You are on page 1of 15

<fjUhg_UfYj]^UnUfY\UV]`]hUW]^g_U]ghfU ]jUb^U&$$+ Jc`(' Vf"% ghf"(+!

*%

?DL7B?:?J;JKE8?J;B@???PLEH?FE:HA;
P:H7LA7B;KJ7H"7D7J7C8KA'

Df]a`^Ybc.%$"g]^YUb^&$$+"

=njcfb]nbUbghjYb]fUX

Df]\jUYbc.%*"hfUjUb^&$$+"

I8?.'+*"&

 HWZi[XWl__dlWb_Z_j[jeckeX_j[b`_j[\ehcWbd_c_d[\ehcWbd_ceXb_Y_cWfeZha[$KkleZdecZ_`[bkfh_aWpWd_ik
h[pkbjWj_d[a_^ZecW_^_ijhWd_^_ijhW_lWd`W_dlWb_Z_j[jWkeX_j[b`_"kbe][heZ_j[b`W_iWc_^eieXWi_dlWb_Z_j[jec_lWdeij
feZha[$ K hWZk i[ WdWb_p_hW`k h[pkbjWj_ fhel[Z[de] _ijhW_lWd`W k ae`[c `[ ikZ`[belWbe -'& _if_jWd_aW *,. eieXW i
_dlWb_Z_j[jec_(*(heZ_j[b`WeieXWi_dlWb_Z_j[jec$Fh_]eZd_kpehWaiW_d`WlWb_ik_if_jWd_Y__pY_`[b[>hlWjia[$?ijhW_lWde
`[  d`_^ele  [ceY_edWbde ijWd`["  jae _c il[ fhkW fejh[Xdk feZhak" i a_c hWp]elWhW`k e ile`_c fheXb[c_cW _ ]Z`[
fhedWbWp[_lejdkidW]k$H[pkbjWj__ijhW_lWd`WfeaWpWb_ikZWeX_j[b`_dW`[[fhWj_pWXh_dkjeij"dWf[jeijj[[ceY_edWbdW
_ijhe[deij$HeZ_j[b`_ikWdai_epd_`_eZiWc_^eieXWi_dlWb_Z_j[jec$Fep_j_ld[[ceY_`["aWeje`[pWZeleb`ijle"fh_ikjd[ik
aeZbWdelWeX_j[b`_eieXWi_dlWb_Z_j[jec"Wd[je[[aeZiWc_^eieXWi_dlWb_Z_j[jec$DW[d[ikijWj_ij_a_pdWW`d[
hWpb_a[_pc[k[ceY_edWbde]ijWd`WheZ_j[b`W_eieXWi_dlWb_Z_j[jec$EX`[]hkf[_if_jWd_aWZeX_lW`kd[\ehcWbd[eXb_a[
feZha[eZbWdelWeX_j[b`__fh_`Wj[b`W$HeZ_j[b`_fh_cW`kdW`l_[feZha[eZZ`[Y[_ikfhkd_aW"WeieX[i_dlWb_Z_j[jeceZ
heZ_j[b`W_ikfhkd_aW$<ehcWbd_eXb_Y_feZha[ikibWX__d[Zeleb`d_$
@a_jcZg^_Z^/_dlWb_Z_j[jkeX_j[b`_"heZ_j[b`_"eieX[i_dlWb_Z_j[jec"[ceY_edWbdeijWd`["\ehcWbdW_d[\ehcWbdWfeZhaW

KLE:

[U ]bZcfa]fUbcgh]fcX]hY`^U ]hX"
FcX]hY`^] i dfcWYgi df]`U[cXVY bU Vc`Ygh fUn!
a]`^U^icViXibcgh]X^YhYhU"8c`Un]Xcdfca^Y!
bU UbU^ic`^]j]^U^YfY_cbghfi_W]^Ug`]_YcX^YhYhi
_c^Y  ]aU ]bjU`]X]hYh" G h]a ^Y iXfi Yb jY`]_]
ghfU\ ^Yfgidcg`^YX]WY_c^YgUgcVcabcg]bcjc
ghUb^YVc`Ygh]bYdcnbUb]WU"Dfca^YbYibU]bibU
_c^] fcX]hY`^] dYfW]d]fU^i gjc^Y X]^YhY cj]g]h Y ]
cfYU_W]^UaUX^YhYhU _Uc]_cbghfi_h]aU_c^Ygi
fcX]hY`^] ]aU`] c b^Yai df]^Y dc^UjY ]bjU`]X]hYhU"
BY_Y gY dfYXcX VY bYY dfca]^Yb]h]  U gjU_]
fcX]hY`^ fYU[]fU bU gjc^ bU]b" BU^YY  Vf]bi
nVc[ gfYY X^YhYhU ] dcgYVbc hY_c df]\jUU^i
hfd`^Yb^Y Vc`cjU  h^Y`Ygb] ]`] XiYjb] bYXcghUhU_ 
]`]c[fUb]Ybcghg`cVcXY]nVcfU"Cb]fcX]hY`^]_c^]
gaUhfU^igjc^YX]^YhYgUjfYb]aV]hYdf]g]`^Yb]bU
jY`]_Ydfca^YbY"?U_Uj[cX^Y]bjU`]X]hYhid]hU!
b^i bU^jYinUVf]bihcgh]nUn]jU^id]hUb^U_c^UgY
h]iViXibcgh] UbYgUXUb^cgh]"FcX]hY`^]ac[i
fYU[]fUh] bU fUn`]]hY bU]bY ] cg^YUh] gY Yghc
YacW]cbU`bc]ghfcYbc]nUVf]bihcnUgjc^YX]^YhY
_c^Y]aUbY_]]bjU`]X]hYhhYginVc[hc[U]bYgfYh!
b] bYfjcnb] `^ih]]bUdYh]"I`^iXg_c^df]fcX]^YXU
gYbUbYdcnbUhY]Vc`bYdc^UjYfYU[]fUbY[Uh]jbc"
@]hYfUhifU dc_Uni^Y XU gi dfjY fYU_W]^Y fcX]hY`^U

DcfYaYU^ bcfaU`bY ]jchbY gjU_cXbYjb]WY 


VYncVn]fUbUhc_c^]ai^Yinfc_ ij]^Y_^YhY U_ 
U dc[chcjc U_c Xc b^Y[U XcY ig`]^YX hY_Y ]
Xi[chfU^bY Vc`Ygh] bY_c[ `UbU cV]hY`^]" ?U_c
hUXU gUijUh] gbU[i cV]hY`^]3 ?U_c gY bcg]h] g
ZfighfUW]^UaU  `^ihb^ca  c[cfYbci  bYg][ifbc!
i  ghfU\ca ] hi[ca _UXU gY i cV]hY`^] Xc[cX]
]bjU`]X]hYh3
GjU_cXbYjbU ]g_ighjU ] fYni`hUh] ]ghfU ]jUb^U
i_Uni^ibUa_U_cgYcV]hY`^]fUn`]_i^iidf]`U[cX!
V]8YbcbU %---"?UchcgicV]hY`^]gdYW]Z]bY
] fUn`]]hY df]Y nU gYVY  hU_c gY ] gjU_U cgcVU
g]bjU`]X]hYhcadf]`]bcfUn`]_i^Y^YXbUcXXfi[Y
dU aU_Uf gY cbY bU`Un]`Y i ]ghc^ X]^U[bcgh]_c^
g_id]b];fYYbgdUbK]YXYf &$$'"
?U_cYgYcV]hY`^bcg]h]g]bjU`]X]hYhcacj]g]c
j]YfUnbc`]_]\]b]hY`^U.cgcVbcgh]fcX]hY`^U jfgh]
] ghidb^i ]bjU`]X]hYhU cgcVY  jfYaYbi bUghUb_U
]bjU`]X]hYhU fcX]hY`^g_]acY_]jUb^]aU cXbcg]aU
ibihUfcV]hY`^] Y_cbcag_]a]gcW]^U`b]adf]`]_U!
aUcV]hY`^] ghidb^icVfUncjUb^U`UbcjUcV]hY`^] 
_jU`]hYh]]Xcghidbcgh]ghfibYdcXf_Y _i`hifbca
a]`^YicV]hY`^] dcac]fcXV]bY df]^UhY`^U]iXfi!
'

IjkZ_`ia_Y[djWhieY_`Wbde]hWZWFhWlde]\Wakbj[jWIl[k_b_jWkPW]h[Xk
*-

NXfUj_U@YihUf 5bUhUaVi_.=bjU`]X]hYhicV]hY`^]]]njcf]dcXf_Y

X]^YhY]a^YVc`Ygbc VfU_i_f]n] cg^YU^igYigU!


a`^Ybc U`]cVc^YgidfYj]Yinfi^Ub]XUdcX^Y`Y
gjc^U Vc`bU cg^YUb^U ^YXbc g Xfi[]a" U_ ]
fcX]hY`^]aU_c^]gibUi]`]aYigcVbcX]^Y`]h]dfc!
V`YaY]chjcfYbcfUn[cjUfUh]cb^]aU  ]jchb]^Y
`U_"FcYbXUb] V`U[XUb] dc`UnU_X^YhYhUijfh]
]`] _c`i  dcbcjbc chjUfU ghUfY fUbY ] jfUU ]ghY
cg^YU^Y.hi[i _f]jb^i `^ihb^i]bUXi:fcY\`]W\ 
%-,*/ >cbUg  %--$/ <]bnY  %--&/ <Yfn][  %--'/
?U``YbVUW\  %--+/ 7`cYfW_Yfg  %--+/ 8YbcbU 
6Uh]b] &$$&/;fYYbgdUbK]YXYf &$$'"

bU gdcnbU^i _U_c b^]\cjc X]^YhY ]aU cXfYYb]


]bjU`]X]hYhbY[Uh]jbY bchc^YdcYhbUZUnU"Cb]
_Ugb]^Y df]\jUU^i bcjcbUghU`i g]hiUW]^i ] hfiXY
gYdcac]X^YhYhi":fcY\`]W\ %-,*/>cbUg %--$/
<]bnY  %--&/ <Yfn][  %--'/ ?U``YbVUW\  %--+/
7`cYfW_Yfg %--+"
?cXhYcfYh]UfUdcghc^YXjUgidfchbUa]`^Yb^U
[`YXYdf]`U[cXVY">YXb]hjfXYXUgYcV]hY`^bU_cb
Vc`b]\ ]g_ighUjU cdcfUj`^U ] bUghUj`^U bcfaU`bc
Zib_W]cb]fUh]  h^" i dchdibcgh] gY df]`U[cUjU
8fchUf  %--)  Xc_ Xfi[] hjfXY gidfchbc  XU gY
cV]hY`^b]_UXbYcdcfUj`^U]XU^Yib^c^df]gihbU
_fcb]bUhi[UC`g\Ubg_m %-*&"

B]lcb]G]b[Yf%--'UbU`]n]fU`]gi`]hYfUhifi
_c^Udc_Uni^YbY[Uh]jUbih^YWU^nVc[dfYh^YfUbc[
cg^YU^U_f]jb^Y]gUaccdhi ]jUb^U_cXfcX]hY`^U"
GUaccdhi ]jUb^Y ] _f]jb^U _cX fcX]hY`^U X^YWY g
]bjU`]X]hYhca dcjYni^i gY gU XYdfYg]^ca  VYg!
dcacbci  VYnbUXbci ] b]g_]a gUacdchc!
jUb^Ya" GaUhfU gY XU _f]jb^U ] gUaccdhi ]jUb^Y
bUfiUjU^i fcX]hY`^g_i dcjYnUbcgh g X^YhYhca 
igd^YUb cX[c^  nXfUj cV]hY`^g_] ]jch  gY_giU`b]
cXbcgfcX]hY`^U]gdcgcVbcghfcX]hY`^UXUgYVf]bi
nUgjc^YdchfYVYB]lcb %--'"

8cVfU  df]`U[cXVU fcX]hY`^U dfYaU 8YbcbU


%--- ] ?]!;`UjU ] Xf" &$$& gUghc^] gY cX.
df]\jUUb^U X]^U[bcnY  fUnia]^YjUb^U fUnjc^U
X^YhYhU  cXbcgU i cV]hY`^] _c^] dfi U^i hcd`]bi ]
g][ifbcgh  dch]WUb^U gUacdcac]  ]b]W]^Uh]jY bU
d`Ubi hfYhaUbU ] j^YfcjUb^U dfcZYg]cbU`W]aU" Hc
^Yi[`UjbcaXi[chfU^Ubdg]\c`c_]dfcWYg]abc[]
[UUihcf]X]^Y`YbUZUnY ghidb^YjY]`]ga^YfcjY"
DfYaU]ghfU ]jUb^iBcc^]b]KU``UbXYf%--*
aU^_YX^YWYgh^Y`Ygb]a]bjU`]X]hYhcabUjY`Ygi
Xc[UU^Y jYnUbY in X]^YhY _c^] bU b^]\ X^Y`i^i
bU^ghfYgb]^Y.Vf][Uc_cnU_cbU]aYX]W]bg_]\dfc!
V`YaU Vf][Uc_cX^YhYhU Vf][UjYnUbUincV]hY`^
]Vf][UnUgYVY"

DUhhYfgcb %--% dfYaU GY`][aUb  %--+ gY


hU_cYfg`U YXUabc[cVfc^bUdfciUjUb^Udc_U!
ni^ibY[Uh]jbYdcg`^YX]WY]bjU`]X]hYhUbU`UbcjY
cV]hY`^]" Cb W]h]fU dfciUjUb^U _c^U [cjcfY XU
fcX]hY`^]X^YWYg]bjU`]X]hYhcaifUnjc^i]aU^ij]Y
nXfUjghjYb]\ ] dg]\c`c_]\ dfcV`YaU ] gaUb^YbY
ac[ibcgh] j`UXUb^U" BUXU`^Y _U Y XU gi aU^_Y
fUb^]j]^Y _UXU id]^U^i cV]hY`^g_] ghfYg bUghc^Y]
nUh]h]h]cghUhU_cV]hY`^]cXghfYgU"DUhhYfgcbgaUhfU
XU]U_c^YVfc^fUnjcXUcV]hY`^]X^YWYg]bjU`]X]hY!
hcaigdcfYX]jgVfc^Ya_cXXfi[]\cV]hY`^] ]b]
gYXU^YVfUbcbYnUXcjc`^ghjc_cXcV]hY`^]X^YWY
g]bjU`]X]hYhcaYY"

FYni`hUh] ]ghfU ]jUb^U dfcjYXYbc[ i F]^YW] 


Di`] ] 7f]_jYb]W] g fcX]hY`^]aU X^YWY g WYfYVfU`!
bca dUfU`]nca 8YbcbU  %--- c cdhYfYYbcgh]
fcX]hY`^U Vc`Yi X^YhYhU   dc_UnU`] gi XU ^Y  nU
cYjY]aU^_YjYYdg]\]_ccdhYfYYb^Ycbc_c^Y
gYjYni^YingUaiVc`YghX^YhYhU bY[c_cb_fYhb]
dcg`cj]_c^YhfYVUgjU_]XUbcVUj`^Uh]"
Gidfchbca]`^Yb^iUdgc`ihbYdf]`U[cXVYcgjf!
bihYacgY]bUjYfUb]^YgdcaYbihi_fcb]bi
hi[i i cV]hY`^] _c^U dc`Un] cX ghU^U`]hU  bYgdc!
gcVbcgh]fcX]hY`^UXUgYigd^YbcbcgYgUghfYgca]
ihjfXb^]_U_cgYh]^Y_cafUnjc^UX^YhYhUbY[Uh]j!
bYYacW]cbU`bYfYU_W]^Yij]^Y_jfUU^i"

AYih]agcVn]fcaXU]ghfU ]jUb^UXU^ifUn`]!
]hY fYni`hUhY bU]`Un]ac ] bU cdfYbY ghUjcjY"
BY_Y cV]hY`^] X^YWY g ]bjU`]X]hYhca bY dc_Uni^i
j]YdfcV`YaUcXcghU`]\cV]hY`^]6YfbUfX %-+(/
8cfbYf  %-+)/ AUfh]b  %-+)/ DUhhYfgcb  %--%/
KY]gVfYb %-,$/dfYaUGY`][aUb %--+"

?U_cgYfcX]hY`^]fUn`]_i^i_UccgcVYhU_cgY]
gjU_]cXb^]\fUn`]]hcbcg]gUghfYgb]ag]hiUW]^U!
aU" IdfUjc hU fUn`]]hcgh ac Y dcjYUh] b^]\cjY
dfcV`YaY" HU_c gY bdf" ^YXUb fcX]hY`^ U[fYg]jbc
Vcf] iga^YfUjU^i] gY bU X]^YhY Xc_ gY Xfi[]
dcj`U] ] bU`Un] ihc]hY Xfi[X^Y  bdf" bU dcg`i"
Cb]giigYV]dfYghfUj`^Yb]cb]ahc]agYXc[UU

;ceY_edWbd[h[WaY_`[eieXWi_dlWb_Z_j[jec
@c[]bc^YnUdfYhdcghUj]h]_U_cgjU_UjfghU
hY_cUchY UjUbcfaU`bcYacW]cbU`bcZib_W]c!
b]fUb^YcgcVY dU^YhU_c]cgcVUaUg]bjU`]X]hY!
hcachY Ubc_caib]W]fUb^YgfcX]hY`^]aU VfUca
*.

<fjUhg_UfYj]^UnUfY\UV]`]hUW]^g_U]ghfU ]jUb^U&$$+ Jc`(' Vf"% ghf"(+!*%

]bjU`]Xbci  Xc_ gi bU^Vc`^Y fYni`hUhY dc_UnU`]


nXfUj]UXc`YgWYbh]"

]gYghfUaU cX[U^UhY`^]aU]Xfi[]aUhYbUhU^bU]b
caYhU]b^]\cjigdcgcVbcghiYb^U fYU[]fUb^U]
fUnjc^U;fYYbgdUbK]YXYf &$$'"

IeY_`WbdWfeZhaWeX_j[b`_

BU]bbU_c^]YcgcVUdf]\jUh]h]gjc^]bjU`]X]!
hYhig_c^YdcjYnUbginfUghca"8UbUggYgjYj]Y
_cf]gh] dc^Ua g]bXfca ji`bYfUV]`bc[ X^YhYhU
_c^] gi ;^if] ] Xf" %--% cd]gU`] _Uc _cad`Y_g
YacW]cbU`b]\]fUnjc^b]\dcfYaYU^UiX^YWY_c^U
cXfUghU^iicV]hY`^g_c^UhacgZYf]df]hU^Ybc[ghfU\U
nU b^]\cj ]jch" ?U_c gY fcX]hY`^g_c dcbUUb^Y
gbU bc dfYbcg] bU X^YhY hU_c cbc gUac dcghU^Y
bYg][ifbc]nUd`UYbc"

I dc[`Uj`^i c fYU[]fUb^i fcX]hY`^U bU dfca]!


^Yb^Yb] bU]b ]jchU V]`c ^Y f]^Y] _U_c ghUjcj] ]
fYU_W]^YgcW]^U`bYc_c`]bYac[iV]h]infc_ghfYgU
fcX]hY`^]aU ] cgcVUaU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca fcX]hY`^]
gY cg^YU^i ]nc`]fUbc  dcgYVbc ] Xfi[U]^Y Xc_
gi  cgcVY g ]bjU`]X]hYhca  gh][aUh]n]fUbY _Uc
bYgdcgcVbY bYacbY]Xf"hY^Y]ghU_bihUi`c[U
gcW]^U`bYc_c`]bY_c^UV]hfYVU`UgaUb^]jUh]ghfYg
cV]hY`^]]dcaU[Uh]cgcVUaUg]bjU`]X]hYhcaXUgY
fUjbcdfUjbci_`^iYi ]jchnU^YXb]WY"

DfYaU ;^if] ] Xf" %--% g]adhca] ji`bY!


fUV]`bcgh] i X^YhYhU gi. dfYh^YfUbc \Yfc^g_] ghUj 
cU^UjUb^Y  `cU g`]_U c gYV]  h^Yg_cVU  YacW]c!
bU`bU cj]gbcgh  U[fYg]jbcgh g hYbXYbW]^ca bY[]!
fUb^U Vc`Ygh]  Vibhcjbcgh ] bY_cbn]ghYbhbcgh i
dcbUUb^idfYaUVc`Ygh] gaUb^YbcgUacdchcjU!
b^Y bYdf]`U[cYbcgh dc^UUbghfU\]bYg][ifbcgh 
dgYiXcnfY`cgh"

NUh]hb]ZU_hcf]idf]`U[cXV]fcX]hY`^UbU]bjU!
`]X]hYhX^YhYhUgifUnia]^YjUb^Y]dcXf_Uc_c`]bY 
_jU`]hYhU dfcZYg]cbU`bY Vf][Y ] _cf]hYb^Y YZ]_U!
gb]^]\ghfUhY[]^UgicUjUb^UgUghfYgca8YbcbU]
6Uh]b] &$$&"
CV]hY`^ XcV]jU dcXf_i cX. fcXV]bY ] df]^UhY!
`^U  nXfUjghjYb]\ X^Y`Uhb]_U `]^Yb]_U ] hYfUdY!
ihU  dfcgj^Yhb]\ ] cX[c^b]\ X^Y`Uhb]_U i]hY`^U 
cX[U^UhY`^U]Xf" bYj`UX]b]\cf[Ub]nUW]^U 7f_jY 
gcW]^U`bYg`i VY dfYXghUjb]_U`c_U`bY]dcXfibY
fY[]cbU`bYj`Ugh]hYdfYXghUjb]_UXf UjbYj`Ugh]]
Xfi[]\"

Ac[i]dfcV`Ya]_c^]bUghU^iijYn]gh]agi.
dUhc`c_]dfcV`Ya]gYdUfUW]^YcXfcX]hY`^U dfcV`Y!
a]X]gW]d`]bY g`UV]^]igd^Y\i_c`]]Xf"Fia]\U 
&$$%"
<cfjUh] %--- i ]ghfU ]jUb^i c YacW]cbU`!
bcafYU[]fUb^iUXc`YgWYbUhUgWYfYVfU`bcadUfU!
`]nca igdcfY]jUbY gi hf] g_id]bY g fUn`]]h]a
ghidb^Ya chYYb^U i_Uni^Y XU gi hU_jY cgcVY.
bYg][ifbY igUa`^YbY g^U_cadchfYVcanUXfi!
hjYb]a df]\jUUb^Ya  nUVf]bihY nU gjc^Y nXfUj!
ghjYbcghUb^Y gb]g_]agUacdcinXUb^Ya] Y`^ca
nU dchcjUb^Ya cX c_c`]bY" U_ gY dc_UnU`c XU
hY ]bU achcf]_]\ dcfYaYU^U bYaU ih^YWU^U bU
YacW]cbU`bcfYU[]fUb^YhYXUgj]UXc`YgWYbh]jf`c
hY_cdf]\jUU^idcghc^Ub^YdcfYaYU^U"

DfYaU ]ghfU ]jUb^i @YihUf ] FU^]  &$$% c


cV]hY`^]aUgX^YhYhca_c^Y]aU]bhY`Y_hiU`bYhY!
_cYdc_UnU`cgYXUgYfcX]hY`^]bYcg^YU^i]nc`]!
fUbccXfcXV]bY]df]^UhY`^UhYXU]acb]dfi U^i
dcac]dcXf_i"GUa]fcX]hY`^]]ghU_bi`]gijU !
bcghgcW]^U`bYdcXf_Y_U_cV]dfYj`UXU`]dchY!
_cYg_c^]aUgigicYb]"BcbUhcadcXfi^igY
^c ij]^Y_ ^Uj`^U^i abc[Y hY_cY nVc[ `cY ]`]
bYXcjc`^bYcf[Ub]n]fUbcgh]gcW]^U`bYg`i VY"

6UZh]f]&$$'i]ghfU ]jUb^iccgcVbc^]gcW]!
^U`bc^ df]`U[cXV] UXc`YgWYbUhU g bUdfYXi^ica ]
bYbUdfYXi^ica h^Y`Ygbca ]bjU`]Xbci i_Uni^Y
bUh^Y`Ygbi]bjU`]Xbcgh_UchY_ciidf]`U[cXV]]
hcnVc[.giV^Y_h]jbc[cg^YU^UbYXcghUh_U nUh]a
cXbcgUgcW]^U`bYgfYX]bYdfYaUcgcVUaUgh^Y`Y!
gbca ]bjU`]Xbcgh] _Uc ] dcaUb^_Ub^U b^]\cjc[
gcW]^U`bc[ ]g_ighjU i Vfc^b]a ]jchb]a g]hiUW]!
^UaU  V]`c nVc[ fcX]hY`^g_c[ dfYnUh]]jUb^U ]`]
Ygh]\ VcfUjU_U i ]bgh]hiW]^UaU" =ghfU ]jUb^Ya
cgcVbY ] gcW]^U`bY df]`U[cXVY bU^`c]^Y fYni`hUhY
dc_UnU`] gi ]gd]hUb]W] g bUdfYXi^ica h^Y`Ygbca

DfYaU Jc`_Yfi %--% ghUj nXfUjghjYb]\ ]


dfcgj^Yhb]\X^Y`Uhb]_UhYX^YhYhcj]\jfb^U_U _Uc
] bU]b b^]\cjY aYigcVbY _caib]_UW]^Y  V]hb]
gi ]aVYb]W] i dcVc`^UjUb^i ]`] dc[cfUjUb^i
dfcV`YaU _c^Y bcg] X^YhYhcjU Vc`Ygh" Dfcgj^Yhb]
X^Y`Uhb]W] hfYVU^i dfi ]h] X^YhYhi dcac ] XcVfc
dcnbUjUh] df]fcXi b^Y[cjY Vc`Ygh]" HU_cYf ^Y
jf`c jU bc dcac] X^YhYhi _U_c V] [U df]\jUh]`]
b^Y[cj] nXfUj] jfb^UW]  U`] ]ghc hU_c ai hfYVU
cac[i]h] gh^YWUb^Y nU^YXb]_]\ ]g_ighUjU g jf!
b^UW]aU_c^]gig`]b]b^Yai"Fia]\U &$$%"
*/

NXfUj_U@YihUf 5bUhUaVi_.=bjU`]X]hYhicV]hY`^]]]njcf]dcXf_Y

gY]ghfU ]h]bY_c`]_cdfcV`YaU.

BYj`UX]bY cf[Ub]nUW]^Y i dfi Ub^i dcXf_Y


cV]hY`^] hfYVU^i cac[i]h] fcX]hY`^]aU gU[`YXU!
jUb^Y W^Y`c_idbY g]hiUW]^Y _fcn YXi_UW]^i ] ]bhY!
fU_W]^i" CX dcgYVbY ^Y jU bcgh] XU cV]hY`^ ViXY
U_h]jbU^YfgY^YX]bchU_cac Ycg][ifUh]_jU`]hYhU
]j`^Yb^U _c^i nUg`i i^i  cgcVY g ]bjU`]X]hYhca ]
b^]\cj]fcX]hY`^]?iaUf %---"

 UbU`]n]fUh]YacW]cbU`bcghUb^YfcX]hY`^U]cgcVU
g]bjU`]X]hYhca/
 ]gd]hUh] h_c ]a bU^YY dfi U dcXf_i ibihUf
i Y]]fYc_c`]bY/
 ihjfX]h][X^YcV]hY`^]g]bjU`]X]hYhcadfcbU`UnY
gbU[i nU bcYb^Y dchY_cU jYnUb]\ in ]bjU!
`]X]hYh"

I`c[U gcW]^U`b]\ fUXb]_U i ]jchi cgcVY g


]bjU`]X]hYhca ] b^YbY cV]hY`^] ^Y. ]bZcfa]fUb^Y
c dfUj]aU  gUj^YhcjUb^Y  dcXiUjUb^Y  dfi Ub^Y
dcXf_Y ] Xf" I gjU_cXbYjbc^ dfU_g] Xc[UU gY
XUgidcXfib]WYbhf]gcW]^U`bYg_fV] _Uc]Xfi[Y
ighUbcjYgcW]^U`bYg_fV] Z]n]_]bYXcghidb]cgcV]
_c^U]aUhY_cYi_fYhUb^i UgcW]^U`b]fUXb]W]bY
dfcjcXY Xcjc`^bc jfYaYbU cVUj`^U^i] hYfYbg_]
dcgUcV]`cXUgYfUX]cbYnUXcjc`^UjU^ic^cf[U!
b]nUW]^] dcg`U  UXa]b]ghfUh]jbc^ dfYcdhYfYYbcgh]
]`]g`"IfVUbW %---"

>_fej[p[_ijhW_lWd`W
DcghUj`^YbYgig`^YXYY\]dchYnY]ghfU ]jUb^U.
<%!dcghc^YnbUU^bYfUn`]_YiYacW]cbU`b]a
fYU_W]^UaUfcX]hY`^U]cgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhca/
<& ! dcghc^Y nbUU^bY fUn`]_Y i ]njcf]aU
bYZcfaU`bY ] ZcfaU`bY dcXf_Y fcX]hY`^U ]
cgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhca/
<'!dcghc^YnbUU^bYfUn`]_Yi]njcf]aUgbU[Y
nU bcYb^Y dchY_cU jYnUb]\ in ]bjU`]X]hYh
fcX]hY`^U]cgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhca"

FY`][]cnbcgh]Xi\cjbcghgibUjf`cjU bca
a^Yghi _Uc dcac _cX gj`UXUjUb^U h^Yg_cVb]\
] ghfU\ca ]gdib^Yb]\ hY_]\ g]hiUW]^U ] ]jch!
b]\ _f]nU" FcX]hY`^] dfcd]hi^i gjc^Y dfYXcX VY c
6c[i cdfUjYXbcgh]]dfUjX]i ]jchi cfUn`cn]aU
nU ]jch" BY_] ]n[iVY j^Yfi i 6c[U  Xc_ Xfi[]
hfU Y ih^Y\i _c^i cbU dfi U" BY_] Y nUXf Uh]
hYaY`^bij^Yfi U`]Y]dU_acfUh]fUnachf]h]_U_c
ig]hiUW]^]_c^U^YnUXYg]`Ub^]\cjcX]^YhYdfcbU]
bY_U_Uj ga]gUc" BY_U ]ghfU ]jUb^U fY`][]cnbcgh]
dc_UnU`U gi XU ^Y j^YfU i ]jchb]a dchY_cUaU
]bhYbn]jb]^U]XUgYdc^YX]bW]j]Yc_fYiXi\cj!
bc^X]aYbn]^]cj^Y_U@YihUf &$$%"DfYaU]ghfU!
]jUb^iK":f]YXf]W\U%-+-dfYaUcf] %--,
fY`][]cnbcghaU^_]gYdc_UnU`UnUh]hb]aZU_hcfca
igicUjUb^igUghfYgcabU_cbfcYb^UX^YhYhUg
]bjU`]X]hYhca"

C;JE:;H7:7
KpehWa_if_jWd_aW
IncfU_ ^Y V]c df][cXb]" Id]hb]_ ^Y ]gdib]`c
+-$]gd]hUb]_U"=U_cginU]gd]h]jUb^YcVUj]^YhYb]
]dcnjUb]`Ubcj]cV]hY`^] bU^jY]dcghchU_^YV]c
gUa]\ cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca  )- & ]`] (*, ]gd]!
hUb]_U  '$ * ]`] &(& ]gd]hUb]_U V]`] gi fcX]hY`^]
cgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhca & (]`]%-]gd]hUb]_UV]`]
giX^YWUcgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhca & +]`]&%]gd]hU!
b]_gigidfi b]W] U) %]`]($giVfUU]gYghfY
cgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhca"NUdchfYVYcjc[fUXUinYh]
gi i UbU`]ni dcXUW] Xj]^i bU^Vfc^b]^]\ g_id]bU.
cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca ] fcX]hY`^U" 8U_`Y  i_idbc
+%$ ]gd]hUb]_U" 8YhU`^Ub cd]g incf_U dc_UnUb ^Y
ihUV`]W]%"

I`c[UdfYXghUjb]_Uj`Ugh]`c_U`bY dcXfibY]
Xf UjbYgUghc^]gYihcaYXUcg][ifUjU^icgcVUaU
g ]bjU`]X]hYhca ] b^]\cj]a cV]hY`^]aU cghjUfYb^Y
nU_cbcanU^UaYb]\dfUjUhYXUbUghc^YdcVc`^!
Uh]b^]\cjig]hiUW]^idfca]i]]XY^i]b_`in]jbc[
XfihjU_U_cV]hc_jU`]hYhb]^Y ]j^Y`]"

I ]gd]h]jUb^i ^Y giX^Y`cjU`c )( ' YbY  U


(( ) ai_UfWU" G_cfc ,, fcX]hY`^U ^Y i XcV]
Xc')[cX]bU"CgcVYg]bjU`]X]hYhcaginUghid`^Y!
bYigj]aXcVb]ag_id]bUaUU`]gibU^nUghid`^Y!
b]^YiXcV]]naYi'*!))[cX]bU ]jchU"

9_b`_fheXb[c__ijhW_lWd`W

HUV`]WU % dc_Uni^Y XU gi ]gd]hUb]W] bU^YY


iVfU_i )' , ]`]bYc Yb^Yb]]bYiXUh]&- %"
FUnjYXYb]\ ^Y * %  U iXcj]WU ]`] iXcjUWU ^Y
%%"

BUhYaY`^ifUb]^]\hYcfYhg_]\gdcnbU^Uc ]jchi
cV]hY`^]cgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhcacd]W]`^]ghfU ]jUb^U
V]c ^Y ]gd]hUh] ]njcfY dcXf_Y fcX]hY`^U ] cgcVU g
]bjU`]X]hYhcaicV]hY`^]"Ihca_cbhY_ghi Y`^Y`c
+&

<fjUhg_UfYj]^UnUfY\UV]`]hUW]^g_U]ghfU ]jUb^U&$$+ Jc`(' Vf"% ghf"(+!*%

JWXb_YW'$IeY_eZ[ce]hW\iaWeX_b`[`W_if_jWd_aW
CcgcVYg]bjU`]X]hYhca

FcX]hY`^]

I_idbc

GDC@

Ai_c

&$)

() +

--

(& '

'$(

(( )

Ybg_c

&((

)( '

%')

)+ +

'+-

)) )

%!&)

)%

%% *

%)+

*+ (

&$,

'$ -

&*!')

,(

%- %

()

%- '

%&-

%- &

'*!()

,)

%- '

&'

--

%$,

%* $

(*!))

%$$

&& +

&*

%$*

%) ,

)*!*)

*(

%( )

$(

*)

-+

**!

)*

%& +

$(

))

,)

C Yb^Yb#iXUbU

%-&

(& &

%+*

+* -

'*,

BYc Yb^Yb#bYiXUbU

%,%

'- ,

%,

+-

%--

FUnjYXYb#U

&*

)+

%*

+$

(&

IXcjUW#iXcj]WY

)*

%& '

%-

,'

+)

6YnC#bYnUjfYbUC

*+

%, &

+)

,'

C

%&$

'& *

%) $

%)&

GhfibU_c`U!?J#J?J

*%

%* *

%* (

-*

GfYXb^U_c`U!GGG

+'

%- ,

(& %

%*'

J]U!JG

&)

*,

,-

((

J]gc_U!JGG

&%

)+

,(

'-

AU[]ghYf]^#Xc_hcfUh

$'

%-

>U_cXcVfU

%%

$+

8cVfU

')

+-

''

('

*'

CgfYXb^U

&%,

(- &

%'+

)+ %

'))

)& $

@cU

%%(

&) +

))

&& -

%*-

&( +

Jf`c`cU

+%

%* $

($

%* +

%%%

%* '

@U_]

'&

+(

%(

)-

(*

Ia^YfYb]

),

%' )

''

%' ,

-%

HY ]

%++

(% %

+*

'% ,

&)'

HY U_

%*(

', %

%%*

(, )

&,$

8C6=GD=H5B=?5

6F5B=GH5HIG
)' ,
&- %
*%
%% $

GHFIB5GDF9A5FC8=H9@>5
%*
'&
')
-$
%%,
(

%( '
&* %
%* )
&, $
+*
*+
$-

A5H9F=>5@B5G=HI57=>5

GHID5B>=BJ5@=8=H9H5

+'

*%' *
'+ ,
(% ,

NXfUj_U@YihUf 5bUhUaVi_.=bjU`]X]hYhicV]hY`^]]]njcf]dcXf_Y

CVfUncjbU ghfi_hifU fcX]hY`^U ]gd]hUb]_U  ^Y


g`^YXYU.%( 'fcX]hY`^UbYaUnUjfYbicgbcj!
bi _c`i ]`] ^Y VYn cgbcjbY _c`Y  &( fcX]hY`^U
]aUnUjfYbigUaccgbcjbi_c`i Xc_^Y&,
fcX]hY`^UgUgfYXb^ca_c`ca"HY_c_c%(fcX]!
hY`^U^Yj]Y]j]gc_ccVfUncjUbc"FYni`hUh]hUV`]WY
%dc_Uni^iXU^Y)&]gd]hUb]_UdfcW]^Yb]`cgjc^i
aUhYf]^U`big]hiUW]^i_UccgfYXb^i"AU`]Vfc^]gd]!
hUb]_U gjY[Ub^]\* 'gaUhfU^iXcVfca &( +
]gd]hUb]_UdfcW]^Yb]`c^Ygjc^iaUhYf]^U`big]hiUW]!
^i`cca Ujf`c`ccab^]\%* '"GUac$ +
gaUhfUgjc^iaUhYf]^U`big]hiUW]^i^U_cXcVfca"

'" NUh]a ^Y V]`U `^Yghj]WU _c`]_c dcXf_Y ] fUni!


a]^YjUb^U ]aU^i cX g`^YXY]\ dc^YX]bUWU ]`]
]bgh]hiW]^U. `UbcjU cV]hY`^]  df]^UhY`^U  fcX!
V]bY  _c`Y[U bU dcg`i  iXfi[U  ghfib^U_U ]n
7NGF  ghfib^U_U ]n cVfUncjb]\ ]bgh]hiW]^U 
Wf_jY]dfYXghUjb]_Uj`Ugh]`c_U`b]\]Xf Ujb]\"
@^Yghj]WU gbU[Y cXbcg]`U gY bU. j^Yfi i gYVY 
6c[U ac`]hji V]^Y[ V`]g_YcgcVY]df]^UhY`^Y"
Fh_akfb`Wd`[feZWjWaW
=ghfU ]jUb^Y ?jU`]hYhU ]jchU cV]hY`^] cgcVU g
]bjU`]X]hYhca dfcjYc ^Y <fjUhg_] gUjYn iXfi[U
h^Y`Ygb]\]bjU`]XU&$$'"[cX]bY"=gd]hUb]W]giV]`]
bYh_c cX `UbcjU cV]hY`^] ]`] gUaY cgcVY g ]bjU!
`]X]hYhca  _c^Y gi gY cXUnjU`Y bU dcn]j  aYX]^U
]`] `c_U`b]\ iXfi[U i ibUdf]^YX dfYXj]Ybc jf]!
^YaYnUXfi Yb^Y]dfYXUjUb^Y"=ghfU ]jU]giV]`]
ghiXYbh] nUXb^Y[ gYaYghfU ," GhiX]^g_c[ WYbhfU
gcW]^U`bc[ fUXU _c^] gi dfc`] cX[cjUfU^ii df]!
dfYai jYnUbi in ]ghfU ]jUb^Y" I ]ghfU ]jUb^Y gi
V]`Yi_`^iYbYgjY idUb]^Yi<fjUhg_c^ UV]`c^Y
`cW]fUbci idUb]^g_]agfYX]h]aUh^"bU&%a^Yghi
i<fjUhg_c^"GiX]cb]W]gi]aU`]Xfi Yb^Y.dfYXU!
jUb^Y ] ]gdib^UjUb^Y Ub_Yhb]\ id]hb]_U  U dcg`]^Y
gi cghU`] i bYZcfaU`bca fUn[cjcfi ] Xfi Yb^i"
Id]hb]_gi]gdib^UjU`]gUacghU`bc UnUgjYbY^U!
gbcY ]`] dcac nVc[ chY UbY achcf]_Y XcV]jU`]
gicXdf]dfYa`^Yb]\ghiXYbUhUUb_YhUfU"

=gd]hUb]W] gi dfcW]^Yb]`] XU ^Y ghidUb^ ]bjU`]X!


bcgh]cgcVY]nb^]\cjYcV]hY`^]hY U_i[chcjc,$
g`iU^YjU" HY_ ^Y %' * ]gd]hUb]_U dfcW]^Yb]`c
]bjU`]X]hYh ia^YfYb]a  U gUac * - ]gd]hUb]_U
`U_]a"
DfYaU jfgh] chYYb^U i cV]hY`^]aU ^Y bU^!
nUghid`^Yb]^U cgcVU  g achcf]_]a dcfYaYU!
^]aU *+  nUh]a g ]bhY`Y_hiU`b]a hY_cUaU
%- )  g chYYb^]aU j]XU %)  g chYYb]a
g`i\ca%$ g[cjcfb]agaYhb^UaU- )hY
gj]Yghfi_]agaYhb^UaU%&"CjU_jUX]ghf]Vi!
W]^UgiX]cb]_UbY]nbYbUi^Y^Yf^YiXfi[U_c^U^Y
V]`U bcg]cW dfc^Y_hU cjc[ ]ghfU ]jUb^U iXfi[U nU
cgcVYgachcf]_]adcfYaYU^]aU"
LWh_`WXb[__dijhkc[dj_

C[jeZ[eXhWZWfeZWjWaW

%" AYhcXU_c^UgY_cf]gh]`UifUXiV]`U^YUb_Yhbc
hYfYbg_c ]ghfU ]jUb^Y" =gd]h]jUb^Y ^Y dfcjYXY!
bc bU hYf]hcf]^i W]^Y`Y <fjUhg_Y dihYa dc`i!
ghfi_hif]fUbc[ id]hb]_U gUghUj`^Ybc[ nU cjc
]ghfU ]jUb^Y _c^] ^Y i_`^i]jUc j]Y fUn`]]h]\
dcXfi^UjYnUb]\in_jU`]hYhi ]jchU"
&" NUcjU^fUX]nXjc^YbYgijUf]^UV`Y_c^YgigY
cXbcg]`YbUgcW]cXYac[fUZg_YdcXUh_Y]gd]hU!
b]_U ] `^Yghj]WY _cbghfi]fUbY nU dchfYVY cjc[
]ghfU ]jUb^UcYacW]cbU`bcaghUb^i]gd]hUb]_U 
]njcf]aU dcXf_Y hY `^Yghj]WY [X^Y dfcbU`UnY
gbU[i nU gicUjUb^Y g dfcV`Ya]aU jYnUb]a
in ]bjU`]X]hYh" =gd]hUb]W] gi bU `^Yghj]W] cX
dYh ghidb^YjU %!^U_c bYnUXcjc`^b]  &!bYnU!
Xcjc`^Ub  '!b] nUXcjc`^Ub  b] bYnUXcjc`^Ub 
(!nUXcjc`^Ub ] )!^U_c nUXcjc`^Ub ]nfU UjU`]
gjc^Y YacW]cbU`bc ghUb^Y. bUdYhcgh  nUVf]bi!
hcgh `^ihb^i bYfjcni bYgfYhbcgh]bYg][ifbcgh 
hYgfYi]nUXcjc`^ghjc"

DcXUW] XcV]jYb] dihYa ]bghfiaYbhUf]^U gi


cVfUYb] _cf]hYb^Ya GDGG#D7 dfc[fUag_]a
dU_Yhca" NU df]_Un]jUb^Y dcXUhU_U ] fYni`hUhU
_cf]hYbYgia^YfYXYg_f]dh]jbYghUh]gh]_YfUgdc!
X^Y`U ZfY_jYbW]^U  gfYXb^U jf]^YXbcgh  a]b]aia ]
aU_g]aia  ghUbXUfXbU XYj]^UW]^U  fUgdcb fYni`!
hUhU" Df]a]^Yb^YbU ^Y X]g_f]a]bUh]jbU UbU`]nY i
]gd]h]jUb^ifUn`]_UaYig_id]bUaU]gd]hUb]_U"
H[pkbjWj__Z_iaki_`W
I ijcXbca X]^Y`i UbU`]n]fU`] gac `]hYfUhifi
] ]ghfU jUb^U _U_c gY cV]hY`^] cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hY!
hca cg^YU^i ] bcgY g ]bjU`]X]hYhca :fcY\`]W\ 
%-,*/  >cbUg  %--/ <]bnY  %--&/ <Yfn][  %--'/
?U``YbVUW\  %--+/ 7`cYfW_Yfg  %--+/ GY`][aUb 
%--+/ 8YbcbU ] 6Uh]b]  &$$&" Ghc[U Yac
UbU`]n]fUh] fYni`hUhY  X]g_f]a]bUh]jb]\ UbU`]nU i
+(

<fjUhg_UfYj]^UnUfY\UV]`]hUW]^g_U]ghfU ]jUb^U&$$+ Jc`(' Vf"% ghf"(+!*%

jYn] g YacW]cbU`b]a ghUb^Ya  ]njcf]aU dcXf_Y


] ]njcf]aU gbU[Y cV^Y g_id]bY ]gd]hUb]_U. gUaY
cgcVYg]bjU`]X]hYhca]fcX]hY`^Y_c^]]aU^iX]^YhY
g]bjU`]X]hYhca"

JWXb_YW )$ IjWdZWhZ_p_hWd_ Z_iah_c_dWY_`ia_ ae[#


\_Y_`[dj_" j[ aeh[bWY_`[ Z_iah_c_dWY_`ia_^ lWh_`WXb_ i
\kdaY_`ec
JUf]^UV`Y

Df]a^YbUX]g_f]a]bUh]jbYUbU`]nYi]gd]h]jUb^i
fUn`]_U aYi g_id]bUaU ]gd]hUb]_U i  gUacdfc!
W^Yb] df]gihbcgh] dc^YX]b]\ YacW]^U ] dcXfW]  i
cXbcgibUZib_W]^i]gd]hUb]_U
;ceY_edWbdeijWd`[eX_j[b`_
=n hUV`]WY & j]X`^]jc ^Y XU gY X]g_f]a]bUh]jbU
Zib_W]^U  nU _c^i K]`_g  `UaVXU ]aU jf]^YXbcgh
$ ,- UhYghcjbUjY`]]bU<]!_jUXfUh)( *' in,
ghidb^YjUg`cVcXY dc_UnU`UghUh]gh]_]nbUU^bca
bUfUn]b]nbUU^bcgh]d1$ $$"?cYZ]W]^Ybh_Ubcb]!
_Y_cfY`UW]^Yig`iU^ihYX]g_f]a]bUh]jbYZib_W]^Y
]nbcg] $ '& ] idii^Y bU dcghc^Ub^Y cgfYXb^Y
dcn]h]jbYjYnY]naYig_id]bU]gd]hUb]_UnUXUb]\
_f]hYf]^g_ca jUf]^UV`ca ] g_idU cX - jUf]^UV`]
_c^Y gY cXbcgY bU dc^YX]bY YacW]^Y" HUV`]WU '
gUXf ]_cYZ]W]^YbhYghUbXUfX]n]fUbY_Ubcb]_YX]g!
_f]a]bUh]jbYZib_W]^Y_c^]dc_Uni^i_c`]_cgjU_U
dc^YX]bUjUf]^UV`UXcdf]bcg]i_fY]fUb^iX]g_f]a]!
bUh]jbYZib_W]^Y"

NUVf]bihcgh

% $(-

,'-

BUdYhcgh

! $&(

(*%

=ghfcYbcgh

$ &(

(((

BYfjcnU

$&$

'%&

BYgfYhbcgh

! $&,

&-,

GfYU

! &,)

! &($

NUXcjc`^ghjc

&'$

! %,)

BYg][ifbcgh

! %-$

%*(

@^ihb^U

! ''$

$)+

@Y[YbXU.
L!X]g_f]a]bUW]^g_]_cYZ]W]^Ybh
F!_cYZ]W]^Ybh_cfY`UW]^YjUf]^UV`]
gX]g_f]a]bUW]^g_caZib_W]^ca
gY cXbcgY bU nUVf]bihcgh _c^U ^Y dcn]h]jbc[
dfYXnbU_U hY `^ihb^i ] gfYi _c^Y gi bY[Uh]jbc[
dfYXnbU_U"

DcXUW] c X]g_f]a]bUh]jb]a _cYZ]W]^Ybh]aU ]


_cfY`UW]^UaU jUf]^UV`] g X]g_f]a]bUh]jbca Zib_!
W]^ca HUV`]WU ' dc_Uni^i XU nU fUn`]_cjUb^Y
dfcaUhfUb]\ Xj]^i g_id]bU  _UXU ^Y f]^Y c Yac!
W]cbU`bca ghUb^i  bU^cX[cjcfb]^Y jUf]^UV`Y _c^Y

DfYXnbU_WYbhfc]XUfYni`hUhUg_id]bU]gd]hUb]!
_U h^" fcX]hY`^U ] cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca cX[cjUfU
dfYXnbU_i_cYZ]W]^YbUhUX]g_f]a]bUh]jbYZib_W]^Y"
BU hYaY`^i WYbhfc]XU ic`^]jc ^Y XU gi WYbhfc]X]

JWXb_YW($IjWj_ij_aWpdWW`deijZ_iah_c_dWj_ld[\kdaY_`["aWhWaj[h_ij_d_aeh`[del_"lh_`[ZdeijM_baibWcXZ[
j[aWded_aWaeh[bWY_`W_Y[djhe_Z_iakf_dW

Zib_W]^U

_ia"

FW

K]`_g
@UaVXU

<]!_jUXfUh

8Z

$ %&

%$$

$ '&

$ ,-

)( *'

$"$$

@Y[YbXU.
!_UfU_hYf]gh]b]_cf^Ybcj]
FW!_cYZ]W]^Ybh_Ubcb]_Y_cfY`UW]^Y
!K]`_gcjU`UaVXU"
<]!_jUXfUh
8Z!ghidb^Yj]g`cVcXY
d!ghUh]gh]_UnbUU^bcghX]g_f]a]bUh]jbYZib_W]^Y
7!WYbhfc]X]
+)

Cg]

FcX]h

! &+*

(,$

NXfUj_U@YihUf 5bUhUaVi_.=bjU`]X]hYhicV]hY`^]]]njcf]dcXf_Y

fcX]hY`^U cV]`^Y Yb] dcn]h]jb]a dfYXnbU_ca ] i


jYc^_cfY`UW]^]gX]g_f]a]bUh]jbcaZib_W]^ca"

gb^caYbcg]h]"
CjU_jU UbU`]nU YacW]cbU`bc[ ghUb^U idii!
^Y bUg bU j]Y infc_U [`YXY dcbUUb^U `UbcjU
cV]hY`^] cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca i gjU_cXbYjbca
]jchi"CjX^YgiicYb]bY_]cXb^]\"IbUghUj_i
YgYUbU`]n]fUh]_U_cgYcV^Yg_id]bY]gd]hUb]_U
bcgY g dcghc^Yca g]hiUW]^ca  h^ h_c ]a dfi U
dcXf_i"

Cj] fYni`hUh] idii^i bU bU^j]Y ]nfU Ybi


YacW]^i nUVf]bihcgh] _cX fcX]hY`^U cV]hY`^] cgcVU
g]bjU`]X]hYhca"CjU^bU`Undchjfi^YfUb]^YbUjY!
XYbU ]ghfU ]jUb^U :fcY\`]W\  %-,*/ >cbUg  %--$/
<]bnY  %--&/ <Yfn][  %--'/ ?U``YbVUW\  %--+/
GY`][aUb  %--+/ 7`cYfW_Yfg  %--+/ 8YbcbU 
6Uh]b] &$$&/;fYYbgdUbK]YXYf &$$'"

=n hUV`]WY ( j]X`^]jc ^Y XU gY X]g_f]a]bUh]jbU


Zib_W]^U  nU _c^i K]`_g `UaVXU ]aU jf]^YXbcgh

5bU`]n]fU^i] Uf]haYh]_Y gfYX]bY [fidY fcX]!

JWXb_YW*$IjWj_ij_aWpdWW`deijZ_iah_c_dWY_`ia[\kdaY_`["aWhWaj[h_ij_d_aeh`[del_"lh_`[ZdeijM_baibWcX#
Z[j[aWded_aWaeh[bWY_`W_Y[djhe_Z_iakf_dW
Zib_W]^U

_ia"

FW

K]`_g
@UaVXU

<]!_jUXfUh

8Z

7
Cg]

7
fcX]h"

$ +$,

%$$

$ *((

$ ),)

%) +-(

$ $&

!$ -((

$ +$,

hY`^U ] cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca icUjU gY XU fcX]!


hY`^] nUVf]bihcgh  bUdYhcgh  bYgfYhbcgh  bYfjcni ]
YacW]cbU`bi]ghfcYbcgh]nfU UjU^ij]YcXgUa]\
cgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhca"BY_]fcX]hY`^]dcghU^igj^Y!
gb]gjc^]\cg^YU^U]dfcbU`UnYgbU[iXUgYbcgYg
b^]aUUbY_]dcf]ihi[i YacW]cbU`bi]ghfcYbcgh
]`^ihb^iGY`][aUb %--+"

$ ), U hYghcjbU jY`]]bU <] ! _jUXfUh %) +- in


+ ghidb^YjU g`cVcXY  dc_UnU`U ghUh]gh]_] nbUU^!
bca bU fUn]b] nbUU^bcgh] d1 $ $&" ?cYZ]W]^Ybh
_Ubcb]_Y _cfY`UW]^Y ]nbcg] $ *( ] idii^Y bU
dcghc^Ub^Y XcVfY dcn]h]jbY jYnY ]naYi g_id]!
bU ]gd]hUb]_U nUXUb]\ _f]hYf]^g_ca jUf]^UV`ca ]
g_idU cX + jUf]^UV`] _c^Y gY cXbcgY bU dc^YX]bY
YacW]^Y" HUV`]WU ) gUXf ] _cYZ]W]^YbhY ghUbXUfX]!
n]fUbY _Ubcb]_Y X]g_f]a]bUh]jbY Zib_W]^Y _c^]
dc_Uni^i _c`]_c gjU_U dc^YX]bU jUf]^UV`U Xcdf]!
bcg]i_fY]fUb^iX]g_f]a]bUh]jbYZib_W]^Y"

CgcVY g ]bjU`]X]hYhca bU^YY gi ]ghU_bi`Y


dcn]h]jbY YacW]^Y. nUXcjc`^ghjc ] gfYi  U`] ]
nUVf]bihcgh_UcYacW]^igbU^^U]a]bhYbn]hYhca"
CjU_jY fYni`hUhY ac[iY ^Y dfchiaU]h] XU gi
df]\jUh]`]gjc^]bjU`]X]hYh bUi]`]gYbcg]h]gUgj]a
dchY_cUaUbU_c^YbU]`UnYhYgidf]\jUh]`]gYVY
cbU_j]aU _U_j] ^Ygi" CXaU\ g`]^YX] nUVf]bihcgh
hc ac Y V]h] fYni`hUh ghfU\U ] bY]nj^Ygbcgh] cX
ViXibcgh]  nVc[ fUna]`^Ub^U c hcaY hc Y V]h]
gb^]aU_UXUj]Yinb^]\bYViXib^]\cj]bU^V`]!
]" CdYb]hc j]X]ac XU ^Y ]bhYbn]hYh bY[Uh]jb]\
YacW]^U_cXcgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhcag`UV]^] Udcn]!
h]jb]\ _UchcgigfYU]nUXcjc`^ghjc ^U]bY[c
_cX fcX]hY`^U" Cjc ]ghfU ]jUb^Y Xcbcg] Xfi[U]^Y
fYni`hUhYcXfUb]^YbUjYXYb]\]ghfU ]jUb^U;^if] 
%--%/ <cfjUh]  %---/  6UZh]f]  &$$%/  Fia]\U 
&$$%" I gdcaYbih]a ]ghfU ]jUb^]aU ^Y bU^YY
f]^Y c a`UX]aU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca" Ac[iY ^Y XU 
h]^Y_ca ]jchUcXfUghUb^YacgcVYg]bjU`]X]hY!
hcaj]Ydf]\jUhYgjc^ig]hiUW]^i]dc_iUjU^igY

DfYaUfYni`hUh]aU]ndfYh\cXbYhUV`]WY)ac Y
gY nU_`^i]h] XU X]g_f]a]bUh]jbi Zib_W]^i i bU^!
jYc^ a^Yf] hjcfY jUf]^UV`Y _c^Y gY cXbcgY bU
JWXb_YW +$ IjWdZWhZ_p_hWd_ Z_iah_c_dWY_`ia_ ae[#
\_Y_`[dj_" j[ aeh[bWY_`[ Z_iah_c_dWY_`ia_^ lWh_`WXb_ i
\kdaY_`ec
JUf]^UV`Y!FUn[cjcf

+*

FcX]hY`^]Xfi[YX^YWY

*(-

(*(

J`Ugh]h]fcX]hY`^]

! -%+

! '($

Df]^UhY`^]

)+*

'%*

BYh_cXfi[]

((+

&$$

Gidfi[

&,$

%-*

?c`Y[YbUdcg`i

! )'&

! %$%

6fUU]gYghfY

$,%

$-%

<fjUhg_UfYj]^UnUfY\UV]`]hUW]^g_U]ghfU ]jUb^U&$$+ Jc`(' Vf"% ghf"(+!*%

f]^ca _Yf] _c^U ^Y nXfUjU" >YXbU aU^_U Xcbcg]


gjc^ cXbcg g _Yf] bU g`^YXY] bU]b. BY [cjcf]
]hY_cgYgdcfUnia]^YjU Xfi[]cg]aaYbY^YbY
fUnia]^i dcg`ibU^Y^Yfcj]g]gUaccaYb]]]aU
jf`cXcVfcdcbUUb^Y dcj^YfUjUgjc^YdchY_cY
]dchfYVYdUnU^YXb]_]f^YUjUacdfcV`Ya hY_c
^YigdcghUj]h]_cbhU_h hfiX]agYhcj]YfUnia^Y!
h]  b^c^ gUa Yghc ^U ^YX]bU jYnU g cghU`]a gj]^Y!
hca">YXUbchUWbUjcX].G]ba]^YbUghfUXUci
dfcaYhbc^bYgfY] df]^Y^YV]cgUacghU`Ub]gUX^Y
hY_c igdcghUj]h] _cbhU_h  g`UVc _caib]W]fUac"
Cjc gi bU^Y] bUjcX] fcX]hY`^U  X^YWY ]n _c^]\
ac Yac j]X^Yh] XU ]aU^i cXbcg dib hcd`]bY ]
`^iVUj]nUgjc^YX]^YhY"BU_cbcj]\hjfXb^]`U_Y
^YfUnia^Yh]YacW]^Y]ghfcYbcgh] nUVf]bihcgh]]
bUdYhcgh]c_c^]aU^YfUb]^YV]`c[cjcfU"

j`Ugh]hY fcX]hY`^Y _c^] gi bY[Uh]jbc[ dfYXnbU_U ]


fcX]hY`^UXfi[YX^YWY_c^Ygidcn]h]jbc[dfYXnbU!
_U"DfYXnbU_WYbhcf]XUfYni`hUhUg_id]bU]gd]hUb]!
_U h^" fcX]hY`^U ] cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca cX[cjUfU
dfYXnbU_i_cYZ]W]^YbUhUX]g_f]a]bUh]jbYZib_W]^Y"
BU hYaY`^i WYbhfc]XU ic`^]jc ^Y XU gi WYbhfc]X]
fcX]hY`^U cV]`^Y Yb] dcn]h]jb]a dfYXnbU_ca ] i
bYhc aUb^c^ gi _cfY`UW]^] g X]g_f]a]bUh]jbca
Zib_W]^ca  Xc_ ^Y dfYXnbU_ WYbhfc]XU cgcVU g
]bjU`]X]hYhca cV]`^Y Yb bY[Uh]jbca Zib_W]^ca ]
ij]gc_c^^Ydcn]h]jbc^_cfY`UW]^]gX]g_f]a]bUh]j!
bcaZib_W]^ca"
BUhYaY`^idfcg^Yb]\jf]^YXbcgh]]ghUbXUfXb]\
XYj]^UW]^Uac[iY^Y_cbghUh]fUh]XUcdfcV`Ya]aU
jYnUb]ain]bjU`]X]hYhbU^j]YaYigcVbcdf]U^i
gidfi b]W] hc^Y]dU_^YXUbdcn]h]jUbdcXUhU_g
cVn]fcaXU^YcV]hY`^cgbcjb]]bU^jU b]^]]b]hY`^
i fUnj]h_i X^YhYhU ^Yf fcX]hY`^] X^YhYhU g ]bjU`]X]!
hYhca i dfUj]`i ]aU^i aUb^Y gcW]^U`bY dcXf_Y
fcXV]bU  df]^UhY`^]  _c`Y[Y  U idfUjc gcW]^U`bU
dcXf_U dcn]h]jbc X^Y`i^Y bU iV`U UjUb^Y ghfYgU
_c^Yagi]n`c Yb]fcX]hY`^]X^YWYg]bjU`]X]hYhca"
Ac[iY^Y_cbghUh]fUh]XUgYdfcV`Ya]jYnUb]in
]bjU`]X]hYh f^YUjU^i ibihUf cV]hY`^]   nUh]a g df]!
^UhY`^]aU]fcX]hY`^]aUXfi[YX^YWY Ug_c`Y[UaU
bUdcg`ibU^f^YY"

J]X^Y`cgYXUgidfi b]W]bU^YYaYigcVbc
fUn[cjUfU^icdfcV`Ya]aU"BUaYigcVbYcXbc!
gY jf`c ^U_c  ih^YY ]b^Yb]WU XU b^]\cjc X]^YhY
]aUcXfYYb]]bjU`]X]hYh"BU]bbU_c^]gYfcX]hY`^]
_UcVfUb]dUfhbYf]bcgYghca]b^Yb]WcaV]hY
ij^YhcjUb df]fcXca b^]\cj]\ cXbcgU df]^Y dc^U!
jY ]bjU`]X]hYhU _cX X^YhYhU" ?U_j] [cX h] cXbcg]
V]`]  jf`c ^Y jY`]_U ac[ibcgh dcjYUbc[ ghfYgU
] dfca^YbU _c^Y Y V]h] bi bY GY`][aUb  %--+/
@YihUf]FU] &$$%"6fUb]dUfhbYf]YV]h]cXjY
nUc_id`^Yb] Vf][UaU ] ]aUh Y aUb^Y jfYaYbU
^YXb] nU Xfi[Y" NVc[ hc[U dUfhbYf abc[Y b^]\c!
jY dchfYVY YacW]cbU`bY  dfU_h]bY  gY_giU`bY 
XfihjYbY ]`]]bhY`Y_hiU`bYbYY]gdib]h]"5_ci
cV]hY`^]dcghc^]gUac^YXUbfcX]hY`^ cbac YV]h]
dcX dcjYUb]a ghfYgca ^Yf bYaU dUfhbYfU _c^]
Yaidfi ]h]dg]\c`c_i Y_cbcag_i]dfU_h]bi
dcac"HcbYnbU]XUYgYicV]hY`^]aUgUgUac
^YXb]a fcX]hY`^Ya dfcV`Ya] bY]nV^Y bc dc^Uj]h]"
BUdfch]j fUn]bUUXUdhUW]^YcV]hY`^]ac YV]h]jYU
bY[cig]hiUW]^UaUi_c^]aUdcghc^]bYg_`UXaYi
dUfhbYf]aU"

FcX]hY`^] ] cgcVY g ]bjU`]X]hYhca bU^YY


fUn[cjUfU^i gU gidfi b]_ca  fcX]hY`^]aU Xfi[Y
X^YWY]df]^UhY`^]aU Xc_cgcVYg]bjU`]X]hYhca^c
bUjcXY j`Ugh]hY fcX]hY`^Y  df]^UhY`^Y ] ghfib^U_Y
fUnb]\dfcZ]`U"
G`^YXY]fYni`hUh]bUgidii^ibUcXbcgYcgcVU
g]bjU`]X]hYhca]fcX]hY`^U"FcX]hY`^]_caib]_UW]!
^igUgjc^]aX^YhYhcabU^YYcd]gi^ig`^YXY]a
hjfXb^UaU. 6`]g_] gac  bUY X]^YhY bUiYbc
gUacbUbUg Yghcdf]Uac]fUnia]^YacgY XU
V]gYac[`cgb^]aXcbY_`YgdcfUnia]^YjUh] acfU
[U gY \jU`]h] nU V]`c _c^i ghjUf g]hb]Wi _c^i ^Y
i]b]c g[fiV]af]^Y]aUgYbYac Yb]hUdcgh]] 
X]^YhY ^Y gj^Ygbc gjc[ \YbX]_YdU  b]^Y ]nc`]fUbc
jY^Y]n^YXbUYbcgUnXfUjcaVfUca jU bU^Y
XcVfUjc`^U]ghfd`^Yb^Y UhcfcX]hY`^acfU]aUh]
nU gjc^Y X]^YhY" 8fi[U aU^_U bUjcX]. =bjU`]X
^Y ]bjU`]X  cgcVU _c^U hY Y igdcghUj`^U _cai!
b]_UW]^i  ]gdfUjb]a Uf[iaYbh]aU ] dcn]h]jb]a
ghUjcac_id`^UjY`]_Vfc^]fYcV]hY`^]"BUghc^]a
gYdf]V`] ]h] _caib]W]fUaccgjYai _Uc]gUghU!

?pleh_feZha[bWdel_cWeX_j[b`_
IbUghUj_icjc[fUXUfUnachf]hYgYfYni`hUh]
]ghfU ]jUb^U]ic]h]h_c`Ubcj]aUcV]hY`^]cgcVU
g]bjU`]X]hYhcadfi UbU^jYidchdcfiigjU_cX!
bYjbca ]j`^Yb^i hY j]X^Yh] fUn`]_Y ]naYi Xj]^Y
dfcaUhfUbY g_id]bY ]gd]hUb]_U h^" cgcVU g ]bjU`]!
X]hYhca]fcX]hY`^U"
=n hUV`]WY * j]X`^]jc ^Y XU gY X]g_f]a]bUh]jbU
++

NXfUj_U@YihUf 5bUhUaVi_.=bjU`]X]hYhicV]hY`^]]]njcf]dcXf_Y

JWXb_YW,$IjWj_ij_aWpdWW`deijZ_iah_c_dWj_ld[\kdaY_`["aWhWaj[h_ij_d_aeh`[del_"lh_`[ZdeijM_baibWcXZ[
j[aWded_aWaeh[bWY_`W_Y[djhe_Z_iakf_dW

Zib_W]^U

_ia"

FW

K]`_g
@UaVXU

<]!_jUXfUh

XZ

7cg]

7fcX]h"

$ )$

%$$

$ ),

$ **

&- %)+

%&

$ $$(

$ ,$-

!$ *%&

Zib_W]^U  nU _c^i K]`_g `UaVXU ]aU jf]^YXbcgh


$ ** UhYghcjbUjY`]]bU<]!_jUXfUh&- %)in%&
ghidb^YjU g`cVcXY  dc_UnU`U ghUh]gh]_] nbUU^!
bca bU fUn]b] nbUU^bcgh] d1 $ $$(" ?cYZ]W]^Ybh
_Ubcb]_Y_cfY`UW]^Yig`iU^ihYX]g_f]a]bUh]jbY
Zib_W]^Y]nbcg]$ ),]idii^YbUdcghc^Ub^YfY`U!
h]jbc XcVfY dcn]h]jbY jYnY ]naYi g_id]bU ]gd]!
hUb]_U nUXUb]\ _f]hYf]^g_ca jUf]^UV`ca ] g_idU
cX%&jUf]^UV`]_c^YgYcXbcgYbUdc^YX]bYYac!
W]^Y"HUV`]WU+gUXf ]_cYZ]W]^YbhYghUbXUfX]n]fUbY
_Ubcb]_YX]g_f]a]bUh]jbYZib_W]^Y_c^]dc_Uni^i
_c`]_cgjU_Udc^YX]bUjUf]^UV`UXcdf]bcg]i_fY]!
fUb^iX]g_f]a]bUh]jbYZib_W]^Y"

b^U_U]n_c`Y]bYj`UX]b]\iXfi[U_c^YgibY[U!
h]jbc[ dfYXnbU_U" BU hYaY`^i WYbhfc]XU ic`^]jc
^YXUgiWYbhfc]X]fcX]hY`^UcV]`^Y Yb]bY[Uh]jb]a
dfYXnbU_ca  U cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca dcn]h]jb]a
dfYXnbU_ca"  >YXb] ] Xfi[] gi i ^U_c^ _cfY`UW]^]
g X]g_f]a]bUh]jbca Zib_W]^ca" CgcVY g ]bjU`]!
X]hYhcagiijYc^_cfY`UW]^]gX]g_f]a]bUh]jbca
Zib_W]^ca"
5f]haYh]_Y jf]^YXbcgh] dc_Uni^i XU ]gd]hU!
b]W] bU^jYi dcXf_i XcV]jU^i cX gjc^Y X^YWY
A1( %$ nUh]a cX gidfi b]_U ( $,  cXaU\
bU_cb hc[U gi fcX]hY`^] ] df]^UhY`^]" NUb]a`^]jc ^Y
ic]h] XU ^Y fcXV]bU i fUnia]^YjUb^i ] dcXfW]
aUb^Y jU bU cX df]^UhY`^U" Cj] fYni`hUh] ]Xi i
df]`c[  bcj]^]\ gcW]c`c_]\ ]ghfU ]jUb^U XU fcX!
V]bghjc [iV] gjc^i jf]^YXbcgh ] b^Y[cjU jU bcgh
g`UV]gdcfUghcaacXYfb]nUW]^YXfihjU"GfcXV]!
bca gY ]gd]hUb]W] ] aUb^Y gUj^Yhi^i ] df]aU^i cX
b^Y dcXf_i bY[c cX df]^UhY`^U <``]b[Yf  %--$/
GW\i`n  %--+/ @YihUf  &$$$" BU_cb  fcXV]bY ]
_c`Y[U bU dcg`i Xc`UnY ]bgh]hiW]^Y" CX ]bgh]hiW]!
^U bU^jYi dchdcfi cV]hY`^] XcV]jU^i cX 7f_jY 
nUh]a bYj`UX]b]\ cf[Ub]nUW]^U  bU_cb hc[U gi
cVfUncjbY]gcW]^U`bYighUbcjY UcbXUdfYXghUj!
b]W] idUb]^U ] dc`]h]Uf] % +%" 8U_`Y `^iX] gi
cdYb]hc bU^bYnUXcjc`^b]^] dcXf_ca  dc`]h]UfU
]dfYXghUjb]_Uj`Ugh]"Dcbcjbc^Yac[iYcjU_ji
`^Yghj]Widfi Ub^UdcXf_YigdcfYX]h]gUgcW]c`c!
_]a ]ghfU ]jUb^]aU i _c^]aU gY  X^YWU  jfYXbi^i
jf`c j]gc_c  nUh]a df]^UhY`^]  fcXV]bU  bYj`UX]bY
]  j`UX]bY cf[Ub]nUW]^Y  U Xbc `^Yghj]WY nUghidU!
^i dfYXghUjb]W] j`Ugh] ] dc`]h]Uf] <U``Yf  %-,+/
GW\i`n %--*/@YihUf&$$$"NUVf]b^UjU]nfU Ybc
bYnUXcjc`^ghjc  cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca ] fcX]hY`^U
dcXf_ca_c^i]adfi UWYbhUfnUgcW]^U`big_fV"
Ac[iY  ^Y XU ^Y cbc dcg`^YX]WU cdhYfYYbcgh]
Vfc^Ya_cf]gb]_U]Zib_W]^U `c]afUXb]aij^Yh]!
aU]bYXcjc`^bcaY_]d]fUbcigUa]\ghfib^U_U"
GjY hc gaUb^i^Y ghjUfbi _jU`]hYhi fUXU gUac[
WYbhfUidfi Ub^iig`i[UIfVUbW %---"=nfUn]hc

DfYaUfYni`hUh]aU]nhUV`]WY+ac YgYnU_`^i!
]h]XUX]g_f]a]bUh]jbiZib_W]^iibU^jYc^a^Yf]
hjcfY jUf]^UV`Y _c^Y gY cXbcgY bU fUnia]^YjUb^Y
_c^Y ]gd]hUb]W] XcV]jU^i cX idUb]^g_]\ j`Ugh] ]
fcXV]bY _c^Y gi dcn]h]jbc[ dfYXnbU_U hY  ghfi!
JWXb_YW -$ IjWdZWhZ_p_hWd_ Z_iah_c_dWY_`ia_ ae[#
\_Y_`[dj_" j[ aeh[bWY_`[ Z_iah_c_dWY_`ia_^ lWh_`WXb_ i
\kdaY_`ec
JUf]^UV`Y!fUnia]^YjUb^Y

J`Ugh idUb]^Y

,(+

)*)

Dc`]h]Uf]

(&+

()&

8^YWU

! %-,

! ($&

Gidfi b]_

! &&,

! &,(

7f_jU

%-*

&&)

FcXV]bU

++*

&%'

Ghfib^U_7NGF

$$(

%)'

FcX]hY`^]

&&$

%'(

BYj`UX]bYiXfi[Y

! (+,

$,%

Df]^UhY`^]

! &*+

$,$

Ghfib^U__c`U

! )')

! $%&

?c`Y[YbUdcg`i

! ()+

$$)
+,

<fjUhg_UfYj]^UnUfY\UV]`]hUW]^g_U]ghfU ]jUb^U&$$+ Jc`(' Vf"% ghf"(+!*%

bYnUXcjc`^ghjc fUnia]^YjUb^Ya ] dcXf_ca cX


ghfUbY dfYXghUjb]_U j`Ugh] dcjYnUbc ^Y g cd]a
bYnUXcjc`^ghjcadcghc^Y]aY_cbcag_]a]Xfi!
hjYb]aghUhigca"

BU_cb UbU`]nY c YacW]cbU`b]a fYU_W]^UaU 


cd\cYb^i g dfcV`Ya]aU ] dcXf_Y bU _c^i cV]!
hY`^] bU]`UnY i gjU_cXbYjbca ]jchi UbU`]n]fUh
Y gY fYni`hUh] _c^] XU^i cX[cjcf bU d]hUb^Y [X^Y
]gd]hUb]W]dfcbU`UnYgbU[inU ]jch"

FYni`hUh] [cjcfY c hcaY _U_c ^Y jY]bU ]gd]!


hUb]_U nUXcjc`^bU dcXf_ca ] fUnia]^YjUb^Ya
_c^idf]aUcXgjc^YcV]hY`^] dcbU^j]YcXX^YWY]
gidfi b]_U j`Ugh]h]\fcX]hY`^U df]^UhY`^U]fcXV]bY 
hc gY ac Y dcjYnUh] g ]b^Yb]Wca XU ^Y hc X]c
b^]\cjY gjU_cXbYj]WY ] XU chjcfYbc fUn[cjUfU^i
cdfcV`Ya]aUibihUfcV]hY`^]"Abc[]acV]hY`^]aU
gi b^]\cjY XfihjYbY jYnY ]njcf dchdcfY nVc[

?pleh_idW][heZ_j[b`W_eieXWi
_dlWb_Z_j[jec
?Uc ] Xc gUXU  g cVn]fca bU V]bUfb] _UfU_hYf
_f]hYf]^g_YjUf]^UV`YXcV]jYbU^Y^YXbUX]g_f]a]bU!
h]jbUZib_W]^U_c^U^Y _U_cgYj]X]]nhUV`]WY,
hU_cYfghUh]gh]_]nbUU^bU"

JWXb_YW.$IjWj_ij_aWpdWW`deijZ_iah_c_dWj_ld[\kdaY_`["aWhWaj[h_ij_d_aeh`[del_"lh_`[ZdeijM_baibWcXZ[
j[aWded_aWaeh[bWY_`W_Y[djhe_Z_iakf_dW

:ib_W]^U

_ia"

FW

K]`_g
@UaVXU

<]!_jUX!
fUh

8Z

7
Cg]

7
fcX]h"

$ $,'

%$$

$ &+

$ -&'

%* &,

$ $&

$ &,(

!$ &,-

B]g_Ujf]^YXbcgh<]!_jUXfUhhYghU_Uc]cgfYX!
b^Y ]nfU YbU _Ubcb]_U _cfY`UW]^U idii^i bU
nU_`^iU_ XU ^Y jYnU ]naYi g_id]bU ]gd]hUb]_U
nUXUb]\_f]hYf]^g_cajUf]^UV`ca]g_idUcXgYXUa
jUf]^UV`]_c^YgYcXbcgYbUdc^YX]bY]njcfYgbU[Y 
]U_c ghUh]gh]_] nbUU^bU  fY`Uh]jbc g`UVc ]nfU Y!
bU"

dcac] _c^i dfi U^i  dc[chcjc dcXf_Y ibihUf


cV]hY`^]"DcXf_U]njUbcV]hY`^]^YbYXcjc`^bUcX
Xf Ujb]\  idUb]^g_]\]`c_U`b]\j`Ugh]"8fihjcV]
hfYVU`c]aUh]j]YcVn]fUdfYaUcgcVUaUg]bjU`]!
X]hYhca]dfcV`Ya]aU_c^Y]aU^icV]hY`^]cgcVUg
]bjU`]X]hYhca"BYj`UX]bYiXfi[Y 7f_jU]`c_U`bU
nU^YXb]WU bU hYaY`^i gidg]X]^Ufbcgh] hfYVU`Y V]
j]YgifU]jUh] fUX]h]]hY ]h]f^YUjUb^idfcV`YaU 
dc[chcjc_cXcV]hY`^]cgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhcaib^]!
\cjc^`c_U`bc^gfYX]b]Fia]\U &$$%"

DfYaUfYni`hUh]aU]nhUV`]WY-ac YgYnU_`^i!
]h]XUX]g_f]a]bUh]jbiZib_W]^iibU^jYc^a^Yf]
hjcfYjUf]^UV`Y_c^YgYcXbcgYbUgbU[i_c^i]gd]!
hUb]W]XcV]jU^iidcXfW]fcX]hY`^U _c^U^Ydcn]!

AU`c fUnia]^YjUb^U nU b^]\ ]aU^i _c`Y[Y g


dcg`U j`Ugh _c`U]dc`]h]Uf]"]b^Yb]WU^YXUgi
cV]hY`^]bYnUXcjc`^bYfUnia]^YjUb^Ya_c`Y _c^U
^Yjf`cjU bUnU]bhY[fUW]^icgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhca
i gcW]^U`bi c_c`]bi" Df]a^Ybca X]g_f]a]bUh]jbY
Zib_W]^Y j]X`^]jc ^Y XU gY cgcVY g ]bjU`]X]hYhca
] fcX]hY`^] aYigcVbc fUn`]_i^i i dYfWYdW]^Y df]!
a`^YbYdcXf_Y"

JWXb_YW /$  IjWdZWhZ_p_hWd_ Z_iah_c_dWY_`ia_ ae[#


\_Y_`[dj_" j[ aeh[bWY_`[ Z_iah_c_dWY_`ia_^ lWh_`WXb_ i
\kdaY_`ec

JUf]^UV`Y!GbU[U

BUhYaY`^ifYni`hUhUac[iY^Y_cbghUh]fUh]XU
`Ubcj] cV]hY`^] jY`]_i dchdcfi bU`UnY i j`Ugh]hc^
cV]hY`^]]df]^UhY`^]aU cgfYXb^iifcXV]b] _c`Y[U!
aU bU dcg`i  7f_j] ] bYj`UX]b]a iXfi[UaU  Xc_
j`UX]bgY_hcfdfi UaU`i Udc`]h]Uf]]dfYXghUj!
b]W]j`Ugh]bYXcjc`^bidchdcfi"
+-

_cYZ]W]^Ybh]

_cfY`UW]^Y

FcX]hY`^]

+-*

*$-

Gidfi b]_

!),-

! (($

6]^Y[cXg]hiUW]^Y

(&,

'($

J^YfUi6c[U

! %,&

! '&$

Ac`]hjU

! %-&

! &*$

J^YfUigYVY

&()

$*'

Df]^UhY`^]

! &$*

$*%

NXfUj_U@YihUf 5bUhUaVi_.=bjU`]X]hYhicV]hY`^]]]njcf]dcXf_Y

gi cdhYfYYb] bY[Uh]jb]a YacW]^UaU" BU^YY


]\ dfUh] nUVf]bihcgh  bUdYhcgh hY YacW]cbU`bU
]ghfcYbcgh" FcX]hY`^] gi Ub_g]cnb]^] cX gUa]\
cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca" :fcY\`]W\  %-,*/ >cbUg 
%--$/ <]bnY  %--&/ <Yfn][  %--'/ ?U``YbVUW\ 
%--+/ 7`cYfW_Yfg  %--+/ GY`][aUb  %--+/ @YihUf
]FU] &$$%/8YbcbU]6Uh]b] &$$&"Dcn]h]jbY
YacW]^Y _Uc hc ^Y nUXcjc`^ghjc bYhc gi  YY
df]gihbY _cX cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca  bY[c fcX]hY!
`^U" NUVf]bihcgh ^Y bU^^UY ]nfU YbU YacW]^U _cX
fcX]hY`^U UbYhcg`UV]^Y[]bhYbn]hYhU]_cXcgcVU
g]bjU`]X]hYhca"

h]jbc[dfYXnbU_U]gidfi b]_U_c^YgibY[Uh]jbc[
dfYXnbU_U"  C giX^Y`cjUb^i dc^YX]bY jUf]^UV`Y
i ghfi_hif] X]g_f]a]bUh]jbY Zib_W]^Y nU_`^ii^Y
gY ]n dcXUhU_U c _cfY`UW]^UaU jUf]^UV`] g hca
Zib_W]^ca"?U_cdfc]n`Un]]ndcXUhU_UgUXf Ub]\
i hUV`]W] -  i cjcaY g`iU^i gi hc df]V`] bc ]ghY
jUf]^UV`Y_c^YgijYicYbY_UccbYgbU^jYca
X]g_f]a]bUh]jbcagbU[ca"Hcgi XU_`Y fcX]hY`^]
]gidfi b]W]"
DfYXnbU_WYbhcf]XUfYni`hUhUg_id]bU]gd]hUb]!
_Uh^"fcX]hY`^U]cgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhcacX[cjUfU
dfYXnbU_i_cYZ]W]^YbUhUX]g_f]a]bUh]jbYZib_W]^Y"
BU hYaY`^i WYbhfc]XU ic`^]jc ^Y XU gi WYbhfc]X]
fcX]hY`^U cV]`^Y Yb] bY[Uh]jb]a dfYXnbU_ca  U
cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca dcn]h]jb]a dfYXnbU_ca  U
^YXb]]Xfi[]giig`UVc^_cfY`UW]^]gX]g_f]a]bU!
h]jbcaZib_W]^ca"

C  dfcV`Ya]aU bU^YY fUn[cjUfU^i gU


gidfi b]_ca  fcX]hY`^]aU ] df]^UhY`^]aU" BU^jYi
dchdcfi nU bcYb^Y gU gjU_cXbYjb]a dfcV`Ya]!
aUdcbcjbcdfcbU`UnYii c^cV]hY`^] dcbU^j]Y
_cXj`Ugh]hYX^YWY nUh]agidfi b]_U]fcX]hY`^U U
bU_cb b^]\ g df]^UhY`^]aU ] fcXV]bca" =bgh]hiW]^Y 
cX_c^]\gibU^nbUU^b]^U7f_jU]bYj`UX]bgY_hcf 
_cb_fYhbc b^]\cjU iXfi[U  dfcW]^Yb^YbY gi bYhc
Vc`^Y cX j`UX]bU gY_hcfU" J`UX]b gY_hcf dfi U
]a`cidcXf_i UbU^`c]^idfYXghUjb]W]j`Ugh]]
dc`]h]Uf]"=U_c^Ygidfi b]_jf`cjU Ubidfi Ub^i
dcXf_Y  g_id]bU fcX]hY`^U ]gh]Y X^YWi _Uc cbY
_c^]]abU^j]Ydfi U^idcXf_i Xc_ginUcgcVY
g]bjU`]X]hYhcahcj`Ugh]h]fcX]hY`^]]gidfi b]_"


Dcbcjbc _Uc]iUbU`]nUaUgUj^YhcXUjbY
dcac]]fUnia]^YjUb^U bU`Un]gYXUfcX]hY`^]j]Y
cX cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca dfcW^Yb^i^i gidfi b]_U
_Uc]njcfgbU[Y Xc_cgcVYg]bjU`]X]hYhcajYY
jf]^YXbcgh] cX g_id]bY fcX]hY`^U df]XU^i j`Ugh]h]a
fcX]hY`^]aU ] df]^UhY`^]aU" HU_j] fYni`hUh] gi ]
`c[]b] i_c`]_c gY df]g^Yh]ac cV]`^Y ^U cjc[ df]!
[cXbc[ incf_U i _c^Ya ^Y XcghU jY`]_] dcghchU_
bYc Yb^Yb]\ cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca _c^] bU^YY
]jYgfcX]hY`^]aU"

GbU[i nU bcYb^Y gU ]jchb]a dfcV`Ya]aU


dfcbU`UnY bU^YY i `Ubcj]aU j`Ugh]hY cV]hY`^].
fcX]hY`^]idchdcf]gidfi b]_U UcgcVYg]bjU`]X]!
hYhcaidchdcf]_c^idf]aU^icXfcX]hY`^U"Ac[iY
^Y nU_`^i]h]  XU cV]hY`^] cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca
dfcbU`UnYgjc^[`Ujb]cg`cbUWij`Ugh]hc^cV]hY`^]"
Gidfi b]_^YbY]na^YfbcjU Ubidfi Ub^idcXf!
_Y" FcX]hY`^] bU cgcV]h bU]b XcV]jU^i   dcXf_i
cX j`Ugh]hY X^YWY  Xc_ cgcVY g ]bjU`]X]hYhca cX
gjc^]\ fcX]hY`^U" Df]^UhY`^] gi jU Ub X]c b^]\cjY
gcW]^U`bYafY Yin`UbcjYj`Ugh]hYcV]hY`^]"

P7AB@KDEH7PC7JH7D@;
FYni`hUh]cjc[]ghfU ]jUb^UXcdf]bcgYidcnbU!
jUb^iYacW]cbU`bc[ghUb^UcV]hY`^]cgcVUg]bjU!
`]X]hYhca]dfcaUhfUb^idcXf_Y_c^idf]aU^icX
i Y]]fYc_c`]bY"=U_cfUn`]]hcghVfc^U]gd]hUb]_U
dc g_id]bUaU ] XcVbU ghfi_hifU i incf_i iaU!
b^i^i ac[ibcgh [YbYfU`]nUW]^Y cj]\ fYni`hUhU 
XcV]jYb] fYni`hUh] i_Uni^i bU jU bcgh i Y ] ]fY
nU^YXb]WYidfi Ub^idcXf_Y hYac[idcg`i ]h]i
d`Ub]fUb^icV]hY`^g_Ydc`]h]_YnUcgcVYg]bjU`]X]!
hYhca_Uc]ViXi]a]ghfU ]jUb^]aUdfi Ub^UZcf!
aU`bY]bYZcfaU`bYdcXf_YcgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhca
]b^]\cj]\fcX]hY`^U"

CV]hY`^] cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca hfYVU^i dcac


j`UX]b]\ ] bYj`UX]b]\ cf[Ub]nUW]^U" J]X`^]jc ^Y
XU ^Y cbU jf`c g`UVU" Ghc[U V] gY cjY ]bgh]hiW]^Y
hfYVU`Y j]Y Ub[U ]fUh] ] i_`^i]h] i dcXf_i cgc!
VUaU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca" DchfYVbc ^Y ]ghU_bih] XU
dfYaU fYni`hUh]aU cjc[ ]ghfU ]jUb^U 7f_jU _Uc
]bgh]hiW]^U dfi U cgfYXb^i dcXf_i cgcVUaU g
]bjU`]X]hYhca" G Xfi[Y ghfUbY ^Y j]X`^]jc XU cV]!
hY`^]dfcbU`UnYgjc^igbU[iij^Yf]i6c[U"Ghc[U
V] j^Yfg_Y nU^YXb]WY idfUjc cV]hY`^]aU _c^Y ]\

I fUXi gY UbU`]n]fU`c YacW]cbU`bc ghUb^Y


cgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhca]fcX]hY`^U h_c]agjYdfi U
dchfYVbi dcXf_i  g _]a fUn[cjUfU^i c gjc^]a
dfcV`Ya]aU ] [X^Y dfcbU`UnY ]jchbi gbU[i" BU
hYaY`^iUbU`]nYfYni`hUhUac[iY^YnU_`^i]h].
`Ubcj]cV]hY`^]cgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhcacgfYXb^Y
+.

<fjUhg_UfYj]^UnUfY\UV]`]hUW]^g_U]ghfU ]jUb^U&$$+ Jc`(' Vf"% ghf"(+!*%

hfYVU^ihfYVU`YdfcbU]UXY_jUhbYbU]bYdcXf_Y
_fcnXfi Yb^U gUj^YhcjUb^Y dfcjcYb^Yg`cVcX!
bc[jfYaYbU]g`""

_c^YfUXYgcgcVUaUg]bjU`]X]hYhca]`Ubcj]aU
b^]\cj]\ cV]hY`^]" Cjc ]ghfU ]jUb^Y ^Y dc_UnU`c
dibc jYY nUXcjc`^ghjc cgcVU g ]bjU`]X]hYhca ]
fcX]hY`^UfUXcaW]j]`bc[gY_hcfU]Wf_jYb]\]bgh]!
hiW]^UbY[cj`UX]bUgY_hcfU"


Ac[iY^Y_cbghUh]fUh]XUcV]hY`^]cgcVUg
]bjU`]X]hYhcadf]\jUU^idcghc^Yig]hiUW]^i cf]!
^Ybh]fUb]gij`Ugh]h]afYgifg]aU `Ubcj]aUgjc^Y
cV]hY`^] cX _c^]\ XcV]jU^i bU^jYi dcXf_i  U XU
]bgh]hiW]^Y _U_cWf_jYbYhU_cbYj`UX]bY]j`UX]bY 
hfYVU^iV]h]jYUdchdcfUgUa]acV]hY`^]aUg]bjU!
`]X]hYhca"

Ghc[U V] hfYVU`c cV`]_cjUh] a^YfY gcW]^U`bY ]


cV]hY`^g_Y dc`]h]_Y bU bU]b XU gY cac[i] Vc`^U
dchdcfU" DchfYVbc ^Y ghjUfUh] ij^YhY i Xfihji
_c^] Y Xcdf]b]^Yh] Vc`^Ya ig_`U]jUb^i b^]\c!
j]\ dchfYVU  cg][ifUh] aUhYf]^U`bY ij^YhY ]jchU 
fUnbcjfgbcgh]XcghidbcghgYfj]gUnUcgcVYg]bjU!
`]X]hYhca]fcX]hY`^YhYjYi^Ujbi]bZcfa]fUbcgh
cb^]\cj]adfUj]aU"


:cfaU`b]gighUj]dcXf_YgibYnUXcjc`^U!
jU^i]dfYaUfYni`hUh]aUcjc[df][cXbc[incf_U
hY ^Y dchfYVbc  dcfUX]h] i bUX]`U Yb^i dfYdfY_U
_U_cV]ZcfaU`b]gighUjdcXf_YcV]hY`^]aUcgcVU
g ]bjU`]X]hYhca nU]ghU ^Ua]c Xcghidbcgh gcW]^U`!
b]\ dfUjU" CgcVY g ]bjU`]X]hYhca gi ^c bYnUXc!
jc`^b]^Y cX gUa]\ fcX]hY`^U df]aUb^Ya ZcfaU`bY
g`i VYdcXf_Y"

Cj]a]ghfU ]jUb^YaXcV]jYbUgibY_Ucgbcj!
bUcV]`^Y ^UYacW]cbU`bc[ghUb^U]dcXf_YXj]^i
g_id]bU]gd]hUb]_U aYih]acghU`c^Y^cabc[c
bYfUn^Ub^Yb]\ X]`YaU hY V] i ViXibcgh] V]`c
dchfYVbcdfcjYgh]XU`^b^U]ghfU ]jUb^UbUcjihYai
]hc_cb_fYhbcidcnbUh]hcgjYinfc_i^YUb_g]c!
nbcghfcX]hY`^U ]ghfU ]h][fidYnUgUacdcac_c^Y
gi fcX]hY`^]aU ]nb]abc jU bY i XcV]jUb^i ]bZcf!
aUW]^U cX_iXdfc]n`Un]bYnUXcjc`^ghjcdfi Ub^U
dcXf_Y Xf Ujb]\ ]bgh]hiW]^U ]hX" FYni`hUh] cjc[
]ghfU ]jUb^U dfYXghUj`^U^i idcncfYb^Y _fYUhcf]aU
gcW]^U`b]\gYfj]gUXUcV]hY`^]cgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhca
bY dYfW]d]fU^i dfi Ybi dcXf_i nUXcjc`^UjU^i!
ca  hc gjU_U_c bY V] hfYVU`c nUbYaUf]h] ] bU
YaiV]hfYVU`cdcfUX]h]"

?Uc hc ^Y bU dcYh_i gdcaYbihc  cV]hY`^]


cgcVUg]bjU`]X]hYhca]aU^igjc^icXfYYbiX]bU!
a]_i]bU]`UnYbUcXfYYbYdfcV`YaY dchY_cY
] bYgi[`Ug]WY ghc[U ^Y dchfYVbc i nU^YXb]W] cg]!
[ifUh]dchfYVbidcac]dcXf_i"Cg]aghfibc[
cgcV`^U i WYbhf]aU nU cX[c^ ] cVfUncjUb^Y  hY
WYbhf]aU nU fY\UV]`]hUW]^i _c^Y dc\UU^i b^]\cjU
X^YWU dchfYVbc^Ycg][ifUh]]Xfi[YcV`]_Ydcac!
]  _Uc hc gi bdf" gdYW]^U`]n]fUbU gUj^YhcjU`]hU
hY XUh] dcXf_i cf[Ub]nUW]^UaU W]j]`bc[ XfihjU

+/

NXfUj_U@YihUf 5bUhUaVi_.=bjU`]X]hYhicV]hY`^]]]njcf]dcXf_Y

B_j[hWjkhW0
%" 6UZh]f] "&$$'"CgcVbU]gcW]^U`bUdf]`U[cXVUiUXc`YgWYbUhUgbUdfYXi^ica]bYbUdfYXi^icah^Y`Ygbca
]bjU`]Xbcgh]"AU[]ghUfg_]fUX"GjYi]`]hYiNU[fYVi"AYX]W]bg_]ZU_i`hYh"
&" 7`cYf_Yg  ;" %--+" Gcn]c`c[]Y XYf 6Y\]bXYfhYb" 9]bY 9]bZiY\fib[" <Y]XYY`VYf[. K]bhYf  Dfc[fUaa 9X"
GW\]bXY`Y"
'" cf] "%--,"Dg]\c`c[]^UfY`][]cnbcgh]"NU[fYV.G`Ud"
(" 8YbcbU ="%---"CdhYfYYb^YfcX]hY`^UX^YWYgWYfYVfU`bcadUfU`]nca!igdcfYXVUcYjU]aU^_]"IA"Dcgd]
if" ?jU`]hYhU ]j`^Yb^UcgcVUgWYfYVfU`bcadUfU`]ncaghf"+'!+-"NU[fYV.<fjUhg_]gUjYniXfi[UWYfYVfU`bY
]X^Y^YdUfU`]nY"
)" 8YbcbU =" 6Uh]b] A"%---"DfcV`Ya]df]\jUUb^U]df]`U[cXVYfcX]hY`^UbUX]^YhYgWYfYVfU`bcadUfU`]nca"I
A"Dcgd]if" CgdcgcV`^UjUb^YfcX]hY`^UnUdf]a^YfYb]hfYhaUbX^YhYhUgWYfYVfU`bcadUfU`]ncaghf"%)'!%*$"
JUfU X]bg_YHcd`]WY.Hcb]a]f"
*" 8YbcbU =" 6Uh]b] A"&$$&"DfcV`Ya]df]\jUUb^U]df]`U[cXVYfcX]hY`^UbUX]^YhYgWYfYVfU`bcadUfU`]nca"I
A"Dcgd]if" NbUb^YaXc]n^YXbUUjUb^Uac[ibcgh]nUcgcVYg]bjU`]X]hYhcaghf"*&!+$"NU[fYV.<fjUhg_]
gUjYniXfi[UWYfYVfU`bY]X^Y^YdUfU`]nY"
+" 8fchUf 8"%--)"7cbgi`h]b[k]h\dYX]Uhf]W]Ubg.dgmW\c`c[]WU`dYfgdYWh]jYg"BYkMcf_.D`Ybia"
," :fcY\`]W\ 5"%-,*"8]YAiYhhYfgW\kYfghVY\]bXYfhYf?]bXYf"<Y]XY`VYf[.<J5#9X]h]cbGW\]bXY`Y"
-" ;^if] ;"%--%"FcX]hY`^]]ZYVf]`cbcX]^YhY"I<"?c[c^if" FUXcj]AYX]W]bg_c[ZU_i`hYhUiNU[fYVighf"
*%!**"NU[fYV"
%$";fYYbgdUb G" K]YXYf G"&$$'"8]^YhYgdcgYVb]adchfYVUaU"@Y_Yb]_"
%%"<U``Yf  A" %-,+" ?i`hifY``Y ;YaY]bgUa_Y]h ! ghUUh`]W\Y ;fYbnYb3 KYfhcf]Ybh]Yfib[Yb XYf xghYffY]W\Yf ibX
GXh]fc`Yf ]a JYf[`Y]W\ ]b KYfh\U`hib[Yb ibX @YVYbgZcfaYb ]b xghYffY]W\" K]Yb. F" C`XYbVcif[ JYf`U[ 
AbW\Yb#JYf`U[Zf;YgW\]W\hYibXDc`]h]_"
%&"<Yfn][ >"%--'"Nif@YVYbgg]hiUh]cbjcbJUYhYfb_cYfdYfVY\]bXYfhYf?]bXYf"6Y\]bXYfhY]b:Ua]`]Y GW\i`Y
ibX;YgY``gW\UZh%* ('!)$"
%'"<]bnY 8"8"%--&"JUYhYfVY\]bXYfhYf?]bXYf"=\fYVYgcbXYfYb GW\k]Yf][_Y]hYb ibX 7\UbWYb"  ;Y]gh][Y
6Y\]bXYfib['% %')!%(&"
%("<``]b[Yf  :"  <U``Yf  A"  %--$" ?]bg\]d UbX GcW]U` BYhkcf_g ]b AcXYfb GcW]Yh]Yg. 5 7fcgg!7i`hifU`
7cadUf]gcbUacb[GYjYbBUh]cbg"9ifcdYUbGcW]c`c[]WU`FYj]Yk* %$'!%&("
%)"<cfjUh]  >" %---" 9acW]cbU`bc fYU[]fUb^Y cgcVU g WYfYVfU`bca dUfU`]nca" I  A" Dcgd] if"   ?jU`]hYhU
]j`^Yb^UcgcVUgWYfYVfU`bcadUfU`]nca ghf",(!,*NU[fYV.<fjUhg_]gUjYniXfi[UWYfYVfU`bY]X^Y^YdUfU`!
]nY"
%*">cbUg A"%--$"HfUiYfibX5ihcbca]YVY]AiYhhYfbVY\]bXYfhYf?]bXYf"AY]bn.;fbYkU`X"
%+"?U``YbVUW\ ?"%--+"J}hYfgW\kYfghVY\]bXYfhYf?]bXYf"AbghYf BYkMcf_ AbW\Yb 6Yf`]b"
%,"?]!;`UjU  @" :i`[cg]!AUgb^U_  F"  6Yni_!>U_cj]bU >" &$$&" FcX]hY`^ghjc ] gifUXb^U" I @" ?]!;`UjU  F"
AUgb^U_!:i`[cn]if" 8cdf]\jUUb^UnU^YXbc.=bhY[fUW]^UX^YWYgdcgYVb]adchfYVUaUghf"%,$!%,,"NU[fYV.
<fjUhg_UiXfi[UnUghfibidcacX^YW]gdcgYVb]adchfYVUaU"
%-"?iaUf ;"&$$&"CV]hY`^]WYfYVfU`bUdUfU`]nU"IA"Dcgd]if" NbUb^YaXc]n^YXbUUjUb^Uac[ibcgh]nU
cgcVYg]bjU`]X]hYhcaghf"+$!+&"NU[fYV.<fjUhg_]gUjYniXfi[UWYfYVfU`bY]X^Y^YdUfU`]nY"
&$"@YihUf N"&$$$":Ua]`]}fYKYfhcf]Ybh]Yfib[Yb]b?fcUh]Yb]aJYf[`Y]W\nixghYffY]W\ibXDc`Yb"8]ggYfhUh]cb"
?Uf`:fUbnYbgIb]jYfg]h}h";fUn"
&%"@YihUf N"&$$%"FY`][]cnbcghcV]hY`^]i<fjUhg_c^ 5ighf]^]]Dc`^g_c^"6c[cg`cjg_UgachfU% ,)!%$+"
,&

<fjUhg_UfYj]^UnUfY\UV]`]hUW]^g_U]ghfU ]jUb^U&$$+ Jc`(' Vf"% ghf"(+!*%

&&"@YihUf N" FU^] ="&$$%"8]^YhYgaYbhU`bcafYhUfXUW]^caicV]hY`^]"@^Yhcd]gghiX]^g_c[WYbhfUgcW]^U`bc[fUXU


-% &-!(+"
&'"B]_c`] G"%--*"Gj]^YhX^Y^Ydg]\Y!CgbcjYaYX]W]bg_YX^Y^Ydg]\c`c[]^Y"NU[fYV.Dfcgj^YhU"
&("B]lcb 7"8"%--'"FYXiW]b[GY`Z!6`UaYUbX;i]`h]bDUfYbhgcZ7\]`XfYbk]h\GYjYfY8]gUV]`]h]Yg":Ua]`]Yg 
X]gUV]`]hmUbXYadckYfaYbh"6U`h]acfY"
&)"Bcc^]b  5" 6"   KU``UbXYf  >" @" %--*" 8YjY`cdaYbh UbX 9jU`iUh]cb cZ U AYUgifY cZ 7cbWYfbg FY`UhYX hc
FU]g]b[U7\]`Xk]h\D\mg]WU`8]gUV]`]hm">cifbU`cZDYX]Uhf]WDgmW\c`c[m&%( (,'!(-,"
&*"C`g\Ubg_m G"%-*&"7\fcb]Wgcffck.5fYgdcbgYhc\Uj]b[UaYbhU``mXYZYWh]jYW\]`X"GcW]U`7UgYkcf_(' 
%-$!%-'"
&+"Fia]\U 6"&$$%"CV]hY`^]X]^YhYgdcgYVb]adchfYVUaU!nU^YXbccXfUghUacibUYajfh]i"IA"AUh]^Yj]
if" NVcfb]_I]hY`^g_YU_UXYa]^YiNU[fYVi'% '))!'*%"NU[fYV"
&,"GW\i`n K"%--*V"9\YibX:Ua]`]Y]bxghYffY]W\]aKUbXY`.KYfhY @YVYbgZcfaYbibX@YVYbgeiU`]h}h/%-,*
V]g%--'#\fg["]b<U``Yf A" <c`a ?"A``YfA"?"GW\i`n K"7mVU9"xghYffY]W\]bKUbXY` dd"
%'-!%*-"JYf`U[Zf;YgW\]W\hYibXDc`]h]_ C`XYbVif["
&-"GW\i`n K" ;`ig_Y <" @YbhgW\ 5"%--*U"DUfhbYfniZf]YXYb\Y]h :Ua]`]YbniZf]YXYb\Y]hibX@YVYbgeiU`]h}h"
=b" A" <U``Yf  ?" <c`a  A" ?" A``Yf  K" GW\i`n   9" 7mVU  9Xg"  xghYffY]W\ ]b KUbXY` dd" %))!%+&"
C`XYbVif[.JYf`U[Zf;YgW\]W\hYibXDc`]h]_"
'$"GY`][aUb A"%--+"CfX]bUfmZUa]`]Yg gdYW]U`W\]`XfYb.UgmghYagUddfcUW\hcW\]`X\ccXX]gUV]`]hm"BYkMcf_.
H\Y;i]`ZcfXDfYgg"
'%"G]b[Yf ;"<"G" =fj]b @"?" =fj]b 6" <Uk_]bg B"9" <Y[fYYbYgg >" >UW_gcb F"%--'"<U`d]b[:Ua]`]Yg5XUdh
Dcg]h]jY`mhc8]gUV]`]hm":Ua]`]Yg X]gUV]`]hmUbXYadckYfaYbh6U`h]acfY *+!,&"
'&"IfVUbW ?"%---"CgcVbU]dfcZYg]cbU`bUcX[cjcfbcghgcW]^U`bc[fUXb]_Uidfca]WUb^i_jU`]hYhY ]jchUcgcVU
g h^Y`Ygb]a ]bjU`]X]hYhca  I A" Dcgd] if"   ?jU`]hYhU ]j`^Yb^U cgcVU g WYfYVfU`bca dUfU`]nca ghf" ,-!-'"
NU[fYV.<fjUhg_]gUjYniXfi[UWYfYVfU`bY]X^Y^YdUfU`]nY"

:?I78?B?JOM?J>?D<7C?BO7D:IEKH9;IE<IKFFEHJ
 J^_i meha Z[Wbi m_j^ %Z_iWX_b_jo m_j^_d \Wc_bo" WdZ m_j^ Xej^ \ehcWb WdZ _d\ehcWb iekhY[i e\ ikffehj$ ?d _ji
_djheZkYj_edj^[h[^Wl[X[[di^emdj^[h[ikbjie\WdkcX[he\^ec[WdZ\eh[_]dh[i[WhY^[iedZ_iWX_b_jom_j^_d\Wc_b_o"
edj^[heb[e\fWh[djiWdZf[hiedim_j^Z_iWX_b_joj^[ci[bl[i"WdZedj^[_cfehjWdY[e\ikffehj$J^[d\ebbemij^[WdWboi_i
e\j^[h[ikbjie\Wh[i[WhY^YedZkYj[Zed-'&f[efb[\hecWbbel[h9heWj_W*,.f[hiedim_j^Z_iWX_b_joWdZ(*(fWh[djie\
f[hiedim_j^Z_iWX_b_jo0WXekjj^[_h[cej_edWbijWj["m^ej^[oWh[]_l[dikffehj\hec"m^ej^[ojWbaWXekjj^[_hfheXb[ci
m_j^"WdZm^[h[j^[odZijh[d]j^\ehb_\[$J^[h[ikbjie\j^[h[i[WhY^^Wl[i^emdj^Wj\Wc_b_[ij^WjYef[m_j^Z_iWX_b_jo
Wh[ceijbo\ebbem[ZXomehho"j[di_edWdZ[cej_edWb[n^Wkij_ed$FWh[djiWh[ceh[Wdn_ekij^Wdf[hiedim_j^Z_iWX_b_jo
j^[ci[bl[i$Fei_j_l[[cej_edi"ikY^WiiWj_i\WYj_ed"Wh[fh[i[djWced]c[cX[hie\j^[\Wc_b_[i"WdZceh[e\j[dfh[i[dj
Wced]f[hiedim_j^Z_iWX_b_joj^[ci[bl[i$IjWj_ij_YWbboh[b[lWdjZ_\\[h[dY[i^Wl[X[[d\ekdZX[jm[[d[cej_edWbijWj[e\j^[
fWh[djiWdZf[hiedim_j^Z_iWX_b_joj^[ci[bl[i$8ej^]hekfie\ikX`[Yji][j_d\ehcWbmWoie\ikffehj\hecj^[c[cX[hi
e\j^[\Wc_b_oWdZ\h_[dZi$FWh[dji][jceije\ikffehj\hecY^_bZh[dWdZcWhh_W][fWhjd[hi"WdZf[hiedim_j^Z_iWX_b_jo
\hecfWh[djiWdZfWhjd[hi$<ehcWb\ehcie\ikffehjWh[feehWdZ_dik\Y_[dj$
@ZnldgYh/Y^hVW^a^inl^i]^c[Vb^a^n!eVgZcih!eZghdchl^i]Y^hVW^a^in!Zbdi^dcVahiViZ![dgbVaVcY^c[dgbVahjeedgi
,'

You might also like