalieninvasions.
LANDOFEGYPT
TheEgyptian gyp riverwassubject j tounfailingly g yregular g andbenign g flooding gwhichleftthedeposits p ofrichblacksoil.This narrowfertilestripofvalleywasrigidlydividedintofields,theboundariesofwhichhadtobereestablishedafterevery periodofflooding. ThingsranalongNile,mostlynorthandsouth,oratrightanglestoit.Orthogonalplanningcamenaturallybothinthefield divisionandinthedesignofcities.ThisaccountsasaremarkabledifferencebetweenMesopotamianandEgyptianorder. ElKahun exhibitsafineexampleofthiswhereinthestandardizedbuildingsaregroupedintospecialzones brickrow housesforworkersandcraftsmen,oftenbacktoback,aquarteroflargemansionsforgovernmentofficials,andanenclosed compoundortheking king.
EL KAHUN, PLAN SHOWING WORKERS HOUSING TO THE LEFT, AND AMPLER GOVERNMENT QUARTERS TO THE RIGHT
Nileaxisconnectedandunifiedthewholeregion. region Italsoactedasamajorhighway highway. Thislinearcharacterisevokedinroyalburialsandtemplesalsowhichappearlikeaseriesofepisodesalonga predeterminedpathbuiltovertime.Incontrasttothis,asseeninMesopotamianzigguratcomplexes, anumberof buildingswithindependentboundarywallsweregroupedtogetherbutwithnounifyingaxis. axis Therepetitivecycleoffloodingoftheriverprojectedaneternalorder.Thebeliefthatdeathwasnotafinalthing but merelythepassagetoanotherregion,wasmanifestationofthesame.Onestombwaslikeoneshouse,builttolastfor eternity t it to t sustain t i the th theatres th t of fafterlife. ft lif
AMARNA (UPPER EGYPT), DIAGRAMMATIC PLAN OF LAYOUT, SHOWING THE RELATIONSHIP TO THE NILE AND THE COURSE OF THE MAIN STREETS.
THEBURIALOFKINGS
EARLYBURIALS Atfirst,asaresultofunificationofEgypt,thePharaohwasgivenadouble burial;symbolicallyatAbydos,sacredsiteofOsirisandtheactualbodyat Saqqara. AtSaqqara,inadditiontotheBurialchambers,thereseveraladditional roomsholdingkingspossessions.Inlateryears,additionalfeatureswere added;smallmortuarytempleonthenorthside, side andawoodenboat alongsidethetombtocarrythepharaohacrossheaven.
ABOVE: CENOTAPH AT ABYDOS (UPPER EGYPT), ROYAL TUMULUS TOMB OF FIRST DYNASTY, 3100 2890 B.C. BELOW: SAQQARA (LOWER EGYPT), MORTUARY COMPLEX OF FIRST DYNASTY
ZOSERSPYRAMIDCOMPLEX
11 9 8
10 12 13 14
5 3 1
2 SAQQARA, MORTUARY COMPLEX OF KING ZOSER, THIRD DYNASTY, ca. 2680 B.C.
Thed Th desire i tomonumentalize li the h tomb band dmake k it i stand doutabove b the h perimeter i of fthe h wall, ll i isobvious. b i Six Si unequal l stagesalsogiveasenseofclimbing,ofaspiration,aneffectvisuallyclosetotheMesopotamianziggurat. ThekingwasidentifiedwithsungodRe,andthepyramidwasarepresentationofthesame.Itprobablystoodforthe moundofcreationwhosesummitwastherestingplaceofSun.Itwasalsothoughtofasthestaircaseofdivineascent whichledthekingtoheaven.
RIGHT: STATUE OF KING ZOSER IN SERDAB LEFT: ZOSER COMPLEX DUMMY CHAPEL, PYRAMID
GIZA ( (LOWER EGYPT), ), THE PYRAMID GROUP, , THIRD DYNASTY, ca. 25702500 B.C.
The pyramid Th id of f Chefren Ch f i known is k f the for h noble bl form f of f Sphinx, S hi a leonine l i body with portraithead of the king. At the east of the complex, in front of the Sphinx, stands temple of Harmakhis. Another valley temple stands next to it, glorified with statues of Chefren. From here, the body is transferred to the mortuary temple via a covered causeway that bridges the sphinx group and the pyramid. The mortuary temple begins with a T shaped hall followed by an open court. The innermost sanctum, that follows, is reserved for offerings for the sustenance of the body. This is then followed by the stone mountain of the pyramid where the body lays.
1 4 5
LEFT: GIZA, G PLAN OF O CHEFREN C CO COMPLEX S O SHOWING G THE MORTUARY TEMPLE (1), THE CAUSEWAY (2), THE VALLEY TEMPLE (3) AND THE SPHINX(4) WITH THE TEMPLE OF HARMAKHIS (5) ABOVE: REMAINS OF THE MORTUARY TEMPLE BELOW: REMAINS OF THE SPHINX GROUP
THETIMEOFGODS
AfterthetermofthreeGizakings, g ,theimmediatesuccessorfeltitnecessary ytoenhancethepyramid py settings g atAbusir with separatesuntemples inthehonorofRe.Themainfeatureofthesetempleswereopencourtcontaininganobelisk mountedonapodium. Thetomb tombs sscaleshrankandthemortuarytemplegrewbiggercompetingwiththeproperpyramidform.Thepyramid nowdidnotevenholdtherealtomb,whichhadmovedelsewherewithinthecomplex.Theemphasishadshiftedfromthe visualglorificationoftherulertothepiousritesoftheburialcult, andthesewerenowdominatedbythenewchiefdeityof thenationalreligion,sungodAmon.BythetimeoftheNewKingdom,thepyramidwasnolongeraroyalprerogative.
DEIRELBAHRI MENTUHOTEP MENTUHOTEPS STOMB TheentireschemeofMentuhotep wasorientedtowardsthenewlystartedtempleofAmon acrosstheriver,themodern Karnak.Ittakesthecompromisedsupremacyofthepharaohalittlefurther,intendingtosatisfytheprovincialaristocracy andthepriesthoodofAmon. Amon Hissuccessor successor,QueenHatshepsut, Hatshepsut marchedforwardwiththesamescheme. scheme Beingawoman, woman herunusualandprecariouspositioncreatedanaddedurgencytodemonstratenearnesstogod.
Thevalleytemplehasdisappeared,sohastheunroofedcausewaylinewithstatuesofking.Thecomplexnowconsistsofa largeforecourtplantedwithtrees,aterracecutoutoftherock,onwhichthemortuarytemplestood,anarrowunit comprisingofacourtandahypostylehall. Thekings king sshareofthecentralspacewasmarkedonlybyacenotaph cenotaph.Hisrealtomblaydeepinthecliff, cliff approachedbya longundergroundtunnelthatstartedinthesmallcourtbehindthetemple.Thepyramidwasaltogetherabsentfromthe queenscomplex.
DEIR ELBAHRI (UPPER EGYPT), THE MORTUARY TEMPLES OF MENTUHOTEP 2050 B.C., , AND QUEEN HATSHEPSHUT, , 1500 B.C.
KARNAKANDLUXOR Thetwotemplecompoundswerelinkedwith oneanotherbyanavenueoframheaded sphinxes;betweenthetwostoodthepalaces andadministrativebuildings.They functionedlikesocialandeconomiccenters whoseadministratorsexercisedpowerin accordance d with ithth thewealth lthof fth their i h holdings. ldi
MONTU
KARNAK,TEMPLE OFAMON
MUT
LUXOR
TOP: LUXOR, LUXOR RAMSES II PYLON; RIGHT: THE AVENUE OF RAMHEADED SPINXES LEADING TO THE AMON TEMPLE; LEFT: AMON TEMPLE, THE GREAT HYPOSTYLE HALL
ENDURANCE OFTHECULT
Thep primacy yofAmon wasneversuccessfully ychallenged g intheNewKingdom. g Thepriesthood p continuedtog growinstrength g attheexpenseofpharaonic supremacy. Thelaterperiod,aroundfirstmillenniumB.C.,observedthesuccessionofforeigndominations;aperiodofEthiopianrule followedbyPersian,GreekempireofAlexandertheGreatuntiltheRoman. Therewerenosignificantmodificationsinthetempletype;itcontinuedtogrowunderthebenevolentapprovalofalien rulersanxioustogainthesupportoftheconservativeAmon priesthood.
....