Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INDUSTRIES”
Introduction
The firm's dividend decision has in the last ten to fifteen years
received considerable attention from financial analysts and
academics.Divergent views have been expressed and it is
understood that the controversy has not been resolved,although
the lack of new authorship on the subject in resent times may lead
one to conclude that tha debate is deadlocked.
A dividend is a payment made by a company to its shareholders.
A company can retain its profit for the purpose of re-investment in
the business operations (known as retained earnings), or it can
distribute the profit among its shareholders in the form of
dividends.
A dividend is not regarded as an expenditure; rather, it is
considered a distribution of assets among shareholders. The
majority of companies keep a component of their profits as
retained earnings and distribute the rest as dividend.
Cash Dividends
Firms distribute as cash dividends a certain percentage of
annual earnings in payout rates. Ordance
Four dates are crucial to accounting ordance for cash
dividends as follows:
Case Example
Let’s assume that the Lie Reliance industries itd.,on March 15, 2009,
declared a cash dividend of $1 per share on 2,000,000 shares
payable June 1, 2009, to all stockholders of record April 15. The
following journal entries are required:
1. Date of declaration, March 15, 2009
[Debit]. Retained Earnings [Cash Dividend Declared] = 2,000,000
[Credit]. Dividends Payable = 2,000,000
2. Date of record, April 15, 2009
Memorandum entry that the firm will pay a dividend to all
stockholders of record as of today, the date of record.
3. Date of payment, June 1, 2009
[Debit]. Dividends Payable = 2,000,000
[Credit]. Cash = 2,000,000
Note: It is appropriate to note that cash dividend declared is
closed at year-end to Retained Earnings.
Property Dividends
Firms may elect to declare a “property dividend”that is payable
in nonmonetary assets rather than declaring a cash dividend.
Because a property dividend can be classified as a “non-reciprocal
nonmonetary transfer to owners”, the property distributed is
restated at fair market value at the date of declaration and a gain or
loss is recognized.
Case Example
Let’s assume that the Reliance Industries ltd. declares a property
dividend, payable in bonds of Lie Dharma Company being held to
maturity and costing $500,000. At the date of declaration the bonds
had a market value of $600,000. The following journal entries are
required:
1. Date of Declaration
Investments in Lie Dharma Company
[Debit]. Bonds = 100,000
[Credit]. Gain on Appreciation of Bonds = 100,000
[$600,000 - $500,000]
[Debit]. Retained Earnings [Property Dividend Declared] = $600,00
[Credit]. Property Dividends Payable = $600,000
2. Date of Distribution
[Debit]. Property Dividends Payable = 600,000
[Credit]. Investments in Lie Dharma Company Bonds = 600,000
Stock dividend:
Given in the form of bonus shares or stocks of the issuing
company or a subsidiary company. Normally, they are offered on
the basis of a prorata allotment
Regular Dividend.
By dividend we mean regular dividend paid annually, proposed
by the board of directors and approved by the shareholders in
general meeting. It is also known as final dividend because it is
usually paid after the finalization of accounts. It sis generally paid
in cash as a percentage of paid up capital, say 10 % or 15 % of
the capital. Sometimes, it is paid per share. No dividend is paid on
calls in advance or calls in arrears. The company is, however,
authorised to make provisions in the Articles prohibiting the
payment of dividend on shares having calls in arrears.
(3) Stock-Dividend:
Companies, not having good cash position, generally pay
dividend in the form of shares by capitalizing the profits of current
year and of past years. Such shares are issued instead of paying
dividend in cash and called 'Bonus Shares'. Basically there is no
change in the equity of shareholders. Certain guidelines have
been used by the company Law Board in respect of Bonus
Shares.
Assumptions of MM model
Existence of perfect capital markets and all investors in it are
rational. Information is available to all free of cost, there are
no transactions costs, securities are infinitely divisible, no
investor is large enough to influence the market price of
securities and there are no floatation costs.
There are no taxes. Alternatively, there are no differences in
tax rates applicable to capital gains and dividends.
firm has a given investment policy which does not change. It
implies that the financing of new investments out of retained
earnings will not change the business risk complexion
of the firm and thus there would be no change in the
required rate of return.
Investors know for certain the future investments and profits
of the firm (but this assumption has been dropped by MM
later).
Argument of this Model
By the argument of arbitrage, MM Model asserts the
irrelevance of dividends. Arbitrage implies the distribution of
earnings to shareholders and raising an equal amount
externally. The effect of dividend payment would be offset by
the effect of raising additional funds.
MM model argues that when dividends are paid to the
shareholders, the market price of the shares will decrease
and thus whatever is gained by the investors as a result of
increased dividends will be neutralized completely by the
reduction in the market value of the shares.
The cost of capital is independent of leverage and the real
cost of debt is the same as the real cost of equity, according
to this model.
That investors are indifferent between dividend and retained
earnings implies that the dividend decision is irrelevant. With
dividends being irrelevant, a firm’s cost of capital would be
independent of its dividend-payout ratio.
Arbitrage process will ensure that under conditions of
uncertainty also the dividend policy would be irrelevant.
MM Model:
Market price of the share in the beginning of the period =
Present value of dividends paid at the end of the period +
Market price of share at the end of the period.
P0 = 1/(1 + ke) x (D1 + P1)
Prevailing
Where: P0 = market price
of a share
cost of equity
ke =
capital
Dividend to
be received
D1 =
at the end of
period 1 and
Market price
of a share at
P1 =
the end of
period 1.
(n + ∆ n) P1–
Value of the I+E
=
firm, nP0
(1 + ke)
Where: n = number of
shares
outstanding
at the
beginning of
the period
change in the
number of
shares
outstanding
∆n = during the
period/
additional
shares
issued.
Total amount
I = required for
investment
Earnings of
the firm
E =
during the
period.
Where:
Price of a
P =
share
Earnings per
E =
share
Retention
b =
ratio
Dividend
1-b =
payout ratio
Cost of
capital or the
Ke =
capitalization
rate
Growth rate
(rate or
return on
br - g =
investment of
an all-equity
firm)
Case A Case B
D/P Ratio 40 30
Retention Ratio 60 70
Cost of capital 17% 18%
r 12% 12%
EPS $20 $20
P = DKe– g
Where: P = Price of
equity shares
D = Initial
dividend
Ke = Cost of
equity capital
g = Growth rate
expected
P = DKe– rb
Where: r = Expected
rate of return
on firm’s
investments
b = Retention
rate (E - D)/E
P = D + r/ke(E -
D)
ke
Example:
A company has the following facts:
Cost of capital (ke) = 0.10
Earnings per share (E) = $10
Rate of return on investments ( r) = 8%
Dividend payout ratio: Case A: 50% Case B: 25%
Show the effect of the dividend policy on the market price of the
shares.
Solution:
Case A:
D/P ratio = 50%
When EPS = $10 and D/P ratio is 50%, D = 10 x 50% = $5
5 + [0.08 /
0.10] [10 -
P = 5] =>$90
0.10
Case B:
D/P ratio = 25%
When EPS = $10 and D/P ratio is 25%, D = 10 x 25% = $2.5
P = 2.5 + =>$85
[0.08 /
0.10] [10 -
2.5]
0.10