Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kimball - Proof of Consumption Technology Neutrality
Kimball - Proof of Consumption Technology Neutrality
feu[Qag`hjxX]._oeE[].^`iht}p.u_b[/t}np.iT~EiT[g`ijx`p.eXcXg/f-]wa_o[=].iTp.hae}]r^`i_b[~uiGa]rhjiG[E]yEeec
t}p.i,].^`iya.t}hjituas?ieup.iu
[`eu]r^`iGpmltqj].eja].t}]ri]r^/i_b[8]rg`_o]r_beu[_|a]r^/t}]k_t]riGfw^/[`eunbeuEq)a^`eXfwvt}?iFf-]waeu[`nbq
feu[Qag`hjxX]._oeE[`].^`iyiFfeu[/euhq!fTt}[_bhjhiFcX_|tN]riGnoq{g`hjx:].ej]r^`iy[/iTla].iGtEcXq!a].t}]riuq
feu[Qa].p.tEa]FtN].iTpt].iGfw^`[/eunbeuuqa^/efwvtNCiGf-]._o[/:]r^`i_o[~uiFa].hjiT[8]yueeXc`ayariGf]reupF].^`i
iGfeE[`euh{q!h{g/a]tEfTfg/hg`n|tN].ifTtux`_]wt}n eN~uiGp,tnbeu[`!xQiGpr_beXc]reuiT]d].e)]r^/i{[`iGla].iGtEcXq
a]wtN]riEeka^/eNlV].^/tN]].^`_|a_|aP]r^/iht}_b[]r^`_b[`ktN]l(eEprvC].^`_b[`v,eu`tmaht}nbnueExQiG[iGfTeu[`eEhq
_o[jtl(eEprn|cyeuQx?iTpriGf-].noqheEs`_bnoimfTtux`_o].t}n4,[{eXfTfGtuar_oeE[ysqyhjiGtu[/a*e}CcXp.tuhtN]r_|ffTt}x/_]wt}n
_ohjx?eupr].a*eupiTXxQeEp]waT].^`ikahtunonXeExQiG[{iFfeu[/euhq{feug/nbc{_ohjhjiGc`_bt}]riTnbqmg`hjx]re].^`i[`iTl
a].iGtuc`qa].t}]rid_b[)p.iGarxQeE[/arim]ret}[q{v_b[/ceuP]riGfw^/[`eunbeuEq{ar^`eXfwv?)Z\[tyfnbeEariGc)iGfeE[`euh{qu
t}[q!ar^`eXfwv]r^QtN]d^/tEa]r^/iyxQeNliTp].e)fw^/t}[/ui]r^/iya].iGtuc`q!a].tN].iyfTtux`_]wt}na]reXfwv!_o[~ueEno~EiGa
t}[VtEcg/a]rhjiT[8],x/preXfiFaradlm_].^Vht}[qiCiGf].aG~uiT[].^`iy].iThjx?eupwt}p.q!~EiTpwa_beu[:euag/fw^
tar^`eXfwv)h{g/a]k^Qt~uihjtu[q)iCiGf].aG
m d*/X,d,\`\(\ud*`*E
eu[/ar_bc`iTp]r^/ieunbnoeNlm_b[`jaeXf_|t}nPx/nbtu[`[`iTpF ax`preEs`nbiTh
wrw /
htN P no[6 j
w
.
d wjw
arg`sXiGf]m]re
w j.
wj
6
_|adfeE[/arg`hjxX]r_beu[e}*[`eE[/cXg`pwt}s`nbiGadt}[/cariTp.~8_|fiFameupkareuhjiyfTeuhjxQeE[`iT[8]m].^`iTp.iTeu
_bad]r^`ia]rp._|f-]rnbqxQe8a_o]r_b~uimh{g`n]._ox/no_|fTt}]r_b~uinoiG~uiTn e}].^`ijfeu[Qag`hjxX]._oeE[jue eXc`adx`preXcXgQf-
_o[`]riFfw^`[`eEnoeEuqu _|ajt}nbn]r^`i_o[`eup.hj t}]r_beu[t~tu_on|t}s/noitN]]r_bhi
- _|ajtV~EiGf-].eup
e}e}].^`iTpfeu[8].preEn~Nt}p._btus`noiFays?iGar_|cXiGa ?arg/fw^tEam]r^/i{t}Eup.iT8tN ]ri8g/t}[8]._]qe}n|t}s?eup
t}[/c].^`i{tuheEg`[8].ad e}~Nt}p._oeEg/atuf]reEp.amgQaiFc:_o[:iFtufw^ariGf]reupFm _ba,t~uiFf-]reEpke}a].t}]ri
~tupr_|t}s/noiFaT ag/fw^tEa]r^`i!a].efwvXaeu~Ntupr_beug/a]q8x?iGaye}kfTtux`_]wt}nd_o[Qfnbg/cX_b[`VariGf-].euparx?i
f
_ QffGt}x`_o].tun|].^`ia]reXfwvXayeu~Ntupr_beug/ay]qxQiFaye}kfTeu[/arg`hjiTpcXg`pwt}s`nbiG aG tu[/c~Nt}p._|t}s`nbiGa
cXiTx?iT[/c`_o[`eu[)]r^`i,x/tua]^/_ba]reEprqe}P].^`i,eu]r^`iGpfTeu[8]rp.eunQ~Nt}p._btus`noiF a_b[ _b[/fnbg/cX_b[`y].^`i
x/tua]^`_|a].eup.qeumnbtusQeEpGtua_o[qX cXn|t}[Qct}[/cpriFarfTe}]r]6-= _ba{t:~uiFf-].eupyeuke}]r^/iTp
iXeuEiT[`eEg/a~Nt}p._btus`noiFas?iGar_bc`iGa -Qarg/fw^:tuam]r_bhi
-`]riFfw^`[`eEnoeEuqar^`eXfwvXa_o[].^`ix`p.e}
cXg/f-]._oeE[e}_b[~uiFa].hiG[8]Eeec/atu[/cfeu[Qag`hjiGpkcXg`pwt}s`nbiGaG8]r^`inbiT~EiTnt}[Qc!fTeuhjxQe8a_o]r_beu[
e}*ueN~uiGpr[/hiG[8](x`g`pwfw^/tEaiFaTTF
"!$#&%'!$(*))!""+,"-*./!102./3&1 (41"-*5!$67 8/820239:3;6<%&=
>
feug/[E]._o[/y]r^QtN](htqj^/t~Eidt}[)iTXeuuiG[`eugQaa]reX fw^/tua]r_|fmiGnoiGhiG[8]G^`i,g`[/f-]._oeE[E_o~EiGa
]r^`i(x/t}pr]eu`gX]r_bno_o]q]r^/t}] cXeiFa[`eu]_b[~ueunb~ui Z\[fTtu[cXiTx?iT[Qceu[fTeu[/arg`hjiTp cXg`pwt}s`nbiGaG
a]wtN]ri~Ntupr_|t}s`nbiGa,].^/tN]cXiGxQiG[/c=eu[x/tEa]yn|t}s?eupyarg`x`x`nbdqu*\Fb^`ijg`[/f]r_beuC[ _ba].^`i
feu[Qag`hjxX]._oeE[Ee8eXc`a(x`p.eXcXg/f_b[`]riGfw^/[`eunbeuEq{lm^`iG[
*Z]mcXiGa.fp._os?iGa]r^/iarg`s/a]r_o
]rgX]._oeE[x?eEa.ar_os`_bnb_]._oiFa_o[x`p.eXcXg/f_b[`feE[/arg`hjxX]r_beu[ueeXc`aG*^/ig`[/f-]._oeED[ cXiFarfTpr_bs?iGa
fTt}x/_]wt}nXtufGfg`h{g`nbt}]r_beu[ ^`i(eup.hg`n|tN]._oeE[y_ba EiT[`iGp.tunEiG[`eug`E^y].etunonbeNl=eup*_b[8~EiGa]rhjiT[8]
tuc g/a]rhjiG[E ]kfTeEa].a(eup]r_bhji4]re}s`g`_bn|cP^`iaiT] cXiTnb_o[/iGtN].iGat}[qp.iGa]rp._bf]r_beu[/a(eu[
t}[Qc ^`i~EiGf-].eup u_b~uiFa].^`i_b[`_]._btun~Nt}nbg`iGaeu*tunonC].^`iya].tN].i~Nt}p._btus`noiFaT
E9F*GIHJGLK4MN4M"GIOQPIRZ
w w
j STu w r
>
U T
" VE
t}[/c]r^`i_bhjx`no_biGciG~ueunbgX]._oeE[e}Q]r^`ikfGt}x`_o].tunXa].efwv~EiGf ]reup aeEno~EiGa]r^`ihtNX_bhj_oFtN]r_beu[
x`preEs`nbiTh
wrw
htN P no[6 j
w
W8
.
arg`sXiGf]m]re
$ Xu
6 wjw
wj
6
Y
?
P 4 T nb[ S TumT j6{T UuTEmT
P* 4 T nb[S T 6 T rj T U T 6 T \. r
w
4 nb[
Q
km S T U T P nb[
?
.
v km S U) P 4 Xno[
w w
w
4 nb[
Q
zP 4 T nb[ S6 r U:6
r
pS U)
c
ht}
" E
r
d wjw
arg`sXiGf]m]re
w j.
wj
6
p"ST UuTF
^`i,hje8a]uiT[/iTpwt}n?priFag`no]eup(]r^`_|afTtuarid_|a(]r^/t}]GXiTXfTiTxX]eup(]r^/ip.iGa.fTtuno_b[`yeufeE[X
a g`hjxX]._oeE[E]r^`i,euxXk]._oht}nQxQeEno_|f_biGa(t}p.i]r^`iartuhjieup].^`ikx`p.eus/noiGhytu[/c]r^/imeunbnoeNlm_b[`
x`preEs`nbiThXlm^`iTp.i ^/tEa[`eiCiGf-]meE[].^`ix`preXcXgQf-]r_beu[!g`[/f]r_beu[s`gX]miT[8].iTpwa(_b[:tuat}[
t}p.ug`hjiT[8]me}*thg`no]r_bx`nb_bfGtN]r_b~uix/priTiTp.iT[/fTiar^`eXfwvC
d
r Q
d
htN P I I 4 r I j6
" E
.
arg`sXiGf]m]re
6
wj
6
Y
:eup.ideEprhtunonbqu
E9F*GIHJGLK4MN4M"GIOiRZ
w w
;
j S T w r
UuTE
E
t}[/c]r^`i_bhjx`no_biGciG~ueunbgX]._oeE[e}Q]r^`ikfGt}x`_o].tunXa].efwv~EiGf ]reup aeEno~EiGa]r^`ihtNX_bhj_oFtN]r_beu[
x`preEs`nbiTh/]r^`iG[
STu
* >
U T 6
VE
t}[/c].^`i{a.t}hjiyiG~ueunbgX]._oeE[eu*]r^`ifTt}x/_]wt}na]reXfwv!~uiGf ]reEpd aeEno~EiGa].^`ihtNX_bhj_oFtN]r_beu[
x`preEs`nbiTh/
c km" S T U T
v c km" S U)
.
w w /
c zPg kc I 4 S \ c U
w
pS U)
-eu[/noq].^`ip.t}]r_beVeud]r^/inbiT~EiTnmeu,feE[/ag/hx`]r_beu[]riGfw^/[`eunbeuEq_b[]r^`igX].g`pri].e].^`i
feu[Qag`hjxX]._oeE[j]riFfw^`[`eunbeuEq^/tEatu[8q{iCiGf](e}].^`iTp]r^/tu[priFarfGt}nb_o[/yfeu[Qag`hjxX]._oeE[ f_o[Qfi
t].iGfw^`[`eEnoeEuq=a^/efwv_|ajcX&i Q[`iGctuajtfw^Qt}[`Ei_b[]r^/inbeuu4nbiT~EiTn(e}k].iGfw^`[`eEnoeEuqE*]r^`_|a
fTt}[=s?ipriFa]wtN].iGc=tuaeE[`noqx`p.iGcX_|f-].iGcgX]rg/pri)fTeu[/arg`hjxX]r_beu[].iGfw^`[`eEnoeEuqVar^`eXfwvXa^/t~ui
t}[q)iCiGf]ke}].^`iTpm].^/t}[p.iGa.fTtuno_b[`jfeu[Qag`hjxX]._oeE[(y/-6`]r^`ifTg`p.priG[E]kfTeu[/arg`hjxX]r_beu[
]riGfw^/[`eunbeuEq=ar^`eXfwv=^/tuaeE[`noq].^`ipriFarfGt}nb_o[`ViCiGf-]Fx`nbg/ajt}[qx`g/priGnoq=_b[Xeup.htN]r_beu[Qt}n
preEnoi_o]kx`nbtqXaG
Z\[ eupwcXiTp]res?i]r]riGpg/[/cXiTpwa].t}[Qc]r^`iiCiGf]euyiXxQiFf-].iGcgX].g`p.ifTeu[/arg`hjxX]r_beu[
]riGfw^/[`eunbeuEqar^`eXfwvXaTPfeE[/kar_bcXiGpk].^`iiGnonbht}[ViF8g/tN]._oeE[:eup,]r^`ijfeEhjx/t}p._bareu[:x/preEs`noiGh
_o[lm^`_|fw^].^`iiCiGf-]wa*e} nbeeuvnb_ovEi(].^`iiCiGf].a*e}?hg`no]r_bx`nb_bfGtN]._o~Ei(x`p.iiGpriG[/fiar^`eXfwvaG
^`iyiTnbnoht}[iG8g/t}]r_beu[_ba
]
) I htNx 7 c j6
d c )"
w
W8
F
-rw j
c
I)"
j
.