Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Aalsmeer Flower - Zubair2
Aalsmeer Flower - Zubair2
Aalsmeer Flower Auction is an organization that deals with flowers auction market. The
marketplace is located in Netherlands. They have planned to establish online auction market due
to the some threat that threatened their comfortable position. These threats are identify using
Porters five forces analysis. Business and information requirement are also look into, to know
what are the business requirement and information requirement for the online auction market.
After getting to know the business requirement and the information requirement, system
development was evaluate to know which method is appropriate for AFA. Waterfall system
development methodology was chosen as appropriate for AFA due to the business and
information requirement of AFA. Effectiveness of the new system developed was consider on
the organization, management and the employee.
1. Introduction
Aalsmeer Flower Auction (AFA) is an auction house that offer global growers, wholesalers and
exporters a central marketplace in which to trade flowers and plants. New developments in
auction market threatened their comfort ability position, firstly, the need for emergence of
alternative, electronically driven flower markets. Secondly, Retailers asked for fresher products,
more varieties, smaller quantities and multiple deliveries each week. And lastly, merger and
acquisitions among retailers increased their size and power. After studying the case, using the
porter’s five forces, it is realized that AFA has some strength to overcome all these threats. By
this the report suggest to Aalsmeer Flower Auction (AFA) the need to restructure the
organization of the flower market by forming alliance with other business to enable them to have
wider market range.
1
2.1. Business Analysis and requirement
Porter assumes that any organization is subject to five forces from its direct business
environment (Porter, 2001). The impact of each force will be analyzed and discussed from
Aalsmeer Flower Auction’s perspective.
Suppliers
Competitors
New
Substitutes
entrants
Buyers
2.1.1. Competitors
Competitors are rivals within an industry (Siegel 2009). The way the competition in flower
market is going is likely to drive AFA out of the market if they did not respond to the change in
the market. This is a threat that requires quick response, it is understood from the case that, there
is already an alternative way of marketing flowers and that is the electronic flower market; this is
high threat to AFA.
2.2.5. Security
The system that will be built by AFA must be secure and users must have trust in using the
system. Online trading involves the use of credit cards as means of payment, buyers and
suppliers must be rest assured that their cards are safe and cannot be hack by fraudster (Liu,
Zhuang, Zhang 2007).
4
Maintenance of the system is important information AFA needs to know. To build system is one
thing and to maintain is another thing. Cost of maintenance needs to be considered and the
availability of the system engineer (Liu, Zhuang, Zhang 2007).
System development methodologies are based on basic software engineering models, such as
waterfall model, and spirals model (Metropolis et al., 1980; Budde et al., 1984; Walt Scacchi,
2001; Ricky Don Preuninger, 2006). Important pros and cons are discussed below:
This is the most common and classic of life The spiral model is similar to the incremental
cycle models, also referred to as a linear- model, with more emphases placed on risk
sequential life cycle model. It is very simple analysis. The spiral model has four phases:
to understand and use. In a waterfall model, Planning, Risk Analysis, Engineering and
each phase must be completed in its entirety Evaluation. A software project repeatedly
before the next phase can begin. At the end passes through these phases in iterations
of each phase, a review takes place to (called Spirals in this model). The baseline
determine if the project is on the right path spiral, starting in the planning phase,
and whether or not to continue or discard the requirements is gathered and risk is
5
project. Unlike what I mentioned in the assessed. Each subsequent spiral builds on
general model, phases do not overlap in a the baseline spiral.
waterfall model
.
Advantages Advantages
Easy to manage due to the rigidity of the Good for large and mission-critical projects.
model – each phase has specific deliverables
and a review process.
Phases are processed and completed one at a Software is produced early in the software
time. life cycle.
Disadvantages Disadvantages
Adjusting scope during the life cycle can kill Can be a costly model to use.
a project
No working software is produced until late Risk analysis requires highly specific
during the life cycle. expertise.
Poor model for long and ongoing projects. Project’s success is highly dependent on the
risk analysis phase.
Poor model where requirements are at a Doesn’t work well for smaller projects.
moderate to high risk of changing.
Based on the pros and cons of the two methodologies discussed above, the situation where either
of the two methodologies is most appropriate will be deduce and the most relevant to the case
will be chosen for AFA as the most appropriate methodology.
6
3.1. Waterfall – situation where most appropriate
AFA is an auction house where buying and selling is taking place. Sellers bring their flowers for
buyers to see and bid for it. They require a system that will facilitate this market online.
Waterfall is most appropriate for development of transaction- oriented system (Kellen 2008).
The objectives of AFA is clear and known and the solution to achieve these are objectives are
been discussed above in the business and information requirement. Waterfall is most appropriate
for project that has clear objectives and solution (Kellen 2008).
Project requirement is clear and that is to open a website that allow suppliers to display their
flowers and buyers can visit the site to browse and search for varieties of flowers and flowers
pots, bid for the flowers and make payment online so AFA can have their commission as a
mediator. Kellen (2008) argue that waterfall is most appropriate in a situation where project
requirement is stated unambiguously and comprehensively.
Electronic auction market is new to AFA. AFA decided to go online due to the threats to the
business. Therefore electronic way of bringing buyers and sellers together is new to them. There
is possibility that AFA team members are inexperience about online auction. Waterfall
methodology of system development is most appropriate in a situation where team members are
inexperienced (Kellen 2008).
7
As discussed in the information requirement above that AFA need information requirement
about the security of the system. The proposed system for AFA (WEB-AUCTION SYSTEM
through a website) needs to be secure due to the kind of information that will be passing through
the system. For example user’s personal information and their financial details need to be
protected. Waterfall is most appropriate in a situation where resources need to be conserved
(kellen 2008).
Electronic commerce is new to AFA which has its own inherent risk associated with it. Spiral
laid more emphasis on risk analysis. Spiral methodology of system development is most
appropriate in a situation where the risk avoidance is give high priority (kellen 2008).
AFA want to reduce cost as possible as they can, this is one of their objective to reduce
transaction cost. Resources incur to develop a system is part of their transaction cost. Spiral is
most appropriate where minimizing resource consumption is not an absolute priority (kellen
2008). This mean spiral encourage waste.
8
3.2.4. Project manager is highly skilled and experienced
AFA is new to e – commerce; managers will have little or no experience regarding system
development. Spiral is good as system methodology where Project manager is highly skilled and
experienced (kellen 2008).
Based on evaluation of where most appropriate the two methodologies can be adopt and in
relevance to the business and information requirement discussed above it is concluded that
waterfall is most appropriate method to be use by AFA. Take for example:
AFA will be able to achieve its business objective by switching to an e- commerce system. E-
commerce will enable innovation, redefine the value chain, reduce transaction costs, strengthen
the link with wholesalers and retailers, and finally increase market share.
4.1.1. Innovation
AFA develops a website that allows sellers to displays their product via internet and buyers to
browse the site to buy the products. It is a new way of doing business as far as AFA is concern.
Now AFA can be reach from any part of the world in as much as there is internet. This will
increase the market share of AFA.
9
4.1.2. Redefine the value chain
AFA will need to redefine the value chain within the organization, with invention of the new
system by removing the non value added chain activities and add value added activities in the
organization. Activities like pushing flowers cart round the auction house is no more useful and
can be eliminated, by removing non value added activities AFA will able to reduce transaction
cost.
This is one of the important objectives of AFA. It is true that switching to e- commerce would
eliminate some costs originally incurred in the transaction of flower by AFA, such as cost incur
in storing the flowers and space. With e-commerce AFA does not need very big space to transact
flowers and the flowers does not need to be kept in AFA warehouse. However, in the short run
the costs incur in the development of the system might quite be high. AFA needs to do costs
benefit analysis to know if the benefit outweigh the costs incur before implementing the e-
commerce.
Increased and more detailed information about varieties of flowers, delivery dates and current
status can increase customer loyalty. In addition, the ability to consistently meet buyers’ desired
delivery dates with more varieties and fresher products, and small quantities eliminates any
incentive for buyers to seek other sources of supply.
Management of organization is responsible for making decision for the organization. Now
that AFA is organizing the auction via e-commerce, the flow of information is accelerated
because electronic connections and communications are already established. As a result,
information can flow easily, directly, and rapidly from buyer to seller.
By switching to e- commerce, AFA will be able to study the trend of the auction market and
this will enable for market forecast that predicts high demand for which type of flower
10
people order for most, by this AFA will need to source for this kind of flowers that is of high
demand. Wal-Mart, For example, uses information about certain regions of the country and
specific situations to increase needed inventory levels of certain products and improve
overall profitability (Stair and Reynolds 2010).
AFA will needs to be making decision regarding the kind of flowers to display on their site and
other decisions as regard the whole organization. With the aid of electronic market decision can
be make easily and fast.
People can be the most important element of e-commerce. They make difference between
success and failure for most organization. E-commerce needs people who have knowledge about
information technology. Information systems personnel include all people who manage, run,
program and maintain the system. AFA needs skilled people like this to run the organization now
that they are adopting e-commerce. However, to the employees in AFA since this a new way of
trading there is possibility that they do not have the required knowledge about e-commerce. AFA
will needs to employed competent staff that run the organization perfectly.
In addition to the elimination of some activities that are non value added, AFA will also retrench
some staff, that services are no longer required.
5.0. Conclusion
Buyers and suppliers will also benefit from the new information system. Buyers have the
opportunity of browsing and searching for varieties of flowers online and bid for their favorite.
Suppliers do not to transport their flowers to the auction house any longer, pictures of flowers
11
and flower plants can be display via the internet. AFA still maintain their role as market
mediator.
6.0. Recommendation
It is highly recommended that AFA should establish a website that support online auction
market. They should make sure that the site is as much as possible be user friendly to attract
customers (suppliers and buyers). They should make sure that the site is fast and secure to
increase the trust customers will have for them. As for the traditional auction house they should
still maintain it on small scale.
Reference lists
Laudon, K.C. and Laudon, J.P., 2007. Essentials of Business Information Systems, Prentice Hall.
Stair, R and Reynolds, G., 2010. Information Systems, Ninth Edition, Course Technology.
Rauniar, Rupak , Morefield, Roger D ,Simms, John and Rauniar, Deepak. (2009). Online
Auctions: A study of Bidder Satisfaction. Volume 16 (Number 1), 7 - 14.
Saini, H., Saini, D. and Gupta,N. 2009. E-Business system development: review on methods,
design factors, techniques and tools with an extensive case study for secure online retail selling
industry. vol 2 , 82 -90.
Ho, G. L., Clive, W., Rene, W. Electronic Market place with Multimedia Representation: Sea of
flower. , 37 - 45.
12
Eric van Heck, Eric van Damme, Jack Kleijnen, Piet Ribbers. 1997. New Entrants and the Role
of Information Technology Case-Study: the Tele Flower Auction in the Netherlands. , 1 - 10.
Ajit Kambil, Eric van Heck. 1996. Competition in the Dutch Flower Markets., 1- 20.
FRED VAN EENENNAAM, RUTH SOESMAN. 2008. The Dutch Flower Cluster. , 1 - 25.
Jos,B. , Sjoerd,H. , Eric, V. H , Steef ,V. 2003. Flourishing e-commerce? Key success factors
for e-commerce in the Dutch floricultural sector. , 1 - 69.
Debra,J. M. Performing Information Requirements Analysis: A View from the Top. pg 286 -
289.
Ernesto, T. and Robbin, V. 2007. Cutting Porter's last diamond: competitive and comparative
(dis)advantages in the Dutch ower industry. Which lessons for Italian SMEs?, pg 1 - 33.
Ernesto, T. and Robbin , V.2008. Cutting Porter’s Last Diamond: Competitive and Comparative
(Dis)advantages in the Dutch Flower Cluster., pg 304 - 319.
Nico, V. H. 2005. E-business and the Dutch Flower Industry A survey for strategic
opportunities., pg 1 - 14.
Tian, Q., Daryl, J. and Shenggen, H. 2007. China’s ornamentals industry is in ‘full bloom., pg 1 -
6.
13
14