Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Capital Investment Analysis and Project Assessment: Purdue
Capital Investment Analysis and Project Assessment: Purdue
EC-731
Economic Profitability
The purpose of an economic profitability analysis is to
determine whether the investment will contribute to the longrun profits of the business. Although various techniques can
be used to evaluate alternative investments, including the
payback period and internal rate of return, the most
Value
Beginning
of Year
$681
8%
735
794
4
5
Annual
Interest
Amount at
End of Year
$54
$735
8%
59
794
8%
64
858
858
8%
69
926
926
8%
74
1,000
Interest
Rate
year for the next five years. The discount factor for money
received at the end of the first year, assuming an 8% rate, is
0.9259. You can find the discount factor of 0.9259 in the
appendix at the point where year one and 8% meet. Hence, the
$1,000 received at the end of the first year has a present value
of only $925.90 ($1,000 x 0.9259). In similar fashion, you
can calculate the present value of the $1,000 received at the
end of years two through five using the discount factors from
the appendix for 8% and the appropriate years.
You can then determine the present value of this flow of
money as the sum of the annual present values. So the
present value of an annual flow of $1,000 for each of five
years (assuming an 8% discount rate) is only $3,992.60. As a
manager, you would be equally well off if you were to receive
a current payment of $3,992.60 or the annual payment of
$1,000 per year for five years, assuming an 8% discount rate.
In essence, discounting reverses the compounding process
and converts a future sum of money to a current sum by
discounting or penalizing it for the fact that you dont have it
now, but have to wait to get it and consequently give up any
earnings you could obtain if you had it today.
Table 2. Computations to Discount to Present Value
Year
Present
Value
Discount
Factor
Cash
Flow
$1,000
0.9259
$925.90
1,000
0.8573
857.30
1,000
0.7938
793.80
1,000
0.7350
735.00
1,000
0.6806
680.60
Total $3,992.60
this debt now will reduce your businesss ability to use credit
in the financing of future investments.
The objective is to evaluate investment alternatives based on
the long-run optimal capital structure of the businessthe
capital structure or combination of debt and equity that you
expect to maintain over a number of years. To determine the
long-run cost of capital (based on this optimal capital
structure) for the business, you must weight the cost of debt
funds and the cost of equity funds by the long-run proportions
of debt and equity that will be used to finance the business. This
results in a weighted cost of capital that can be summarized as:
d = K eWe(1 t) + K dWd(1 t)
Where d is the discount rate, K e is the cost of equity funds
(rate of return on equity capital), We is the proportion of
equity funds used in your business, K d is the cost of debt funds
(interest), t is the marginal tax rate, and Wd is the proportion
of debt funds in your business.
The purpose of the weighted cost of capital formula is to
obtain a discount rate that accurately reflects the long-run
direct cost of debt funds and the opportunity cost of equity
funds, along with the long-run proportions of debt and equity
that will be used in the firm. Note that the cost of equity funds
is best estimated as the opportunity cost (income foregone) of
committing equity to this particular investment compared to
other investments.
The best way to specifically measure this cost is to look at the
rate of return being generated by the equity capital currently
being used in your business. You calculate this rate of return
as the sum of the cash return plus the gain in asset values
divided by net worth or equity (market value basis) as
measured on your businesss balance sheet. You calculate the
annual cash return as annual net income from the income
statement. You determine annual capital gain by comparing
the market value of assets of the business this year to the value
last year; you can obtain these data from your balance sheet.
Because the cash flows that you will discount in Step 3 will be
computed on an after-tax basis to reflect all costs and cash
flows, you should compute the discount rate on an after-tax
basis as well. So you multiply the cost of equity (K e) times one
minus the marginal tax rate (1 t) to adjust it to an after-tax
rate. Also note that because interest (the cost of debt funds) is
Purdue Extension Knowledge to Go
required. For example, if you were evaluating the construction of a new retail building, the capital outlay would include
not only the purchase price of the building, but also the cost
of any additional inventories that might be required. In
essence, these additional working capital commitments will
be necessary to operate the larger facility, and you must
consider them as part of the capital outlay for the new investment.
Then,
Net Income x Marginal Tax Rate
= Taxes
The marginal tax rate reflects the additional taxes that will be
paid on income generated by the particular investment. Note
that depreciation enters in this computation of the tax
liability. As shown above, the additional tax liability will
reduce the net cash flow from a particular investment.
You should include the terminal value, also known as
salvage value, of a particular machine or a piece of
equipment as a positive cash flow in the last year if it is to be
sold or traded on a new item. The salvage value is part of the
cash benefit stream that will be received if the capital item is
sold. Or if it is traded for a new capital item, as is often the
case with machinery, the salvage value reflects the reduced
cash outlay that will be incurred to purchase the new machine.
After you compute the annual net cash flow for each year of the
project, you have produced a series of annual net cash flows.
lowest net present value ranked last. You would then implement all those alternatives with a positive net present value if
the funds were available to do so. If the funds to acquire the
alternative investments were limited, you would choose that
combination of projects that generates the largest total net
present value with the limited funds.
A Profitability Example
To show you how to use the net present value procedure in
capital budgeting, lets apply it to an example of deciding
whether a mechanic should add a tow truck to his business. A
good tow truck can be bought for $76,800. The mechanic has
researched the costs to operate the truck and the possible
revenues that could be earned. Additionally, he has estimated
that the truck would be worth about $30,000 when the project
would end in five years.
The tax rate is expected to be 35%, and the business will
finance the project with 60% equity and 40% debt in the long
run. The cost of equity capital (return on equity funds
currently being used in the business) is 13.4%, and debt funds
can be borrowed at 10.6%.
= K eWe(1 t) + K dWd(1 t)
= 0.134 x 0.6 x 0.65 + 0.106 x 0.4 x 0.65
= 0.052 + 0.028
0 (salvage value)
5,590 (taxes)
= 0.08
Where
d
= discount rate
t
6
5,760 (taxes)
= tax rate
Then,
$15,971 (net income) x 35% (marginal tax rate)
= $5,590 (taxes)
Annual computations, based on the mechanics estimations of
revenue and expenses, would be as shown in Table 3.
Table 3. Annual Cash Flows for an Investment Project
Year
Cash
Revenue
Cash
Expense
$42,032
Salvage
Value
Taxes
Net Cash
Flow
$20,301
$5,590
$16,141
42,360
20,910
3,777
17,673
42,122
21,242
4,139
16,741
41,887
21,583
4,413
15,891
41,654
21,931
15,054
34,669
30,000
Based on the positive net present value of Step 5, the mechanics decision would be to buy the tow truck and add that
service to his business. The tow truck will generate a return
that exceeds the cost of funding the ventureit generates a
positive net present value.
Financial Feasibility
Once you have analyzed the profitability of various investments and chosen an alternative, you need to evaluate its
financial feasibility. Financial feasibility analysis determines
whether or not the investment will generate sufficient cash
income to make the principal and interest payments on
borrowed funds used to purchase the asset. If you will be
making the purchase with equity funds and a loan is not
required, then financial feasibility analysis is unnecessary.
Feasibility Calculation
Step 4. Calculate the present value of
the annual net cash flows.
The mechanic would compute the present value of the net
cash flows as the sum of the discounted annual net cash flows
(net cash flow times the discount factor) (Table 4).
Table 4. Computations to Reach Net Cash Flow for
Each Year of an Investment
Year
Annual Net
Cash Flow
Discount
Factor
$16,141
0.9259
$14,945
$17,673
0.8573
$15,151
$16,741
0.7938
$13,289
$15,891
0.7350
$11,680
$34,669
0.6806
$23,596
$78,661
down payment will reduce the size of the loan and the annual
principal and interest payments. Possibly, you could increase
the net cash flow from the project by controlling expenses
more carefully or increasing utilization. If you cannot reduce
or eliminate the deficit, then you must subsidize with cash
from some other source to make the capital purchase
financially feasible. By completing a financial feasibility
analysis, you can estimate the size of the needed subsidy.
This does not necessarily mean that the mechanic should not
make the investment. It does mean that it will not generate
enough cash to make the loan payment. Consequently, the
mechanic should consider changes such as a longer term
loan or a down payment and smaller loan. Other possibilities
to make the project financially feasible would be to subsidize
it with cash from elsewhere or reduce expenses so as to
increase the cash flow from the investment.
A Feasibility Example
Final Comment
Payment Schedule
Year
Annual Net
Cash Flow
Principal
Interest
Total
After-Tax
Payment Schedule
Surplus or
Deficit
$16,141
$13,013
$6,374
$19,387
$2,231
$17,156
$-1,015
17,673
14,093
5294
19,387
1,853
17,534
139
16,741
15,262
4125
19,387
1,444
17,944
-1,203
15,891
16,529
2858
19,387
1,000
18,387
-2,496
34,669
17,901
1486
19,387
520
18,867
15,802
3.0%
1.00
.9709
.9426
.9151
.8885
.8626
.8375
.8131
.7894
.7664
.7441
.7224
.7014
.6810
.6611
.6419
.6232
.6050
.5874
.5703
.5537
.5375
.5219
.5067
.4919
.4776
.4120
.3066
.1697
3.5%
1.00
.9662
.9335
.9019
.8714
.8420
.8135
.7860
.7594
.7337
.7089
.6849
.6618
.6394
.6178
.5969
.5767
.5572
.5384
.5202
.5026
.4856
.4692
.4533
.4380
.4231
.3563
.2526
.1269
4.0%
1.00
.9615
.9246
.8890
.8548
.8219
.7903
.7599
.7307
.7026
.6756
.6496
.6246
.6006
.5775
.5553
.5339
.5134
.4936
.4746
.4564
.4388
.4220
.4057
.3901
.3751
.3083
.2083
.0951
4.5%
1.00
.9569
.9157
.8763
.8386
.8025
.7679
.7348
.7032
.6729
.6439
.6162
.5897
.5643
.5400
.5167
.4945
.4732
.4528
.4333
.4146
.3968
.3797
.3634
.3477
.3327
.2670
.1719
.0713
5.0%
1.00
.9524
.9070
.8638
.8227
.7835
.7462
.7107
.6768
.6446
.6139
.5847
.5568
.5303
.5051
.4810
.4581
.4363
.4155
.3957
.3769
.3589
.3418
.3256
.3101
.2953
.2314
.1420
.0535
5.5%
1.00
.9479
.8985
.8516
.8072
.7651
.7252
.6874
.6516
.6176
.5854
.5549
.5260
.4986
.4726
.4479
.4246
.4024
.3815
.3616
.3427
.3249
.3079
.2919
.2767
.2622
.2006
.1175
.0403
6.0%
1.00
.9434
.8900
.8396
.7921
.7473
.7050
.6651
.6274
.5919
.5584
.5268
.4970
.4688
.4423
.4173
.3936
.3714
.3503
.3305
.3118
.2942
.2775
.2618
.2470
.2330
.1741
.0972
.0303
6.5%
1.00
.9390
.8817
.8278
.7773
.7299
.6853
.6435
.6042
.5674
.5327
.5002
.4697
.4410
.4141
.3888
.3651
.3428
.3219
.3022
.2838
.2665
.2502
.2349
.2206
.2071
.1512
.0805
.0229
7.0%
1.00
.9346
.8734
.8163
.7629
.7130
.6663
.6227
.5820
.5439
.5083
.4751
.4440
.4150
.3878
.3624
.3387
.3166
.2959
.2765
.2584
.2415
.2257
.2109
.1971
.1842
.1314
.0668
.0173
7.5%
1.00
.9302
.8653
.8050
.7488
.6966
.6480
.6028
.5607
.5216
.4852
.4513
.4199
.3906
.3633
.3380
.3144
.2925
.2720
.2531
.2354
.2190
.2037
.1895
.1763
.1640
.1142
.0554
.0130
8.0%
1.00
.9259
.8573
.7938
.7350
.6806
.6302
.5835
.5403
.5002
.4632
.4289
.3971
.3677
.3405
.3152
.2919
.2703
.2502
.2317
.2145
.1987
.1839
.1703
.1577
.1460
.0994
.0460
.0099
10
8.5%
1.00
.9217
.8495
.7829
.7216
.6650
.6129
.5649
.5207
.4799
.4423
.4076
.3757
.3463
.3191
.2941
.2711
.2499
.2303
.2122
.1956
.1803
.1662
.1531
.1412
.1301
.0865
.0383
.0075
9.0%
1.00
.9174
.8417
.7722
.7084
.6499
.5963
.5470
.5019
.4604
.4224
.3875
.3555
.3262
.2992
.2745
.2519
.2311
.2120
.1945
.1784
.1637
.1502
.1378
.1264
.1160
.0754
.0318
.0057
9.5%
1.00
.9132
.8340
.7617
.6956
.6352
.5801
.5298
.4838
.4418
.4035
.3685
.3365
.3073
.2807
.2563
.2341
.2138
.1952
.1783
.1628
.1487
.1358
.1240
.1133
.1034
.0657
.0265
.0043
10.0%
1.00
.9091
.8264
.7513
.6830
.6209
.5645
.5132
.4665
.4241
.3855
.3505
.3186
.2897
.2633
.2394
.2176
.1978
.1799
.1635
.1486
.1351
.1228
.1117
.1015
.0923
.0573
.0221
.0033
10.5%
1.00
.9050
.8190
.7412
.6707
.6070
.5493
.4971
.4499
.4071
.3684
.3334
.3018
.2731
.2471
.2236
.2024
.1832
.1658
.1500
.1358
.1229
.1112
.1006
.0911
.0824
.0500
.0184
.0025
11.0%
1.00
.9009
.8116
.7312
.6587
.5935
.5346
.4817
.4339
.3909
.3522
.3173
.2858
.2575
.2320
.2090
.1883
.1696
.1528
.1377
.1240
.1117
.1007
.0907
.0817
.0736
.0437
.0154
.0019
11.5%
1.00
.8969
.8044
.7214
.6470
.5803
.5204
.4667
.4186
.3754
.3367
.3020
.2708
.2429
.2178
.1954
.1752
.1572
.1409
.1264
.1134
.1017
.0912
.0818
.0734
.0658
.0382
.0129
.0015
12.0%
1.00
.8929
.7972
.7118
.6355
.5674
.5066
.4523
.4039
.3606
.3220
.2875
.2567
.2292
.2046
.1827
.1631
.1456
.1300
.1161
.1037
.0926
.0826
.0738
.0659
.0588
.0334
.0107
.0011
continued
12.5%
1.00
.8889
.7901
.7023
.6243
.5549
.4933
.4385
.3897
.3464
.3079
.2737
.2433
.2163
.1922
.1709
.1519
.1350
.1200
.1067
.0948
.0843
.0749
.0666
.0592
.0526
.0292
.0090
.0009
13.0%
1.00
.8850
.7831
.6931
.6133
.5428
.4803
.4251
.3762
.3329
.2946
.2607
.2307
.2042
.1807
.1599
.1415
.1252
.1108
.0981
.0868
.0768
.0680
.0601
.0532
.0471
.0256
.0075
.0007
13.5%
1.00
.8811
.7763
.6839
.6026
.5309
.4678
.4121
.3631
.3199
.2819
.2483
.2188
.1928
.1698
.1496
.1318
.1162
.1023
.0902
.0794
.0700
.0617
.0543
.0479
.0422
.0224
.0063
.0005
11
14.0%
1.00
.8772
.7695
.6750
.5921
.5194
.4556
.3996
.3506
.3075
.2697
.2366
.2076
.1821
.1597
.1401
.1229
.1078
.0946
.0829
.0728
.0638
.0560
.0491
.0431
.0378
.0196
.0053
.0004
14.5%
1.00
.8734
.7628
.6662
.5818
.5081
.4438
.3876
.3385
.2956
.2582
.2255
.1969
.1720
.1502
.1312
.1146
.1001
.0874
.0763
.0667
.0582
.0508
.0444
.0388
.0339
.0172
.0044
.0003
15.0%
1.00
.8696
.7561
.6575
.5718
.4972
.4323
.3759
.3269
.2843
.2472
.2149
.1869
.1625
.1413
.1229
.1069
.0929
.0808
.0703
.0611
.0531
.0462
.0402
.0349
.0304
.0151
.0037
.0002
15.5%
1.00
.8658
.7496
.6490
.5619
.4865
.4212
.3647
.3158
.2734
.2367
.2049
.1774
.1536
.1330
.1152
.0997
.0863
.0747
.0647
.0560
.0485
.0420
.0364
.0315
.0273
.0133
.0031
.0002
16.0%
1.00
.8621
.7432
.6407
.5523
.4761
.4104
.3538
.3050
.2630
.2267
.1954
.1685
.1452
.1252
.1079
.0930
.0802
.0691
.0596
.0514
.0443
.0382
.0329
.0284
.0245
.0116
.0026
.0001
16.5%
1.00
.8584
.7368
.6324
.5429
.4660
.4000
.3433
.2947
.2530
.2171
.1864
.1600
.1373
.1179
.1012
.0869
.0746
.0640
.0549
.0471
.0405
.0347
.0298
.0256
.0220
.0102
.0022
.0001
17.0%
1.00
.8547
.7305
.6244
.5337
.4561
.3898
.3332
.2848
.2434
.2080
.1778
.1520
.1299
.1110
.0949
.0811
.0693
.0592
.0506
.0433
.0370
.0316
.0270
.0231
.0197
.0090
.0019
.0001
17.5%
1.00
.8511
.7243
.6164
.5246
.4465
.3800
.3234
.2752
.2342
.1994
.1697
.1444
.1229
.1046
.0890
.0758
.0645
.0549
.0467
.0397
.0338
.0288
.0245
.0208
.0177
.0079
.0016
.0001
continued
18.0%
1.00
.8475
.7182
.6086
.5158
.4371
.3704
.3139
.2660
.2255
.1911
.1619
.1372
.1163
.0985
.0835
.0708
.0600
.0508
.0431
.0365
.0309
.0262
.0222
.0188
.0160
.0070
.0013
.0000
18.5%
1.00
.8439
.7121
.6010
.5071
.4280
.3612
.3048
.2572
.2170
.1832
.1546
.1304
.1101
.0929
.0784
.0661
.0558
.0471
.0398
.0335
.0283
.0239
.0202
.0170
.0144
.0061
.0011
.0000
Notes
New 6/05
12
www.ces.purdue.edu/new