LivingWithCoyotes

PanelistName: GroupName:
PBL Rubric for
Expert Panelists

1 2 3 4
Statement of the
Problem
No problem
stated
Unclear/confusing or
incomplete
Clear and accurate Conveyed in a
"catchy," unique way
Understanding
the problem
No evidence Unclear/confusing statement
of the problem
Explains problem clearly Explains problem
using more than one
points of view
Content-specific
vocabulary
No content
vocabulary
used
Misused or mispronounced
content area vocabulary
Uses content area vocabulary
accurately
Uses a wide range of
vocabulary, naturally
and fluently
Evidence of
research
Does not
mention
Limited evidence of research Multiple resources named Multiple resources
including expert
speakers and field
experiences noted
Solution to the
problem
No solution
offered
Unreasonable/implausible
recommendation
Viable solution fully explained
with minor modifications
needed
Viable solution with
no modification
needed
Compliments:


Areas for improvement: