after paying indemnity; OR

2. Oblige BP to pay price of the

land except if its value is
considerably greater than the
building etc., in which case BP
shall pay reasonable rent, and
oblige S to pay proper rent (ART.
448)
Good Faith
1. Acquire improvements w/o
paying (ART. 449); OR
2. Order demolition or removal of
the improvements (ART. 450);
OR
3. Compel BP to pay price of the
land, regardless of its value, or
S to pay proper rent.
*In all case, collect damages (ART.
451) AND reimburse BPS for
preserving the land (ART. 452)
Bad faith
Indemnify BPS for improvements
AND pay damages (ART. 454; ART
447 by analogy)

B has the right to retain until paid

and cannot be required to pay
rent; OR
2. BP pay price of the land (or pay
reasonable rent) and S pay proper
rent.
Bad faith
1. Lose improvements w/o being
indemnified; OR
2. Remove the improvements;
OR
3. BP pay the price of the land S
pay proper rent.
* In all cases, pay damages AND
recover reimbursement for
preservation of the land.

Good Faith
1. Receive indemnity for
improvements AND receive
damages; OR
2. Remove them in any event AND
receive damages.
Bad faith
Bad faith
As though both acted in good faith (in pari delicto) (ART. 453)