The most complex challenge for today's CIOs is to increase the information technology (IT) organization's ability to rapidly respond to new business needs while continuing to cut costs.
Reducing fixed/non-discretionary spending is key to increasing IT agility; and an often overlooked tactic is optimizing the IT hardware refresh cycle.
A company's IT hardware refresh policy drives decisions on millions of dollars in annual capital spending and operating expense. Introduction 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 An effective refresh policy will guide IT and accounting personnel through the analyses needed to balance the trade- offs between capital spending, operating efficiency, and risk mitigation.
A systematic approach to optimizing an IT hardware refresh policy unhooking technology decisions from accounting's useful life calendar - in a way that drives savings in capital, labour, and operating costs. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Introduction Technology refresh refers to the adoption of newer technology to meet changing needs or to mitigate the risk of obsolescence of existing technology.
As Information Technology changes from a backend support entity to a strategic enabler, the role of technology refresh becomes more important. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Technology Refresh Management In recent years, technology refresh has seen an expansion of its scope, going beyond just IT assets to all kinds of items that may form part of the IT landscape.
Aging/obsolete technology Out-of-suport technology Skill set shortage Compliance Cost reduction Standardization Innovation Vendor stability 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Drivers Aging/obsolete technology
Organizations worldwide are stuck with aging technologies and find themselves in a very difficult situation. Many of them dont have a proactive approach to regular technology assessment; its always taken granted that as long as the existing technology is meeting its stated purpose its good to go. Over time, these legacy technologies get heavily customized to meet the user demands. Each change makes it more complex and rigid for future migration to a newer technology. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Drivers Out-of-support technology
As organizations continue to use dated technology, they often land in situations where they are stuck with out-of- support technology components. This happens due to the product vendor upgrading its technology stack and subsequently not supporting the older versions in an effort to migrate all their customers to their supported stack. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Drivers Skill set shortage
As technology advancements keep happening, the focus keeps shifting to the newer breed of technologies. Even the academia focuses on the newer technologies than the legacy technologies. This slowly causes a skill set shortage as the people who know the legacy technology become lesser in number and getting skilled resources becomes an issue. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Drivers Compliance
Regulatory compliance is mandatory for all organizations. With physical boundaries diminishing and access to information becoming easy, the chances of security breaches are also increasing. This forces organizations to develop controls and procedures which will prevent any security leak and will ensure all the established controls are in place to fulfil compliance. As the technology component enters into a phase of obsolescence and the existing vendors stop supporting it, these components become vulnerable to compliance requirements. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Drivers Cost Reduction
Organizations think technology refresh decisions are high investment items. On the contrary technology refresh helps in reducing the operational spend and enhances the organization capability, which in turn helps to lower the unit cost of IT. With the passage of time, legacy technology becomes expensive on account of its maintenance cost. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Drivers Standardization
In todays business environment, mergers, acquisitions and consolidation have become the mantra for growth. M&As often bring together diverse technology components and the new organization has to manage them and plan their future roadmap. Organizations start considering standardization of diverse technology components into strategic ones and look at technology refresh as a way to achieve their standardization goals. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Drivers Innovation
To improve their competitive positions, organizations scan the technology environment constantly to evaluate the latest trends and developments in the market. As they find newer technologies which can provide better competitive advantage, they start considering technology refresh as a strategy to migrate to newer technologies. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Drivers Vendor Stability
Vendor stability is one of the key factors which drive technology refresh considerations. Organizations always want to use products from vendors who have good market standing and are stable. If the vendor stability becomes an issue then it affects their ability to invest and grow the products that they have which in turn creates issues with competitiveness. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Drivers Today technology refresh is managed in a reactive manner.
Organizations treat these investments as capital expenditure and, based on their performance, earmark a certain percentage of their IT budget for their technology refresh initiative. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 How do Companies Handle it Today As the diagram illustrates, in most enterprises, the time for technology refresh is rather long because of the processes involved, and in a dynamic marketplace, such a system is unlikely to deliver desired results. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 How do Companies Handle it Today Most of organizations are familiar with the need for technology refresh, but they are hesitant to grapple with the issue at hand. 5D approach for managing the technology refresh at enterprise level: 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Approach for Managing Technology Refresh 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Suggested Model Technology awareness The awareness level within the organization on different technologies and innovations happening within the market place plays a critical role towards building a technology strategy. Technology intelligence This involves constant evaluation of the technology trends, market trends, product plans, budget constraints, supplier roadmap etc. The technology awareness feeds into the technology intelligence by means of alerts and reports. Health check This involves scanning the AS-IS technology landscape of the enterprise and using a structured scorecard to assess the health of each of the technology components or a group of technology components. Technology strategy The technology strategy is set at the enterprise level and it uses the various inputs coming from the previous steps. This should be a core component of the overall IT strategy and architecture-guiding principles 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Determine New license costs: The cost of new licenses will drive up the total cost of acquisition (TCA), as during the migration from one platform to another; new licenses will normally need to be purchased. Ongoing maintenance and support costs: Maintenance and support costs range from 18% to 22% of the license fees for commercial software and are fixed-cost (subscription support) for open-source technologies. The initial costs can be low when calculated as a percentage of a discounted license base, escalating after the initial contract period. Support and maintenance costs are among the largest ongoing software costs, so constitute one of the largest savings when migrating off a platform. It is precisely these savings that are offset to the initial migration costs, causing the ROI to require up to five years or more to recover. Consolidation while migrating: If the organization can consolidate the technology stack while migrating, the cost savings can certainly be greater. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Cost Benefit Analysis (Determine)
Analyze the drivers The drivers for technology refresh as applicable to the organization context should be analyzed. This helps to bring out the key issues and the risks that the organization may be carrying from the technology obsolescence perspective. Identify technology refresh candidates Based on the enterprise technology strategy, health check outcome of the as-is technology landscape and the identified drivers, organization has to determine the potential candidates that will be candidates for the technology refresh across the enterprise. This can be a multiyear view. Evaluate refresh options Once the refresh candidates are narrowed down and the associated risks get identified, then the different options should be evaluated. The option evaluation should be done in conjunction with the time horizon, risks and available alternatives Build a refresh strategy Refresh strategy should clearly articulate how the technology refresh is going to work, broad solution options, roadmap, risks involved and mitigation, approach of implementation etc. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Design
Refresh Planning Once the overall technology refresh strategy is built, the next step is to start the planning for its implementation. This has to be done considering all the other initiatives that may be happening within the enterprise. Detailed Solution Design Solution design involves working out the detailed solution and the necessary changes that need to be carried out across the different technology stacks. Test Planning With diminishing knowledge on the legacy footprint and obsolete technologies its essential for the organization to have a good testing strategy and plan in place. Proof of Concept (PoC) The pilot exercise helps in identifying the issues, validating the workability of the solution. This will also enable the incorporation of changes that need to be done to the overall strategy before deploying the technology refresh program across the enterprise. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Develop Execution Here the execution of the technology refresh is done as per the designed solution and refresh plan that has been built. Organizational resources are channelized to work on the execution. Testing Once the changes are done testing is performed as per the test plan to make sure everything is working fine. There could be multiple rounds of testing to verify not just the components being changed but also to make sure the dependent existing components too work as expected. Training Technology refresh involves change and to make it widely accepted and usable proper training should be planned and provided to the different stakeholders. Many a times organization might have deployed the best of the breed technology but people dont know how to use it and leverage it to their advantage. Training plays a critical role in success of the technology refresh program. Rollout Rollout is the actual deployment of the new technology components in production or actual usage by the end users of the technology components. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Deploy
Stabilize Once the technology refresh rollouts are happening the organization should also keep its focus on stabilizing the refreshed technology components. Decommission Most of the time, organizations tend to lose focus on the decommissioning aspects. Once the upgraded or new technology components are rolled out, the old technology components should get decommissioned in a phased manner. This is critical for the organization; the presence of the old components will delay the benefit realization. Benefit Measurement During technology refresh ROI analysis, the benefits are projected and these should get measured on an ongoing basis after the implementation. Benefit realization is a key element from the prospective of finding the actual benefits coming from the refresh program. Feedback Technology refresh is not a one-off activity. Rather its a cyclical process and the organization should constantly capture the feedback and feed it into the technology strategy and solution design so that new learnings are captured and used for improvements. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Deliver
Overall benefits gained from a technology refresh program include:
Agile IT Infrastructure Supported technology components No risk to compliance Improves time to market capability Improves scalability and maintainability Reduction in OPEX for the IT Helps in standardization Helps in improving the overall IT capability 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Recommendations and Suggestions Listed bellow are some suggestions to avoid the technology obsolescence trap:
Put IT strategic planning at the heart of the CIO management agenda Develop a technology strategy Do a health check of the AS-IS landscape Fund Technology refresh program Focus on retiring older systems
2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Recommendations and Suggestions CIOs are being challenged to increase the business value of their company's existing investment in IT. Optimizing their IT hardware refresh policy - replacing accounting's useful life calendar with a more accurate set of useful technical lives - is a powerful but often-overlooked way to impact a significant portion of IT's capital and operating expense budgets.
With a rush of technology investment decisions on the horizon - broad implementation of server and storage virtualization, PC upgrades to handle the next-generation of Windows - CIOs that analyze their current infrastructure landscape and develop a hardware refresh roadmap provide their IT organizations with a framework to make decisions that drive the maximum business return out of tighter and tighter IT budgets. 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 Recommendations and Suggestions References 1. IBM i 7.1 Technical Overview with Technology Refresh Updates; March 2013 2. Optimizing Technology Refresh - Closed loop Lifecycle Planning by Bruce Michelson 3. Shaping the future of end user services by Ian Bradbury 4. Optimizing Technology Refresh Practices - http://www.archstoneconsulting.com/services/itstrategy- opeations/white-papers/optimizing-it-technology.jsp 5. Realizing value of Innovation - TCS Journal 6. TCS Case Study Bank 7. HP Case Study Bank 2 nd Year PT MBA Term Project Presentation SML 701 References THANK YOU Group 14 Term Project Presentation SML 702