You are on page 1of 1

Clarence Newton Reynolds, Jr.

(1890-1954) Head of WVU Mathematics Departmenrt, 1938-1946. He


was at first a student of Maxime Bocher at Harvard. After Bocher's death,
Reynolds took his Ph.D. under G. D. Birkhoff, and spent the rest of his
life at WVU trying to prove the Four Color Conjecture. In two papers in the
Annals of Mathematics in 1926-1927 Reynolds was able to use clsassical
reduction techniques to prove that four colors suffice for all maps having
no more than 28 countries. This was one of the best results until 1976
when Kenneth Appell, Wolfgang Haken and graduate student John Koch
used computers and new techniques to prove the theorem that 4 colors always
suffice. Reynolds had joyously told a friend of mine (retired Professor Wilbur
Bluhm) who had been a student at WVU circa 1946, that he had proved the
4CC, but it is said that Philip Franklin found an error in the proof. I have not
been able to find the manuscript in his posthumous papers, so it remains
unknown whether he was onto something. He did leave a large table of
'topologically applicable number-theoretic functions', but no evidence how
this might have been applied. He gave a talk about this at the 1950
International Congress of Mathematicians at Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Reynolds patented a 'Relativity Slide Rule' in the 1910 to 1920 period that
shows how Einstein's addition of velocities operates. I have his large,
working classroom model, a wooden device about six feet long. He
published a paper about this in the old Bulletin of the West Virginia University
Scientific Association, Vol. 2(1923), pp. 3-11, showing how to construct and
operate it. A photo of this device is displayed here:

Here is the four foot long wooden working model of the


Relativity
Slide Rule invented by Professor C. N. Reynolds.
Remark: I shall never forget my own excitement when Frank Bernhart
told me in 1976 about the amazing new and correct proof of the 4CC! This
event was a highlight of our conversation at the AMS Summer Meeting at
Toronto, Canada in August 1976. But wouldn't it be comforting to find an
old-fashioned proof we could check easily?

You might also like