Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Therapy
By Nelson Binggeli, PhD
The principles and methods of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) are
among the primary ways that I help my clients achieve their goals for positive
change in their lives. Because CBT is a very collaborative form of therapy, I
believe it is helpful for my clients to understand these principles and methods.
Ultimately, I would like for my clients to become skilled in using CBT on their
own to meet the challenges in their lives, long after their work with me has
ended. Prior to reading this material, please read my disclaimer regarding
information provided on this website.
An overview of CBT
CBT is a form of psychotherapy that has been demonstrated to be effective in
helping to people to overcome a wide variety of problems, including those
involving depression and anxiety. It is based upon scientifically-informed
principles of human psychology and its effectiveness for many problems has
been supported by hundreds of scientific studies. CBT focuses on the
patterns of thought and behavior that maintain both adaptive and maladaptive
behavior. It assumes that these patterns are learned, and that new patterns
can be learned when old ones are no longer useful.
CBT tends to be a present-centered, active, collaborative, and short-term form
of therapy. Although therapists do not disregard how problems may have
developed (e.g., as a result of childhood experiences), their primary focus is
on helping the client identify and change what is maintaining the problem in
the present. The relationship between the therapist and the client is marked
by collaboration, and clients are encouraged to take an active role in applying
the techniques both within and between therapy sessions. Therapy tends to
be short-term (often between 5-30 sessions over a period of one to 18
months), and emphasizes the client learning principles and techniques that
will serve them long after their work with the therapist has ended.
and researcher who helped to bridge the gap between the cognitive and the
behavioral is Albert Bandura. There are many more important theorists and
researchers that this brief history necessarily omits.
For further reading
More information about CBT can be found on the websites of the following
professional organizations:
Academy of Cognitive Therapy
Association for Behavioral & Cognitive Therapies
Beck Institute for Cognitive Therapy & Research
National Association of Cognitive Behavioral Therapists
An article describing CBT by Ben Martin, PsyD on PsychCentral.com
Research supporting CBT
Butler AC, Chapman JE, Forman EM, & Beck AT. (2006). The empirical status
of cognitive-behavioral therapy: a review of meta-analyses. Clinical
Psychology Review, 26, 1, 17-31.
Hollon, S. D., Stewart, M. O., & Strunk, D. (2006). Enduring effects for
cognitive
behavior therapy in the treatment of depression and anxiety. Annual Review
of
Psychology, 57, 285315.
Olatunji BO, Cisler JM, Deacon BJ. (2010). Efficacy of cognitive behavioral
therapy for anxiety disorders: a review of meta-analytic findings. Psychiatric
Clinics of North America, 33, 3, 557-77.
The Society of Clinical Psychology (a division of the American Psychological
Association) provides a summary of Research Supported Psychological
Treatments, many of which are based on CBT.
-Navigation: Home > Resources > Coping skills & treatments > Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
model works, I have used the experience of Person B from the vignette
above.
Cognitive distortions
The term cognitive distortion refers to errors in thinking or patterns of thought
that are biased in some way. They may include: (A) interpretations that are
not very accurate and which selectively filter the available evidence, (B)
evaluations that are harsh and unfair, and/or (C) expectations for oneself and
for others that are rigid and unreasonable. The more a persons thinking is
characterized by these distortions, the more they are likely to experience
disturbing emotions and to engage in maladaptive behavior. A number of
common patterns2 of cognitive distortions have been identified, including:
1. All-or-nothing thinking: Looking at things in absolute, black-and-white
categories, instead of on a continuum. For example, if something is less than
perfect, one sees it as a total failure.
2. Overgeneralization: Viewing a negative event as a part of a never-ending
pattern of negativity while ignoring evidence to the contrary. You can often tell
if youre overgeneralizing if you use words such as never, always, all, every,
none, no one, nobody, or everyone.
3. Mental filter: Focusing on a single negative detail and dwelling it on it
exclusively until ones vision of reality becomes darkened.
4. Magnification or minimization (e.g., magnifying the negative and minimizing
the positive): Exaggerating the importance of ones problems and
shortcomings. A form of this is called catastrophizing in which one tells
Where do these distortions come from, and what purpose do they serve?
Frequently, cognitive distortions develop in childhood as the result of
unfortunate and difficult life experiences and/or being taught to use them by
significant others (e.g., parents and peers). We also become more prone to
cognitive distortions when under stress, because under pressure we are apt to
take more cognitive shortcuts resulting in less accurate and more extreme
interpretations and reactions. Cognitive distortions can also serve the function
of trying to protect us from harm. For example, when a depressed or anxious
person thinks, I cant do it, it justifies inaction and protects the person from
possible failure. Of course, this strategy is ultimately self-limiting and
defeating, and keeps people stuck in old patterns that dont work very well.
How CBT views emotions
CBT is not saying that all negative or painful emotions are bad and that we
should always think positively. Emotions such as fear, anger, and sadness
can be very appropriate and even useful. Fear can tell us there is danger, and
motivate us to protect ourselves. Anger can inform us that our rights are
being violated, and we need to take action to assert our rights. Sadness can
be the result of losing something or someone important to us, and can
indicate that we need to take the time to grieve.
What is important is not whether an emotion is positive or negative, but
whether it is adaptive or maladaptive. Negative and painful emotions can be
adaptive if they are based on accurate thinking and guide an appropriate
response. Maladaptive emotions are driven by distorted thinking and cause
unnecessary suffering and inappropriate responses. One way of defining
mental health might be the extent to which one can recognize the difference
between adaptive or maladaptive emotions.
The process of cognitive restructuring
Cognitive restructuring refers to the process of replacing cognitive distortions
with thoughts that are more accurate and useful. Cognitive restructuring has
two basic steps: (1) Identifying the thoughts or beliefs that are influencing the
disturbing emotion; (2) Evaluating them for their accuracy and usefulness
using logic and evidence, and if warranted, modifying or replacing the
thoughts with ones that are more accurate and useful.
In CBT, the therapist guides the client through the process of becoming more
aware of what they are telling themselves and helps them to evaluate, and
when appropriate, to modify their own thinking. In essence, the therapist
teaches the client a process that will help them distinguish distorted thinking
from more accurate and useful thinking. CBT emphasizes that this is best
done as a collaborative process in which the client is assisted in taking the
lead as much as possible. The therapist refrains from assuming that the
clients thoughts are distorted and instead attempts to guide the client with
questions that encourage the client to make their own discoveries. Clients are
also encouraged to engage in his process on their own during their time
between sessions by using a written format, described below.
The Cognitive Restructuring Worksheet
When learning Cognitive Restructuring, it is very helpful to use a worksheet
designed to guide the process. I encourage you to download the Cognitive
Restructuring Worksheet (which is in Microsoft Word format) to have available
as you read the next section. Having it in this format allows you to print
multiple copies, or to type directly onto it. The table below depicts the main
headings of the worksheet.
The following are instructions regarding how to use this worksheet. Below
these instructions is an example of a completed Cognitive Restructuring
Worksheet.
Part I: Identifying emotion-causing thoughts
Instructions: When you are experiencing a negative emotion use the following
procedures to identify the emotion-causing thoughts.
1. Situation: Briefly describe the situation that led to the emotions.
2. Emotions / ratings: Identify the emotions you are experiencing and any
physical sensations. Emotions can be described by single words, such as
sad, nervous, afraid, angry, guilty, or ashamed. For more examples of
emotion words, click here. Then, rate the intensity of your emotions using the
scale below.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
3.
What are the advantages of telling myself this? And what are the
disadvantages?
2.
What might be a more useful or helpful way of thinking about this?
3.
To the degree that this belief is true, what should I do about it?
4.
5.
Be sure to record any data that contradicts the thought, and the more
rational thoughts you may have composed.
2. This list of cognitive distortions was partially adapted from: The feeling
good handbook, byDavid Burns. Plume, 1999.
3. These lists of questions were adapted from: Cognitive therapy: Basics &
beyond, by Judith Beck.
4. This semi-fictional male college student is a representative composite of
several clients I have worked with over the years.
-Last updated: 02.05.10
-Navigation: Home > Resources > Coping skills & treatments > Cognitive Behavioral Therapy >
Cognitive restructuring
set of techniques for helping people to overcome this habit. Therapists help
their clients to set weekly goals, to identify possible sources of positive
reinforcement, and to schedule and structure their activities.
I plan to write a more detailed guide to the specific techniques of behavioral
activation. Until then, you can read more about it by exploring the links
provided below.
Online resources regarding behavioral activation
Wikipedia (Behavioral Activation)
Derek Hopko, PhD (behavioral activation researcher)
Christopher Martell, PhD (behavioral activation researcher)
The Society of Clinical Psychology
PDFs available from the Centre for Clinical Interventions Depression
Resources): An overview of behavioral activation; Fun activities
catalog; Behavioral activation worksheet
Book recommendation
An excellent book for the general public is: Overcoming depression one step
at a time: The new behavioral activation approach to getting your life back, by
Michael E. Addis & Christopher R. Martell. New Harbinger, 2004.
Selected research
Cuijpers P, van Straten A, Warmerdam L. (2007). Behavioral activation
treatments of depression: a meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology Review, 27,
318326.
Dobson KS, Hollon SD, Dimidjian S, Schmaling KB, Kohlenberg RJ, Gallop
RJ, Rizvi SL, Gollan JK, Dunner DL, Jacobson NS. (2008). Randomized trial
of behavioral activation, cognitive therapy, and antidepressant medication in
the prevention of relapse and recurrence in major depression. Journal of
Consulting & Clinical Psychology, 76, 468477
-Navigation: Home > Resources > Coping skills & treatments > Cognitive Behavioral Therapy >
Behavioral activation
Disorder, and Specific Phobia. This article first describes how anxiety
disorders develop at least partially through classical conditioning and
avoidance. It then presents the principles of exposure therapy.
Classical conditioning
In order to understand why exposure therapy works, it helps to understand
classical conditioning and its role in the anxiety disorders. Classical
conditioning was first demonstrated by Ivan Pavlov, a Russian physiologist, in
his famous experiments with dogs around the turn of the 20th century. Pavlov
showed that if you repeatedly ring a bell right before giving food to a dog, it
will eventually come to salivate upon hearing the bell only. The general
principle that Pavlov discovered was that if you repeatedly present a stimulus
that naturally causes a reaction (e.g., food causing salivation) right after
presenting a previously neutral stimulus (i.e., the bell), an animal will come to
react to the previous neutral stimulus in a similar way.
Classical conditioning forms part of the basis for anxiety disorders. People
with anxiety disorders have come to associate non-threatening neutral stimuli
with either traumatic experiences or imagined future catastrophes. They have
learned to react to a previously neutral stimulus as if it were an actual threat.
For example someone with a phobia of dogs may experience a stress reaction
just by looking at a picture of a dog. They may rationally know that the picture
cannot hurt them, but nevertheless their brain triggers the release of
adrenaline to help their body either fight or flee. This illustrates how classical
conditioning is an automatic emotional response that bypasses rational
thought.
Classically conditioned responses are recorded deep in the emotional centers
of the brain (i.e., the limbic system). When we perceive that something is
threatening, our emotional centers send out an alarm. It takes a few more
milliseconds for the rational centers of our brain to process what is
happening. When we are afraid, our body responds more strongly to the
alarm from the emotional centers of the brain than to our rational thoughts.
This is responsible for the phenomenon of knowing that something isnt
threatening and yet still feeling afraid.
In Panic Disorder, people come to fear body sensations that actually are not
harmful. In Generalized Anxiety Disorder, people react to thoughts and
Exposure therapy can be challenging for both clients and for therapists.
Confronting stimuli that causes feelings of fear, helplessness, shame, disgust,
or horror is not easy. However, there is a lot of scientific evidence that it
works, and most people find that ultimately the short-term pain caused by
exposure is greatly outweighed by becoming liberated from classically
conditioned fear responses. In addition, the graduated nature of the
exposures (i.e., starting with less fearful stimuli) and the use of improved
coping strategies make it somewhat less challenging than it might otherwise
be.
There are several theories about why exposure works. The one that has the
most research support is that it works primarily through the mechanism of
habituation. Habituation occurs when the repeated exposure to a stimulus
decreases our responsiveness to it. For example, we may come to tune out
the noise of a loud fan after being in a room with it for a while. It is also
possible that we replace one form of conditioning for another (this has been
called counterconditioning). Because an anxiety response cannot continue
indefinitely, eventually anxiety decreases during exposure. When this
happens, the association between the stimulus and the anxiety response is
weakened and replaced with an association with a more relaxed state.
Theorists who emphasize cognitive factors argue that (a) safe exposure may
help people think about the stimuli more objectively, (b) people come to
expect that theyll be less anxious in the presence of the stimuli, and (c)
exposure may strengthen the persons beliefs that they are capable of coping
with their anxiety.
Creating an anxiety hierarchy
The first step in conducting exposure therapy is creating what is called an
anxiety hierarchy. This is a list of the stimuli that causes an anxiety reaction
arranged in a hierarchy according to how much anxiety each stimuli causes.
For example, stimuli that cause only mild anxiety are listed at the bottom of
the list.
More specific information about how to create an anxiety hierarchy will be
provided here soon.
Conducting exposure exercises