Muaf:

(Al-Uthmaaniyy)

1.

2.

Makkah:

^\
2:116:1, p. 18

^\
2:132:1, p. 20

3.

_\
3:133:1, p. 67

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

Madeenah: Al-Imaam:

Ibnu Katheer Aboo Jafa

Naafi

_\
3:184:10, p. 74

_\
3:184:11, p. 74

`\
4:66:15, p. 89

a\
5:53:1, p. 117

a\
5:54:5, p. 117

Y:

Ibnu akwaan:

Ad-DooriyyK:

Wash:

Shaam:
Ibnu Aamir

, K, Kh:

Baah:

Wash:

(Uthmaan )
(Madeenah)

Koofah:

Aaim
Aboo Am
amzah
Yaqoob
Al-Kisaaiyy
Khalaf

Khalaf:

9.

10.

b\
6:32:7, p. 131

b\
6:63:12, p. 135

11.

b\
6:137:8, p. 145

12.

13.

14.

15.

c\
7:3:14, p. 151

Khalaf:

, K, Kh:

N:

c\
7:75:1, p. 160

c\
7:141:2, p. 167

Qaaloon:

Wash:

c\
7:43:17, p. 155

Shubah:

Wash:

16.

e\
9:100:18, p. 203

17.

18.

e\
9:107:1, p. 204

f\
10:22:3, p. 211

19.

20.

21.

22.

23.

24.

25.

n\
18:36:11, p. 298

n\
18:95:3, p. 303

q\
21:4:1, p. 322

q\
21:30:1, p. 324

s\
23:87:2, p. 347

Khalaf:

AJ:

m\
17:93:19, p. 291

s\
23:89:2, p. 347

Shubah:

26.

27.

s\
23:112:1, p. 349

s\
23:114:1, p. 349

, K:

Khallaad, K:

Khalaf:

28.

29.

30.

u\
25:25:5, p. 362

v\
26:217:1, p. 376

w\
27:21:7, p. 378

31.

32.

AJ, Wash:

x\
28:37:1, p. 390

\
36:35:5, p. 442

As-Soosiyy:

Khalaf:

af:

33.

\
39:64:4, p. 465

34.

\
40:21:16, p. 469

36.

37.

\
40:26:13, p. 470

\
42:30:5, p. 486

\
43:68:1, p. 494

38.

39.

\
43:71:9, p. 494

\
46:15:4, p. 504

AJ, Wash:

N:

35.

Shubah:

Y:

uwais:

A:

af:

Khalaf:

Y:

As-Soosiyy:

40.

\
47:18:6, p. 508

Qaaloon:

Wash:

41.

42.

43.

44.

45.

\
55:12:2, p. 531

\
57:10:30, p. 538

\
57:24:10, p. 540

\
55:78:4, p. 534

\
72:16:1, p. 573

\
72:20:1, p. 573

46.

\
91:15:1, p. 595

AJ:

As-Soosiyy:

Y:

Khalaf:

As-Soosiyy:

Khalaf:

K, Kh:

* Differences in writing words joined or separated are not considered in this list, they only affect pausing.
15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 32, 35, 38, 44.

writing closeness*:
M 45
Makkah
Madeenah N 45
Al-Imaam I 45
K 45
Koofah
B 45
Baah
Sh 45
Shaam

1.
2.
closest
B 33 I 32
I 34 B 31
B 40 K 36
I 36 B 35
I 40 K 35
N 28 I 17

3.
K
Sh
N
M
M
B

4.

29
28
34
29
33
14

N
M
M
N
N
M

5.
furthest average
27 Sh 12
26.6
27 K 25
29.0
32 Sh 17
31.8
25 Sh 8
26.6
31 Sh 14
30.6
12 K 8
15.8

* No. 45 and * (the one before it) were not counted.

big reading closeness*:

closest

Makkah

[M]

45

IK

Ibnu Katheer

IK

45

[M] 43 [B] 34 [I] 33 A 32 32 [K] 31 s 31 f 30 Sh 30 30 K

Madeenah

[N]

45

Aboo Jafa

AJ

45

[N] 44 N 44 [I] 33 A 31 [B] 30 s 30 I 30 f 29 Sh 29 29 [Sh] 29 H

Naafi

45

[N] 45 AJ 44 [I] 34 A 32 [B] 31 s 31 f 30 Sh 30 30 I 29 Kh 28 [Sh] 28 H

Al-Imaam

[I]

45

42 s 42 Sh 41 A 41 41 Kh 40 [B] 40 [K] 39 38 K 38 [N] 34 N

34 [M] 33 IK 33 AJ 33 I

Koofah

[K]

45

44 K 44 Kh 44 f 42 Sh 42 [I] 39 [B] 38 38 s 37 A 36 [M] 33 IK

31 [N] 28 N

27 AJ 26 [Sh] 12 I

12 H 11

af

45

Kh 43 [I] 42 [K] 42 Sh 41 41 K 41 [B] 39 39 s 38 A 37 [M] 31 [N] 31 IK 30 N

30 AJ 29 [Sh] 14 I

Shubah

Sh

45

Kh 43 [K] 42 [I] 41 f 41 41 K 41 s 40 A 39 39 [B] 38 [M] 30 IK

30 AJ 29 I

amzah

45

45 [K] 44 Kh 43 f 41 Sh 41 [I] 38 [B] 37 37 s 36 A 35 IK

30 [M] 29 [N] 27 N

26 AJ 25 [Sh] 10 I

10 H 9

Al-Kisaaiyy

45

45 [K] 44 Kh 43 f 41 Sh 41 [I] 38 [B] 37 37 s 36 A 35 IK

30 [M] 29 [N] 27 N

26 AJ 25 [Sh] 10 I

Khalaf

Kh

45

[K] 44 f 43 Sh 43 43 K 43 [I] 40 [B] 39 39 s 38 A 37 [M] 31 IK

30 [N] 29 N

28 AJ 27 [Sh] 12 I

Baah

[B]

45

44 44 s 43 [I] 40 f 39 Kh 39 [K] 38 Sh 38 37 K 37 [M] 34 IK

34 [N] 31 N

31 AJ 30 I

Aboo Am

45

[B] 44 s 44 43 [I] 41 Sh 39 f 37 Kh 37 [K] 36 35 K 35 [M] 32 IK

32 [N] 32 N

32 AJ 31 I

aw

45

[B] 44 s 44 A 43 [I] 41 f 39 Sh 39 Kh 39 [K] 38 37 K 37 [M] 32 IK

32 [N] 30 N

30 AJ 29 I

uwais

45

44 44 [B] 43 [I] 42 Sh 40 f 38 Kh 38 [K] 37 36 K 36 [M] 31 IK

31 [N] 31 N

31 AJ 30 I

Shaam

[Sh] 45

45 I 44 [N] 29 AJ 29 N 28 [I] 18 [B] 15 A 15 f 14 s 14 Sh 13 13 [M] 12 IK 12 [K] 12 Kh 12

Hishaam

45

[Sh] 45 I 44 [N] 29 AJ 29 N 28 [I] 18 [B] 15 A 15 s 14 f 13 Sh 13 13 [M] 12 IK 12 [K] 11 Kh 11

Ibnu akwaan I

45

[Sh] 44 H 44 [N] 30 AJ 30 N 29 [I] 19 [B] 16 A 16 s 15 f 14 Sh 14 14 [M] 13 IK 13 [K] 12 Kh 12

43 [B] 34 [I] 33 [K] 33 A 32 32 f 31 Kh 31 s 31 Sh 30

furthest
29 K

Maaaif Qiraaaat
total
average average average

29 [N] 28 N

27 AJ 26 I

13 [Sh] 12 H 12

28.0

28.2

28.1

30 Kh 30 [N] 28 N

27 AJ 26 I

13 [Sh] 12 H 12

30.2

26.9

28.0

45 AJ 44 [I] 34 A 32 f 31 [B] 31 s 31 Sh 30 30 I 30 Kh 29 [Sh] 29 H

29 [M] 28 IK 28 [K] 28

27 K 27

30.0

31.8

31.3

29 Kh 27 [M] 26 IK 26 [K] 26

25 K 25

31.3

29.5

30.1

26 K 26

32.0

30.1

30.7

19 [Sh] 18 H 18

32.8

35.4

34.7

30.0

33.4

32.4

14 H 13

33.2

33.0

33.1

14 [Sh] 13 H 13

32.3

33.3

33.0

30.8

31.5

31.3

10 H 9

30.8

31.5

31.3

12 H 11

32.5

32.8

32.7

16 [Sh] 15 H 15

31.6

34.4

33.6

16 [Sh] 15 H 15

33.3

33.0

33.1

14 [Sh] 13 H 13

33.0

33.0

33.0

15 [Sh] 14 H 14

33.0

33.1

33.1

10 K 10

17.2

19.9

19.2

9 K 9

21.7

17.5

18.9

10 K 10

22.3

18.4

19.7

28 [M] 27 IK 27 [K] 27

30 [N] 30 N

* ( 19, 22, 26, 27) was considered agreeing with both readings, even in the cases where it was only read as qul.

I: IK.
II : N, AJ.
I don't know whether group I and II could be combined () , they seem different.
III : K, , Kh, f, Sh.
IV : A, , s.
Group III and IV may or may not be combined () .
V: H, I.
Although group II and V seem different, there is some remarkable correspondence.