, ,

,

,
: ,
2003,
.1


,
.



.
.

(
) ,
, ,

.
1

. , . , . : .
, , .
10 (2001), . 3-44 J. Christianidis, D. Dialetis, K. Gavroglu: Having a knack for the nonintuitive: Aristarchus Heliocentrism through Archimedes Geocentrism, History of Science,
. XL (2002), . 147-168 . , . , . :
: , , . 12 (2003), . 3555.

50

,


, , .
,
,
.
,
,


.

(
)
. 19
20 ,
, ,

. , ,

.
.
, ,
, ,
,
.

(1473-1543)

. ,
T.L.
Heath.2

T.L. Heath: Aristarchus of Samos, the Ancient Copernicus, New York, Dover, 1981.
( , 1913)

51

, , , ,
.

20
, ,

.

( ),
.

,
, ,
.

.

,
.

, , .
, (,
, ),
, ,
, ,

. , , ,
, ,
, . ,




,.
( , ,
),
,
,

52

. ,
,
,
, ,


, ,
.
-
,
, ,


.
,


.
:

;

;
;
,
;
, :
;

,
;

20
( )
,

53

.3


.
,
,
,
.

Heath
.

:

.
.
.

.
.
Heath
.
.


.
.


.
, :

,
, ;
,

Owen Gingerich, Did Copernicus owe a
debt to Aristarchus?, Journal for the History of Astronomy, . 16 (1985), . 37-42.

54

, ,
,
, ;

;

, ,


,

.



.

,
, .
,

,
,

, ,
.

, ,
, ,
,
,
.


.


,

55

.

,

.

,
, ,
, ,

, ,

.
:


,
,
, ,
,
, . ,
,

, ,
, .
.
1
.. ,
,
.
,
( / ) .

, /
. :
(
) (

56

). ,


.4




, ,

.
5

,
.

,
.

.

,
.
,
,
,

4

,
. , , De revolutionibus, .
5
. , 1.

57

.
Weisheit und Wissenschaft: Studien zu Pythagoras,
Philolaos und Plato6 Walter Burkert
: ,

,
, , []
..
,
,
.
, .
,

,
.7

D.R. Dicks
.8
:
1.
.
2.
,
, .
3.
,
,
, ,
.
4. ,

Nrnberg, Verlag Hans Carl, 1962. Edwin L. Minar, Jr.

Lore and Science in Ancient Pythagoreanism, Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press, 1972. Burkert
.
7
W. Burkert: .., . 9-10.
8
D.R. Dicks: , , . .
, , - . , 1991, . 84.

58

6 .. ,
,
5 ,

.
5. (3 .. .)
(4 .. .) ,
, ,

.


,


.
.

, ,
, ,

: Aristarchus of Samos, the
ancient Copernicus T.L. Heath (1913) D.R. Dicks
(1970) .
Heath
: , ,
,
, ,



, .9
, , Dicks
Heath : T.L. Heath
(6
9

T.L. Heath: .., . 51. .

94.

59

..) . []

.10
,

, , ,

.

,
:
)
,
.
)
.


.
, (. 220 ..).
,11

. , . (. 48-49)
:
[. ]
. , (. 21)
, :
..

.
,
,
.
,
. ,
10

D.R. Dicks: .., . 85-86.

(Vitae philosophorum).
11

60

,

.12
. ,

. , ,
, ,
,
,
,
.
(
,
),
, ,
( ),
.

. ,
5 .. .,


.13
(. 100 ..),
, ,
( ), ,
14 .

, .
,
400 ..

12

5 .. .
. W. Burkert: .., . 337 . 3. B.L. van der Waerden
Die Astronomie der Pythagoreer (Verh. d. kon. Ned. Ak. v. Wet., Afd. Natuurk. I 20.1,
1951, . 49 .., 54)
,
360 .. (. D.R. Dicks: .., . 93).
14
(. W. Burkert: .., . 228-229).
13

61

, , ,
,
. , (293a17293b30) :
, ,

,
.
, , , ,
, ,
. , , ,
,


.
, , [ ]
,

.
,
,

[] .
, ,
[]
, , ,
, (. )
,
[ ]
. []

,
. ,

, ,
.

62

,
. , ,


[ ].
[ ]
[ ], , ,


[
]
[ ].


( 520 ..),

.

15 :
, [ , ]

[ ] .
.

, , ,
, , . ,
, ,
.
, , ,
, ,

, ,
. [ ]
15

Simplicius: In Aristotelis quattuor libros de caelo commentaria, . J.L. Heiberg. : Commentaria in Aristotelem Graeca, . 7, Berlin, Reimer, 1894, . 511, 20 512, 20.

63

[]. ,
, ,
, .
, ,
,
. , ,
(.
)

,
, .
,
[] . , ,
[ ] , [ ] []
, .
, ,
.
,

. ,
[],
, [ ] [.
], , , .

,


. , , [] ,
, [
], ,
, [ ] .



.
: )
. )

64

. )
.
.
1)
, ( ),
( ).
2) ,
.
3)
, ..
.16
4) ,
, (;)
(
). ,
,
.


.

,
, , ,
.


,
.
,


.

.

16

, , (. D.R. Dicks: .., . 91).

65

(
)
. ,
,
.

(De placitis)
100 ..
, ,
,
(. 470 .).


.

,17
, :
[ ] [] ,
, ,
, , , .
, [ ] [
]. [ ] [],
[] ,
, , ,
, , ,

. , [ ]
[ ],
, ,
,
, . ,
,
,

17

H. Diels (.): Doxographi Graeci, Berlin, Reimer, 1879, . 336-337.

66

.
Heath ( Diels)
(

)
,
.18
Heath
,
.
,
.19

,
.

.

5 ..
.

.



.
, ,
,
.
, , , ,
,
.
, , ,
18
19

T.L. Heath: .., . 97, . 3.

. W. Burkert: .., . 243 ..

67

(Quaestiones Academicae priores, II, 39),

,
.
,
,
, . (
)
, (5 .. .).
,
, 5 ..
.
.


.
:
)
.

.
)
( , ..),
,
,
, .
.


.
, , .

.


, ,
,
.

68

.
.
P. Duhem, ,
, ,
.20
Heath:
. [] ,

.21 Heath
,
()
. , van der Waerden
Die Astronomie der Pythagoreer
,

,
.
.

. Walter
Burkert,
.
:
,

,
,
,
.22 , ,



.


20

P. Duhem: Le Systme du Monde, . I, Paris, Hermann, 1913, . 8.

T.L. Heath: .., . 49.
22
W. Burkert: .., . 303.
21

69

:
) Duhem
, ,

.23 , ,
.
Duhem 40b8-c3,

,

,
.24
)
25 (, . 25),
,
,
.26 :

.



23

P. Duhem: .., . 8.
. , 1.
25
21 . ( 5 .. ).
26

. , , , , .. ( 3 .. .) (2 .. .), .
,
(. 160 ..) , , , ,
.
24

70

,
,
, , , ,
, , ,
,
.

, .27
, ,
.
.

.
() .
.

. Duhem
.
) ,
, .

, Heath
,
, ,
,
. , ,
Heath, .
(, 10,
218a33) :
[] ,
27

, (, , ,
, ), , , Duhem (.., . 8, . 3), .

71

.
( Heath):
Some (of the Pythagoreans) say that time is the motion of the whole
(universe), others that it is the sphere itself.28

(I, 8, 40b):
[ .] <> [ ]
.
( Heath):
Pythagoras held time to be the sphere of the enveloping (heaven).29
,
, . ,
,
, .
() ,

.30

(
), Heath .
, ,
, ,
.
Heath

, ,
(

28

T.L. Heath: .., . 49.

T.L. Heath: .., . 49.
30
Ioannis Philoponos: Ioannis Philoponi in Aristotelis physicorum libros octo commentaria, 2 ., . H. Vitelli. : Commentaria in Aristotelem Graeca, . 16-17,
Berlin, Reimer, 1887-1888, . 17, . 709, 5.
29

72

< > ,

31). ,
, , : <
> ,

,
.32 Heath


(
) .



Heath .

Heath Pythagoras
(. 46-51)
.
Heath , ,
.


, ,

.
, ,
(I, 24, 2b),
,

. :
( )
31

Simplicius: In Aristotelis physicorum libros octo commentaria, 2 ., . H. Diels. : Commentaria in Aristotelem Graeca, . 9-10, Berlin, Reimer, 1882-1895,
. 9, . 700, 17-19.
32
Simplicius: .., . 700, 19-22.

73

.
<>.
, ,
. , Heath,
.33

34.
Heath;
Tannery :


.
, ,


, ,
. ,
()
().35 Heath
Burnet
,36
: ,
Tannery.37 , Heath,
!
Heath , ,

33

T.L. Heath: .., . 50.

, . ( ..

, , ,
.)
, , 500 ..
35
P. Tannery: Pour lhistoire de la science hellne, 2 , Paris, Gauthier-Villars,
1930, . 213-214. ( .)
36
J. Burnet: Early Greek Philosophy, 4 , London, 1930, . 123, note.
37
T.L. Heath: .., . 50.
34

74

.
.


Heath
,
,
. , ,
,
Heath,
, .
, ,
,
.
. , , J.L.E.
Dreyer (1852-1926),
Heath ,
.
.38

4 .. ,

,39
, , ,
,

( Ereli )
.

38

J.L.E. Dreyer: A History of Astronomy fron Thales to Kepler. New York, Dover, 1953.
History of the Planetary Systems from Thales to Kepler, 1906.
39
. :
1.

75

,
3 .. .40


,
.

, .


. 41
:
[ ]
,

, ,
.
, ,
, , ,
.

,
, ()
, ,
, , (
) ,
,
. : ,
,

.

40

4
3 .. .
41
, . , . . . , , 1974, . 180, 20 - 182, 19.

76

: , ,
, ,
,
, ( )
,

(),
,
, , .

,
.
.
, ,
,
.
, R
, , ,
(, R ).

.
;
, ,

, , .

, (
)
,
(), .

.42
42

, Heath . 303-304 , , ,
.
.

77

,
.43

, ,
,
. , ,
,
. , ,



.
, ,
, ,


,
.
, ,
,
:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
43

.
.

.
.

, J.L. Heiberg, P. Ver Eecke Heath

A manual of Greek Mathematics,
. ,
.

. , : .

78

.
,
,

.
,
, , ,

.
, ,
,
,
,
. ,

: = : .

,
,
. ,
4
,
, ,
, ,
() .

.44 , ,
,
, . ,
, ,

,
44

, , . .

79

.
,

.


.
, .
,

,
.

( ,
)
. ,
Heath ,45
,
, ,
. , ,

( , ,
) :
: = :
.
,
.
,

.


,

45

T.L. Heath: .., . 308-309.

80

( /
) .


, ,
.
,
:
; , ,

;

:

, ,

,
.
, ,
,
.
,
,
,
.
.

.

.
, ,
.
, , ,
, .

, , ,
,

81

, ,

;
, ,
,
;
; , , (
) ,
,
,
;
, ,

;
.

.

. , ,

.


,

.
. -
(
)

.

-
,
.

.
:

82

,
, (
)
,
,
.
. ,
,

.

, ;

,

:
: , ,
.
.
, ,
.

,
.

,
, : ,
,

: = :

: = :
.

83

. , ,


,
.


. , ,
.
, ,
,
, ,
,
- . ,
,
,

.


(
) ,

. .
,
.




.

,

.
, ,

, ,
,

84

. ,
,

, , .
modus operandi

.

. ,

.
.
.
,
!

(10) . .
,

. (8) ,
, (2)
(3) .
(4) : (1)
, (1) (2)
I.
(1)
(1)

. (1)
I,
. , ,
, (1) .


.
.

85

,

.
.
.
, ,
,
.
;

;
, ,

;
,
, ,
, ;

.
, , .
, Erchardt Erchardt-Siebold.46

, , ,

;
, ,
. , ,


-
.


.
.

46

R. von Erhardt & E. von Erchardt-Siebold: Archimedes Sand-Reckoner. Aristarchos

and Copernicus, Isis, 33 (1942), . 578-602, . 588 ..

86

( ),

.
,
, . ,
( 300 ..)
,
. , ,
,
( , ..),
.

,
,
,
...

.

.
, ,
, ,
,

.
(
).
,

,
, ,
.