You are on page 1of 1

PrimarySource:ShouldAmericadroptheatomicbombonJapan?

1. WhatreasondoesTrumanoffertojustifytheuseoftheatomicbomb?

TrumanthoughtthathewouldsavemanyAmericanlivesandshortenthewar.Theexcerpt
states,wehaveuseditinordertosavethelivesofthousandsandthousandsofyoung
Americans.HisdutyaspresidentwastouseanyweaponavailabletoreserveAmerican
lives.Trumanalsobelievedthatthiswastheonlyresolutiontotheconflict.
2. WhydoesLeahysayhewasagainstusingthebomb?

Leahysaysthatkillingcitizensindiscriminatelygoesagainstmorals.Leahysays,I

wasnot
taughttomakewarinthatfashion,andwarscannotbewonbydestroyingwomenand
children.
3. Whomdoyouthinkmakethemorepersuasiveargument?Explainyouranswer.

Trumanmadethemorepersuasiveargumentbecausehehadmorelogicalreasonsfor
droppingtheatomicbombthatLeahy.However,IbelievethatLeahymadesomereasonable
pointsfordropping.Droppingthebombcausedunnecessarydestruction.

You might also like