QuestionTheprosandconsofhavingsomeoneselectyourcareer.

Includenegativeandpositiveaspect Pros
Ifyouknowonlyaboutpainting,andifsomeonenominatedyoutobesoftwareengineer.Andif youdontevenknowABCofwhatyouaredoingthenyouwilleitherbefiredorourcouldhave todriveyourselfintotheground(gettiredofworkinghard)tomastereverything.Anotherpros isthatyouwanttobeathleteandyouarenominatedtobeadoctor,youknowwhattodowhen youaredoctorbutyouwillnotgetachargeoutofworkingasadoctorthenaathlete.Theseare thethingsthatIthinkareprosofhavingsomeoneselectyourfuture.

Cons
ifyouareshy,youwanttobescientistandtheonewhoisassigningjobsknowsthatyouwant tobethatsoyouredreamisfulfilled.ThisisthethingthatIthinkareconsofhavingsomeone selectyourfuture.

Rules. RulesInJonasCommunity
1.NoPain 2.NoJetsToFlyOverCommunity 3.NoOneCanCutInLineWhilePlaying 4.InAFamilyThereIsOneMother,OneFather,TwoChildrens 5.EldersDecideJobs 6.EldersDecideMarriage 7.After12StudentsStartReceivingJobs 8.ShouldNotSpeakVeryFast 9.NewbornBabiesShouldBePerfect

QuestionJonascommunityhasalotofrules.Doyouthinkthatsgood orbadtohavethesemanyrules?Justify.
Noitsnotgoodtohavemanyrulesbecausewemaygetdazedofwhatyoumaydotofollow thisrule.Sometimeourrulesmaygoagainstsomeofyourassignmentlikeyourmaamwants yourhomeworktomorrow,theworksheetisveryhardtodoandyourtimeisupnowyouhaveto playdownthenyoucanbreakyourruleandcompleteyourhomeworkinyourplaytime.Another problemisthatyourrulescangoagainstlikeoneofyourrulesaystosleepat7&Anotherrule sayseatat8thenyourrulesaredisobeyingeachother.SobytheabovestatementsIThink thatweshouldnothavelonglistofrules.

QuestionHowwouldyoufeelifyouwereinplaceofJonasinthe ceremonyoftwelevesandwouldhavereceivedthejobofreceiver
IfIwasinplaceofJonasintheceremonyIwouldbeangry,sad&curious.SadbecauseItisso parsalityofnotreceivinghisjobastheyweresetaccordingtotheirbirthdays.Iwouldhave beensoangryandsaidtheelderstoreleaseherfromcommunitybutIunderstandthatif Jonaswasgiventhechancethentheelderswouldthinkthatheisgivenextracare&others arenot.CuriousbecauseIwouldbeverycurioustoknowwhichjobisassignedtome.After receivingthejobofIwouldhavebeencryingthatIonlygotthemostharshassignmenteverin thecommunitybutIwouldalsobehappythatIhavesomeuniqueskillthatshouldbetherein receiverofmemory

QuestionBrainstormdistinctivememoriesfromgrowingup.Make surememoriesareincompletesentencesbutinlistform.Nexttoeach memory,youshouldcategorizethedescriptionbasedonthe rememberedemotion.traumatic,exciting.Includeatleastone negativeandonepositiveevent.

Positive: Therewasheldamusiccompetitioninvibrant&Ihavenevergonetoanyofmusic competition,Iwasfrightenedthatwhatisgoingtohappenbutthenalsowewon becausewedidplentyofhardwork&thenafteronemonthofcompetitionwegotour trophies.ItwasmyfirsttrophyIwasfeelingveryproud.

Negative: WhenIwasthreeyearsold,IfelldrainageinfrontofmyhouseatONGCcolony Agartala.Mylefthandgotfractured&mybirthdaywasfourdaysaway.Icelebratedmy birthdaywithbandageandpaintraumatic

Thegiversaysthatwithoutmemoriesknowledgeismeaningless, whatdoeshemean?
GiverissayingthetruthbecauseIfyouknowthatwhatissnowbutyoudontknowhowitisfelt thenyourknowledgeismeaningless.IalsothinkthatheisgivenassignmentReceiverof Memoryfromthenameyoucanseethathewillreceivememorybecauseheisvery knowledgeable(ashewasoneoftopperinclass)sothathisknowledgedoesn'tgowasteas thegiversaid.SoIagreetowhatgiverissaying.

Doyouthinkitsfairthatonepersoninthecommunitythereceiver shouldhavetobeburdenedandpainedbythememoriessothatno oneelseis?Explain.

No,Ithinkitsnotfairthatonlythereceiverofmemoryshouldbeburdenedwithpain,thepain shouldbesharedwiththepeoplesothateveryoneshouldhavesomememoryofhowtheouter worldlookslikesothathecouldunderstandhowthepainofotherworld.Ifapersonwillonly haveallpainfulandhappymemorythethereisnopointinlivingbecausewewillonlybeseeing thecommunityaroundusandwouldnotseeanythingthatisoutofthiscommunity.Ithinkthat Thereceivershouldnothavehaveallthememorybutitshouldbedistributedtoeveryoneinthe community.

Whatdoyoulearnaboutwhatreleaseis?Howdoyoufeel?Doesthis changeyouropinionaboutthecommunity.Whatdoyounowthink aboutthecommunity

FrommyopinionreleaseforAdultsmeanstobefreefromthecommunityandgosomewhere elseinaniceplacewheretheycangetpeaceandlivehappilyeverafter.ButforBabiesit Hurtsalotcausethebabywhoarenotperfecttheyarebeenkilledbythenurturerandthat

wouldhavecausedlotofpain.Ifiwouldhavebeentherulingbody(Elders)Iwoulderasethat rule.Iwouldfeelverysadforchildrensbeingreleasedfromthecommunity&feelhappywhen oldpeoplearereleased.InmymindIthinkthatthecommunityisnotandnevergoingtobea perfectplace,FirstIusedtothinkthatthecommunityisalittlebitnotperfectbutnowIthink Thatthecommunityisahelltypeplace.

Jonasknowsthatifhisplanfails,hecouldbekilled.Buthebelieves thatifhestays,hislifeisnolongerworthliving.Doyouagree?
Yes,Idoagreewithwhatjonasissayingbecauseitslikejailifyouareinthecommunity becauseyouwilldieinthesamepositionwhenyouwerebroughttothecommunityisahell typeplacewherenoonewantstoliveandeveniwoulddowhatjonasisdoing(Escapeoutof thecommunity),ItmaybehardbutinsteadoflivinginaDystopiaitsbettertolivesomewhere elsewhereyoucanexpressyourselfwithfreedombecauselifeismeaninglessifyoudont expressyourselfandIwouldliketoappreciatejonasfortakingthismuchhardstepstolivehis life.

HowdothinkthegiverwillfeelwhenherealizesJonasisgone?How willJonasfriendsandfamilyfeel?
Giverwillfeelsad&proud.Sadbecausegiverlovedjonasandhehavemanyfeelingsohe musthaveunderstandhowapersonfeelswhensomebodyelseisleaving.Proudbecausehe isverybravethatheisleavingthecommunityknowingthatifsomeonefindhimhewouldbe killed. Familymembers&FriendwillfeelnothingBecausetheyhavenoemotions&motherand fatherdontneedtobesadbecauseiftheydidntfoundjonasthentheywillnameakidjonas andgiveittothem.

Howdoyouthinkthestoryends?
Ithinkthatthejonasisgoingtodiebecausewhenamanisgoingtohehearechonotaproper sound&nowifjonasisgoingtodieandthensomeonewillfoundgadrielinthesnowandthen theywilltakegabeandleavejonasinsnow.

Createyourownendingforthestory
Thenafterawhilepeoplefindjonashandinsidethesnowwhentheydigtheyfindajonas freezedinthesnowandababy.Theytakethebabyandleavethejonasinthesnow.Then suddenlyavoiceofhelpcame.Firsttheywereamazedthatwereisthevoicecomingfrom, thentheygottoknowthatitwascomingfromthefrozenjonas.Theyremovedhimoutofthe snowandthentheyletthemstayintheirhouse.