COMPARISON OF IS 3589, IS 5504 WITH API 5L AND ASTM A252 Gr2

S.N.

PARAMETER

IS 3589

CHEMICAL
COMPOSITION

CARBON EQUIVALENT

PURCHASER
REQUIREMENT

MIN . SPECIFIED YS = MIN . SPECIFIED YS =

YIELD STRENGTH(YS) 235 MPa, MAX. LIMIT 240 MPa, MAX. LIMIT
NOT SPECIFIED
NOT SPECIFIED

MIN . SPECIFIED YS = 241 MIN . SPECIFIED YS = 241

MPa, MAX. NOT SPECIFIED MPa, MAX. SPECIFIED YS =
448 MPa

TENSILE STRENGTH
(UTS)

C=0.20
%MAX; C=0.25
S=0.04%MAX & P=0.04 %MAX;S=0.05%MAX &
% MAX ; Mn =1.30 MAX P=0.05 % MAX ;
NOT MENTIONED

IMPACT TESTING

HARDNESS TESTING

DWTT

MECHANICAL
TESTING FREQUENCY

FUT CALIBRATION
PIPE

10

BODY REPAIR

11

12

IS 5504

NOT MENTIONED

API 5L PSL2 GR.B

C=0.26 %MAX; S=0.03%MAX C=0.22 %MAX; S=0.015%MAX

& P=0.03 % MAX ; Mn =1.20 & P=0.025 % MAX ; Mn =1.20
MAX
MAX
MANDATORY REQUIREMENT (
MAX 0.43 % )

MIN .
SPECIFIED MIN .
SPECIFIED MIN .
SPECIFIED VALUE MIN . SPECIFIED VALUE 414
VALUE 410 MPa, MAX. VALUE 410 MPa, MAX. 414
MPa,
MAX.
NOT MPa, MAX. 758 Mpa
NOT SPECIFIED
NOT SPECIFIED
SPECIFIED
NOT REQUIRED

NOT REQUIRED

PURCHASER
REQUIREMENT

MANDATORY REQUIREMENT (
MIN 27 JULES AT 0 DEG.
CENTIGRADE )

NOT REQUIRED

NOT REQUIRED

PURCHASER
REQUIREMENT

PURCHASER REQUIREMENT

NOT REQUIRED

NOT REQUIRED

NOT REQUIRED

PURCHASER REQUIREMENT

ONE PIPE/HEAT

ONE PIPE /LOT OF 200 ONE PIPE/100 PIPE/HEAT

LENGTH OR LESS

ONE PIPE/100 PIPE/HEAT

TWO NOTCH & ONE TWO NOTCH & ONE TWO NOTCH & ONE TDH TWO NOTCH & ONE TDH
TDH HOLE
TDH HOLE
HOLE
HOLE
ALLOWED

ALLOWED

ALLOWED

NOT ALLOWED

SILENT

SILENT

1.59 mm MAX.When WT less

than 12.7 mm
&
0.125t/3.18mm which ever is
MIN when WT greater than
12.7 mm

1.59 mm MAX.When WT less

than 12.7 mm
&
0.125t/3.18mm which ever is
MIN when WT greater than 12.7
mm

PLATE OFF SET

DENT

API 5L PSL1 GR.B

d = 6MM WHEN OD <610 SILENT

MM , D=1% OF OD
WHEN OD>610 MM .L=
1/2 OD

d = 6.35mm & length 1/2 OD d=6.35mm & length 1/2 OD for

for shallow dent ,3.18 mm & shallow dent ,3.18 mm & length
length 1/2 OD for sharp dent 1/2 OD for sharp dent

13

14

15

BEAD HEIGHT

60% OF WT FOR ID, SILENT

FOR
OD
NOT
SPECIFIED

3.18 mm when WT less 3.18 mm MAX.when WT less

than12.7mm & 4.76mm when than12.7mm
&
4.76mm
WT greater than 12.7mm
MAX.when WT greater than
12.7mm

SILENT

SILENT

d = 0.79mm & L = 1/2 t ,max 2 d = 0.79mm & L = 1/2 t ,max 2

nos in 300mm, d = 0.4 mm & nos in 300mm, d = 0.4 mm & L
L =1/2 t for any length
=1/2 t for any length any length

+20% & -12.5%

PLUS 15% TO
12.5%

PURCHASER
REQUIREMENT

4 TO 7 METERS FOR
SINGLE
RANDOM
LENGTH AND 7 TO 14
METERS FOR DOUBLE
RANDOM LENGTH

0.75% OD

0.75% UPTO 1000mm -0.79mm, +2.38mm when OD -0.79mm, +2.38mm when OD >
OD, 1% OVER 1000mm > 20"
20"
OD

SILENT

SILENT

0.75% when OD < 20",

+0.75% - 0.25% when
OD
20" and 36", +6.35mm,
-3.20mm > 36"

1% OF OD

0.75%

1% OF OD

0.75% when OD < 20", +0.75%

- 0.25% when
OD
20"
and 36", +6.35mm, -3.20mm >
36"
1% OF OD

0.2 % OF TOTAL LENGTH

0.2 % OF TOTAL LENGTH

UNDERCUT

THICKNESS
TOLERANCE

16

PIPE LENGTH

17

END DIAMETER

18

BODY DIAMETER

19

OVALITY

20

STRAIGHTNESS

21

INSIDE WELD BEAD

GRINDING

22

SQUARENESS

23

DIFFERENCE OF END
DIAMETER

24

WEIGHT

0.2
%
LENGTH

OF

TOTAL SILENT

MINUS +15%, -12.5% when OD <

20", +17.5%, -12.5% (GrB or
lower), +19.5%, -8.0% (Gr X42 or Higher), WHEN OD > 20
"
2.74 M to 6.86 M WITH AVG.
OF 5.33M 4.27 M to 13.72 M
WITH AVG. OF 10.67 M , 5.33
M to 16.76M WITH AVG
OF13.35 M,6.40 M TO
19.81M WITH AVG OF 16.0 M
,8.53 M to 25.91 M WITH
AVG. OF 21.34 M

+15%, -12.5% when OD < 20",

+17.5%, -12.5% (GrB or lower),
+19.5%, -8.0% (Gr X-42 or
Higher), WHEN OD > 20 "
2.74 M to 6.86 M WITH AVG. OF
5.33M 4.27 M to 13.72 M WITH
AVG. OF 10.67 M , 5.33 M to
16.76M WITH AVG OF13.35
M,6.40 M TO 19.81M WITH AVG
OF 16.0 M ,8.53 M to 25.91 M
WITH AVG. OF 21.34 M

MIN. 100 MM

SILENT

MIN. 100 MM

MIN. 100 MM

1.6 MM

SILENT

1.59 MM

1.59 MM

SILENT

SILENT

2.38 MM

2.38 MM

" +10% ,- 3.5%

SILENT

" +10% ,- 3.5%

" +10% ,- 3.5%

PREPARED BY: SUNIL PATEL

M A252 Gr2
ASTM A252 Gr2
P=0.050 % MAX

NOT MENTIONED

MIN . SPECIFIED YS = 240 MPa,

MAX. LIMIT NOT SPECIFIED
MIN . SPECIFIED VALUE 415
MPa, MAX. NOT SPECIFIED
NOT REQUIRED

NOT REQUIRED
NOT REQUIRED

ONE PIPE /LOT OF 200

LENGTH
TWO NOTCH & ONE TDH HOLE

ALLOWED

SILENT

SILENT

SILENT

SILENT

Max :12.5% & Min :tnx0.875 (tn :

nominal wall thickness, in)

SINGLE RANDOM LENGTH : 16

to 25 ft,
DOUBLE RANDOM
LENGTH :OVER 25ft with a min
AVERAGE of 35 ft , UNIFORM
LENGTH : Length as specified
with a permissible variation of 1
in

THE OUT SIDE DIAMETER OF

THE PIPE SHALL NOT MORE
THAN 1% FROM THE
SPECIFIED OUT SIDE
DIAMETER

SILENT
SILENT

SILENT
SILENT
SILENT

SILENT