Solomons Snap Judgement

Your Name: Cecilia Carbone

Partners Name: Alex Bierrenbach
Partners Subject: Catholic view on marriage
The person has 3 sources of the 10 required

Each source is clearly related or relevant to the topic stated above? If yes, state
which is best: if no, state which arent

Yes all three are good, the one on thisibelieve.org is best because it touches
upon equal marriage

Each source is clearly owned (identify writer/editor/sponsor)? If yes, which is most

clearly owned; if no state which arent

Yes, the one from Jstor and this ibelieve.org are most clearly stated.

Each sources owner/sponsor has clear credentials? If yes, state the best example of
this; if no, state which dont

Yes, thisibelieve.org has an opinion that makes sense, its recent and
relevant.

Each source is fairly recent? If yes, which is most recent; if no, state which is oldest

The one from Jstor doesnt have a date. The day book entries are very recent
and thisibelieve.org is from 2008.

Each source is viable as academically suitable content? If yes, which is strongest; if

no, state which arent and why

Yes, the one from Jstor, it specifically talks about restrictions on marriage for
priests.

Which source has the highest, overall quality? Why?

The Jstor article, its very clear and talks about a lot of different restrictions
priest have.

Which source is the pro viewpoint? What makes this source special/ standout?

Jstor, it really just discusses why priest cant marry

Which source is the con viewpoint? What makes this source special/ standout?

Thisibelieve.org talks about why gays should be married

Overall, you consider these sources to be of Poor, Average, Good, Excellent, or

Superior Quality? Why?

I felt they were good sources because they gave basic information for the
topic but they couldve been more in-depth and had more information.

I think, solely on these sources, he/she would earn a grade of a 80, because

They dont have a very strong focus on the subject, theyre all broad. They
had good information but it was all similar.

Does your partner agree or disagree with this evaluation? Elaborate with the
response.

Yes my partner agreed. He thinks he should find sources that pin point to one
general idea that isnt so broad.