Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MISSION
To present people, ideas, news and views To disseminate information on NGO
periodically to readers to promote movement to improve communication
networking among NGOs. which in turn can catalyze human
development.
Editorial Coordination by P.S.Sundaram, Former Editor, The New Indian Express &
Managing Editor, Media India, at MEDIA INDIA, Hyderabad.
Mail: info@mediaindia.org Phone: 040 2340 1212 /1313 Fax: 040 2340 1414
Printed at: Kalajyothi Process (P) Ltd, RTC X Roads, Hyderabad - 500 020 (A.P.) India
3
Catalyst For Human Development
4
Catalyst For Human Development
Contents
5
Catalyst For Human Development
Authors
P R O F I L E S of A U T H O R S
Dr Pat obtained her BSc from the University of Chaula first came to Ashoka as
California and MS and PhD from Cornell University an intern in the U.S.A./Canada
where she was a National Institutes of Health programme and she did her
Fellow. She underwent practical medical training in Master of Arts in International
Ithaca, NY and rural areas of the US as well as at Relations at Maxwell School at
the Government Maternity Hospital and the Syracuse University and first
Osmania General Hospital in Hyderabad,India. learnt about Ashoka Fellow
Helping the less fortunate was an important goal in Harendra de Silva while writing
her life. She co-founded the Institute for Rural her thesis on Tamil women
Health Studies in 1981. It will celebrate its silver jubilee this October. Pat combatants in Sri Lanka. Before coming to Ashoka, Chaula
spends 10 months of the year in India and two months as a Visiting Faculty worked on a government research project on nuclear ter-
member at the University of Cambridge in England. She is an early Ashoka rorism and at the UN on small-arms disarmament. Chaula
Fellow and has also won the Ashoka and Mc Kinsey Community Based will be a key figure in Ashoka's Global Venture Integration
Investment Award. programming.
6
Catalyst For Human Development
Authors
ASHOKA TEAM:
Ms. Sohini Bhattacharya Ms. Beverly Schwartz
Ms. Nomito Kamdar Ms. Dolon Sen
Ms. Sandhya Moraes Ms. Sandra Sitar
Ms. Devashri Mukherjee Ms. Shivangini Tandon
Ms. Alexis Ettinger Mr. Devin McIntire
Ms. Lily Paul
bruce.margolis@gmail.com
umkumar@gmail.com
Catalyst accepts no responsibility, directly or indirectly, for the views and opinions
expressed by the authors as well as for the pictures used in the articles.
8
Catalyst For Human Development
”
Preface
HE central theme of the third issue of Catalyst is Ashoka, a nonprofit organization devot-
T ed to the cause of developing social entrepreneurship. For-profit organizations like private
companies or publicly held corporations create material wealth for the society while social
entrepreneurs contribute to generate human wealth. It is this human wealth in return that pro-
duces material wealth with a huge multiplier effect to help solve the problem of poverty, one
of the objectives of Catalyst.
It was the genius and insight of late management guru, Peter Ducker who first realized that
Non—Profit Organizations (NPO) or Non—Governmental Organizations (NGO) also required
the application of sound management principles and it resulted in a systematic study to build
a body of knowledge. While the future management historians will appreciate the contribution
of Peter Ducker to NPOs and NGOs, they would equally like to admire the significant contri-
bution of William Drayton for first coining "social entrepreneurship" and then promoting social
entrepreneurs throughout the world.
Ashoka has influenced directly or indirectly many philanthropic organizations like Skoll
foundation started by Jeff Skoll of eBay, Acumen Fund started by Rockefeller Foundation,
Cisco Systems Foundation and three individual philanthropists and many others. Since the
beginning of human history, man has been influenced by an urge to help fellow human
beings. Many successful rich families in every country of the world have always established
charities to help the less fortunate. Though teaching how to fish is better than giving fish is
appreciated by all, it is not often practised. Ashoka not only believes in this old chinese wis-
dom, it has taken one step forward by urging social entrepreneurs to revolutionize fishing
itself.
For a country like India with more than 1.1 billion people, and more than 60% of the popu-
lation actually below the poverty line (official BPL is based on unrealistic criteria), we need
thousands of social entrepreneurs to fight poverty. India's problems like several democracies
are made difficult because of the poor governance, total abdication of one's social responsi-
bilities by the literate class and the resultant non-functioning of democratic institutions.
On paper there are more than a million (some even claim it is two million) NGOs in India.
The fact that Ashoka has been able to identify only about 262 fellows, shows that we need
far more social entrepreneurs. Many NGOs start in India not because of the felt need, but
because of the ready availability of foreign funding. Often the agenda and strategy for some
NGOs are set not based on India's ground realities, but by the perceived objectives of foreign
donors. It is here one can actually admire and appreciate the objectivity of an institution like
Ashoka.
Ashoka model social entrepreneurs are able to contribute significantly today in India even
under the most unfriendly and corrupt political system as shown by many Ashoka -American
India Foundation Fellows. It is our hope and Ashoka's challenge that some of these fellows
will indeed revolutionize "fishing" by bringing systemic changes in the corrupt body politic of
India. Right To Information Act is indeed a big step forward, just like Consumer Protection Act
(CPA) was in 1986, to fight the corrupt system. But we all know that CPA failed to bring about
consumer revolution despite the act being a fine and path—breaking legislation in the world.
Honest, dedicated and competent people often stay away from the messy need of fighting
the system today because politics is bad. We need some outstanding Ashoka Fellows who
can overcome the stigma of politics to cleanse politics while not being swayed by the power.
Dr Bhamy V. Shenoy
9
Catalyst For Human Development
Guest Editorial
VENKATESH M. RAGHAVENDRA
N the evening of what was touted as 7/11 by the Bill Drayton, Founder of Ashoka, coined the term "social
O media, I was sitting in the Bangalore airport on my
way to New Delhi. The TV monitors in the airport started
entrepreneurship" when he initiated the Ashoka
Fellowship in 1980. The term has become part of the
beaming news of the Mumbai train blasts. After the initial mainstream development lexicon now. Today Ashoka,
reactions of shock and anger, the immediate thought that which was first launched in India, operates in 62 countries
came to my mind - what are 'social entrepreneurs' doing and has invested in over 1700 Ashoka Fellows. Ashoka's
about this? My mind then raced to the work of many of paradigm of investing in innovative local solutions and
them I know in Mumbai. nurturing them to national and international scale through
Teesta Setalvad is transforming school curricula to rid a range of support and services has changed the way we
them of religious and other types of biases. Shakil Ahmed view development and philanthropy.
and his team of volunteers help the residents in Mumbai Particularly within the Indian context, social
slums demand their rights and exercise their power as cit- Entrepreneurs are creatively powering the systemic
izens, without fearing the police, the bureaucrats, or the changes that are required to ensure that all citizens
muscle-flexing politicians. Beena Lashkari is equipping receive services, and are fairly treated. At a moment
slum children ages three to eighteen with formal educa- when forces like cable television, the trappings of a con-
tion, keeping them in school. The list goes on. Sonali sumer culture, malls, and fast food chains are conspiring
Ojha working with youth, Shielu Srinivasan focusing on to raise the aspiration levels of the emergent Indian yup-
senior citizens, Mathew Spacie using sports as a vehicle pie, social entrepreneurs provide the perfect counterbal-
for social change, Dr. Armida Fernandez offering maternal ance to remind people of the role they need to play as cit-
care to low-income families - all of these change-agents izens.
are Ashoka Fellows based in Mumbai and they share in Considering the sheer size of India and its complexity of
common the determination to solve systemic problems in issues, Ashoka has known all along that "we cannot do it
our society. alone". So when we found like-minded organizations like
Yes, wherever possible they rushed to the train stations the American India Foundation (AIF), and discovered an
and the nearest hospitals to the aid of the injured and the alignment of values and vision, we partnered with them at
needy. Subsequently and very quickly, they made their first opportunity. Our partnership with AIF (www.aifounda-
voices heard as a community of concerned individuals. tion.org) is now in its fourth year and has enabled us to
But most importantly they are fighting the larger battle, double the number of innovations/social entrepreneurs we
and a daily one, of prejudice, class and caste differences, are able to invest it. Today Ashoka-AIF Fellows are work-
basic education, accountability in government and public ing in Bhavnagar, Bongaigon, Bhopal, Bhubaneshwar and
delivery-systems. Driven by innovation and their spirit of every other imaginable area of the country and on every
enterprise, they are holding together a complex communi- issue that matters. Diaspora leaders like Rajat Gupta,
ty - Mumbai in this instance - and striving to establish a Lata Krishnan, Desh Deshpande and many others have
semblance of balance, fairness, and equity, creating hope endorsed the contribution of social entrepreneurs to the
and offering opportunity. They are fighting the potent future of the country and have joined hands in the cause.
forces of exploitation, discrimination and denial of oppor- We are honored that Catalyst has focused this issue on
tunities which they know will spawn unrest and frustration the efforts of "social entrepreneurs" and their relevance to
that can lead to "explosive situations" in societies. India, especially the emergent India. You will read the sto-
Social entrepreneurship may sound like the newest ries of Ashoka Fellows, covering topics as diverse as
buzzword these days, very handy to government, busi- women's co-operative movements in Southern
ness, media and civil society alike. But it has been prac- Maharashtra to schooling for have-nots in Kolkata to mar-
ticed for ages although not under that term. Social entre- keting rural innovations in Chennai. The common thread
preneurs like Florence Nightingale who transformed the that you will see is a lifetime of dedication, constant inno-
profession of nursing, Vinobha Bhave with the land reform vation, nimble execution and strategies that can tip entire
movement, James Grant who headed UNICEF and systems and not just nibble around the edges of the criti-
launched the "child survival revolution" have left their foot- cal issues. We are sure that these powerful examples and
prints on history. The role of social entrepreneurs and role models will inspire and challenge you to improve your
their huge contribution is increasingly being recognized. own community or to rally behind the work of these incred-
The Magsaysay Award presented last month to Ashoka ible Ashoka Fellows, realizing Ashoka's vision of "every-
Fellow Arvind Kejriwal for his crusade against corruption one a changemaker".
in India is a very current example. vraghavendra@ashoka.org
10
Catalyst For Human Development
Ashoka
Everyone a Changemaker
BILL DRAYTON
INTRODUCTION will reach adulthood with a self-definition that does not
include changemaking and a social skill set that largely pre-
ODRIGO Baggio has been relentlessly pursuing his cludes it. Those without will be marginalized.
R vision, of bridging the digital divide that plagues the
Favelas of Rio de Janeiro, since long before the term gained
The children of elite families grow up being expected to
take initiative and being rewarded for doing so. This confi-
currency. His chain of community-based computer training dent ability to master new situations and initiate whatever
schools now serves hundreds of slums worldwide. While changes or actions are needed is in essence what defines
beginning his work in Rio, he learned just how motivated and the elite.
capable of learning the young people in the Favelas were. However, the other 97 percent grow up getting very little
And also how competent the Favela community was in such experience. Adults control the classroom, work setting,
organizing. and even extra-curricular activities. Most school and other
Consider the impact Rodrigo has on a community when he youth cultures are not competent and do not support initia-
introduces his program. It is not a school created by the gov- tive-taking. This situation, coupled with society's attitudes,
ernment or outsiders. It is a school created, funded and man- drums home the message to this majority: "You're not com-
aged by people in the community. The students are respon- petent or perhaps even responsible."
sible for learning and then making their way. Think how many Over the last century, many other groups - including
patterns and stereotypes are crumpled by these simple and women, African Americans, even colonial peoples - had to
very obvious facts. It is a uniquely economical model that make their way from such debilitating stereotypes to becom-
strengthens the broader community and serves as a founda- ing fully accepted, capable contributors. These groups had to
tion for other initiatives long into the future. travel strongly similar human and community transformation
As important as Rodrigo's impact is on the digital divide, paths.
this second dimension of his impact is far more important - Building on the history of these earlier movements and on
the idea of catalyzing new local changemakers into being. the accumulated experience of hundreds of leading social
The whole process is enormously contagious. When entrepreneurs working with young people, Ashoka and many
champions build the teams they need to launch the idea they partners* have prototyped and are beginning to launch at
have adopted they are providing not only encouragement but scale the equivalent of a women's or older person's move-
also training to potential next-generation local changemak- ment for young people.
ers. As their numbers multiply, so does the number of sup- Although this movement must ultimately change how
port institutions, making the next generation of entrepreneur- everyone thinks about and relates to young people, it is
ing and changemaking easier. Not only do people not resist, young people and their peer communities who will have to
but they respond readily to this change. Who wants to be an change most. It is essential that they be central actors - both
object when they could be changemakers, when they could in actually shifting to the new pattern and in championing the
live lives far more creative and contributory? change.
The most important contribution any of us can make now To manage this eventually massive emergent movement
is not to solve any particular problem, no matter how urgent. Ashoka has created an independent but close partner, Youth
What we must do now is to increase the proportion of Venture. To build and launch this movement, Ashoka, Youth
humans who know that they can cause change. And who, Venture, and their partners are following a strategy that exer-
like smart white blood cells coursing through society, will cises enormously powerful jujitsu-like leverage; leverage that
stop with pleasure whenever they see that something is works on four mutually reinforcing levels, summarized in
stuck or that an opportunity is ripe to be seized. Table 1.
Each of these four needs the others. But they will not snap
Yet this will not be easy. Society can- into place together or everywhere in society instantly. This
Transforming the makes the job facing the pioneers much harder than it will be
not significantly increase the propor-
Youth Years for their successors; and it requires a phased, several-stage
tion of adults who are, and know they
are, changemakers until it changes the way all young people strategy. The central challenge is getting to the scale where
live. Yet, this "everyone a changemaker" world is an the synergies between these four levels - and across
unreachable fantasy unless the youth years become years of schools, neighborhoods, and regions - kick in and become
practicing being powerful and acquiring the required under- irreversibly self-multiplying. Ashoka/Youth Venture, recogniz-
lying skills: applied empathy, teamwork, and leadership. ing this is the heart of the matter, has been experimenting
If young people do not grow up being powerful, causing with a dozen different avenues and is gaining increasing
change, and practicing these three interlocked skills, they traction.
11
Catalyst For Human Development
Ashoka
Partnering with national organizations with many chapters (e.g., the Girl Scouts) or broad reach (e.g., Youth
Services America).
Co-venturing with public-spirited corporate partners (most recently with Staples in Europe and Latin America).
Communicating the stories of Youth Venturers broadly (including a growing relationship with MTV in the U.S. and
Mexico).
Replicating the successful United Way model. After two years, almost all the schools have multiple Youth Venture
teams; the area's community college gives college credit for high school Venture work; and virtually all young peo-
ple in the area experience multiple Venture models.
Building a network of stand-alone, volunteer-led local Youth Venture organizations akin to Scout, 4-H, and Little
League groups.
Building links to youth communities (e.g., punk rock bands, debate groups) built around a common interest that
cut across institutions and geography.
Getting to scale locally: Using all avenues in a few medium-sized metropolitan areas or small provinces or states
(e.g., New Hampshire).
ACTIONS I M PA C T S
In any school, community, or country each By leading, these young Venturers become
year, 1/2 of 1 percent of the young people lifelong leaders. They have mastered the
have a dream and create a lasting venture. essential skills of empathy, teamwork and
leadership.
Each venture engages a team (typically 3-5 in
the core group plus 20 who tutor, coach, Everyone learns teamwork, that they can
broadcast, etc.) lead, and how to do so. This multiplies the
next generation's proportion of "natural" lead-
1% of a school or youth community launches ers.
Ventures with an average 25 participants.
Over two years: 20% to 25% of the whole As Venturer peer groups recruit and sell their
institution is engaged, likely "tipping" its youth work, they can both tip their school or neigh-
culture. borhood youth culture and also will wear
down old attitudes and logistic barriers.
Society questions the current pattern, builds
an empowering movement for young people. Everyone redefines the youth years and lives
Youth Venture participants provide role mod- them as a time of expected initiative, compe-
els/champions. The press joins in. tency, and contribution.
Although the movement is far up the learning curve, it needs many more partners who are excited by this
movement-building challenge of accelerating to scale. And it needs to communicate its alternative vision for the
youth years and ultimately for a rapidly multiplying proportion of the population who has the power to change things.
The millennium when only a tiny elite could cause change is coming to an end.
But to move beyond, we must end the infantilazation of young people. They and the rest of us must enable all
young people to be fully creative, initiatory, and powerful changemakers.
wdrayton@ashoka.org
Excerpt from Innovations a journal from MIT Press
12
Catalyst For Human Development
Ashoka
13
Catalyst For Human Development
Ashoka
societies to take new leaps. "the most powerful and most hopeful historical
With the belief that the most powerful force for force of our era." In other words, Ashoka sees itself
social change lies in the hands of social entrepre- at the core of a historical moment: a dramatic
neurs, Drayton started Ashoka: Innovators for the transformation in society in which social entrepre-
Public in 1980 to find these rare, highly powerful neurs are paving the way for the "citizen sector" to
individuals. grow and establish itself as an innovative and pow-
Named after the peace-loving third century BC erful force to improve the lives of people around
Indian emperor, Ashoka aims to identify leading the world.
social entrepreneurs around the world, provide The citizen sector, commonly referred to as the
them with "social venture capital" and professional non-profit or non-governmental sector, is a term
support, and connect them to a global peer net- used by Drayton to describe a sector not by "what
work. Ashoka elected its first social entrepreneur - it isn't", but rather "what it is"-a sector made up of
or Ashoka Fellow - in India in 1981. Today, there citizens, for citizens. This sector, stagnant for hun-
are over 1,700 fellows in 60 countries - with ideas dreds of years, has experienced a similar revolu-
that have contributed to such activities as saving tion in growth and productivity in the past 25 years
over 9 million hectors of the Amazon Rainforest, that the business sector saw in the 1700s with the
increasing school enrollment in rural Bangladesh Industrial Revolution.
by 44%, and equipping almost one million at-risk Now, according to Drayton, the citizen sector has
children with computer and internet skills in been generating jobs at 2.5 to three times faster
Brazilian slums. than the rest of society, and in the US, for example,
The collective impact of the entire Ashoka the number of IRS-recognized citizen sector organ-
Fellowship is even more telling: Within five years, izations has more than doubled in a decade. With
over 93% of the fellows have had their work individ- the number of organizations dramatically rising
ually replicated by other organizations, and more around the world and its level of sophistication
than 50% have changed national policy. increasing, the citizen sector is now at a critical
While fellows may achieve initial impact on their point in its development.
own, it is the support of Ashoka that allows them to Understanding these historical forces at work,
sustain, scale, and spread their idea in the six Ashoka is responding by building an infrastructure
broad fields in which they work: learning and edu- that supports the growth and sustainability of the
cation, environment, health, human rights, civic social entrepreneurship field and entire citizen sec-
participation and economic development. tor. Much needed tools and systems are now being
As a result of gathering these individuals global- created, including seed financing and capital,
ly, Ashoka has created a network of incalculable bridges in business and academic sectors, and
power, which is not so much about funding, though strategic partnerships that deliver social and finan-
fellows do receive a modest stipend. Rather, these cial value. Ashoka's work in this area is helping
fellows, who typically work alone in hostile condi- close the historical gap between the business and
tions, receive support, share ideas and knowledge, citizen sectors, creating important avenues for inte-
and, quite literally, find protection. gration and synergy between both sections.
Even more powerful, fellows enter an environ- Once these systems are in place, believes
ment that fosters and supports collaborations Drayton, will we finally experience an "everyone a
amongst each other. Fellows with innovative solu- changemaker" world. This will be a world, he says,
tions in similar fields - regardless of geographical where each individual has the freedom, confidence
region - share insights and together distill the best and societal support to respond quickly and effec-
principles emerging from their work. For example, tively to social challenges. To that end, Ashoka
Ashoka's environmental fellows addressing issues strives to shape a global, entrepreneurial, and
of water-from access to water to sanitation to envi- competitive citizen sector, one that allows social
ronmental conservation-realized that the intersec- entrepreneurs to thrive and enables the world's cit-
tion of their approaches could lead to greater izens to think and act as changemakers.
change than they could achieve alone. As a result, That is why Drayton is now ensuring he reach
the India Sustainable Water Project was born, and tomorrow's changemakers as soon as possible.
the collaboration is now working to distill their col- Through his latest creation, Ashoka's Youth
lective insights into action and change of policy. Venture, young people are empowered to take ini-
And so together, Ashoka and its global network of tiative and create change within their community. It
fellows, business entrepreneurs, policy makers, supports youth to start their own social ventures
investors, academics, and journalists are now and as a result, is transforming the way society
working collectively to ensure that social entrepre- views young people as able agents of change.
neurs and their innovations continue to inspire a "Today only 2 or 3 percent of people control
new generation to create positive social change. change," says Drayton. "Imagine a world where
The foundation to this momentum is an under- everyone is a changemaker."
standing, as Drayton says, of how we are serving www.ashoka.org
14
Catalyst For Human Development
Ashoka
Featuring are:
Fazle Abed
BRAC
Bill Drayton
Ashoka
Peter Eigen
"This series is an opportunity to listen to Transparency International
stories and strategies of the global greats of Oded Grajew
social entrepreneurship -- a powerful new Ethos Institute + World Social Forum
form of public leadership." Alice Tepper Marlin
Social Accountability International
David Gergen Mohammad Yunus
Harvard's John F. Kennedy School of Grameen Bank
Government,
Editor-at-large for U.S. News & World Report, This exciting 16-program film series
Former White House advisor to Presidents is now available on DVD at:
Nixon, Ford, Reagan and Clinton. http://dvd.ashoka.org
for a special launch price of $35.99
only!!!
To download the films:
www.video.google.com (keyword:
For more details please contact: Ashoka)
Erin Fornoff efornoff@ashoka.org
Manmeet Mehta mmehta@ashoka.org They will also soon be available online
at Amazon and Netflix.com
15
Catalyst For Human Development
Ashoka
CHAULA KOTHARI
Ashoka is a world of fun for creative problem-solvers. It is a home to visionary entrepreneurs
giving them freedom to create and experiment with solutions on a global level.
N India, alongside the much-written-about technology boom, or design a service delivery mechanism for providing electrici-
I there is another sector quietly undergoing an image
makeover. Surprisingly, it is the social sector or, as it is more
ty in urban slums. Secondly, as David Bornstein writes in How
to Change the World, "The citizen sector is going through
recently called, the citizen sector. Long associated with khaadi changes that are comparable to those that occurred in the
kurtas and protest morchas, the citizen sector in India has business sector over the past three centuries." The business
always lagged far behind the business sector. Ironically, most sector has traditionally been served by entire industries devot-
social change in the country is linked not to social action but to ed to preparing people for meeting its needs - business
the empowerment of the middle class thanks to a growing schools, technical and leadership development resources, set
economy. However, a closer look reveals the truth behind standards to evaluate performance and award achievement,
these perceptions. According to the latest Economic Survey of accreditation institutes, magazines and publications on talent
India (ESI), expenditure on the social sector by both central in the sector, recruiting firms and many more similar services.
and state governments has been con- On the other hand, till recently, the citi-
sistently rising. There has also been an zen sector had no such infrastructure;
impressive drop in poverty levels. schools and universities had little
The survey also predicts a shift expertise in preparing students for
towards a healthier balance between careers in the sector and there were
quality and quantity. An area where this hardly any services for people who want
quality/quantity differentiation is evident to transition to the citizen sector from
is in the human capital being attracted to other fields.
the sector. Today, the sector attracts top This scenario is gradually changing -
talent with solid credentials and diverse top management schools around the
backgrounds. A look at some of the main world now offer programmes in social
movers and shakers in the sector con- entrepreneurship. Working in the citizen
firms this - Vijay Mahajan, founder of sector is now considered a legitimate
BASIX, India's first microfinance institu- career choice and there is serious com-
tion, is an IIMA graduate; Satyan Mishra, petition to get into the best schools and
the man behind the Drishtee.com rural jobs connected to the sector.
internet kiosk model holds an MBA from Ashoka is the pioneer in thinking
Delhi University; Arvind Kejriwal, one of about ways of meeting the talent gap for
main forces behind the new Right to the citizen sector and views its own
Information Act is a former Income Tax officer. Clearly, the citi- recruitment strategy as a means of resourcing the citizen sec-
zen sector is no longer about people desiring to do "social tor. Many recent additions to the global Ashoka family are a
work" but rather, it is a magnet for some of the best minds who perfect example of the shifting trends we just discussed -
want to apply their skills and experience to solving deep-root- Arthur Wood, who leads Ashoka's Social Financial Services
ed problems of national, and often global, scale. It is no longer programme, made a seamless move from being an invest-
unusual today for experienced corporate sector executives to ment banker to engaging global financial services firms to
switch careers midway and join the citizen sector - SKS enter the business of social investing and increasing flow of
Microfinance's Vikram Akula immediately springs to mind. finance into the sector. The common thread running through all
One reason behind this shift is just the sheer scope and these examples is a thirst for innovation and entrepreneurship.
nature of the work involved - where else can an entrepreneur We are setting the benchmarks for quality human resources
enjoy the challenge of trying to solve problems of large magni- and our staffing model has inspired other organizations in the
tudes that have eluded policymakers, activists, economists, citizen sector. Ashoka's unique recruitment philosophy and
political theorists and countless armchair philosophers? It is approach enable us to bring together some of the best vision-
not surprising that people who love predicting consumer trends aries and creative thinkers to collectively brainstorm around
and strategizing on how to corner markets would also enjoy fig- important systemic challenges.
uring out how to market education opportunities to street kids ckothari@ashoka.org
16
Catalyst For Human Development
Ashoka
S. M. CYRIL
In 1979, we set out to make our school a resource centre for development and for social inte-
gration for impoverished people. As we look back on our efforts we can see how, by seizing
every opportunity, our programme has grown on its strengths. Now as we look forward to the
future, and we see the quality of students emerging from our school, we hope that our school
has also become a resource centre for social transformation.
INCE 1964, I was aware of and uneasy about my role dren teach Class III students; and IX & X students teach
S as an English medium school principal in India. The
school provided a well-rounded and high-quality education
class IV.
We started working with street, or "rainbow," children. All
to the children of wealthy families while thousands of their around us were children with no access to education. They
peer groups were receiving no education. I began to ques- live by their wits on the streets. We created a school for
tion the outcome of an education system which inadvertent- them where they are welcomed and can come and go as
ly does little to break down the vicious cycles caused by the they please, regardless of what state they are in. Most often
divide between the affluent and the poor - where money they wear dirty and ragged clothes. The non-rainbow stu-
guarantees a good education, increasing employment dents invited them in until they realized they were welcome.
opportunities, and, in turn, enables one to earn enough Soon the rainbow children began bringing their friends
money to pay for the education of the next generation. along with them.
Conversely, the poor are trapped in their economic status
because they don't have access to good schooling, and Students Teach Students teach rainbow children to help
thus have very limited access to job opportunities. Children them catch up. The government man-
Consequently, in 1979 the school's staff and I began an dates everyone from Class V upward to
experiment in which dramatic changes have 2 periods a week of Work
were made in the school's managerial Education or SUPW. This entails that all
practices, over the years, which result- day, everyday there are 50 children, free,
ed in a growing network of nonprofit eager and ready to teach other children
workers, government officials, police on a one-to-one basis. They learn rapid-
officers and businessmen. The pur- ly until they reach the class appropriate
pose of this experiment was to provide to their age. As soon as they can read in
as many children as possible with edu- Bengali or Hindi (their mother tongue)
cational and life opportunities. they shift to using books provided by the
government, and are integrated into the
Experiment’s We began by chang- mainstream classes. We integrated
Origins ing the school's hundreds of street children thus into our
ethos. The school school over the years. Today many are
started admitting a student body of 50% affluent and 50% functional and happy citizens.
impoverished children. The children from wealthy families Not satisfied with only teaching the children in our own
provided financial security for the school. Four-year-olds school district, we began to train teachers from remote vil-
were admitted on a lottery system, pooling children from lages and slums where some teachers are unwilling to go.
both rich and poor communities. Soon the school had a In this way we could extend good teaching methodologies
healthy mixture of children with different levels of intelli- to many children who are too far away to come to our
gence, religious backgrounds, and socio-economic statuses school. Called the "The Barefoot Training", the pro-
- resulting in a fully integrated school! gramme has brought us to collaborate with NGOs and build
With the help of an NGO called CINI, next we got involved a network that reaches many parts of the country and
with impoverished village schools. These schools had a expand even internationally.
ratio of 120:1 children to teacher. In a few cases just one The Barefoot Training is now included in the Government
master looked after the entire primary school. Often condi- Programme, Sarva Siksha Abhiyan (SSA). Working with
tions were so cramped that each Thursday, we used to take 50 NGOs in Kolkata, we carried out a city-wide survey,
150 of our children outside for teaching. We worked with revealing that 44,646 children are out of school. Of these
3,500 rural children in 12 rural schools. Our 10-year-olds children, the Kolkata Municipal Corporation has already
(Class V) teach the Pre-primary and Class I levels; Class VI placed 5,000 in existing schools. Currently, with the help of
students are in charge of teaching Class II; VII and VIII chil- about 60 NGOs and funding from SSA, 10,000 children are
17
Catalyst For Human Development
Ashoka
in the process of being placed in schools. Furthermore, Childline and the National Education Group (NEG) have
this collaboration has helped open 450 centers to cater to also helped create a national network of NGOs through
26,000 rainbow children all over the city. We have been the zonal office over the past ten years. We are now try-
recognized by the government as the apex training body ing to contact more school principals to include them in
of primary teaching methods to teachers. We have trained our latest effort to support the use of large school facilities
nearly 1,400 to date. The NGOs, who take responsibility during 2 p.m. to 8 a.m. off-hours as a home for at-risk girls
for hiring teachers and center managers, send their on the streets. We already have 300 such children in
recruits to us for training. The CLPOA, a forum of all the Loreto Sealdah, 140 in Loreto Bowbazar and 119 in
NGOs of the city, receives money from SSA, disburses it Loreto House. To enroll principals interested in joining us,
and looks after the overall management of the pro- we planned a 2-day workshop in August for which a large
gramme. number of principals have already signed up. This work-
Our HDCL programme has expanded our network dra- shop is one of many implements that will encourage net-
matically. In this programme children reach out to domes- working and result in the improvement of education in
tic slave children. Loreto students, who are children of rel- India.
atively wealthy families, meet domestic slave children traf-
fickers within their parent's social circles. Loreto students Networks are built when people working towards a
pressure the "employers" to send the slave children to common goal come together to share ideas, experi-
school. They successfully got 300 domestic slave chil- ences and resources to help each other. This synergy
dren admitted into schools. We have built a 30 schools results in a far larger achievement than the sum of the
network that works with other NGOs in Kolkata and the efforts of people working alone.
surrounding area. Save the Children Fund has funded this
project and aided in the network development process. smcyril@rediffmail.com
Editorial Mission
18
Catalyst For Human Development
Ashoka
Ashoka to Launch
Anti-Corruption Initiative
CATALYST INTERVIEW WITH ASHOKA'S CO-PRESIDENT, DIANA WELLS
Diana joined Ashoka in the 1980s after graduating from Brown with a BA in South
Asian Studies. Diana also has helped in creating the Fellowship Support Services, a
social networking system for Ashoka social entrepreneurs. She has conceived and
developed Ashoka's widely respected Measuring Effectiveness Programme.
Catalyst for Human Development: What was the moti- DW: India has changed so much in the last decade in the
vation behind the founding of Ashoka? private sector. The economy is booming and the energy
in the country is just incredible. Now, look at the citizen
Diana Wells: Well, if you trace the history of the social sector . Has it advanced at the same pace? No. The citi-
sector, you will find that prior to the late seventies, the zen sector in India must be nimble enough to catch up
only players in this field were government social welfare with the economic growth. Ashoka has redefined in India
projects or multilateral institutions like UN, World Bank social innovation to beyond traditional development and
and so on. The idea that any random individual citizen poverty alleviation. For instance, CV Madhukar of
could just up and start a social initiative Parliamentary Research Services, pro-
would have raised many eyebrows vides MPs with the research they need
back then. Today there exists an entire to make more effective policy deci-
citizen sector. When Bill started sions. Vineet Rai started Aavishkaar, a
Ashoka, he looked around, saw these venture capital fund for rural innova-
informal, individual initiatives and tors. Another example is Pratima
decided that Ashoka's role would be to Joshi, and use of Geographic
highlight only social entrepreneurs Information System (GIS) technology
using the most innovative approaches for urban development. These uncon-
in their work. And since then innovation ventional initiatives represent the
has been our strategy of choice. changing citizen sector in India.
CFHD: What would you define as the CFHD: So what next on the Ashoka
values behind Ashoka's philosophy front?
and work?
DW: We like to be one step ahead of
DW: We strive to understand the world, others. For instance, while CSR is still
understand the person we are dealing a new concept in many places, we
with, the people we are serving. Our have already moved on to the next
goal is not just solving the present step : business-CSO(Civil Society
problem but making that change sys- Organisations) partnerships. The CSO
temic and sustainable. We encourage partners serve each entity's core
entrepreneurship and initiative taking DIANA WELLS motives, (profit as well as social mis-
as well as value collegiality. We are a sion) creating a win-win situation for
community that works together, that helps one another, both rather than a donor-grantee relationship. Ashoka's
that is more than the sum of the parts. And finally, we Social Financial Services is inventing funding streams for
strive to be empathetic in our work across different cul- the sector. Our Global Academy is reaching out to acade-
tures, communities and situations. The Ashoka family is mia to help prepare young people for social entrepre-
a dynamic network of people with eclectic backgrounds, neurship careers. In order to succeed and become sus-
along with tons of creativity and enthusiasm. tainable, social entrepreneurs (much like business entre-
preneurs) require infrastructural support. Ashoka is sim-
CFHD: Ashoka's first Fellow was from India and you ply building the infrastructure for the sector while helping
have a strong connection to the country. Tell us in finance, human resources, partnerships and so on.
about Ashoka's work in India. In India, we are on the verge of launching an anti-cor-
ruption initiative, which will be led by Ashoka fellows
19
Catalyst For Human Development
Ashoka
working in this field. The initiative will engage the busi- information on funding sources. I also helped with con-
ness sector as well as policymakers and aim for systemic necting fellows to potential partners, and resource mate-
changes to tackle the problem. Ashoka is providing the rials. I realized that fellows could swap insights and learn
supporting framework and infrastructure that is neces- from each other and hence I started Ashoka's Fellowship
sary to seed and sustain such cross-sector collabora- Support Services programme. This initiative has now
tions. evolved into a highly sophisticated global fellowship net-
work of social entrepreneurs collaborating with each
CFHD:What attracted you to Ashoka? other and collectively impacting policy and systems.
DW: I joined Ashoka in 1988. My background is in anthro- CFHD:Any interesting stories in Ashoka operations?
pology and I have always been interested in South Asia.
While travelling abroad, I observed that imposing west- DW: (Laughs) There are so many… especially from the
ern development ideas in less-developed communities early days when we operated on a shoestring budget.
without regard to local context was often more detrimen- Sushmita, our former President, and I were reminiscing
tal than beneficial. Hence when I learnt about Ashoka, I once. She told me that in India she would have her
was immediately attracted by Bill's philosophy of finding daughter cut Post to half so as to get more use out of
social entrepreneurs within the local community. It made them. I too remember that in the pre-internet era. We
so much more sense. And, when you link these local would often have to hold off sending out letters because
entrepreneurs into a global network that facilitates learn- we did not have enough funds to cover the cost of stamps
ing, you have created a most amazing tool for systemic to send mail outside US. We have come a long way from
change. During my first months at Ashoka, I observed that. I am proud to say that economy and efficiency are
team members returning from visits abroad and helping still the hallmarks of this organization.
by bringing back requests from individual fellows for
20
Catalyst For Human Development
Ashoka
LILY PAUL
N sixty countries around the globe, Ashoka is leading a decides whether the candidate is likely to become a highly
I relentless search for visionaries with ideas for social
change. Ashoka has created an extensive process to iden-
capable social entrepreneur at the national level.
tify and select social entrepreneurs. This process includes Board Approval
testing the strength of their ideas to deliver large-scale and The final stage is approval by Ashoka Board of Directors to
unprecedented social impact. For fellows, the search and ensure high standards, consistency and spot policy prob-
selection process critically contributes to the evolution of lems.
their ideas as they reinvent, rethink, and refine their vision. The results of this rigorous process are telling. Ashoka
Ashoka Fellow Ratnaboli Ray states: "At a time when has selected over 1,700 Fellows who are dedicated to pio-
people paid little attention to my ideas, Ashoka spent hours neering systemic change; 97% of fellows continue their orig-
listening. So many times during the search and selection inal work after 10 years; 95% of Fellows have their work
process, I had tried to reconsider my strategies, throw out replicated by other organizations; and 50% have changed
unrealistic plans, and react to hypothetical situations… It national policy. Ashoka fellows not only realize their core
was one of the most introspective and forward thinking vision as they receive financial support, but also become
processes I have ever experienced." part of a peer network of like-minded innovators.
When Bill Drayton began his journey to identify social
entrepreneurs, he would record information about each lpaul@vsnl.com
visionary he met on a small index card. In time, he was able
to map out the network of people he met doing innovative
work. He would tap into the intelligence of each new social ASHOKA'S SELECTION
entrepreneur he found to lead him to other visionaries.
Twenty-five years later, Ashoka has formalized this strategy CRITERIA
into a rigorous process, known as Venture, to find and elect
the highest quality social entrepreneurs with the most pow- A Knock-out Test: Unique ideas
erful new ideas. Today, Ashoka staff from around the world Does the idea envision an entirely new solution to a
use a standard 5 step-selection process which assesses the problem?
candidates' match with Ashoka's criteria for election to the
Fellowship. Creativity
How creative is the person as a problem-solver and
Selection Process visionary? How does the person approach obstacles
Nomination and opportunities? How does he or she create original
Applications are welcome from anyone, but Ashoka's global solutions?
network of nominators, who are leaders in many fields, play
a critical role in identifying candidates who meet Ashoka's Entrepreneurial Quality
selection criteria. How committed is the person to his or her idea? Will it
be impossible for him or her to rest until their vision
Initial Review becomes a new reality?
Ashoka country representatives review each candidate's
application. Then they conduct reference, background Social Impact of the Idea
checks, site-visits and interviews. Lastly, the country repre- Will the new idea create solutions that transcend to
sentative makes a recommendation to support worthy can- national and global problems? Is the idea practical,
didates. useful and replicable? How many people will be affect-
ed?
Second Opinion Review
An Ashoka board member or outside senior professional Ethical Fiber
conducts an intensive second opinion review. Can you intuitively trust the candidate? Are his or her
motivations deeply rooted in a commitment to serve oth-
Selection Panel ers?
A selection panel of senior social entrepreneurs, led by a
board member of Ashoka or outside senior representative,
21
Catalyst For Human Development
SALUTES ASHOKA FELLOWS
22
Catalyst For Human Development
Ayyappa Masagi Geeta Ramanujam Anil Singh
M.V. Mathew Gita Ramaswamy Aman Singh
Raja Menon Sagari Ramdas Chetna Gala Sinha
Jyoti Mhapsekar Milind Ranade Sujit Sinha
Satyan Mishra Ilango Rangaswamy Matthew Spacie
Haushala Prasad Mishra D.Rangaraj Sheilu Srinivasan
Dinesh Kumar Mishra Rama Rao S. Srinivasan
Shaheen Mistri Padmanabha Rao Nirmala Srinivasan
Rajat Mitra Jaya Prakash Rao Dr. Thara Srinivasan
George Mathew Molakal Sridevi Rao H. Sudarshan
Kapilananda Mondal Balkrishna Renake A.K. Susheela
Cyril Mooney Prasad Rasal S.L.N. Swamy
Dadasaheb More Ashok Kumar Rau Madhavi Suneel Tambay
Emami Murmu Ratnaboli Ray K.A. Thomas
P. Muthu Aromar Revi Vijay Uttarwar
Ramesh Nandwana Kishor Rithe Rajeev Vartak
Shyamala Natarajan Anselm Rosario Sarat Babu Vasireddy
Nalini Nayak Krishna Roy Dr. Prem Victor
Debashish Nayak Sikha Roy Anu Wakhlu
M. B. Nirmal Mira Sadgopal Sonam Wangchuk
Sonali Ojha Suman Sahai Romulus Whitaker
Shree Padre Palagummi Sainath Murali Mohan
Shivaram Pailoor Ashok Salvi Rajiv Khandelwal
A.R. Palaniswamy J. M. Sampath Madan Mohan Rao
S. Pandian S.Santhi Ashoka Bharti
Ganesh Pangare Pradip Sarmah Balaji Sampath
Rita Panicker Kailash Satyarthi Shanti Raghavan
M.G. Papamma Sunita Satyarthia Muthu Velayutham
Vikram Parchure Vasant Savangikar Kitayun Rustom and
M.L. Parshuram Nirupama Sekhri Rashneh
Ashraf Patel Soma Sengupta Sharad Sharma
Priti Patkar Teesta Setalvad Vishal Talreja
Abhijit Pathak Naginbhai Shah Bhargavi Davar
Aditya Patnaik Anil Shaligram Pratibha Shinde
S. N. Patro Heeralal Sharma M.D. Rajmane
Kalyan Paul Sudhirendar Sharma Deep Purokayastha
Isidore Phillips Anant Sharma Amlan Ganguly
Anil Pilgadkar Shantharam Umanath Shenai Abhishek Ray
Arvind Pitre Suchitra Sheth C.V. Madhukar
Jagdish Pradhan Parul Sheth Hasina Karbhih
Raju Purohit and Deepti Falgun Sheth Kousalya Periasamy
Shah Beena Sheth Lashkari Pratima Joshi
Lenin Raghuvanshi Ravindra Shetye Rehana Abid
Vineet Rai Avinash Shirke Seema Prakash and Prakash
S. Rajagopalan Abhay Shukla Michael
Janaki Rajan Martand Mapu Singh Solomon Jaya Prakash
Y.J. Rajendra Laxman Singh Vineet Rai
Ravichandra Raju Yogendra Singh V. S. Chary
23
Catalyst For Human Development
Micro Finance
HERE are several participants in the developmental arena, making cheap funds available to commercial banks
T arena: national and foreign governments, international
agencies, private companies, and non-governmental organ-
for this purpose. As the number of layers in the lending
structure increased, the focus turned to ensuring that there
izations (NGOs). In developing countries, governments would be as much lending as the available funds would
have traditionally been the agents for health care, education allow, and the risks associated with nonpayment of princi-
and job training, especially in rural areas (which is where the pal and interest would be minimized. The intermediaries
majority of the population in most developing nations lives). became less interested in whether the funds are extended
This situation has arisen due to the inability of rural popula- to those who are really poor or would be used for any busi-
tions to pay for basic services. ness activity.
NGOs have taken up projects in support of government Today, there are several for-profit funds and supposed-
initiatives to improve the quality of education and health- ly not-for-profit organizations marketing micro-credit lend-
care, while focusing on specific critical areas such as ing in developing countries and some of them come with
HIV(Human Immunodeficiency Virus)/AIDS, illiteracy, advertised returns on investment. One such leading micro-
financing of small businesses and women's empowerment. credit intermediary in India recently publicized in a major
Despite the positive contributions by NGOs in many areas, newspaper that he has been charging 36 percent interest
they have not been involved in major developmental under- until recently when he dropped the rate to 24 percent for
takings that are intended to create large employment and some borrowers by making the lending process more effi-
wide income generation through sustainable businesses. cient. After all, credit card companies charge as high as 28
This is partly attributable to the fact that NGOs generally percent interest for credit-risk customers, it argues.
lack good managerial skills and organizational structure to The assumption is that every poor person can be res-
take up business ventures, and donor funds are usually cued from poverty fairly quickly and easily with a modicum
restricted to narrowly defined projects that address specific of money. Micro-credit to the poor is intended mainly for
concerns. starting or expanding small businesses run by beneficiar-
ies. Many make the claim that the micro-credit facility
Micro-finance is not The expression "social entrepre- (loans of around $100 to each impoverished person) has
a Panacea neurship" was coined to reflect elevated tens of millions of people out of poverty in the
some form of corporate benevo- developing world. Moreover, assertions that more than 90
lence toward the poor, and many new NGOs have been percent of the people who receive micro-credit are gen-
formed under this banner. Mohamed Yunus who founded uinely poor, that most of them succeed in businesses start-
the Grameen Bank in Bangladesh in 1976 meant exactly ed with these loans, and that they repay the loans at 24
that when he started giving poor people credit and assist- percent annual interest or higher, go essentially unchal-
ed them in their local business ventures. Subsequently, lenged.
with donor and government funds, several NGOs around I have seen that a small number of people, mostly village
the world started offering small loans to women who could leaders and their family members, operate the few shops
not otherwise obtain credit directly from commercial banks. in their villages. They are the only ones who have the nec-
Many developmental experts have now termed micro-cred- essary support mechanism, knowledge, and skills to make
it a revolutionary concept in solving global poverty. a business succeed. A great majority of the rural popula-
Many variations of the original micro-credit model were tion who are poor do not have the ability to start or own
introduced by lenders. Some offer loans only to groups businesses, with or without access to credit; it is unrealis-
(Sanghas) as opposed to individuals, and each group is tic to expect them to succeed in business.
held responsible for repaying the loan by their members. Our foundation's study of some 17 villages and over 50
Commercial banks that were previously lending directly to micro-credit programme in South India shows that less
individuals and groups began advancing loans only to a than 5 percent of those who receive such loans start any
new set of micro-credit lending intermediaries. Soon, gov- business of their own (mostly unsustainable, such as buy-
ernments, international agencies and donors entered this ing some sheep and selling them a little later, hopefully at
24
Catalyst For Human Development
Micro Finance
a profit equal to the wages foregone), and less than 2 per- The Future Role As the number of NGOs prolifer-
cent remain in that business beyond the first 2 years after of NGOs ates, there is increasing concern
starting. Only a few among the poor can expect to succeed about the nature of their activities,
as entrepreneurs with such small amounts of money and and whether public funds are used by them appropriately to
with little other support, training, or skills. benefit the poor. Unlike private companies, NGOs are sel-
The truth is that most beneficiaries of micro-credit repay dom brought to public scrutiny for their effectiveness. There
the loan from income received from their regular jobs and is not much accountability for their activities; even serious
from grants provided by governments for self-help pro- inefficiencies are accepted as though they are in the nature
gramme. Not surprisingly, it is the intermediaries - commer- of the "NGO business." If this situation is to improve, an hon-
cial banks and loan facilitators - that stand to gain the most est assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of NGOs
from the spread between the cost of funds and loan interest as institutions of public service must be undertaken. The cri-
rates. teria for making public funds available to them must match
For example, commercial banks in India receive funds from those activities for which they are best suited.
the government-run National Bank for Agriculture and Rural While NGOs differ widely in their respective capabilities,
Development (NABARD) at 5-6 percent for micro-credit pro- past performance reveals where they have been generally
gramme. They lend at 10 to12 percent to the micro-credit most successful. NGOs have been good advocates for
intermediary that in turn lends at 24 to 36 percent to the final many social causes, pointing out problems and offering
beneficiary. ideas for improvement. They are capable of carrying out
So what makes micro-lending so popular for intermediaries impartial investigations to obtain relevant information, and
and the poor alike in countries like India? If you lend money make recommendations and lobby to get laws enacted. In
to a poor person, and he/she returns it, and if this process is doing so, NGOs have effectively contributed to the formula-
done twice (no need to start any business, but maintain good tion of public policy on a variety of issues dealing with pover-
paperwork), then the poor person is eligible for a government ty, environment, consumer protection, women's rights,
grant for $100 or more. The free money from the government among others.
can be used to repay the third time a micro-loan is made to The supportive role being played by NGOs in the delivery
the beneficiary. The government is now short by the amount of basic services by the government is commendable.
of grant made, but both the poor person and the micro-cred- NGOs have been instrumental in mobilizing community par-
it businessman are assured of their capital and returns. ticipation in a variety of projects through awareness creation
Why do we have to go through this roundabout way to offer and dissemination of appropriate information. By gaining the
free money to poor people, when there are several direct confidence of the poor communities they serve, NGOs have
means to reduce their debt burden? The answer is this: effectively reached out to the people in the government's
micro-credit is often a "hand-out" to the poor on the pretext of effort to deliver services.
an exciting concept, namely, social entrepreneurship, while NGOs undoubtedly have a major role to play in the effort
the intermediaries are assured of high returns. to alleviate poverty. However, it also must be recognized that
A new breed of educated and well-trained loan sharks, most NGOs are not organized to effectively execute major
with support from banks, is now getting into the micro-credit projects. Further, it would be a mistake to involve NGOs in
business in India. It does appear that this form of lending has activities that are best suited for the private sector.
”
taken over as the trendy cure-all for those pushing "social
entrepreneurship." There is constant publicity in the media
with success stories, and it seems that the few exceptions in
entrepreneurship give the impression that most poor benefi-
ciaries are able to run sustainable businesses with little
money. It is doubtful that the present form of micro-credit, as
practised in India, results in any sustainable development to
benefit the poor.
By appropriately channeling public and donor funds, NGO
activities can be confined to those areas in which they have
sufficient strength. Disappointment in the performance of
governments and lack of sufficient trust in the private sector
are not good reasons to lean on NGOs for carrying out tasks
for which they are not suited.
george@optonline.net
25
Catalyst For Human Development
Rural Development
26
Catalyst For Human Development
Rural Development
I asked Sabina what she wants to be. She said that she to the free school, since both mother and daughter are
had two choices. One is to work in the fields, like a normal forced to work in the fields for a living. However, she does
day wage labourer, if work is available. The other option, send her three younger daughters to school, even though it
which requires money her family doesn't have, is to go for saps her entire energy, and income.
higher studies. Sabina said she would like to study nursing It may seem unfair that the eldest daughter must work
if she had the opportunity. while the younger daughters can go to school. However, the
Her desire to be a nurse is even more poignant when one mother's resolve was strong. She declared that even
considers the fact that in the Adivasi villages, tribal customs though feeding an extra mouth is too much, she is not going
and superstitions are still rampant. Which poor villager, to marry off her eldest daughter before she reaches mar-
whose biggest problem is where the next meal is going to riageable age. It is worth mentioning here that all the
come from, would choose to have his son or daughter women attending the meeting were married much before
spend their entire childhood and youth learning something the legal marriage age. This generational shift in the way
that will not only prevent them from being a daily-wage these women are perceiving women's rights is the result of
labourer, but will make them unemployed, disaffected and the ERDS child marriage awareness programme.
depressed youth? The poor parents who are told to send Another incident I came to know of was while attending a
their son or even daughter to school will ask another ques- social support programme for the old and abandoned peo-
tion in return: what will that do? Help make them sit at home ple. I spoke with a 70-year-old woman whose children had
and not even earn a meal? This is the environment that thrown her out of the house. As a result she was living by
dedicated organisations like ERDS are trying to improve, by begging. However, since ERDS enrolled her into the pro-
increasing the opportunities which proper education can gramme she has been regularly getting food and clothing
provide. and now does some basic work so she does not have to
To top it all, the girls in these rural villages are subjected beg any more.
to early marriage Yet another
which removes woman spoke to me
them from school- about how she is
ing, even at the making a reason-
ages of 9 or 10. able earning from
Families end up the small saving and
selling away their micro-credit pro-
daughters, as the gramme run through
burden of the cost ERDS. She is a
of dowry for a mar- member of a team of
riage is enormous. 10 village women.
This takes place When asked if her
regularly even husband, a Muslim,
where it has been questioned her
termed illegal by the entrepreneurial
law. Unfortunately, actions, she
the government the answered, "No". On
means of spreading awareness or the administrative the contrary she said not only has her husband begun to lis-
machinery to ensure adherence. The people at ERDS rec- ten to her more often, and actively supporting her member-
ognize the importance of encouraging families to send their ship of this self-help group, but his love for her had
daughters to school instead of marrying them off young. increased!
At each of the meetings, workshops or classes that I But the most satisfactory part of my interactions was in
attended, I was reminded of the enormous public service seeing the expectant and eager faces of the children who
the organisation is involved in. Three specific incidents are are getting a chance to develop in life, thanks to the primary
worth mentioning here, to highlight the effect of the work schools being run by ERDS and the child sponsorship pro-
being done by these modern day followers of Gandhi. The gramme. These programmes, run with the help and assis-
first incident was a conversation I had while attending a tance of other NGOs, are the grand ones in the firmament
seminar organised by an ERDS social worker in a remote of the work of ERDS and its tireless workers. They are suc-
village. The subject of the seminar was "creating awareness ceeding in their attempts to leave the world a bit better, and
among very poor villagers against child marriage." Thirty they are not resting. Mr. Madhu Basu, the guiding light and
people attended the seminar, 24 of whom were women. general secretary of the association, says that they are just
The woman I spoke with talked about how she copes with beginning, and a lot more needs to be done. How true! Until
raising four children, all girls, who are often considered to be every Sabina Soren finds her feet firmly in the ground and
a burden in the rural areas of India. every elderly parent finds social help, and until mothers find
I asked if she faced a tough family situation by giving birth the confidence to stand on their own feet to better them-
to four girls. The woman cried, saying that they are so poor selves and their families, this work needs to be taken fur-
she cannot even provide three meals a day for the family! ther.
She could not even afford to send her 15-year-old daughter erds@cal2.vsnl.net.in
27
Catalyst For Human Development
Social Service
Karmayog
SUCHETA DALAL
Karmayog means selfless service. Or, as the Bhagwad Gita says, “Working to the
best of one's abilities without becoming attached to the fruits of work” is
called karmayog.com - a netbased meeting ground of people who
need to help those who want to give, or simply spread
an important message.
aunched by Vinay Somani (through his R O Somani Charitable Trust) in 2004, Karmayog, with over
L 1000 page views a day, has grown rapidly to reach a national and international audience. But its
most significant breakthrough was probably after the deluge of 26 July 2005 in Mumbai that killed 500
persons.
Karmayog set up a flood resource website within a day, offering services, volunteers, money and
material. The crisis exposed the absence of a formal mechanism for Government and civic authorities
to interact with NGOs and share information. Karmayog helped form an NGO-coordination committee
comprising 65 NGOs. Karmayog itself is a similar e-meeting ground for NGOs in mumbai and across
India. It also has a 5,000 - member discussion group and 1,60,000 - strong email group. Karmayog
clicked for two reasons.
First, because of its intense and knowledgeable discussions on everything-from vermicomposting to
relief operations to the problem of stray dogs. Active discussions are facilitated by a yahoo group that
allow flexibility of access (htt://groups.yahoo.com/group/karmayog).
Secondly, Vinay Somani's business background helps it to function with businesslike objectivity, which
is inclusive but firm. Volunteers, donors and NGOs often tend to post short and incomplete messages
seeking or offering help. He clears the messages with a reminder to fill out appropriate forms listed on
the website. This clarity of content and approach is an important strengh. Somani started out with a sim-
ple format for volunteers and donors to interact with each other in an on-line forum. This led to meet-
ings and discussions, and Karmayog began to feel the need to create better profiles and share its infor-
mation and learnings with socially sensitive people.
Today, its e-group allows even experts to share their views and receive feedback that are at times
contrary to their own ideas. Karmayog's thoughtfully designed formats extract detailed information from
NGOs on organizational structure and specific needs providing comprehensive information to donors
and potential volunteers on quality of assistance required (money, infrastructure, volunteering) and its
delivery. It also encourages people make donations of as little as Rs. 100 a month to help carefully
selected NGOs. Sector-mapping is another initiative. Karmayog volunteers have collated a list of
schools and NGOs working with hearing-challenged persons as well as ENT hospitals, hearing aid man-
ufacturers and doctors.
The volunteer list on karmayog.com has 650 listings from all over the world, offering to devote all or
a part of their time to public service. Many students and tourists visiting India have signed up to volun-
teer with NGOs for a couple of months and have found placements. Others have found jobs in their area
of interest. An orphanage for street children in Mumbai found a good Samaritan in Spain.
At a more personal level, individuals have been able to make their specific skills work on a part time
basis, fulfilling an important need among voluntary organizations. If you want to be a karmayogi by find-
ing the right cause to support, or volunteer with, check out www.karmayog.com.
info@karmayog.com
Sucheta Dalal's article was first published in MoneyLIFE magazine.
28
Catalyst For Human Development
Social Service
29
Catalyst For Human Development
Social Service
that just by tearing it in small pieces and after sanitiz- Innovation award, is another programme that channels
ing it we can provide sanitary napkins to 20 women. It urban excess to poor rural schools. The idea is to bring
involves no issue of affordability, no problem in dispos- unused school material and clothing from wealthy
al, no plastic sheet, nothing technical. schools to undeveloped village schools to bolster basic
We started GOONJ eight years ago, gathering 67 school resources. Today hundreds of kids enjoy uni-
articles of clothing on a simple premise that after 3 forms and school supplies that they would otherwise
years, whatever we haven't used we don't need. We have been thrown away. Between growing student
began spoking with friends and relatives, collecting populations on both sides of the economic divide, a
some material, distributing it as we tested marketing permanent source of warm clothing is a linkage as
and needs-level strategies. We emphasized the impor- every time the urban school kids discard, the village
tance of giving it with dignity and sensitivity to cultural, school kids will have what they so desperately need.
religious and geographical nuances. When the pro- Now GOONJ is in its expansion phase. Post-
gramme grew a little we submitted formal requests to Tsunami, when we approached the Tamil Nadu govern-
funding agencies. They always replied: " It does not ment for 2 million donated clothes, we were sure that
fall in our parameter." Our efforts continued for years, we would be able to handle that kind of quantity. Today
and no agencies engaged in supporting us. Providing after a year of highly quality conscious sorting and
adequate clothing was simply not seen as a worthy packing, some of that material has gone to Tsunami
cause. This challenge only increased our resolve. affected people, breaking the myth they were not
As much as the funding agencies and corporate sec- accepting old clothes. When clothes were provided in
tor ignored this issue, the masses came forward over- a dignified manner, properly sorted, they were readily
whelmingly, understood the issue and supported us accepted.
wholeheartedly with finances and material. GOONJ Apart from reaching different parts of the country this
thus started growing as a people's movement. material has also gone to earthquake victims in
Today VASTRADAAN deals with over 10,000 kgs of Kashmir and Pakistan through the Indian Army with the
material every month. The test marketing was done on help of the Pakistani High Commission. A big chunk of
Delhi roads but today we work with over 100 agencies this cloth, which is not fit for wearing, is being turned
in 17 states of India. In cities we have a strong network into cloth sanitary napkins, sitting mats and school
of people, corporations, schools, resident welfare bags, to be given to people across India. When
associations who support us in collection. In the vil- Deutche bank decided on its own to support this unique
lages we have a network of social activists, Ashoka project and Safexpress offered free transportation we
Fellows, grassroot NGOs, and for Kashmir and felt that clothing has started becoming an issue….
Arunachal, units of the Indian army who are our imple- Today other countries are trying to study this model
mentation partners. where we have built a wide network in many parts of
A strong feedback system ensures systematic distri- the country, on the very basic issue of clothing. This
bution of the clothing. Partnership with local groups network and systems can be utilized for anything. If
gives us a better understanding of local issues and one talks about health- then medicines and sanitary
needs and the initiative 'cloth for work' uses the mate- napkins, if we talk about Education- then school mate-
rial as resource for development in rural India. Under rial, in the normal course - clothes, utensils, footwear
this initiative, GOONJ, with the help of local partners, and other basics and in a disaster situation just add
identifies a much needed development activity in a vil- ration, tarpaulin and other disaster relief material.
lage, like a damaged road or a dirty lane and the vil- One doesn't need to start afresh in the event of a dis-
lagers work to make improvements. Instead of money, aster. Just by activating the existing pipelines spread
they get clothes as wages. Imagine the potential value all over the county one can achieve the purpose. It's
of old unused clothing in your cupboard - roads could this concept which won us our second Changemakers
be repaired in Morigaon, Assam or irrigation technolo- Innovation award.
gy could be installed in Sunderban Delta, West. The scope of the concept can be envisaged from the
India still has 35% of its population living below the fact that today, apart from clothes, we are even dealing
poverty line, with the majority of the poor living in the with things like furniture and computers. Thus we are
villages. Basic resources essential for survival are hard using clothing as an entry point into the entire move-
to procure, for example, medicines for the sick, or ment of treating urban wastage as a resource for rural
books for school children are far from available in many India.
of the remote and isolated rural areas because they In future I hope GOONJ is able to offer a solution to
have escaped the attention of state policies. On the an often talked about reality of India- the rising dispar-
other side of the spectrum, India is said to be undergo- ity between rich and poor, and how this is a problem
ing its biggest consumer boom with the ever-increasing that is only going to get worse.
purchasing power in the cities and towns. 'Conditions Our vision is to spread the idea so far and wide that
of plenty' along with shrinking space for the urban soci- whenever anybody thinks of discarding something
eties result in excess materials being accumulated that reusable they know of a channel to reach it to a person
can be utilized, but is now wasted. GOONJ is just mak- who needs it most.
ing use of this reality.
'SCHOOL to SCHOOL,' winner of the changemakers anshugoonj24@gmail.com
30
Catalyst For Human Development
Social Service
HE traffic lights turn red and the cars screech to a halt bomb of growing social unrest.
T at a busy signal…a 7 year old boy, in an oversized
shirt and bare feet rushes towards the opened windows
Given the failure of our political leaders to provide ade-
quate response, private action has become indispensa-
waiting vehicles, of his eyes gleaming with hope that ble and perhaps the only real solution to address the
some kindred passenger will throw a few coins at him. needs of the underprivileged.
Tonight he wants to go to bed without a thrashing from The fundamental premise of GiveIndia's operating
the "master" for not having "earned" enough. model is that the donor is an "investor" looking for returns
The gentleman in the car ahead, on the other hand is of some kind (most commonly the satisfaction of knowing
more exasperated than usual at this sight. The air condi- that their money made a difference to someone else's
tioner in the car is not working. He has had to lower the life). While it is possible that there are people who give
window to get a breath of fresh air. He slaps his forehead without any expectations, our efforts are targeted at
impatiently and tells his driver to quickly raise the window those who need to know that their money is making a dif-
glasses before the young boy on the road can approach ference.
his car and "harass"
him. He has had a Internet In 2000,
long hard day with Giving GiveIndia
his auditor on where pioneered
he can invest the 2 online donations in
million dollar profit India. GiveIndia offers
he has made. The donors an online mech-
boy runs dangerous- anism to donate to wor-
ly between the cars thy NGOs. The organi-
to one that seems to zations promoted must
hold greater prom- fulfill stringent criteria,
ise. This is a com- in a variety of fields of
mon sight on our work, emphasizing
roads and many of accountability and
us have been an transparency. Donors
audience to it. use the information
GiveIndia was generated about these
born out of the organizations to select
vision of one individ- the organizations they
ual who believed would like to support.
that if we wanted a
better society - a more just and equitable community - Payroll Our Payroll Giving Programme is
then we must encourage and support those that have Giving designed to allow employees of partici-
taken the steps to bring about change. pating companies to donate as little as Rs
50 [write in dollar value for this] every month, directly
The Need for a GiveIndia is founded on the from their salaries. An employee can choose to educate
Giving Culture belief that "equal opportunity" is a child, help a blind person see or provide a wheelchair
the cornerstone of civilization. to a disabled person, among other options.
Every human being must have roughly the same oppor-
tunity to succeed in life, irrespective of where or how Charity GiveIndia is the Charity partner of the
he/she is born. Events Mumbai & Delhi Marathons. These
The last two decades have witnessed the gap widening marathons have helped us reach out to
between the rich and poor in India. While the poor don't large number of new donors by allowing them to run and
get a fair chance to succeed in life due to lack of access raise money for a cause. By "piggy backing" existing
to decent education, healthcare and livelihood opportuni- events that are already planned, it is ensured that the
ties, the well-off continue to enjoy benefits from a global- cost of fundraising is less than 10%.
ising economy - greater incomes, decreasing taxes,
100% inheritance, etc. The net result is a ticking time-
32
Catalyst For Human Development
Social Service
ABOUT
THE FOUNDER
GiveIndia is the brainchild of Venkat Krishnan who graduated from IIM-
Ahmedabad in 1993 and started his career with the media. He then helped set up
Sony Entertainment Television in India as part of the core management team. In
1996, he co-founded Eklavya Education Foundation (http://www.eklavya.org/) along
with 3 other IIMA alumni. He set up GIVE Foundation in 2000, to create a "giving cul-
ture" in India by providing people with opportunities to contribute to good causes,
with very high standards of transparency and accountability. GIVE (Giving
Impetus to Voluntary Effort) today raises over US $ 200,000 a year through
http://www.giveindia.org/ and affiliated efforts. GIVE also channels over
US $ 1million a year to India's voluntary sector through its
Corporate Philanthropy and Grant
Management services.
aarti@giveindia.org
www.giveindia.org
”
numbers are poor and miserable.
33
Catalyst For Human Development
Women Finance
Mann Deshi group envisions a future where financial services are available to
women who aspire to make life better for future generations.
E don't mind answering your questions, Amma, but why Our research has included some pioneering and important
‘W don't you do something useful? The baby is sick.' And
thus began our career as village researchers. Bhavani was 25
health policy work. The Central Planning Commission has used
two of our research papers for policy formation. The WHO
with an M.Sc. in nutrition, including a gold medal. I was sport- sought us out for a unique longitudinal study on cervical cancer
ing a newly acquired Ivy League PhD in International Nutrition based upon our own pioneering study of cervical cancer in rural
and Development Policy with specialties in medicine and agri- areas. Currently we are working with the London School of
cultural economics. The setting was a remote village in a Hygiene and Tropical Medicine and Unilever Research on a
drought-prone district in Andhra Pradesh, India. The year was study on hand washing and behavioral change.
1982. Bhavani and I, an American, had just set up our 'Institute But the joy of our lives centers around the two clinics IRHS
for Rural Health Studies' and this was our first research project. runs in the remote rural areas of Mahbubnagar District and its
We had been offered a one-room cowshed by the village related program 'Travellers Aid for the Sick'. The rural clinics
sarpanch, complete with one light bulb and a mud floor! Such are staffed entirely by local people who have been, and contin-
generosity was hard to come by in such an impoverished sur- ue to be, trained by short-term American and British volunteer
rounding. doctors. A laboratory, gynecology unit, pharmacy plus general
Our research was focused on studying the variation in food outpatients make up each clinic. Outreach work is preventative
supply and its relationship to nutritional status. All families we and includes teaching.
were studying about had children under More than 600 primary school chil-
five. We were measuring a wide range dren are taught health education each
of inputs from labor force participation week, classes for teenagers on issues
and harvests, to food consumption and of heath and sexuality are held on
health with everything in between, but Fridays and extensive home visits
the villagers, while cooperating fully, made covering antenatal care and
begged us to fill the real gap in their child heath up to the age of three.
lives - medical care. And if we couldn't When primary healthcare is not suf-
provide that, at least, they begged, ficient, clinic staff know they can send
"help us to find it and protect us from a patient directly to the District
being neglected". And thus began our Hospital where IRHS Patient
real careers as health providers as well Counsellors will assist them to access
as researchers. The need was great. care. At the District Hospital, the IRHS
The first week I left Bhavani and our also runs the state's only rural cervical
research assistant alone in the village to return to Hyderabad, cancer screening outpatient service. This is a duplicate of the
a baby died in her arms. village-to-village programme, also run by IRHS in which each
We have never looked back since those hard early days and week a different village is selected for provision of both early
have continued to combine research with the provision of detection of cervical cancer and treatment using colposcopy,
healthcare, both curative and preventative. Bhavani was an biopsies and cryotherapy.
'elderly' 34 before she allowed herself to marry and return to In the central bus station (the largest in Asia with 75 plat-
her native West Bengal. In those intervening years she was my forms), the state transport company has built for the IRHS an
colleague, my best friend and my teacher. That included teach- office from which to base its service to rural people seeking
ing me how to eat properly with my fingers. more advanced healthcare. Run by two trained Patient
The Institute for Rural Health Studies (IRHS) has certainly Counsellors, the Travellers Aid for the Sick center receives
not lived up to its name given the amount of direct healthcare patients from the clinics and helps them to reach the main
and preventive health provided over these past 25 years. I Hyderabad government hospitals where they can access care.
suppose we should look for a new name that more aptly Back at the bus terminal, at all times, one Patient Counsellor
describes what we do. But a bi-directional organization can scouts the platforms looking for incoming rural villagers from all
offer staff more opportunities to learn research techniques, can over the state who have come to Hyderabad, a city of 7 million
provide policy makers with sound policy with which to formulate people, to seek medical care not available to them in their
health policy - all the while offering some of the poorest vil- remote villages. In addition to this service, the counsellors in
lagers in the world the medical assistance they need to return the bus terminal also offer first aid, and counselling on HIV pre-
to a productive life. vention and reproductive health.
hyd2_irhsirhs@sancharnet.in
35
Catalyst For Human Development
Health
36
Catalyst For Human Development
Health
Community Mental For over 15 years, SCARF the Tsunami, OXFAM supported this project. We linked
Health served the rural communities in to two centres in tsunami affected regions and offered
Tamil Nadu with the aid of the counseling and treatment. Now, with support from
International Development Research Centre (IDRC) Deutsche Bank, we have enlarged the scope of this
from Canada, some Italian NGOs and the WHO. One of service. This is novel because it is cost effective by
the main goals is to increase awareness about mental ill- reducing the need for infrastructure and saving much
nesses with the specific aim of dispelling myths and mis- travel time.
conceptions using traditional folklore and audio-visual
material. Even those who held the belief that only magi- Family and Child SCARF supports the education
cal and religious treatment can help were slowly con- Support of 40 children every year -
vinced to take psychiatric medication. Traditional heal- these are children whose
ers were also involved. More than 200,000 persons in fathers are too disabled by mental illness to work and
villages around Tamil Nadu were screened for mental support the children's education. A child guidance clinic
disorders. If someone was diagnosed, she or he was also helps children and their parents.
treated. Simple measures, such as the distribution of Although disability caused by mental illness has been
goats and livestock, were taken to allow the mentally recognized worldwide decades ago, the Indian govern-
disabled to earn a livelihood. ment included it in the Persons with Disabilities Act only
recently. This move resulted after much lobbying, in
In 1990, I was elected a senior which SCARF played a leading role.
An Ashoka Fellow
Ashoka fellow to work in the
urban slums of Madras for two years. I chose two slums Challenges The greatest challenge is to
by the sea (both of which were subsequently affected by simplify the understanding of
tsunami) and another slum further inland. A door-to-door mental illness and communicate it effectively to the pub-
survey revealed great mental morbidity. Therefore, an lic. While a child with spastic limbs or a woman with
outpatient clinic was started two days a week. Many blindness are quick to attract sympathy, this is not so
awareness programmes were also conducted using cin- with mental illness. Even educated people do not under-
ema and music. stand it. The picture of a woman collecting garbage on
At this time, there were over 100 health posts in the road or an aggressive man talking to himself evokes
Chennai, which were similar to primary health centers more fear and disgust than empathy. We had to system-
(PHCs) in villages. This was under the World Bank’s atically overcome this challenge through various means.
IPP-V project. With the permission of the state govern- There is also the stigma associated with mental ill-
ment, I trained all the multi-purpose workers in these nesses. Donors who would have no hesitation in having
health posts to identify serious mental disorders and their help acknowledged by eye or heartcare institutions,
make appropriate referrals. Other side tasks for the very often did not want their names to be displayed in
mutli-purpose workers include working with the families SCARF. Of course, there is the low priority accorded to
and ensuring follow-up with the patient. The World Bank mental health in general and rehabilitation in particular.
recognized this initiative as an innovative project. Thus, Fundraising is another major task, since mental health
I became a panelist to elect other Ashoka fellows. does not appear on the agendas of many international
donor agencies.
scarf@vsnl.com
Telemedicine SCARF's most recent innovation
is using telemedicine for the community projects. After
37
Catalyst For Human Development
Water
38
Catalyst For Human Development
Superstition
40
Catalyst For Human Development
Accidents
RAUMA support systems are not solely the domain of doc- leagues. After four hours of being stranded, in the early morn-
T tors and medical professionals. They require a network of
various stakeholders to save lives on the highways. Lifeline
ing, help arrived. Dr. Das and Sushmita spent their recovery
time planning HRP. Using the inspiration they got from the
Foundation's HIGHWAY RESCUE PROJECT has demon- traumatic experience for three years, the couple developed a
strated how this can be achieved in India. plan to improve such practices as traffic management, driver
Today, while Road Traffic Accidents (RTAs) rank as the 9th education, safety research and development to make sure that
major cause of deaths world-wide, they are the leading cause lives are not lost on highway.They developed such rescue util-
of mortality between the ages of 15-44 years. By 2020 it is ity ideas as integrated and centralized ambulances. Without
predicted to rank as the 2nd major cause of deaths world-wide. owning a single facility, the two spent three years coordinating
ambulances, cranes, metal cutters, police
In India India ranks for high RTA facilities, hospitals and blood banks to
fatality rates in the world. launch HRP on 1st July 2002.
It has only 1% of the world's vehicles but With no South Asian programme prece-
accounts for 6% of the world's accidents. dents of this magnitude for guidance,
The country recorded 92,000 deaths in Lifeline developed a pilot project to make
2003-04. RTAs cost the country Rs. 75,000 the 263 km of NH8 between Ahmedabad
crore or 3% of its GDP. and Surat safer. Lifeline employees care-
While in developed countries, drivers fully mapped the highway, incorporating
and passengers account for more than every highway landmark, developed soft-
70% of deaths, the majority of those killed ware to locate accident callers and set up
or injured in India are pedestrians and a 24-hour control room team. Today
users of two-wheelers and public trans- Lifeline serves 1401 kms of national high-
portation. Road safety experts call them ways in Gujarat and 337 kms in
"vulnerable road users". Not even at the Maharashtra. Within 6 months, it is to be
government level is there a clearly defined expanded on NH2 in West Bengal and
policy to make the parties concerned to NH8 in Rajasthan. Lifeline's network of
administer post-accident trauma care. providers includes 164 ambulances in
Gujarat and 30 in Maharashtra, 67
Out of all accidents leading to fatalities: Hospitals, 42 Cranes and metal cutters, 27
20% die on the spot due to open skull Blood Banks and 56 Police Stations. The
injuries, major cardio-vascular injuries, multi-organ injury or central control room at Baroda responds to any distress call. In
sudden acute blood loss; 48 months of its launch HRP saved the lives and limbs of near-
30% die due to delay of transportation or during transporta- ly 1,800 seriously injured accident victims on highways of both
tion, which is often primitive; and the states.
50% die in hospitals within 5 days of admission, due to infec-
tion and multi-system failure. Lifeline is trying to ensure every citizen
Future Directions
has immediate access to EMS. It has
The above facts prove that timely evacuation and better partnered other NGOs in getting a draft resolution on EMS Act
transportation of victims can definitely save lives. Currently for Gujarat. The state would be the first in the country to have
Emergency Medical Services is still in its infancy in India. such an act. The draft act will address funding ; establishment
Lifeline Foundation conceptualized, developed and launched of protocols and systems ; credentialisation of Trauma care
a Highway Rescue Project (HRP) for the country for the first personnel and hospitals and scope of practice ; benchmarking
time on July 1, 2002. and licensing of ambulances and transportation networks ;
standardisation and certification of training programmes ; cre-
HRP was founded by Dr. Subroto Das ation of a nodal EMS agency at the State level ; and Single
The Human
and Sushmita Das in August 1999 after phone Number for Public Access in Emergencies.
Resources Project
they survived a terrible accident on a
rainy night on the NH8 Highway. With broken bones, info@highwayrescue.org
bleeding faces and damaged knees, they were left stranded www.highwayrescue.org
and fought all night for their lives and the lives of their col-
41
Catalyst For Human Development
Ecology
The eco-paradise, called the Western Ghats, is breathtaking. The complex and long-term
struggle necessary to conserve it is quite vital for the region. The adventure-tourism
model is one tool that goes to strengthen the conservation movement -- an
interaction between urban and rural organisations.
community. While catalyzing involvement of community on serving the folk dances and ballets of Western Ghat cultures.
issues related to environment, they are the organizations, Organized training and choreography involving experts have
torchbearers that run the outdoor programmes. This unique led to invitations to demonstrate the folk dances in larger
form of employment allows them to get paid to share their cities.
valuable know-how.
GHATS GHATS is an economic venture that bol-
Amateur Naturalists Focused on building barefoot natu- sters the income of rural villagers by
Team ralists teams, the Amateur adding shelf life to renewable non-timber forest products.
Naturalists Team (ANT) has estab- These products have unique value because the delicacies
lished its own Training center at
Kagadalu in Sira Taluk, Karnataka.
Using street plays, folk music and
Drama, the organization demon-
strates the role of nature. ANT also
is key in encouraging children and
youth to take up environmental
research which is essential for
future conservation strategy devel-
opment.
The training of young girls in the
art of Chittara is generating oppor-
tunities for the preservation of a
unique Indian culture. Part time
and full time training programmes,
offered by Chittaradangala, have
successfully involved women of
43
Catalyst For Human Development
Social Change
”
pate in the full Saïd MBA programme and supports Skoll
Fellows who do research in and teach social entrepreneur-
ship.
The Centre also convenes the Skoll World Forum on
Social Entrepreneurship, an annual conference that brings
together the world's foremost practitioners and thought
leaders in the emerging field of social entrepreneurship.
To foster connections online, the Skoll Foundation
45
Catalyst For Human Development
Skoll Awards
46
Catalyst For Human Development
Skoll Awards
Grant Amount:
$1,015,000 over
47
Catalyst For Human Development
Skoll Awards
48
Catalyst For Human Development
Skoll Awards
49
Catalyst For Human Development
Innovation
World Summit on
INNOVATION & ENTREPRENEURSHIP
A BETTER GENERATION IN THE MAKING
Attended by over 600 of the World's Leading Innovators and Entrepreneurs from 55 Countries, including several
pre-eminent thought leaders, entrepreneurs, investors and developers, the WSIE is the first-of-its kind forum, which
aims to develop practical solutions to address the most important issues facing emerging nations and to inspire the
development of the next generation of entrepreneurs and innovators to fully celebrate the opportunities of the
21st century in a climate of global prosperity.
Given below are some of the highlights of the participants who attended the Summit which
was held in the first week of April 2006 at Muscat, Oman.
COMMITMENT HIGHLIGHTS
Dr. Alexander Boehmer, Coordinator, MENA-OECD Investment Programme
Committed to establish the MENA-OECD Enterprise Financing Network aimed to
improve the regulatory conditions for financing entrepreneurship. The Network
aims to foster entrepreneurship finance in the region by: · Creating a plat-
form to connect entrepreneurs, financiers, research bodies, and government reg-
ulators · Providing avenues for private sector participants to effectively input into
key investment policy reforms relevant to financing of entrepreneurship
Des Ryan, Business Support Manager, Qatar Science & Technology Park
(QSTP)
Committed, through QSTP, to providing a range of capacity building programs that
include the setting up in Qatar within the next year a proof of concept fund, a new
enterprise fund and a technology venture fund. These important funds for entre-
preneurs will be supported by a range of entrepreneur skill program including an
entrepreneur course, a mentoring program and a workforce development initia-
tive.
50
Catalyst For Human Development
Innovation
Dr. Claude Béglé, COO, DHL Express Germany & Managing Director, DHL
Express Central Europe Committed to personally mentor a young entrepreneur in the
field of express / logistics from a WSIE member country, and use his personal time to
coach the entrepreneur and discuss his/her plans. In addition, Dr. Béglè committed to
organize an invitation for the entrepreneur to come to DHL's headquarters to Bonn,
Germany for introduction to the company and the industry and provide contacts to other
entrepreneurial and innovative teams.
David Wortley, Project Manager, NTI Creative Industries Centre for Knowledge
Exchange, De Montfort University
Committed to provide access to the virtual collaboration technologies at De Montfort
University to support and facilitate virtual meetings/seminars for the development of
knowledge exchange. He also committed to promote and profile local entrepreneurs.
51
Catalyst For Human Development
NGOs
ANY Indian which are unable to make long term plans, as their tradi-
M NGOs are meet-
ing such challenges
tional sources of revenue are purely temporary in nature.
Excerpts from the interview with Bart W. Edes, who BWE: The ADB sees and checks the antecedents and
heads the NGO and Civil Society Center at ADB: records of hundreds of NGOs in India with which we are
associated. We also look at details like
Catalyst for Human Development : The Asian whether they are registered, paying tax
Development Bank has launched a net- regularly and making information
work to bring together all non-govern- Bart W. Edes, available to public, before we
mental organisations and private release funds. Moreover, we are
sector across the Asia Pacific Head, Asian not expected to disburse small
region last year. How is the Development Bank's grants directly. We will edu-
response ? cate the NGOs on their activ-
NGO and Civil Society ities and guide them through
Bart W. Edes: The ADB held a our newsletters. PRAXIS
meeting in Thailand in 2004 which
Center, is all praise for India, which is a not-for-prof-
was attended by some 30 NGOs many Indian NGOs it, autonomous, development
and corporates. The intention was to -- support organisation, has
promote sustainable development,
working at been doing an excellent job to
eradicate poverty and to improve the grass roots facilitate the promotion of par-
quality of life in the region. I am glad to ticipatory practices in human
say that the response was encouraging
level. development initiatives in an inte-
and the network was launched in February gral manner.
2005.
CFHD: What are ADB's views about YES ?
Many corporates are persuading the NGOs to work for
knowledge capacity building. There is a common ground BWE: Asian countries like India and Philippines are in
for both and they can work together in helping the poor advantageous position compared to other continents as
thus complementing the efforts of the Governments. a very high young population who can change the world.
They are forging partnerships to provide disaster relief, As far as YES is concerned, it deserves support. It is
protect the environment, address health needs, promote also working with Governments, NGOs and businesses.
education, and assist marginalized and disadvantaged The members of YES are practical, showing results.
communities. The network would also help the NGOs, ADB will wholeheartedly support its activities.
52
Catalyst For Human Development
Portrait
53
Catalyst For Human Development
Awards
About mid last year Transparency able to citizens, who can file petitions
International released a survey detailing under the Act to request information, docu-
corruption trends in India. After polling ments, status of work and thus question
over 14,000 respondents in 20 Indian governmental negligence, misuse, corrup-
states, the organisation assessed that tion or apathy.
Indians pay some 20,000 crores in bribes Heading Parivartan's small team of vol-
annually while availing services from one unteers, Kejriwal began work publicizing
or more of eleven public utility services. the Act, encouraging people to use it and
The trend reflects more than just vast urging that they not be cowed down by the
amounts of illegal money transfer. It epito- open hostility unleashed by politicians and
mizes what has become a way of life - bureaucrats who were often being ques-
62% of citizens polled said that they tioned for the first time.
thought corruption was "real" and admit- Five years on, Kejriwal acknowledges
ted to having used a bribe or a "contact" (euphemism for that there have been "huge changes-cultural changes" -
getting work done by not strictly transparent methods) to on both sides. Bureaucrats were getting used to the fact
get a job done. that they have to be transparent. People have now start-
Even as Transparency International India was releas- ed demanding accountability.
ing its dismal survey findings, a movement for change Once the Right to Information Act came into effect in
had already taken root and begun at the grassroots, 2001, Kejriwal began training programmes to spread
with the everyday citizen demanding his right to know. awareness about the potential of the act. Parivartan
Spearheaded by a Delhi-based citizen's group, began work in a slum in East Delhi. Launching the Drive
Parivartan (change), working for transparency and Against Bribe campaign with the support and coopera-
accountability in governance, local politicians and tion of the media, Kejriwal has been trying to encourage
bureaucrats were being challenged by the very citizen every section of society to get involved with the RTI Act.
they were elected to serve. What began as work in Delhi has now spread through
The face of Parivartan is the dynamic and capable the country. Trainers from various NGOs came to Delhi
Arvind Kejriwal. Recipient of the prestigious to be taught under a special model and then went back
Magsaysay Award in 2006, Kejriwal activated India's to their cities to swing the RTI into motion.
right-to-information movement empowering New Delhi's Kejriwal is still trying to "develop linkages". Work also
poorest citizens to fight corruption. Kejriwal was granted began with student groups in Delhi to show them how
an Ashoka Fellowship in 2004, four years after he relevant the RTI Act can be to their lives.
founded Parivartan after watching opaque government Kejriwal now hopes to move Parivartan's work beyond
procedures first hand at an earlier job as a tax officer RTI. "It gives you information but doesn't ensure your par-
with the Indian Revenue Service. ticipation in governance," he points out, about the Act. So
Parivatan was set up to deal with bribery and extortion Parivartan will move logically into the crucial areas of
which the common man experiences for everything he local empowerment in matters of governance.
needs-from a license to a passport. If there was a prob-
lem getting a job done, Parivatan would intervene on www.parivartan .com
behalf of the citizen. But how far could they go and how
much could they cover?
The question was answered with the passage of the
Right to Information (RTI) Act in Delhi in 2001, a land-
mark piece of legislation applicable in all Indian states
except Jammu and Kashmir. It holds officials account-
54
Catalyst For Human Development
Awards
SUNITA NARAIAN
Environment
Sunita Narain, 43, has been with the She has written numerous articles in
Centre for Science and Environment newspapers, magazines including a
from 1982. She is currently the director of weekly/fortnightly/column on environment
the Centre and the director of the Society and development, Green Politics and
for Environmental Communications and Down To Earth for leading dailies.
publisher of the fortnightly A crusader of pollution-pre Delhi, Sunita
magazine,Down To Earth. In her years at Narain dreamt of world’s cleanest-public
the Centre, she has worked hard at trasport-network for the city. Says Sunita,
analysing and studying the relationship “New Delhi was choking to death. Air
between environment and development polution was taking one life per hour.”
and at creating public consciousness According to Time Magazine, in the
about the need for sustainable develop- mid-1990s, Narain filed a lawsuit to force
ment. Delhi's buses, taxis and rickshaws to convert to clean-
er-burning compressed natural gas (CNG).
AWARDS 2005: Stockholm Water Prize (2005) for In July 1998, the Supreme Court ruled largely in her
CSE for its work in promoting effective water manage- favor and adopted many of her proposals. It ordered a
ment along with improved human rights" under the ban on leaded fuel, conversion of all diesel-powered
dynamic leadership of Sunita Narain. buses to CNG and the scrapping of old diesel taxis
2005: Padma Shri by the Government of India, New and rickshaws.
Delhi. But busmakers and oil companies--supported by
Over the years, she has also developed the man- government ministers--objected loudly. So the court
agement and financial support systems needed for the formed a committee, led by Lal and Narain, to enforce
institution, which has over 100 staff members and a its judgment.The unlikely duo immediately ran into
dynamic programme profile. She is currently in charge roadblocks. Bus companies took vehicles off the road,
of the Centre's management and plays an active role stranding angry commuters. Mile-long queues of rick-
in a number of research projects and public cam- shaws formed at the handful of gas stations with CNG
paigns . pumps.
Her research interests are wide-ranging - from glob- Oil companies trotted out scientists who claimed that
al democracy, with a special focus on climate change, CNG was just as polluting as diesel. But Narain and
to the need for local democracy, within which she has Lal fought back. By December 2002, the last diesel
worked both on forest-related resource management bus had left Delhi, and 10,000 taxis, 12,000 buses and
and water-related issues. 80,000 rickshaws were powered by CNG. Although
She began her career by writing and researching for air pollution in Delhi has stabilized, the fight for clean
the State of India's Environment reports and then went air is far from won. Some 400 to 600 new private cars
on to study issues related to forest management. roll onto the city's streets every day. Narain and Lal
For this project she travelled across the country to don't claim to have slowed global warming. But their
understand people's management of natural efforts have attracted requests for advice from as far
resources and in 1989 co-authored the publication away as Kenya and Indonesia. "Delhi leapfrogged,"
Towards Green Villages advocating local participatory Narain says with a grin. "People noticed."
democracy as the key to sustainable development. In
the early 1990s she got involved with global environ-
mental issues and she continues to work on these as www.cseindia.org
researcher and advocate.
Narain remains an active participant, both nationally
and internationally, in civil society. She serves on the
boards of various organisations and on governmental
committees and has spoken at many fora across the
world on issues of her concern and expertise.
55
Catalyst For Human Development
Awards
VINEET RAI
Best Business
The Mumbai-based Aavishkaar represents the collective assets of
India Micro Venture Capital Fund more than 80 investors.
(AIMVCF) is among the top ten The company has thus been able
best global business houses which to bring together a new blended-
received the World Business value asset class by merging main-
Awards on May 10, 2006, at the stream venture capital principals of
United National Headquarters in risk capital and intensive hand hold-
New York. ing with the kind of nurturing needed
World Business Awards are by sustainable businesses that aim
sponsored jointly by the United to address rural development
National Development Programme issues.
(UNDP), the Prince of Wales Aavishkaar's Co-founder and
International Business Leaders CEO, Vineet RaI, believes that the
Forum (IBLF) and the International World Business Award is an
Chamber of Commerce (ICC) and acknowledgement that small initia-
are given away annually to the best tives have a critical role to play in
business models across the world. meeting challenging global issues enshrined in the
The selection panel of the World Business Awards Millennium Development Goals.
identified 10 finalists out of 77 entries received from AIMVCF is now in the process of expanding its fund
33 countries for year 2006 awards, for striving size and is aggressively engaged in identifying new
towards fulfillment of the Millennium Development investment opportunities in innovative rural initiatives
Goals (MDGs). and start-up microfinance service companies that
AIMVCF is the only recipient from India of the pres- enhance commercial and social value.
tigious award and the second Indian company so far,
after ITC got it in 2005. www.aavishkaar.org
Set up as a social venture capital fund in 2001 to
provide early-stage capital to micro and small enter-
prises that lack access to conventional financial insti-
tutions, Aavishkaar India reaches out to hundreds of
thousands of firms with resource-efficient products
and solutions that enhance livelihood options in a sus-
tainable manner.
”
It approved 9 equity investments before being
picked up for the award. And the range of investments
is Rs. 10 Lakh to Rs. 50 Lakh (US $ 20,000 to $
1,00,000) from its corpus fund, which
- Walter D. Wintle
56
Catalyst For Human Development
Book Reviews
57
Catalyst For Human Development
Essay
HE life of primitive mankind was "solitary, poor, nasty, (approximately 10 million children annually) die - mostly
T brutish, and short," as Thomas Hobbes, a 17th
Century English philosopher, described it. Perhaps, the
from preventable diseases.4
The advantages of civilization are clearly not reaching
origin of human civilization stems from the desire to at least a billion people. Harvard economist Kenneth
change this. Agriculture, planting and collecting cereal Rogoff warns that the unfair distribution of wealth within
grains or tending animals, made meaningful settlements most countries will lead to serious social tensions all over
possible for humans 10,000 years ago. In the following the world. (KenRogoff. 2006)
thousands of years social organizations evolved. This To have a fair distribution of resources we must provide
can be chiefdom, where a chieftain rules the people, or a access to basic needs, income generating activities,
state society, where a ruling class is supported by a health care and basic education for all. During one of my
bureaucracy. At every stage of progress until present- visits to India, Mr. Krishna Mohan, a grass root worker of
day, more and more people benefit from access to natu- an NGO, took me to small villages near Jetni, Orissa on
ral resources, opportunities power and wealth to live their a hot summer day. I observed him in action. He met peo-
full potential. Yet, a large section of the population is left ple who are among the 1 billion we count in the extreme
behind. poverty category. He was making them realize their
Ours is a world of extremes. The poorest 40 percent or potential, by providing the means and tools to do small
2.5 billion of the world's population lives on less than US vegetable garden-
$2 a day 1. There has ing, tend goats, sell
been a reduction in eggs, get basic
poverty due to various medical check-ups,
development pro- attend literacy
grammes in the last classes and train
decade. But due to an women to deliver
increase in population, babies to reduce
today's world still has 1.1 child and maternal
billion people living in mortality. In him, I
extreme poverty. The see the means to
World Bank defines bridge the gap. But
extreme poverty as living one Krishna Mohan
on $1 or less per day 2. can do only so
Most of those in extreme much in his life
poverty are in Sub- time. The problem
Saharan Africa and South is a billion people
Asia. Here, where poor large. Today we
health and the lack of have the knowl-
education deprive people edge, technical
of productive employment, deplete environmental skills, tools and means to bridge the gap. But the
resources and create corruption, conflict, and misgover- resources, money and time are the problems. We need
nance, waste public resources and discourage private faster, better solutions that can be multiplied 1,000 folds
investment. to reach millions of people. Only then can the problems
Sixteen percent of the total wealth available in the of the billions be solved.
world is produced capital.3 Everyone in the world should A social entrepreneur can create new solutions to
have equal access to the remaining 84 percent of the social problems and implement them on a large scale.
wealth on this planet. However, natural resources are not Therefore we need them. We need them by the
available to all equally. This results in the gap between thousands!.
the rich and poor. Approximately 50 percent of the world's srao@afhd.org
population has 10 percent of the world's wealth and the Reference:
richest 20 percent has 71.2 percent of the world's wealth.
(Dr. B. Milanovic, Personal Communications, World 1. http://www.undp.org/publications/annualreport2006/
equitable_growth.shtml
Bank)The life expectancy to a child in the developing 2. http://devdata.worldbank.org/wdi2006/contents/
world is short. The under-5 mortality is a very good indi- Section1_1_1.htm
cator of human development. Everyday in the developing 3. Where is the Wealth of Nations?' World Bank 2005).
world, 29,000 children under the age of five years 4. http://www.cdc.gov/malaria/impact/index.htm
58
Catalyst For Human Development