2012

2012

 :
:
:

, , , , , ,
, .
.

:
; 02-5300800 ,1-800-20-2222 :02-5300867 :
orders@idi.org.il :
www.idi.org.il :
, ,4482 9104401

() ,"
)Copyright 2012 by The Israel Democracy Institute (R. A.

. :

. : /

17

. , :

39

44

48

. ,
.
.

. ,
,
.
. " "
, , , , .

.
, , ,
.
, .
.
.
. ,
*.

" ".
.2012
, ,
( ) .

" " .
* , ( ' ( )12 ),
" ,2011-' .64

. ,
"" ,
.
,
, .
, , ,

, " " ;
;
( );

.

,
" "


. ,
: ;
; .

" "
( ,2012 ,
).
2011 (open government
)partnership 1.
, ,
, .
2
1

. . () ,
, , , 73
, : , , , , .
. , ,

,

([ www.economist.com/node/21531430 .)]2012
)1( :
; ( )2
; ( )3
; ( )4
( ,

.

)1( : ; ( )2
.

.


.
, ,

. ""

.

, .

, ,91 :
,2012 ,' .)24

. :
" , .

]...[ .

3
".
" " , ,e-government
(Information and Communication
)Technologies ICT
.
ICT : ,
4
.
" " "
" ( )2012
5, :
, ;
;
( );
. ,

6
.
3
4
5
6

( ,)2' .17 ,13

, , , ,
.2006 ,
( )2'
.24-16
""

" " /
( : , ,).

 10

,

( ,
) .
" " ( )
2011 .
,:
;
;
. ,
. 2011

, , ,
. , ,

.
,
, .

,
,
(
) 7. ,
; ()
8
; .


7

1 ,2012

22 .2011
( .)2

11

.
. ,
,

.

"-"
()
( ,)data ( )information ( ,)knowledge (,)wisdom
9.
, .
( )
: ,
,
.
10
, :

1 0

- (Government to Individual Delivering

:)Services G2IS

.
- (Government to Individual as
:)Part of the Political Process G2IP
, .

( , ) ;
,

, ( ,)2000 ( .)4

 12

- ( Government to Business as a Citizen

:)G2BC
.
- (Government to Business in the
:)Marketplace G2BMKT
( )
,
.

- ( :)Government to Employees G2E

.
- ( :)Government to Government G2G
(
, ,
).

,
:
,
, ,
,
. )1( :
:
; ( )2 :
, , , ,
; ( )3 :
(
) (
, ,

13

) 11.
( ) .
,
.

, .
.
12.
" " " "
, .
13
' ,
(
/)

.
" ," .
, .
: ,
,
.
" ," .

.
.
" : " ,
, ,
.

11
12
13

( ,)2' .129
' " , :
" , (.710-665 :)2011
.

 14

" "

.
.1997
( ) .
," :
;
( );
( )" ( ) . 1997
. 2002
14,
.

" "
.
( gov.net
).
.
,
( ").
.

( " , :
1 4

, , ,2002' " .5 "

(
)
. ,
;
; ;
.data.gov

15

;
" " ;
, ).
.
( ; ;
; ,).
.
.
( ").
:

15

, ,
( .
.)gov.il
( ,
, ,
) . ,
.
" " .
, .
2011
, , pdf
. " " (
) ,
.
.
, ,
( .)2009 , ,

15

 16

, ,
.
, , ,
.
( )
, ,
"".

, , , ,

.
, " "
.
.

17

. : /

, .
,
. ,
, ( ,
16
).

:
, , , .
,
.
(' )1
"
' '
" . " "

.
( "" ""
17
).

, ( )
(
) . ,
,
1 6
17

' 117 ,23.1.2012 ,' .6

James Surowiecki, The Wisdom of Crowds, New York: Doubleday, 2004

 18

/ / ,
, 18. ,

.
() :
2012
, .
,
.
, ,
.
, 19. ,
.

" " . , ,
.

.

" " .
. ,
, , 20.

.
, . " "
,
(
" ") . ,
,
1 8
19
2 0

" , " , .18.5.2011 ,

' " , " ,.24.3.2012 ,
" , " , : , :
, : ,2002 ,' .86-63

19

.
.
, ,

( )
. ,
" "
/// . ,
"" , ,
( , , , , , ) 21.
"
" 22,
. , , ,

23. .

:
" " , , , ,
, ( , )
24
( ).
.
: ,
; ,
; ,

25
, , .
2 1
22
2 3
2 4
2 5

" , " , (.514-423 :)2010

.
" , : " ,
(.73-9 :)2007
,2011' .82
" , :
" , , .2008 ,

 20

.
.1 .
.
() ().
.2 . , :
( , , , );
; ;
; ;
26
.
.
27.
, ;
; ; ; ;
; ,
28.
( , ) .
" " ( 29.)multiple deprivation
,
30, " .
26

2 7
2 8
2 9
30

" " "

, ,
. )1(" :
; ( )2 ,
"; ( )3 . :
, ;
;
".
, ,
, ,2006 ,' .47
.
" , , .2007 ,
, ,17 , -2006 .2007
, , ,
. "
" ( " , .)28

21

31
.

2005 ,
, .
)1( :
; ( )2 ( )benchmarking
32. "
" ,
.
.1 ( 2010 ,)
100

75

50

25

EU-27

'

Eurostat :
: .

3 1
32

.
.

 22

,2010
,
. 2000 47.1% , ,201076.6%
. ,
. 2000 19.8% ,
68.1% ,2010 .
,
:
( ,)95.3% 59.1%
. , 93.4%
33
, 37.8% .
100

.2 ( 2010-2000 ,)

90

77
68

74
66

80

71
62

69
59

66
55

62

70

59

55

49
35

31

54

60

50

47

50
40

25

23

20

30
20
10

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010

: , .2010

33

( ,
,2010 ,' .)7

23

.3 2010 ,
(; )
80
70

73

60
57

50

51
44

40
37

35
29

10

30
24

20

17

16

10
0

: , .2010

.4 , 2009 ,
()

80

76.1

69.8
62.6

70
60
50
40

42.2

30
26.8

20
10

5.2

: , .2010

 24

: ,2009 76%
70% . 63% ,
, 42% .

2010
( 75% ,)49%
.
( 92% ,91%) .
, ( 76%
82%) . /
( 53% ,
27%) . ,
.
.5 , ()
92

91
76

82

75
53

49

27

: , .2010

100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0

25

. 40% ,

.

, .
,
34
5% .
," "" , ,
, "
. 51%
. ,
. ,
35
".
, ,
: 24-20 ,90%
75 .23%
( )66%
(.)67%
67%
( ) .

, , ,
:
" " , ( ""
, , ,
, ) ,
. , "

3 4
3 5

( .)25
" , " : ".13.12.2009 ,ynet ,

 26

. .

36
.
.6 ,
*
()
80
70
67

66

61

56 58

46
37 36

50
40

36

30

32

27

20

17

10

+60

60

40-59

20-39

: , .2010
* .

: 53% ,
70% 71% , 84% .
.

,
( 55%,33%
36

" , " , ,
[ ].

27

) , 86%
37
, , 80% .
.7 , ()
100
90
80

84
71

70

70
60

53

50
40
30
20
10
0

: , .2010

.
.
,

38.

, .
.
37
3 8

, 14
,2010 .4
" , ( :)Cultured Technology
" , , [ ].

 28

39
.

40.
: 2000" 41.7% :
,33.9% : ( 4,000" ) ,
85% ,83.4% 41.
: ,
( 57.2% ,52.2%)
( 67.9% ,63.1%).
.8 , 2008 ,
()

85 83.4
63.1

67.9
55.5

60.6
52.2

61.8

57.2

66.5

41.7
33.9

4,001

2,001

4,000

2,000

100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0

: : , ' .2010 ,3
39
40

4 1

.
, ,
- ,
.
, , ' ,3 .2010

29

2010
:

42

: .

:
.

: .

: .

: .

: .

" " .
43.


" . ( )
, , , ,
42

43

" " .2012

( " , ,"2012
)2012 , 85%
55% .
(
, 58% ; 60%
70% )
( 50% 55 , 92% .)17-12

" .
, ,
. ,
. (
) .
( )2011 , ,
( ,
).

 30

.
,
" 44. , ,

(
, "" ).

( "" , ,
45
) , .
OECD (
2012 )
. (
) ,
.

46
.
: ,
" " 47. .
" 48.

44

4 5
46
4 7
48

( ,)2' .51-50
" "
(
).
( ,)26' .48
()" ," , , :
,2012 ,' .12
" 650/04 ' ,2006 , : "
,' .29
" . : "
(") ,' ,63-6 : " ,' .29

31

, .
: ,
49
".
,
.
.
,
" 50. ,
" 51, ,
, ,
,
52.
" .
' ' '
' '' ,,
, " 53.

" ,
54
, ' '".
( 55 )
("" )
. ,
.

4 9
5 0
5 1
52
5 3
54
55

( ) , ,.
, ( ' ( )12
) ," ,2011- .64
" ," ( ,)46' .13
" , :
" , : , ( ,)46' .239
" ," ( ,)46' .23

Helen Nissenbaum, Privacy in Context: Technology, Policy, and the Integrity of Social
( Life, Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2010 , ,' .)17

, .

 32

, .
, , ,
() 56. ,
57 (
IP ) , " " ,
,
.

.

, ,
, .

,
58
, .

:

(
)
()

.

56
57

58

,
, , ," ,' .137-104

" , " ,
(.131-51 :)2010
, , ,
.2.6.2001 ,

33

," 59,2009 ""
60.
, .

, ,,
. ,
,
, , , ,
, .

. :
[ ]... ""
, .
(
) ,
61
.

59

60

61

( ) ,
.
( ) ,".2011-

, .
.
. , ,
. ,
, , ,14.1.2009 ,
' .5-4
.

 34

" " ( ,
)
, , .
, ,
( :)2009
2000 1.3 , , ,
[ ]... 200,000 , ,
188,000 [ ]...
.
,
62
.
(
)
.

63.
,
, " ".

.
64.
,
,2009 " " ,
,
,

6 2
6 3
6 4

' 1 ,30.6.2009 , .
" ,' .11
'" , , : ",
.15.11.2009 ,

35

[ ]...
,
65
.
( " )
" "
66
.

: , , ,
, .
" , , :
67
?".

" [ ]...
" .
, , .
" ,
, , " :
[ ]... ,
" 68.
.
,
69
( ) .
,

6 5
6 6
6 7
68
6 9

' 1 .

" .
' ( .)64
.
" ,' .21 ,14

 36

, .
,
.
, " ":

. , ,

, [ ]...
, ,
70
[ ]... .
,
,
.
, [ ]...
. ,

71
90-80.
,
. 2007
, , ,
, . 2008
, ,
.
.2009 ,
2008 .
2008

7 0
71

" , ".30.7.2009 ,ynet ,

" , , ,30.6.2009' .26

37

. ,2008

.
," 2009
.

.
.
,

. " ,
72
' , ?' ".
. ,
( )2011
.
: ( , , ) , ,
( , , ) , , , ,
, , . ,
, :
.
.
;
;
.
.

( ,)function creep

. , ( )
: ,

7 2

" ,8070/98 ," " (.2004 ,856 ,842 )4

 38

(
,
73
).

(
) 74.

75,

76.


77
.

7 3
74
75
76
77

" ,' .17

.
( .)60
" , ,
, , " , .26.7.2009 ,
' ( .)64

39

. , :

2012
.

78

:
( ;)66%
, ( 77%
" " " ").
.1 , ()

37.3
39.9
21.6
1.2

: , , .2012
:
2-1.

, ,
( .)47% " "
. " "
( )13% ,
78

 40

. ( )8%
553% .

( 3).

.9 (
)
100
92

80
70

60
52
41

28

26

37

40
20

20
0

: , , .2012

( .)92%
: ( ,)70% ( ,)52% ( ,)41%
( ,)36.5% ( )28% ( 20%( )26% "").

41

( )benchmark
, .
" .2 ,
, ?" ()

5.6

6.9

4.0

5.7

32.3

39.6

37.8

25.9

17.0

15.8

20.9

22.4

45.1
100

37.8
100

37.3
100

46.1
100

599

164

175

95

: , , .2012
* 599 .

( )32.3%
17% .
, ( )5.6%
.

 42

.10 ,
( )
100
92

90
80
70

70

60
50

52

40

37

30
20
10

: , , .2012

" "
( ) .
, .
(
) .
,
(
) , " " ,
, ( 4
) . " , " ,
, ""
. ,
, (
) .

43

( )
( )
.
, " /"
( , , 55 ,).
,
. " "
( )

( )
.
,
(
) ( ""

) ,
.

, , ,
, .

 44

. .
( ) ,
"" (
,
) . ( )2011

, .
,


.
. ,
.

. ,

. "
" ,
.
.
79
" ".
, ,
, .
.
,
. , "

7 9

' 117 .

45

" , , .

(
) .

( ,
" ")
: ,
.

, ,
; ,

.

" " , ,


, ,
.

/ / (")
, " "
, , , .

( )
.

, .

 46

,

.

. : ,
, ,.

.

. " "


.

,

.

.
.

,
.

,
, , ;
;
.

. , ,
, ( )
.

47

: , , , ,
, ,
, .
80
.

.
, , ;
; ,

( .)2011

"
, ,' .157-144

80

.
" : " :
, : .2010 ,

 48

.1 , ()

,
,

21.1
38.0
28.4
37.2

20.0
36.0
30.8
40.4

13.3
24.0
16.2
21.3

1.1
2.0
0.8
1.1
/

44.4
23.7
/

100
100
100
100

90
50
509
388

:5-1 , , .2012

.2
, ()

34-18

53.4
55.6
47.0

46.1
51.3
44.1

30.1
48.5
34.0
8.1
44.6

25.9
28.3
24.2
4.5
32.1

49

.3 ()

47.0

50.4

13.1

15.7

9.2

7.2

8.2

11.5

2.7

4.8

15.4
4.5
100
95

8.5
2.0
100
175

""

/

/


/

.4 ""
()

54-35

66.1
46.8
62.5
50.3
27.9

51.3
41.2
46.1
44.1
23.0

62.7
58.8
56.3

51.3
46.1
44.1

 50

.5 "
" ()

54.3
51.7
35.1
29.9
21.8

50.2
46.1
32.1
23.0
11.4

50.6
38.4
36.9
36.2
25.5

46.1
20.5
32.1
23.0
11.4