Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ROBERTO M. QUIJANO
Acting Managing Director
Pailig Development Foundation Inc.
REGINA SALVADOR-ANTEQUISA
Executive Director
Ecosystems Work for Essential Benefits Inc.
VIOLETA M. GLORIA
Lanao Peace Partnership Coordinator
GIZ-Civil Peace Service-LPP/EFK
RECOMMENDATIONS
FROM PARTICIPANTS
Strengthen the institutional
capacity of the future
Bangsamoro police force
SPECIFIC
PROVISION/STATUTE IN THE
BANGSAMORO BASIC BILL
BASED ON VALIDATION
Section 1-18, Art XI. Public Order and
Safety
LPP recommends that the
Bangsamoro Police Force and the
PNP will prioritize curbing or
preventing the proliferation of illegal
drugs and arms trade in the region
and neighbouring areas.
drugs
Persistence of RIDO
Poor environmental
protection practices
*Strengthen environmental
law enforcement in the
Bangsamoro autonomous
setup
*Greater powers for
Bangsamoro to implement
localized actions against
environmental law
violators
Militarization of
communities:
MILF law
enforcement
operations
AFP troops
getting interested
in the outcomes
of local conflicts
Protection of minority
rights
ISSUE/ CONCERN
Transparency in every
aspect of govt affairs
RECOMMENDATIONS
FROM PARTICIPANTS
*Institutionalize citizen
participation in various
aspects of Bangsamoro
governance
*Policy recognition of role
of CSOs in fostering
inclusive Bangsamoro
SPECIFIC
PROVISION/STATUTE IN THE
BANGSAMORO BASIC BILL
BASED ON VALIDATION
Art IX Sections 1-21. Bangsamoro
Basic Rights.
Art IV Sec 2. Democratic Political
System
Art IV Sec. 4 Civilian government
development
Effective law
enforcement and
policing:
-fairness of enforcing
the law
-avoid discrimination
-easy solution of crimes
Dominance by a few
families over Moro
politics and electoral
outcomes
*Abolition of political
dynasties in Bangsamoro
Improving the
madrasah education
system
*Grant competitive
salaries for madrasah
educators, similar to
regular teachers
*timely release of salaries of
madrasah teachers
*build more madrasah schools
*sufficient honorarium and
other benefits for
imam/madaris teachers;
*recognition of madrasah by
LGU
*building of madrasah
buildings, esp. in the remote
Poverty
areas
*for Central govt and
Bangsamoro govt to implement
a comprehensive social and
economic devt program aimed
at lifting the Bangsamoro areas
from impoverishment
- road infra
- support to agriculture
- education (enshrined as
right in Basic Law)
- social services (enshrined
as right in Basic Law)
Ensuring affirmative
action for education of
Bangsamoro youth
Preamble.
Basic Rights.
RECOMMENDATIONS
FROM PARTICIPANTS
SPECIFIC
PROVISION/STATUTE IN THE
BANGSAMORO BASIC BILL
BASED ON VALIDATION
Topic A:
Institutionalization
of Maranao Culture
Maranao
culture are
slowly faded
As a Maranao,
we should
sustain our
culture because
Maranao are
very Hospitable
If could only
sustain the
Maranao
culture. disunity
will not be arise
Language and
the way
a) Customs create
institution or school that
focus on Maranao Custom,
problem is that the one
who handle or preserve for
10 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
Maranao dress
up nowadays
were faded
Main purpose of
this topic is to
be integrated in
Department of
Education is the
establishment
of Bangsamoro
in the
ratification of
BBL.
To strengthen
the Taritib Ago
Igma
(Customary Law
in Maranao)
Government
should
recognize and
support the
Taritib Ago
Igma
c) History Darangun
(History) of Maranao,
before Agoncilio Maranao
are very good. They call
Mindanao as promise
Island. But when Agoncilio
came into scene He said,
promise Island is made by
Politician
d) Rights It is more on Civil
Rights
11 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
Topic B:
Assertion of Equal
Rights and
Privileges of MNLF
Mujahedeen in the
Present Phase of the
MILF-GPH Peace
Agreement
Causes:
1. MILFs Non
recognition
of brother
MNLF
Mujahedeen
struggle for
total
liberation of
the
Bangsamoro
homeland.
2. OIC believes
more in the
12 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
scripted
MILF-GPH
peace
agreement
than the
silent
majority
(MNLF
based).
3. As a result
of the WAR
of attrition
employed by
the GPH
and other
accomplice
to the crime
of soft
genocide
committed
against the
Bangsamoro
people.
4. The divide
and rule
tactic
employed by
the GPH on
the
Bangsamoro
people.
Effects:
1. Bangsamoro
people
disunited.
2. Poverty
proliferated
throughout
the
Bangsamoro
homeland.
13 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
3. We lost our
dignity as a
Bangsamoro
nation.
Topic C: How was the
Agreement between
MNLF And GPH? It
may be forgotten.
Issues:
1. What is now
happening on
the Agreement
between MNLF
and GPH on the
year 1976 until
now?
Did the
GPH
stop the
negotiati
on with
the
MNLF?
The
GPH did
not
conform
on
MNLF
the
TRIPOL
I
agreeme
nt that
had
been
affirmed
on the
14 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
year
1976
Topic D:
The GPH and MILF guarantee
inclusivity in the establishment of
Bangsamoro government.
Decommissioning
of Firearms
Advantage:
If both side
(GPH-MILF)
are sincere on
the peace
agreement on
the Annex on
Normalization
then its
possible that
we can achieved
peace
The only way
for us to feel
that were safe
mostly to those
who had a
conflict or Rido,
having weapon
had a big role to
protect us from
danger
Signing of the
Agreement should be
push through sincerely
What have agreed
should be implemented
to have true and lasting
peace
We need to have a
patience and unity for
the peace to sustain
Inclusiveness and
participatory of MNLF
in the issues of peace
process nowadays
Disadvantage:
If the Mujahidin
will not be
knowledgeable
concerning on
the annex on
Normalization,
possible peace
will no longer
15 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
exist
Topic E:
Character of
Bangsamoro
Majority affirm
that in every
trouble that
happen, Moros
are usually their
blaming
The agreement
between the
MNLF and the
Government on
Tripoli
Agreement on
1976 during the
time of Nur
Misuari, is Nur
Misuari still the
Chairman on
MNLF?
Is government
will not lie on
the Agreement
that was being
processed?
Government did
not conform the
agreement that
was agreed on
the both side
MNLF & GPH
16 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
Topic F:
What will happen
when the dialogue
between the MILF &
GPH will not
succeed/what will
happen if the
agreement will not
be fully
implemented?
The people will
be force to
prepare for
another battle
The Moro
fighters have
already
experienced it
last 1996 when
the government
of the
Philippines did
not follow what
has been agreed
between the
MILF and the
GPH
The Government
should be sincere in the
agreement to fulfill
lasting peace in
Mindanao recognition
of the MNLF former
and current combatant
in the current MILFGPH agreement
Citing a
conversation of
MNLF
Commander
Nur Minsuari
with secretary
Deles, Nur
Minsuari asks
what does Sec.
Deles talks
about when she
said that the
second phase of
1996 agreement
17 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
are already
done when they
have not given
what the MILF
is asks for
The team agrees
to the content of
the Framework
Agreement
Topic G:
Concerns of the
Youth
Rights
(Kabnar)
Benefits
(Gona)
Connection
Education we need to
know and understand
what is stated in the
BBL/FAB concerning
the youth what are our
ancestors fighting for?
Establishment of Youth
Organization within
the Bangsamoro (like
Sangguniang
Kabataan-Separate)
Rules and regulations
concerning the Youth,
what are the
restrictions? What can
we do and cannot do?
18 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
IV.
V.
To know the
Dos and
Donts
Moral
RECOMMENDATIONS
FROM PARTICIPANTS
A.
Strengthening
Shariah Law
-
Full implementation of
Shariah Law
Creation of Municipal Shariah
Court in every municipality
Creation of Provincial District
Court in every province
Creation of Shariah Supreme
Court
Organization of Shariah
Affiliate Court
Strengthening of qualification
of Shariah Lawyer
o Must be a member of
SPECIFIC
PROVISION/STATUTE IN THE
BANGSAMORO BASIC BILL
BASED ON VALIDATION
Sec. 1- 28; Art X. Bangsamoro
Justice System includes the
strengthening of Shariah Justice
system.
19 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
B. Retaining
Muslim
Mindanao in
the
Bangsamoro
Government
Suggestion and
Recommendation
-
C. In the
event CAB
will be failed?
What shall we
do? What are
Bangsamoro Parliamentary
Government in Muslim
Mindanao
Bangsamoro Political Entity
in Muslim Mindanao
Bangsamoro Government in
Muslim Mindanao
The word Muslim must be
stated in the proposed Basic
Law
The word Muslim Mindanao
is the legacy of late President
Corazon Aquino to the
Muslim when it is stated in
the fundamental law, hence
its retention.
Discussion Note
All notable/doable
perspectives and actions must
be based on the mandate of
the people, religion and
country as a basic unit
20 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
our
perspectives
and actions?
framework of discussion.
Salient Features
Strengthening; peaceeducation; peace-economy
and strong faith
Key Understanding
Unity of efforts, perseverance,
trust worthiness and genuine
Jihad Fiy Sabiylillah
Observations
Muslim Leaders must have to
be always with sincere
support.
Activities
Series of Peoples
Consultations through forum
and discussions to arrive at a
remarkable point.
Timeline and Milestones
At utmost needs and upon
comprehensive consensus of
stakeholders
Signs of CAB Failures
21 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
CAB Failures:
Joint supports and strong
connections to the
International Communities
In case of failures of GRPMILF Negotiations, still
subject to international law,
and not to local law
Stop military (AFP)
deployment to the
Bangsamoro Areas and
communities
Accessibility of Mass Media
Conclusion
The Success of Peace
Agreement serves as the
tangible progress of peace
living conditions of the
Filipino People and the
Bangsamoro.
22 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
Points of Discussion
-
Manners of Selection
Proportional Representation
Manners of Succession
Strengthening Sultanate
Participation in the
Bangsamoro Government
E. Lake Lanao
and Its
Environ
F. Current
ARMM
23 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
Government
vs
Bangsamoro
Entity
G. If CAB will
be successful
H. Muslim
Justice in
Supreme
Court
Appointment of Shariah
Lawyer Justice to decide
appealed Shariah cases
Appointment of Shariah
lawyers, real notarial
commission, anywhere in the
Philippines over Bangsamoro
24 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
I. Duration of
Transition
Government
(MILF)
K. EconomicBase Building
for
Bangsamoro:
The AgriIndustry
Venue
documents
Shariah lawyer eligibility to
lateral entry
Basic Shariah law to be
incorporated to educational
curriculum within
Bangsamoro Territory
Creation of Shariah Court in
Luzon and Visayas
Councilor, Lawyer- in any of
which is an appropriate
addressed to Shariah lawyers
Areas of Consideration
The areas of autonomy consist
largely of agricultural lands
that are under-utilized.
Modern
technology/technocrats are
readily mobilize among
Bangsamoro communities
Capital Formation for agriindustry can come from both
private and public sector
25 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
Conflict affected areas in Lanao del Norte, which is not part of the
Bangsamoro Core Territory, recommends that they should be included in
the rehabilitation or reconstruction under the Normalization and
Transitional Justice Aspects of Comprehensive Agreement on the
Bangsamoro.
26 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
LPP noted that while there is a democratic mechanism and option for
communities who wanted to petition for inclusion in Bangsamoro territory
however, there is no express mechanism for others who wanted to petition
for exclusion.
While we recognize that the BBL provide democratic options for the
Bangsamoro people outside the core territory, but we also share their
sentiments that the marginalization of hinterland communities have
encouraged or motivated them to consider the option to petition for
inclusion with hope to experience positive community development and
transformation.
There was also serious concern on when will the Comelec issue the
directives and mechanism on the process of petitioning for inclusion.
27 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.
ROBERTO M. QUIJANO
Acting Managing Director
Pailig Development Foundation Inc.
REGINA SALVADOR-ANTEQUISA
Executive Director
Ecosystems Work for Essential Benefits Inc.
VIOLETA M. GLORIA
Lanao Peace Partnership Coordinator
GIZ-Civil Peace Service-LPP/EFK
28 | P u b l i c C o n s u l t a t i o n o n B a n g s a m o r o B a s i c L a w , N o v 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , I l i g a n
city.