Claiming the Land Assignment

!
!

Dimension/Task

1. Research : The product

reveals a synthesis of the
research of the article and
contains a personal
opinion and conclusion

Limited
(1 pt.)

The author
attempted to
synthesize some of
the research and
personal opinion
on the article.

Acceptable
(2 pts.)

Proficient
(3 pts.)

The product showed

exemplary
performance by
The author synthesized the demonstrating
research, information, and complete synthesis
personal opinion. The
of the research and
findings from the research personal opinion of
were summarized, but a
the author. The
conclusion was not stated findings from the
in closing.
research were
summarized, and a
conclusion was
stated in the closing.

2. Accuracy : Current
concepts, terms, and
conventions are use
correctly and with clarity
throughout the product.

Elements and ideas

are presented in a
Elements are somehow
disconnected,
linked together but reflect
rather organized
some inconsistency.
fashion.

The product is highly

and tightly
organized. Ideas,
concepts, and
principles are
presented in a
consistent fashion
across the product.

3. Depth : The product

reflects a personal
position on the article by a
rich analysis of relevant
and high quality
references.

The product
presents a position
highly dependent
on a superficial
analysis of
references.

The produce presents

a personal position
based on an
integration of
relevant and high
quality references.

The product presents a

position supported by
some analysis of relevant
references.