Professional Documents
Culture Documents
the Brown
News in brief r ot c r e co n s i d e r e d
U. to
offer int’l
Nearly 400 bumped
from poli sci course
More than 380 students will
have to search for a new course
to take this semester, as the
master’s
Department of Political Science
has capped POLS1510: “Great
Powers and Empires” to 300
to juniors
students. By Ashley Aydin
“I’ve taught this class before Senior Staff Writer
and I’ve never had a problem
giving overrides or students not The Office of International Pro-
being able to take the course,” grams will announce today the
said Minh Luong, the adjunct launch of “Brown Plus One” — a
lecturer of political science who program that will allow juniors to
teaches the course. “Right now begin earning a master’s degree from
there are 680 people enrolled in either the Chinese University of
this class, which way exceeds the Hong Kong or The University of
capacity of (Salomon 101).” Herald archives Edinburgh.
The capacity of Salomon 101, Amidst heavy student protest, the faculty voted to abolish Naval ROTC in the spring of 1972. Now, after Congress’ Juniors will complete the first
including the balcony area, is repeal of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,” 24 students have applied to sit on a committee to consider the program’s return. half of a master’s during a semester
See more coverage on page 2.
594 people. or year abroad and then return for
According to Luong, another another year after graduating Brown
125 students who had not yet
registered were also trying to
Questions linger in alleged intimidation to complete the degree.
The program will offer degrees
enroll in the class. By Jake comer to rest. girlfriend to get a photograph of in the hard sciences, social sciences
Luong said James Morone, Senior Staff Writer In the deposition, Pat Brosnan Burch. But the investigator already and humanities, Kendall Brostuen,
professor of political science and — the owner of Brosnan Risk Con- possessed a picture of Burch from associate dean of the College and
chair of the department, told While the owner of the security sultants — states that an investi- the internet, and did not take a director of international programs,
him the class must be capped firm accused of participating in picture of him after delivering the wrote in an e-mail to The Herald.
and that only juniors and seniors witness intimidation in the Wil- News analysis package. Brosnan states the pur- The application process for the
will be allowed to enroll. Luong liam McCormick case denies pose of the ploy was to covertly program will be similar to the stan-
said that he felt this was “within wrongdoing in a November de- gator in his employ anonymously surveil — not threaten — Burch, dard study abroad application pro-
position obtained by The Herald, hand-delivered a package to the cess, with one addition — students
continued on page 4 his testimony fails to put the issue home of witness Mike Burch’s continued on page 3 will need to declare their intention
to return to a foreign university to
complete the degree after graduat-
Comics...................5
editorial..............6 In Prof ’s new children’s Examining Brown’s
Opinions...............7 book, math can bite need to compete
Campus news, 8 opinions, 7 38 / 15 30 / 10
2 Campus News The Brown Daily Herald
Wednesday, February 2, 2011
1970s in the midst of anti-Vietnam cording to an Apr. 29 article in The — With additional reporting by
War protests and allegations that Herald. Nicole Boucher
Daily Herald
the Brown fibers and nanomaterials and the
adverse health effects with which
they are associated. She collaborates
www.browndailyherald.com with Robert Hurt, professor of en-
195 Angell St., Providence, R.I. gineering, in her research. Kane has
Ben Schreckinger, President Matthew Burrows, Treasurer also worked on a number of both
Sydney Ember, Vice President Isha Gulati, Secretary national and international advisory
The Brown Daily Herald (USPS 067.740) is an independent newspaper serving the panels.
Brown University community daily since 1891. It is published Monday through Fri- Herbert is the chair of the De-
day during the academic year, excluding vacations, once during Commencement, once partment of Geological Studies. He
during Orientation and once in July by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Single copy free
for each member of the community.
said he focuses on “understand-
POSTMASTER please send corrections to P.O. Box 2538, Providence, RI 02906. ing the ways in which climate can
Periodicals postage paid at Providence, R.I. change naturally,” by studying the
Subscription prices: $280 one year daily, $140 one semester daily. ocean’s bottom. He and his team
Copyright 2011 by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. All rights reserved.
produced the world’s longest pa-
editorial Business
leotemperature, a recording that
(401) 351-3372 (401) 351-3360
herald@browndailyherald.com gm@browndailyherald.com
helps understand how temperature
changes over time.
The Brown Daily Herald
Wednesday, February 2, 2011 Campus News 3
Private investigator’s testimony fails to settle allegations
continued from page 1 He states delivery of the package After Clatch finished the ploy,
A timeline of events in the McCormick case was not a threat but a ploy to lure Brosnan says Clatch called him
but the investigator called Burch Burch into a situation in which to tell him, “it worked; he went
August 30, 2006 — First-year orientation begins for about the incident the following Clatch could take a picture of him, to dinner. And unfortunately, she
William McCormick, then a member of the Class of 2010 and a day from a blocked phone number. and that neither he nor the female still didn’t get the picture.”
wrestling recruit. He testifies that the investigator alum’s father were aware of the When asked why Clatch failed
was offered money to obtain the ploy until after it had taken place. to get a photograph of Burch, Bros-
Sept. 6 — A female classmate of McCormick’s makes a picture in 2009, but the investiga- But according to Clatch’s notes nan first responds that he does
complaint to the University that he has been stalking her. tor did not attempt to do so until — subpoenaed in connection with not know. When asked why Clatch
late 2010. He testifies that he was the deposition — Brosnan’s firm said she did not get a photograph,
Sept. 13 — The female student alleges that McCormick unaware Burch had spoken in the already possessed a picture of Brosnan responds “lighting.”
raped her on the night of Sept. 6. McCormick is forced to leave press about the case, but he had Burch taken from the internet. “Maybe because she tried to
campus. received news articles — attached And according to Brosnan’s de- draw him on at 7:30 at night,” Kil-
to e-mails — about the case. position, Clatch did not take any patrick replies. Clatch’s invitation
Sept. 14 — Russell Carey, senior vice president for The deposition was taken Nov. photograph of Burch after deliv- requested Burch come to dinner
Corporation affairs and governance, hands McCormick a 3 by McCormick’s lawyer, Scott ering the package, even though at 7:30 p.m.
plane ticket home to Wisconsin. He is not informed that Kilpatrick, two weeks after he filed Burch went to the restaurant after Later in the deposition, the
he has been accused of rape. Over the following days, a motion alleging that Burch had receiving the invitation. questioning turns to Clatch’s
McCormick is made aware of the accusation, begins preparing been subject to witness intimida- Brosnan says he asked for the phone call to Burch the follow-
a defense with his adviser — assistant wrestling coach Mike tion. Burch — a former assistant photograph “because I suspected, ing day, and the role it played in
Burch — and hires attorney Walter Stone to advise him. wrestling coach and the Univer- particularly when the civil case the ploy.
According to federal court records, Stone’s law firm — Adler sity-appointed adviser to McCor- came above ground, that there may When first asked why Clatch
Pollock & Sheehan — was representing the University in a mick when he was accused of rape be a possibility this may evolve at called Burch the following day
separate matter while Stone was advising McCormick in the in 2006 — received an anonymous some later date for the client into from a blocked number, Brosnan
disciplinary process. package Sept. 27 inviting him to a a focused surveillance … and it responds, “I don’t know.” When
free dinner at the DownCity Diner would certainly be very handy to asked again about the purpose
Oct. 3 — The female student’s father — a University alum, “to show our appreciation for ev- have a recent photograph.” of the call, Brosnan says Clatch
donor and fundraiser — e-mails President Ruth Simmons, erything you do.” Brosnan states that his em- “wanted to convey to (Burch) that
“Ruth … I am working to resolve the matter with the student The following day, Burch re- ployees performed surveillance there was no ulterior motive to
who attacked (the female student) — the goal is to have him ceived a phone call about the pack- of Burch in September of 2009, but the extent that she thought that
withdraw from Brown and not have a University hearing. This age from a blocked number. Using “never got a photograph.” this would be helpful to him to
will enable (the female student) and the other students to subpoenas, Kilpatrick’s law firm Kilpatrick asks Brosnan, “You understand in some way. That’s
avoid having to come in contact with the student and face traced the call to a phone owned needed a picture of him because what she said to me.”
questioning from his advocate.” by Pat Brosnan, the founder of you didn’t have one and didn’t Brosnan states in the deposition
a New York private investigative know what he looked like; right?” that he did not know that Burch
Oct. 15 — McCormick withdraws from Brown, citing firm known to work for the father to which Brosnan responds, “I was a witness in a lawsuit “until re-
medical reasons. In court documents, he will later allege the of the female alum who accused didn’t have a picture, no. There cently.” He also states that although
experience aggravated an existing seizure condition. McCormick of rape. McCormick was no picture.” the female alum’s father had sent
is suing the female alum, her father According to the deposition, him news articles in which Burch
September 2009 — McCormick’s new lawyer, Scott and the University in federal court. Kilpatrick then brings Brosnan’s talks to reporters about the Mc-
Kilpatrick files a complaint under seal in Rhode Island Superior In the deposition, Brosnan attention to notes from Clatch’s Cormick case, he did not read the
Court. The claim alleges that McCormick was falsely accused states he was retained in 2009 2009 surveillance of Burch, which articles and was unaware Burch
and that the University mishandled the accusation because to surveil Burch and ensure his include a headshot of Burch taken had been vocal in the media about
of the financial relationship of the female alum’s father to daily patterns would not bring from the internet. the case.
the University. The motion to seal is granted, and there is him into contact with the female Brosnan confirms the photo- Brosnan says he does not think
no public record of the suit. The case is soon transferred to alum, then a senior. Brosnan says graph is of Burch and responds, the package — which consisted of
federal court, where it is again placed under seal. the surveillance ended in 2009, “We didn’t feel that the photos an invitation and flowers — could
but that at that time he offered the were of sufficient quality and clar- reasonably have been considered
April 12, 2010 — The Herald prints a story based on a investigator assigned to the case, ity and crisp enough in case that scary.
leaked copy of the complaint. The case is unsealed later that Sharon Clatch, $1,000 to obtain a we had to go on a surveillance, on He did not respond to e-mails
day at a hearing in front Judge William Smith. picture of Burch if she were to find a focused surveillance, at a later and a phone call seeking comment
herself in Providence in the future. date.” for this story.
Sept. 27 — A package addressed to Burch — who has
been named a witness in the case — is hand-delivered
anonymously to the home of Burch’s girlfriend, a single
mother. It contains an invitation to a free meal at Downcity
Diner — a restaurant across the street from the law firm
representing McCormick. Burch shows up for dinner, where
he finds out the restaurant was given cash by two women to
pay for his meal. The next day, Burch receives an anonymous
phone call about the package.
Jan. 6, 2011 — Well over a year into the suit, Federal Judge
William Smith recuses himself without explanation.
comics
BB & Z | Cole Pruitt, Andrew Seiden, Valerie Hsiung and Dan Ricker
How we compete
the other Ivy League schools have one.” the process of de-emphasizing the Program competitive with both colleges and univer-
Now, I don’t mean to suggest here that in Liberal Medical Education that kept it sities by offering the best of both worlds.
By kurt walters Simmons has some agenda to undermine unique and relevant to the liberal arts. Add With so much change, we are at a tenu-
the New Curriculum and the university- to that the new school of engineering (ev- ous crossroads. But there are steps we can
Opinions Columnist college model. Far from it — although Si- eryone else was doing it!) and rumors of a take to preserve our educational culture
mon Liebling’s columns such as “Brown, future School of Community Health, and while still improving the school. First, let’s
Inc.” do have significant merit. Rather, the we see a subtle yet fundamental transfor- make sure that we aren’t promoting the
In President Obama’s recent State of the risk is that in the rush to make improve- mation away from Brown’s university-col- segmenting of the University into many
Union address, we heard repeated appeals ments, Brown’s culture will be overlooked lege identity. schools without good reason. Liberal edu-
to renew America’s long-term competitive- through neglect and die a slow “death by In the midst of these changes, we seem cation thrives at the intersection of many
ness and to “win the future” against emerg- a thousand cuts.” By the time we realize a to have lost sight of the best way for Brown different disciplines, so we should be wary
ing rivals like India and China. Similarly, in shift has happened, it will already be too to compete — by staking out a position that of putting up barriers to interdisciplinary
the decade following Ruth Simmons’ hir- late. is uniquely “Brown” rather than becoming contact by breaking up the University.
ing as President in 2001, Brown has seen Brown has long had an emphasis on the an also-ran “Yale Jr.” Second, we must create incentives for
a heightened emphasis on becoming more liberal arts rather than professional or vo- For the subset of present and future stu- professors to engage in undergraduate
competitive with other schools in the fight cational training. In 1946, then-president dents who are looking for a self-directed teaching and especially advising over ex-
to attract the best students in the country clusively prioritizing their research. Stu-
and from around the world. dents come to Brown looking for under-
After inheriting a stalled and stagnant graduate excellence, and faculty members
campus, the Simmons administration In the midst of these changes, we seem to have lost sight must be here for the same reason. The New
quickly initiated a raft of reforms under of the best way for Brown to compete — by staking out Curriculum, with its characteristic free-
the Plan for Academic Enrichment. Many dom and resulting reliance on strong ad-
of them were incredibly beneficial, ranging a position that is uniquely “Brown” rather than vising, dies without a faculty deeply com-
from need-blind admissions for domestic, mitted to undergraduates.
non-transfer students, to impressive in- becoming an also-ran “Yale Jr.” Finally and most importantly, we need
creases in fundraising and faculty hiring. vigilance, energy and passion from the stu-
But with the huge changes the school has dent body regarding the University’s gov-
seen comes a significant risk of losing the Henry Wriston lauded the University’s in- liberal arts education at a school with a ernance and future. We should promote
educational culture and university-college clusion of engineering within the liberal strong focus on undergraduates and the and be proud — not suspicious — of our
model that make Brown so attractive in the arts college rather than “segregating it in resources of a university (as I once was), I differences from other schools. We cannot
first place. In many cases, Brown’s leader- a separate school.” Similarly, Wriston not- don’t think it’s an exaggeration to say that expect faculty and administration to main-
ship seems to be taking its cues more from ed how Brown had eliminated previous Brown is the best choice in the world. There tain the New Curriculum and a culture that
trying to copy Harvard, Yale and Princeton experiments with programs in medicine, are plenty of great options for pre-profes- most benefits undergraduate students —
— the “HYP(e)” schools for short — than agriculture, business and forestry because sionals, but if you try to think of other true we must fight for that ourselves.
from trying to improve Brown’s unique cul- they were found to be “fundamentally in- university-colleges, it’s hard to get much
ture. Just take how the recent tenure reform compatible” with Brown’s commitment to further than perhaps Wesleyan or Dart-
debate was sparked by the fact that Brown liberal arts learning. mouth. If Brown abandons its unique fo-
has a considerably higher rate of tenure ap- Today, of course, it is no secret that cus and model, it would leave a gaping void Kurt Walters ’11 was ecstatic to see a
proval than other Ivy League schools, and Brown has a rapidly expanding medical in the college landscape. By instead com- page labeled “The university college” in
how a principal argument for establishing school, which soon will be geographically peting with ourselves to be the best Brown the bookstore’s Brown promo pamphlet.
the new school of engineering was “well, all separated from the main campus and is in University possible, we will be de facto Here’s looking at you, Brown PR team.
Daily Herald Campus News
the Brown Wednesday, February 2, 2011
Math and monsters add up in children’s book with extensive training in theory
and methods of the discipline. For
example, my husband’s grandmother
By Ben kutner whole book took a thousand hours.” read it.”
Staff Writer After receiving coverage Jan. Her book opens, “This child is
22 from Keith Devlin on NPR, the abandoned.” Leinaweaver brings
From the author of “The Pentagram book leapt to the number-one posi- readers along on the journey she
Integrals for Inscribed Polygons” tion on Amazon for the children’s took from 2001 to 2003 as a PhD
and “Spherical CR Geometry and math book category for over a day, student in Ayacucho, Peru. The book
Dehn Surgery” comes “You Can Schwartz said, one year after the examines a phenomenon she calls
Count on Monsters,” a colorful book was published. “child circulation,” where Peruvian
picture book featuring 100 math- The NPR coverage was “essen- children live away from home, often
themed monsters. Professor of tially a four-minute glowing ad- with an aunt or a friend of the family.
Mathematics Richard Schwartz’s vertisement,” Schwartz said. “It was Peruvian government and adoption
first children’s book offers young on a Saturday morning, I actually officials would sometimes view these
children a unique math experience. overslept.” children as abandoned.
The book, recently featured on Schwartz published the children’s “I was interested in finding out
National Public Radio, is filled with book with A K Peters, Ltd., a pub- why that was so common,” Lein-
colorful graphics of monsters that lishing company that focuses on aweaver said. “I saw it as a sort of
correspond with the numbers one to books related to computer science adoption, even though sometimes
100, presenting young children with and mathematics. Schwartz had sev- kids would only move temporarily,
a unique and exciting way to learn eral previous publications with the like for a year or two.”
about concepts like prime numbers company, but he said they were very The book compares this phenom-
and factoring. The graphic of each mathematically complex. enon to another method of relocat-
monster is related to the number it “You Can Count on Monsters” is ing children: legal adoption. Ulti-
represents — the number five mon- the first book for very young chil- mately, Leinaweaver was interested
ster, for example, is a five-sided star. dren published by A K Peters, said in “how the government and Que-
The project originally took the Courtesy of Richard Schwartz Klaus Peters, a co-founder of the chua-speaking people thought dif-
form of a poster of the 100 monsters, Monsters, like this one representing a factoring tree, fill Schwartz’s book. company and a former professor ferently about where people should
which Schwartz said he had made of mathematics at the University be and who should take care of their
for one of his daughters. monsters using X Fig, a program actual graphics of the 100 monsters of Erlangen in Nuremberg, Ger- children,” she said. She gathered a
“I wanted to just make some- used by many mathematicians that and two appendices at the end of many. The company had previously wealth of perspectives, interview-
thing for her,” he said. brings up shapes and geometrical the book containing the Sieve of published other books for middle- ing social workers, parents of the
Schwartz said he made several patterns, he said. Eratosthenes and Euclid’s proof for school children, but this book is children, receiving families and the
comic books when he was in his 20s The book contains three sec- prime numbers. intended for children six and up, kids themselves.
and that creating graphics is a hobby tions — an introduction explain- “I kind of did it in bursts,”
of his. He created the pictures of the ing the concepts in the book, the Schwartz said. “I’d estimate the continued on page 5 continued on page 5