pvt WROERSN UBRARL Blackwell Companions to Philosophy ‘stan san woe es mu wer een te een oon ct ons rset bce we ad yt a weer tut anne ecapuumdnarte |? fgepamumiadn te rgmencenar |= | ageeaterae me |) roomate tetany ae | 12 camasion wo Gnnent 4 nemo ie se ad ae ee | ‘ibe shear saccqnimicmunen | RaTEnt Tae a sure" soak mes | se acomemin cpt sae sangumsdase 1 fp kao Par Sue ps \ ‘LGeTitntanenetmes sm | 1g Cmgain wie aie ‘gauges erent | Ear eee Blackwell Companions to Philosophy A Companion to Business Ethics Edited by ROBERT E. FREDERICK Bentley College BStAckweltony © cr Pe a 199 tyra nr esc metas ee ‘eke men yen noes hn nd “ere ea coe Rabe eh al mgs pe RRESHSRE CRT me Narcan gue ree easton sit ie Beh ey retin 10819 Pann Foodie “stk ten i Contents ist of Cotrbtors 1A Kantian approach to business eles 2. ularenion and basnee thee 4 Social contac approaches to buries thes Uridine "snag sa re thes andthe pragma tite 7 Tenis theory and business thes 1 - snes ethice na fee sity 9 Nature snd busine tice| 1 | AKantian approach to business ethios* NORMAN BOWIE hn mnt ry yn en ic igo eo fe wth {ott sosong tiene wa gyno slg Kaa ‘Doth tht kant name en ee be een 1987 are ‘oro publ bck ht yeaa Kt chy oases em ‘er Bont (199) fl hs op) Kat et known ded eon he “eet psn" wth ipsa en sts et ut vt pr wth ep a thre ich mre» Xa po ‘er eer ha hs nhs ay eas on We ke et as ar ‘pe bent owing sme fh ests Kant eens Ute fonhient pale fe, en dw hy Kasco te pty (fen tnten nti meal cd pole are Kn ory oe | eal ole wha el dcuon of Kan emeplan snd nc [Sat mth ect tie sop bes ret iy tn ott nl hep met [Thies ne ese ly eek nr i onan (rinse fda weds oarbon nee sen ca oro Caan ae a ce ue Wen el en ne ets Pee pi one 37-00 aern, Wisc a, eta o a han a he ry tne we? a insite Ye eats Ome ‘dunes ne eh eee snes eine NS MH, a tome ears any o 0 rae sc cd 2 encogin ta et ie Be mip went = Sy Te at ‘pero ie aon anno parce iso CS a enim neh enh coal ‘Sond sums aiden meen wth ansene rates toi ou ee 1 cteny on ans whi you con wie sie 1 Aco ay ra peso oc 2 ey wee tebe 2 il 8 Sabie nd over tem ety ce Be ne a mn coin ar a nn ne be mse ec Om Et ie w SE Inge apes Lm sy. ey, hese “the self defeating nature of imaoral actions Eons seman te con rae 2A shi ca a Ur tein an pana, al ‘eter ten we 8 sn at wut bnpenthe cle no weetmeyene acto) Wont te (coe come a to te nyo hat ai on octane ing oni feet ey ath no son ri a ca Kt 990, 1) meer ene cali” ai sell tee aan bo a your acta ee a ‘Sins honey at le oe ‘eal den pte ei pe ee ct ae ‘om tee trp here ido wpe ‘Brewin ae ny man we ey ae ers mae eke wh Ko sa eH ot si eee ae semi the ogo wu fe Be ato hye Rather Kat ‘regia even rating remiss ane Th te grea pera oc et ee pin) qe th an acon svar oral prme The acne bet ‘Eon te pn oa wich he an lps he ot eae Sea: Ahab ange who asp ann ety mol a {fre dc dete pte ih Scns nl sh ea he Scapa tan te uly ha eae inter. a ma Tit Cost ther cmp Mie ak. ey enoe imam aces ae pen tata Spee i sh eape arte bs rons ut een sna sagan Col fem whch pened selng be nr tcl nt Dose rod | ice ae io tted spr a wl cbc cre nga he |) Eisen scatter tos dct ram at etd eee ee | over, ee cont eno pee propery. everyone mer eke Fok | ecyae then sig soul be ome Ge the rca ast we | Seeaternte rpc cnt nmin nt rm cg onto e Tic pps wes os itn te ay one ad exces, Sn at he aga a ke i ee feats poet, then aaa hat pemnd ealng won he = 9 Hower ite wong wc abou aww wb is pit opty. So Kat au ale. ee er 196 9B) or i in ies a’ Tet rpg that te pai pat oy Ut pened eat wa egal cacy aleesci ere ts mit see ong property weal be selena ‘ecg te rn er ier tn pepe ec ae | Cra wn et een te melt { ‘reticent es tennis mr eos cn eam ee cok sean et ac es eects ea are tie ‘ome era ea nee crn sien f4 0, eT ers ame non ret ea sey ad yas dt ai “Thus the categorical pectin captures one of the key fares of mara i crete i gaara sate Cee eee enna emtr ey bln cecal genera am ‘ihe tones tn sn a Rene Seemann om 5 yhe inn in Ocenn Cy, Maryan my favre soo one had arg eae ge ath sie ee ne me Siento prem i co ae Shomctlfarar uraunmrr sna Senet cecn Teenage setter emgeranaea nen pet eae sa sat own ett hnde te a + ay, encase reagan | ‘alg Kang mth the Cine ave egal erp hres se ‘Somat hve pled ea ong Kang Ko developed el Sem that ‘Sloat bn ores ded thr dence ice Tha pi Inotone fas ama reae raethe wie oalesrcert t as ‘rn desde ened an Hen Kang sare ing ees ‘a cet bts eas” A Kanan wor gree wih he eo ep lig ong woulda premise stanng comme tern os {lle ene. ‘te pte or dt srt Kans oo wl By that ea hse mises showing hat wo cers rst of rally ee, etal ‘Say ho han ee nt ole eee oe ee. Tedeve ‘Semlping stk akties company espns wo at pve ure intr shot de compos Ars Kanan weal xp, invests me ot fehcnang eye companies cing eta nrg, Bry LP ed atom wer aba tat su ee Tecan ee then aster and ens ol he sr ew tomo Ee Isotir fms te mareansto the punt wha eR sock at At Toe Mach 2,107 Bs Wes era tht Rasa ok ake sarap 127% 1996 and a ety aed 658 thi 1997. (Se ete Rainn sc mrt as plenged. Howe he rst one cinta with th arate) “tv oolong weer the wees amen “gras acoa nen uve sedge he conte! te “fea Tt Kat's nace po. Aad when encuhpaleehae "aban carte pects ibe checks et ce min tgs hve Ge wil and tho ae aie ot orn as outed by Nant ard thy tae dg r= tle eon poe Te nan cena nan nyt i i a ar a ners Tse eh ants cond olan hector pert: Ales et ya pron a od sd nee ara meaty What ae splot is orale ote etre pera rans Bef sale tout ha ret rn” pene a bal al Byes coal nso, No oe wel maaan 9 A seam eater yuri toe Wha ths oan inert ds ost patnme cna thet oerego oe en man cn an een tl Rec of ae ea. och rt et em ee nie ‘et perce et te es em omen ae Eee oc a yea ine tn ne owe, sly ening on eso Sc at mil re et yt ee, tener i Af sree NT Xan Pe a epg cowie asl OS SS a ema on Seong dno he sy oa ene an eget age Pn oa at psi 2 Si ieynatect ce ons oe sn at ne pies db red a 8 ann wd mre eet hai a pi, The eaten aie ol Reece ee ire at ee a on ep cone a ema Mt cate 3 md 190 Ar eyo mone? aed sae, leet ane ae wea Howe tt mere Kt erect Fann we pe emg asay sag WY OESS her cave cee em ate see sere ner cnn mee al ibe OE Gf ny tn of ese pang eget wo at eran 8s ee by tami he se teas of wt oO ‘ean hep inate amet een management a ‘nh cna ot htm he ae eee ‘Ses ia tin, nara ‘siete imi my bao ao. "tesa mo nan mon ns hc ge ot sine peice Sch ee weer eco Une pn bck apenen copes ea ‘Staal ne shou cmp ona ep eae hoe ‘ena eppercnvcce lap wi cet fpr seen. ee es mi ha dng Sivonsotnph tone st mine i. hs anced otras tern 9 ‘headin pte oak msg Swarr tent masa oes le rr cht | Msmer and dept: nae pnts mage. ann aes ston at Esato oreo See cee earaniomntereerrd piace cigmistintcetass era sear igarimsotcmasars Sat inet a i sos snap en log edn gl east th at ot ‘eer wt ze.sail onan nowt | aetna oes ori fhe are ent ese ot Ue utzon ak aay of tat ing a a ees Fn exci genes ao roi ws We else fe the work’ es i a ert earl aac 8 1 Sir that melee pe at he ote oman bee a hy Pat eek ee open ane ‘ent nn etc so ches lee nt ‘aug ing gan ome manage at ois see a gegen tu Thay Ean ae erp hdc a Kain i scot he td man enrtmnemeteny seep re a carn ur secon ncn cee orl een eran Tenn vetnaestae-osiis 1 ee ee he acy te emule wd tes ie tn sal aa ese thy 5 ae aa ai ene oe toto ke et When tn he nd nt bros cate aa ee ny one a ee ee ener yeeamtvh et + Stace aoe el ee ay unc: a Sean ssa at gta diy es Bene es eh poses ed 0 eats oc eb ese coh ee ones toe roan cs i un heraoalr ast thse prin can be ed ors th lao orKants stacey pee Rei ke ale ee bean oma ry the as ptr pero ony nce os kr ama wert rpc oss ope 2 equ Prince 3 ong a one hel [Smer cnn b dsion asic mr i, The ttn pa ‘Spb on ssn ni spre gaton lbeneene wh mt ett eM of Marae There a (199% p52 ss tec lt th se ir it gta Sestak nh wish mete au “ ‘eset hr oes ti aut othe creat ee Mf sorpetns [ebro xy they hae ty co sy tn Aad epost teens Soy pcs args rig the nas ‘Siang bss orcs ore tena ih lows the corer thao anon ~wuh ox os ten eos ple and re ron a fetags mot pa anol wer rs wis a elo tes ‘Eucla pv lta pratt Fer weal creat aes fhe fille ote bens aly oie? uprated Teeth rah ptt ops conte ot ae prince hse Rainn views anoint mal omy, Fach ember ath rg fens cena ates Ocean St 3 je sa eet ean i al i eres eat. On rote: ch re sus rel Ketan oral o> ah ven the ori eras pars stealth stn angle Ogee ata a So coun a oe end Anadis enon wh ne th ata ups os marl Bm et ak iti etry. ug as, betsy Y eo aan ue daha cy Xv ido ten oy hry ¥ ere pent hy cso (960) cy X aed at Eivraes roe srs oar copra. ue he poe: ist nara let ad aw 9 eae Alles ween ese yc reso esr oan mane cel s heny Fos ty ess vn i ny an se deere they andy bree icy oe calle ran tat oe no bela ty ated etl ncaa mh hoy Xone Win teeery peta conway Ts ec ee th i nh oe wk era cn ae te wae ote a sete mi ti ar teh op beeen dint ora Geto ans st ine he te ea oc, ale 2 te aban ale cps sales rl ‘i reo arc at ee “erent, 2S “atin ere pis a. men min cee al mm en ns a a een Kean mel DoD TESS OS a ee En oe ea ner poe mt we ee ch grate wi se me wk let ns Megara rssh a crite Sesh pel airerttrotaowenie om ane geri che ts ty tia “nee tee ochre pe, ee ar bums Seaencene tain moe ee isa srt tba ch ro a cman a mY settee wo es Kant i ae te iano al azn sna Bt "Ponce, asi cm sey uy cou neon ann unent en f ‘esta a Kaban ee tht ie E ae rth sina sie ‘the purity of motive ; ecear oxotno mere aio tat at on a el eon cet eee iret ance ti Mt need corps) Se eg ee ee rns wt Cl sree run, op. A dst ‘arcu yen tore win ty iy or neo poet it aa Sse ees seo er sin ene al enn wi yt vatainmectvede ‘Went teresa "Sh nett me ry te ens meh ty no mn saunter ty etl ‘hee iin il ngs ete weet ve sc fe cay pt of het hat | ior ean itn, — = atalino eet otis ir tcl ee tery a ah tr Pel apes ae nan ee te, ta {Sd nnd cosh pe kwon te eet set tit capa oh opiate re peed Sn ptt thin of eet cow rac oe eee Sac kane ere Cope eg oo rece cinf rete Tn ats Eero, See te cheer teenie nde eon nce | Giisbncniocte het be =o | Seite ane bee os thet ston 5 patna tbr races ie pat oe Freee trerr tare ve conteitn ome sens ea Fees tart icons ots noes he oa sacl tbr coe onc wt ce eae Ganon i al nl cance the le tec nvr, ca ns rot sae cen rt nti str io Kans rl hbo ales, we cn he ety So ans com ci ovis atinvorrei hanen commas canting USES CES | ha oo oe a) Nr be ce Hat ml ed 0 wre 1 wb, ncn em isn wae TY ‘ere ome ws a's oy me ype a ae carne tat aan bcc 1 ay em ES a LS caren Eee eden yn rat Pl Be a er te a ct nun mT a eS Fre a a bn ae “ers ey oe scm tng as a ica ca me eta es tenn iat SMG em rl et SN sec He pet sense pe we es SY So ns ote we en peta by were unin “sin ta spre oss a AS i lager rc ey ee ed abet ek eM whi a ut rf 9 et time PS te onset ee ne hs lk a adres oe ng hy oo bw sit eh cto ting osha et ates nS | nie wel acne We Con * SN une ty cl are et he ee ny be a set ey xe a ee eet a ios iat 18 i.e, ecm ia nes, cs com ea gm oer ae aot Nee, ay one pate cement Ko i ea ny uc gener nM POE SS Le ea te we An of ae ner sng ibe canteen, a ely nL 07 a ‘emer anes in toy oe sens! et ee Oa Seta, Tren cons aetna A samen a nn enon STEEL en a cy rel alco We a a ed one oon Beko son eer ioe nhs Ene rb cme ie Speenennsintine ete nts gs cn onl cad sm ih ov iy ey, Si aimee a ‘Senmn v Hk Suc ewe re inte Se 5 Gra 5 let ha cero ee Si el on ma oy Oo bey Sant cost at opal ctr ma eo ty wpe soe urea Sch rps wu on tig Sic ce nt at ts ae as evr n W hth tat ne spas wd re etna hd Sh iia on ar een vi uo Sar Kat «patina ni fcc coe pomeg rar dat oem ne See reed See sy dh eh ts a Bee eae Ric Sare win ge Seiecctareeenrnniareer st eens anette sa es ny sng ad fn Nato St tg he ntti i canst ne eres samarcmaree sone ‘eet ont ane py none ntosp rl ig font a in ae ne ef ee coms we oT Fe one ga abe hi otter on Saal ce eu, yeh es am pe lms ee a mo foetuses eso ut 2 | | Utilitarianism and business ethics MILTON SNOYENBOS AND JAMES HUMBER neferences| et "eat ei "we eae Ea ee am Hr 705) Te Toe oe mc is en. mec sa 96 en Yt tet Pe oa gy yen ew Ke come Tar emp 196 ra No a Be ya Me air pera ane c pc nig a oe an ri nti Mae | ie. sro mains SN x mans ‘et ad te es mie ‘ce tes diester et thar in eh coven Tarik crustal ory el hear ease seo wher human cose gh er won ame ecm lutintan nt iheneroemgneerind aly ea {Srey ety sn Sate heat Forel ee a ose {eyo cl nt cs ya en my athe tare en {om aman el ol cn a at wan wrong bc ae a once tert vn tata ne ese ake ee ret | feria tau oreo in her tt ah or wn ore lat "tes trig» mie who meng pnts oy on he act ea | Suen The ts bind lt Ct we sb et oe | Beenie wie tent so dows mt eng batt st cones OF uy te abt what wermeaa yt sequins tbe st nr ay sos beats aso mae ee be ews sn wh cme on ptr an the er pe WOU aye rae ei ond th lier a ou. tat eee Morton tear. Ag at te one of ws creer eds theo th sp i, we oul cons eee els eles tare rand ee ter an te er Mt mans yy a only tl fn ohm listing rooney heat neonate eet ect ar sling fos ty ase sco ew abe Ay thant arti eat cate eho te tina