Professional Documents
Culture Documents
OVER.
Page Two
Page Three
Page Four
Page Five
with such
a strange penalty. (5 marks)
37. What effort has the Duke already made on Shylock's behalf? (2 marks)
38. In your own words, explain two points of Shylock's punishment. (2 marks)
39. What two reasons does Portia have for consulting Dr. Bellario? (2 marks).
PART THREE: PARAGRAPH RESPONSE (13 marks)
INSTRUCTIONS: Select one of the following topics, then write a paragraph
of approximately 100 words on one of the following
topics (10 marks). Up to THREE additional marks will
be awarded for the quality of your written expression.
A. Portia is an unusually intellectual Shakespearean heroine. Briefly compare
her to at least one other female principal in a play by Shakespeare; some
possibilities include
Calpurnia or Portia in Julius Caesar, Kate in The Taming of the Shrew, Juliet
in
Romeo and Juliet, Lady Macbeth in The Tragedy of Macbeth, Ophelia in The
Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, and Cordelia in The Tragedy of King
Lear.
B. The Merchant of Venice is not frequently studied in schools because it seems
to be
racist. With specific reference to five incidents or passages in the play, respond
to this criticism of the play.
C. Unlike some of Shakespeare's early villains, Shylock is a developing
character for
whom we begin to feel some sympathy. Briefly compare him to at least one
other antagonist in a play by Shakespeare; some possibilities include Cassius
in Julius Caesar, Tybalt in The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet, Macbeth in The
Tragedy of Macbeth, Claudius in The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark,
and Edmund in The Tragedy of King Lear.
D. It is possible to argue that the theme of both the main plot and the subplot of
The Merchant of Venice is "The quality of mercy is not strained . . . ." With
reference to both plots, respond to this interpretation of the play.
END OF TEST
-5Name
Score......../31
William Shakespeare's
Merchant of Venice Open-Book Test
Block.........
33. (2 marks)
34. (2 marks)
35. (2 marks)
36. (5 marks)
9.
20.
31.
English
10.
21.
M. C.
11.
12.
13.
22.
23.
24.
Part Two: Short-
-1OVER.
ROUGH WORK & PLANNING ONLY
-237. (2 marks)
38. (2 marks)
39. (2 marks)
."
OVER
-3-
Score for
Score for Written
content, Part 3.
Expression.
3a.
3b.
(10)
(3)
(Excerpted from the Marker's Guide for the January, 1993, English 12 Provincial
Examination.)
Written Expression 3
The 3-mark paragraph addresses the writing task directly, making clear its purpose. It
flows smoothly, employing apt phrasing and appropriate transitions. When the reference
requires a quotation, it is integrated into the text suitably and correctly. Diction is
sophisticated and precise; sentencing is varied. Errors are those characteristic of first draft
material.
Written Expression 2
The 2-mark paragraph does the job required in a reasonably coherent manner. Its
syntax is competent, but somewhat repetitive and occasionally awkward. Vocabulary is
adequate and, in general, appropriate. Quoted references may be awkwardly incorporated
or of questionable value. Errors may arrest the reading flow.
Written Expression 1
The 1-mark paragraph relates to the problem posed by the question in a random
manner. The purpose of the response may frequently be questionable. Vocabulary, while
appropriate, may be general, simplistic, and/or imprecise. Sentence structures may be
repetitive, and sentence sense may be problematic. Errors reflect a deficient command of
language appropriate to the expository task. N. B. Paragraphs may be awarded zero for
failure to provide a response in keeping with the purpose of the question.
-4Name K E Y
Block.........
William Shakespeare's
Merchant of Venice Open-Book Test
English
M. C. Score......../31
young again through herbs gathered by such magical moonlight as shines on them.
Jessica provides a romantic, female figure from classical myth to match Dido.
35. (2 marks) Portia's father established that there should be a "trial of Caskets" so
that his daughter would marry one true of heart, and not a mere fortune-hunter.
Bassiano's success seems to resolve Antonio's problem since Bassiano will now be
able to re-pay his debt to Antonio, who is turn will re-pay Shylock. As both a soldier
and a scholar, Bassiano is less likely to be attracted to the "outward shows"; thus, he
proves himself worthy of the subtle Portia.
36. (5 marks) Shylock calls his sinister agreement "a merry sport," suggesting that
its terms are a mere jest. He asserts that he is really lending the money "gratis" to
win Antonio's favour; in other words, the loan is presented as a peace-offering. The overconfident Antonio is not imaginative enough to see Shylock's real intention, which he has
taken considerable pains to disguise as "kindness." What advantage could he gain,
Shylock argues, from obtaining flesh he can neither eat nor sell?