Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Comparison Between Suppressing Approaches of Very Fast Transients in GIS PDF
Comparison Between Suppressing Approaches of Very Fast Transients in GIS PDF
1, JANUARY 2013
303
AbstractIn this paper, first transient waves in the gas-insulated substation (GIS) are analyzed and methods for suppression
of very fast transients (VFTs) in GISs are introduced. For suppressing VFTs, four methods are presented, including suppression
by terminal components, capacitance components, adopting a resistor-fitted disconnector, and ferromagnetic rings. Finally, these
approaches are compared with each other. These methods can be
divided into two groups. The first group contains the methods (such
as terminal components and reconfiguration) that can be used after
installation of the GIS and during the operation of the GIS. The
second group contains the methods (such as the resistor-fitted disconnector and ferromagnetic rings) that must be used as an extra
limitation before installation and during the design of the GIS. Advantages of the first group are simplicity and the low cost of implementation along with producing minimal changes in the installed
GIS. The main advantage of the second group is estimation of all
factors during the design of the GIS. Finally, the best approach for
the suppression of VFTs is chosen based on the criteria of the transient waves and feasibility.
Index TermsGas-insulated substation (GIS), suppression of
very fast transient (VFT), switching, VFT.
I. INTRODUCTION
304
TABLE I
ELECTRICAL EQUIVALENT PARAMETERS OF GIS COMPONENTS [12], [14]
the load side) [12][14]. This has been simulated in the present
study.
During the closing operation of switches, the sparks are modeled by a fixed resistance in series with an exponentially decreasing resistance [12][14]
(5)
is taken as
is 1 ns, and
0.5 .
where
Computer simulation has been performed using the Alternative Transients Program (ATP), a widely used version of the
Electromagnetic Transients Program (EMTP). The simulation
of exponentially decreasing resistance has been calculated using
transient analog control systems (TACS) and modeled in ATP/
EMTP. The fast Fourier transform (FFT) technique is used to
produce the frequency spectra from the time-domain current
waveforms. The simulation time step has been set as 0.1 ns.
III. SUPPRESSION OF VFTS
Several factors may contribute to transformer failure due to
VFTO, including:
peak magnitude of the overvoltage;
nonlinear voltage distribution along the winding, which
could result in high voltage (HV) between turns;
resonance or partial winding resonance in the HV winding
if these coincide with the excitation frequencies [4], [5].
According to the factors mentioned before, the main purpose of
this paper is the mitigation of VFTO according to the following
criteria:
decreasing the peak voltage;
decreasing the maximum voltage change;
decreasing the maximum rate of rise of the overvoltage;
decreasing the predominant frequencies amplitude.
The transient electromagnetic fields, in turn, leak out into the
external environment through discontinuities and become coupled to the control equipment or data cables present in the GIS.
305
Fig. 2. Magnitude waveform of the VFTO at the power transformer for different source-side terminals.
Fig. 3. Variation of the peak magnitude of the VFTO with the length for a
different source side terminal at the power transformer.
Fig. 4. Frequency spectra of the VFTO at the power transformer for the different source-side terminal.
the voltage amplitude for a 30-m GIL terminal is (53 kV) higher
than the amplitude of a 3-m cable (27 kV). Similarly, for the
frequency of 1.83 MHz, a voltage amplitude of the 30-m GIL
terminal is 50 kV. The VFT magnitude for this type of terminal
is noticeably lower in comparison with a 10-m cable terminal,
which is 80 kV.
Assuming that the resonant frequencies in the power transformers are around 6 MHz [15], the frequency spectra of the
VFTOs from 4.2 to 6.4 MHz for different terminals at the power
transformer have been simulated and displayed in Fig. 5. An inspection of Fig. 5 reveals that the frequency amplitude of 5.1
MHz on the 10-m GIL terminal is minimized and on the 3-m
cable terminal, it is maximized. On the other hand, for a 3-m
306
Fig. 5. Frequency spectra of the VFTO from 4.2 to 6.4 MHz for the different
source-side terminal at the power transformer.
cable, the frequency amplitude of 5.4 MHz is the lowest compared to the other terminal components. The frequency amplitude of 5.7 MHz, on the 30-m cable side, has maximum value
but the 30-m GIL has the minimum value. This suggests that the
resonant frequency amplitude can be mitigated by replacing the
suitable terminal.
It should be noted that changing the terminal component can
decrease the amplitude of a specific frequency and, at the same
time, increase the amplitude of another frequency. Hence, one
can conclude that no specific terminal exists which can definitely decrease the amplitudes of all frequencies. Therefore, the
resonance frequency of GIS power transformers should already
be determined to choose the sufficient terminal component.
Referring to the aforementioned issues, the 30-m cable generates the lowest voltage for both side terminals (load and source
terminals). Also, the 30-m cable terminal has the lowest frequency amplitudes compared with other terminals.
As a conclusion for this case study, among the suggested terminals, the 30-m cable would result in the lowest voltage for
both source- and load-side terminal components. Also, utilizing
this terminal decreases the magnitude of the frequency components to the lowest value among the different terminals. By
using 30-m cable in the load side, the magnitude of the frequency components will be further reduced in comparison with
the source side.
B. Suppression of VFT via Capacitor Components
The extra capacitance components can damp the VFT waveforms front at transformer terminals and improve the VFT distribution along the transformer windings. It is also helpful for
absorbing the sharp spikes of the VFT since surge arresters do
not act quickly enough to prevent steep fronted switching transients. Therefore, installing an additional surge capacitor at the
transformer HV terminal is highly useful to mitigate the effects
of VFTs. However, a surge capacitor paralleled with the surge
arrester may be used as a wave modifier [16].
Fig. 6 describes the influence of high capacitance components
on the VFTO and VFTC. Clearly, by gradually increasing the capacitance, the VFTO, which has been caused by DS restriking,
Fig. 7. Frequency spectra of the VFTO for the different capacitances at the
power transformer.
307
Fig. 8. Frequency spectra of the VFTO from 4.2 to 6.4 MHz for the different
capacitances at the power transformer.
has the capacitance of around 0.2 nF, can help to achieve the
optimum point for this case study.
Fig. 9 shows the influence of high capacitance components on
the frequency contents of VFTC. As can be seen in this figure,
the increment of the capacitance does not have any influence on
the high-frequency components.
In the studied case, in order to decrease the VFT at the power
transformer, the application of surge capacitors is a feasible alternative due to space limitation and cost, if the suitable capacitance value is selected. Due to the impracticality of adding capacitance in HV systems, the CCVT is utilized instead of PT. As
an alternative solution, an extra surge arrester can be installed
close to the switching terminal.
C. Suppression of VFT by Adopting a Resistor-Fitted
Disconnector
The resistor-fitted disconnector is designed to connect a resistor in series with the circuit in the event of restriking, having
no mechanical contacts to connect the resistor, only a movable
electrode [7]. The resistor-fitted disconnector decreases the amplitude of VFTO and VFTC.
This solution is known to be used in practice for solving the
VFT problem as opposed to some methods that are still at the
experimental stage. However, this solution has problems due to
space limitations and cost. Also, it is not suitable for installed
GISs (which are currently under operation) due to maximum
changes and costs involved in GISs.
Fig. 11. Measurements (the left-hand side graphs: experimental [9]) at the end
of the busbar. (a) Without ferromagnetic rings. (b) With ferromagnetic rings.
308
Fig. 12. Waveform of the VFTO at the power transformer for the different suppressive methods of VFTO.
Fig. 13. Frequency spectra of the VFTO for different suppressive methods of
VFTO.
Fig. 14. Frequency spectra of the VFTO from 4 to 7 MHz for the different
suppressive methods of VFTO.
Fig. 15. Waveform of the VFTO at the power transformer for the different suppressive methods of VFTO.
Fig. 16. Frequency spectra of the VFTC for the different suppressive methods
of VFTC.
309
[11] V. V. Kumar, J. T. M., and M. S. Naidu, Influence of switching conditions on the VFTO magnitudes in a GIS, IEEE Trans. Power Del.,
vol. 16, no. 4, pp. 539544, Oct. 2001.
[12] D. Povh et al., Modeling and analysis guidelines for very fast transients, IEEE Power Eng. Rev., vol. 17, no. 13, pp. 7171, Oct. 1996.
[13] Z. Haznadar et al., More accurate modeling of gas insulated substation
components in digital simulations of very fast electromagnetic transients, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 434441, Jan. 1992.
[14] D. Xuzhu et al., Transients at GSU transformer terminals. I. Historical
case analysis, in Proc. IEEE Power Eng. Soc. Winter Meeting, 2001,
vol. 1, pp. 312317.
[15] L. Guishu, S. Haifing, Z. Xile, and C. Xiang, Modeling of transformer
windings under very fast transient overvoltages, IEEE Trans. Electromagn. Compat., vol. 48, no. 4, pp. 621627, Nov. 2006.
[16] A. Greenwood, Electrical Transients in Power Systems, 2nd ed. New
York: Wiley, 1991.
[17] J. Lijun et al., Estimating the size of ferrite for suppressing VFTO
in GIS, in Proc. 8th Int. Conf. Prop. Appl. Dielect. Mater., 2006, pp.
388391.
Ahmad Tavakoli was born in Esfahan, Iran, in 1985.
He received the M.Eng. degree in power systems
from the University of Science and Technology,
Tehran, Iran, and is currently pursuing the Ph.D.
degree in power engineering and computational
intelligence at the University of Tasmania, Hobart,
Australia.
His research interests include smart grids, power
quality, renewable energy, optimization and modeling, high-frequency modeling, power systems
protection, electrical transients in power systems,
and electromagnetic interference/electromagnetic compatibility.
Ahmad Gholami is an Associate Professor of Electrical Engineering at the University of Science and
Technology, Tehran, Iran.
His current research interests are power systems,
high-voltage systems, and isolators.
REFERENCES
[1] H. Elahi et al., Lightning overvoltage protection of the paddock
362-145 kV gas-insulated substation, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol.
5, no. 1, pp. 144150, Jan. 1990.
[2] J. Meppelink et al., Very fast transients in GIS, IEEE Trans. Power
Del., , vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 223233, Jan. 1989.
[3] J. A. Martinez, Statistical assessment of very fast transient overvoltages in gas insulated substations, in Proc. IEEE Power Eng. Soc.
Summer Meeting, 2000, vol. 2, pp. 882883.
[4] M. M. Rao et al., Frequency characteristics of very fast transient currents in a 245-kV GIS, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 20, no. 4, pp.
24502457, Oct. 2005.
[5] A. M. Miri and Z. Stojkovic, Transient electromagnetic phenomena
in the secondary circuits of voltage and current transformers in GIS
(measurements and calculations), IEEE Power Eng. Rev., vol. 21, no.
7, p. 68, Jul. 2001.
[6] M. Mohana Rao et al., Electromagnetic field emission from gas-to-air
bushing in a GIS during switching operations, IEEE Trans. Electromagn. Compat., vol. 49, no. 2, pp. 313321, May 2007.
[7] D. Xuzhu, S. Rosado, L. Yilu, W. Nien-Chung, E.-L. Line, and G.
Tzong-Yih, Study of abnormal electrical phenomena effects on GSU
transformers, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 18, no. 3, pp. 835842,
Jul. 2003.
[8] L. Qingmin and W. Minglei, Simulation method for the applications
of ferromagnetic materials in suppressing high-frequency transients
within GIS, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 22, no. 3, pp. 16281632,
Jul. 2007.
[9] L. Jin et al., Characteristic parameter analysis on the suppressing
VFTO in GIS by ferrite, in , Proc. Int. Symp. Elect. Insul. Mater.,
2005, vol. 3, pp. 825828.
[10] Y. Yamagata et al., Suppression of VFT in 1100 kV GIS by adopting
resistor-fitted disconnector, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 11, no. 2,
pp. 872880, Apr. 1996.
310