Date of Issue:

Design Review and Comments

Version:
Page:
Ref. No.:

MZ&PARTNERS W.L.L.
DESIGN REVIEW AND COMMENTS
Design Review
ABRAJ QUARTIER
Doha, Qatar
For approval
(REVISION 0)
NOV. 03, 2014

JUNE 2014
V2
Page 1 of 5
DE/F4/V2

Date of Issue:

Design Review and Comments

Version:
Page:
Ref. No.:

JUNE 2014
V2
Page 2 of 5
DE/F4/V2

Design Review Summary:

Discipline

Date of Issue

Design Team
Response

03/11/2014

Eng. Fadi Haidar/ Reynold J. Barraca

Design Stage (For approval)

1.0

Architectural

2.0 Civil / Roads/ Infra/ Drainage, etc

3.0 Structural
4.0 Electrical
5.0 Mechanical
6.0 Plumbing
7.0 Telecommunication / IT/ AV, etc
8.0

Fire Protection

9.0

Interiors, FF&E and Signage

10.0 Landscape & Irrigation

11.0 Security
12.0 QA/QC

Final Issue
(After Workshop)

Remarks

Date of Issue:

Design Review and Comments

Version:
Page:
Ref. No.:

INTRODUCTION / BACKGROUND TO REVIEW

This report is intended to review the structural report for Louver Panel
DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED FOR REVIEW
Calculation report

JUNE 2014
V2
Page 3 of 5
DE/F4/V2

Date of Issue:
Version:

Design Review and Comments

Page:
Ref. No.:

JUNE 2014
V2
Page 4 of 5
DE/F4/V2

1.0 - DISCIPLINE NAME

Section #

Document Description/ Reference

1.1

Calculation Report

1.1.1

Page 7

Comment

As indicated on the general

description page 7 of the report
the maximum height of panel is
7.43 which is also the height of
mullion however on page 12 the
maximum length used was
4930mm. Please clarify?

Response

Closed Out

Date of Issue:

Design Review and Comments

Version:
Page:
Ref. No.:

1.1.2

Page 10

Checking of section compactness

of mullion is not shown on the
calculation. Indicate also the
mullion profile name otherwise
show the complete details of the
mullion dimension, thickness of
web and thickness of top and
bottom flange. For e.g. Gutmann
F60+160155.

1.1.3

Page 16

Checking of section compactness

of louver should be calculated .
Thickness of louver should
indicated on the properties of
louver.

1.1.4

Bearing capacity of mullion

Provide calculation for the

bearing capacity of the mullion
under the bolts shear.

1.1.5

Deflection, shear and bending diagram

Please show in graph not in the

table. It's difficult to read if it is in
the table or provide the STAAD
model.

1.1.6

Drawings

The font size of attached

drawings are very small. It's hard
to read or provide A3 size.

JUNE 2014
V2
Page 5 of 5
DE/F4/V2