Technical Comparison of Offers for Filter Integrity Tester

TECHNICAL EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS FOR FILTER INTEGRITY TESTER

Sl Items Requirement Imperial Corporation Ltd. Khan & Deen Traders IRMECO GmbH, Germany
No.
The below tests must be performed Sartocheck Junior BP Plus: Palltronic Flowstar (FFS02): Palltronic AquaWIT System (AW02)
automatically-
Does not meet the Meets the requirement The equipment can perform the
1. Forward flow (Diffusive flow) test requirement required tests but in semi-automatic
Integrity Test
01 2. Bubble point test way except one which does not meet
types Sartocheck 4: Palltronic Flowstar XC (FFXC):
3. Combined forward flow (Diffusive the requirement.
flow) test and Bubble point test
4. Water Intrusion test. Meets the requirement Meets the requirement

1. Forward flow test: Sartocheck Junior BP Plus: Palltronic Flowstar (FFS02): Palltronic AquaWIT System (AW02)
0.1 – 200 cc/min
1. 0- 999 ml/min Meets the requirement 1. Meets the requirement
2. Water intrusion test: 2. N/A
Measuring 0.01 – 50 ml/min 3. Meets the requirement 2. 0.05 – 50 ml/min which does not
02
Range Sartocheck 4: Palltronic Flowstar XC (FFXC): meet the requirement.
3. Bubble point test:
700 – 6000 mbar/min 1. no information Meets the requirement 3. meets the requirement
2. no information
3. no information
1. Forward flow test: Sartocheck Junior BP Plus: Palltronic Flowstar (FFS02): Palltronic AquaWIT System (AW02)
0.1 ml/min
No information Meets the requirement Meets the requirement
2. Water intrusion test:
Resolution of
03 0.01 ml/min Sartocheck 4: Palltronic Flowstar XC (FFXC):
test
3. Bubble point test: 1. no information Meets the requirement
50 mbar 2. no information
3. no information

Page 1 of 3
Sl Items Requirement Imperial Corporation Ltd. Khan & Deen Traders IRMECO GmbH, Germany
No.
1. Forward flow test: Sartocheck Junior BP Plus: Palltronic Flowstar (FFS02): Palltronic AquaWIT System (AW02)
+/-3% or +/-0.05%, whichever is
greater No information No information Meets the requirement
Test
04 Sartocheck 4: Palltronic Flowstar XC (FFXC):
accuracy
2. Water intrusion test: Does not meet the requirement
+/-3% or +/- 0.02 ml/min, whichever Meets the requirement
is greater
1. Forward flow test: Sartocheck Junior BP Plus: Palltronic Flowstar (FFS02): Palltronic AquaWIT System (AW02)
Within 3% of measurement 1. Meets the requirement
No information 2. does not meet the requirement Meets the requirement
05 Calibration
2. Water intrusion test: Sartocheck 4: Palltronic Flowstar XC (FFXC):
Within 0.33% of full scale 1. no information
2. no information Meets the requirement
1. Maximum inlet pressure must be Sartocheck Junior BP Plus: Palltronic Flowstar (FFS02): Palltronic AquaWIT System (AW02)
at least 8000 mbar 1. Meets the requirement
2. Test pressure range: Meets the requirement Meets the requirement
2. Test pressure range must be 50 – 100-6000 mbar which partially
Pneumatic 6000 mbar match the requirement.
06
specification Sartocheck 4: Palltronic Flowstar XC (FFXC):
1. Meets the requirement
2. Test pressure range: Meets the requirement
100-8000 mbar which partially
match the requirement.
1. Compressed air inlet: Sartocheck Junior BP Plus: Palltronic Flowstar (FFS02): Palltronic AquaWIT System (AW02)
Staubli Nipple type connection
2. Compressed air outlet: No information Meets the requirement Meets the requirement
Pneumatic
07 Staubli coupling type connection Sartocheck 4: Palltronic Flowstar XC (FFXC):
connection
3. Vent: Hose connection
(dimension must match with that of No information Meets the requirement
hose)
Sartocheck Junior BP Plus: Palltronic Flowstar (FFS02): Palltronic AquaWIT System (AW02)
Must have a built-in thermal type Printer is ink-ribbon type and
printer to print test result does not meet the requirement. Meets the requirement No information
automatically
08 Printer Sartocheck 4: Palltronic Flowstar XC (FFXC):
Printer is ink-ribbon type and
does not meet the requirement. Meets the requirement

Page 2 of 3
Sl Items Requirement Imperial Corporation Ltd. Khan & Deen Traders IRMECO GmbH, Germany
No.
5 - 50ºC Sartocheck Junior BP Plus: Palltronic Flowstar (FFS02): Palltronic AquaWIT System (AW02)

No information Meets the requirement Meets the requirement

Operating
09 Sartocheck 4: Palltronic Flowstar XC (FFXC):
temperature
15 - 35ºC which does not Meets the requirement
meet the requirement
1. The equipment must have option Sartocheck Junior BP Plus: Palltronic Flowstar (FFS02): Palltronic AquaWIT System (AW02)
for automatic self test, flow check
and air clean. 1. no information 1. No information 1. Meets the requirement
2. no information 2. Meets the requirement 2. Meets the requirement
2. Must have display to show the 3. no information 3. Meets the requirement 3. No information
test progress as bar chart or line 4. offered 4. No information 4. No information
10 Others graphs. Sartocheck 4: Palltronic Flowstar XC (FFXC):

3. Both stabilization and test time 1. Have cleaning option only.
must be automatically controlled. 2. Touch screen color TFT
display
4. The equipment must be supplied 3. no information
with inlet and outlet hoses. 4. Offered
The equipment must be supplied Sartocheck Junior BP Plus:
with the following documentations-
1. offered
1. Calibration and test certificate. 2. not offered
3. offered
2. Material certificate of hose 4. not offered
11 Documentation
Sartocheck 4:
3. Instruction manual
1. offered
4. IQ, OQ documents. 2. not offered
3. offfered
4. Offered
Meets the requirement
Palltronic Flowstar (FFS02): Palltronic AquaWIT System (AW02)
1. not offered 1. No information
2. not offered 2. No information
3. not offered 3. No information
4. Offered 4. Offered
Palltronic Flowstar XC (FFXC):
1. Must be supplied
2. Must be supplied
3. Must be supplied
4. Offered

Comments:

From the above technical evaluation Palltronic Flowstar XC (FFXC) covers the most kinds of integrity tests which meet our requirement. This model is also being used in
SVPO and Cephalosporin plant and from our previous experience it is user friendly. Moreover, the calibration option of this model is convenient. So, we recommend Palltronic
Flowstar XC (FFXC).

Page 3 of 3