Collaborative Essay Peer Review

What is the thesis of the paper?

List the points used to support the thesis.

Are the supporting points and evidence convincing? Why or why

not?

Have the writers anticipated or addressed any counter-

arguments?

List any possible counter arguments the writers have not

addressed. Include suggestions for overcoming these counter
arguments.

Give your opinion on the organization and structure of the paper.

Suggest improvements to the organization and structure.
(Remember to look for focus and strong transitions).

Does the paper have a satisfying conclusion? Does it address the

so what question? Suggest improvements to the conclusion.

Are there any grammatical or usage errors that are distracting or

impede your understanding of the text? Please point them out to
the writers.