You are on page 1of 31

ACCA P3 PROFESSIONAL LEVEL

Business Analysis

SMART Revision notes


Prepared by Darren Sparkes
Email: darrensparkesnotes@sky.com

ACCA P3 - Business analysis

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

Contents

Page no.

A message from Darren3


Paper 3 Examiners Approach..... 4
Extracts from the Examiners report Dec 08...5
Examination Technique.....7
Background and examination format............10
Syllabus Overview...........11
Strategic Planning........12
Mission and Objectives13
Business & Professional Ethics......14
Internal Analysis...15
External Analysis......16
Strategic Options..18
Method of Growth............19
Portfolio Analysis..20
Strategic Choice & Change Management....21
Marketing...22
Organisational Structure..23
International Market Place......24
Business Process Change.....25
Information Technology.............26
Quality.......27
Project Management...28
Role of Finance...29
Review and Control....30
Strategy and People31

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

Thank you for requesting a copy of my SMART Revision Notes.


The notes act as a learning and memory aid for the core models, theories and academic tools included in the syllabus.
However, in order to pass your examination the academic knowledge must be combined with extensive question practice
leading up to the examination.
Your examiner is not interested in the regurgitation of your knowledge but how you APPLY that knowledge to the
scenarios provided in order to answer the requirement set.
I suggest that you should practice as many exam standard questions as possible before the examination. Your practice
answers can be a mixture of answer plans and full written answers to get through as many questions as possible.
However, I would also suggest that it is essential for you to practice at least one full examination to time before entering
the exam room. It is only by replicating the time pressure in the exam that you can appreciate the importance of time
planning on the day.
Keep a look out for relevant articles appearing in your professional magazine or on the Institutes website prior to the
examination, particularly if they are written by the examiner.
I would welcome feedback on the notes.
And remember.
Whether you believe you can or you cant, youre right. (Henry Ford)
Regards,
Darren Sparkes

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

Approach Required
Differentiation is important to individuals seeking to pass a management and
strategy examination.
It is the ability to link strategic and financial analysis;
it is the confidence to use creative thinking in the way you answer a
particular problemwith alternative ways of viewing and solving a problem
Ralph Bedrock (Paper 3 Assessor)

There is no absolutely correct answer candidates who provided


coherent justification awarded appropriate marks
Steve Skidmore (P3 Examiner)

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

Extracts from the Examiners comments December 2008


In

general:
Performance showed an improvement on the previous sitting
Answers much more within the context of scenarios than previous sittings
Financial and quantitative data figured more prominently in answers
The three optional questions were equally popular
Q1b was biggest problem for candidates where many answers did not address the question
Q1a (PESTEL) so popular it lead to some candidates over-answering it, leading to time problems
As a result, answers to the final optional question often appeared rushed
Vast majority of papers were well written and well presented
Hand writing still remains a problem for some it is no use having great ideas if no-one can read them

Section A - Question 1
Q1a there were plenty of clues in the case study, most of which featured in candidates answers, with the
exception of legal responsibilities
Some candidates strayed onto internal issues (strengths and weaknesses) which were not given marks
Q1b The case study is rich in material to support the cultural web approach
Asked to explain the three strategy lenses Some candidates very well prepared showed great
understanding and gained full marks - Others showed very little knowledge and only scored two or three
marks.
Overall many candidates provided good answers to question 1
Reference to the case study context was much better than on previous papers

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

Section B
Many more candidates than before supporting their argument with financial analysis
Many who used financial data in part a failed to do so in part b
The model answer suggests that MMI should not acquire the company many candidates approved the
acquisition with justification through IT synergies credit was given for this approach
Candidates do not always have to agree with the examiners analysis to gain the marks on offer!
Question combined the themes of project management, quality and the systems development life-cycle
Part a relatively straight forward which candidates either knew or did not
Consequently, some candidates scored very few marks whilst others gained full marks
Part b answered relatively well many candidates giving a wide range of options.
Part c often overlap with part b
Many candidates did not clearly justify their answer
In some cases not enough points made to get the marks on offer
Part b relatively difficult in the time-constrained pressurised environment of the examination
Well answered many scoring eight or more out of ten.
This was very heartening!!!

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

Therefore, to pass P3 learn from the examiners


comments:
Analyse the requirements verbs and keywords
Planning think before you write the answer
Application, application, application
Theoretical answers score few marks
You can only apply what you know learn it!
Use and interpret the numbers (they are usually
easy calculations so its the interpretation that
gets the marks)
Time management the marks are your guide

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

Examination Technique to give the Examiner what he wants


1. USE 15 MINUTES READING TIME WISELY
Examine section B questions and choose the two on which you can MAXIMISE MARKS (not necessarily
those on your favourite topics)
If you have some time left then analyse Question 1 requirements and skim read the Q1 scenario to get a feel
for the relevant issues and identify where the information is for each part of the requirements.
2. WORK OUT TIMINGS
Q1 = 90 minutes. Planning = 20-25 minutes, Writing answer = 65-70 minutes
Section B Questions = 45 minutes each. Planning up to 10 minutes, Writing answer 35 minutes.
Break down the time required for each part of the requirements using the marks as a guide. 1.8 minutes per
mark in total, 1.4 minutes per mark after planning.
I suggest you start with Question 1 as you know you have 90 minutes to complete it.
START PLANNING IN YOUR ANSWER BOOK
3. ANALYSE THE REQUIREMENTS
Identify the verb, or verbs, and make it stand out. The verb tells you what the examiner wants you to do, e.g.
evaluate, recommend, analyse, calculate. Be sure to identify all the verbs in the requirement just in case
there is more than one thing to do, e.g. analyse and discuss, evaluate and recommend.
Identify key words. These tell you what to do it on or about, e.g. evaluate what?, recommend what?
4. ALLOCATE MARKS TO EACH VERB IN THE REQUIREMENT
This can now determine how much to write for each verb in the requirement
5. IDENTIFY RELEVANT MODELS, TOOLS, THEORIES FROM YOUR KNOWLEDGE BANK

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

6. DEVELOP HEADINGS AND NUMBERS LAYOUT


Put key elements of model in plan as headings, e.g. Porters 5 Forces analysis = 5 headings. Headings will
give your answer a framework and structure.
Use requirements to develop headings to show marker that you are answering the question asked
7. DISTRIBUTE MARKS ACROSS HEADINGS
This can now determine how much you write under each heading
8. ANALYSE THE SCENARIO
Make brief notes in your plan under relevant headings from models/tools/theories and requirement
Find relevant numbers for calculations
9. WRITE UP YOUR ANSWER TO MAXIMISE MARKS
Layout calculations in a logical and easy to mark format put them in an appendix in your answer plan
Add value to calculations by asking SO WHAT?
Use as many headings as possible to give the answer structure
Short sentences in short paragraphs
Work on 2 sentences for each mark 1 sentence making your point/answering the question + 1 sentence for
application
A third sentence giving some SO WHAT? could get you another mark
Leave a blank line between points/paragraphs to make your answer easy on the eye
Be strict with timings. When time is up on a question, or part of a question, move on.
Stick to answering the requirement use your plan to keep you on track
REMEMBER THE THREE GOLDEN RULES 1)APPLICATION 2) APPLICATION and 3)APPLICATION

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

Exercise professional
judgement

Select relevant
data

Determine appropriate
techniques

Candidate Requirements

Apply knowledge
and skills

Assess the strategic position of the organisation


Evaluate strategic choices available to an organisation
Discuss how an organisation might go about its strategic implementation
Model and redesign business processes and structures to implement and
support the organisations strategy taking account of customer and other
major stakeholder requirements
Integrate appropriate information technology solutions to support the
organisations strategy
Apply appropriate quality initiatives to implement and support the
organisations strategy
Advise on the principles of project management to enable the implementation
of aspects of the organisations strategy with the twin objectives of managing
risk and ensuring benefits realisation
Analyse and evaluate the effectiveness of a companys strategy and the
financial consequences of implementing strategic decisions
The role of leadership and people management in formulating and
implementing business strategy

Paper Background

Objectives of the
paper

Format of paper

Section A 50%

Compulsory
Major case study
Usually four parts
Case will include numbers

Choice of two from three


Each question likely to include
two parts
Will include short scenario
May include numbers

Section B 50%

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

10

Governance and Corporate Social Responsibility

Syllabus Overview

Cultural Web

SMART

Mission and objectives


Purpose, Strategy, Policies, Values

Mendelow's power-interest matrix

Stakeholder Analysis

PEST

Resource audit

External Analysis

Porters 5 Forces

Internal Analysis
Core competences

Corporate
Appraisal

Porters Diamond
Product Life Cycle

Benchmarking

SWOT

Porters Generic
Strategies

Porters Value Chain


CSFS
BCG, PSPM, DPM, APD,
Mkt attract/SBU strength

Portfolio analysis

The Strategy Clock

Strategic
Options

TOWS Matrix

Withdraw

Ansoffs productmarket matrix

Risk
Acquisition vs organic vs joint development

Suitability, Acceptability, Feasibility

Strategic Choice

Cost/Benefit
Change Management

International
Trading

HRM

IT

Structure

Project Management

Implementation
Sources of Finance

Marketing

Quality
Software Quality

Review and Control


Business Process Change

Not for Profit Organisations

Software Solutions
Financial Measures

Investment Appraisal

Non-financial Measures
BSC

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

11

Integrates activities

Competitive advantage

Position
Analysis

Corporate =
Strategic level

Relationship with environment

Whole
organisation

Business = Tactical
level

Interdependant

Functional = Operational level

All stakeholders
Long-term

Choice

Strategy
Freewheeling Opportunism
Market Driven reactive
Hands on management
Exploit complacent players
Relies on leaders vision
No formula for success
Take advantage of market
opportunities
Stock market problems

a course of action, including


the specification of resources, to
achieve a specific objective

Alternative

Incrementalism (Lindblom)
Building block approach
Build strategy through incremental steps not radical
shifts
Accepts uncertainty of future
Builds commitment
May be too slow
Ideas often compromised

Emergent Strategy - Bottom up (Mintzberg)


Intended
Strategy
Unrealised
Strategy

Deliberate
Strategy

Realised
Strategy

Emergent
strategy

E.G. Hondas entry into the USA, 3M


ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Johnson,
Scholes &
Whittington

Design

Strategic
Lenses

Action

Experience

Ideas

Strategic
Planning

Purpose

Rational Top Down Approach

Mission & Objectives

Respond and fit to environment


Utilise scarce resources
Provide direction
Ensure consistent objectives
Monitor progress

Corporate appraisal
Strategic options

Strategic choice

Implementation

Review

Advantages
Identification of
strategic issues
Consistency of goals
Improve
performance/survival
Pro-active
Recognises
environment
Optimum use of
resources

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Disadvantages
Expensive (time
and money)
Bureaucracy
Stifles creativity
Less relevant in
a crisis

Darren Sparkes, 2009

12

Purpose

Advantages
Resolve stakeholder conflict
Set direction
Help formulate strategy
Communicates values to
employees
Marketing to customers

Strategy

Policies and
standards

Criticisms
Meaningless terms used
Written retrospectively?
Not communicated to
employees
Ignored by managers

S
M
A
R
T

Specific
Measurable
Attainable
Relevant
Timebound

Mission
Values

the most generalised type


of objective which can be
thought of as its raison detre.

Objectives

Mission Statement

Culture

Published version of the


Mission

Stakeholders

Mendelows Power Interest Matrix


Low

Low

Interest

High

Minimal Effort

Keep Informed

Give Direction

Education /
Communication

High

Mission and
Objectives

Keep Satisfied

Key Players

Intervention

Participation Keep
Close

Critical Success
Factors
"The limited number of areas
in which results, if they are
satisfactory, will ensure
successful competitive
performance for the
organization.
They are the few key areas
where things must go right for
the business to flourish.

Power

The way we do things around here

If results in these areas are


not adequate, the
organization's efforts for the
period will be less than
desired."

Cultural Web
cultural paradigm
Routines & Rituals
Stories & Myths
Symbols
Power structure
Organisation structure
Control systems

Not for Profit Organisations

Features of objective setting


Multiple and contradictory objectives
Participation in objective setting
Providers of funding different to beneficiaries of service
Priorities may change frequently
Value for money a requirement not an objective
Increased role of personal objectives
Efficiency

Economy

Effectiveness
ACCA P3 Business Analysis

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

13

Equal opportunities

Corporate Governance

C
O
P
P
I
T

Divorce of ownership and control


Separate roles of CEO and Chairperson
Audit Committee / Remuneration Committee
Directors re-election at least every 3 years
Non-exec Directors
o Independent
o Role on audit / remuneration
committees
o Corporate conscience
o Mentors to inexperienced execs
o Strategic value through expertise

Competence

Consumer health and safety

Objectivity
Professional due care
Politeness

Bribes
Safety in the workplace

Integrity
Technical Standards

Environment

Professional Ethics

Innovation &
ideas from
close links to
community

Multiple
stakeholder
obligation

Reputation
and branding

Competitive
advantage
Recruitment

Shaper of
society

Views on Business Ethics

Business and
Professional
Ethics

Small company
advantage in the
supply chain

Attract ethical
investor funds

The business of
business is business
(Shareholder View Friedman)

Long-term Self-Interest /
Stakeholder view

Avoid future Government policy

Benefits to Business
Reduced risk

Honesty in Advertising

Corporate Social
Responsibility

Johnson, Scholes & Whittington Ethical Stances


Long-term
shareholder
interest

Fair Trade

Sustainability

Self control, not self interest

Short-term
shareholder
interest

Issues

Firms should acknowledge their social


responsibilities.

Potential problems

No universal acceptance of
morals & ethics

Management to concentrate on
maximising profits and
shareholder wealth.
Businesses have no duty to
society.
Societal benefits will arise as a
result of commercial success.

Conflict of CSR with shareholder wealth

Reduced revenues
Increased costs
Diverts funds from shareholders
Distracts management

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

Competitive disadvantage

Disclosure of business information

Deciding what is ethical


ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Bad publicity from monitoring and enforcement

14

Same as
competitor / easy
to copy

Different to
competitor /
difficult to copy

Resources

Basic

Unique

Competences

Threshold

Core

Manpower
Management
Money
Make-up
Machinery
Methods
Material
Markets
Management Info

Strategic
Assets

9 Ms

Strategic Capability
Resource audit

Valuable
Rare
Cant be copied
Not substitutable
Give access to wide
range of markets

Uncover Knowledge
Discover Knowledge
Capture Knowledge
Share Knowledge
Distribute Knowledge
Lever Knowledge
Maintain Knowledge

Explicit

Porters Value Chain

Internal Analysis
(Strengths & Weaknesses)
Benchmarking
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.

Select processes to be
benchmark
Assign responsibilities
Choose type of benchmarking
Choose partner
Interaction
Collect data
Implement changes

Roving role
Temporary roles
Selection based on skill & competences
Input into own development
Separate & relevant incentive schemes
Remote locations
Flexible working
ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Competitive

identify activities within the firm which


add value to customers and those that
do not

Primary Activities

Value Networks

Knowledge Workers

Reputation

Innovative
Ability

Core Competences
the activities or
processes that critically
underpin competitive
advantage.

Knowledge Management
Tacit

Architecture

Internal

Inbound Logistics
Operations
Outbound logistics
Marketing and sales
Service

Support/secondary activities

Procurement
HRM
Technology development
Firm infrastructure

Uses

Streamline linkages
Eliminate non-value added activities
Business Process Re-engineering
Benchmark key processes

Process/Activity
BEST IN PRACTICE
These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

15

Economic
Globalisation
Economic cycle
Interest rates
Inflation
Employment levels
Exchange rates

Social & Demographic


Income distribution
Education levels
Population size
Age profile
Lifestyle changes
Fashions and tastes
Consumerism

Technological
Internet
Government
spending on RnD
Communications
Speed/rate of
change
Processes and
methods of
production

PESTEL analysis
(External, Environmental analysis)

Political
Taxation
Government policy
Foreign trade
regulations
Protectionism
Globalisation

External Analysis
(Opportunities and Threats)

Threat from New Market Entrants


Barriers to Entry:

Economies of Scale

Other cost advantages

Capital requirements

Access to distribution channels

Patents, Government policy

Reaction of existing firms

Competitive Rivalry

Greatest where:

Competitors of similar size

Slow market growth rate

High fixed cost industry

Lack of differentiation

Power of Buyers

External Analysis
(Opportunities and Threats)

Legal
Health And Safety
Employment
Consumer protection
Monopoly legislation
Industry watch dogs

Threat from Substitute


Technologies

Power greatest where:

Few buyers

High number of suppliers available

Cost is high proportion of buyers total cost

Low switching costs

Buyers have low profits

Buyers have full information

Little product differentiation

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Porters 5 Forces
(Competitive,
Industry analysis)

Ecological
Globalisation
Pollution
Energy usage
Disposal of waste
Sustainability of
resources

Can same features be produced


cheaper?
Can new features be provided for same
cost?
Level of danger may be influenced by
barriers to entry and/or power of buyers

Power of Suppliers
Power greatest where:

Few suppliers

Few substitutes

High switching costs

Threat from forward integration

Customer not significant to supplier

Supplier has differentiated product

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

16

Problems:

No common shape
Unpredictable
Self-fulfilling
prophecy
Product orientated
ignores market

Firm structure, strategy, rivalry

Product Life-cycle
Stages:

Introduction: high risk, little competition, low volume, high advertising = losses + negative cash

Growth: increased competition, growing volumes, EOS, high advertising = losses to profits + negative

to positive cash
Maturity: steady repeat sales, high volumes, EOS, low level advertising = profits + positive cash

Decline: falling volumes, falling prices = profits to losses + positive to negative cash, divest

Porters
Diamond

Factor
conditions

National
Competitive
Advantage

Demand
conditions

Related and supporting industries

Balance the portfolio

External Analysis
(Opportunities and Threats)
Corporate Appraisal
Internal + External Analysis
= Corporate Appraisal = Position
Appraisal= SWOT Analysis
Strengths

Weaknesses

Internal Analysis

INTERNAL

Factors specific to the organisation

External Analysis
Factors open to all in the industry
ACCA P3 Business Analysis

EXTERNAL
Opportunities

Threats

TOWS
These notes are not intended to cover
the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

17

High

Hybrid

Differentiation

Focused
Differentiation

To beat the five


forces

Porters Five
Forces

PESTEL

Porters Generic Strategies


Benefit

Low

Strategic
Clock

Low Price

No Frills

Fail

Price

Low

Method of Growth? (See next page)

Fail

Differentiation

Focus (Niche)
(Cost or Differentiation, focus on market
needs, develop core competencies)

What Basis?

Strategic Options
What Direction?
competitive products,

Do nothing
/ Withdraw

complementary products, by-products

Vertical Integration
Advantages

Economies of combined
ops

Economies of control and


coordination

Avoiding the market

Tap into technology

(better margin, potential price cuts, entry


barrier, reduce supplier power)

Beware of Stuck in the Middle

Definition of market
Ignores factors such as competitors
Suggests strategies in isolation

Horizontal diversification

Overall Cost Leadership

(Premium price, better margin, barrier,


reduce buyer power)

Positioning view

Resource Based View

Market Facing

High

Limitations

Strategically develop
organisation in line
with environment

Fail

Disadvantages

Increased operational
gearing

Reduced flexibility to
change partners

Capital investment needs

Ansoffs Matrix
Products, existing and new (PEN)
Markets, existing and new (MEN)

Market Penetration (cost reductions,

price reductions, advertising, minor product


modifications)
Conglomerates

Product Development (exploit


Advantages
existing customers, RnD, buy-in and badge,
Disadvantages

Flexibility
JVs, Licensing)

No additional benefit to

Quick growth
shareholders through

Market Development (new markets

Access to capital
synergies
such as foreign markets, new segments such

Portfolio effect

No operating advantages
as adult to child or industrial to consumer)

Avoidance of anti
Diversification (related = vertical
monopoly legislation
integration or unrelated = conglomerate
ACCA P3 Business Analysis
These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Uses

Analyse rivals
Suggest own strategy
SBU level strategy

Limitations
Unclear definition of industry
Defines advantage in terms of position not

resources

Lack of empirical evidence


Ignores middle ground
Restricts firm to position in present
industry
Requires perfect information

Risks
Product
Market
Operations and
management
Financial
Darren Sparkes, 2009

18

Advantages

Disadvantages

Quick
Lower risk
Overcomes barriers to entry
Same number of competitors
Can block a competitor
Possible synergies
Possible under-valuation of
target

Acquisition
The attractiveness test
The cost of entry test
The better off test

Disadvantages

No premium for assets


People development
Staged investment
Established culture
Introduction of new
technology and systems
easier
Possibility of grants

Acquisition versus
Organic growth

Porters 3 Tests for


Acquisitions

Advantages

Purchase premium
Integration issues
o Systems
o People
o Culture
Synergies do not
materialise
Reputation of target

Slow
Increases number of
competitors
Overcoming barriers to
entry
No opportunity for
synergies
Higher risk

Organic
Growth
Divestment

Possible synergies

Market
Economies of scale
Shared activities
Surplus assets
Vertical integration
Skills transfer
Dilution of risk
Reduced power of
buyers/suppliers
Tax advantages

Method of
Growth?

Withdrawal

Joint Development
Methods

Strategic Alliance
Licensing

Long-term agreement to
share knowledge,
competences, technology
for mutual benefit

Franchising
Giving the right to exploit a business
method/model in return for a capital sum
plus a share of the profits. Franchisor
usually provides support e.g. marketing,
training, technical
ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Demerger

Joint Venture
Separate business entity
with equity form two or
more businesses

Quick
Higher price due to
strategic value

Giving the right to


exploit brand, recipe,
process etc for a
share of the profits

Gives shareholders
an exit route
Management can
focus on core areas
Two companies can
develop separate
identities

Management Buyout
(MBO)
Quick growth
Access to competences
Less financial risk/outlay
Overcome product, market,
operational risk
May lose competences
Train future competitors
Brand infection
Operational and contractual
disputes
Ownership of assets
Sharing of profits

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Consider

On-going involvement of
holding company

Why is holding company


selling?

Loss of Holding company


help, e.g. technical support,
finance services

Quality of management team

Price

Personal risk, e.g. home at


risk?
Darren Sparkes, 2009

19

Problems:

Definition of axes

Definition of market

No account of complimentary goods

Assumes high market share = advantage

Business Sector
Prospects

Directional Policy Matrix


Unattractive

BCG Matrix
Relative market
share

High
High
Market
growth

Low

STAR
Build then Hold
Losses to profits, negative
to positive cash

PROBLEM CHILD
Build or Divest
Losses, negative cash

CASH COW
Hold then Harvest
Profits and positive cash

DOG
Harvest then Divest
Profits to losses, positive
to negative cash

Low

Weak

Withdrawal

Companys
Competitive Avge
capabilities

Phased
withdrawal

Average
Phased
withdrawal
Proceed with
care
Proceed with
care

Attractive

Double or quit

Try harder

Growth
Growth

Strong

Cash
Generation

Leader
Leader

Public Sector Portfolio Matrix


Value for money

High

Low

High
Public sector Star

Public
need &
Funding
effective
ness

Political hot box

Portfolio
Analysis
Market Attractiveness/SBU Strength matrix
Business strength/Competitive position

Golden Fleece

Back drawer issues


discontinue

Low

Low
High

Opportunities to add value

Ballast

Strong

High

High

Heartland
Edge of
Heartland

Long-term
Industry
attractiveness

Med

Ability to
Add value
Low
Low

Alien Territory

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Average

Weak

Enhance Lead
Diversify
Re-invest

Hold leadership
Leverage
strengths
Use EOS

Maintain
leadership
In
attractive
segments

Avoid me too
Differentiate
Re-invest

Segment
between growth
and harvest

Harvest
Price-up
Cut costs
Line pruning

Segment focus
Seek
advantage

Harvest through
sale of business

Divest/Liquidate

Value trap
These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Ashridge Portfolio Display Corporate Parents

Darren Sparkes, 2009

20

Acceptability

Suitability

Feasibility

Will the proposed strategy meet


the objectives of the organisation
and, therefore, be acceptable to
the major stakeholders?

Is the proposed strategy suitable for the


present situation and circumstances of the
organisation?
i.e. Is it suitable given the SWOT
analysis?

Has the organisation got, or can it get,


the necessary resources to carry out the
strategy?

Strategic
Choice

Risk
`

Cost/Benefit

Strategic Drift
Strategy

Environment

Types of Change
Transformation
Incremental

Extent of change

Evolution

Realignment

Driving Forces

Change
Management
Revolution

Strengthen

Unfreeze

Change
Kaleidoscope

Diversity

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Weaken

Reconstruction

Power

Preservation

Restraining Forces
Social
Factors

Time
Scope

Personal
Factors

Adaptation

Speed
of
Change
Big Bang

Job Factors

Lewins Force
Field Analysis

Readiness

Capability

Capacity

Change

Organisational
Factors

Refreeze
Supporting
Mechanisms

Participation
Education & communication
Facilitation & support
Negotiation
Manipulation
Coercion

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

21

Coordinated marketing

Implementation Issues
Customer needs

Profitability

Analyse environment
and competitors PEST
/ Porters five forces

Marketing
Strategy

Target Markets

Kotlers Four
Pillars
A
I
D
A

Marketing
identify, anticipate and satisfy
customer requirements

Awareness
Interest

division of the market into


homogenous groups of potential
customers who may be treated
similarly for marketing purposes

Desire
Action
Production

Physical
Evidence
Processes

Communications Mix:
Advertising
Sales promotion
Public relations
Personal selling

Place

Distribution
channels
Market coverage
Outlet locations
Warehousing

Marketing Mix 4Ps


Price

set of controllable
marketing variables used to
produce desired response in
the target market

Price levels
Discounts
Allowances
Payment terms
Delivery options

Product qualities
Features, options,
range, warranty,
branding, packaging

Product
Product Life Cycle
Product
to meet
needs

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Sales

Marketing

Promotion
7 Ps

Product

Firms orientation

People

Market Segmentation and


Target Market

Marketing Research

Geographic
Demographic
o Age
o Gender
o Income
o Family life-cycle
Social class
Psychological
Education
Hobbies
Undifferentiated

systematic gathering,
recording and analysing of data
about problems relating to the
marketing of goods and services

Field Research
(Primary data)
Interviews, focus groups,
questionnaires,
experiments, Test
marketing

Differentiated
Concentrated

Desk research
(secondary data)
Internal
Accounts, Sales
reports, Customer
complaints

External
CSO reports,
Business
monitors, Trade
journals,
newspapers

Product
mix

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

22

Implementation Issues

Divisional

Entrepreneurial

Functional

Fast decisions
Responsive to market
Congruence
No career structure
No autonomy
Single product & market

Economies of scale
Specialists with some autonomy
Career structures
Frees up entrepreneur
Slow decisions (bureaucratic)
Functional silos
Few products & markets

Centralised vs Decentralised
S
T
O
P
T
I
E
S

Multiple products &


markets
Autonomy for SBU
managers
Training of SBU managers
Frees up senior managers
Focus on specific
products/markets
Loss of congruence?
Duplication of effort
Isolation of SBU
managers

Matrix

Types of Structure

Strategy

Network
Organisation

Technology
People

Planning and control


Tasks
Ideology
Size

Decentralisation
Advantages:

Frees senior
management

Better local decisions

Better motivation

Flexibility

Training/career path

Virtual
Organisation

Outsourcing

Objectives

Environment

Breakdown of silos
Shared knowledge
Skill development
Innovation and creativity
Dual command
Dilution of functional
authority
Time consuming meetings

Direct supervision

Internal market

Organisational
Structure

Planning processes

Mintzbergs
Structural

Performance
management

Managing
Business
Units

Culture
Self-control

Disadvantages:

Loss of control

Loss of congruence

Duplication of effort

Extra costs of control

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

External
Relationships

Strategic Apex
Technostructure

Strategic
Planning co.s

Synergy
Manager

Financial
Control co.s

Portfolio
Manager

Strategic
Control co.s

Parental
Developer

Middle Line
Operating core

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Support
Staff

Reduced cost
Skill shortages
Flexibility
Focus on core business
Loss of control
Supplier dependency
Confidentiality
Loss of in-house skills

Simple structure =
entrepreneurial
Machine bureaucracy
= functional
Professional
bureaucracy =
decentralised
Divisional form
Adhocracy = matrix

Darren Sparkes, 2009

23

Country
specific costs
Economies
of scale

Political
Influences

Acquire
resources

Cost advantages

Convergence of Markets

Political
Diversify
sources of
sales &
supply

Expand sales

Legal
Economic

Social/cultural

Reasons for growth in


international business

Objectives of
international
growth

Trend to Global
products

General
risks

Technological

Competitive
Forces

Exporting

The International
Market Place

Low capital outlay


Low risk
Can learn about market
May not meet customer needs
Perceived lack of commitment
High distribution costs

Methods of International Expansion

Joint Venture &


Franchising

Access to local resources


Reduced national sentiment
Shared capital input
Access to competences and
knowledge
Shared profits
Lose competences
Train competitor
Operational disputes

Global

Perceives foreign markets as


similar to domestic market
Products & marketing mix
constant
Standardisation to save time and
money
Supply-driven policy

Multi-Domestic

See overseas market as distinctive


Customised products and
marketing mix

Increased overseas sales volumes


BUT

Fewer EOS giving higher costs, so


volumes not turned into profits

Hybrid

Foreign Direct Investment

Closer to market
Retain profits
More control
Reduced operational conflicts
High financial risk
Staffing decision
Integration difficulties

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Standardise wherever possible,


e.g. RnD, Branding
Market convergence may allow
standardised product
BUT
Demand-driven
Customised marketing mix
where necessary = GLOCAL

STAFFING

Overcomes lack of host skills,


unified culture, Transfers
competencies
Resentment by host, single
cultural view

Multi-cultural view, inexpensive


Limits career mobility, isolates HQ
from subsidiaries

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Efficient use of HR, builds strong


culture and management
network
Subject to National immigration
policies, expensive
Darren Sparkes, 2009

24

Transition
Implementation Issues
Strategic
Importance

Low
High
Process
Complexity
Dynamics
Low

Development

High

Process Re-engineering

Complex but not core


competence
- Outsource

Complex & dynamic


High strategic value for
advantage
- Process Improvement

Static / commodity
Outsource/Automate
Minimum resources

Static but valuable


- automate for efficiency

Redesign
Process Redesign

Analysing
Process Improvement

Planning
Improving Processes

Harmons
Process-Strategy
Matrix

Business
Process Change

Feasibility
Analysis

Software
System
Project

Process
Measures

Value -added
analysis
Eliminate non-value
added activities

Feedback control systems

TARA
Action

Technical
Operational
Economic
Social
Weighting and Scoring

Design
Implementation

Simplification
Eliminate duplicated
activities

Software Solutions
Systems Development Life
Cycle

Interviews
Questionnaires
Observation
Documenting tools
Workshops
Protocol Analysis
Prototyping
Staff training
Installation
File conversion
Testing

Gaps &
disconnects
Failures in
communication

Review

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Review

Input-Process-Output

Targets

Actuals

Quality of Support
User Friendliness
Ability to meet needs
Compatibility/Integration
Costs
Supplier factors

Generic Solutions
Speed
Cost
Risk
Support
Unique needs
Supplier power
Compatibility/Integration
These notes are not intended to cover
theadvantage
whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus
No

Darren Sparkes, 2009

25

Implementation Issues

McFarlan's Strategic Grid


Strategic impact of future systems

Value chain

Low

L
o
w
Strategic
impact of
current
systems

High

Support

Turnaround

No strategic value

Expect info system


to become
strategically
important in the
future

Generic strategies

H
i
g
h

Factory

Strategic

See strategic value


of info system now
but expect value to
decrease in the
future

Depend on info
system for
competitive
advantage

E-commerce

Strategic
Context

E-marketing

E-branding

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

7Ps

4Ps
People
Processes
Physical evidence

Push vs Pull

Supply Chain
Management

Downstream
(Customers)

6 Is
Integration
Industry structure
Independent
locations
Individualisation
Intelligence
Interactivity

-Recency
-Frequency
-Monetary
value

WebPresence

Information
Technology

Retention

Extension

E-business

Integrated
E-commerce

Customer Life
Cycle

Acquisition

Porters Five Forces

Customer
Relationship
Management

Selection

Barriers
Technophobia
Security
Set-up costs
Running costs
Limited
opportunities
Limited resource
Disinterested
customers

Switching costs
Disintermediation
Re-intermediation
Updates
Communication
User community
Tracking
preferences
Customisation

E-sourcing
E-procurement
Upstream
(Suppliers)

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

E-purchasing

E-payment

Risks

Technology
Organisational
No cost savings

Darren Sparkes, 2009

26

Internal

Implementation Issues

External

Quality
Certification

Failure
Commitment

Communication

Appraisal

Quality
Standards

Costs
(PAF)

Preventative

Competence

6 Cs
Customers

Proactive

Continuous
improvement

Quality Assurance
Reactive
Quality Control

TQM

Fitness for
Use

Level 1
Performed process

Quality

Capability
Maturity
Model
Integration
(CMMI)

Level 2
Managed process

99.99966%

Get it right
first time

Six
Sigma
Quality
Software

Level 3
Defined process

Key
Requirements
Level 4
Quantitatively Mangd
Level 5
Optimising process

Problem Solving
Process
(DMAIC)

The V Model

Team Roles

Define

Test Plans
Requirement spec
Functional spec
System Design
Unit Design

Acceptance testing

System testing

I
T
Coding

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Integration testing

3.4 defects in
1 million

Measure
Analyse

6 Cs

6 Sigma
Champion

Master Black belt

Implementation
Leader
Black Belt

Improve

Unit testing

Green Belt
Control

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

27

Implementation Issues
Technological
Operational
Economic
Social

Resources

Tolerate / Accept
Treat / Reduce
Transfer / Insure
Terminate / Avoid
Project
Initiation
Document

Risk
Quality

Time

Sponsor
Manager
Team

Formally terminate
project

Gantt Chart

Stakeholders

Initiation

Work
Breakdown
Structure

Quality
Resources
Evaluation
Dissemination
Exit
Sustainability

Statements of
Work

Project
Management
(IPECC)

Ensure
Completed

Critical
Path
Analysis

Time

Project
Appraisal

Feasibility

Planning

Product
Breakdown
Structure

Cost
Breakdown
Structure

Execution
Put plan into action

Completion
Monitor
And
Control

Final report & audit

Evaluate performance

Project Evaluation & Review Technique (PERT)

Purpose
Scope
Deliverables
Costs
Time
Objectives
Stakeholders
Org structure
SWOT

Tie up loose
ends
Compare PID
to Outcome

Project Leader
TARA

Smooth
handover
Corrective
Action

Frequency

Adjust Plan

Fast Track

Complexity
Risk
Cost

Project
Initiation
Document

Motivation
Planning
Co-ordination
Communication
Problem solving
Change Mgt
Budgeting
Meetings

Crashing
Motivation

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Increase
resource
These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

28

Economy
Efficiency
Effectiveness
Spend funds
effectively

Competitive
Strategy

Raise
maximum
funds

Core Costs

Objectives
Investment
Strategy

Management
R&D
Support Services

Cost
Gearing
Control
Security
Cash flow
Availability
Exit routes

Retained earnings
Ordinary shares

Considerations

Financial
Strategy

Not for Profit


Organisations
Strategy

Equity

Financing
Decisions

Alternatives

Pref shares

Debt

Grants

ROCE
Payback

Role of Finance

Traditional
Methods

Investment
Appraisal

Ratios

Discounted cash
flow techniques

NPV
IRR

Asset turnover
ROCE
Receivables
Payables
Inventory
Revenue/employee

Profitability

Inter-firm comparison
Limitations

Accounting policies

Bias by large/small firms

Unrepresentative avge

Industry classifications

Financial periods

Limitations
Only comparative
Inflation
Definitions
Accounting policies
Availability of info
Historical

Debentures
Loans
HP/Leasing
Overdraft
Trade Creditors

ROCE
Gross/Net Margin
ROE

Efficiency

Liquidity

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Current ratio
Quick ratio

Dividend cover
Interest cover
EPS
PE ratio

Gearing

Investor ratios

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

29

Examples
Gross margin
Net margin
Cost % sales
Profit

Problem:
no account taken of invested
capital used to generate
profits

Return On
Investment
(ROI)

Residual
Income (RI)

PBIT X 100 = %
CE

PBIT
(CE x imputed interest rate)
RI

Relative Measure %

Absolute Measure s

Profit Related Measures

Benefits

Longer-term
measures
More difficult to
manipulate
Measures
determinants and
results
Promotes goal
congruence
Includes
stakeholders

Potential
Drawbacks

Measures conflict
with each other
Requires cultural
change
Overload
paralysis by
analysis
Time and cost
No obvious
relationship with
shareholder wealth

Review and Control

Problems:

Problems:

The Balanced Scorecard


Financial Perspective

Customer
Perspective

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Absolute measure
poor for
performance
comparisons

Joint issues when used in isolation


Internal Business
Perspective

Learning & Growth


Perspective

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Sub-optimal
investment
decisions
Deplete capital
assets too early

Identify CSFs
Identify competences required for CSFs
Develop KPIs for competences
Measure competence
Take action continuous improvement

Backwards looking measures


Short-termist decisions
Open to easy manipulation of discretionary costs and
capital employed

Conclusion
Financial measures should not be used in
isolation to measure performance but should
be combined with non-financial measures.

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Darren Sparkes, 2009

30

Implementation Issues

Current & future


HR needs

HR Gap

Labour supply

Current HR
position

Trait
Style
Contingency
Situational

Strategic and
coherent
approach

TARA

Analyse behaviour
Recruitment
Training needs
Manage
performance
Benchmarking

ACCA P3 Business Analysis

Purpose

Job design

Assessment
& Appraisal
Barriers

Performance
Measurement

Reward
Management
Motivation

Performance
Potential
Training

Recruitment

Strategy and
People

Competency
Frameworks

Communication
Teamwork
Delegation
Motivation
Trust

Leadership

Workplace
Learning

Knowledge
Management

Exploitative autocratic
Benevolent authoritative
Participative
Democratic

Likert's
Management
Styles

Learning
organisation

Charismatic
Transformational
Transactional

Classical

HR Planning

Scientific Mgt
Job enrichment
Japanese Mgt
BPR
Teamwork
Succession
planning

Categories
Levels
Design Issues
Techniques
Strategic alignment

Considerations:

Fair & consistent

Motivation

Reward performance

Recognise job factors

Control salary costs

These notes are not intended to cover the whole of the ACCA P3 syllabus

Confrontation
Judgement
Chat
Bureaucracy
Event
Unfinished
business

Employee ranking
Rating scales
Checklists
Critical incident method
Free reporting
Performance contract
BARS
Appraisal interviews

Darren Sparkes, 2009

31

You might also like