You are on page 1of 36

Best Australian

Brands 2009
Ranked by brand value
Contents

01 Best Australian Brands Appendix


A letter from Damian Borchok
27 Commonly asked questions
02 Overview
Best Australian Brands 2009 32 About Interbrand

03 Why the Best Australian Brands 32 Contact us


ranking is important

04 The Red Thread by Jez Frampton


Putting the brand at the core of the
business becomes a uniting force behind
everything you do and say to drive value

08 The future of future-proofing brand


investments by Greg Silverman
How will we measure the unobservable
and make informed brand investment?

10 Planning your touchpoints to


accelerate profit by Rune Gustafson
Understanding brand as a central
organising principle requires the
management of every touchpoint to
build the experience for consumers

12 Interbrand’s approach to
valuing brands
Criteria for consideration
and methodology

13 Top line industry stories


by Lynton Pipkorn
Trends and insights into Australian brands

16 Ranking
Profiles of Australia’s Most
Valuable Brands and other prominent
Australian brands
Best
Australian
Brands
Interbrand presents the fourth ranking of the most
valuable Australian brands, arranged by brand value.

The economic turmoil of recent months has demand for their goods and services around the
made it more important than ever to world. Strong brands also create allegiance, use
understand your brand. The past studies of differentiation so they are not easily replicable,
the Best Australian Brands were conducted in work harder to impact markets, and command
times of economic growth. In good economic premium pricing. The best brands also attract
times, most brands will create some sort the best talent, continually reward investors,
of value. But in today’s uncertain times, use leadership to grow market share, and fare
where short- to medium-term profits are better in economic downturns. They are
under significant pressure, the challenge business assets that create value and give
for all brands will be to evaluate their brand companies tighter control of their future.
proposition and better understand their
customers’ perceptions of value. At the same As this study shows, many Australian brands Biography:
time, the dramatic shifts in demand and are poised for further growth. Australian brands As Managing Director for Australia,
business sentiment have altered the horizon are aggressively seeking to expand away from Damian Borchok believes
for most marketing departments. There is our shores into larger and more lucrative brands need bold strategies and
continued pressure placed on ROI, and the overseas markets. This promises these brands remarkable creative execution to
temptation is to cut marketing budgets, greater growth opportunities, and reduces risk deliver breakthrough performances.
discount prices and reposition brands as value to their earnings profile and further revenue His past clients include Telstra, News
propositions to maintain cash flows. Yet, such generation capabilities. Some companies such Limited, Goldman Sachs JBWere,
tactical approaches may erode long-term as Billabong, Macquarie Group, Harvey Norman, ASX, Perpetual, Fuji Xerox, Diageo,
brand value – we all know it is much harder Ansell, Computershare, Flight Centre and even Qantas, David Jones and Nestlé.
to trade a customer back up the value chain Australia Post have now established offshore
once margins have been eroded. cash flows. This strategy has proven to be
a great success for these brands, and it is clear
Protecting the brand’s long-term compound that many Australian brands are well prepared
investment must remain the highest priority. for the challenges that lie ahead. I would like
The careful crafting of a brand’s positioning to take this opportunity to congratulate each
must not be put at risk by expedient use of brand in making the Best Australian Brands
tactical communications that drive short- table. I wish you every success in your brand-
term volume benefits. Such a strategy can building efforts and the future that lies
lead to the destruction of the promises that ahead. I would also like to take this moment
created value for the brand in the first place. to thank Monash University and the Faculty
The real test for Australian brands weathering of Business and Economics for their research
the economic downturn and creating support in producing the Best Australian Brands
sustainable long-term brand value lies in 2009 study.
understanding these promises and staying
true to the pillars that form the foundation Yours sincerely,
of a business’s brand value.

Strong brands develop even stronger products


and services, undeniably creating sustainable
value for their owners. If brands are innovative
and managed correctly, they can move Damian Borchok
seamlessly across geographies, transcend Managing Director
different languages and cultures, and create Interbrand Australia

Best Australian Brands 2009 01


Overview
Best Australian
Brands 2009

We are delighted to unveil the Best Australian It is important to mention that there are The key to successful brand value
Brands 2009. other valuable Australian brands that would management for Australian brands is to put
make this list. However, because of differing in place strategies that take advantage of
In order to qualify for the Best Australian Brands reporting periods or the inability to separate opportunities in the downturn, then set
study, the company that owns the brand must individual brand earnings from consolidated a budget to achieve that strategy. Brands
be listed on the Australian Stock Exchange or figures, we are unable to include or estimate will need to work harder and smarter in this
have its financial information publicly available. their individual brand value. period to maintain leadership and generate
The brand must be registered for at least three brand value. Central to their success will be
years, and it must originate in Australia or be The importance of brand valuation the ability to get closer to stakeholders by
owned by Australian companies. employing more robust, end user-orientated
The articles in this study introduce the analytics practices to yield greater evidence-
The following insights highlight the specifics importance of understanding the importance based insights and outcomes.
of the Best Australian Brands ranking, of brands as a central organizing principle.
and the present situation of Australia’s best Brand valuation is an essential step in this The article, “The Future of Future-Proofing
performing brands. process. It provides the weaponry to identify Brand Investments”, by Greg Silverman
how brand influences performance by highlights how analytics can assist brands
• Telstra, in first position, continues to be uncovering the key drivers that effect to make more informed brand investments.
Australia’s most valuable brand at A$ 9.7 consumer choice. And as a management These analytics-based approaches aid
billion. In second position and valued at tool, brand valuation also reveals a number precision in decision-making and lead to more
A$ 7.1 billion, the Commonwealth Bank of of key insights that serve to provide an ROI effective insights and profitable outcomes.
Australia (CBA) is Australia’s most valuable perspective and, more importantly, inform By integrating brand analytics approaches
banking brand (with National Australia the future strategic direction of the brand. throughout strategy, design and brand
Bank at A$ 5.1 billion taking out third place). valuation, more precise capabilities are
These include: now available. These offer more effective
• The top 10 brands proved to be very stable diagnostic tools to understand the economic
and have demonstrated an ability to manage • Recommendations for how brand value benefits that brand assets provide to their
their brands to create greater value over drivers can be incorporated into brand owners. Brands with foresight and vision
a sustained period of time. positioning, media planning, communication can now more effectively leverage the
touchpoints and experience differentiation and strength of the brand
• The big financial services brands in Australia proposition relative to their competitors.
have not yet been as seriously affected as • The health of the brand – strengths, As a result, it is not only possible to quantify
their contemporaries in others countries. weaknesses, brand development a brand’s contribution in the decision-making
This is a result of the legacy of a strong opportunities, brand stretch and market/ process and to measure its competitive
regulatory system, strong balance sheets competitive threats strength in acquiring and retaining
and a healthy domestic deposit base. CBA is customers. Now, we can also predict the
by far Australia’s biggest bank and has gained • The extent to which brand and value of an innovation and understand at
considerable value by representing ”a safe communications strategies are contributing which communications touchpoint a brand
financial haven“ for a lot of Australians. to creating brand value investment generates the most demand.

• O
 f considerable interest going forward will • D
 rivers of competitive advantage and how By better understanding the equity drivers
be how Westpac will manage the value of its these are sustainable that create demand and impact brand value,
A$ 6.7 billion merger (the combined values brands will be better positioned to maintain
of both the Westpac and St. George brands). • A
 reas of brand weakness and the strategies cash flows, justify ROI and preserve the now
The challenge will be to continue to grow required to build brand strength and lift precious equity residing in the brand. In doing
the value of the St. George brand, currently brand performance this, brands will be best positioned to emerge
valued at A$ 1.9 billion, without eroding from the downturn and ready to capitalize
Westpac’s value. • M
 arketing spend guidance to ensure the on their weaker rivals when markets begin
greatest value impact to recover.

02 Best Australian Brands 2009


Why the Best
Australian Brands
ranking is important

The branding practices employed by Brand valuation can assist in positioning Most importantly, this ranking is presented
Australian companies are becoming more brand building as a critical aspect of to foster debate and put greater emphasis
and more sophisticated. Interbrand’s fourth enterprise by answering the following on the practice of branding. Our goal is to
ranking of the Best Australian Brands questions. demonstrate that brands are important
continues to put an emphasis on brand assets yielding significant economic value.
performance and its contribution to Are we investing adequately in our brand? To maximise the value inherent in your brand
business performance. The ranking provides Putting an economic value on a brand requires proactive and consistent investment,
brand values that are measures of economic (overall and by segment) can help make management and measurement.
performance, stating what the brand is a strong business case for marketing
worth overall and among competitors. investments, overall and across a brand Why do no Australian brands make the
Brand value brings to marketing what portfolio. While delivering a very important Global Best Brands list?
“revenue goals” or “financial hurdle rates” ROI measure, brand valuation, more While there are many significantly valuable
bring to other aspects of business. importantly, can help organisations to Australian brands, none have yet to appear
understand what levers drive brand value. on the Best Global Brands list. To qualify
The most important information comes It is these insights that can assist in the for the global table, at least one-third of
when one looks behind the number – appropriate allocation of investment and earnings needs to be earned from outside
as a single number only tells so much. It is the development of the strategic catalysts the company’s home base. The brand must
more important to understand what drives that can influence future value creation. also be well-established in a wide number
brand value: of markets around the world and be
Is our marketing performance effective managed consistently as a global brand.
• Intangible earnings: the cash flow of and efficient? To put it into perspective, the 100th most
a business not associated with such Your customers make decisions every day valuable brand in the 2008 Best Global
tangible assets as equipment or materials between you and your competitors. Brands Study was VISA, with an estimated
Analysing the role of brand in those decisions value of US$ 3.338 billion, which is
• The role of brand: a measure of how much helps you to focus your strategy on the equivalent to A$ 5.188 billion at current
brand influences purchasing decisions attributes that differentiate your brand from exchange rates. While some Australian
others and to strengthen your relationship brands have a greater brand value, they
• Brand strength: a benchmark of a brand’s with your best customers, thereby ensuring simply do not have the geographic spread
relative risk compared to competitors future earnings. that would make them eligible to reach the
Top 100 Best Global Brands list.
Understanding the drivers of brand value can Are short-term tactics driving long-term
inform management action, from overall value creation?
business strategy to specific marketing By analysing the strength of your brand,
tactics. It is an easy-to-use metric to help you can target marketing campaigns to
brand owners determine where they are, your most valuable customers in the most
where they are going, and how to get there. competitive manner. This can enable you to
drive short-term sales without sacrificing
long-term brand strength and relevance.

Best Australian Brands 2009 03


The Red Thread:
creating and managing
brand value
by Jez Frampton

“All of the ropes of the royal fleet,


from the strongest to the thinnest,
are braided so that a red thread
travels through all of them, and you
cannot remove it without untying all
of them. Even the smallest fragment
will still allow you to recognise that
Biography:
Jez Frampton, Interbrand’s Group

the rope belongs to the crown.”


Chief Executive, is responsible for
managing the firm’s worldwide
interests and enhancing the
strategic and creative offering. From Goethe’s Elective Affinities (1809)
Jez’s experience has provided him
the opportunity to work with
different clients across multiple The Red Thread is a concept woven smallest fragment to the whole, is powerful
sectors, including premier brands through many cultures. According to Greek and captivating. In our world, this is
like Budweiser, IBM and Toyota. mythology, Theseus found his way through a wonderfully rich and simple metaphor
the Minotaur’s labyrinth by following for brand value.
Ariadne’s red thread, and a famous Chinese
proverb describes an invisible red thread The top performing brands understand
that connects us to all of the people we’ll the reality behind this metaphor. For them,
ever meet. The Russians call it krasnaia nit, the notion of value runs like a red thread
and the French le fil rouge. In German, roter through their brands, driving demand
faden – literally “red thread” – is used to throughout every aspect of their business.
describe the central or recurrent theme They know that their brands must function
of a larger work. as assets, not as expenses, and that even
the greatest brand idea is only as powerful
The idea of a bright, illuminating thread as its ability to generate value.
that runs through everything, from the

04 Best Australian Brands 2009


The subject of brand value has been well detail about fuel consumption, lubricant
documented since Interbrand first developed temperatures, braking heat and even driver
the concept in the early 1980s. Today, our heart rate. When the competition is fierce
competitors, commentators in the press, and the difference between winning and
the financial community, and the industry losing can be measured in fractions of
at large have much to say about the topic. a second, every detail must be tuned to win.
At heart, it’s a simple idea. If a brand plays
a role in choice and a consumer must choose Imagine how powerful it would be if you
between different competitive products or understood how your brand creates value
services in a marketplace, then the brand to the same degree of detail. Are you as
must contribute to earnings and profit and intimate with the performance of your
hence, must be quantifiable and valuable brand as Formula 1 racing teams are with
to the owner. In order to really understand the performance of their cars? Are you as
the creation of brand value, we need to prepared to battle the competition? Do you
understand what factors drive demand, quantitatively understand exactly how your
what role the brand plays across each of brand generates value?
those factors, and how strong the brand is
versus its competitors. By using brand valuation as a diagnostic
tool, we can now understand the precise
But the Red Thread is about more than economic benefits that brand has on every
a value-generating brand. It’s about aspect of our businesses. It is now possible
understanding how that value is generated. not only to quantify a brand’s contribution in
It’s about creating, managing, and the decision-making process and to measure
measuring brand value across every aspect its competitive strength in acquiring and
of the business. retaining customers, but to predict the value
of an innovation and understand at which
To put this into context, let’s consider an touchpoint our brand investment generates
analogy. Capable of accelerating from zero the most demand. The Red Thread helps us
to 100 miles per hour and back to zero in see where in the acquisition process we lose
under four seconds, a Formula 1 racing car potential customers to our competitors,
represents the very edge of technology in which brand attributes are relevant at each
the motor industry. Every car is fine-tuned step in the customer journey, and far more.
for each individual race, and every surface Most importantly, it helps us determine
and element of the car can be altered to create exactly what it is that must be changed,
the best aerodynamics, braking pressure, and how, in order to maximise value.
tire pressure, gear ratios, suspension and
more. It is not the car but each individual
component of that car that must contribute
to the vehicle’s ultimate success.

What’s more, those components can


be quantitatively measured, giving the
racing team the information necessary to
optimise the car’s performance in real time.
Data streams from car to trackside with

Best Australian Brands 2009 05


Brand building isn’t
a separate exercise
from the day-to-day
running of the business.
It is integral to it.

Consider our work for BMW. Everything in Or take Interbrand, an example that is near
that organisation is coerced and corralled and dear to me. For us, the notion of brand
into a single unifying vision, all united by value itself is our Red Thread. We are the
one value-generating idea. For BMW, this consultancy that sees brands as economic
red thread is the commitment to please assets, as drivers of demand, and creators
customers with the very best in automotive of wealth. We believe that behind every great
engineering. This manifests itself in a brand is a great idea that generates value.
few obvious ways, such as its tagline and Our daily mission is to understand how that
messaging, but also guides management value is created across our clients’ businesses,
decisions on everything from showroom providing strategic advice and creative
plans to fabric choices, and ensures that the solutions that have a common purpose and
company’s outer voice (what it says it’s going foundation in generating demand. Whether
to do) reflects its inner voice (what it actually we are producing the corporate identities
does). And, as 93 percent of employees that will fuel the iconic images of the 21st
believe that BMW Group is a great place to century or crafting brand architectures to
work, it’s no wonder this translates to a brand optimise the way a major global enterprise
worth US$ 23 billion and the highest brand manages its assets, value is quite simply
value per automobile sold. the lifeblood at the very heart of our business,
the common theme that unites us and
This is true of many of the world’s most makes us stand out from the crowd.
valuable brands. Look at Apple, whose
promise of a different experience through I believe that the concepts of brand and value
ease of use creates a red thread that touches are inseparable. To be truly effective, brands
all aspects of their business, including must be built around the thing that generates
product innovation and interface design. the most value for your business. A brand
At Disney, the commitment to create conceived in this fashion will create demand,
magical experiences produces undeniable in turn improving the monetary value of
value, forming a red thread that affects the business. Managed properly, this ever-
everything from the appearance and growing cycle of value creation will define
behavior of its “cast members” to its the very essence of the 21st century’s
television programming. For Nike, the idea eminent brands.
of performance runs through the business
from “Just do it” to how the organisation
gets it done.

06 Best Australian Brands 2009


But to get there, we need to change the That’s a powerful shift in thinking in a
fundamental way that we think about our relatively short period of time. Not everyone
businesses. Most companies spend massive is there yet, but the leaders are. The global
amounts of time and money optimising their corporations at the top of the Fortune 500 or
supply chains, but few are willing to make our own Best Global Brands ranking see the
an adequate investment in the demand world this way, and it’s only a matter of time
side of their businesses. This is most likely before it becomes common practice.
because the supply side is physical and
real. It’s easy to understand the return on Some audiences, despite accepting the
tangible investments. The demand side of notion of a red thread, might believe that
our businesses, though, is often less clear. the current economic climate makes this
It requires courage to invest in intangible the wrong time to invest in measuring and
assets. Thankfully, the ability to measure managing brand value. But this could be
these intangible assets through precise a costly mistake. This is the ideal time to
analytics should help us refocus our attention optimise budgets to ensure that every dollar
on creating demand. spent is driving demand and creating value.
Every boardroom is subject to greater degrees
We must also change the way we think about of scrutiny over the use of shareholder funds
brands themselves. Ten years ago, brands and now, more than ever, we need to know
were seen as an extension of marketing: where we’re likely to win, and where we’re
a kind of halo around a business that likely to lose.
made it emotionally appealing. Marketing
departments spent time creating “brand ads”
with their agencies, an exercise seen as more
strategic and separated from the day-to-
day process of selling products, announcing
promotions, or launching campaigns. All businesses that
Today, the world has come to realise that
aspire to build greater
brands are an extension of business strategy. value should consider
Now understood to define the essence of
differentiation and to serve as primary and
their red thread.
integral drivers of demand, brands have as Without one, your
much to do with product, service, retail,
packaging, culture, web, pricing, channels,
brand may not be
and environments, as they have to do with generating real value.
marketing and communications.

Best Australian Brands 2009 07


The future of
future-proofing brand
investments
by Greg Silverman
Biography: The web search definition is important because it suggests
Greg Silverman is the Global Practice that brands are competing with each other for consumers.
Leader of Analytics. With over 20 years When focusing on competition, the branding industry
of experience in the business, traditionally looks to the role of the brand, as it is a measure
Greg and his team measure brand of influence and compares the brand against other decision
investment to show in advance criteria. This measure of influence is capitalised on when
whether an idea has the potential to a brand’s equity unlocks value by connecting with end-users.
earn brand equity. He has done work Unlocked value is brand strength – the ability to protect
on an extensive list of clients that future revenue.
boast some of the biggest brand
names in the world, including AT&T, The new order
Bank of America, Lexus, and Gillette. This relatively static picture of competition and branding
has dominated the landscape for decades. However, over
the last decade, this framework has broken down with the
increasing dominance of social networks. Social networks
are moving the branding debate from the traditional and
hierarchical to the latent and networked. As such, the
Understanding brand today long-held view of competition and branding no longer works
Before defining the way a brand works, it is necessary to because the forces behind the collective value of all social
understand the role of the brand and brand strength. The role networks have changed. In short, our customers’ culture
of brand explains what percentage of any purchase decision is trumping our strategy.
is attributable to the brand. It is a measure of the influence
brand has on customer demand. This understanding informs Along with the declining relevance of old strategy models,
decision-makers on how the brand is doing today. Brand we are witnessing a decline in the impact of the measures
strength, on the other hand, is a series of benchmarks that attached to them. The greatest advance in the past decade
measure a brand’s ability to secure ongoing customer demand has been in the realm of choice-based research and marketing
(choice, repurchase, retention). mix models that measure change in a limited number of issues
in a marketplace. Marketing mix models are rooted in the
Together, the role of brand and brand strength provide conventional wisdom that, if you track spending and sales –
managers with the knowledge to understand the future simultaneously controlling for all other variables – then you
outcomes of marketing decisions made today. When can clearly identify what is optimal. A question still remains:
incorporated with current computing and analytics What company can actually control for all the variability of
capabilities, the combination is no longer just informed the market? Media mix has clearly improved efficiency, but
speculation. Rather, it offers measurable scenarios that the process is backward-looking. Additionally, the rigid data
can provide insights that lead to courageous decisions. requirements do not accommodate the most important
factor: emergent social network influences are
If you type ”brand management” in the Google search box not simple to track.
and follow the link to the first definition available, this is
what appears: “Branding seeks to distinguish your company, Here’s a common example: Apple’s new iPhone specs were
product or service from the competition and create a lasting posted among friends on Facebook and the specs received
impression in your prospect’s mind.“ (www.1000ventures.com) poor feedback, which magnified critics’ reviews. How can
Given the relevancy scores that Google is presumed to obtain Apple account for word of mouth that could change the
– 90 percent – it is safe to assume that this definition is the product launch environment? The challenge now is to predict
common understanding of brand management. the unpredictable in a new market environment.

08 Best Australian Brands 2009


A new paradigm Agent-based modeling has already enabled:
Many marketers today unnecessarily constrain themselves
by saying, “You can only optimise what you know.” • A US healthcare provider to accurately predict the
With today’s consumers riding on waves of unobserved adoption of a new plan among seniors
and hard to track patterns, new tools are needed to provide
a future-looking perspective on brand-related value creation. • A global sports organisation to launch a rebranding
The breakthrough in measurement will come in agent-based campaign that creates free buzz
modeling (ABM). An agent-based model is a computational
model for simulating the actions and interactions of • An automotive company to effectively reduce
autonomous individuals in a network. It is capable of incentives while growing market share
assessing an individual’s effects on the system as a whole
by combining elements of game theory, complex systems, • A major consumer goods retailer to lower store
emergence, computational sociology, multi-agent systems, size 30 percent and increase sales
and evolutionary programming. Monte Carlo methods are
used to introduce randomness. The future
Media mix optimisation drives cost management, which can
The models simulate the simultaneous operations of help “meet the street,” but often sacrifices investment in new
multiple agents, in an attempt to recreate and predict the revenue streams. Discrete choice modelling can evaluate
actions of complex phenomena. The process arises out of changes in the know. Although both offer insights into brand,
a multiplicity of relatively simple interactions. The tool not neither delivers on the imagination required to generate
only captures the efficiency requirements of media models, growth for brands. In the end, revenue sustainability is the
but also accounts for emerging forms of behavior that hallmark of a good brand. Its strength lies in its ability to
fuel innovation. Currently, it is being applied to forward- protect future earnings during down markets and unlock
looking business decisions. value where brand can play a role.

There is no better time than now for


strong brands to understand models
that uncover the hidden behavior
behind these new revenue streams.

Seemingly disparate groups of information become value creating segments

Best Australian Brands 2009 09


Planning your touchpoints
to accelerate profit
by Rune Gustafson

The brand ultimately engages customers This is followed by, “There are no additional
(or any other stakeholder) in many different rules.” Nordstrom recognises that building
ways, be it through advertising, product, customer relationships is done one customer
packaging, and its people. Each contact or at a time. Nordstrom shares fantastic
touchpoint builds up an experience that relationship-building stories throughout the
endures well beyond the product or service. organisation to illustrate and train everyone
It defines and reinforces the perceptions about what its service ethos of “going the
that customers have about the brand. extra mile” means in practice. For example,
Conversely, it is equally powerful at defining a customer who was at its Chicago store
negative perceptions of a brand. searching for a black bow tie told this story:

For service businesses, touchpoints are often “I was going to a black-tie party, and
time-based and are perishable experiences needed a ready-made bow tie. Nordstrom’s
that increase reputation risks. But touchpoints didn’t stock one, but the guy there said,
also provide a golden opportunity to create “If you have ten minutes, how about I teach
a powerful moment of intimacy through you how to tie one?” And, in the middle of
staff-customer interactions. Shifting these a busy Saturday afternoon, he did just that
Biography:
perceptions is the crucial foundation to and got the sale. “I was happy, I recommend
Rune Gustafson is Chief Executive
staying closer to current customers and them to everyone, and I still tell the story
Officer of Interbrand in London.
engaging new customers to try your brand ten years later.”
Rune leverages his extensive
for the first time. These deliver increased
experience in brand and retail
revenues and margins that accelerate brand Clearly, the power of a great service ethos
propositions to regularly contribute
value and profitable growth for investors. can generate sales, great relationships and
to publications and conferences
great word of mouth marketing. But the most
throughout the UK and Europe.
Nordstrom targets a single touchpoint important lesson marketers can learn from
Nordstrom, the US retailer, has dominated Nordstrom is that it invests primarily in a single
its market though the service it delivers to its touchpoint. Of course, its stores are clean and
core customers. It has proven that customers well designed, but its focus is on the staff-
We continually observe that the most will pay a higher price for a superior service. customer touchpoint.
successful brands strive to put the brand In so doing, this helps to differentiate it from
at the heart of their business. low-price discount brands (Nordstrom’s sales Every CEO and CMO knows that they must invest
per square foot are twice the industry average). in their brand’s experience. But the question
They understand that, by using the brand The service differentiation is delivered though that haunts them is: Which touchpoint is the
as a central organising principle, they can the belief that, at all times, the most important driver of purchases and which ones are simply
direct every single business function, from person in the entire business is the customer. nice to have? Early thinking on touchpoints
HR and Distribution to Finance. In doing It counter-intuitively achieves this – not was based on satisfying each contact to a better
so, they are able to deliver a truly holistic with a biblical service manual – but with level than your competitor. This approach is
brand experience that runs through the a single rule: highly ineffective and reduces business
organisation and then outwards, thus performance because it follows four classic
engaging the customer. “Use your good judgment in all situations.” touchpoint management mistakes.

10 Best Australian Brands 2009


Classic touchpoint Fact-based touchpoint Making bolder, fact-
management mistakes strategy based investment
decisions

01 Targeting too many The only way to develop a touchpoint The InterContinental Executive Board boldly
customer segments strategy that will increase business decided to invest heavily in its staff as its
Businesses often try to appeal to the widest performance (and avoid these four mistakes) primary touchpoint, with the statistical
possible audience. But without defining a is with a fact-based, analytical approach. knowledge that this would deliver the highest
narrow, attitudinally based audience, the ROI. In fact, it would provide almost double
touchpoint experience will be fragmented InterContinental Hotels is an excellent the ROI compared to any other touchpoint.
and often results in conflicting perceptions. example of a traditional brand that has Had it made many of the classic touchpoint
re-invigorated itself by developing a new mistakes outlined above and invested too
02 Dilution of the brand investment across brand positioning and executing it perfectly little in too many touchpoints with too many
too many touchpoints by embedding it in the customer experience customer segments, it would certainly not
There are literally hundreds of possible and offer. It used a sophisticated statistical have achieved such strong business results.
touchpoints and no brand in the world has Return on Investment (ROI) model designed InterContinental’s brand has revived in the
the time or resources to deliver each contact to identify where and how to invest in the year following the 2006 rebrand. There was
to the highest level. customer experience. First, it identified an increase in positive brand perception of
a narrow target audience that had a clear 10 percent and an increase in revenue per
03 Competing on basic factors only attitudinal preference for luxury travel room of 12 percent (source: IHG.com).
In an increasingly competitive environment, experiences that enriched their life and The success of this rebranding was the ability
classic benchmarking activities ensure that provided them with the additional social of the business to put their brand positioning,
brands copy each others’ differentiators currency of local knowledge and stories. “In the Know,” at the heart of their operations
resulting in a zero sum game. They are Then, InterContinental cleverly used the and translate this into a valuable touchpoint.
mistakenly all trying to compete on best statistical model to identify which specific
practices rather than boldly challenging parts of the customer experience truly In a world where consumers are bombarded
convention. Those that do, like Virgin drove them to choose InterContinental by multiple messages every minute and
or Disney, have been able to create an and, as a result, strongly increased their internal investment is increasingly scarce,
unassailable differentiation with their satisfaction. This provided the Executive there is an unequivocal case to be made
chosen target customers. Board with the clear evidence of what drives for drastically reducing the number of
revenues and margin. It also identified touchpoints and investing strongly in a single
04 Relying on customer myths areas of cost saving; parts of the experience touchpoint that accelerates brand value and
to prioritise choices (and costs) that could be removed without profitable growth. This naturally raises the
The leading brands demonstrate that they affecting their customers satisfaction. following critical questions for every CEO
have the leadership mindset to make hard and CMO:
choices and prioritise customer segments, Its new positioning is the hotel brand that is
touchpoints and investments based on facts “In the Know” and delivers exactly what its • How do you currently measure the ROI
rather than perceived wisdom. guests value without the things they don’t of your touchpoints?
value. Guests benefit from the authentic,
insider knowledge about the places they • Which touchpoints can you live without?
visit. They are prepared to pay a premium
(and stay more frequently) for gaining this • Which touchpoint can you truly own

Each contact
social currency and the priceless stories they that differentiates your brand?
could share with their family and friends.

or touchpoint
The challenge was to educate and motivate • Which touchpoint actually drives
large numbers of migrant or part-time your profits?

builds up an
staff employees to deliver on this promise
consistently around the world. It was

experience
a fundamental shift to move from hiding
the staff to making them the heroes and

which endures
encouraging them to interact with guests.
For employees, this new positioning was

well beyond
translated into an insider knowledge program
for staff. It used the phrase, “To you it’s just

the product
a walk to work; to our guest it’s a great view
of local culture” to educate and empower

or service.
all their staff to share their local knowledge
with guests.

Best Australian Brands 2009 11


The Interbrand approach
to valuing brands

Criteria for Methodology


consideration

Using the Australian Stock Exchange (ASX) The Interbrand method for valuing brands Role of brand analysis
200 list of Australia’s largest publicly traded is a proven and straightforward formula that A measure of how the brand influences
corporations, and drawing upon more examines brands through the lens of financial customer demand at the point of purchase
than 30 years of consulting experience, strength, importance in driving consumer is applied to the economic earnings to arrive
Interbrand formed an initial consideration selection, and the likelihood of ongoing at Branded Earnings. For this study, industry
set of eligible brands. All were then subject branded revenue. Our method evaluates benchmark analysis for the role the brand
to the following criteria that narrowed brands much like analysts would value any plays in driving customer demand is derived
candidates significantly: other asset: on the basis of how much they’re from Interbrand’s database of more than
likely to earn in the future. 5,000 prior valuations conducted over the
• The brand must have originated in course of 20 years. In-house market research
Australia. Hence, foreign-owned brands There are three core components to our is used to establish individual brand scores
operating in Australia are excluded, proprietary method, as follows. against our industry benchmarks.
e.g. Coke, McDonald’s, Nike and Ford
Financial analysis Brand strength score
• The brand must be Australian owned. Our approach to valuation starts by This is a benchmark of the brand’s ability to
Similarly, once Australian-owned but now forecasting the current and future revenue secure ongoing customer demand (loyalty,
foreign-owned brands have been excluded, specifically attributable to the branded repurchase and retention) and thus sustain
e.g. Holden, Vegemite, Arnott’s and Speedo products. We subtract operating costs from future earnings, translating branded earnings
revenue to calculate branded operating profit. into net present value. This assessment is
• There must be substantial publicly available We then apply a charge to the branded profit a structured way of determining the specific
financial data for capital employed. This gives us economic risk to the strength of the brand. We compare
earnings. All financial analysis is based on the brand against common factors of brand
• The brand must be a market-facing brand publicly available company information. strength, such as market position, customer
Interbrand culls from a range of analysts’ franchise, image and support.
• The Economic Value Added (EVA) must be reports to build a consensus estimate for
positive. If a brand is reporting negative financial reporting.
earnings, it can be difficult to derive a brand
value for the brand, unless strongly positive
forecast earnings are projected

• It is critically important that we are able


to identify the brands total financial
Financial Analysis Brand Value Calculation
performance, including revenues, profit Forecasted current and
future revenue specifically
and asset base attributable to the brand

Role of Brand
Analysis
A measure of how the
brand influences customer
demand at the point of
Role of
purchase Brand
Analysis

Brand Strength
A benchmark of the brand’s
ability to secure ongoing
customer demand (loyalty,
repurchase, retention). Year � Year � Year � Year � Year �

Brand Strength Analysis BRAND


Brand Revenues = Discount Rate VALUE

Economic Earnings
Brand Earnings

12 Best Australian Brands 2009


Top line industry stories
by Lynton Pipkorn

Australian brands hit home. As a result, a number of Australian


companies have battled significant write-
continue to grow downs, rising input costs and adverse

despite difficult times foreign exchange conditions, all of which


have put significant pressure on profitability
and the performance of their brands.

The past decade has been a boom for For the first time since the early nineties,
Australian companies, with revenues Australia is feeling the effects of a recession.
and profits showing extraordinary growth. However, while a number of challenge
In line with this growth, Australian remain, interest rates are now at their
Biography: brands have continued to strengthen and lowest point in many years and inflation
Lynton is Interbrand Australia’s Brand prosper, and the aggregate value of the appears to have stabilised.
Valuation and Analytics practice head. top 10 Australian brands is now worth
Lynton is responsible for valuing brand approximately A$ 43 billion. As we battle the global recession, the
assets and managing the strategic challenge for Australian brands will be to
outcomes resulting from valuation Over the past decade, the Australian re-evaluate what they understand about their
and analytics projects for clients. economy has experienced robust economic customers. They must apply these insights
His previous clients include Qantas, growth, buoyed by the expectation that into consumer motivations and brand
Nab, VISA, MLC, PwC, Bank of New revenues and corporate profits will grow perceptions to position their brands to
Zealand, Gazprom, National Foods, across all industrial sectors. With near full respond to these changes in business and
Nestlé and Nokia. employment, businesses and consumers consumer sentiment. This can only stimulate
have exhibited confidence in spending and demand and build corporate value in the
investment, propelling the performance of years ahead.
many brands to new heights.
It is also prudent to recognise that total
More recently, however, the Australian company values in relation to market
economy has faced a number of challenges. capitalisation are declining in the short-term
The fall out of the sub-prime mortgage due to high levels of volatility. However,
turmoil and ongoing global financial crisis, well-managed brands are stable assets
the rise and subsequent sharp fall of the in terms of brand value, and those that have
Australian dollar, and the volatility in fuel, positioned themselves for the long term
materials and raw commodity prices have all should be the first to prosper when the
economy begins to show the first signs
of recovery.

Best Australian Brands 2009 13


The highly publicised bankruptcy of Lehman Nevertheless, despite the financial crisis,

The emergence of Brothers and the threatened insolvency of


major banking and financial services brands
Australian banks are among the best
capitalised and highest rated in terms of
private equity such as Northern Rock, AIG, Royal Bank credit quality, and they continue to reinforce
of Scotland, Citigroup and Merrill Lynch their reputation as some of the strongest
triggered a significant crisis of confidence banking brands in the world.
with lenders and consumers, forcing the
Australian Federal Government to guarantee Macquarie Group, one of the ranking
In recent years, private equity has begun
the savings of all deposits under A$ 1 million. standouts, has exhibited considerable
taking ownership and controlling stakes
growth and resilience with its innovative
in key brands. Brands that exemplify this
Notwithstanding the fallout of the credit investment banking model. The model
trend include Myer, Nine Network, Seven
crunch, the four major banks continue to provides significant opportunity for
Network and Repco.
retain prominent top 10 positions in the expansion of the brand into new financial
Best Australian Brands study. products and overseas investment markets.
With the exception of Myer, private equity
Local challengers Babcock & Brown,
purchases have resulted in significant
CBA remains the number one banking brand, Allco Finance Group and MFS (re-branded
restructures of a number of businesses,
while St. George has entered the top 10 for the Octaviar) have not proven as resilient.
meaning their financials are no longer
first and perhaps the last time. The combined
available or company structures are no longer
value of the four major banks is worth A$ 20.1
comparable to analyse for the purposes
of this study.
billion, almost half the value contained in the
top 10.
Retailing
Brands such as Channel Nine and Channel
In 2008, the Bendigo and Adelaide Bank
Seven have been subsumed by complex
merger marked the first major change in
company ownership and reporting structures,
the structure of the Australian banking
making it difficult to access and isolate key
industry. Since then a number of other
valuation and financial inputs required to The Australian retail sector, including
regional and smaller brands have expressed
create the Best Australian Brands study. a number of major department store
plans to merge as a result of domestic
and grocery brands, has also undergone
and international pressures.
significant changes. The performance of

Banking and finance Commonwealth Bank, with the acquisition


the sector has generally been very robust.
However, more recently, profit forecasts
of BankWest and 33 percent of Aussie Group,
have been hit by a collapse in consumer
has consolidated its place as Australia’s
sentiment and the revised 2009 - 2010
largest financial institution. St. George, before
economic outlook.
the merger announcement with Westpac,
was looking to challenge the “big four”
Coles Myer has been disbanded, now that
The Australian banking landscape dominance. Now, as a combined dual-branded
Myer has been purchased by private equity,
has undergone considerable changes organisation, the merged entity should create
and the remainder of the Coles Group
in the past decade, with the sector one of Australia’s largest tier one banking
business and associated brands have been
exhibiting strong growth and robust and finance groups.
sold to Wesfarmers.
operating conditions.
The financial crisis has also hampered the
Woolworths has gone from strength to
However, as we head into a deepening global performance of a number of Australian banks.
strength, capitalising on the management
economic downturn, we have seen a flurry In particular, ANZ and NAB both face
and ownership changes of its major rival,
of activity connected to the extraordinary a number of bad debt write-downs, and the
while also taking the opportunity to re-craft
events of the sub-prime meltdown and the Federal Government’s bank deposit guarantee
its visual identity and solidify its superior
resulting global financial crisis. The retail has caused a flight of capital from the
brand proposition.
commercial banks have suffered their non-bank sector. The higher cost of lending
first collective profit fall in 15 years with has also impacted the non-bank lending
David Jones has made great strides amidst
pre‑tax profits down by 23 percent in 2008. sector, which saw Westpac swallow Rams
the turmoil of the Coles Myer divestiture.
The tightening of credit and the continued Home Loans in 2007 and Commonwealth
It is now enjoying the spoils of consistent
rationalisation in the banking industry Bank take a 33 percent stake in Aussie Group
investment in its store footprint and
is anticipated to create further adverse in 2008.
environment, and it is securing key premium
operating conditions.
and luxury brands to cement its leading
It is anticipated that further consolidation
position as the “House of Brands” for
In this context, the marketing messages from in the sector will continue, with Wizard
Australian department store shoppers.
the major banks were quick to reflect the being the latest brand to be acquired by
The effective use of Australian supermodels
changing consumer and business sentiment Aussie Group. As the banking and finance
Megan Gale and Miranda Kerr has also
– from growth and wealth creation to security market continues to suffer, brand portfolio
reinforced David Jones’s premium brand
and preservation – by shifting their positioning management will become a greater
positioning in the ongoing Australian
to safety and a return to conservatism in the challenge for a number of companies.
department “store wars”.
long term.

14 Best Australian Brands 2009


Like Coles, Myer is currently in a turnaround
phase and is expected to challenge its
major rival David Jones with profit in 2007
Airlines and travel Television media
up 40 percent after a number of years of
underperformance. Myer has fought to
maintain its quality positioning, with a focus
on youth and a broadening of its product
offer to encourage mainstream appeal. The airline industry is tough and volatile. Australia’s three large commercial networks
Qantas, Flight Centre and Virgin Blue’s have undergone significant changes in their
The consumer retail sector, however, remains fortunes have all been heavily reliant structure and operating environments.
under considerable pressure. on the previously buoyant domestic and
international economic conditions. In particular, the Nine Network is no longer
As levels of consumer demand continue to under the control of the Packer empire.
deteriorate, the shift to provide greater value Due to the difficulties in accurately assessing Its Publishing and Broadcasting Limited
to consumers will be key to David Jones and the brand value of airlines based upon business was broken up and the majority
Myer maintaining growth. To do so without publically available information, Qantas, of the media assets including the television
compromising the premium positioning that Jetstar and Virgin Blue have been excluded stations sold into private equity through
distinguishes them from the likes of Target from financial analysis in our study. PBL Media.
and smaller high street retailers will be just as
critical to their continued success. Nonetheless, Australian airline brands play Similarly, the Seven Network has experienced
an important role and we have included them major corporate structural change, with
The Best Australian Brands table has also seen in our commentary. In recent times, we have Seven Media Group formed in a joint venture
the emergence of JB Hi-Fi and the continued seen the industry recover from global security with private equity to house its television,
dominance of home appliance and electrical and health threats. Combined with a strong magazine and internet interests.
goods retailer Harvey Norman. local economy, this has propelled the expansion
of the business and leisure travel markets. Media fragmentation, technological advances
A high Australian dollar and continued Previously buoyed by a rise in the Australian and the changing viewing habits of mass
marketing support of the brand during the dollar, the industry has benefited enormously audiences have drastically altered the way
past four years have seen Harvey Norman from increased discretionary spending. people consume information and, specifically,
expand aggressively both in Australia and advertising and brand communications.
overseas. Its profits reflect consumer desire Qantas has been able to capitalise significantly The advent of online media and digital content,
for the latest in electrical goods, advancements on its dual-brand strategy in this period. and the need to converge and integrate
in computer technology and the affordability Now Qantas plans to withdraw from the “old” media with the “new” have also created
of imported households items. Harvey Norman, NZ domestic market, but will instead launch innovative partnerships linking Seven with
like all retailers, continues to face the stress of Jetstar with a fleet of new A320s, flying digital platform Yahoo! and similarly Nine
the economic downturn and must continue more routes than Qantas was servicing in with Microsoft.
to build the value proposition of its offering competition with Air NZ and Pacific Blue.
to customers. Jetstar’s low cost base could well place Ten has continued with its strategy to target
extreme pressure on the other carriers. youth, while the ratings decline at the Nine
JB Hi-Fi, a newcomer to the Best Australian Network has resulted in the Seven Network
Brands table, has proven a surprise competitor The introduction of new-to-market brands taking the coveted number one position.
to Harvey Norman. Its brand positioning – Jetstar, Tiger and V Australia – has also
as a discount but expert music and electrical created more options for Australian domestic As consumer spending continues to slow,
goods retailer has insulated the brand from and overseas travelers, resulting in an media industry cash flows are expected to
the harshest affects of the slowdown. increase in routes and a reduction in fares. follow suit as the reduction in advertising
Stretching the brand, from music and MP3 The rise in competition has driven a visible revenues begins to bite. The slowdown has
players into home entertainment, and differentiation, creating a clear low, middle already affected the earnings of one major
continuous expansion into other household and premium segmentation to service the network, with Network Ten’s profit falling
goods has also widened its appeal and needs of consumers. by approximately 25 percent.
mitigated some earnings risk.
Qantas has since overhauled its first and
JB Hi-Fi sales rose by an impressive 43 percent business class lounges, and modernised its
to A$ 1.8billion in 2008. After an impressive fleet with the acquisition of new Boeing 787s
first half in 2009, there is further profit growth and Airbus A380s designed to improve
forecast despite the deterioration of consumer patronage and reduce long-haul fuel costs.
sentiment and the potential that Australia Qantas has also revitalised its visual identity
may enter a period of recession. through a rebrand to complement these
investments in premium travel facilities.
At the height of the oil spike in 2008, high
fuel prices worked to decimate Virgin Blue’s
profit, which was down 55 percent from
2007. Qantas was able to weather the storm
with profit up by 44 percent, and holiday
and travel services provider Flight Centre
improved by 38 percent year on year.

Best Australian Brands 2009 15


Best Australian Brands 2009
2009 2009 Brand Value
Brand Sector
Rank A$ Million

1 Telecommunications 9,700

2 Banking / Financial Services 7,100

3 Banking / Financial Services 5,100

4 Banking / Financial Services 4,800

5 Retail 4,600

6 Banking/Financial Services 3,200

7 Banking/Financial Services 3,100

8 Apparel 2,200

9 Banking/Financial Services 1,900

10 Retail 1,300

11 Postal and Logistics 900

12 Retail 760

13 Retail 670

14 Travel 630

15 Gaming 560

16 Manufacturing 500

17 Share Registry Services 380

18 Utilities 220

19 Retail 190

20 Banking/Financial Services 150

16 Best Australian Brands 2009


Australia’s Best Brands 2009
1 9,700 A$m 2 7,100 A$m

TELSTRA. Since the full T3 privatisation in CBA. The Commonwealth Bank of Australia While many of the banks struggle to find
2006, Telstra has identified a large opportunity (CBA) remains the number one bank brand in differentiation, CBA has sought to reposition
for future growth in the Australian Australia. CBA has managed to not only hold itself and bring its service experience to
telecommunication industry. Telstra’s vision off the competition, but continue to build life through the proposition “Determined to
is to build on and enhance its position as the their brand despite potential threats such as be Different”. With scale and a diversified
leading full service telecommunications and the slowing economy and ongoing pressure business mix core pillars of the group’s
information Service Company in Australia, as on banks due to the credit crunch. CBA has offering, in 2008 CBA bought the BankWest
well as to expand its presence internationally. achieved outstanding results through its brand from HBOS as well as a 33 percent
Telstra has forged a path for itself as the clear continued focus on delivering products interest in mortgage broker Aussie. CBA
brand leader in many sectors. It is the only customer’s want and a concerted effort by continues to build its strong reputation with
media and information services company the brand to improve customer service. This is active involvement in the community via high
in Australia that provides its customers backed by a commitment of A$ 580 million over profile sponsorships such as Cricket Australia,
with a truly integrated telecommunications the next four years to upgrade its technology The Australian of the Year Awards and the
experience across fixed line, mobiles, systems to improve efficiency and service. Commonwealth Bank Foundation.
broadband, information, transaction,
search and pay TV. Under CEO Sol Trujillo’s
stewardship, Telstra has continued to exploit
its scale advantage by creating and integrating

3
partnerships with its sub-brands and various
third parties, including handset providers, 5,100 A$m
media partners and mobile retailers.
This integrated effort forms the cornerstone
of Telstra’s “transformation” strategy to move NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK (NAB) is one to staff, suppliers, government and consumers.
customers onto upgraded internet and of Australia’s largest banking and financial Further reinforcing this re-positioning, NAB’s
wireless phone networks. Mobile advertising services organisations. NAB provides a broad current A$ 32.6 million marketing expenditure
has significant future growth potential range of comprehensive and integrated involves major advertising campaigns such
with the introduction of WAP and 3G phone financial products and services through its as “Climb Ev’ry Mountain” and “nab a small
services and the increasing demand for various units. These include NAB with MLC word for a big life” have continued to build
internet and data transfer services on mobile in Australia, Bank of New Zealand, Clydesdale affinity with consumers. NAB’s investment
phones. Telstra reported that mobile service and Yorkshire banks in the UK, and NABCapital in sponsorship with the AFL and 2006
revenues grew 12.3 percent for the year, in its global institutional markets and services Commonwealth Games also contributed
while mobile data growth shot up 44.1 business. After the negative publicity generated to introducing NAB’s positioning changes
percent. Rich content and data services form during the trading and board scandals of 2004, successfully, engaging stakeholders and lifting
a key domestic and international revenue NAB has aggressively sought to reposition the its brand health measures. More recently,
plank for the future. With ambitions to be brand to counteract any lingering reputation NAB has suffered a number of write-downs
seen as much more than just Australia’s and image challenges. In 2006, the new NAB associated with its exposure to the global
largest telecommunications services provider, brand identity was unveiled with a renewed credit crunch, recording its first negative
Telstra have the opportunity to impact the focus to refurbish branches, retrain and result since 2004, with the 2008 group result
lives of all Australians in the wider cultural engage staff, improve services and introduce taking a substantial hit from a A$ 2.7 billion
landscape, and deepening its influence by new and more competitive financial services provision for bad debt. As economic conditions
becoming a global telecommunications force. and products. Accompanying communications and financial markets continue to deteriorate
campaigns sought to breakdown even further and hamper the performance of all the major
the bureaucracy and previous negative banks, NAB and its contemporaries will need

Telstra’s mobile associations in the bank, reflecting the brand


journey of an organisation fighting back from
to position themselves strongly for the
expected tough times that lie ahead.

service revenues adversity. These changes have allowed NAB to


become more approachable, open and friendly

grew 12.3 percent


for the year,
while mobile data
growth shot up
44.1 percent.

Best Australian Brands 2009 17


Offering extended
4 4,800 A$m
hours and flexibility
WESTPAC has maintained its profile and customer culture and implement
for its customers
reputation as one of Australia’s best
managed and largest financial services
compelling customer segment strategies.
These will serve to continue to generate
and staff, its brand-
companies. Remaining steady in the face
of the global financial crisis, Westpac
revenue and profit growth amidst a very
different and challenging banking
aligned culture
continues to increase its brand value
through maintaining best practice in
landscape. The credit crunch and changing
conditions in the market have also impacted
will ensure that
corporate social responsibility and its
commitment to customer service.
the key communications messages from
the banks, prompting them to position
Westpac maintains
Offering extended hours and flexibility for
its customers and staff, its brand-aligned
their brands less aggressively around
growth and more conservatively around
its brand leadership.
culture, under newly anointed CEO Gail safety, stability and security of deposits
Kelly, will ensure that Westpac maintains and preservation of investment in financial
its brand leadership and continues to products. The St. George merger will
grow in strength. Recognised as one service 10 million customers and create
of Australia’s best corporate citizens, Australia’s second largest banking entity.
Westpac has won numerous reputation Westpac’s prudent reputations and AA
awards due to its sustainability policies rating will ensure it can maintain its
and corporate social responsibility strong position as the banking and finance
practices. With the approved St. George industry faces further economic and
merger expected to take shape in 2009, financial headwinds in 2009.
Westpac aims to continue to drive a strong

5 4,600 A$m

WOOLWORTHS. Despite the economic been a tremendous success in the private


downturn, Woolworths remains in pole label segment, and store brands will play
position as Australia’s largest grocery retailer. a greater role in generating revenues for
CEO Michael Luscombe has built formidable the supermarkets during the downturn.
market share and year-on-year sales growth. Staple foods and basic commodities are also
Woolworths continues to drive a wedge not expected to affect revenues, unlike the
between itself and its major rival Coles as impact of the slowdown in more discretionary
it tries to reinvent itself for the renewed categories. A marketing budget of over
challenge ahead. Woolworths not only has A$ 100 million ensures Woolworths is
a strong management team and an excellent well-poised to roll out its refreshed brand
refurbishment strategy in place, but it also identity across all key customer touch points.
has the flexibility in its business model that Just as the Safeway brand is phased out in
other competitors do not, to counter the dual Victoria, Woolworths’s ownership of the
threat of an economic slowdown and the positioning of “the fresh food people” in this
entry of foreign supermarket competitors. increasingly competitive retail environment,
As the growth of IGA, Aldi and Costco will only serve to reinforce its focus on its
continues, and the divesting of Coles to customers. Woolworths’s new identity
Wesfarmers progresses, retail supermarkets communicates positive values to customers
are now competing more aggressively, with associations to fresh, simple, interesting
especially with the trend towards higher and modern. All of this suggests a more
margin own label brand offerings. Woolworths positive shopping experience and a renewed
Home Brand and Woolworths Select have focus on freshness and quality.

18 Best Australian Brands 2009


6 3,200 A$m 7 3,100 A$m

MACQUARIE GROUP is the preeminent financial, advisory and investment ANZ. Despite the global financial turmoil
Australian investment banking brand. services to investors, corporations and and the merger and acquisition activity of its
Despite the financial crisis, the collapse governments. Macquarie’s strength and nearest rivals Westpac and Commonwealth
of the investment banking system on reputation has grown as a result of its Bank, ANZ continues to pursue its long
Wall Street, and the plight of its local ability to match its ambitions with an term strategy of organically growing its
rivals, Macquarie continues to thrive innate ability to deliver results and brand footprint into the Asia- Pacific region.
through its brand mantra of innovation outperform sometimes much bigger and Through an aggressive expansion in retail
and the diversity of its business model more established international investment branches and via a number of joint ventures
and operating activities. This unique banking rivals. Macquarie Group now with Asian banks, ANZ’s push into the Asian
mix of business strategy, attracting has more than 60 office locations across market is perceived by some to be high risk.
and rewarding the best human capital, 25 countries, and continues to establish However, growing the brand internationally
and access to financial markets has itself as a venerable name amongst the could provide ANZ with a major competitive
underpinned an extraordinary growth investment banking elite in the world’s advantage over its domestic rivals whose
trajectory. The Macquarie brand has major financial centres. Macquarie Group’s presence is not nearly as strong in the Asian
been built upon its expertise, strong model has, however, come under some market. Despite offshore risks, ANZ is still
relationships, unique product offering, pressure as a result of deteriorating asset eyeing Asia as the source of 20 percent of
and its rising status as a result of consistent values due the de-leveraging of the global earnings over the next five years after the
performances in the financial services economy through the financial crisis. division grew earnings by 52 percent in fiscal
sector. The Macquarie brand communicates The test for Macquarie will be to leverage 2008. In order to support its strategy ANZ
what it will deliver – inspired and its hard earned reputation and leadership has invested in the highest share of voice
innovative solutions to difficult financial credentials in continuing to innovate, while of the “big four”, investing $46.6 million in
problems. In the last number of years, consolidating the brand in the challenging marketing and advertising expenditure in
Macquarie’s success and its willingness and diverse markets it operates. Only time 2007. Domestically, ANZ has been prominent
to prove the doubters wrong has allowed will tell if Macquarie Group can continue in mortgage lending, securities, margin
it to mature into a global investment to withstand the banking and finances lending and institutional banking, however
banking brand and diversified financial industry’s greatest challenge. as the property boom recedes, and economic
services group, providing banking, conditions generally deteriorate as a result
of the credit crisis, ANZ has suffered its first
profit fall since 1998. Furthermore, ANZ’s

The Macquarie relationships with various securities lending


clients and subsequent bad debt provisions
brand communicates have caused some harm to the brand’s

what it will deliver – reputation. In responding to the global


financial crisis impacting on local operations,
inspired and innovative ANZ is actively looking to protect its image

solutions to difficult by applying a more rigorous and conservative


approach to lending and in its application to
financial problems. risk management procedures in the future.

8 2,200 A$m

BILLABONG. The board sports clothing consistent strategy of building credibility product design and innovation has also
market has experienced phenomenal by sponsoring major sporting events and ensured that the brand has remained both
growth over the last decade. Billabong has forging relationships with respected sports relevant and contemporary. Billabong has
successfully leveraged the brand’s heritage stars in the surf, skate and snow segments also aggressively expanded internationally
and place in Australia’s unique surfing culture has also helped propel the authenticity of the into North America and Europe, and it is now
to stretch into new customer segments, brand across new generations. By moving becoming increasingly popular in Eastern
categories and geographies, becoming the the brand’s focus from the male-dominated Europe in both urban and regional areas.
world’s largest surfing and board sports surfing culture to board-sports inspired It may need to manage its exposure to the
apparel brand. Recent diversification of the activities, innovative unisex lifestyle US and emerging economies where growth is
product range into skate and snow categories accessories and leisurewear, Billabong has expected to slow, however, a lower Australian
will deliver a more stable platform for growth been able to engage more diverse consumer dollar will no doubt assist them in their quest.
providing the strength to combat major segments and reinforce its position.
rivals Quicksilver and Rip Curl. Billabong’s A commitment to continual investment in

Best Australian Brands 2009 19


9 1,900 A$m 10 1,300 A$m 11 900 A$m

ST. GEORGE’s commitment to service, HARVEY NORMAN. The previously high AUSTRALIA POST. A flexible and diverse
personal attention and the development of Australian dollar, the explosion in popularity business model has allowed Australia Post
close relationships with customers is one of of personal media devices and the adoption to address the threat of electronic
its main competitive advantages compared to of digital TV have driven consumers to communication and declining traditional
the “big four” banks. These strengths include electrical goods retailers in their droves. post volumes by focusing on growth
a track record of positive credit quality, high A commitment to stock the highest selling from the globalisation of small business.
staff engagement ratings relative to the brands and a successful franchise strategy By staying at the forefront of innovation
industry, and excellent product management has enabled Harvey Norman to grow revenues in the post and logistics industry, Australia
and innovation capabilities. St. George also and increase market share to become Post has been able to maintain its brand
strives to play a positive role in the Australia’s dominant consumer electronics leadership in Australia and fend off the threat
community by supporting charities, the arts, and homewares retail brand. Harvey of larger global business logistics competitors.
sporting clubs, business programs and Norman’s comprehensive product mix, At the same time, Australia Post has also
disaster relief initiatives. While St. George and strong customer value proposition and broadened the scope of its offering. With the
Westpac’s merger will create one of Australia’s aggressive marketing and communications acquisition of Star Track Express, Australia
largest financial services companies for support have consistently delivered superior Post has expanded its non-core services
customers, shareholders and employees, the brand performance across the wider market. and continued to enjoy strong results.
challenge post merger will be to ensure that However, the falling Australian dollar Post Logistics has emerged as another
the St. George brand maintains its unique and the economic slowdown have affected source of high growth for its B2B services
positioning. It must continue to live up to the forecast outlook for Harvey Norman. division. However, the collapse of Australia
its reputation as the friendly bank next door As a well-known counter-cyclical advertiser, Post’s extension – Post Bill Pay – damaged
through its “Good With People, Good With typically increasing ad spend during times the brand’s credentials in the internet
Money” position. The strategy to be big but of slowdown in order to gain market share, services market. As a ubiquitous brand
look small in the eyes of customers has been Gerry Harvey has revealed he is to cut his in Australia attempting to modernise its
St. George’s key strength, with the brand A$ 300 million marketing and advertising persona, the recent “Part of Everyday”
claiming that superior customer service and budget by “at least 20 percent” and he is to campaign has positioned the brand as more
a personal approach to business will remain close a number of under-performing stores. contemporary and relevant, breathing new
as the St. George brand continues to operate All this could spell harder times ahead for life into the Australia Post brand.
as a separate brand entity. St. George also the retailer.
hopes to grow organically across Australia
while harnessing the potential in its existing
brand strengths and capabilities. The global

12
financial crisis and the roll-on impact of
a slowing Australian economy are also 760 A$m
negatively affecting the banking market,
with the ability to supply quality credit
steadily deteriorating and threatening the
DAVID JONES has reinforced its position previously stocked at major rival Myer.
long term viability of a number of smaller
as Australia’s premium department store The use of Australian supermodels
competitors. Now that St. George is part of
brand. The brand has achieved this Megan Gale and Miranda Kerr as David
Westpac, and with consolidation expected to
position via an unwavering focus on Jones brand ambassadors has also
continue in the banking and finance industry,
supplying high calibre branded products, reinforced David Jones’s credibility
to sustain its growth ambitions it will be
providing excellent customer service, and and premium brand positioning in the
more important than ever for St. George to
consistently communicating its first class ongoing Australian department
keep its unique identity and not be seen by
status and leading reputation for quality. “store wars”. David Jones has dominated
consumers as just part of the ”big four”.
Through this strategy, David Jones has the competitive retail environment
built higher margins by offering exclusive in recent years and it has delivered
supply deals with premium brands and by strong year on year store sales growth.
The strategy to investing in current and new stores to With the Australian economy
create a more luxurious retail brand experiencing an economic downturn,
be big but to look experience. To consolidate its position, it will be challenging for David Jones
the retailer has successfully established to sustain such high historical growth,
small in the eyes exclusive supply agreements with over however, the brand is well positioned
50 new brands, some of which were to maintain its leadership status.
of customers has
been St. George’s
key strength.

20 Best Australian Brands 2009


13 670 A$m 14 630 A$m

MYER is Australia’s largest chain of discount retailers, operating 65 stores FLIGHT CENTRE. Unpredictable events
department stores, retailing a broad range across Australia. Former Miss Universe such as threats to global security, rising oil
of merchandise. The implementation of Jennifer Hawkins has successfully led prices, economic volatility and fluctuations
an integrated media strategy that includes Myer’s most publicised promotional in exchange rates have always hampered
the distribution of catalogues and activity since 2006, and she recently the global and domestic travel industry.
a magazine has brought together brand signed a multi-million- dollar deal to be However, Flight Centre has continually
touchpoints and advertising campaigns the face of Myer for another four years. emerged from these threats to be the leading
into closer harmony. The “Myer is my store” Although Myer has delivered a more provider of travel solutions through its
byline is the current campaign driver efficient business model and begun to commitment to demonstrating its “lowest
and this campaign stretches across all invest and reinvigorate key retail stores, airfares guaranteed” value proposition
aspects of Myer’s media spend, in line Myer has been unable to defend against alongside its flexible and responsive business
with Myer’s strategy of providing a range David Jones’s aggressive pursuit of growth model. Flight Centre was quick to recognise
of products to suit everyone’s needs. and positioning at the premium end of the movement of customers researching and
This has been extended through point of the market. With a retail downturn paying for travel services on the internet.
sale, in-store signage, direct marketing, underway, Myer is set to counter the drop As consumers migrated online, Flight Centre
and sponsorships. Myer’s brand position in consumer spending by doubling its has capitalised on the growth of its customer
in the market was deteriorating under marketing budget for the first three base in Australia and overseas through an
the previous management of Coles Myer, months of 2009 in a multi-million-dollar innovative combination of retail and online
however the divestment and takeover bid to drive traffic to stores. With the brand strategies. Extensive employee
by private equity has heralded a renewed competitive environment in the training programs have resulted in Flight
focus on the core business and a return department “store wars” set to get tougher, Centre becoming an employer of choice,
to profitability. Currently, Myer is in direct it shall remain an intriguing battle. voted as one of the best 100 places to work.
competition with both high end and Its A$ 2.4 million investment in adventure
travel brand Intrepid has allowed it to enter
the niche travel sector, and its partnership
with the Nine Network and Getaway has
contributed to its position as the number
one travel agency brand in Australia. With the
global slowdown expected to impact on
revenues in the highly sensitive and volatile
travel industry, Flight Centre’s dedication
to quality, value and innovation will put it
in a good position to continue to outperform
its sector.

Flight Centre has


15 560 A$m capitalised on
the growth of its
CROWN. Since 2004, Crown has enjoyed roller” positioning and continual upgrades
strong growth and a generally buoyant aim to attract both local and international customer base
economy in Australia. However, economic customers. Some of these upgrades include
slowdown may affect the profits of the Crown’s refurbishment of the main gaming in Australia and
gambling and luxury accommodation room, three first-class restaurants, and
industry in the short to medium term, a third hotel and conference centre. Crown’s overseas through
with the James Packer-led Crown Empire continuous improvements also include
no exception. The worsening conditions an investment into A$ 2billion worth of U.S. its innovative
of the global economy are expected not casino and gaming assets. Crown has
only to affect local customers but also the successfully positioned its brand around combination of
highly lucrative Asian market. However, entertainment and leisure, avoiding the
Crown’s major events schedule, expanding pitfalls associated with gambling and other retail and online
entertainment offerings, exclusive “high related social problems.
brand strategies.

Best Australian Brands 2009 21


16 500 A$m 17 380 A$m

ANSELL is a recognised worldwide leader in


COMPUTERSHARE. A dominant position in itself as the market leader. In conjunction
branded latex and rubber products, supplying
Australian share registry services has given with share registry management services
a diverse range of business and consumer
Computershare clear leadership on products, including corporate actions, shareholder
markets. After strong margin pressure from
technological innovation and performance. relations management, employee share plans
high latex prices, Ansell has leveraged its
With the Australian market for investor and electronic investor communication,
strong brand position and diversified the
services now only accounting for a fraction Computershare is now able to provide total
brand into new categories such as non-latex
of its revenue, Computershare has leveraged share transaction settlement services.
protective wear while shifting towards
its brand leadership in registry services and This shift towards a total client solutions model
a more premium offering in its professional
aggressively pursued acquisitions has great potential and is a core proposition
division and consumer rubber glove ranges.
internationally to become a global player for the brand. Given the recent downturn in
Recent acquisitions in the US condom market
and position itself as a specialist technology global share markets, this provides the platform
have been unable to make a substantial
solutions provider. Emerging markets are from which Computershare can build even
imprint on revenues as yet, however, Ansell
a source of strong growth, with Russia a key further on its attributes of efficiency, trust
has entrenched its status as market leader
standout where Computershare has solidified and security.
in Australia after fending off an increase in
competition locally. Operating in increasingly
mature markets, Ansell has pursued new
growth in emerging markets in Asia, Eastern
Computershare has leveraged
Europe, and South America to leverage its
brand strength in key latex supply markets.
As a result, the brand has generally enjoyed
its brand leadership in registry
robust performance since 2005.
services and aggressively
pursued acquisitions
internationally to become
a global player.

With the second 18 220 A$m


largest market
share in a fiercely ORIGIN ENERGY’s authentic “green”
brand credentials place it in an enviable
In terms of pricing, the traditional coal
and gas fired energy market has

competitive position to accommodate an increasingly


environmentally conscious retail energy
experienced volatile wholesale prices
in the past few years, however, Origin’s

landscape, Origin market. Origin is highly active in


distributing and developing renewable
integrated supply chain has enabled it
to ride out the storm. The most recent

has been able and environmentally friendly energy


solutions, with interests in solar energy,
”Things we love” campaign brings to life
the company’s desire to operate its

to differentiate wind power and geothermal energy


production. With the second largest
business in a way that ensures the things
we love today will still be here for us to

itself with its market share in a fiercely competitive


energy and utilities landscape, Origin has
enjoy in the future. This campaign aims
to set Origin apart as a brand leader in

sustainability been able to differentiate itself with its


sustainability credentials, yet the threat
the energy industry and communicate
its commitment to the brand promise.

credentials. of imitation by competition remains.

22 Best Australian Brands 2009


JB Hi-Fi’s mix of high 19 190 A$m

selling products, quality JB Hi-Fi has emerged as one of the high

service without the performers in the music retailing and


consumer electronics category. Despite

attitude, and pared-back


worsening economic conditions in retailing,
JB Hi-Fi has demonstrated the extraordinary
strength of its brand in the past year. Its mix

store environment of high-selling products, quality service


without the attitude, and pared-back store

combines to create an
environment combines to create an
authentic value proposition that is very
popular among consumers. JB Hi-Fi continues

authentic value proposition to gain market share on the back of this


best-in-category business model, and it will

that is very popular


press ahead with the roll out of 24 new stores,
as well as a planned aggressive expansion
into New Zealand. Shifting towards

among consumers. consumer electronics has increased the


competitive pressure from the likes of
category leaders like Harvey Norman,
however, the JB Hi-Fi brand has continued
to take share as it stretches into these core
categories. The brand’s authentic value
proposition and the staff’s instinctive ability
to make a sale should place the brand in
a strong position to tackle the downturn.

20 150 A$m

BENDIGO AND ADELAIDE BANK. Bendigo and Adelaide Bank has also held
Bendigo Bank’s value continues to rise the highest level of customer satisfaction
due to continued organic growth and its in the local banking sector will also serve to
A$ 1.6 billion merger with Adelaide Bank increase market share. The strengths of the
in 2007. Bendigo’s market share has been partnership will include a stronger wealth
largely driven by the publicity surrounding management business, larger retail
its community bank positioning and by network, increased margin lending
growing its suite of innovative financial capabilities, and a continued push towards
services options. The consolidation of both the SME banking segment. With a
Bendigo and Adelaide Bank should prove demonstrable commitment to communities
to be a successful union with consumers with various arts, sports and charitable
due to the positioning of both institutions foundations, the emergence of Bendigo bank
as community banking brands with solid to use the Olympics as a brand building
financial services offerings. Given St. George’s opportunity signals their intent to grow their
acquisition by Westpac, Bendigo and national deposit base. Bendigo has about
Adelaide Bank have the opportunity to 400 branches and through the merger now
position themselves as the leading has a greater ability to leverage brand
independent community bank that engages investments to contend with the big banks
with local communities. The fact that to win customers.

Bendigo and Adelaide Bank


have the opportunity to position
themselves as the leading
independent community bank.
Best Australian Brands 2009 23
Other prominent
Australian brands
A number of strong and well-performing brands
were not featured in the ranking, but they
nevertheless play a significant role in the Australian
brand landscape. We dedicate this section to
other prominent Australian brands that came
close to making the Top 20 table or were unable
to be included.

QANTAS is the world’s second oldest and new, more spacious seating, enhanced
Australia’s largest airline with 51 percent interiors, lounges designed by Marc Newson,
value share in the domestic air luxurious first class check-in facilities, and
transportation industry. Qantas also a new flying experience courtesy of the
continues to build on a strong position in premium economy cabin. Through continual
Australasia and in key strategic markets support of the brand and investment in
in Asia-Pacific and Western Europe. its capital base, Qantas is making a genuine
Despite a potentially disastrous dalliance effort to stay relevant and maintain
with private equity in 2006, the airline is its long-term growth strategy despite the
in comparably strong shape versus many economic downturn. The significant
of its international and domestic peers, investment in its new fleet and its continual
bolstered by a solid cash position and focus on its 5 million Frequent Flyer members
a revitalised fleet. Qantas has also been is expected to boost customer loyalty and
consistently responsive in meeting volatile satisfaction. In 2008, the global airline
and uncertain market conditions while industry drastically cut capacity as fuel prices
delivering a highly successful dual brand rallied to record highs. However, as energy
strategy with Jetstar. 2007 also marked the prices later retreated, pushed lower by the
year of brand renewal for Qantas, with the economic crisis that continues to dampen
airline unveiling a new identity to complement demand, Qantas is currently entertaining
its new fleet of state-of-the-art Boeing 787 possible merger opportunities with rivals
and Airbus A380 aircraft. The Flying Kangaroo, to exploit long-term cost, marketing and
as it is affectionately known, has also unveiled supply-synergy benefits.

2007 marked the year of brand


renewal for Qantas, with the
airline unveiling a new identity
to complement its new fleet
of state-of-the-art Boeing 787
and Airbus A380 aircraft.
24 Best Australian Brands 2009
NETWORK TEN. Although Network Ten has commercial channels have developed online
slipped to third in overall market share ratings, partnerships with related entertainment
it has been able to maintain leadership in companies, Ten has resisted establishing
the coveted, yet hard to reach, 16-39 year a more comprehensive service online.
old segment. Ten continue to pursue this However, Ten has been proactive in
targeted strategy and offer a clearly addressing the opportunities presented by
differentiated proposition to the market the multi-channeling capabilities of digital
where programming is aimed at those television, demonstrated by its first mover
audiences that are of most interest to advantage with the new dedicated 24-hour
advertisers. After enjoying an excellent run free-to-air channel, One. This new sports
in popularity for local programming in the programming platform will utilise a high
past few years, Big Brother has finally come integration advertising model to avoid
to an end but Australian Idol, The Biggest dilution of revenue derived from the existing
Loser and So You Think You Can Dance are mainstream analogue channel.
still holding up well. While the other

Suncorp has focused


on customer service to
differentiate itself from its
SUNCORP is Australia’s sixth largest bank
and a leading finance, insurance, and banking
corporation. Suncorp’s acquisition of

considerably larger Sydney Promina in 2007 established the company


nationally and gave weight to its model as

and Melbourne peers.


a diversified retail financial services
organisation. Although a pricing war on
insurance premiums cut the performance
of the insurance arm, the banking division
has continued to grow with the relative
buoyancy of the Australian economy up until
late 2008 and the significant growth of the
Queensland property market. Suncorp has
focused on customer service to differentiate
itself from its considerably larger Sydney
and Melbourne peers, boasting 68 percent
customer satisfaction compared to the
“big four’s” average of around 60 percent.
The banking division has attempted to reduce
its reliance on the Queensland market by
expanding its presence in NSW, Victoria
and WA to grab additional market share
and become a super-regional bank brand.
However, Suncorp’s exposure to the cooling
Queensland property market has exposed
the bank’s reliance on its home market and
its performance in 2009 has suffered
accordingly. Chief executive John Mulcahy
has agreed to step down from his post after
six years in the role. Due to the global financial
crisis, falling asset values and access to the
wholesale lending market continues to
threaten the stability of Australia’s regional
banks, with Suncorp’s long-term future
currently uncertain.

Best Australian Brands 2009 25


AGL. For energy providers like AGL a commoditised product, and it has
the past number of years has seen grown its customer base to over 6 million
significant change unfold in every area of to become Australia’s leading energy
the domestic gas and electricity market. supplier. In 2007 and 2008 global energy
New markets have opened and existing prices increased significantly, while
markets have evolved as the national government and public pressure to
grid was privatised and opened up to improve sustainability and innovation
competitive energy wholesaling and into clean fuels and subsequent
retailing amidst a climate of volatile compliance with various emissions goals
wholesale energy costs. In an industry provided further incentive for more
where oil and gas prices determine effective brand building activities. In early
profitability, AGL distinguishes itself 2008, AGL launched its new retail brand
through building its reputation, campaign, “Energy in Action”, across
customer relationships, and reliability. a variety of media. This re‑positioning
With increasing competition and the highlights the actions AGL has taken in its
upcoming privatisation of the NSW renewable energy portfolio and positions
power network, AGL has continued to AGL with its new brand and staff promise
focus on downstream retail activity to of “Actions, not words”.
build a point of difference in its brand for

Lend Lease has been very


successful on a global
scale, operating in more
LEND LEASE. Having come a long way from
its original Dutch/Australian roots, Lend
Lease is now Australia’s largest property

than 40 countries and management and investment company.


The company has been successful on a global

employing more than


scale, operating in more than 40 countries
and employing more than 11,000 people
worldwide. In all markets, the Bovis Lend

11,000 people worldwide. Lease division constructs and manages large


building projects. In the Asia-Pacific region,
Lend Lease also operates as Delfin Lend
Lease, a major Australian residential property
developer. In addition, Lend Lease also
operates a retail development investment
business in the UK, and a number of other
ventures in the United States. With the
re-pricing of asset values, a major symptom
of the fallout in the global financial crisis,
current volatility in the commercial
property market is likely to continue for the
foreseeable future. Last year, Lend Lease
reported a 46.7 percent fall in its annual
profit due to property revaluations and
write-downs in the value of some of its UK
businesses, as both the US and UK residential
markets continue to suffer. Looking towards
its future growth, Lend Lease is contracted
to develop the A$ 13.2 billion Olympic village
for the London Olympic Games. Not only
will this make up for some of its lost profit,
it will also create brand awareness and
expand knowledge of its expertise in the
international market.

26 Best Australian Brands 2009


Answers to the
most commonly
asked questions
The purpose of this section is to address the
questions that you might be asking in relation
to the Best Australian Brands table.

01 What is brand value? 28 11 Is it possible to recognise brand


value on a balance sheet? 30
02 Why value brands? 28
12 What is Interbrand’s view on brands
03 How does Interbrand derive the appearing on balance sheets? 30
value of brands? 28
13 Why is Interbrand an expert
04 What was the basis for the in assessing brand value? 31
financial assessments? 29
14 Does Interbrand conduct other
05 What was the basis for the brand studies? 31
marketing assessments? 29
15 What is the difference between
06 Why are certain brands not the valuations in Best Australian Brands
on the list? 29 and consulting valuations for clients? 31

07 Was there a limit to the number of


brands included from any one industry? 29

08 What is the relationship between the


following terms: brand awareness, brand
equity, brand share, and brand value? 29

09 Do the valuations reflect the


underlying state of the economy? 30

10 How does brand value rank against


ad spending? 30

Best Australian Brands 2009 27


01 What is brand value? 03 How does Interbrand derive the Shell, people buy not only because of the
Brand value is the dollar value of a value of brands? brand, but also because of the location
brand, calculated as Net Present Value Our valuation approach is a derivative of the petrol stations and use of loyalty
(NPV) or today’s value of the earnings of the way businesses and financial programs. For each of the brands (and
the brand is expected to generate in the assets are valued. It fits with current categories) we have assessed the Role of
future. Like any other financial value, corporate finance theory and practice. Branding. The Role of Branding is derived
brand value is based on the assumptions There are three key elements and they as a percentage (%). Thus, if it is 50%, we
and information available at that point are detailed below. take 50% of the EVA as brand earnings.
in time. Brand value is calculated If it is 10%, we only take 10% of the EVA.
according to the most widely accepted Financial Forecasting
and used valuation principles. This makes We identify the revenues from products Brand Strength
brand value comparable to business- or services that are generated with the To derive the net present value of the
and all NPV-based asset values. brand. From these branded revenues forecast brand earnings, we need
we deduct operating costs, applicable a discount rate that represents the risk
The valuations of brands appearing in taxes, and a charge for the capital profile of these earnings. There are two
the Best Australian Brands are calculated employed to derive the economic value factors at play: firstly, the time value of
in their current use to their current that is generated by all tangible and money (i.e. $100 today is more valuable
owner. Therefore, these valuations do intangible business assets of the branded than $100 in five years because one
not necessarily represent the potential business. Economic Value Added (EVA) can earn interest on the money in the
purchase, extension or licensing value is a value-based management concept meantime); and secondly, the risk
of the brands. and is a generally accepted principle to that the forecast earnings will actually
measure the ability of a business to materialise. The discount rate represents
generate returns over and above its these factors as it provides an asset-
invested capital. Based on reports from specific risk rate. The higher the risk
02 Why value brands?
financial analysts, we prepare a financial of the future earnings stream, the higher
The purpose of these valuations is to
forecast and calculate the EVA of the the discount rate will be. To derive today’s
demonstrate to the business community
branded business. value of a future expected earnings
that brands are very important business
stream, it needs to be discounted by
assets and, in many cases, the single
Role of Branding a rate that reflects the risk of the
most valuable company asset. We also
Since EVA includes the returns for all earnings actually materialising and the
aim to make branding and marketing key
assets employed in the business, we time for which it is expected. For example,
business issues that have direct
need to identify the earnings that are $100 from the Coca-Cola brand in five
shareholder value impact. Through eight
specifically attributable to the brand. years requires a lower discount rate than
years of publishing Best Global Brands
Through our proprietary analytical $100 from the Fanta brand in five years,
in BusinessWeek magazine, we have
framework, called Role of Branding, as the Coca-Cola brand is stronger and
created the world’s most significant and
we can calculate the percentage of EVA therefore more likely to deliver the
influential brand and marketing study.
that is entirely generated by the brand. expected earnings.
In fact, PRWeek magazine produced
In some businesses, e.g. in fragrances
a study demonstrating that the
or packaged goods, the Role of Branding The assessment of Brand Strength
BusinessWeek/Interbrand Best Global
is very high – as the brand is the is a structured way of assessing the
Brands ranking was the third most
predominant driver of the customer specific risk of the brand. We compare
sought-after benchmark report by CEOs,
buying decision. However, in other the brand against a notional ideal and
CFOs and Marketing Directors.
businesses (in particular B2B) the brand score it against common factors of
is only one purchase driver among many, brand strength. The ideal brand is
and the Role of Branding is therefore virtually risk-free and would be
lower. For example, people are buying discounted at a rate almost as low as
Microsoft not only because of the brand, government bonds or a similar risk-free
but because the company has an installed investment. The lower the brand
base of 80 percent of the market and it strength, the further it is from the
would be extremely difficult for most risk-free investment and so the higher
users to switch their existing files to a the discount rate (and therefore the
new software platform. In the case of lower the NPV).

28 Best Australian Brands 2009


04 What was the basis for the 06 Why are certain brands not 07 Was there a limit to the number of
financial assessments? on the list? brands included from any one industry?
Published annual reports were used This is a frequent question, especially No. However, one of the requirements
to examine the revenues, earnings from companies who would expect their of a leading brand is that it is, in fact,
and balance sheets of the brand- brands to be on the list. The most likely leading. The mark of leadership is not
owning companies. Analyst reports possible reasons are as follows: just about market share, but also about
from investment banks are used as behaving as a leader – setting trends,
the basis for identifying the specific • T
 he brand has a pure B2B audience quality standards, authority and so on.
brand revenues and earnings, and for and little wider public profile As a result, there are brands that are in
forecasting future earnings. and awareness the top three of their category’s market
share but did not make the cut, and there
• T
 here is insufficient level of public are brands that are not top three that
financial data available to enable did make the ranking. The rules described
05 What was the basis for the us to identify the branded business are guidelines and, ultimately, each
marketing assessments? (e.g. the company has multiple brand was assessed for inclusion on its
Unlike other brand value rankings, brands, as in the case of Fosters, own merits.
Interbrand does not rely on a single or has unbranded production)
source of marketing information.
Using a single brand study would limit • T
 he brand is not big enough or profit
the type of information (usually was insufficient 08 What is the relationship between
perceptual data) and the type of the following terms: brand awareness,
customer (usually general public) that • I t is not a customer facing brand - brand equity, brand share and
can be considered. Because many leading holding companies were excluded brand value?
brands operate in specific customer (e.g. IAG, Wesfarmers) Brand value is the only measure that
segments (particularly B2B brands), looks at the economic benefit of the
sourcing data exclusively from the • W
 holly owned or local subsidiaries of brand to its owner. In other words, it is
general public would prove very global brands were excluded on the an end in itself. Brand awareness and
restrictive. Instead, Interbrand refers to basis that their value is not entirely brand equity are a means to an end.
a wide array of primary and secondary rooted in Australia and/or they did Brand awareness is simply knowledge
sources, which are applicable to each not originate here (e.g. GM Holden, that a brand exists, thus brand
brand. These include ACNielsen, Arnott’s, Kmart) awareness may prompt customers to
IBIS World, Factiva, BRW, Thompson consider buying a product. Brand equity
Reuters, Australian Financial Review, is a measure of customer perceptions
Adnews, B&T and Datamonitor, among of a brand, thus it may give a customer
many others. reason to prefer one product over the
alternatives. Brand share is simply the
market share achieved by the brand.
Thus brand awareness, equity and share
are all measures of what a customer
thinks or does. It is not an assessment
of the economic value created by those
thoughts or actions.

Best Australian Brands 2009 29


09 Do the valuations reflect the 11 Is it possible to recognise brand 12 What is Interbrand’s view on
underlying state of the economy? value on a balance sheet? brands appearing on balance sheets?
Yes – in two ways. The forecasts are Several accounting standards – such as We support the decision by the different
prepared with an overall view on International Accounting Standards IFRS accounting standards to recognise the
economic growth at a point in time. and US-GAAP – require the recognition value of brands on the balance sheet.
The formula for converting the Brand of acquired goodwill, including brands, Interbrand has led the debate on this
Strength Score into a discount rate is on the balance sheet. The standards clearly issue for many years. However, current
tied to the underlying government identify brands as intangible assets with accounting standards allow only for the
bond yield. an infinite economic life. This means that, recognition of acquired brands, not
unlike other intangible assets (e.g. patents, internally developed brands. Also, the
databases) or goodwill (e.g. training, impairment test for brands on the
workforce), brand value does not have balance sheet allows only for a potential
10 How does brand value rank against to be amortised through the income value reduction but not increase.
advertising and marketing spending? statement. However, they are subject The acquisition criterion means that the
It is not really appropriate to try to to an annual impairment test and their Gucci brand is recognised on the balance
correlate these two components. carrying value needs to be reduced if the sheet of PPR as an intangible asset, while
Brand value is a measure of the output value declined. The technique is consistent the Louis Vuitton brand does not show
from a series of brand investments and with the way in which Interbrand up on the balance sheet of LVMH.
initiatives over a long period of time. has assessed brands for balance sheet
Advertising is one component amidst inclusion – although, of course, using We conclude that the recognition of
a wide spectrum of communications more extensive and proprietary data. acquired brands on the balance sheet is
that companies employ. Other a step in the right direction for providing
communications include sponsorships, shareholders with better information
online, point of sale, word of mouth, about the assets in which they have
experiential marketing and customer invested. However, it is still not sufficient,
service. In some cases, brands are built as the value of internally generated
with very little or no advertising, as in the brands cannot be disclosed despite
case of Google where the online space, making up the vast majority of the most
word of mouth and public relations are valuable brands around the world.
the key communications channels.

30 Best Australian Brands 2009


13 Why is Interbrand an expert 15 What is the difference between the
in assessing brand value? valuations in Best Australian Brands
In 1988, Interbrand developed and and consulting valuations for clients?
introduced the first valuation of a portfolio The valuation methodology is the same,
of brands that used a brand specific however, the level of detail and the
valuation approach. Since then, we have data input differ significantly. The Best
continuously updated and improved our Australian Brand valuations are based on
valuation approach to make it the global publicly available marketing and financial
industry standard of brand valuation. data. Also, the Best Australian Brand
The Interbrand brand valuation valuations are mostly consolidated
methodology is the most widely top-line assessments, although we
endorsed and employed valuation recognise segment differences for
approach around the world. Interbrand diversified brands by product or service
alone has valued more than 5,000 brands but not geography or any other
in all industries worldwide. Our valuations classification (e.g. financial services or
have been endorsed by leading academic technology). As the valuations are based
institutions including Harvard, on publicly available data, they are only
Thunderbird, Columbia, Emory and as reliable as the data that the brand-
St. Gallen. Our valuation approach has owning companies publish about
a wide range of applications, including themselves (in annual reports, analyst
strategic brand management, marketing briefings, press articles, syndicated
budget allocation, marketing ROI, market research). Consulting valuations
portfolio management, brand extensions, are based on detailed customer
mergers and acquisitions, balance sheet segmentations, as well as in-depth
recognition, licensing, transfer pricing marketing and financial analyses.
and investor relations. Our valuations They have a much higher level of
have been audited for inclusion on the accuracy and granularity. The purpose
balance sheet by all leading accounting of a consulting valuation extends well
firms. Also, many tax authorities and law beyond assessing financial numbers and
courts around the world have accepted goes on to identify and quantify value
our valuation approach. drivers so as to manage brands for
increasing the shareholder value of the
underlying businesses. However, if
clients undertake consulting valuations,
14 Does Interbrand conduct other we are in a much better position to
brand studies? identify publicly available data that is
In addition to Australia, we have likely to align the Best Australian Brands
established national brand value rankings valuation with the consulting valuation.
in Switzerland, France, Spain, Singapore, In cases where companies make our
China, Taiwan, Malaysia, Mexico, consulting valuations publicly available,
Russia, Canada and Brazil. These follow for example through a note in the
an identical valuation process to our balance sheet, these values will also be
Annual Global Best Brands study but only published as the Best Australian Brands
evaluate locally-owned brands. ranking value.

Best Australian Brands 2009 31


About Interbrand We’re not interested in simply being the
Interbrand began in 1974 when the world world’s biggest brand consultancy. We want
still thought of brands as just another to be the most the most valued.
word for logo. We have changed the
dialogue, defined the meaning of brand We pioneered the technique for valuing
management and continue to lead the brands in 1984 and have continued to
debate on understanding brands as improve upon the methodology and set the
valuable business assets. pace for other approaches. Our valuation
techniques have long been recognised by
We now have nearly 40 offices and are business, academics and regulatory bodies
the world’s largest brand consultancy. as a uniquely valuable strategic tool. Today,
Our practice brings together a diverse we have conducted over 5,000 valuations
range of insightful right – and left – brain for clients to provide guidance in managing
thinkers making our business both their most valuable asset – their brand.
rigorously analytical and highly creative.
Our work creates and manages brand
value for clients by making the brand
central to the business’s strategic goals.

Contact us
General and media inquiries:

Damian Borchok Additional information on brands


Managing Director www.interbrand.com
Interbrand Australia www.brandchannel.com
Tel: +61 2 8260 2031
Mob: +61 437 478 586
damian.borchok@interbrand.com.au

Renzo Scacco
General Manager
Interbrand Australia
Tel: +61 3 8416 3218
Mob: +61 438 722 825
renzo.scacco@interbrand.com.au

32 Best Australian Brands 2009


Creating and managing
www.interbrand.com brand value TM

You might also like