Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Henderson Guide To UCITS
Henderson Guide To UCITS
Guide to UCITS
Important Information This document is solely for the use of professionals and is not for general public distribution.
Contents
Introduction UCITS: the original vision for Europe UCITS III Non-sophisticated and sophisticated funds Shorting and portfolio symmetry Derivatives Risk management requirements UCITS funds, hedge funds and Newcits funds The transition from UCITS III to UCITS IV UCITS comparison table Conclusion Glossary of terms Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4 Page 5 Page 7 Page 8 Page 9 Page 10 Page 11 Page 12 Page 13
An inauspicious start
It was not long after the implementation of UCITS began before cracks started to appear. The disparate rules of various member states still made it difficult for companies to effectively market their products across borders. Furthermore, the definition of the new permitted investments was already considered slightly behind the curve in relation to the latest techniques being used by fund managers. The first UCITS initiative was always considered very much work in progress, and it was no surprise that the legislation helped highlight several flaws. It was widely anticipated that the development of a second directive (UCITS II), the formulation of which began in the early 1990s, would be able to address such issues. Unfortunately, UCITS II managed to raise more questions than it answered and left the EU member states no closer to agreement about how best to market funds across borders. The proposed outline for UCITS II was subsequently abandoned after the council of member states failed to reach an accord over how far the proposals should go and what form they should take.
UCITS timeline
Original UCITS Directive adopted by the European Union (EU)
EU publishes a new proposal drafted in two parts: the Product and Management directives
February 2007: the deadline by which firms were required to ensure funds were UCITS III compliant
1985
1990s
Plans for UCITS II published, but never go past the proposals stage
1998
2001
Proposals for UCITS III adopted in December 2001, allowing firms to passport their funds across EU member states and increasing the number of investment strategies
2007
2009
UCITS IV directive approved by European Parliament, with implementation expected to take place in 2011
UCITS III
The UCITS III legislation was divided into two distinct directives. The Management Directive determined the processes relating to how investments could be marketed across EU member states. The Product Directive dictated the type of investments and financial instruments that a UCITS III fund could invest in.
Key characteristics
Non-sophisticated funds
Traditional long-only equity portfolios that contain physical holdings as assets Derivatives are only used for Efficient Portfolio Management (EPM) Derivatives cannot be used to create symmetry within a portfolio No disclosure on derivatives required within investment objectives The commitment approach to risk measurement calculates exposure in terms of the obligation to a third-party, including predicted market moves Required to submit a non-sophisticated risk framework with regulators
Sophisticated funds
Additional portfolio scope, including additional asset types/classes, derivatives and investment strategies Symmetry, hedging and other derivative strategies permitted for investment purposes Required to disclose derivative usage in investment objectives Sophisticated risk measurement technique i.e. Value at Risk (VaR) must be calculated on a daily basis Required to submit a sophisticated risk framework with regulators
Shorting types
Naked shorting when a short trade is implemented without the seller borrowing the security. The German government previously initiated a ban on naked shorting on some financial securities, on the basis they cause dangerous market volatility. Hedging using exposure in one security or market to offset or limit exposure in another. For example, a manager may believe that oil Company As share price is undervalued, but is concerned that the oil sector is volatile. The manager could therefore go long on Company As shares, and sell a short position on its rival in the sector, Company B. If the value of Company A goes up, the managers long position will do well, but the hedge will lose money if Company B also rises. If however, oil price volatility causes the share price of both Company A and Company B to fall, the hedge means the manager will reduce his potential loss on Company A through the short position on Company B. Arbitrage an attempt to profit from market inefficiency through the mispricing of certain assets. An example of an arbitrage trade would be purchasing long futures contracts on a UK gilt, and shorting the underlying gilt itself.
Derivatives
As already discussed, UCITS III sophisticated funds cannot physically short sell a stock. However, by purchasing a derivative of that stock, a fund manager can achieve a similar effect, at considerably lower cost than can be achieved through trading in the assets themselves.
A derivative is simply a contract between two parties that relates to or derives from a physical asset. By investing in a derivative, a fund manager is making an investment decision based on the potential performance or risk characteristics of the underlying asset the derivative relates to. This allows a manager to increase their level of investment within a security, without the need to trade the underlying security itself. Derivatives can be used to increase levels of risk in a stock or market where a manager has the most conviction instead of being constrained to small deviations away from a traditional benchmark. A sophisticated UCITS III fund can theoretically hold no physical stocks and instead consist entirely of derivatives and cash or cash-like instruments.
What is leverage?
A fund manager can take a position in an asset in a number of ways, including owning physical stock. Derivatives, however, provide a method for the manager to take the same stake for a much smaller outlay, as a derivatives contract can be bought at a fraction of the cost of purchasing the physical asset. This is therefore a leveraged position, and while upside is amplified, downside is amplified too.
Back-office requirements
For those fund management firms seeking to launch and market sophisticated funds, a robust derivatives trading platform is vital. The development of an infrastructure that properly addresses the risks involved when using derivatives requires a lot of resources and manpower. Any fund management company has to create systems and processes capable of dealing with the added administration involved (ranging from instructions, trades, settlement, pricing and valuations), in order to ensure compliance with all regulatory requirements. These processes need to feed directly into the companys risk management framework to be submitted to the regulators. But more importantly, they need to be processed on an automated basis, with as little manual intervention as possible. Fund management companies who wish to trade derivatives on a regular basis are therefore required to make considerable investment in systems and architecture to ensure the monitoring, measurability and reporting capability of their derivatives exposure. This commitment is crucial to ensure that derivatives can be successfully integrated into sophisticated portfolios.
Stress testing
Stress testing is designed to analyse how a portfolio of securities would potentially react in times of extreme circumstances, such as during a major stock market crash (for example Black Monday in 1987, 9/11 or the banking crisis in 2008). Fund management companies are expected to calculate VaR on a regular basis and stress testing using historical and Monte Carlo (a mathematical analysis technique) methods should also be performed regularly. By subjecting the fund to these types of rigorous tests, it is hoped that consumers can be encouraged to feel a certain degree of confidence that a UCITS III compliant fund will behave as described by its stated objectives, even if the worst should happen. The 2008 banking crisis, however, offered proof that UCITS III offers no guarantee of immunity from risk.
Example
A VaR of 4 means an investment worth 100 million could lose 4% of its value (or 4 million) over a set period. The confidence level is set at 99%, which means that over the same period there is a 99% chance that the fund will not lose 4% of its value.
Explaining VaR
VaR is an attempt to summarise the potential loss to a portfolio of assets over a certain period of time. It is an effective measurement of risk while it happens and is an important consideration when firms make trading or hedging decisions. Almost all major financial institutions have now adopted VaR as a cornerstone of day-to-day risk measurement.
Master-feeder structures
The new directive also looks to introduce master-feeder fund structures. This is a way for fund managers to benefit from economies of scale and the efficiencies associated with a large pool of assets (the master), by selling feeder funds across different investor markets. For example, this will enable a master fund to create a feeder version of the same fund in another jurisdiction. The feeder will invest 85% or more of its net asset value into the master fund, the remainder can be held in cash or invested in derivatives for hedging purposes. The feeder and the master can be located in the same or different member states, although agreements must be in place to ensure information is shared appropriately between different depositories and auditors.
10
Directive
Directives approved Harmonisation across the EU
UCITS
1985
UCITS II
UCITS III
2001
UCITS IV
2009
(max 5%) 10% EU member states failed to reach agreement on UCITS II proposals
*
Other provisions
Streamlined notification procedure Simplified Prospectus Capital and qualification requirements Supervision of management companies Comprehensive risk management processes Cross-border fund mergers Master/Feeder structure/Asset pooling Management Company Passport
* Efficient portfolio management (EPM) only Key Investor Information Document
11
Conclusion
Since its implementation, UCITS has become more than just another EU regulatory requirement for companies. In many respects it has evolved into a brand, a way of showing to potential investors throughout Europe that the product they have selected is fully regulated and offers them greater investment choice and transparency.
The fund management industry underwent a rigorous restructuring in order to be able to fully use the powers available through UCITS, but the events of the last few years have demonstrated that a successful application of the new powers has been far more challenging than many anticipated. Being a good long-only manager is not enough to successfully manage a long/short product. The skill set needed to be able to make money from shorting stocks is markedly different and takes time to learn. It is very difficult to overemphasise this point and should be remembered when looking at the new absolute return fund offerings from long-only managers.
12
Glossary of terms
Absolute return Absolute return is a measurement of the return of an asset over a period of time. Absolute return differs from relative return because it does not compare the fund with a benchmark. Absolute return funds look to make positive returns in all market conditions. An absolute return fund therefore generates returns with a degree of independence from movements within financial markets. Alpha is the standard measure for assessing the performance of active fund managers. It is the return in excess of a benchmark index, or risk free investment, and it enables clients to work out if the level of return they receive more than makes up for the additional risk they choose to take on, i.e. risk adjusted return. Asset allocation aims to divide an investment portfolio among different categories of assets, such as equities, bonds, property and cash, by different countries or regions, or different sectors. How much you choose to invest in each can have a significant influence on performance of the portfolio. A benchmark enables investors to compare the performance of the fund against a relevant index. For example, a UK invested fund might have the FTSE All-Share Index as a benchmark and a stated objective to outperform the index over a certain period. A measure of volatility that determines the risk of a security in relation to the wider market. A beta of 1.0 indicates that a fund carries the same level of risk as the market, and should therefore provide the same level of return. However a fund with a beta of 1.2 would in theory be 20% more volatile than the market, and should therefore offer investors the prospect of greater returns for the additional risk. A CDS is an agreement designed to switch investment exposure between two parties. The buyer pays a periodic fee for protection against a specific event (such as the default of an investment grade bond). A CDS is often used like an insurance policy, but there is no requirement to actually hold any asset, which makes it a derivative. A derivative is a financial instrument derived from another asset. Rather than buying or selling the asset itself, two parties enter into an agreement to exchange money, assets or some other value at a future date. Derivatives are used to increase or decrease exposure or reduce or increase levels of risk within a portfolio and are more cost-effective than purchasing the underlying assets themselves. The aim of diversification within an investment portfolio is to reduce your overall levels of risk. By choosing asset classes that behave in different ways you do not over-rely on one particular asset for returns. A portfolio of different kinds of investments, and in various geographical locations, will, on average, yield higher returns and pose a lower risk than any individual investment found within the portfolio.
Alpha
Asset allocation
Benchmark
Beta
Derivatives
Diversification
13
Duration
An indication of how sensitive a bonds price is to changes in interest rates. It takes into account all the cashflows received over the life of the bond (i.e. coupons and nominal value). The higher a bonds duration, the more sensitive (or volatile) its price will be to a change in interest rates. If interest rates were expected to fall, investors would normally benefit most from rising bond prices if they lengthened duration. If rates were to rise, they could limit the negative impact of declining prices by shortening duration. A fund management strategy that involves buying certain stocks long and selling others short, by borrowing stock from a third party at an agreed fee and selling it, and then buying the stock back later, at a lower price, or by selling short a derivative on a stock.
Long/Short fund
Exchange Traded funds (ETFs) Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) are collective investment funds that aim to replicate the growth of an index by investing in the same basket of shares as an index or series of indices and is itself traded on an exchange (for example, members of the FTSE All-Share). Fund of funds Fund of funds (also referred to as multi-manager funds or manager-of-manager funds) are designed to increase diversification by investing in a variety of funds, including those managed by other investment managers. They provide a simple and cost-effective solution for investors looking for portfolio diversity by investing in a wide range of good quality funds. A UCITS III fund can be created as a fund of funds, but UCITS III funds are not permitted to invest in a fund of funds. Hedge fund A fund that uses an assortment of trading techniques and instruments to meet its objective. The aim is to provide positive investment returns irrespective of the performance of stock markets. A hedge fund can take short positions, employ derivatives, use leverage and has relatively few investment restrictions. A strategy used to offset investment risk, especially useful during periods of market uncertainty. A fund created to provide the same returns as a designated index. Therefore the fund invests in all the companies within the index according to a market value weighting. Leverage is essentially borrowing money to increase levels of exposure. It allows a manager to increase the amount invested in the fund to more than 100% of the total fund net asset value. A fund where investments are purchased and returns are derived from the performance of those holdings. This is in contrast to a long/short fund, where performance can also be generated from short positions, including stocks that the fund does not own.
Hedging
Index funds
Leverage
Long-Only fund
14
A market neutral fund strategy will result in an investment portfolio that does not display a correlation with the designated market. Therefore during a period of market weakness, the portfolio should theoretically be able to continue to generate positive returns. Investing in the stock market enables you to benefit from its growth potential over the medium to long-term. However, there is also a risk (market risk, also known as systemic risk) that you could lose your money if the stock market in which you have invested in experiences a fall in value. The securities market dealing in short-term debt and monetary instruments. Money market instruments are forms of debt that mature in less than one year and are very liquid. A mathematical computer simulation that generates random scenarios so that infinite potential outcomes of an investment strategy are played out and are therefore known or visible. See fund of funds. Fund managers can apply a multi-strategy investment approach in order to allocate investment capital to a variety of different investment strategies and asset classes. This increases the diversity of the fund and can also be used to potentially reduce risk. A non-sophisticated UCITS III employs a traditional long-only fund structure restricted to the purchase and sale of physical assets such as equities and bonds and can use derivatives only for efficient portfolio management. An open-ended fund in the form of a company that continually creates and issues shares or units on demand as opposed to a closed-ended company whose price is affected by demand in addition to underlying assets growth. An investment that pools many investors into a single vehicle, offering access to a well-diversified portfolio of equities, bonds or other securities. New shares can be issued and redeemed when required. Fund managers can use portfolio symmetry in order to reduce risk and generate additional returns. The manager takes a short position in an asset class, while simultaneously adding a long position ensuring that the portfolio has symmetrical long/short exposure. An arbitrage strategy which aims to exploit an identified price inefficiency, for example the same stock listed on two exchanges where demand in one exchange pushes the price higher, and making the price on the other exchange relatively cheap.
15
Market risk
Money markets
Pooled investment
Portfolio symmetry
Relative value
Risk framework
The risk management mechanism that a fund manager uses to monitor risk within portfolios. This will include the use of stress testing and regularly calculating Value at Risk (VaR). A short seller looks to profit from companies whose shares could fall in value by borrowing stock with the intention of buying the stock back at a later date, at a lower price, or by taking a short position using a derivative. Where a short position is initiated through physical stock and therefore stock lending the stock is returned to the lender at the agreed date, and the short seller makes a profit from the difference between the two prices, minus an agreed fee. A sophisticated fund uses advanced investment techniques including derivative instruments and trading strategies in order to achieve its stated objectives. Stress testing of portfolios is designed to determine how a fund will react to different financial situations, and is a useful method to calculate how a fund could potentially react during a financial crisis. The Monte Carlo simulation is one of the most widelyused stress-testing methods. The total return of an investment includes the income and capital appreciation of an asset, including interest, capital gains, dividends and distributions received over a given time period. The phrase over-the-counter (OTC) refers to financial instruments, such as derivatives, that are traded between two parties without the use of a central exchange. A fund with unconstrained asset allocation has the freedom to invest in a variety of asset classes, regions or size of company. A well-diversified portfolio of investments should derive returns from a variety of uncorrelated asset classes, so that performance remains consistent despite market downturns or volatility. VAR is a way of measuring the potential maximum loss of a fund over a specific time period or in a worst case scenario. A way to measure the tendency of a funds value to vary over time. Volatility tends to be measured by the variance or standard deviation of the price and is said to be high if the price typically changes dramatically in a short period of time.
Shorting
Stress test
Total return
Volatility
16
This document is intended solely for the use of professionals, defined as Eligible Counterparties or Professional Clients, and is not for general public distribution. Past performance is not a guide to future performance. The value of an investment and the income from it can fall as well as rise and you may not get back the amount originally invested. Tax assumptions and reliefs depend upon an investors particular circumstances and may change if those circumstances or the law change. If you invest through a third party provider you are advised to consult them directly as charges, performance and terms and conditions may differ materially. Nothing in this document is intended to or should be construed as advice. This document is not a recommendation to sell or purchase any investment. It does not form part of any contract for the sale or purchase of any investment. Any investment application will be made solely on the basis of the information contained in the Prospectus (including all relevant covering documents), which will contain investment restrictions. This document is intended as a summary only and potential investors must read the Prospectus before investing. Issued in the UK by Henderson Global Investors. Henderson Global Investors is the name under which Henderson Global Investors Limited (reg. no. 906355), Henderson Fund Management plc (reg. no. 2607112), Henderson Investment Funds Limited (reg. no. 2678531), Henderson Investment Management Limited (reg. no. 1795354), Henderson Alternative Investment Advisor Limited (reg. no. 962757), Henderson Equity Partners Limited (reg. no. 2606646) (each incorporated and registered in England and Wales with registered office at 201 Bishopsgate, London EC2M 3AE and authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority) provide investment products and services. Telephone calls may be recorded and monitored. HGI36632/0810